140 trial by error justice in post qadhafi libya

8/13/2019 140 Trial by Error Justice in Post Qadhafi Libya

1/53

!"#$% '( )""*"+,-./#01 #2 3*./45$67$8# 9#'($!"##$% '()*+,-.*/ 01."2( 3%4-.* ,5678 " #$ %&'() *+#,

-./0'.1/(2.1) 3'(4(4 5'26&

9%(#:;(.*%.)%70.60 826(40 #9:

#+;+


2/53

!$'%1 *8 :*2/12/.

!"#$%&'(# *%++,-. /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// '

0#$1++#23,&'124///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// '''

5/ 52&-13%$&'12 ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 655/ 7#8,$'#4 19 &:# ;,4& ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ',2 ?1>12',> 0%># @6A66B6ACDE ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// %&'12,-. *&, @6AJABLM66E //////////////////////////////////////////////////// 6M

6/ *N#$',> $1%-&4//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 6LL/ =&+N 0#91-+4 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 6D

555/ O%4&'$# ,9- K,3:,9' //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 6J=/ 7,$P 19 ?129'3#2$# ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 6>,N4# 19 &:# *&, *#$%-'&. =NN,-,&%4 /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// LL?/ 5+N%2'&. //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// L#442#44 /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// DTR5/ ?12$>%4'12 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// DA=; ;! UQ 5? !*

=/ G,N 19 7'H., ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// C6

F/ V>144,-. 19 =$-12.+4 /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// CL

?/ =H1%& &:# 52-2,&'12,> ?-'4'4 V-1%N ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// CD

Q/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N 0#N1-&4 ,23 F-'#9'284 12 &:# G'33># !,4& ,23 U1-&: =9-'$, 4'2$# LM6M /// CC

!/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N F1,-3 19 W-%4#4 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// CJ


3/53

-./0'.1/(2.1) 3'(4(4 5'26&

!"##$% '()*+,-.*/ 01."2( 3%4-.* ,5678 6< 04."$ =86>

!"#$%&'(# *%++,-.W:#-# ,-# +,2. 2#$#44,-. $%-#4 &1 7'H.,X4 N#-(,4'(# '24#$%-'&.Y H%& 9#S +1-# %-8#2&

&:,2 -#N,'-'28 '&4 Z%3'$',> 4.4+/ K,3:,9'B#-, ('$&'+4Y 3'4&-%4&'28 ,2 ,NN,-,&%4 &:#.

('#S ,4 , -#>'$Y &,P# +,&-4 '2 &:#'- :,234[ 41+# ,-+#3 8-1%N4Y 4$#N&'$,> 19 &:#

4&, ,H'>'&. &1 $,--. 1%& Z%4&'$#Y ,-H'&-,-'>. 3#&,'2Y &1-&%-# 1- ,44,44'2, N-#4%+#3

K,3:,9' >1.,>'4&4[ 1&:#-4Y &,P'28 ,3(,2&,8# 19 3'41-3#-Y 31 ('1>#2$# 91- N1>'&'$,> 1-

$-'+'2,> ,'+4/ =>> &:'4 &-'88#-4 +1-# 8-'#(,2$#4Y 9%-&:#- %23#-+'2'28 $129'3#2$# '2

&:# 4&,/ F-#,P'28 &:'4 $.$># -#\%'-#4 +%>&'BN-128#3 ,$&'12] 3#>'(#-'28 Z%4&'$# &1 91-B

+#- -#8'+# ('$&'+4 H. -#91-+'28 &:# Z%3'$',-. ,23 P'$PB4&,-&'28 &-,24'&'12,> Z%4&'$#[

4$-##2'28 1%& #"B-#8'+# >1.,>'4&4 8%'>&. 19 $-'+#4 S:'># ,(1'3'28 S'&$:B:%2&4[ ,23

-#'2'28 '2 ,-+#3 8-1%N4Y '2$>%3'28 &:14# 1N#-,&'28 %23#- , 4&, %+H-#>>,/ ^2>#44&:#-# '4 , $>#,- +#44,8# _ &:# Z%4&'$# 4.4+ '4 H#'28 -#91-+#3[ 21 ('1>#2$# 1- ,H%4#Y

312# '2 &:# N,4& H. K,3:,9'B#-, 199'$',>4 1- '2 &:# N-#4#2& H. ,-+#3 8-1%N4 S'>> H#

&1>#-, _ &:#-# '4 , -#,> -'4P 19 #4$,>,&'28 &,-8# ,44,44'2,&'124Y %-H,2 ('1>#2$#

,23 $1++%2,> $129>'$&4/

5& :,4 H##2 S#>> 1(#- , .#,- 4'2$# K,3:,9'X4 -#8'+# S,4 1%4 ,23 4&'>> &:#-# '4 21

9%2$&'12'28 $1%-& 4.4+ '2 +,2. N,-&4 19 &:# $1%2&-.Y S:'># ,-+#3 8-1%N4 $12&'2%#

&1 -%2 N-'4124 ,23 #291-$# &:#'- 1S2 91-+4 19 Z%4&'$#/ W:# 4#(#-# 3#9'$'#2$'#4 19 &:#

$%--#2& Z%3'$',> 4.4+ ,-# -11Y 9'-4& ,23 91-#+14&Y '2 &:# 9,'>'284 19 &:# 12# &:,&Y

'2 N-'2$'N>#Y '& :,4 -#N>,$#3/ 23#- K,3:,9'Y &:# Z%3'$',-. 4%99#-#3 9-1+ N1>'&'$'4,&'12

19 ,NN1'2&+#2&4Y -,+N,2& $1--%N&'12 ,23 &:# %4# 19 #"&-,Z%3'$',> +#,24 &1 &,-8#&

N1>'&'$,> 1NN12#2&4/ 1%- 3#$,3#4 19 4%$: ,-H'&-,-. Z%4&'$# 4#-(#3 ,4 , H%-3#241+#H,$P3-1N &1 &:# 2#S 81(#-2+#2&X4 #991-&4[ 9,$#3 S'&: , $:1'$# H#&S##2 4%++,-'>.

3'4+'44'28 Z%3'$',> 199'$#-4 S:1 4#-(#3 %23#- K,3:,9' 1- 8-,3%,>>. 4$-##2'28 &:#+

12#BH.B12#Y &:# 2#S ,%&:1-'&'#4 41 9,- :,(# 1N 91- &:# >,&-/ a:'># &:'4 S,4 &:#

-'8:& 3#$'4'12Y '& :,4 $12&-'H% &1 N%H>'$ 4$#N&'$'4+ -#8,-3'28 &:# 4$1N# 19 $:,28#/

W:# 4'&%,&'12 :,4 H##2 $1+N>'$, H. &:# N-1>'9#-,&'12 19 ,-+#3 8-1%N4/ Q'4B

&-%4&9%> 19 &:# K,3:,9'B#-, Z%3'$',-. ,23 N1>'$#Y 9-%4&-, H. &:# 4>1S N,$# 19 &-',>4

,8,'24& 91-+#- 199'$',>4Y 9,$'28 4&, 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4 '2 3'4,--,. ,23 #+H1>3#2#3 H.

&:#'- 2#S N1S#-Y 41B$,>>#3 -#(1>%&'12,-. H-'8,3#4 _ ,23Y ,& &'+#4Y $-'+'2,> 8,284

N14'28 ,4 4%$: _ :,(# H##2 1N#-,&'28 ,H1(# &:# >,SY :'23#-'28 &:# S1-P 19 '2(#4&'8,B

&1-4 ,23 Z%38#4/ W:#. ,>> ,& 12$# ,44%+# &:# -1>#4 19 N1>'$#Y N-14#$%&1-4Y Z%38#4 ,23

Z,'>#-4/ =-+#3 H-'8,3#4 $-#, '2(#4&'8,&'12 ,23 ,--#4& %2'&4[ 3-,9& >'4&4 19 S,2 '2B3'('3%,>4[ 4#& %N $:#$PN1'2&4 1- 91-$# &:#'- S,. '2&1 N#1N>#X4 :1+#4 &1 $,N&%-# N-#B

4%+#3 1%&>,S4 1- N#1N># 4%4N#$ 19 ,'3'28 &:# 91-+#- -#8'+#[ ,23Y '2 41+# $,4#4Y

-%2 &:#'- 1S2 3#&'12 9,$'>'&'#4 '2 &:#'- 1S2 :#,3\%,--4Y '41>, 9,-+4 1- $1+B

+,23##-#3 91-+#- 4&, H%'>3'284/ W:1%4,234 19 '23'('3%,>4 ,-# '2 &:#'- :,234Y 1%&B

4'3# &:# 199'$',> >#8,> 9-,+#S1-P ,23 S'&:1%& H#2#9'& 19 Z%3'$',> -#('#S 1- H,4'$ 3%#

N-1$#44/ =44,44'2,&'124 ,23 8-1S'28 ,&&,$P4 ,8,'24& 81(#-2+#2& 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4 :,(#

9%-&:#- 3,-P#2#3 &:# N'$&%-#/

W:'4 :,4 ,>> &:# :,>>+,-P4 19 , ('$'1%4 $.$>#] '+N,&'#2$# S'&: &:# N,$# 19 Z%4&'$#

,23 1(#-,>> +'4&-%4& #+H1>3#2 ,-+#3 8-1%N4[ &:#'- '2$-#,4#3 ,$&'('4+ %23#-+'2#4

&:# 4&, ,H'>'&. &1 9%2$&'12Y '2$>%3'28 12 +,&-4 19 >,S ,23 1-3#-[ ,23 &:'4 '2 &%-2

('23'$, &:# ,-+#3 8-1%N4X $>,'+ &:,& '& '4 &:#'- 3%&. &1 9'>> &:# (,$%%+/


4/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 ((

^23#->.'28 &:'4 4&, 19 ,99,'-4 ,-# &S1 $129>'$&'28 ('#S4 19 H1&: &:# 41%-$# 19 &:#

N-1H>#+ ,23 &:# 2,&%-# 19 '&4 -#+#3./ *1+# _ ;-'+# G'2'4- =>' b#'3,2X4 81(#-2B

+#2& ,+128 &:#+ _ ('#S &:# ,-+#3 8-1%N4 ,4 , N-'2$'N,> $,%4# 19 8-1S'28 ('1>#2$#[

&:#. ,3(1$, &:#'- 3'4H,23+#2& 1- ,H41-N&'12 '2&1 &:# 199'$',> 4#$%-'&. ,NN,-,&%4

,23 &:# &-,249#- 19 3#&,'2##4 %23#- &:#'- $12&-1> &1 &:# 4&, Z%3'$',-./ c&:#-4Y '2B

$>%3'28 &:# H-'8,3#4 &:#+4#>(#4Y ('#S &:# ,-+#3 8-1%N4X ,$&'('&. ,4 2#$#44,-. '2 >'8:&

19 3#9#$&'(# 4&, '24&'&%&'124 ,23 $12&'2%#3 4S,. 19 K,3:,9'B#-, 199'$',>4/ W:#4#

$1+N#&'28 2,--,&'(#4 &-,24>, '2&1 3'(#-8#2& ,NN-1,$:#4 &1 &:# Z%3'$',-.] H#&S##2

&:# 81(#-2+#2&X4 $,%&'1%4 ,NN-1,$: &1 S##3'28 1%& 91-+#- 199'$',>4 12 , $,4#BH.B

$,4# H,4'4 ,23 &:# H-'8,3#4X $,>> 91- -11&B,23BH-,2$: 3'4+'44,> 19 ,>> N-#4%+#3 >1.,>B

'4&4/ W1 +,2. 7'H.,24Y 9-%4&-, H. :1S >'&&># ,NN#,-4 &1 :,(# $:,28#3Y &:# >,&-

('#S %231%H>. $,--'#4 ,NN#,>/

?12&-,3'$&1-. 81(#-2+#2& N1>'$'#4 &1S,-34 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 N,-&>. #"N>,'2 &:# #"B

'4$# 19 4%$: N1>,-'4#3 ('#S4/ W:# U,&'12,> W-,24'&'12,> ?1%2$'> @UW?EY 7'H.,X4

9'-4& N14&BK,3:,9' 81(#-2'28 H13.Y (1S#3 &1 H%'>3 , 2#S Z%4&'$# 4.4+ H,4#3 12 &:#

-%># 19 >,S/ d#&Y '& 4'+%>&,2#1%4>. #2$1%-,8#3 $1241>'3,&'12 19 &:# H-'8,3#4Y 8-,2&'28

199'$',> -#$182'&'12 &1 , >,-8# 2%+H#- 19 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 &:,& $,--'#3 1%& &:#'- 1S2 N1B

>'$'28 ,$&'('&'#4/ W11Y '& N-1('3#3 &:#+ S'&: '++%2'&. 91- $-'+#4 ,-8%,H>. $,--'#3 1%&

'2 3#9#2$# 19 &:# -#(1>%&'12/ W:# UW?X4 4%$$#441- _ &:# #>#$ V#2#-,> U,&'12,>

?128-#44 @VU?E _ N,-&',>>. 91>>1S#3 '2 '&4 911&4N4Y 4,2$&'12'28 #991-&4 H. 81(#-2B

+#2&B,99'>', ,-+#3 8-1%N4 &1 4#'e# 4%4N#$ '23'('3%,>4 S'&:1%& -#8,-3 91- 3%#

N-1$#44/

V'(#2 &:'4Y '& '4 , $-#3'& &1 b#'3,2X4 81(#-2+#2&Y ,NN1'2 '2 U1(#+H#- LM6LY

&:,& '& '4 &-.'28 &1 H%$P &:# &'3#/ f# ,23 :'4 Z%4&'$# +'2'4- :,(# ,221%2$#3 , N1>'$.

19 e#-1B&1>#-,2$# &1S,-3 ,-H'&-,-. 3#&'12 1- -#(#28# ,44,44'2,&'124 ,23 +,3# '& ,

N-'1-'&. &1 &-,249#- '2&1 4&, $%4&13. &:1%4,234 19 ,-H'&-,-'>. 3#&,'2#3 '23'('3%,>4/

*&, 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4 :,(# #+N&'#3 4#(#-,> '>>#8,> 3#&'12 $#2&-#4 '2 &:# $,N'&,> ,23

&:# >#8'4>,&%-# N,44#3 , >,S $-'+'2,>'4'28 &1-&%-# ,23 ,H3%$&'124/

5& '4 (#-. +%$: , S1-P '2 N-18-#44Y &:1%8:Y ,23 &:# H,>,2$# 19 N1S#- 31#4 21&

$>#,->. &'>& &1S,-3 &:# 81(#-2+#2&/ 59 21& $,-#9%>>. +,2,8#3Y ,23 '2 N,-&'$%>,- '9 >#8'&B

'+, 8-'#(,2$#4 -#8,-3'28 &:# 4>%88'4: N,$# 19 Z%4&'$# 91- K,3:,9'B#-, $-'+#4 ,-#

21& ,33-#44#3Y , $129-12&,&'12,> ,NN-1,$: &1S,-3 &:# H-'8,3#4 $1%>3 S#>> H,$P9'-#/

W:#-# '4 #('3#2$# ,>-#,3.] &:# Z%4&'$# +'2'4&-. ,23 N-'+# +'2'4-X4 199'$# :,(# $1+#

%23#- ,&&,$PY ,23 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 &:-#, &1 &,P# 1(#- N-'4124 $%--#2&>. %23#- 81(B

#-2+#2& $12&-1>/

V#&&'28 &:'4 -'8:& S'>> #2&,'> , 91-+ 19 N1>'&'$,> +%>&'B&,4P'28/ W:# 81(#-2+#2&

S'>> :,(# &1 N-1('3# ('4'H># 4'824 &:,& '& '4 ,33-#44'28 4:1-&$1+'284 '2:#-' 9-1+

&:# N,4& '2 1-3#- &1 -#4&1-# $129'3#2$# '2 &:# Z%4&'$# 4.4+ ,23 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4/

?-'+'2,> N-14#$%&'124 ,8,'24& :'8:B-,2P'28 K,3:,9'B#-, 199'$',>4 ,-# ,2 '+N1-&,2&

4NY H%& &:#. S'>> 21& 4%99'$#[ S:,& '4 2##3#3 '4 , +1-# $1+N-#:#24'(# &-,24'&'12,>

Z%4&'$# N-1$#44 &:,&Y '2 ,33'&'12 &1 $-'+'2,> &-',>4Y '2$>%3#4 ,NN-1N-', (#&&'28

+#$:,2'4+4 91- 91-+#- -#8'+# >1.,>'4&4 ,23 &-%&: $1++'44'124/ =& &:# 4,+# &'+#Y

,-+#3 8-1%N4 _ #(#2 &:14# :,'>#3 ,4 :#-1#4 19 &:# %N-'4'28 _ S'>> 2##3 &1 H# :#>3

,$$1%2&,H># 91- &:#'- ,$&'124 ,4 S#>>[ Z%4&'$# 91- ('$&'+4 19 .#4-3,.X4 $-'+#4 +%4& 81

:,23B'2B:,23 S'&: Z%4&'$# 91- ('$&'+4 19 &13,.X4/


5/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 (((

/#$0++#12,&'013

40 -#3&0-# &-%3& '1 &5# 6%2'$',7 3.3+ ,12 #13%-# ,$$0%1&,8'7'&.

!* /71 ;-'4:Y ,4 , +,&- 19 %-8#2$.Y , 4$-##2'28 N-1$#44 &1 #23 ,-H'&-,-. 3#&'124/

D/ 0#,$&'(, $%--#2&>. 212B1N#-,&'(# $1%-&4Y ,23 '2 3'4&-'$&4 S:#-# >'28#-'28 3'4B

&-%4& &1S,-34 &:# 4&, Z%3'$',-. '4 &:# $,%4# 91- &:#'- $>14%-#Y -#,$: 1%& &1 >1$,>

,-+#3 8-1%N4Y 21&,H>#4 ,23 >1$,> $1%2$'>4 &1 N-1+1 8-#,- 3',>18%# 12 &:# 4&,

Z%4&'$# 4.4+/

C/ 0#,$: 1%& &1 1-3'2,-. $'&'e#24 &:-1%8: +#3', ,23 $'('> 41$'#&. 8-1%N4 &1 #"N>,'2

&:# $%--#2& Z%3'$',> 4.4+ ,23 -#4&1-# $129'3#2$# '2 S:,& +,2. 4&'>> N#-$#'(# ,4

, K,3:,9'B#-, -#>'$/

!* /71 ?121"$% @$/#*2$% :*2A"1..+

I/ ;,44 , +13'9'#3 H'>> 12 &:# Z%3'$',-.Y ,4 3#4$-'H#3 ,H1(#Y 41 &:,& Z%38#4 ,-# (#&B

H. ,2 '23#N#23#2& N,2#>Y ,23 %4# &:'4Y -,&:#- &:,2 &:# ;1>'&'$,> ,23 =3+'2'4B

&-,&'(# !"$>%4'12 7,SY ,4 &:# N-'2$'N,> +#,24 &1 S##3 1%& $1--%N& ,23 &,'2

+#+H#-4 19 &:# Z%3'$',-./

J/ =NN-1(# &:# 3-,9& >,S4 12 &-,24'&'12,> Z%4&'$# ,23 -#4&-'$&'12 19 +'>'&,-. Z%-'4B

3'$&'12 &1 +#+H#-4 19 &:# ,-+#3 91-$#4/

!* /71 B88#01 *8 /71 ?121"$% 3"*.10-/*"+

T/ !24%-# &:,& ,>> '2(#4&'8,&'124 ,23 $-'+'2,> &-',>4Y '2$>%3'28 &:14# 19 91-+#- -#B

8'+# 199'$',>4Y -#4N#$& 3%# N-1$#44 ,23 ,-# $123%$ $124'4& S'&: &:# ?13# 19

?-'+'2,> ;-1$#3%-#/

!* A*C1"2=12/. /7$/ 7$C1 41$'#&. 1-8,2'4,&'124X

#991-&4 &1 31$%+#2& N,4& ,23 -#$#2& ,H%4#4/


6/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 (7

40 5#79 -#'1 '1 ,-+#2 :-0%93

!* /71 ?121"$% @$/#*2$% :*2A"1..+

A/ =+#23 >,S D,-'9. &:,& N#-N#&-,&1-4 19 $-'+#4 4%$: ,4 &1-&%-#Y +%-B

3#- ,23 -,N# $1++'& 3%-'28 ,23 ,9- &:# LM66 S,- S'>> 21& H# 8-,2 >#8,>

'++%2'&./

!* /71 B88#01 *8 /71 ?121"$% 3"*.10-/*"+

6M/f1>3 +#+H#-4 19 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 ,$$1%2&,H># 91- &:#'- ,$&'124Y 21&,H>. &:14#

'2(1>('28 &1-&%-# ,23 3#,&: '2 3#&'12/

!* /71 I2/1"#*" >#2#./"( $26 K181201 >#2#./"(+

66/ F,- '23'('3%,>4 ,23 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 -#4N124'H># 91- 4#-'1%4 $-'+#4 9-1+ >#,3#-B4:'N N14'&'124 '2 &:# 4&, 4#$%-'&. ,NN,-,&%4/

6L/ !24%-# &:,& %2'&4 19 &:# *%N-#+# *#$%-'&. ?1++' @**?EY 7'H., *:'#>3 ,23

1&:#- 81(#-2+#2&B,NN-1(#3 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 :,>& &:# N-,$&'$# 19 ,--#4&'28 '23'('3B

%,>4 ,23 4&1-+'28 :1+#4 1- 199'$#4 S'&:1%& S,--,2& 1- #('3#2$# 19 S-12831'28/

6D/ !24%-# &:,& 12>. 199'$',> 4#$%-'&. %2'&4 ,--#4& 41B$,>>#3 S,2 '23'('3%,>4 ,23

&:,& 4%$: %2'&4 ,3:#-# 4&-'$&>. &1 3%# N-1$#44/

!"#


7/53

-./0'.1/(2.1) 3'(4(4 5'26&

!"##$% '()*+,-.*/ 01."2( 3%4-.* ,5678 6< 04."$ =86>

W-',> H. !--1-] O%4&'$# '2 ;14&BK,3:,9' 7'H.,

5/ I2/"*6-0/#*2

52 c$&1H#- LM6LY ,-+#3 8-1%N4 >#3 ,2 ,44,%>& 12 &:# &1S2 19 F,2' a,>'3 91>>1S'28

'&4 -#9%4,> &1 :,23 1(#- 41B$,>>#3 S,2 '23'('3%,>4/ W:# -#4%>& _ 1(#- IM 3#,3 ,23

+1-# &:,2 6MYMMM 9,+'>'#4 91-$#3 &1 9>## &:#'- :1+#4 _ S,4 , 4&,-P '>>%4&-,&'12 19Y

,+128 1&:#- N-1H>#+4Y &:# -'4P4 N#-4'4& 3'4,--,. '2 7'H.,X4 Z%3'$',-. #2&,'>/6G1-#

&:,2 , .#,- ,23 , :,>9 4'2$# &:# 9,>> 19 K,3:,9'X4 -#8'+#Y &:# ,H4#2$# 19 , 9%2$&'12'28

$1%-& 4.4+ ,23 &:# 81(#-2+#2&X4 '2,H'>'&. &1 $%-H ,-+#3 8-1%N4 _ S:'$: $12&'2%#

&1 -%2 N-'4124 ,23 #291-$# &:#'- 1S2 91-+4 19 Z%4&'$# _ 9%#> 9-%4&-,&'12Y :,+N#-'28

#991-&4 ,& 2,&'12,> -#$12$'>',&'12 ,23 %23#-+'2'28 &:# ,%&:1-'&. 19 , 4&'>> S#,P ,239-,8+#2 4&,/L

^N12 $1+'28 &1 N1S#-Y 7'H.,X4 2#S >#,3#-4 N-1+'4#3 , $>#,2 H-#,P 9-1+ &:#

,H%4#4 19 &:# N,4&Y S:#2 N1>'&'$,> &-',>4Y 3#&'12 ,23 P'>>'28 19 -#8'+# 1NN12#2&4

S#-# $1++12N>,$#/ 7'P#S'4#Y &:#. -#N#,>. ,44#- &:#'- $1++'&+#2& &1 &:# -%>#

6 c2 LI *#N+H#- LM6LY 9'8:-4 9-1+ &:# &1S2 19 G'4-,&, (1S#3 &1 N%-8# F,2' a,>'3 19 91-+#-

-#8'+# -#+2,2&4 '9 >#,3#-4 19 &:# $'&.Y S:'$: &:#. ,$$%4# 19 H#'28 , N-1BK,3:,9' 4&-128:1>3Y -#9%4#3

&1 :,23 1(#- &:14# -#4N124'H># 91- &:# 3#,&: 19 c+-,2 *:,,H,2/ f# S,4 , 91-+#- -#H#> 9-1+ G'4B

-,&, $-#3' S'&: $,N&%-'28 K,3:,9'/ 52Z%-#3 ,23 3#&,'2#3 '2 F,2' a,>'3Y :# 3'#3 19 :'4 S1%234

,9- :'4 -#>#,4#/ W:# V#2#-,> U,&'12,> ?128-#44 @VU?E 4%NN1- &:# 3#+,234Y '44%'28 VU? Q#B

$-## TiLM6LY ,%&:1-'4'28 91-$# &1 $,N&%-# &:14# ,>>#8#3>. -#4N124'H># 91- :'4 3#,&:/ W:# 3#$-## 4&,&B

#3 &:,& g&:# 3#9#2$# +'2'4&-. ,23 &:# '2-'1- +'2'4&-. ,-# &,4P#3 S'&: &:# ,--#4& 19 &:14# -#4N124'B

H># 91- &:# P'32,NN'28 ,23 &1-&%-# 19 &:# +,-&.- j*:,,H,2k ,23 :'4 $1+N,2'124Y ,23 &:# ,--#4& 19

1&:#-4 S,2 H. Z%4&'$#Y S:1 +%4& H# :,23#3 1(#- &1 &:# Z%3'$',-. S'&:'2 3,.4 9-1+ &:# '44%B

,2$# 19 &:# 3#$-##/ 7'P#S'4# N-'412#-4 4&'>> H#'28 :#>3 '2 F,2' a,>'3 +%4& H# -#>#,4#3/ W:# &S1 +'2B

'4&-'#4 ,-# ,%&:1-'4#3 &1 &,P# ,>> ,NN-1N-', +#,4%-#4Y '2$>%3'28 &:# %4# 19 91-$# '9 2#$#44,-. &1 '+B

N>#+#2& &:'4 3#$-##h/ G'4-,&,2 9'8:-4 9-1+ &:# 7'H., *:'#>3 `1-$#4 @7*`EY , $1,>'&'12 19 ,-+#3

8-1%N4 &:,& 1N#-, %23#- &:# $:'#9 19 4&,99X4 ,%&:1-'&.Y '+N14#3 , &:-##BS##P 4'#8# 12 &:# 1%&B

4P'-&4 19 &:# &1S2/ W:#. $%& 199 #>#$&-'$'&.Y S,- ,23 9113 4%NN>'#4 '2 ,2 ,&+N& &1 N-#44%-# &:#

&1S2X4 ,%&:1-'&'#4 &1 :,23 1(#- &:# ,>>#8#3 9%8'&'(#4/ 0#$12$'>',&'12 $1%2$'>4 ,23 VU? ;-#4'3#2&

G1:,++#3 G,8,-'#9 9,'>#3 &1 H-1P#- , N#,$#9%> ,8-##+#2&/ Q#4N' &:# 4'#8# ,23 &:-#,&4 19 ,&&,$PY

F,2' a,>'3 &-'H,> #>3#-4 -#9%4#3 &1 :,23 1(#- &:#'- +#2 &1 S:,& &:#. $124'3#-#3 >,S>#44 +'>'&',4 ,23

$,>>#3 91- , N-1N#- '2(#4&'8,&'12/ W:#. ,>41 S#-# -#>%$&,2& &1 :,23 &:#+ 1(#- &1 , 4&, &:,& _ '2

&:#'- S1-34 _ :,3 , gH-1P#2 Z%3'$',> 4.4+h/ =9- 4#(#-,> -1%234 19 2#81&',&'124Y &:#. 4&, &:#'-

S'>>'282#44 &1 ,>>1S &:# ,-+. #2- &:# &1S2 ,23 &1 :,23 1(#- &:14# '23'('3%,>4 91- S:1+ &:# N-14B

#$%&1- S1%>3 4'82 ,2 ,--#4& S,--,2&/ G'4-,&,2 ,%&:1-'&'#4 -#9%4#3 &:# N-1N14,>Y ,23 &:# 7*`Y S'&:

41+# ,-+. H,$P'28Y >,%2$:#3 , 9%>>B4$,># ,&&,$PY 6TBLC c$&1H#-/ =$$1-3'28 &1 &:# 81(#-2+#2&

4N1P#4N#-412Y 4N#,P'28 '++#3',>. ,9- &:# ,&&,$PY g,-1%23 IM N#1N># 3'#3 '2 &:# $>,4:#4hY H%& 21

199'$',> 3#,&: &1>> S,4 #(#- #4&,H>'4:#3/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y VU? +#+H#-4Y *%N-#+# *#$%-'&.

?1%2$'> @**?E $1++,23#-4Y 7*` +#+H#-4Y &-'H,> >#,3#-4Y Z%38#4 ,23 N-14#$%&1-4Y W-'N1>'Y b>'

,23 F,2' a,>'3Y U1(#+H#-BQ#$#+H#- LM6L[ U,4- ,>BG,2,,Y 81(#-2+#2& 4N1P#4N#-412 ,& >#('4#3

Z1'2& N-#44 $129#-#2$#Y W-'N1>'Y LC c$&1H#- LM6L/ = 4'+'>,- -#9%4,> &1 :,23 1(#- gS,2h '23'('3%B

,>4 &-'88#-#3 ,-+#3 $>,4:#4 '2 W-'N1>'X4 $#2&-,> b,S'., *&-##& 2#'8:H1%-:113 12 C U1(#+H#- LM6LY

'2 &:# $1,4&,> $'&. 19 l:1+4 &:# 2#"& 3,.Y ,23 ,8,'2 '2 F,2' a,>'3 '2 +'3BQ#$#+H#- LM6L/ 52 #,->.

LM6DY 7*` 91-$#4 9-1+ b,S'., $>,'+#3 &:,& 91%- N#1N># 3'#3Y '2$>%3'28 ,2 7*` $1++,23#-Y '2 8%2B

9'8:&4 91>>1S'28 ,2 ,&+N& &1 ,--#4& , gS,2h -#4'3#2& 19 &:# 2#,-H. &1S2 19 =Z,.>,&[ :1S#(#-Y

N#1N># 9,+'>',- S'&: &:# '2$'3#2& $>,'+ &:# $>,4:#4 S#-# 1(#- 3-%8 -1%/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y

&-'H,> >#,3#-4Y 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4Y W-'N1>' ,23 *,H-,&:,Y O,2%,-. LM6D/L `1- #,->'#- ,2,>.4'4 19 $1++%2,> $>,4:#4Y '2$>%3'28 &:14# '2 F,2' a,>'3Y 4## ?-'4'4 V-1%N G'33>#

!,4&iU1-&: =9-'$, 0#N1-& Um6DMY;'('2#2 '8.,?3 !12%-'1: @01A7'$&3Y 6C *#N+H#-

LM6L/


8/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 *

19 >,S/ R'4'&'28 , 2#S 3#&'12 9,$'>'&. '2 O%>. LM6L 12 &:# #(# 19 &:# $1%2&-.X4 9'-4&

#>#$&'12Y 91-+#- ;-'+# G'2'4- ,>Bl##H 4,'3Y gN-1N#- Z%4&'$# '4 12# 19 &:# -#,4124

S:. &:'4 -#(1>%&'12 4&,- ,23 12# 19 &:# -#,4124 S:. S# #23#3 S:#-# S# ,-#h/D

!$:1'28 &:14# S1-34Y &:# 2#S N-'+# +'2'4-Y =>' b#'3,2Y (1S#3 &1 &%-2 7'H., '2&1

g, 4&, 19 >,Sh @2,B7,& C,1%1E/C*%$: N>#38#4 ,-# #24:-'2#3 '2 &:# =%8%4& LM66

52-'+ ?124&'&%&'12,> Q#$>,-,&'12Y ,$$1-3'28 &1 S:'$: g&:#-# 4:,>> H# 21 $-'+# 1-

N#2,>&. #"$#N& H. ('-&%# 19 &:# "& 19 &:# >,ShY ,23 gZ%38#4 4:,>> H# '23#N#23#2&Y

4%HZ#$& &1 21 1&:#- ,%&:1-'&. H%& &:# >,S ,23 $124$'#2$#h/I

W:# ,%&:1-'&'#4 %231%H>. :,(# +,3# N-18-#44 '2 4#(#-,> -#4N#$&4[ 21&,H>.Y &:#

$123'&'124 '2 S:'$: :'8:B-,2P'28 N-'412#-4 ,-# :#>3 $>#,->. :,(# '+N-1(#3Y ,23 &:#

*%N-#+# ?1%-& :,4 8,'2#3 8-#,- '23#N#23#2$#/ G1-#1(#-Y 91>>1S'28 , Q#$#+H#-

LM6L *%N-#+# ?1%-& -%>'28 &:,& 3#$>,-#3 %2$124&'&%&'12,> $#-&,'2 N-1$#3%-#4 %4#3

'2 &-',>4 ,8,'24& 4#2'1- K,3:,9'B#-, 199'$',>4 @N-1$#3%-#4 H#\%#,&:#3 H. &:# 91-+#-

-#8'+#EY Z%38#44#& 1%& &1 -#$&'9. &:#+/J

d#&Y &:#4# ,$:'#(#+#2&4 21&S'&:4&,23'28Y +%$: Z%3'$',> -#91-+ 4&'>> ,S,'&4/ ;,-&

19 &:# N-1H>#+ '2(1>(#4 &:# >128 :'4&1-. 19 N1>'&'$,> '2-9#-#2$# ,23 $1--%N&'12 &:#

$%--#2& 4.4+ '2:#-' ,23 &:,& 2##34 4#-'1%4 $1--#$&'12/ =>41Y ('#S4 12 ,NN-1N-'B

, -#+#3'#4 3'(#-8#/

D *## g7'H., Z%4&'$# 4.4+ 4&,82,2& 3#4N' 9%23'28hY =>BO,e##-,Y 6 O%>. LM6L/ ;-1&4 ,8,'24& &:#

3#&'12 19 , N-1+'2#2& >,S.#- ,23 :%+,2 -'8:&4 ,$&'('4&Y ,&:' W#-H'>Y S:1+ K,3:,9'B#-, 4#$%-'&.

199'$',>4 '2 F#28:,e' $,>>#3 '2 91- \%#4&'12'28 12 6I `#H-%,-. LM66Y S#-# , N-#$%-41- &1 &:# >,-8#-

,2&'B-#8'+# N-1&4 &:,& #-%N '2 &:# #,4-2 $'&. 1(#- 4%H4#\%#2& 3,.4/ W#-H'> :,3 -#N-#4#2

9,+'>'#4 19 &:# ('$&'+4 19 &:# =H% *,>'+ 6AAJ N-'412 +,44,$-# 3%-'28 S:'$: 4#$%-'&. 199'$',>4 P'>>#3

1(#- 6YLMM 3#&,'2##4 91>>1S'28 , N-'412 -'1&/ W:# \%#4& 91- Z%4&'$# H#$,+# , $#2&-,> &:#+# 19 &:#

LM66 %N-'4'28[ &:#4# ,4N'-,&'124 S#-# 4.+H1>'4#3 H. &:# &-,2491-+,&'12 19 F#28:,e'X4 $1%-&:1%4#

'2&1 &:# %N-'4'28X4 1N#-,&'124 $#2&-#/ W:# $:1'$# 19 91-+#- O%4&'$# G'2'4- G%4&,9, =H3#> O,>'> &1

:#,3 &:# U,&'12,> W-,24'&'12,> ?1%2$'> @UW?EY &:# 4#>9BN-1$>,'+#3 ,44#+H>. &:,& >#3 &:# 9'8:&

,8,'24& &:# -#8'+#Y S,4 >>'28[ '2 LM6MY :# :,3 $>,4:#3 S'&: K,3:,9' 1(#- Z%3'$',> -#91-+/ W:# ,NB

N1'2&+#2&4 &1 &:# UW? 19 W#-H'> ,23 =:+#3 b1%H,'-Y 7'H.,X4 >128#4& 4#-('28 N1>'&'$,> N-'412#-Y

S#-# #\%,>>. 4'82'9'$,2&/C *## N%H>'$ ,33-#44#4 H-1,3$,4& 12 7'H., a,&,2'., -,3'1 $:,22#>Y I O,2%,-. LM6D/ g7'H., 4&, 19

>,S ,23 Z%4&'$# ,23 -#4N#$& 19 :%+,2 -'8:&4h '4 ,>41 &:# +1&&1 19 &:# LM6LBLM6C 4&-,'$ N>,2 19 &:#

Z%4&'$# +'2'4&-./I 0#4N#$&'(#>. =-&'$>#4 D6 ,23 DL 19 &:# 52-'+ ?124&'&%&'12,> Q#$>,-,&'12Y ,NN-1(#3 ,23 ,2B

21%2$#3 H. &:# UW? 12 D =%8%4& LM66Y :#2$#91-&: ?124&'&%&'12,> Q#$>,-,&'12 @LM66E/ W:# DT ,-&'B

$>#4 ,-# &:# P#. 81(#-2,2$# N-'2$'N>#4 %2&'> ,31N&'12 19 , N#-+,2#2& $124&'&%&'12 ,23 #>#$&'12 19

-#N-#4#2&,&'(# H13'#4/J ?124&'&%&'12,> ?:,+H#- 19 &:# *%N-#+# ?1%-&Y -%>'28 IAiLIY LD Q#$#+H#- LM6L/ =>&:1%8: '2

LMMI 7'H., ,H1>'4:#3 &:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& @+,5D,+, ,7E35,,8E ,23 &:# N#1N>#X4 N-14#$%&'12 199'$#

@, 4#N,-, 199'$# 91- $,4#4 :#,-3 '2 &:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-&EY &:# 6A,S -#8%>,&'28 &:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-&

S,4 21& 4$-,NN#3/ =4 , -#4%>&Y #(#2 ,9- &:# $1%-& $#,4#3 &1 #"'4&Y 1-3'2,-. N-14#$%&1-4 $12&'2%#3

&1 ,3Z%3'$, +14& $-'+'2,> 199#2$#4Y '2$>%3'28 N1>'&'$,> $-'+#4Y N%-4%,2& &1 &:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-&X4

N-1$#3%-#4 ,4 1NN14#3 &1 &:14# -#8%>,&'28 1-3'2,-. $-'+'2,> N-14#$%&'12/ *N#$'9'$,>>.Y 4%4N#$&4 ,NB

N#,-'28 H#91-# , ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& $1%>3 H# 3#&,'2#3 91- >128#- N#-'134 S'&:1%& Z%3'$',> -#('#S ,23 3'3

21& :,(# , -'8:& &1 , >,S.#- 3%-'28 '2--18,&'124[ >'P#S'4#Y N-14#$%&1-4 3'3 21& 2##3 &1 81 &:-1%8:

,2 '23'$&+#2& $:,+H#- &1 H-'28 , $,4# &1 $1%-&/ ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& N-1$#3%-#4 $12&'2%#3 &1 H# %4#3 %2&'> ,

LD Q#$#+H#- LM6L *%N-#+# ?1%-& -%>'28/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY 4#2'1- +'2'4&-. 19 Z%4&'$# 199'$',>Y

>#8,> 4$:1>,-Y O,2%,-. LM6D/ W:# *%N-#+# ?1%-& -%>'28 4:1%>3 ,99#$& ,>> $,4#4 ,8,'24& K,3:,9'B#-,

199'$',>4 &:,& :,(# -#,$:#3 &-',> N:,4#/ W:#4# '2$>%3# $,4#4 ,8,'24& 91-+#- '2>>'8#2$# $:'#9 =H%

b#'3 Q1-3,Y 91-+#- 1-#'82 G'2'4- =H3#> =&' ,>BcH#'3'Y 91-+#- :#,3 19 &:# V#2#-,> ;#1N>#X4 ?12B

8-#44 @V;?E G%:,+#3 F#>\,4'+ bS,' ,23 91-+#- ;-'+# G'2'4- ,>BF,8:3,3' ,>BG,:+%3'Y ,>> 19

S:1+ ,-# H#'28 :#>3 ,23 &-'#3 '2 W-'N1>'/ W:# *%N-#+# ?1%-& -%>'28 ,>41 '4 >'P#>. &1 ,99#$& N-#N,-,B

&'124 91- &:# &-',>4 19 K,3:,9'X4 412 *,'9 ,>B54>,+ ,23 '2>>'8#2$# $:'#9 =H3%>>,: *#2%44'/


9/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 ,

*#(#-,> >,S+,P#-4 H#>'#(# &:,& Z%4&'$# S'>> 12>. H#8'2 &1 H# 4#-(#3 ,9- , &:1-B

1%8: N%-8# 19 &:# Z%3'$',-./ 1- &:'4 N%-N14#Y &:#. 4%NN1-& &S1 3-,9& >,S4 &:,& S1%>3

>#,3 &1 &:# 3'4+'44,> 1- H,--'28 9-1+ 199'$# 19 , >,-8# N#-$#2&,8# 19 $%--#2& Z%38#4

,23 N-14#$%&1-4/Ta:'># 2#'&:#- >,S :,3 H##2 ,NN-1(#3Y N%H>'$ N-#44%-# &1 g$>#,24#h

&:# 4.4+ 19 91-+#- 199'$',>4 '4 +1%2&'28/ ?-'&'$4 19 &:#4# H'>>4Y '2$>%3'28 +14& $%-B

-#2& +#+H#-4 19 &:# Z%3'$',-.Y H#>'#(# &:,& 4%$: , N%-8# S1%>3 31 +1-# :,-+ &:,2

8113/ W:#. ,-8%# '24,3 &:,& , >'+' 2%+H#- 19 N#1N># 4:1%>3 H# 3'4+'44#3Y H%&

12>. ,9- '23'('3%,> 4$-##2'28 ,23 ,>1284'3# '2-2,> -#91-+ 19 &:# Z%3'$',-. ,23 &:#

#2&'-# $1%-& ,NN,-,&%4Y '2$>%3'28 +'>'&,-. $1%-&4Y S:'$: #2Z1. S'3# >,&'&%3# &1 &-.

$'('>',24 ,23 ,-# ('#S#3 ,4 >,$P'28 '23#N#23#2$#/ N-1H>#+4 ,4'3#Y Z%3'$',> ,%&:1-'&. >'P#S'4# :,4 H##2 #-13#3

H. 1(#-,>> >,$P 19 4#$%-'&./ W:# ,H4#2$# 19 ,2 #99#$&'(# 2,&'12,> N1>'$# 91-$#Y S'3#B

4N-#,3 ,(,'>,H'>'&. 19 S#,N124 ,23 N#-4'4& ,44,44'2,&'12 19 4#$%-'&. 199'$',>4 :,(#

:,+N#-#3 &:# 4&, '2(#4&'8,&'(# $,N,$'&. ,4 S#>> ,4 '&4 ,H'>'&. &1 $,--. 1%& Z%4&'$#/

W#>>'28>.Y &:# '2(#4&'8,&'12 '2&1 &:# *#N+H#- LM6L ,&&,$P ,8,'24& &:# /*/ $124%>,

'2 F#28:,e'Y S:'$: P'>>#3 &:# ,+H,44,31- ,23 &:-## 1&:#- /*/ $'&'e#24Y :,4 $1+# &1

, 4&,234&'>>/A

=$-144 &:# $1%2&-.Y $-'+'2,> $1%-&4 1N#-, ,& , H,-# +'2'+%+/ 52 &:# O#H#>

=P:3,- -#8'12Y #,4& 19 F#28:,e'Y '2,3#\%, 4#$%-'&. ,23 &:-#,&4 ,8,'24& >1$,> N-14#B

$%&1-4 ,23 Z%38#4 :,(# 91-$#3 &:# 4%4N#24'12 19 ,>> '2(#4&'8,&'124 ,23 &-',>4 4'2$#

T W:# 9'-4& '4 &:# 3-,9& >,S 12 &:# Z%3'$',-. N-#4#2 H. &:# *%N-#+# O%3'$',> ?1%2$'> @*O?E &1 &:#

VU? 12 6J c$&1H#- LM6L/ 5& S1%>3 3'4+'44 ,>> +#+H#-4 19 &:# Z%3'$',-. ,23 $:,-8# , 4#$-#& $1++'&B

# S'&: #"$>%4'(#>. -#,NN1'2&'28 &:14# 3##+#3 9'& 91- 3%&./ W:# 4#$123 '4 &:# 3-,9& >,S 12 N1>'&'$,>

,23 ,3+'2'4&-,&'(# #"$>%4'12 @,7E,F7 ,7E3'.,3' B, ,7E'2,-'EY :#2$#91-&: N1>'&'$,> #"$>%4'12 >,SY S:'$:

, $1++' 19 2'2##2 VU? +#+H#-4 N-#4#2 &1 &:# VU? 12 6C #H-%,-. LM6D/ W:'4 H'>> N-1B

N14#4 &1 3'4H,- ,>> Z%38#4 S:1 4#-(#3 12 , K,3:,9'B#-, ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& ,23 1&:#- &.N#4 19 41B$,>>#3

g#"$#N&'12,>h 1- g4N#$',>h $1%-&4Y ,4 S#>> ,4 ,>> 91-+#- N-14#$%&1- 8#2#-,>4 ,23 N#1N>#4X N-14#$%&1-4

@N-14#$%&1-4 '2 &:# N,-,>>#> ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-&4 4.4+EY '--#4N#$&'(# 19 '23'('3%,> $123%$&Y 91-

.#,-4/ 1- +1-# 12 &:# 4N#$',> $1%-&4Y 4## H#>1S/ =4'3# 9-1+ +#+H#-4 19 &:# Z%3'$',-.Y &:# N1>'&'$,>

#"$>%4'12 H'>> >'4&4 DI 1&:#- $,Q-'#4 19 N#1N># &1 H# H,--#3 9-1+ :'8:B-,2P'28 N1>'&'$,> ,23 ,3+'2B

'4&-,&'(# N14'&'124/ =& &:# &'+# 19 S-'&'28Y >,S+,P#-4 S#-# '2 &:# N-1$#44 19 3-,9&'28 , 2#S (#-4'12

19 &:# N1>'&'$,> '41>,&'12 H'>>Y S:'$: &:#. :1N#3 S1%>3 8,'2 #21%8: 4%NN1-& '2 &:# VU?/< ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y Z%38#4Y +#+H#-4 19 &:# *%N-#+# O%3'$',> ?1%2$'> ,23 &:# Z%4&'$# +'2'4B

&-.Y W-'N1>'Y O,2%,-. LM6D/A 7'H., :,4 '24'4 '& S'>> >#,3 '2(#4&'8,&'124 '2&1 &:# ,&&,$P/ 1- +1-# &:,2 4'" +12&:4Y /*/ 199'B

$',>4 -#N#,>. 4,'3 &:#-# :,3 H##2 21 21&'$#,H># N-18-#44Y S'&: 12# $,>>'28 '& g, Z1P#h/ 0#%-4Y 6A

Q#$#+H#- LM6L/ 52 &:,& N#-'13Y 7'H.,2 ,%&:1-'&'#4 +,3# 21 ,--#4& ,23 -#9-,'2#3 9-1+ \%#4&'12'28 ,

2%+H#- 19 4%4N#$&4 S:1 ,3+'& &1 Z1%-2,>'4&4 &:,& &:#. S#-# 12 &:# $124%>, 8-1%234 &:# 2'8:&

19 &:# ,&&,$P/ = W%2'4',2 ,23 ,2 !8.N&',2 2,&'12,> 4%4N#$ 19 H#'28 $122#$ &1 &:# ,&&,$P S#-#

%23#- '2(#4&'8,&'12 '2 &:#'- :1+# $1%2&-'#4Y H%& '2 O,2%,-. LM6D , Z%38# -#>#,4#3 &:# W%2'4',2 91-

>,$P 19 #('3#2$#[ &:# !8.N&',2 '4 H#>'#(#3 &1 H# 4&'>> 3#&,'2#3/ `#,- 19 N144'H># -#N-'4,>4 >#3 +,2.

4#$%-'&. 199'$',>4 '2 F#28:,e' &1 -#4'82 9-1+ &:# '2(#4&'8,&'(# ,+[ &:# $:,'2 19 $1++,23 S'&:'2 '&

N,44#3 9-1+ 12# 4#2'1- Z%3'$',> 199'$',> &1 ,21&:#- H#91-# &:# N-14#$%&1- 8#2#-,> '2 W-'N1>' ,44'82#3

&:# $,4# &1 ,2 '2(#4&'8,&'(# Z%38# 9-1+ &:# $,N'&,>/ Q%-'28 , G,-$: LM6D ('4'& &1 &:# ^/*/Y ;-'+#

G'2'4- =>' b#'3,2 -#'-, &:,& :'4 81(#-2+#2& '4 gP##2 12 -#,$:'28 &:# &-%&: ,23 &1 4## &:,&

Z%4&'$# '4 ,$:'#(#3h ,23 g&1 S1-P S'&: ;-#4'3#2& cH,+, 4#-'1%4>. '2 1-3#- &1 ,$:'#(# &:'4 81,>h/ *##

('3#1Y d1%W%H#Y 6D G,-$: LM6DY SSS/.1%&%H#/$1+iS,&$:n(oa.d&O*>1S'28 3,.Y

-#N1-&4 #+#-8#3 &:,& , +,2 4%4N#$ 19 '2(1>(#+#2& '2 &:# ,&&,$P :,3 H##2 3#&,'2#3 '2 7'H.,Y H%&

'& S,4 21& $>#,- S:#&:#- $:,-8#4 :,3 H##2 H-1%8:&/ g*1%-$#4] F#28:,e' 4%4N#$& 3#&,'2#3 '2 7'H.,hY

?UU @12>'2#EY 6C G,-$: LM6D/


10/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 9

Q#$#+H#- LM6L/6MW:# $1%-&:1%4# '2 a,33,2Y , 3#4#-& $'&. 41+# JMMP+ 41%&: #,4&

19 W-'N1>'Y S,4 &1-$:#3 '2 #H-%,-. LM6D ,23 ,>> $,4# 9'>#4 3#4&-1.#3/66G14& 81(#-2B

+#2&B$12&-1>>#3 N-'4124 ,-# 1(#-$-1S3#3 ,23 3#(1'3 19 N-1N#- 4#$%-'&.Y , 4'&%,&'12

&:,& :,4 >#3 &1 2%+#-1%4 Z,'>H-#,P4 4'2$# &:# #23 19 &:# $129>'$&/6LW:# N-#4#2$# 19

&:1%4,234 19 $12('$ $-'+'2,>4Y S:1+ K,3:,9' 4#& 9-## '2 &:# #,->. 3,.4 19 &:#

%N-'4'28 ,23 S:1+ $%--#2& ,%&:1-'&'#4 :,(# H##2 %2,H># &1 -#$,N&%-#Y ,>41 :,4 $12B

&-'H% &1 &:# '2$-#,4# '2 H,23'&-. ,23 ('1>#2$#/

G14& '+N1-&,2&>.Y &:# 4&, :,4 H##2 %2,H># 1- %2S'>>'28 &1 N-#(#2& '23'('3%,>4

,23 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 9-1+ ,NN>.'28 g('$&1-X4 Z%4&'$#h/ f%23-#34 19 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 &:,&

#+#-8#3 ('$&1-'1%4 ,23 -#9%4#3 &1 >,. 31S2 &:#'- ,-+4 ,9- &:# -#8'+#X4 9,>> 4&'>>

9%2$&'12 ,4 N,-,>>#> N1>'$# 91-$#4Y ,& &'+#4 S1-P'28 ,8,'24& 4&, '2-#4&4/ =>&:1%8:

41+# ,-+#3 8-1%N4 21+'2,>>. 9,>> %23#- &:# ,%&:1-'&. 19 , $'('>',2 1- +'>'&,-. N-14#B

$%&1-X4 199'$# _ 3#N#23'28 12 S:#&:#- &:#. :,(# H##2 -#$182'4#3 H. &:# '2-'1- 1-

3#9#2$# +'2'4&-. _ &:#. &1 ,$& H1&: '23#N#23#2&>. ,23 ,-H'&-,-'>./ *%$: H13'#4

91- &:# +14& N,-& ,>41 >,$P '2(#4&'8,&'(# $,N,$'&.Y ,23 &:#'- +#+H#-4 :,(# 2#(#- %2B

3#-812# 91-+,> N1>'$# 1- >#8,> &-,'2'28/ f,('28 $1+N'>#3 >'4&4 19 gS,2h '23'('3%B

,>4 _ S'&:1%& -#9#-#2$# &1 ,2. Z%3'$',> N-1$#3%-# _ &:#. :,(# $,--'#3 1%& ,-H'&-,-.

,--#4&4Y P'32,NN'284 ,23 P'>>'284 19 ,>>#8#3 g,2&'B-#(1>%&'12,-.h 9'8%-#4 S#>> ,9- &:#

#23 19 :14&'>'&'#4/ 523##3Y +1-# &:,2 TYMMM N#1N># $,N&%-#3 H. 41B$,>>#3 -#(1>%&'12B

,-. H-'8,3#4 3%-'28 ,23 ,9- &:# LM66 $129>'$& -#+,'2 '2 ,-H'&-,-. 3#&'12Y 91- &:#

+14& N,-& '2 +,P#4:'9& N-'4124/6D

6M?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y ,$&'('4&4 ,23 199'$',>4Y Q#-2,Y G,-$: LM6D/ ?1%-& 199'$#4 ,-# 1N#2Y H%&

41>#>. &1 -#$1-3 ,+'$,H># 4#&&>#+#2&4/66=>BG,2,-, 2#S4 @12>'2#EY LT #H-%,-. LM6D/ W:# $1%-&X4 -#8'4&-,- $,>>#3 &:# 9'-# ,2 g'2&'12,>

$-'+'2,> ,$&h/ 5H'3/6L O,'>H-#,P4 :,(# &,P#2N>,$# 9-1+ , 2%+H#- 19 4&,B$12&-1>>#3 3#&'12 9,$'>'&'#4 ,$-144 &:#

$1%2&-.] 9-1+ b,S'.,X4 O#3,.#+ N-'412 '2 O%2# LM6L[ *#H:,X4 0#91-+ ,23 0#:,H'>'&,&'12 524&'&%

'2 O%>. LM6L[ W-'N1>'X4 G,9&%:, @cN#2E N-'412 ,23 O3#'3, N-'412Y -#4N#$&'(#>. '2 =%8%4& ,23 c$&1B

H#- LM6L[ ,23 F#28:,e'X4 l,S9'.,X4 N-'412 '2 =%8%4& LM6L/ =>41Y %N &1 LMM '2+, 9>#3 9-1+

*#H:,X4 N-'412 '2 #,->. Q#$#+H#- LM6L/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y :%+,2 -'8:&4 ,$&'('4&Y W-'N1>'Y =%B

8%4& LM6L/ *## ,>41 gW:'-&.B91%- '2+, 12 &:# >114# 91>>1S'28 +,44 N-'412 H-#,P1%& '2 *#H:,hY

>'8., G#-,72Y 6J O%>. LM6L[ gLMM '2+, #4$,N# *#H:, N-'412 ,4 ?128-#44+#2 9-1+ #ee,2 4&,8#

VU? S,>P1%&hY>'8., G#-,72Y J Q#$#+H#- LM6L[ gF>,4& ,23 Z,'>H-#,P -1$P 7'H.,X4 F#28:,e'hY =>B

O,e##-,Y 6 =%8%4& LM6L[ gW-'N1>' N-'412 4%99#-4 +,44'(# H-#,P1%&hY FF?Y 6I c$&1H#- LM6L/ =$$1-3'28

&1 a#4-2 199'$',>4 ,3('4'28 &:# 81(#-2+#2& 12 N-'412 -#91-+Y 3#&'12 $#2&-#4 '2 W-'N1>' ,23

b,S'., ,-# 1(#-$-1S3#3Y H#&S##2 IM ,23 6MM N#- $#2& H#.123 $,N,$'&./ 52 G'4-,&, , 2%+H#- 19

4$:11>4 :,(# H##2 &%-2#3 '2&1 3#&'12 $#2&-#4/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y '2-2,&'12,> N-'412 -#B

91-+ ,3('4#-4Y W-'N1>'Y O,2%,-. LM6D/6D W:#-# ,-# 21 199'$',> 4&,&'4&'$4 12 &:# N-'412 N1N%>,&'12Y H# '& 19 &:14# %23#- 81(#-2+#2& $12&-1>

1- '2 &:# $%4&13. 19 '23#N#23#2& ,-+#3 8-1%N4/ 7'P#S'4# &:#-# ,-# 21 199'$',> 2%+H#-4 19 4#2B

$#3Y $:,-8#3 1- %2$:,-8#3 3#&,'2##4/ =$$1-3'28 &1 f%+,2 0'8:&4 a,&$: @f0aEY '2 c$&1H#-

LM6L ,NN-1"'+,>. # S#-# '2 3#&'12[ 19 &:#4#Y DYMMM S#-# '2 81(#-2+#2& $%4&13.Y

,NN-1"'+,>. LYMMM S#-# :#>3 H. &:# *%N-#+# *#$%-'&. ?1++'[ ,23 &:# -#4& S#-# :#>3 H. (,-B

'1%4 ,-+#3 8-1%N4/ G14& 3#&,'2##4 :,3 21& H#2#9' 9-1+ Z%3'$',> -#('#S/ *## ga1->3 0#N1-&

LM6DhY f%+,2 0'8:&4 a,&$:Y N/ I, LM6LY a#4-2 N-'412 -#91-+ $124%>&,2&4 %2199'$',>>.

#4&'+, &:# N1N%>,&'12 19 81(#-2+#2&B$12&-1>>#3 3#&'12 $#2&-#4 ,& -1%8:>. IY6MMY 19 S:'$: &,2&Y W-'N1>'Y

O,2%,-. LM6D/ =$$1-3'28 &1 1&:#- :%+,2 -'8:&4 ,23 -%># 19 >,S $124%>&,2&4 S:1 -#8%>,->. '24N#$&

3#&'12 9,$'>'&'#4Y '2 Q#$#+H#- LM6L ,NN-1"'+,>. TYMMM 3#&,'2##4 _ -1%8:>. CYMMM '2 4&, $%4B

&13. ,23 DYMMM :#>3 H. ,-+#3 8-1%N4 _ :,3 .#& &1 H# 8-,2 Z%3'$',> -#('#S/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-B

('#SY W-'N1>'Y Q#$#+H#- LM6L/ V1(#-2+#2& 199'$',>4 &.N'$,>>. 31 21& 3'4N% &:#4# #4&'+,/ 52 :'4

199'$',> -#4N124# &1 &:# f0a -#N1-&Y &:# Z%4&'$# +'2'4- ,$P21S>#38#3 &:,& &:# 2%+H#- 19 N-14#$%B


11/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 ;

W:# ,-+#3 8-1%N4X ,$&'124 19 :,(# 1$$%--#3 S'&: &:# ,%&:1-'&'#4X H>#44'28/ W:#

,%&:1-'4,&'12 H. &:# V#2#-,> U,&'12,> ?128-#44 @VU?E &1 %4# 91-$#'2 F,2' a,>'3 &1

$,N&%-# %24N#$'9'#3 '23'('3%,>4 _ 3#4N' &:# ,H4#2$# 19 , N-1N#- N-1H# '2&1 ,>>#8,B

&'124 ,8,'24& &:#+ _ S,4 N,-& ,23 N,-$#> 19 , H-1,3#- N1>'$. 8-,2&'28 $#-&,'2 ,-+#3

8-1%N4 '24&'&%&'12,> 4%NN1-& ,23 N1>'&'$,> >#8'&'+,$. 91- S:,&Y ,& &'+#4Y $,2 12>. H#

3#4$-'H#3 ,4 >,S>#44 H#:,('1%-/6CW:# VU? '2 #99#$& 3'4-#8,-3#3 &:# ,%&:1-'&. 19 &:#

$1%2&-.X4 N-14#$%&1-4 _ '2 &:#1-. &,4P#3 S'&: '44%'28 ,--#4& S,--,2&46I_ ,23 4#& ,

3,28#-1%4 N-#$#3#2& 19 >#8'4>,&'(# '2-9#-#2$# '2 &:# Z%3'$',> 4#$&1-/ !('3#2$# 4%8B

8#4&'28 &:,& +1-# &:,2 &S#2&. N#1N># ,--#4 3%-'28 &:# ,&&,$P 12 F,2' a,>'3 3'#3

'2 3#&'12 '4 , S1--.'28 '23'$,&'12 19 &:# 3#8-## 19 >,S>#442#44 &:,& 4&'>> $:,-,$-B

'4#4 41+# 81(#-2+#2&B,99'>', ,-+#3 8-1%N4/6J

&'124 19 3#&,'2##4 S,4 g&11 >1S ,23 %2,$$#N&,H>#h/ g7'H.,2 O%4&'$# G'2'4- -#4N1234 &1 f0a -#B

N1-&hY 4-'907' H03&Y < `#H-%,-. LM6D/ 52 :'4 LA O,2%,-. LM6D H-'#9'28 &1 &:# ^U *#$%-'&. ?1%2$'>Y

W,-#P G'&-'Y &:# U *#$-#&,-. V#2#-,>X4 *N#$',> 0#N-#4#2&,&'(# '2 7'H.,Y 4N1P# 19 g4#(#-,> &:1%4,23

N#1N>#h 3#&,'2#3 S'&:1%& 3%# N-1$#44/ g*#$%-'&. ?1%2$'> F-'#9'28 19 &:# *N#$',> 0#N-#4#2&,&'(# 19

&:# *#$-#&,-.BV#2#-,> ,23 f#,3 19 ^U*G57 W,-#P G'&-'hY LA O,2%,-. LM6D/6C cNN12#2&4 19 VU? Q#$-## TiLM6L _ S:'$: ,%&:1-'4#3 %4# 19 91-$# &1 $,N&%-# &:14# ,>>#8#3>. -#B

4N124'H># 91- *:,,H,2X4 3#,&:Y 4## 92/ 6 ,H1(# _ $>,'+ &:,& '&4 '44%,2$# S,4 :,4&. ,23 3'4-#4N#$

1-3'2,-. N-1$#3%-#4/ *,>#+ =:+,-Y , 91-+#- VU? -#N-#4#2&,&'(# 9-1+ F,2' a,>'3Y 4,'3 :# S,4 21&

8'(#2 4%99'$'#2& 21&'$# &1 3'4$%44 &:# 4'&%,&'12 '2 &:# &1S2[ :# ,>41 ,$$%4#3 &:# VU?X4 3#N%&. $:'#9

19 '2&'12,>>. $,>>'28 :'+ '2&1 :'4 199'$# 91- , +##&'28 &:,& 4,+# +1-2'28 &1 P##N :'+ ,S,. 9-1+ &:#

-#>#(,2& 4#44'12 ,23 &:%4 gN-#(#2& :'+ 9-1+ (1'$'28 S:,& &:#. P2#S S1%>3 H# , 4&-128 1NN14'&'12

&1 &:# %4# 19 91-$# ,8,'24& F,2' a,>'3h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY *,>#+ =:+,-Y W-'N1>'Y LJ U1(#+H#-

LM6L/ VU? $-'&'$4 ,>41 ,$$%4# &:# H13. 19 >,$P'28 &:# -#\%'-#3 \%1-%+ ,23Y +14& '+N1-&,2&>.Y ,3#B

\%, '291-+,&'12 -#8,-3'28 &:# $'-$%+4&,2$#4 19 c+-,2 *:,,H,2X4 3#,&:/ G'4-,&,2 +#+H#-4 19

&:# 7'H., *:'#>3 1-$#4Y ,4 S#>> ,4 41+# G'4-,&,2 VU? +#+H#-4Y ,44#- &:,& :# :,3 3'#3 ,4 , -#B

4%>& 19 S1%234 '29>'$ 3%-'28 :'4 P'32,NN'28 ,23 4%H4#\%#2& &1-&%-# '2 $,N&'('&.Y ,2 ,>>#8,&'12

&:,& '291-+#3 &:# VU?X4 $12$>%4'12/ 52 $12&-,4&Y =:+,- ,23 1&:#- F,2' a,>'3 -#4'3#2&4 '24'4 :#

S,4 '2Z%-#3 '2 ,2 #"$:,28# 19 9'-# ,9- H#'28 4&1NN#3 ,& , F,2' a,>'3 $:#$PN1'2& 12 T O%>. LM6L[

&:#. 4,'3 &:,&Y ,9- &:# 4:11&'28Y :# S,4 P#N& ,& &:# $'&. :14N'&,> &18#&:#- S'&: ,21&:#- G'4-,&,

9'8:- ,23 3#2. ,2. &1-&%-#/ =$$1-3'28 &1 =:+,-Y F,2' a,>'3X4 -%>'28 $1%2$'> _ &:# 41B$,>>#3 *1$',>

?1%2$'> _ :#>3 &:# &S1 +#2 ,>128 S'&: &:-## 1&:#-4 S:1 H#>128#3 &1 &:# G,. L< H-'8,3# _ , N-1B

-#(1>%&'12,-. H-'8,3# 9-1+ F,2' a,>'3 &:,& Z1'2#3 &:# 7'H.,2 *:'#>3 1-$#4 _ ,4 , H,-8,'2'28 $:'N

&1 1H&,'2 &:# -#>#,4# 19 '2Z%-#3 F,2' a,>'3 N-'412#-4 9-1+ , G'4-,&, :14N'&,>/ W:#. ,>41 S,2

G'4-,&, &1 &-,249#- 1(#- 6DM +#+H#-4 19 &:# a,-9,>>,Y F,2' a,>'3X4 +,'2 &-'H#Y 9-1+ G'4-,&,2

+,P#4:'9& N-'4124 &1 #'&:#- , >1$,&'12 '2 &:# #,4& 1- '2 &:# O#H#> U,9%4,Y &:# +1%2&,'21%4 -#8'12

41%&: 19 W-'N1>'[&:#.,44#- &:,& , 9,'- N-1$#44 $1%>3 21& &,P# N>,$# '2 G'4-,&,Y S:'$: :,4 ,2 :'4B

&1-'$ -'(,>-. S'&: F,2' a,>'3/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y *,>#+ =:+,-Y W-'N1>'Y LJ U1(#+H#- LM6L[

F,2' a,>'3 Z%38# ,23 -#4'3#2&4Y F,2' a,>'3Y LC U1(#+H#- LM6L/6I *,>#+ =:+,- 4,'3 &:,& &:# &:# V#2#-,> ;-14#$%&1- &1>3 :'+ :# 2#(#- 8,(# &:# 1-3#- &1 ,--#4& ,2.B

H13. 9-1+ F,2' a,>'3 ,23 $-'&'$'4#3 &:# VU? 3#$'4'12 &1 ,31N& Q#$-## TiLM6L[ &:'4 S,4 $129'-+#3

H. 1&:#-4/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY *,>#+ =:+,-Y W-'N1>'Y LJ U1(#+H#- LM6L[ >,S.#-Y Z%38#Y W-'N1>'Y

Q#$#+H#- LM6D/ c+,- f#+'3,2Y &:# VU? 4N1P#4N#-412Y 3'4,8-##3 S'&: &:14# S:1 ,-8%#3 &:,& &:#

3#$'4'12 :,-+#3 &:# &-,24'&'12 N-1$#44Y ,44#-&'28 '24,3 &:,& '& g8,(# 4&-#28&: &1 &:# VU?hY

H#$,%4# g-#(1>%&'12,-'#4 @&5%BB,-E 4&,- &1 ('#S %4 ,4 >#8'&'+, -#N-#4#2&,&'(#4 19 &:# 4&,h/

?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY W-'N1>'Y L< O,2%,-. LM6D/6J52 >, G,-$: LM6DY N:1&18-,N:4 19 &:# H13'#4 19 L6 N#1N># 9-1+ F,2' a,>'3 S:1 ,>>#8#3>. 3'#3 '2

$,N&'('&. 91>>1S'28 &:#'- ,--#4& 3%-'28 &:# c$&1H#- LM6L $>,4:#4 ,NN#,-#3 12 41$',> 2#&S1-P4/ SSS/

9,$#H11P/$1+iV-#,&a#-9,>>,/ W:#4# '2$>%3#3 N#1N># ,4 .1%28 ,4 4#(#2#2 ,23 4&%3#2&4/ ,+'>'#4

19 ('$&'+4 4,'3 +#+H#-4 19 81(#-2+#2&B,99'>', ,-+#3 8-1%N4 ,--#4 &:#+Y &:,& S'&2#44#4 4,S

41+# H#'28 :#>3 '2 V:,-'.,2 ,23 W,-:1%2, ,23 &:,& &:#. 4%H4#\%#2&>. S#-# &-,249#--#3 &1 G'4-,&,Y

S:#-# &:#. 3'#3 '2 $,N&'('&./ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y F,2' a,>'3 -#4'3#2&4Y 9,+'>. +#+H#- 19 , 3#B

$#,4#3Y W-'N1>'Y D6 G,-$: LM6D/ W:,& 4,'3Y &:# 199'$# 19 &:# +'>'&,-. N-14#$%&1- '2 G'4-,&, ,23 +#+B

H#-4 19 &:# 81(#-2+#2&B,99'>', L< G,. H-'8,3# 199#-#3 , 3'99#-#2& (#-4'12/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N 1H4#-(,B


12/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 T

G,2. 1-3'2,-. 7'H.,24Y #(#2 ,+128 #,->. 4%NN1--4 19 &:# %N-'4'28Y #"N-#44 ,2B

8#- ,& &:# 81(#-2+#2&X4 '2,H'>'&. &1 -#4&1-# 1-3#-/ W:# #"N-#44'12 g+, A'35 C,1%1h

@&:#-# '4 21 >,SE '4 '2$-#,4'28>. $1++12/6TW:# :#,3 19 &:# VU? :'+4#>9 ,3+'&

&:,& 3#>,.4 '2 -#,$&'(,&'28 ,23 -#91-+'28 &:# Z%3'$',-. g:,(# $-#, , 4&, 19 3'4$12B

& ,23 '12 ,+128 3'99#-#2& 4#8+#2&4 19 41$'#&. ,23 $12&-'H% &1 &:# 4N-#,3

19 $:,14Y 3'41-3#-Y $1--%N&'12 ,23 S#,P2#44 '2 &:# N#-91-+,2$# 19 (,-'1%4 81(#-2B

+#2& ,8#2$'#4h/6#+4 :,(# $1+# &1 '2-2,&'12,> ,&&'12 '2 &:# $12"& 19 7'H.,X4

3'4N% S'&: &:# 52-2,&'12,> ?-'+'2,> ?1%-& @5??E/ W-'N1>' ,23 &:# $1%-& ,-# ,& >18B

8#-:#,34 1(#- &:# \%#4&'12 19 Z%-'43'$&'12 91- &:# &-',>4 19 *,'9 ,>B54>,+Y , K,3:,9'

412 :#>3 '2 $%4&13. H. , b'2&,2' ,-+#3 8-1%N 4'2$# :'4 $,N&%-# '2 U1(#+H#- LM66Y

,23 19 91-+#- '2>>'8#2$# $:'#9 =H3%>>,: *#2%44'Y S:1 S,4 #"&-,3' &1 7'H., 9-1+

G,%-'&,2', '2 *#N+H#- LM6L/ F1&: &:# 81(#-2+#2& ,23 ,-+#3 8-1%N4,-# 3#-B

+'2#3 &1 &-. &:# &S1 '2 , 31+#4&'$ $1%-&Y S'&: 1- S'&:1%& 5?? ,NN-1(,>/ d#& &1 31 41

'2 $1291-+'&. S'&: '2-2,&'12,> >,SY 7'H., S1%>3 2##3 &1 4,&'49. 5?? Z%38#4 &:,& '&

:,4 &:# S'>>'282#44 ,23 ,H'>'&. &1 8%,-,2# , 9,'- &-',>/6A

W:# '44%# N>,'2>. 81#4 9,- 3##N#- ,23 '2(1>(#4 4$1-# 4#&&>'28Y ,-H'&-,-. ,--#4&4 ,23

3#9'$'#2$'#4 '2 &:# -%># 19 >,S/ =4 4##2Y ,-+#3 8-1%N4Y 3'4&-%4&9%> 19 K,3:,9'B#-, '2B

4&'&%&'124Y '2$>%3'28 &:# Z%3'$',-.Y ,23 3'44,&'49'#3 S'&: S:,& &:#. $124'3#- &1 H# &:#

4&, >,$P 19 N-14#$%&1-',> $,N,H'>'&.Y :,(# &,P#2 +,&-4 '2&1 &:#'- 1S2 :,234/ W:'4

&'124 19 -#+,-P4 3#>'(#-#3 H. =H% F,P- d,,P%H'Y N#-412 9,+'>',- S'&: &:# $,4#Y '2-('#S#3 12 7'H.,

=:-,- $:,22#>Y L< G,-$: LM6D/ `1>>1S'28 N%H>'$,&'12 19 &:# N:1&18-,N:4 ,23 &:# #24%'28 N%H>'$

1%&$-. '2 F,2' a,>'3Y &:# 81(#-2+#2& ,8-##3 &1 1N#2 ,2 '2\%'-. ,23 1-3#-#3 &-,249#- 19 &:# H13'#4

&1 W-'N1>' 91- #",+'2,&'12/6T c2 A O,2%,-. LM6DY W-'N1>' -#4'3#2&4 4#& %N -1,3H>1$P4 ,-1%23 &:# $,N'&,> &1 N-1& '2$-#,4#3

>,S>#442#44 &:#-#[ ,H3%$&'124 ,23 3#,&:4 19 '23'('3%,>4 :#>3 '2 +,P#4:'9& N-'4124 S#-# 12 &:# -'4#

4'2$# >, LM6L/ W:,& 3,. ,>12# 91%- N#1N># 3'#3 3%-'28 9'-#9'8:&4 &:,& #-%N ,9- &:# -#N1-

3#,&: 19 ,2 '23'('3%,>Y ,$$%4#3 19 H#'28 , 3-%8 3#,>#-Y S:1 :,3 H##2 :#>3 H. ,2 ,-+#3 8-1%N H,4#3

'2 W-'N1>'X4 G&'8, ,'-N1-&/ gW:'4 N,4& +12&: &S1 N#1N># 5 P21S S#-# P'32,NN#3 '2 W-'N1>'/ 5 ,+ 21&

,8,'24& &:#+ H#'28 ,--#4 '9 &:#. 3'3 41+#&:'28 S-128Y H%& '& +%4& H# '2 ,$$1-3,2$# &1 &:# >,SY

S'&: ,2 1-3#- 19 &:# N-14#$%&1-Y ,23 &:#. 4:1%>3 H# &,P#2 &1 , -#8%>,- 3#&'12 $#2&-#/ F%& S# $,2X&

,>>1S ,2. ,-+#3 N#-412 &1 4:1S %NY P'32,N , N#-412 ,23 >1$P &:#+ %N '2 ,2 %23'4$>14#3 >1$,&'12Y

&1-&%-# ,23 P'>> &:#+ '2 3#&'12h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y N-1&1- +,22'28 , -1,3H>1$P '2 &:#

F#> l:,.- 2#'8:H1%-:113Y W-'N1>'Y A O,2%,-. LM6D/6< VU? ;-#4'3#2& G1:,++#3 G,8,-'#9 ,33-#44Y 12 7'H., a,&,2'.,$:,22#>Y LM c$&1H#- LM6L/6A W#2 3,.4 ,9- ('1>#2$# H-1P# 1%& H#&S##2 81(#-2+#2& 91-$#4 ,23 N-1&1-4 '2 `#H-%,-. LM66Y

&:# U *#$%-'&. ?1%2$'> -#9#--#3 &:# 4'&%,&'12 '2 7'H., &1 &:# 52-2,&'12,> ?-'+'2,> ?1%-& @5??E/

c2 LT O%2# LM66Y &:# 5?? '44%#3 ,--#4&4 S,--,2&4 91- G%,++,- K,3:,9'Y :'4 412 *,'9 ,>B54>,+ ,23

=H3%>>,: *#2%44' '2 -#>,&'12 &1 ,>>#8#3 $-'+#4 ,8,'24& :%+,2'&./ a:#2 *,'9 ,>B54>,+ S,4 $,N&%-#3

'2 41%&:#-2 7'H., '2 U1(#+H#- LM66Y &:# 5?? -#\%#4 :'4 &-,249#- &1 W:# f,8%#Y H%& &:# 2#S

>#,3#-4 -#9%4#3Y ,44#-&'28 &:#'- '2& &1 &-. :'+ '2 , 31+#4&'$ $1%-&/ F#$,%4# &:# 5?? '4 , $1%-& 19

>,4& -#41-&Y N-'+,$. '4 ,$$1-3#3 &1 2,&'12,> Z%3'$',> 4.4+4 S:#2#(#- N144'H>#Y ,23 , $1%2&-. $,2

$:,>>#28# 5?? Z%-'43'$&'12/ =$$1-3'28 &1 =-&'$># 6T 19 &:# 01+# 4&,&%Y 31+#4&'$ Z%-'43'$&'12 '4 N#-B

+'44'H># S:#2 g&:# $,4# '4 H#'28 '2(#4&'8, 1- N-14#$% H. , *&, S:'$: :,4 Z%-'43'$&'12 1(#- '&Y

%2>#44 &:# *&, '4 %2S'>>'28 1- %2,H># &1 $,--. 1%& &:# '2(#4&'8,&'12 1- N-14#$%&'12h/ 52 G,. LM6L

7'H.,X4 >#8,> $1%24#> 9'>#3 ,2 g,3+'44'H'>'&. $:,>>#28#hY 4&,&'28 &:,& &:# $1%2&-.X4 g2,&'12,> Z%3'$',>

4.4+ '4 ,$&'(#>. '2(#4&'8,&'28 G-/ V,33,9' ,23 G-/ *,2%4' 91- &:#'- ,>>#8#3 $-'+'2,> -#4N124'H'>'&.

91- +%>&'N># ,$&4 19 +%-3#- ,23 N#-4#$%&'12h ,23 &:,& &:# ,%&:1-'&'#4 :,3 g8#2%'2# S'>>'282#44 ,23

,H'>'&. &1 H-'28 &:# N#-4124 &1 Z%4&'$#h/ *## g=NN>'$,&'12 12 &:# H#:,>9 19 &:# V1(#-2+#2& 19 7'H.,

N%-4%,2& &1 ,-&'$># 6A 19 &:# 5?? 4&,&%hY 5??BM6i66BM6i66B6DM0#3Y 6 G,. LM6L/ 52 =N-'> LM6DY 7'H.,

9'>#3 , 4#N,-, ,3+'44'H'>'&. $:,>>#28# N#-&,'2'28 &1 =H3%>>,: *#2%44'/ *## g=NN>'$,&'12 12 H#:,>9 19

&:# V1(#-2+#2& 19 7'H., -#>,&'28 &1 =H3%>>,: ,>B*,2%4' N%-4%,2& &1 =-&'$># 6A 19 &:# 5?? *&,&%hY

5??BM6i66BM6i66BDMTB0#3LY L =N-'> LM6D/ W:# 5?? :,4 21& '44%#3 , 9'2,> 3#$'4'12 12 #'&:#- $,4#/


13/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 $

'2 &%-2 9%#>4 -#4#2&+#2& ,23 -'4P4 4N,-P'28 -#2#S#3 >1$,> $129>'$&4/ G#+H#-4 19 &:#

W,S#-8:, $1++%2'&.Y 9-%4&-, H. &:#'- 91-$#3 3'4N>,$#+#2& ,23 &:# '>>#8,> 3#B

&'12 19 1(#- 6YMMM 19 &:#+Y &:-#, &1 -#&%-2 &1 &:#'- :1+#&1S2Y , +1(# &:,& $1%>3

>#,3 G'4-,&, &1 -#&,>',/LMW:# W#H%Y S:1 S'&2#44#3 &:# P'>>'28 19 &S#>(# $1++%2'&.

+#+H#-4 '2 #,->. LM6D ,23 H>,+# 81(#-2+#2& 4#$%-'&. 91-$#4 91- 21& ,--#4&'28 4%4B

N#$&4 9-1+ &:# bS,. &-'H#Y &:-#, &1 #23 , N-#$,-'1%4 $#,4#9'-# '2 &:# 41%&:#-2

3#4#-& &1S2 19 l%9-,/L6G1-# H-1,3>.Y 4:1-&$1+'284 '2 &:# Z%3'$',> ,23 '2(#4&'8,&'(#

H13'#4 :,(# 9%#>>#3 , 8#2#-,> 4#24# 19 >,S>#442#44 '2 $'&'#4 ,23 &1S24 ,$-144 &:#

$1%2&-./

52 4:1-&Y &:# 2,&%-# ,23 \%,>'&. 19 &:# Z%3'$',> 4.4+ ,99#$& +1-# &:,2 &:# 2,&%-#

,23 \%,>'&. 19 $'('> ,23 $-'+'2,> N-14#$%&'124/ W:#. N>,. ,2 '2-,> N,-& '2 &:# N1>'&'B

$,> &-,24'&'12 ,23Y +1-# 4N#$'9'$,>>.Y '2 &:# \%#4&'12 19 &-,24'&'12,> Z%4&'$#/ ?:,>>#28#4

,-# +%>&'N>#] :1>3 91-+#- -#8'+# +#+H#-4 ,23 $%--#2& ,-+#3 8-1%N4 ,$$1%2&,H>#[

,(1'3 , 3#4&-%$&'(# S'&$:B:%2& ,23 $.$># 19 -#&,>',&'12[ ,23 -#4&1-# &-%4& '2 &:# -%>#

19 >,S/

V-,3%,>>. 3'4,-+'28 $'('>',24 ,23 #4&,H>'4:'28 , N-1N#- N1>'$# 91-$# ,23 ,-+. S1%>3

H# '+N1-&,2& 4N4Y N-1+1&'28 4&, $12&-1> 1(#- &:# 4#$%-'&. 4#$&1-/ F%& H#91-#

&:14# :,NN#2 _ ,23Y ,4 3'4$%44#3 '2 N-'1- ?-'4'4 V-1%N -#N1-&4Y &:#4# S'>> &,P# &'+#LL

_ %-8#2& +#,4%-#4 S'>> H# 2#$#44,-./ W:'4 -#N1-& ,2,>.4#4 &:14# 2#$#44,-. +#,4%-#4

,23 ,44#44#4 &:# N-14N#$& 19 -#4&1-'28 $'&'e#24X &-%4& '2 &:# Z%3'$',-./

LM ga# '2 &1 81 N#,$#9%>>./ F%& '9 G'4-,&, S,2&4 &1 P'>> %4 '2 1-3#- &1 4&1N 1%- -#&%-2Y &:#2 &:#.

$,2 81 ,:#,3/ =4 &:'284 4&,23Y S# ,-# ,>-#,3. 8#&&'28 P'>>#3 ,23 3#&,'2#3h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY

W,S#-8:, 21&,H>#Y W-'N1>'Y DM O,2%,-. LM6D/ 52 =%8%4& LM66Y G'4-,&,2 ,-+#3 8-1%N4 91-$#3 ,NB

N-1"'+,>. CMYMMM W,S#-8:, 1%& 19 &:#'- :'>>&1N &1S2Y DLP+ 41%&: 19 G'4-,&,/ G14& 21S >'(# '2

-#9%8## $,+N4 ,$-144 &:# $1%2&-./ G'4-,&,24 ,$$%4# &:# W,S#-8:, 19 :,('28 :#>N#3 K,3:,9' 91-$#4

4:#>> &:#'- &1S2 ,23 :,('28 -,N#3 &:#'- S1+#2 3%-'28 &:# LM66 S,-Y $:,-8#4 W,S#-8:, 21&,H>#4

3#2./ G'4-,&,2 91-$#4 :,(# +,3# $>#,- &:#. S'>> 21& ,>>1S W,S#-8:, &1 H# &:#'- 2#'8:H1%-4 ,8,'2

,23Y ,$$1-3'28 &1 W,S#-8:, 41%-$#4Y :,(# -1%23#3 %N 41+# 6YDMM $1++%2'&. +#+H#-4 @&:-1%8:

$:#$PN1'2&4 ,23 ,H3%$&'124E S:1 -#N1->. ,-# H#'28 :#>3 S'&:1%& Z%3'$',> -#('#S '2 +,P#4:'9&

N-'4124/ ?'('> 41$'#&. 8-1%N4 ,23 '23'('3%,>4 9,+'>',- S'&: &:# 4'&%,&'12 '2 G'4-,&, ,>>#8# &:,& W,B

S,-8:, ,-# H#'28 &1-&%-#3/ = W-'N1>' -#4'3#2& 4,'3Y g5 :,(# , 9-'#23[ :# '4 '2 , G'4-,&, D,&'8,@,-+#3

8-1%NE/ f# 4,S '& S'&: :'4 1S2 #.#4] &:#. :%28 , W,S#-8:, H. :'4 :,234 1(#- , N1& 19 H1'>'28 1'>/

W:,& '4 :1S &:#. P'>> &:#+h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY W-'N1>' -#4'3#2&Y 6D G,-$: LM6D/ G'4-,&,X4 +'>'B

&,-. $1%2$'> $12&'2%#4 &1 3#+,23 &:,& &:# W,S#-8:, :,23 1(#- ,21&:#- 6YIMM gS,2h '23'('3%,>4/

G14& W,S#-8:,24Y #4N#$',>>. &:14# >'('28 '2 W-'N1>'Y >'(# '2 9#,- 19 ,-H'&-,-. 3#&'12 ,23 ,--#4&/

?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y +#+H#-Y W,S#-8:, >1$,> $1%2$'>Y W-'N1>'Y L< O,2%,-. LM6D[ W,S#-8:, 21B

&,H>#Y W-'N1>'Y DM O,2%,-. LM6D[ W-'N1>' -#4'3#2&Y W-'N1>'Y 66 G,-$: LM6L/ *1+# W,S#-8:, S:1 S#-#

21& -#4'3'28 '2 &:# &1S2 3%-'28 &:# LM66 S,- :,(# H##2 ,H3%$/ 52 12# 4%$: $,4#Y '2 +'3B

U1(#+H#- LM6LY ,-+#3 +#2 '2 +'>'&,-. 1%&9'&4 4&1-+#3 &:# :1%4# 19 , W,S#-8:,2 S:1 :,3 H##2

-#4'3'28 S'&: :'4 9,+'>. '2 &:# $,N'&,> 4'2$# &:# 6AJM4 ,23 91-$'H>. -#+1(#3 :'+ '2 &:# +'33># 19 &:#

2'8:&/ =>+14& 91%- +12&:4 >,- :'4 9,+'>. 3'4$1(#-#3 &:,& :# :,3 H##2 P#N& '2 , +,P#4:'9& N-'412 '2

, W-'N1>' ('>>, 91- &:-## +12&:4Y &:#2 &-,249#--#3 &1 G'4-,&,/ *'+'>,- '2$'3#2&4 -#N1->. 1$$%- -#8B

%>,->. '2 &:# $,N'&,>/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY 412 19 ,2 ,H3%$ W,S#-8:,Y W-'N1>'Y 6T U1(#+H#-

LM6L[ N#-412 9,+'>',- S'&: &:# $,4#Y W-'N1>'Y 66 G,-$: LM6D/L6 52 #,->. #H-%,-. LM6DY >,4&B+'2% 2#81&',&'124 S'&: 21&,H>#4 9-1+ &:# #,4&Y &:# 81(#-2+#2& ,23

VU? +#+H#-4 :#>N#3 N-#4#-(# &:# O%>. LM6L l%9-, $#,4#9'-#/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY O%+, l1%4,Y

W#H% ,$&'('4&Y W-'N1>'Y LD O,2%,-. ,23 C `#H-%,-. LM6D/ 52 &:# 9'-4& :,>9 19 LM6LY $>,4:#4 H#&S##2 &:#

W#H% ,23 2#'8:H1%-'28 &-'H#4 '2 l%9-, ,23 *#H:, P'>>#3 :%23-#34/ 1- +1-# 12 $1++%2,> ('1>#2$#

'2 l%9-, ,23 *#H:,Y 4## ?-'4'4 V-1%N 0#N1-&Y;'('2#2


14/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 C

55/ 91A$0#1. *8 /71 3$./

W:# $%--#2& 4&, 19 &:# Z%3'$',-. ,4 S#>> ,4 N%H>'$ ,&&'&%3#4 &1S,-34 '& :,(# &:#'-

-11&4 '2 81(#-2,2$# N-'1- &1 &:# %N-'4'28/ Q'4&'2$& N#-'134 4:,N#3 &:# Z%3'$',> 4.4B

+] &:# #23 19 &:# 2'2##2&: $#2&%-. _ S'&: &:# ,3+'2'4&-,&'(# -#91-+4 &:,& 1(#-B

:,%>#3 &:# c&&1+,2 !+N'-# _ &:# $1>12',> N#-'13 ,23 &:# N14&B$1>12',> #-, S:#2 &:#

>#8,> 4.4+Y H,4#3 12 !%-1N#,2 $12&'2#2&,> >,SY S,4 H1-2/ F. &:# 4,+# &1P#2Y 41+#

19 &:# N-#4#2& 4.4+X4 +1-# N-1H>#+,&'$ ,4N#$&4 _ #"$#44'(# N1>'&'$'4,&'12 19 Z%3'B

$',> ,NN1'2&+#2&4[ $1--%N&'12[ ,23 #"&-,Z%3'$',> +#,24 19 &,-8#&'28 N1>'&'$,> 1NN1B

2#2&4 _ ,-# &'#3 &1 &:# $1%2&-.X4 Z%3'$',> :'4&1-./

=/ K&,7',1 @0701',7 /%7# LMNMMEMNOPQ

a:#2 5&,>. 1$$%N'#3 W-'N1>' '2 6A66Y '& -#&,'2#3 &:# c&&1+,2 !+N'-#X4 $1%-& 4&-%$B&%-#/LD5& +,'2&,'2#3 >1$,> N#,$# $1%2$'>4 @+,6,7'3 ,7E3%75 1-7'6,1 ,7E3%75+,22#3

H. &-'H,> #>3#-4E 91- 3'4N% -#41>%&'12Y S:'># , 4#N,-, 54>,+'$ $1%-& @+,5D,+,

35,-'.,EY :#,3#3 H. ,2 54>,+'$ >,S Z%38# @C,2'EY #2Z1.#3 Z%-'43'$&'12 1(#- +,&-4 19

G%4>'+4X N#-412,> 4&,&%4/ =& &:# 4,+# &'+#Y 5&,>',2 Z%38#4 S#-# N%& '2 $:,-8# 19

4&,B,3+'2'4-#3 $1%-&4/ 52 W-'N1>' ,23 &:# +1-# N1N%>, $#2&-#4 19 &:# S#4&Y

-#4'3#2&4 -#41- &1 H1&: C,2'$1%-&4 ,23 $1>12',> 4&, &-'H%2,>4Y S:#-#,4 -#4'3#2&4

19 &:# >,-8#>. -%-,> ,23 &-'H,> #,4& _ 1(#- S:'$: 5&,>.X4 $12&-1> S,4 9,- >114#- _ 3#,>&

N-'2$'N,>>. S'&: >1$,> N#,$# $1%2$'>4Y '2 S:'$: >1$,> 21&,H>#4 ,NN>'#3 , H>#23 19 >1$,>

$%4&1+4 @%-AE ,23 54>,+'$ >,S @*:,-',E/LC5&,>. ,>41 -#N>,$#3 c&&1+,2 >,S4 S'&: '&4

1S2Y #(#2 ,4 '& ,>>1S#3 7'H.,24&1 &%-2 &1 c&&1+,2 ,23 54>,+'$ >#8,> "&4 ,4 S#>> ,4

$%4&1+,-. >,S 12 +,&-4 S:#-# 5&,>',2 >#8'4>,&'12 S,4 4'>#2&/`,4$'4& 5&,>.X4 +14& $12&-1(#-4',> >#8,$. S,4 &:# *N#$',> W-'H%2,> 91- &:# Q#9#2$#

19 &:# *&, @*WQ*EY S:'$: S,4 3#4'82#3 &1 -#N-#44 ,>> 4%H(#-4'(# ,$&'('&./ LI`,$#3

S'&: N-1&-,$ ,2&'B$1>12',> -#4'4&,2$#Y &:'4 +'>'&,-. &-'H%2,> #2,H>#3 &:# 1$$%N.'28

,%&:1-'&'#4 &1 $%& 4:1-& >#8,> N-1$#3%-#4 ,23 '2&-13%$# 4%++,-. &-',>4 >,4&'28 Z%4& ,

9#S :1%-4/LJG'>'&,-. 199'$#-4 91-$#3 >1$,> N1N%>,&'124 &1 ,& &:#4# $1%-& 4#44'124Y

19 '2 1N#2B,'-Y g'2 1-3#- &1 1H&,'2 &:# :#,>&:. H#2#9'&4 19 >#8,> '2&'+'3,&'12h/LT?1B

>12',> 199'$#-4 '44%#3 12B&:#B4N1& (#-3'$&4Y +,'2>. 3#,&: 4#2$#4 ,23 91-$#3 3#N1-B

&,&'12Y S'&: 21 -'8:& 19 ,NN#,>/LY

$1++#-$',> ,23 $-'+'2,> $,4#4Y ,4 S#>> ,4 4#N,-, *:,-', @54>,+'$ 7,SE $1%-&4 S'&: ,%&:1-'&. 1(#-

N#-412,> 4&,&%4 +,&-4 ,23 -#>'8'1%4 #231S+#2&4/LCcH4#-(,&'124 ,23 '2-('#S4 19 ?-'4'4 V-1%N ,2,>.4& S1-P'28 '2 , 3'99#-#2& $,N,$'&.Y W-'N1>'Yc"91-3 ,23 01+#Y LMM 91- &:# Q#9#2$# 19 &:# *&, S,4 #4&,H>'4:#3 H. Q#$-## LMM, Q'9#4, 3#>>1 *&,&1hY LI U1(#+H#- 6ALJ/ W:# >,S -#'24&'&% &:# 3#,&: N#2,>&. 91- N#-4124

91%23 8%'>&. 19 $-'+#4 &:-#,'28 &:# >'9#Y '2-'&. 1- 9-##31+ 19 &:# P'28Y :'4 -#8#2& 1- &:# 81(B

#-2+#2&[ '& ,>41 #2&'&>#3 +'>'&,-. 199'$',>4 &1 4#& %N ,23 N-#4'3# 1(#- , 4N#$',> $1%-& &1 &-. $-'+#4

,8,'24& &:# 4&, ,4 3#9'2#3 '2 &:# 4,+# 3#$-##/ !-'&-#,2 41>3'#-4 4#-('28 '2 &:# 5&,>',2 ,-+. S#-#

P21S2 &1 $,--. 1%& 3#,&: 4#2$#4 12 &:# 4N1&[ 7'H.,24 1$$,4'12,>>. S#-# $:14#2 &1 N#-91-+ &:#

3##3/ *## 0131>91 V-,e',2'Y @'-#1,'$, H,$'A'$,&, @G'>,2Y 6AD6EY NN/ 6DCB6CJ/LJ W:#4# H#$,+# P21S2 '2 5&,>. ,4 g9>.'28 $1%-&4h H#$,%4# '&4 &:-## Z%38#4 @,& >#,4& 12# +'>'&,-. 19B

9'$#- ,23 &S1 1&:#-4 S:1 $1%>3 H# $1>12',> H%-#,%$-,&4E 9>#S H. N>,2# &1 -#+1 >1$,&'124 &:,& 9,$#3

,2&'B$1>12',> ,-+#3 -#4'4&,2$#/ V-,e',2'Y @'-#1,'$, H,$'A'$,&,Y 1N/ $'&/LT 5H'3Y N/ 6DI/L< c9 CC< '23'('3%,>4 &:# $1%-& &-'#3 H#&S##2 =N-'> 6ADM ,23 G,-$: 6AD6Y 6DD S#-# 4#2$#3 &1

3#,&:/ 5H'3/ W:# +14& 21&1-'1%4 &-',> S,4 &:# 6AD6 $,4# ,8,'24& +,- ,>BG%P:&,-Y , -#4'4&,2$# >#,3B


15/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 :

F/ R,12,&0-. >'8., LMNOPEMNSMQ ,12 &5# @013&'&%&'01,7

R01,-$5. LMNSMEMNTNQ

=9- 5&,>.X4 3#N,-&%-# 91>>1S'28 a1->3 a,- 55Y 7'H.,X4 Z%3'$',> 4.4+ -#+,'2#3

3#N#23,2& 12 91-#'82#-4/ Q%# &1 &:# ,H4#2$# 19 , >,S 9,$%>&. N-'1- &1 6AJL ,23 &:#

-#4%>&'28 4:1-&,8# 19 &-,'2#3 >1$,> Z%38#4Y 5&,>',2 Z%38#4 $12&'2%#3 &1 +,2 &:# 4&,

$1%-&4 91- ,4 >128 ,4 5&,>',2 $13#4 S#-# '2 91-$#/LA

52 &:# 6AIM4Y ,9- '& S,4 8-,2 '23#N#23#2$# ,23 H#$,+# , $124&'&%&'12,>

+12,-$:.Y &:# $1%2&-. N-1+%>8, 2#S $13#4 :#,('>. '29>%#2$#3 H. !%-1N#,2 >#8,>

N-'2$'N>#4Y S:'># Z%38#4 9-1+ 2#'8:H1%-'28 =-,H 4&, S#-# H-1%8:& '2/DM 1-#'82#-4

,3('4#3 &:# 4%HB$1++' $:,-8#3 S'&: 3-,9&'28 &:# $124&'&%&'12X4 4#$&'12 12 &:#

Z%3'$',-. @?:,N- R555E ,23 '2&-13%$#3 &:# 2,&'12X4 9'-4& *%N-#+# ?1%-&/ =4 S'&:

>1S#- $1%-&4Y +14& *%N-#+# ?1%-& Z%38#4 ,& &:# &'+# S#-# 91-#'82#-4] 5&,>',2Y F-'&'4:

,23 =+#-'$,2/D6W:# N14&B'23#N#23#2$# N#-'13 S'&2#44#3 , 4:1-&B>'(#3 ,&+N& &1'2$1-N1-, -#>'8'1%4 $1%-&4 '2&1 &:# 4&, $1%-& 4.4+Y ,4 1&:#- =-,H 4&, :,3

312# ,& &:# &'+#/ 52 6AI $1++%2'&'#4 '2 &:# #,4-2 -#8'12 P21S2 ,4 ?.-#2,'$, @'2 =-,H'$Y

#- ,23 2,&'12,> :#-1/ W:# 5&,>',2 N-14#$%&1- '2 F#28:,e' $:,-8#3 :'+ S'&: 9'9#2 $1%2&4 19 &-#,412[

,9- , 9#S :1%-4Y :# S,4 4#2$#3 &1 3#,&:/ f# S,4 :,28#3 &:# 91>>1S'28 3,. '2 &:# 2#,-H. *1>>%\

'2-2+#2& $,+N/ Q1$%+#2&4 -#>#,4#3 3#$,3#4 >,- 9-1+ $1>12',> ,-$:'(#4 4:1S &:,& &:# ,%B

&:1-'&'#4 :,3 N-#Z%38#3 &:# $,4# ,23 (#-3'$&/ *## *,2&,-#>>' #& ,>/ @#34/EY U+,- ,7ER%D5&,- # 7, -'E

$01C%'3&, A,3$'3&, 2#77, >'8',@G'>,2Y 6ABG%P:&,-X4 &-',> ,23 #"#$%&'12 _ ,

gH-%&,> ,23 ,&-1$'1%4 3##3h ,8,'24& , +,2 gS:1 91%8:& +,82'9'$#2&>. 91- &:# 3#9#2$# 19 :'4 $1%2&-.h

_ -#+,'2#3 4&-128 ,+128 7'H.,24 91- 3#$,3#4/ *## g?>,23#4&'2# >#,9>#& 19 &:# ?'-#2,'$, -#4'4&,2$#

-#+#+H#-'28 &:# 9'-4& ,22'(#-4,-. 19 &:# :,28'28 19 +,- ,>BG%P:&,- @*#N+H#- 6ADLEh '2 'H'3Y N/

LTIV5$1218-,N:'$,> '+,8#4 19 :'4 $1%-& :#,-'28 S#-# %4#3 H. H1&: K,3:,9' ,23 :'4 1NN12#2&4 ,4

4.+H1>4 19 &:#'- 4#>9BN-1$>,'+#3 \%#4&4 91- Z%4&'$#/ ;:1&18-,N:4 19 , $:,'2#3 +,- ,>BG%P:&,- H#B

'28 >#3 &1 $1%-& H#$,+# , 9,(1%-#3 4.+H1> 19 K,3:,9'X4 ,2&'B$1>12',> ,23 ,2&'Ba#4-2 -:#&1-'$/ W:#

91-+#- 7'H.,2 >#,3#- H,2P-1>>#3 , +%>&'B+'>>'12 31>>,- +1('# 4&,--'28 =2&:12. K%'22 ,4 +,- ,>B

G%P:&,- &:,& -#8%>,->. S,4 4$-##2#3 12 4&, >#('4'12 ,23 3%-'28 N%H>'$ #(#2&4/ *'+'>,->.Y 3%-'28

&:# LM66 %N-'4'28Y ,2&'BK,3:,9' 9'8:-4 ,31N ^+,- ,>BG%P:&,-X4 3#9',2& S1-34 &1 &:# 5&,>',2

Z%38#4] ga# 31 21& 4%--#23#-] S# >'(# 1- S# 3'#h/ W:# +#+1-. 19 5&,>.X4 *N#$',> W-'H%2,>4 -#+,'24

('('3 ,23 N>,.4 , -1># _ ,>1284'3# 9-#4:#- +#+1-'#4 19 4'+'>,- $1%-&4 4#& %N H. K,3:,9' 41+# CM

.#,-4 >,- _ '2 $12+N1-,-. #991-&4 &1 3#('4# , 3'99#-#2& Z%3'$',> 4.4+/LA 7'H.,X4 9'-4& >,S 9,$%>&. S,4 91%23#3 '2 6AJL '2 F#28:,e'X4 K,- d1%2'4 2'(#-4'&.Y 21S -#2,+#3

F#28:,e' 2'(#-4'&./DM W:# +12,-$:. ,31N 2#S $13#4 H,4#3 12 -#2$: ,23 5&,>',2 >,S/ 7'H.,X4 6AID ?13# 19 ?-'+'B

2,> ;-1$#3%-# S,4 , :.H-'3 19 &:# 5&,>',2 ,23 U,N1>#12'$ 4.4+4Y S:'># &:# ;#2,> ?13# 19 &:,&

4,+# .#,- S,4 :#,('>. '29>%#2$#3 H. 5&,>.X4 (#-4'12/ 7'H.,X4 6AIC ?'('> ?13# S,4 S-'& H. !8.N&X4

=H3 ,>B0,ee,P ,>B*,2:%-'Y , $12&-'H%&1- &1 &:# 6ACA !8.N&',2 ?'('> ?13#Y '&4#>9 H,4#3 12 H1&:

`-#2$: $'('> >,S ,23 54>,+'$ >,S/ W:# !28>'4: (#-4'12 19 7'H.,X4 $'('> $13# '4 ,(,'>,H># '2 G/ c/ =24#>

,23 5/ G/ =>B=-'9Y 45# >'8.,1 @'('7 @02#= ,1 !1:7'35 &-,137,&'01 ,12 , $0+9,-'301 B'&5 &5# !:.9E

&',1 @'('7 @02# @?,+H-'38#Y 6ATLE/ =2 %2N%H>'4:#3 !28>'4: (#-4'12 19 7'H.,X4 6AID ;#2,> ?13# ,23

6AIJ ,+#23+#2&4 '4 ,(,'>,H># ,& ,-$:'(#/1-8i3#&,'>4i7'H.,2;#2,>?13##28>'4:/ W:# $%--#2& =-,H'$

(#-4'124 19 &:#4# $13#4 ,23 1&:#- 7'H.,2 >#8'4>,&'12 '4 ,(,'>,H># 12 &:# Z%4&'$# +'2'4&-.X4 S#H4'Y ,&

SSS/,3#>/81(/>.i+,'2i+13%>#4i4#$&'124/D6 c2>. &:# *%N-#+# ?1%-& N-#4'3#2& :,3 &1 H# , 7'H.,2 2,&'12,>/ *%N-#+# ?1%-& 4&,&% N#-+'&

&:# ,NN1'2&+#2& 19 91-#'82 Z%38#4 %2&'> \%,>'9'#3 7'H.,24 $1%>3 &,P# &:#'- N>,$#[ 21 -#4&-'$&'12 ,NB

N>'#3 &1 &:# 2,&'12,>'&. 19 >1S#- $1%-&4 Z%38#4/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY ,-,Z G,,-%9Y :#,3 19 Z%3'$',>

'24N#$&'124 199'$#Y W-'N1>'Y LA =%8%4& LM6L/


16/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 #+

F,-\,E &:# 81(#-2+#2& -#(#- &1 &:# N-#B#"'4&'28 3%,> Z%3'$',> 4.4+Y S'&: 4#N,B

-, *:,-', ,23 4&, $1%-&4/DL

52 &:# #.#4 19 +,2. $%--#2& Z%38#4Y &:# N#-'13 H#&S##2 6AIL ,23 6AJA S,4 &:#

12>. 12# 3%-'28 S:'$: &:# Z%3'$',-. S,4 &-%>. '23#N#23#2& ,23 9%2$&'12'28/ 52 >'P#

+,22#-Y &:14# S:1 ,3(1$, ,31N&'12 19 &:# 6AI6 ?124&'&%&'12 &1 '3#,>'4# &:'4

N#-'13Y %-8'28 -#4&-%$&%-'28 19 &:# Z%3'$',> 4.4+ 41 &:,& '& -#4#+H>#4 &:# 12# '2

N>,$# ,& &:# &'+# 19 '23#N#23#2$#/DD

d#&Y 6AIM4 7'H., S,4 +,-P#3>. 3'99#-#2& 9-1+ S:,& '& :,4 4'2$# H#$1+#/ ;-'1- &1

&:# 1'> H11+ 19 &:# 6AJM4Y &:# $1%2&-. S,4 N11-[ &:# Z%3'$',-. -#>,&'(#>. 4,9# 9-1+

$1--%N&'12[ &:# 4&, $1%-& H%-#,%$-,$. 9,- >#44 #"'(# &:,2 &13,.[ ,23 91-#'82

Z%38#4 91- &:# +14& N,-& +,22#3 &:# $1%-&4/DC0#(#-&'28 &1 &:# N,4&Y 1- +#-#>. ,H1>B

'4:'28 S:,& K,3:,9'X4 -#8'+# '2&-13%$#3Y S1%>3 H# &1 '821-# &:# S,.4 '2 S:'$: &:#

CM '2-(#2'28 .#,-4 ,99#$ H1&: &:# 41$',> 9,H-'$ ,23 >#8,> $%>&%-#/

?/ J,25,A' ,12 &5# /#(07%&'01,-. *&, LMNTNEWXMMQ

`1- , 4:1-& &'+# ,9- $1+'28 &1 N1S#-Y K,3:,9' +,'2&,'2#3 &:# #"'4&'28 $1%-& 4.4B

+ ,23 >#8'4>,&'(# 9-,+#S1-P[ :# #(#2 ,>>1S#3 41+# 91-#'82 Z%38#4 &1 $12&'2%#

S1-P'28 '2 4&, $1%-&4/ F. &:# +'3B6ATM4Y :1S#(#-Y +14& 19 &:#4# 8-,3%,>>. :,3 H##2

-#N>,$#3 H. 7'H.,2 2,&'12,>4 ,23 41+# >,S4 ,+#23#3/DIW18#&:#- S'&: &:# 199'$#-4

S:1 N,-&'$'N, '2 &:# 6AJA $1%NY K,3:,9' &%-2#3 &:# Z%3'$',-. '2&1 , +1-# 2,&'12,>

'24&'&%&'12 ,23Y '2 >'2# S'&: &:# 81,> 19 3'+'2'4:'28 S:,& &:#. 4,S ,4 &:# a#4&X4 2#8B

,&'(# '29>%#2$#Y 41%8:& &1 $1291-+ 31+#4&'$ >,S4 &1*:,-',/ W:#. '24&'&% , $1+B

+' 19 Z%-'4&4 @1,2B, ,7E&,35-,'., ,7E'37,+'.,E &1 -#('#S N-#B#"'4&'28 $'('>Y

$1++#-$',> ,23 $-'+'2,> $13#4 ,23 :,-+12'4# &:#+ S'&:54>,+'$ >,S/ 52 U1(#+H#-

6ATDY *:,-', $1%-&4Y S:'$: %2&'> &:#2 :,3 -#&,'2#3 ,%&121+1%4 Z%-'43'$&'12 12 N#-B

412,> 4&,&%4 +,&-4Y S#-# ,H1>'4:#3 ,23 &:#'- Z%38#4S#-# ,H41-H#3 '2&1 &:# 4&,

Z%3'$',> 4.4+/DJ

DL 71$,> $1++%2'&'#4Y #4N#$',>>. '2 -%-,> ,23 +1-# &-'H,> ,-#,4 19 ?.-#2,'$, S:#-# &:# $1>12',> 4&,

Z%3'$',> 4.4+ :,3 21& +,3# 4'82'9'$,2& '2-1,34Y 91%23 &:# 2#S $'('> $1%-&4 &11 $1+N>'$, ,23

#"N#24'(# 91- 4#&&>#+#2& 19 >1$,> 3'4N%/ W:#. N-#9#--#3 &-,3'&'12,> N#,$# $1%2$'>4 ,23 54>,+'$

$1%-&4 ,23 %-8#3 &:# 2,&'12,> 81(#-2+#2& &1 -#(#-& &1 &:# 91-+#- 4#N,-,&'12 H#&S##2 -#>'8'1%4 ,23

$'('> $1%-&4/ 52 6AI c-8,2'4,&'12 &:,& 4N>'& &:# &S1/DD W:# 9#3#-,>'4& +1(#+#2&Y S:'$: 4%NN1-&4 ,31N&'28 &:# 6AI6 $124&'&%&'12 -,&:#- &:,2 3-,9&'28 ,

2#S 12#Y '4 , F#28:,e'BH,4#3 8-1%N &:,& #+#-8#3 '2 =N-'> LM6L/ 5&4 +#+H#-4 ,3(1$, -#&%-2 &1 ,

9#3#-,> 4.4+ ,4 1%&>'2#3 '2 &:# +12,-$:'$,>B#-, $124&'&%&'12/DC ?%--#2& Z%-'4&4 $>,'+ &:,& Z%38#4 #2Z1.#3 8-#,- '23#N#23#2$# ,& &:# &'+#/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-B

('#S4Y Z%38#4Y N-14#$%&1-4Y >,S.#-4Y W-'N1>'Y F#28:,e'Y G'4-,&,Y F,2' a,>'3Y O%2#B*#N+H#- LM6L/DI ?-'4'4 V-1%N 52-('#SY `,-,Z G,,-%9Y :#,3 19 Z%3'$',> '24N#$&'124 199'$#Y W-'N1>'Y LA =%8%4& LM6L/DJ=NN>'$,&'12 19 54>,+'$ >#8,> #&4 N-#4#2 $#-&,'2 3'99'$%>&'#4/ c2# #",+N># '2(1>(#3 S:,& &1

31 S'&: &-,3'&'12,> 91-+4 19 54>,+'$ N%2'4:+#2&Y 4%$: ,4 &:# 4#(#-,2$# 19 , :,23 91- &:#9&/ Q#H,

,-14# 1(#- S:#&:#- &:'4 >'-,>>. +#,2& ,+N%&,&'12 1- -,&:#- 4:1%>3 H# 4##2 ,4 , +#&,N:1- 91- N-#B

(#2&'28 &:# :,23 9-1+ $1++'&&'28 9%&%-# $-'+# H. -#+1('28 2##3 ,23 +N&,&'12/ 7'H.,X4 -#>'8'1%4

>#8,> 4$:1>,-4 ,31N +14&>. >'-,> '2-N-#&,&'124Y H%& &:#4# S#-#4N,-4#>.,NN>'#3 '2 K,3:,9'B#-,

$1%-&4Y ,4 Z%38#4 '2(1P#3 #"#+N&'124 ,23 \%,>'9'$,&'124 $124'4& S'&: 54>,+'$ #&4/ *:#'P: ,>B

*,3#\ ,>BV:,-',2'Y &:# $%--#2& +%9&' 19 7'H.,Y $>,'+4 &:,& &:# *:,-',4,&'12 19 >#8,> $13#4 $,--'#3 1%&

%23#- K,3:,9' S,4 >'+'/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#S4Y =3#> ,>BG4#>>,&'Y 91-+#- :#,3 19 W-'N1>'X4 =NB

N#,>4 ?1%-&Y W-'N1>'Y L G,. LM6L[ *:#'P: ,>B*,3#\ ,>BV:,-',2'Y W-'N1>'Y LJ U1(#+H#- LM6L/ *## ,>41

&:# $:,N- 12 g7,S ,23 &:# O%3'$',-.h '2 f#>#2 ?:,N'2 G#&e @#3/EY >'8.,= I @0%1&-. *&%2.

@a,4:'28&12Y 6A


17/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 ##

Q%-'28 &:# 9'-4& .#,-4 19 K,3:,9'X4 -%>#Y &:# 2#S >#,3#-4:'N +1-# 1- >#44 -#4N#$

&:# 4&, $1%-&4X '23#N#23#2$# ,23 H,4'$ 3%# N-1$#44 19 >,S/ =>&:1%8: #,->. 12 '&

'2&-13%$#3 &:# $12$#N& 19 $-'+#4 ,8,'24& &:# 4&, '2 &:# $-'+'2,> $13#Y , $%--#2&

+#+H#- 19 &:# Z%3'$',-. 4,'3Y g'2 &:14# '2'&',> .#,-4 j,9- &:# 6AJA $1%Nk Z%38#4 S#-#

,8,'24& G%,++,- jK,3:,9'kY ,23 $-'+'2,> $1%-&4 S#-# 21& $1>>,H1-,&'28h S'&: &:#

-#8'+#/DT7'P#S'4#Y Z%38#4 ,44#-& &:,&Y K,3:,9'X4 ,&+N& &1 -#4&-'$& Z%3'$',> '23#B

N#23#2$# 21&S'&:4&,23'28Y &:# -#8'+# S,4 %2,H># &1 %4# $-'+'2,> $1%-&4 ,23 1-3'B

2,-. $-'+'2,> >#8'4>,&'12 '2 $,4#4 19 ,>>#8#3 N1>'&'$,> $-'+#4[ ,4 , -#4%>&Y '& #4&,H>'4:#3

S:,& $,+# &1 H# P21S2 ,4 g#"$#N&'12,>h 1- g4N#$',>h $1%-&4 @+,5,D'+ '3&'&51,'.,E

&1 N-14#$% 199'$',>4 ,99'>', S'&: &:# +12,-$:./D. ,9- &:# j6AJAk -#(1>%&'12Y 1%- $1%-&4 S#-# #"$#>>#2&Y ,23 &:# Z%38#4

S#-# :12#4&/ F#$,%4# 19 &:'4Y &:# -#8'+# &-'#3 &1 $:,28# 41+# >,S4 '2 1-3#- &1 -#B4&-'$& &:#'- 9-##31+ &1 ,3Z%3'$,/ W:#. S,2 &1 >'+'& &:# Z%38#4X '23#N#23#2$#

H%& S#-# %24%$$#449%>/ *1 &:#. $-#, &:# 4N#$',> $1%-&4 ,23 ,NN1'2 -#8'+#

>1.,>'4&4 &1 &:#+/DA

a'&: &:# 6ATT #4&,H>'4:+#2& 19 4MB$,>>#3 -#(1>%&'12,-. $1++'Y &:# 1-3'2,-.

Z%3'$',> 4.4+ '&4#>9 S,4 H-1%8:& '2&1 >'2#/ W:#4# $1++' _ S:14# 3#$'4'124

4%N#-4#3#3 >#8'4>,&'12 _ #2Z1.#3 N1>'$# 9%2$&'124Y '2$>%3'28 &:# N1S#- &1 ,--#4& -#8'+#

1NN12#2&4 ,23 +,2,8# 3#&'12 $#2&-#4/CM52-2,> 4#$%-'&. 4#-('$#4 @,7E,+,1 ,7E

2,D5'7'E $1%>3 H,- &:# -#>#,4# 19 N-'412#-4 #(#2 ,9- &:#. :,3 4#-(#3 &:#'- -+4/

W:# -#8'+# >'P#S'4# ,NN1'2 Z%38#4 S'&:1%& >#8,> &-,'2'28 ,23Y H#&S##2 6A.Y &:'4 :,3 &:# N-,$&'$,> #99#$& 19 H-'28'28 &:#Z%3'$',> 4.4+ %23#- &:# '2-2,> 4#$%-'&.X4 ,%&:1-'&./

W1 &:'4 3,.Y &:# $1%2&-. >'(#4 %23#- &:# 4:,31S 19 &:#4# 3#$'4'124/ W:# $:'#9 19

Z%3'$',> '24N#$&'124 4,'3]

=9- 6ATTY &:# Z%4&'$# +'2'4&-. S,4 $:,28#3 '2&1 &:# Z%4&'$# 4#$-#&,-',&/ W:# -#(1B

>%&'12,-. $1++' N>,$#3 &:#'- 1S2 N#1N># ,4 +#+H#-4 19 &:# Z%3'$',-.Y #(#2

'9 &:#. >,$P#3 >#8,> &-,'2'28/ G,2. N1>'$# 199'$#-4 H#$,+# Z%38#4/ *1+# S1%>3 S1-P

91- &S#2&. .#,-4 ,4 N1>'$#+#2 ,23 &:#2 H# N-1+1 &1 Z%38#4:'N4/ W13,.Y S# ,-#

9,$'28 &:'4 N-1H>#+Y ,4 -1%8:>. DMBCM N#- $#2& 19 Z%38#4 3'3 21& 81 &:-1%8: 91-B

+,> >#8,> &-,'2'28/C6

!(#2 ,4 &:# Z%3'$',-. '2$-#,4'28>. $,+# %23#- 4&, $12&-1>Y 4N#$',> $1%-&4 S#-# '2$:,-8# 19 N1>'&'$,> &-',>4Y , N-'2$'N,> +#,24 19 \%,4:'28 3'44#2&/ =>&:1%8: ,& 9'-4& &:#4#

S#-# ,3 :1$Y &:#. 8-,3%,>>. 3#(#>1N#3 '2&1 ,2 #2&'-#>. 4#N,-, $1%-& 4.4+/

DT ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY G%4&,9, c+,- =>' =H% K,&'9,Y +#+H#-Y 199'$# 19 &:# ,&&1-2#. 8#2#-,>Y

W-'N1>'Y L G,. LM6L/D< g!"$#N&'12,> $1%-&4h '4 &:# >'-,> &-,24>,&'12 19 &:# =-,H'$ +,5,D'+ '3&'&51,'.,Y S'3#>. %4#3 &1

3#4$-'H# &.N#4 19 K,3:,9'B#-, &-'H%2,>4 &:,& 9#>> 1%&4'3# &:# 1-3'2,-. $-'+'2,> Z%4&'$# 4.4+/ W:#.

,-# ,>41 -#9#--#3 &1 ,4 g4N#$',>h $1%-&4 @+,5,D'+ &,5,33%3'.,EY &:# -+ &:'4 -#N1-& %4#4/DA?-'4'4 V-1%N 1H4#-(,&'124Y 4N##$: H. l,+,> Q,:,2Y N-#4'3#2& 19 &:# *%N-#+# ?1%-&Y &1 &:# ?1%2$'>

19 G'2'4-4Y N-'+# +'2'4-X4 199'$#Y W-'N1>'Y L6 U1(#+H#- LM6L/CM c2 &:# 0#(1>%&'12,-. ?1++'Y 4## ?-'4'4 V-1%N G'33># !,4&iU1-&: =9-'$, 0#N1-& Um6MTY

H09%7,- H-0& '1 Y0-&5 IA-'$, ,12 &5# R'227# !,3& LZQ= R,D'1: *#13# 0A >'8.,Y J O%2# LM66/C6 ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY `,-,Z G,,-%9Y :#,3 19 Z%3'$',> '24N#$&'124 199'$#Y W-'N1>'Y LA =%8%4& LM6L/


18/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 #*

6/ *N#$',> $1%-&4

52 6AT6Y &:# -#8'+# 4#& %N &:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& @+,5D,+, ,7E35,,8E &1 &-. 91-+#- -1.B,> 9,+'>. +#+H#-4Y N-'+# +'2'4-4 ,23 1&:#- 199'$',>4 9-1+ &:# 3#N14#3 +12,-$:.

,$$%4#3 19 -'88'28 #>#$&'124 1- g$1--%N&'28 N%H>'$ 1N'2'12h/CL= 0#(1>%&'12,-. ?1+B

+,23 ?1%2$'> @0??E +#+H#- N-#4'3#3 1(#- &:# $1%-&Y S:'$: ,>41 '2$>%3#3 , -#N-#B

4#2&,&'(# 9-1+ &:# ,-+#3 91-$#4 ,23 &:# N1>'$#[ &:# 0?? 21+'2, ,>> Z%38#4/ F. &:#

>, 6ATM4Y &:# $1%-& :,3 &-'#3 1(#- LMM N#1N># ,99'>', S'&: &:# 91-+#- +12,-$:.Y

'2$>%3'28 91-+#- l'28 53-'4Y S:1 S,4 4#2$#3 &1 3#,&: '2 ,H4#2&',/CD

W:# ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& 9%2$&'12#3 #(#2 ,9- '& :,3 9'2'4:#3 3#,>'28 S'&: 91-+#- -#B

8'+# 199'$',>4/CC -1+ &:# >, 6A'&'12 '2 LMMIY '& ,$ ,4 , N,-,>>#>

4.4+ S'&: '&4 1S2 N-14#$%&1-',> H13. @+,D&,8,7B'2,, ,7E35,,8'Y 199'$# 19 &:#

N#1N>#X4 N-14#$%&1-E/ 5& &-'#3 +14& N1>'&'$,> ,23 4#$%-'&. $,4#4Y 8,'2'28 '2-2,&'12,>

21&1-'#&. 21&,H>. 91- >%+N'28 &18#&:#- N#-N#&-,&1-4 19 ('1>#2& ,$&4 ,23 81(#-2+#2&$-'&'$4 4##P'28 N#,$#9%> N1>'&'$,> $:,28#/CIc(#- &:# .#,-4Y &:# $1%-& &-'#3 ,23 4#2$#3

+,2. $%--#2& N1>'&'$',24 ,23 ,$&'('4&4Y '2$>%3'28 U,&'12,> W-,24'&'12,> ?1%2$'> @UW?E

,23 VU? +#+H#-4Y ,4 S#>> ,4 54>,+'4&4/CJ

52 &:# >, 6ATM4Y &:# -#8'+# #4&,H>'4:#3 ,21&:#- Z%3'$',> H13.Y &:# 0#(1>%&'12,-.

?1++'/ 5&4 +#+H#-4Y $'('>',24 S:1 ,$ ,4 , N,-,>#8,> 4#$%-'&. 91-$#Y N-#4'3#3

1(#- N-1$##3'284 ,8,'24& '23'('3%,>4 $:,-8#3 S'&: S:,& S#-# 3##+#3 $-'+#4 ,8,'24&

&:# -#(1>%&'12/CTQ#9#23,2&4 :,3 2#'&:#- >#8,> $1%24#> 21- -'8:& 19 ,NN#,>[ g-#(1>%B

&'12,-. Z%38#4h 4#2$#3 +,2. &1 3#,&:/C>#3 &1 ,& #"#B

$%&'124Y S:'$: S#-# $,--'#3 1%& 12 %2'(#-4'&. $,+N%4#4 ,23 >#('4#3/CA=>&:1%8:

&:#-# '4 21 #('3#2$# &:#. #(#- S#-# 91-+,>>. ,H1>'4:#3Y &:# -#8'+# ,NN#,-4 &1 :,(#

4&1NN#3 %4'28 -#(1>%&'12,-. $1%-&4 H. &:# >, 6AAM4/IM

CL W:# 0#(1>%&'12,-. ?1++,23 ?1%2$'> @0??E '2$>%3#3 &1N 199'$',>4 S:1 $,--'#3 1%& &:# 6AJA $1%N/

?:,'-#3 H. K,3:,9'Y '& S,4 &:# $1%2&-.X4 81(#-2'28 H13. 9-1+ 6AJA &1 6ATTY S:#2 &:# V#2#-,> ;#1B

N>#X4 ?128-#44 @V;?E -#N>,$#3 '&/ W:# 0?? #4&,H>'4:#3 &:# 9'-4& ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-& 12 LJ c$&1H#- 6AJA/

W:# $%--#2& VU? N-#4'3#2&Y G1:,+#3 G,8,-'#9Y S-1 ,H1%& &:# 4N#$',> $1%-& 4.4+ '2 >'8.,=

+'1 ,7E35,-,?'., ,7E2%3&%-'., '7, ,7E35,-,?'., ,7E&5,B-'.,j7'H.,] -1+ $124&'&%&'12,> >,S &1 -#(1B

>%&'12,-. >,Sk @?,'-1Y LMM# >'4& 19 N#1N># 4#2$#3 H. &:#4# $1%-&4 '4 ,(,'>,H># '2 'H'3Y NN/ #X4 ?128-#44E 7,S Ii6A'4#3 &:'4 $1%-&Y #4&,H>'4:'28 H1&: '&4 $1+N14'&'12 ,23 Z%-'43'$&'12/ W:# >,S -#\%'-#3 ;#1N>#X4 ?1%-&

Z%38#4 &1 H# =-,HY g8113Y $1++'& -#(1>%&'12,-j'#4k S'&: , 41%23 -#N%&,&'12h ,23 :,(# $1+N>#

H,4'$ >#8,> 4&%3'#4/CIg7'H.,] a1-34 &1 Q##34hY f%+,2 0'8:&4 a,&$:Y LI O,2%,-. LMMJ/CJ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY G%4>'+ F-1&:#-:113 +#+H#-Y W-'N1>'Y c$&1H#-BU1(#+H#- LM6L/CT 7,S T6i6ATL H,22#3 ,2. 8-1%N ,$&'('&. H,4#3 12 N1>'&'$,> '3#1>18. $12&-,-. &1 &:# N-'2$'N>#4 19

&:# 6AJA -#(1>%&'12/ g7'H.,] a1-34 &1 Q##3hY 1N/ $'&/C< !"#$%&'124 &.N'$,>>. S#-# $,--'#3 1%& 12 T =N-'>Y &:# ,22'(#-4,-. 19 &:# -#8'+#X4 6ATJ 4%NN-#44'12

19 4&%3#2& N-1&4 '2 W-'N1>' ,23 F#28:,e'/CA= 7'H.,2 S1+,2 '2 :#- IM4 4,'3Y g'& S,4 :1--'H>#/ a:#2 5 S,4 , >'&&># P'3Y &:#. S1%>3 H-1,3$,4&

&:#4# :,28'284 12 >#('4'12/ W:#-# S#-#2X& ,4 +,2. $:,22#>4 ,4 &:#-# ,-# 21SY ,23 &:#. -#N#, &:#

911&,8#Y 41 .1% S1%>3 #23 %N S,&$:'28 '& #(#2 '9 .1% 3'3 21& S,2& &1h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY W-'N1>'Y

G,. LM6L/ *#8+#2&4 19 &:# ;#1N>#4X ?1%-& &-',>4 ,>41 S#-# H-1,3$,4&/ g5 ,+ 21& 4%-# '9 S# S#-# 4:1S2

&:# ,$&%,> &-',> 1- Z%4& &:# $:,-8#4 19 S:'$: &:#4# N#1N># 4&113 ,$$%4#3/ =>> 5 P21S '4 &:,& S# S1%>3

4## &:#4# N#1N># H#:'23 H,-4 _ +,2. 19 &:#+ Z1%-2,>'4&4 B ,23 , (1'$# S1%>3 4&, &:# $:,-8#/ U1SY

'2 -#&-14N#$&Y 5 P21S &:,& +,2. 19 &:14# $:,-8#4 S#-# 9,H-'$,/ F%& ,& &:# &'+#Y :1S $1%>3 .1%

P21Sn a# H#>'#(#3 S:,& S# S#-# &1>3h/ ?-'4'4 V-1%N '2-('#SY W-'N1>' -#4'3#2&Y LL Q#$#+H#- LM6L/IM W:# >,4& &'+# , -#(1>%&'12,-. $1%-& S,4 $12(#2#3 ,NN#,-4 &1 :,(# H##2 &1 &-. +'>'&,-. 199'$#-4

9-1+ F,2' a,>'3Y ,$$%4#3 19 N,-&'$'N,&'28 '2 , 6AAD $1%N ,&+N&/ =>>#8#3 4%NN1--4 9-1+ &:# &1S2


19/53

?."($ @A '..-.B C;)*"2% "D E-)*FG(#/(1" H"@A(

3'(4(4 5'26& J(KK)0 L14/MN2'/O %P'(H1 Q0&2'/ NR#9+= #$ %&'() *+#, S1>0 #,

*112 ,9- K,3:,9'X4 $1%NY &:# -#8'+# ,>41 4#& %N +'>'&,-. $1%-&4 @+,5,D'+ ,3D,E

-'.,E/I6^2&'> 6ATCY &:#4# S#-# ,3 :1$ &-'H%2,>4[ 4%H4#\%#2&>.Y &:#. H#$,+# .#& ,2B

140 trial by error justice in post qadhafi libya

Documents