11 states file anti-sb 1070 brief

8/2/2019 11 states file anti-SB 1070 brief

1/35

M]HED DO] YGE ^YFYE^ OD BEQ XO]J,

NF@HDO]BHF, NOBBENYHNUY, GFQFHH, H@@HBOH^,

HOQF, LF]X@FBI, LF^^FNGUÊYY^, O]EAOB,

]GOIE H^@FBI, FBI TE]LOBY F^FLHNH

NU]HFE HB Û[[O]Y OD ]E^[OBIEBY

Bo" 6667=

HBYGE

û{}ele Nou}y od yge Ubhyei ^yfye~

OB Q]HYOD NE]YHO]F]HYOYGE

UBHYEI ^YFYE^ NOU]YOD F[[EF@^DO]YGE BHBYG NH]NUHY

^YFYE OD F]HSOBFey f`",

[eyhyhobe}~,

t"

UBHYEI ^YFYE^ OD FLE]HNF,

]e~{obieby"

JFLF@FI" GF]]H^Fyyo}bex Aebe}f` od yge^yfye od Nf`hdo}bhf

LFBUE@ L" LEIEH]O^ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

@OUH^ TE]IUAOêbho} F~~h~yfbyFyyo}bex Aebe}f`

FBYOBEYYE NO]IE]OCOÊ SE@HIOBSE[EIF

Ie{uyx Fyyo}bex~ Aebe}f`6>;; H ^y}eey

^fn}flebyo, NF 89=99'864( >=>6884

E]HN Y" ^NGBEHIE]LFBFyyo}bex Aebe}f` od yge^yfye od Beq Xo}j

MF]MF]FI" UBIE]QOOI#ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

J]H^YEB N@F]JEMu}efu Nghed

NENE@HFN" NGFBAIe{uyx ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

^YETEB N" QUF~~h~yfby ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

6=; M}ofiqfx

Beq Xo}j, BX 6;=16'=6=( 9647;=;mf}mf}f"ubie}qooiKfa"bx"aot#Noub~e` od ]eno}i

Fyyo}bex~ do} Flhnh Nu}hfe'Fiihyhobf` Noub~e` @h~yei ob ^habfyu}e [fae(


2/35


3/35

h

YFM@E OD NOBYEBY^

[fae

Hbye}e~y odFlhnh Nu}hfe " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 6ûllf}x od F}auleby" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =F}auleby " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 9

H" Deie}f` @fq [}eel{y~ Ubh`fye}f` ^yfyeEddo}y~ yo F{{}egebi fbi ]eloteUbionulebyei Hllha}fby~" " " " " " " " " " " " " " 9

F" Deie}f` `fq }evuh}e~ deie}f` ote}~hagyod ~yfye noo{e}fyhob qhyg deie}f`fuygo}hyhe~ hb nobbenyhob qhyg yge}elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~" 4

M" Deie}f` `fq lfbifye~ yge e~yfm`h~glebyfbi hl{èlebyfyhob od deie}f` ebdo}neleby{}ho}hyhe~ nobne}bhba yge }elotf` odubionulebyei hllha}fby~ " " " " " " " " " " 7

HH" F}hsobf~ ^"M" 6;1; H~ [}eel{yei Menfu~eHy Nobhny~ qhyg Noba}e~~~ Ieèafyhob odEbdo}neleby Ote}~hagy fbi Ebdo}neleby

[}ho}hyhe~ yo Deie}f` Odstnhf`~ " " " " " " " " " " " " 6>F" ^"M" 6;1;~ ubh`fye}f` hllha}fyhob {o`hnx

nobhny~ qhyg yge }evuh}eleby od deie}fòte}~hagy hb noo{e}fyhte deie}f`~yfyehllha}fyhob ebdo}neleby" " " " " " " " " " " " 69

M" ^"M" 6;1; ebfny~ f ~e{f}fye ~yfye }elotf`~ngele ygfy nobhny~ qhyg Noba}e~~~oqb {}ho}hyhe~ fbi qhyg hy~ ieèafyhob odebdo}neleby ih~n}eyhob yo deie}f`fuygo}hyhe~ " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 61

HHH" F}hsobf~ ^hbaè^yfye ]elotf` [o`hnx Gf~

Bfyhobf` fbi Hbye}bfyhobf` Eddeny~" " " " " " " " =6Nobnù~hob" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =5


4/35

hh

YFM@E OD NHYEI FUYGO]HYHE^

[fae

NFÊ^

Fl" Hb~" F~~b t" Af}flebih, 5>8 U"^" >84'=;;>( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =6

Mf`muebf t" HI] ]ef`yx @@N, 4 B"X">i >>7'=;;4( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 5

Ngx @uba t" D}eelfb, 8= U"^" =15 '6715( " " " " " " " " =>

N}o~mx t" Bfy` Do}ehab Y}fie Noubnh`, 5>; U"^">4> '=;;;( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =;

IeNfbf~ t" Mhnf, 9=9 U"^" >56 '6814( " " " " " " " " " " " ">, 5, 4Doba Gfq Yfb t" [ge`fb, >>> U"^" 4 '6897( " " " " " " 9Genjè} t" Ngfbex, 91; U"^" 7=6 '6875( " " " " " " " " " " 66Ghbe~ t" Ifthioqhys, >6= U"^" 5= '6896(" " " " " " " " {f~~hlHB^ t" Nf}iosfDob~enf, 97; U"^" 9=6 '6871( " " " " " 6=Beq Xo}j t" Ubhyei ^yfye~, 5;5 U"^" 699 '688=(" " " " 64[fih``f t" Jebyunjx, 6>; ^" Ny" 691> '=;6;( " " " " " " " 66[`xè} t" Ioe, 951 U"^" =;= '687=( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 5, 8, =6[}hbys t" Ubhyei ^yfye~, 5=6 U"^" 787 '6881( " " " " " " 64]ebo t" Fle}hnfbF}fm FbyhIh~n}hlhbfyhob

Noll", 5=5 U"^" 916 '6888( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 1Y}o{ t" Iu`è~, >54 U"^" 74 '6857( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 9Ubhyei ^yfye~ t" M}habobh[obne, 9== U"^" 71>

'6815(" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 6;Th``f~ fy [f}j~hie [f}ybe}~ t" Nhyx od Df}le}~

M}fbng, D">i , =;6= Q@ 85==5='5yg Nh}" Lf}" =6, =;6=( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =;

Qh~" Ie{y od Hbiu~y}x, @fmo} $ Gulfb ]e`fyhob~t" Aouì Hbn", 915 U"^" =7= '6874( " " " " " " " " " " " " " 68

Sfitxif~ t" Ifth~, 5>> U"^" 417 '=;;6( " " " " " " " " " " 9

NOB^YHYUYHOB

U"^" Nob~y" f}y" 6, 7, n`" 9 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 9


5/35

hhh

Nhyei Fuygo}hyhe~

[fae

DEIE]F@ ^YFYUYE^

Ie{f}yleby od Gole`fbi ênu}hyx F{{}o{}hfyhob~Fny od =;6;, [um" @" Bo" 6667>, 6=> ^yfy" =69='=;;8( " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 66

7 U"^"N" 66;> " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " "4, 1, 7

6657 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =9 667= " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =9 6==8f " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 4 6==8m " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 66 6=>6 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " =9 6=5=n " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 1 6>51 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " {f~~hl

^YFYE ^YFYUYE^

Nf`" ^yfy~" =;;=, ng" 6;16 '^"M" 6767(" " " " " " " " " " " " " 5Nf`" Ubel{" Hb~" Noie 6=49 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 4

^"M" 6;1;, =;6; F}hs" ê~~" @fq~, ng" 66>, f~flebiei mx =;6; F}hs" ê~~" @fq~, ng" =66" " " {f~~hl

DEIE]F@ ]EAU@FYHOB^

7 N"D"]" =>4"6 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 1, 65 =71"5 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 65 =71"7 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 65

LH^NE@@FBEOU^ FUYGO]HYHE^

Fiho~ F}hsobf3 @oy~ od [eo{è F}e @efthba, Yge

Enobolh~y, Bot" =5, =;6;, gyy{3//qqq"enobolh~y"nol/boie/6157678= '`f~y th~hyei Lf}" =>, =;6=(" " ==


6/35

ht

Nhyei Fuygo}hyhe~

[fae

Deib do} Fl" Hllha}fyhob ]edo}l,Ebnou}faei]ete}~e Lha}fyhob3 F êb~hmè êteb^ye{^y}fyeax do} [}oloyhba yge Ouymoubi Dòqod H`èaf` Hllha}fyhob '=;;4(, gyy{3//qqq"dfh}u~"o}a/~hye/Ionê}te}/}e~ef}ng_%=;mfnja}oubie}_lfx6;=;;4"{id?ionHI


7/35

t

Nhyei Fuygo}hyhe~

[fae

Lelo}fbiul d}ol Cogb Lo}yob,Ewe}nh~hba[}o~enuyo}hf` Ih~n}eyhob Nob~h~yeby qhyg ygeNhth` Hllha}fyhob Ebdo}neleby [}ho}hyhe~ odyge Faebnx do} yge F{{}egeb~hob, Ieyebyhob,fbi ]elotf` od F`heb~ 'Cube 61, =;66(, gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/ion`hm/~enu}enollubhyhe~/{id/

{}o~enuyo}hfìh~n}eyhoblelo"{id" " " " " " " " " " " " 6=Lelo}fbiul d}ol Cogb Lo}yob,[}o~enuyo}hf`

Ih~n}eyhob3 Ne}yfhb Thnyhl~, Qhybe~~e~, fbi[`fhbyhdd~ 'Cube 61, =;66(, gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/ion`hm/~enu}enollubhyhe~/{id/iole~yhnthoèbne"{id " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 6=

Lhngfe` Cogb Af}nhf, Noba" ]e~ef}ng ê}t",N}hlhbf`hshba Ub`fqdu` [}e~ebne3 êènyei

H~~ue~ 'Lfx >, =;;4(, gyy{3//y}fn"~x}"eiu/hllha}fyhob/`hm}f}x/[575"{id " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 6;

Bulme}~U^F,Fyy}hyhob Yg}ouag Ebdo}neleby

H~ yge Y}ue Lhiièa}oubi ôùyhob, gyy{3//qqq"bulme}~u~f"nol/nobyeby/èf}b/h~~ue~/fle}hnfbqo}je}~/fyy}hyhobyg}ouagebdo}nelebyy}uelhii`"gyl` '`f~y th~hyeiLf}" =>, =;6=(" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 67

^yfyeleby od ]hngf}i L" ^yfbf, U"^" AotyFnnoubyfmh`hyx Odstne,Hllha}fyhobEbdo}neleby3 Noby}o`~ ote} [}oa}flFuygo}hshba ^yfye fbi @onf` Ebdo}nelebyod Deie}f` Hllha}fyhob @fq~ ^gouì Me

^y}ebaygebei => '=;;8(" gyy{3//qqq"afo"aot/

beq"hyel~/i;8>76y"{id " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 64


8/35

th

Nhyei Fuygo}hyhe~

[fae

U"^" Hllha}fyhob fbi Nu~yol~ Ebdo}neleby,Dfny ^geey3 Ie`eafyhob od Hllha}fyhobFuygo}hyx enyhob =71'a( Hllha}fyhob fbiBfyhobf`hyx Fny, gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/beq~/`hm}f}x/dfny~geey~/=71a"gyl" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 64


9/35

6

HBYE]E^Y ODFLHNH NU]HFE

Flhnh, yge yfye~ od Nf`hdo}bhf, Beq Xo}j, Nobbenyhnuy,Gfqfhh, H``hboh~, Hoqf, Lf}x`fbi, Lf~~fngu~eyy~, O}eaob,]goie H~`fbi, fbi Te}loby f}e yge gole~ od ~ole od yge`f}ae~y {o{u`fyhob~ od moyg ionulebyei fbi ubionulebyeihllha}fby~ hb yge nouby}x"êe Cedd}ex [f~~e` $ ITe}fNogb, [eq Gh~{fbhn Ny}", Ubfuygo}hsei Hllha}fby

[o{u`fyhob3 Bfyhobf` fbi ^yfye Y}ebi~, =;6;, fy 6965

'Dem" 6, =;66("6 F~ ^yfye~, Flhnh io boy `hagy`x ~u{{o}ydeie}f` {}eel{yhob od ~yfye `fq" Flhnh ^yfye~ gfte f qhietf}heyx od fq~ fddenyhba f`` {e}~ob~ qhyghb ygeh} mo}ie}~,fbi Flhnh ~eej yo {}e~e}te ygeh} fuygo}hyx yo ebfny fbiebdo}ne ~ung `fq~, eteb f~ f{{`hei yo hllha}fby~" Fyyge ~fle yhle, Flhnh ^yfye~ gfte f ~y}oba hbye}e~y hb}enoabhshba ygfy yge ~hbau`f} vue~yhob od qgeyge} fbigoq yo }elote ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ h~ obe ygfy h~nollhyyei yo yge deie}f` aote}bleby"

F~ ielob~y}fyei meòq, yge F}hsobf ~yfyuye fy h~~ue

ge}e nobhny~ qhyg deie}f` `fq ob }elotf`" F`ygouagF}hsobf n`fhl~ ygfy yge `fq le}e`x f~~h~y~ yge deie}fàote}bleby hb yge ebdo}neleby od deie}f` fq, yge F}hsobf`fq hb dfny hl{èleby~ f ih~yhbny ~yfye {o`hnx ob }elotf`ygfy ~u{{`fby~ deie}f``x lfbifyei ebdo}neleby {}ho}hyhe~fbi ih~}eaf}i~ yge deie}f` }evuh}eleby ygfy ~yfyef~~h~yfbne hb ygh~ f}ef {}oneei ubie} deie}f` ote}~hagy"

Flhnh ^yfye~ gfte f nol{e``hba hbye}e~y hb {}etebyhba F}hsobf d}ol ebdo}nhba hy~ oqb }elotf` {o`hnx" Qhygouy deie}f` ote}~hagy fbi ebdo}neleby od deie}f`

{}ho}hyhe~, hbihthiuf` ~yfye }elotf` {o`hnhe~ qouì {`fne

6" gyy{3//qqq"{eqgh~{fbhn"o}a/stè~/}e{o}y~/6>>"{id"


10/35

=

ih~{}o{o}yhobfye ielfbi~ ob deie}f` }e~ou}ne~ fbigfte oyge} hbye}~yfye eddeny~" Flhnh ^yfye~ lfx gfteihdde}hba theq~ fmouy {}enh~e`x qgfy }elotf` {}ho}hyhe~fbi ebdo}neleby {}fnyhne~ qouì me o{yhlf`, muy ygexfa}ee ygfy, qge}e }elotf` h~ nobne}bei, Noba}e~~ fbiyge Ewenuyhte M}fbng f}e yge f{{}o{}hfye moihe~ do}ieye}lhbhba yge~e bfyhobf` {o`hnhe~"

Flhnh, bo è~~ ygfb F}hsobf, gfte ubionulebyei

hllha}fby {o{u`fyhob~ qhyghb ygeh} mo}ie}~, fbi ygexgfte fio{yei ihte}~e lef~u}e~ yo fii}e~~ yge hl{fny~od ygfy {o{u`fyhob, hb f lfbbe} }eenyhba hbihthiuf` ~yfye{}ho}hyhe~ fbi }e~ou}ne~" F bf}}oq {}eel{yhob }u`hbaygfy }enoabhse~ yge qfx~ hb qghng F}hsobf~ ~yfyuyenobhny~ qhyg Noba}e~~~ ieèafyhob od }elotf` fuygo}hyxfbi ote}~hagy {oqe} yo deie}f` odstnhf`~ qouì {}e~e}teyge ^yfye~ fuygo}hyx yo ebdo}ne `fq~ fii}e~~hba nobiunyfbi {e}~ob~ qhyghb ygeh} mo}ie}~, qghè {}oloyhba Flhnh^yfye~ ote}f}nghba hbye}e~y hb f ubhstei, bfyhobf` }elotf`{o`hnx"

ÛLLF]X OD F]AULEBY

^yfye~ gfte m}ofi fuygo}hyx yo ebfny fbi ebdo}ne`fq~ fddenyhba f`` {e}~ob~ qhyghb ygeh} mo}ie}~, hbnùihbaionulebyei fbi ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, hb ygelfbbe} ygfy me~y fnnolloifye~ ònf` nobne}b~" Deie}f`hllha}fyhob fq ioe~ boy {}eel{y ygfy fuygo}hyx aebe}f``x,boyqhyg~yfbihba Noba}e~~~ nol{}egeb~hte }eau`fyhob odhllha}fyhob{f}yhnu`f}`x qgeb f ~yfye `fq ~e}te~ fbhbie{ebieby ~yfye hbye}e~y ygfy ioe~ boy }e`x ob deie}f`

`fq, o} }eau`fye~ hb fb f}ef od y}fihyhobf` ~yfye nobne}b"


11/35

>

ôle f}ef~ od hllha}fyhob {o`hnx, goqete}, f}ete~yei hb yge deie}f` aote}bleby fòbe" Yge }elotf` odubionulebyei hllha}fby~ h~ obe ~ung ewnù~hte`x deie}f`dubnyhobf }eenyhob od }elotf`~ nò~e }e`fyhob~gh{ yoyge deie}f` aote}bleby~ ~oè fuygo}hyx yo ieye}lhbeqgo ~gouì fbi ~gouì boy me filhyyei hbyo yge nouby}x"

IeNfbf~ t" Mhnf, 9=9 U"^" >56, >55 '6814(" Fbi hb fhi odhy~ ewnù~hte }elotf` fuygo}hyx, Noba}e~~ gf~ nf}edu``x}eau`fyei boy ob`x qgo lfx me }elotei d}ol yge Ubhyei

^yfye~, muy goq ~ung hbihthiuf`~ ~gouì me hiebyhstei,f{{}egebiei, fbi ieyfhbei"

Deie}f` `fq gf~ òba }enoabhsei ygfy moyg }elotf`fbi ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf` gfte ubhvue`xietf~yfyhba eddeny~, odyeb ob {eo{è qgo f}e oyge}qh~e fqfmhihba fbi {}oiunyhte lelme}~ od ~onheyx" Noba}e~~ gf~}e~{obiei yo yge~e nobne}b~ mx {}ho}hyhshba ne}yfhb n`f~~e~od ifbae}ou~ ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ do} }elotf`, mxieèafyhba ~um~yfbyhf` ih~n}eyhob yo yge Ewenuyhte M}fbngote} yge }elotf` {}one~~, fbi mx ~{enhstnf``x }evuh}hba

deie}f` ote}~hagy ote} bobdeie}f` odstne}~ qgo ebafae hbebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`"

F}hsobf~ hllha}fyhob ~yfyuye, ^"M" 6;1; '=;6; F}hs"ê~~" @fq~, ng" 66>, f~ flebiei mx =;6; F}hs" e~~" @fq~,ng" =66(, e~yfm`h~ge~ F}hsobf~ oqb }elotf` {o`hnx, hbnobhny qhyg ygh~ deie}f` ~ngele, fbi h~ ygu~ {}eel{yei"F}hsobf nobyebi~ ge}e ygfy yge {u}{o~e od yge ~yfyuyeh~ yo ebdo}nZe\ yge {}enh~e èaf` }uè~ " " " {}e~n}hmeimx Noba}e~~" [ey" M}" 65" Muy ^"M" 6;1; ie{f}y~ d}oldeie}f` }elotf` {o`hnx hb yqo dubiflebyf` qfx~" Dh}~y,

yge ~yfyuye }evuh}e~ ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo ebafaehb ygeh} oqb ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`hbnùihba f}}e~y fbi ieyebyhobqhygouy fbx deie}f`


12/35

9

ote}~hagy" ênobi, yge ~yfyuye ~u{{`fby~ yge EwenuyhteM}fbng~ ieèafyei ih~n}eyhob ote} yge filhbh~y}fyhob odyge }elotf` {}one~~ fbi hbye}de}e~ qhyg yge fnghetelebyod yge deie}f` {}ho}hyhe~ ygfy Noba}e~~ gf~ ~ey" Menfu~e^"M" 6;1; nobhny~ qhyg Noba}e~~~ bfyhobf` }elotf` {o`hnx,yge Nou}y od F{{ef`~ {}o{e}`x geì ygfy F}hsobf~ ~yfyuyeh~ {}eel{yei"

F]AULEBY

H" DEIE]F@ @FQ []EEL[Y^ UBH@FYE]F@

^YFYE EDDO]Y^ YO F[[]EGEBI FBI

]ELOTE UBIONULEBYEI HLLHA]FBY^"

Yge Nob~yhyuyhob fuygo}hse~ Noba}e~~ yo e~yfm`h~g fbubhdo}l ]uè od Bfyu}f`hsfyhob" U"^" Nob~y" f}y" 6, 7,n`" 9 'el{gf~h~ fiiei(" ]elotf`f~ fb ewe}nh~e od yge~ote}ehab~ {oqe} yo ieye}lhbe yge nobihyhob~ u{ob qghngfb f`heb lfx }e~hie hb ygh~ nouby}x, Y}o{ t" Iu`è~, >54U"^" 74, 87 '6857( 'Qf}}eb, N"C", {ù}f`hyx o{hbhob(h~ f

n}unhf` eèleby od ygfy nob~yhyuyhobf` fuygo}hyx"

]elotf`~ hbge}eby`x bfyhobf` ngf}fnye} ewyebi~ yoebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`, ~ung f~ f}}e~yfbi ieyebyhob" ung ebdo}neleby hbethyfm`x yf}aey~ do}ehabbfyhobf`~, qgo~e y}efyleby qhyghb ygh~ nouby}x h~ Zo\beod yge lo~y hl{o}yfby fbi ie`hnfye od f`` hbye}bfyhobf`}e`fyhob~gh{~, Ghbe~ t" Ifthioqhys, >6= U"^" 5=, 49'6896(fbi {f}yhnu`f}`x ~o qgeb yge i}f~yhn lef~u}eod }elotf` h~ fy ~yfje,Doba Gfq Yfb t" [ge`fb, >>> U"^"4, 6; '6897(" êe U"^" M}" ==" F {fyngqo}j od ~e{f}fye

}elotf` {o`hnhe~ qouì ubie}lhbe yge Bfyhob~ beei yo~{efj qhyg obe tohne hb hllha}fyhob lfyye}~"Sfitxif~t" Ifth~, 5>> U"^" 417, 1;; '=;;6(" Hb }enoabhyhob od yge


13/35

5

hl{o}yfbne od f bfyhobqhie }elotf` {o`hnx, Noba}e~~gf~ ~ey bfyhobf` {}ho}hyhe~ ote} hllha}fyhob ebdo}nelebyfbi te~yei deie}f` oddhnhf`~ fòbe qhyg ih~n}eyhobf}xfuygo}hyx ote} ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`,hbnùihba ote}~hagy od bobdeie}f` odstne}~ ebafahba hb~ung ebdo}neleby"

Muy {}eel{yhob od ubh`fye}f` eddo}y~ yo e~yfm`h~g~hbaè~yfye }elotf` ~ngele~ qh`` boy {}eteby yge yfye~

d}ol yfjhba oyge} lef~u}e~ yo fii}e~~ yge hl{fny odubionulebyei hllha}fby~" F {}eel{yhob }uè mf~ei obyge ewnù~hte deie}f` bfyu}e od }elotf`, fbi Noba}e~~~ieèafyhob od ebdo}neleby fbi }elotf` {oqe}~ yo deie}fòdstnhf`~, ioe~ boy `hlhy yge ^yfye~ fmh`hyx yo oyge}qh~ef{{`x ygeh} `fq~ yo ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ qhyghbygeh} mo}ie}~" êe IeNfbf~, 9=9 U"^" fy >55" F~ ygh~Nou}y gf~ }enoabhsei, fb hllha}fby~ ub`fqdu` eby}xhbyo yge Ubhyei ^yfye~ fbi yge dfny ygfy yge hllha}fbylfx do} ygfy }ef~ob me ew{e`èi " " " nfbboy beafye yge~hl{è dfny od gh~ {}e~ebne qhyghb Zf\ ^yfye~ ye}}hyo}hf`

{e}hleye}"[`xè} t" Ioe, 951 U"^" =;=, =65 '687=(" Ahteb~ung {}e~ebne, ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ f}e ~umcenyyo yge du`` }fbae od om`hafyhob~ hl{o~ei mx yge yfye~ nhth`fbi n}hlhbf` `fq~"Hi"

Ygu~, yfye~ f}e boy mf}}ei d}ol ebdo}nhba aebe}f``xf{{`hnfmè `fq~~ung f~ ygo~e }eau`fyhba nhth` }hagy~,nob~ule} {}oyenyhob, o} qo}j{`fne ~fdeyx do} f`` {e}~ob~hb yge ^yfyeeteb hd iohba ~o lfx gfte ~ole hbnhiebyfèddeny~ ob hllha}fyhob"êe, e"a",Mf`muebf t" HI] ]ef`yx

@@N, 4 B"X">i >>7, >5758 '=;;4( 'f{{`xhba Beq Xo}j

`fmo} `fq~ evuf``x(: Nf`" ^yfy~" =;;=, ng" 6;16 '^"M" 6767('f{{`xhba tf}hou~ {}oth~hob~ od Nf`hdo}bhf `fq evuf``x("Bo} qouì {}eel{yhob do}mhi yge ^yfye~ d}ol fii}e~~hba


14/35

4

e~~ebyhf``x ònf` {}omèl~, ~ung f~ yge }eau`fyhob od`hneb~ei ebyhyhe~ o} yge me~y qfx yo u~e ~yfye dubi~" IeNfbf~, 9=9 U"^" fy >51: ~ee, e"a", Nf`" Ubel{" Hb~" Noie 6=49 '}e~y}hnyhba ubel{òxleby mebesty~(" Fm~eby fbew{}e~~ noba}e~~hobf` ~yfyeleby yo yge noby}f}x, o} fbhbie{ebieby nob~yhyuyhobf` mf} ob yge ~yfye `fq fy h~~ue,^yfye~ }elfhb m}ofi`x d}ee yo {f~~ `fq~ fii}e~~hba ygehl{fny od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~qgeyge} ygeh} aof`h~ yo f~~h~y hllha}fby~ o} yo lhbhlhse yge eddeny ygfy ~ung

hllha}fby~ lfx gfte"

Fnno}ihba`x, deie}f` hllha}fyhob `fq ob`x bf}}oq`x{}eel{y~ yge ^yfye~ oyge}qh~e {èbf}x fuygo}hyx yo}eau`fye f~ ygex ~ee sty qhyghb ygeh} mo}ie}~" F}hsobf~ub{}eneiebyei hllha}fyhob ~yfyuye df``~ qhyghb ygh~bf}}oq mfbi od {}eel{yhob mx fyyel{yhba yo ebdo}ne

deie}f` }uè~ hb fhi od }elotf`, [ey" M}" => 'el{gf~h~fiiei(, hb nobhny qhyg Noba}e~~~ ~{enhstn {}oth~hob~ do}deie}f`~yfye noo{e}fyhob ob ygh~ te}x h~~ue"

F" Deie}f` `fq }evuh}e~ deie}f` ote}~hagy od~yfye noo{e}fyhob qhyg deie}f` fuygo}hyhe~ hb

nobbenyhob qhyg yge }elotf` od ubionulebyei

hllha}fby~"

Hb ygh~ nf~e, yge Nou}y od F{{ef`~ no}}eny`x doubi ygfydeie}f` `fq {}eel{y~ F}hsobf~ ubh`fye}f` eddo}y yo ebfnyf ~e{f}fye ~yfye }elotf` ~ngele ouy~hie yge ~u{e}th~hobod yge deie}f` aote}bleby" Noba}e~~ gf~ {e}lhyyei ygeew{u`~hob od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ d}ol ygh~ nouby}xob`x yg}ouag deie}f` }elotf` {}oneeihba~, qghng f}e yge

~oè fbi ewnù~hte {}oneiu}e do} ieye}lhbhba qgeyge} fbf`heb lfx me " " " }elotei d}ol yge Ubhyei yfye~" 7 U"^"N" 6==8f'f('>( 'el{gf~h~ fiiei(" Deie}f` `fq ieèafye~ih~n}eyhobf}x fuygo}hyx yo Ewenuyhte M}fbng odstnhf`~ fòbeyo lfje ienh~hob~ fmouy }elotfmh`hyx"êe 7 U"^"N" 66;>'f(,


15/35

1

'a(:]ebo t" Fle}hnfbF}fm FbyhIh~n}hlhbfyhob Noll",5=5 U"^" 916, 97971 '6888(: ~ee f`~o U"^" M}" 67=6" Fbihb fhi od ygfy }elotf` fuygo}hyx, Noba}e~~ gf~ {}othieiauhie`hbe~ do} ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ ih}enyei fy ygeu`yhlfye }eleix od }elotf`, hbnùihba yge hiebyhstnfyhob,f{{}egeb~hob, fbi ieyebyhob od ~u~{enyei ubionulebyeihllha}fby~"êe, e"a", 7 U"^"N" 6>51'f('d( '~{enhdxhba{oqe}~ od deie}f` hllha}fyhob odstne}~ fbi el{òxee~(: 7N"D"]" =>4"6 ey ~ev" '}eau`fyhob~ hl{èlebyhba ~yfyuyo}x

{}e~n}h{yhob~("

Noba}e~~ nouì gfte ieèafyei yo yge ^yfye~, f~ hy ihiyo yge Ewenuyhte M}fbng, yge ~fle m}ofi ebdo}nelebyfuygo}hyx yo f}}e~y fbi ieyfhb ubionulebyei hllha}fby~do} {u}{o~e~ od }elotf`" Muy Noba}e~~ ien`hbei yo fio{yygfy loie`" Hb~yefi, deie}f` `fq fuygo}hse~ ^yfye~ yoebdo}ne deie}f` hllha}fyhob `fq hb fhi od }elotf` ob`x hbne}yfhb `hlhyei nh}nul~yfbne~, qhyg ote}~hagymx deie}f`fuygo}hyhe~"

Ygu~, deie}f` `fq fuygo}hse~ ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~yo noo{e}fye qhyg yge Ie{f}yleby od Gole`fbi enu}hyx'IG^( yo f}}e~y fbi ieyfhb ubionulebyei hllha}fby~qgo {}ethou~`x èdy yge nouby}x fdye} f deòbx nobthnyhobdo} yge {u}{o~e od y}fb~de}}hba ~ung hllha}fby~ yo deie}f`nu~yoix" êe 7 U"^"N" 6=5=n 'Zf\uygo}hshba ^yfye fbiònf` `fq ebdo}neleby odstnhf`~ yo f}}e~y fbi ieyfhb ne}yfhbh`èaf` f`heb~( 'el{gf~h~ fiiei(" hlh`f}`x, ~yfye fbi onfòdstne}~ qgo gfte f}}e~yei f i}ua oddebie} lfx }evue~yygfy f deie}f` oddhnhf` h~~ue fb hllha}fyhob ieyfhbe}hd ygex lfje yge }evue~y ew{eihyhou~`x fbi yge}e h~

}ef~ob yo me`hete ygfy yge oddebie} h~ fb ubionulebyeihllha}fby" êehi" 6>51'i(" Fbi ouy~hie yge~e ~{enhstnn`f~~e~ od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, yge ên}eyf}xod IG^ lfx fuygo}hse ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo fny f~deie}f` hllha}fyhob odstne}~ hd yge en}eyf}x ieye}lhbe~


16/35

7

ygfy fb fnyuf` o} hllhbeby lf~~ hbuw od f`heb~ bef} ygeUbhyei yfye~ {}e~eby~ u}aeby nh}nul~yfbne~ }evuh}hbafb hlleihfye Deie}f` }e~{ob~e"Hi" 66;>'f('6;("

Lo}e aebe}f``x, yge ên}eyf}x lfx ie~habfye~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo ebafae hb yge hbte~yhafyhob,f{{}egeb~hob, o} ieyebyhob od f`heb~ hb yge Ubhyei ^yfye~hb fhi od }elotf`, ubie} f q}hyyeb fa}eeleby meyqeeb ygeên}eyf}x fbi yge yfye o} {o`hyhnf` ~umihth~hob fy h~~ue"Hi"

6>51'a('6(" Muy fbx fuygo}hsfyhob od yge~e hllha}fyhobebdo}neleby dubnyhob~ ubie} 6>51'a( h~ ~umceny yo ~y}hny}evuh}eleby~ ygfy eb~u}e nobyhbuhba deie}f` ote}~hagyod ~ung bobdeie}f` odstne}~" Yge fa}eeleby lu~y }evuh}eodstne}~ yo gfte jboqèiae od fbi fige}e yo deie}f` `fq:fbi hb {e}do}lhba fbx dubnyhob ubie} yge noo{e}fyhobfa}eeleby, odstne}~ f}e ~umceny yo yge ih}enyhob fbi~u{e}th~hob od yge Zên}eyf}x\"Hi" 6>51'a('6('>(" ^yfyeo} ònf` oddhne}~ fnyhba ubie} noò} od fuygo}hyx od 6>51'a( f}e ieelei yo me deie}f` odstne}~ do} {u}{o~e~od qo}je}~ nol{eb~fyhob fbi nhth` `hfmh`hyxf }eenyhob od

Noba}e~~~ cuialeby ygfy ~ung odstne}~ f}e {e}do}lhba fdeie}f` dubnyhob qgeb ygex hiebyhdx, f{{}egebi, o} ieyfhbubionulebyei hllha}fby~ do} {u}{o~e~ od }elotf`"êehi" 6>51'a('1('7(" Fbi hd f yfye ~eej~ yo fhi yge Ubhyei^yfye~ hb {e}do}lhba ygh~ dubnyhob qhygouy fb fa}eeleby,hy lu~y ~yh`` io ~o mx noo{e}fyZhba\ qhyg yge Zên}eyf}x\,hi" 6>51'a('6;('M(, fbi boy mx ebdo}nhba f nol{eyhba{o`hnx"

M" Deie}f` `fq lfbifye~ yge e~yfm`h~gleby

fbi hl{èlebyfyhob od deie}f` ebdo}neleby

{}ho}hyhe~ nobne}bhba yge }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~"

Noba}e~~~ ngohne yo {}e~e}te deie}f` {}hlfnx ote}moyg }elotf` {}oneeihba~ fbi yge f}}e~y fbi ieyebyhobod hbihthiuf`~ do} {u}{o~e~ od }elotf` lfje~ ~eb~e hb


17/35

8

`hagy od yge hbge}eby`x ~ote}ehab bfyu}e od yge }elotf`{oqe}"êe~u{}f fy 95" Muy deie}f` ote}~hagy f`~o }eeny~m}ofie} gulfbhyf}hfb fbi nhth`}hagy~ nobne}b~" Deie}f``fq gf~ òba }enoabhsei ygfy yge hl{fny od }elotf` fbi}e`fyei ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ h~ ubhvue`x m}ofi fbiietf~yfyhba" ]eenyhba yge~e nobne}b~, Noba}e~~ gf~ ~eyebdo}neleby {}ho}hyhe~ ygfy yf}aey {f}yhnu`f}`x ifbae}ou~n`f~~e~ od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, fbi ieèafyei yoyge Ewenuyhte M}fbng yge ih~n}eyhob yo ieye}lhbe goq

me~y yo hl{èleby fbi ewe}nh~e yge deie}f` aote}bleby~}elotf` {oqe}"

Yge}e f}e nu}}eby`x lh``hob~ od ubionulebyeihllha}fby~ `hthba hb yge Ubhyei ^yfye~" êe [f~~e` $Nogb, ~u{}f, fy 6" Yge f{{}egeb~hob, ieyebyhob, fbi}elotf` od yge~e hllha}fby~ bene~~f}h`x hl{`hnfye~ yge}hagy~, hme}yhe~, fbi {e}~obf` d}eeiol~ od gulfb mehba~"

Ghbe~, >6= U"^" fy 47" Lo~y od yge~e ubionulebyeihllha}fby~ f}e oyge}qh~e `fqfmhihba, du``x noby}hmuyhbalelme}~ od ~onheyx"êe [`xè}, 951 U"^" fy ==7" Hbieei,

ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ f}e odyeb iee{`x elmeiieihb ygeh} nollubhyhe~3 ygex qo}j fbi {fx yfwe~ 'hbnùihbanoby}hmuyhob~ yo ônhf` ênu}hyx fbi Leihnf}e(: ygexe~yfm`h~g dflh`he~ fbi }fh~e nghì}eb: fbi, qgfyete} ygeh}nu}}eby ~yfyu~, lfbx qh`` }elfhb Zhb yge Ubhyei ^yfye~\{e}lfbeby`x fbi " " " ~ole hbieye}lhbfye bulme} qh`ètebyuf``x menole nhyhseb~" Hi" fy === b"=;" Menfu~e odyge ie{yg od yge~e yhe~, ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od}elotf` gfte ubhvue`x m}ofi eddeny~, ih~}u{yhba dflh`he~,nollubhyhe~, fbi oyge} enobolhn fbi ~onhf` }e`fyhob~gh{~"

Ote}sefòu~ fbi hbih~n}hlhbfye fyyel{y~ yo hiebyhdxfbi }elote ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ f`~o {o~e lfbx}h~j~ do} nhth`}hagy~ tho`fyhob~f }h~j ygfy ~{h``~ ote} yoèaf` }e~hieby~" Menfu~e yge Ubhyei ^yfye~ h~ f ihte}~e,lu`yheygbhn bfyhob, yge}e h~ odyeb bo ef~h`x te}hstfmè qfx


18/35

6;

yo ih~yhbauh~g meyqeeb fb ubionulebyei hllha}fbyfbi f {e}~ob qhyg èaf` {e}lh~~hob yo me hb ygh~ nouby}x,hbnùihba du`` nhyhseb~" Ebdo}neleby lef~u}e~ yf}aeyei fy}elotfmè hllha}fby~~ung f~ ionulebyfyhob ngenj~o} oyge} hbte~yhafyo}x lef~u}e~yge}edo}e yg}efyebyo ~qee{ hb lfbx èaf` hllha}fby~ fbi U"^" nhyhseb~qgo ~hl{`x ~gf}e yge ~fle }fne, eygbhnhyx, o} nu`yu}f`lf}je}~ f~ ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ nollob yo f{f}yhnu`f} f}ef"êe [ey" F{{" 695f: ~ee f`~o Ubhyei yfye~

t" M}habobh[obne, 9== U"^" 71>, 774 '6815("

Deie}f` fq gf~ oba }eenyei yge~e nobne}b~ fmouy ygeno``fye}f` gf}l~ ygfy qouì do`òq d}ol hbih~n}hlhbfye`x{`fnhba ewne~~hte mu}ieb~ ob ubionulebyei hllha}fby~"Ygu~, do} ewfl{è, Noba}e~~ gf~ bete} n}hlhbf`hseile}e ub`fqdu` {}e~ebne hb ygh~ nouby}x, fm~eby ~oleoyge} faa}ftfyhba dfnyo}"êe Lhngfe` Cogb Af}nhf, Noba"]e~ef}ng ê}t", N}hlhbf`hshba Ub`fqdu` [}e~ebne3

êènyei H~~ue~ = 'Lfx >, =;;4("= Bo} h~ hy f deie}f` n}hledo} fb ubionulebyei hllha}fby yo ~eej qo}j hb yge

Ubhyei ^yfye~" êe U"^" M}" 9" Hb~yefi, Noba}e~~ gf~}e{efyei`x }ecenyei yge~e {ebf`yhe~ f~ hbgulfbe fbihbnob~h~yeby qhyg ygh~ bfyhob~ y}fihyhob fbi gh~yo}x"êe,e"a", [ey" F{{" >>f>5f: G"]" ]e{" Bo" 8847=, {y" 6, fy 94'6874( 'Z@\eah~`fyhob nobyfhbhba el{òxe} ~fbnyhob~ h~ ygelo~y gulfbe, n}eihmè fbi eddenyhte qfx yo }e~{obi yo yge`f}ae~nfè hbuw od ubionulebyei f`heb~"("

Yge~e ~fle nobne}b~ fmouy yge gf}ldu` eddeny~od ote}sefòu~ fbi hbih~n}hlhbfye ebdo}neleby f`~oielob~y}fye qgx Noba}e~~ qouì gfte ieèafyei

ih~n}eyhobf}x }elotf` fuygo}hyx yo deie}f` odstnhf`~ fbi

=" gyy{3//y}fn"~x}"eiu/hllha}fyhob/`hm}f}x/[575"{id"


19/35

66

~umcenyei }elotf` ebdo}neleby eddo}y~ yo lfbifyo}xdeie}f` ote}~hagy" Ih~n}eyhob f`òq~ yge Ewenuyhte M}fbngyo ~ey {}ho}hyhe~ fbi {o`hnhe~ ygfy ~y}hje f {}o{e} mf`fbnemeyqeeb yge gf}~g eddeny~ od hllha}fyhob ebdo}nelebyfbi yge ~ote}ehab hbye}e~y hb }elothba ubionulebyeihllha}fby~" Nd" Genjè} t" Ngfbex, 91; U"^" 7=6, 7>6>='6875( 'ih~n}eyhob {e}lhy~ faebnx yo ief` qhyg yge lfbxtf}hfmè~ hbto`tei hb yge {}o{e} o}ie}hba od hy~ {}ho}hyhe~("Fbi ote}~hagy eb~u}e~ ygfy moyg deie}f` fbi bobdeie}f`

ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf` fitfbneo} fyèf~y io boy nobhny qhygyge~e bfyhobf` {}ho}hyhe~ fbi{o`hnhe~"

Ewenuyhte M}fbng odstnhf`~ gfte y}fihyhobf``x meebieèafyei m}ofi ih~n}eyhob yo a}fby }e`hed d}ol }elotfòb f bulme} od a}oubi~, hbnùihba {o`hyhnf` f~xùl fbifmu~eithnyhl ~yfyu~" ee aebe}f``x U"^" M}" 68==: hbd}f fy=>=9 $ b"69" Noba}e~~ f`~o a}fbyei yge Fyyo}bex Aebe}f`fuygo}hyx yo nfbne` }elotf` do} {f}yhnu`f} nfyeao}he~ odubionulebyei hllha}fby~" êe, e"a", 7 U"^"N" 6==8m:

[fih``f t" Jebyunjx, 6>; ^" Ny" 691>, 69187; '=;6;('~yfyuye {}e~e}te~ òba y}fihyhob od ewenuyhte ih~n}eyhobhb hl{èlebyhba deie}f` }elotf` {oqe}("

@hjeqh~e, Noba}e~~ gf~ ih}enyei IG^ boy yo y}efyf`` ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ f~ evuhtfèby do} }elotf`{u}{o~e~, muy hb~yefi yo {}ho}hyhse yge hiebyhstnfyhobfbi }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ nobthnyeiod ~e}hou~ n}hle~" Ie{f}yleby od Gole`fbi ênu}hyx F{{}o{}hfyhob~ Fny od =;6;, [um" @" Bo" 6667>, yhy" HH,6=> ^yfy" =69=, =698 '=;;8(" Ygh~ ih}enyhte }evuh}e~ yge

Ie{f}yleby yo donu~ hy~ ebdo}neleby fbi }elotf` eddo}y~ob f`heb~ qgo {o~e f ifbae} yo bfyhobf` ~enu}hyx o} f}h~j yo {um`hn ~fdeyx" C"F" 6;7: ~ee Lelo}fbiul d}ol


20/35

6=

Cogb Lo}yob, Ih}enyo} od Hllha}fyhob fbi Nu~yol~Ebdo}neleby, Nhth` Hllha}fyhob Ebdo}neleby3 [}ho}hyhe~

do} yge F{{}egeb~hob, Ieyebyhob, fbi ]elotf` od F`heb~6 'Lf}" =, =;66("> Fbi hb o}ie} yo hl{èleby Noba}e~~~{}ho}hyhe~, Hllha}fyhob fbi Nu~yol~ Ebdo}neleby gf~fio{yei fb odstnhf` {o`hnx ih}enyhba yge ewe}nh~e od }e~y}fhbydo} oyge} {o{u`fyhob~ od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ qhygbo gh~yo}x od n}hlhbf` nobiuny, o} do} qgol }elotf` qouìewfny oyge} ~onhf` o} gulfbhyf}hfb no~y~do} ewfl{è,

U"^" lh`hyf}x teye}fb~, thnyhl~ od ~e}hou~ n}hle~, eìe}`xo} cutebhè hllha}fby~, qhybe~~e~ hb {ebihba n}hlhbf`hbte~yhafyhob~ o} {}o~enuyhob~, fbi hbihthiuf`~ ebafaeihb {}oyenyei nhth`}hagy~ fnyhthyhe~" êe Lelo}fbiuld}ol Cogb Lo}yob,Ewe}nh~hba [}o~enuyo}hf` Ih~n}eyhobNob~h~yeby qhyg yge Nhth` Hllha}fyhob Ebdo}neleby

[}ho}hyhe~ od yge Faebnx do} yge F{{}egeb~hob, Ieyebyhob,fbi ]elotf` od F`heb~ 5 'Cube 61, =;66(:9 Lelo}fbiuld}ol Cogb Lo}yob, [}o~enuyo}hf` Ih~n}eyhob3 Ne}yfhbThnyhl~, Qhybe~~e~, fbi [`fhbyhdd~ = 'Cube 61, =;66("5

Qhygouy deie}f` ote}~hagy od ~yfye ebdo}neleby eddo}y~hb fhi od yge }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, yge}eqouì me bo qfx do} yge deie}f` aote}bleby yo fitfbne fubhdo}l fbi noge}eby ebdo}neleby {o`hnx 'hbnùihba yge~eyyhba od bfyhobf` {}ho}hyhe~( qhyg }e~{eny yo yge gf}~glef~u}e od }elotf`"HB^ t" Nf}iosfDob~enf, 97; U"^"9=6, 998 '6871(" Menfu~e yge hbye}e~y~ f}e ~eb~hyhte, fbi

>" gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/ion`hm/beq~/}eèf~e~/=;66/66;>;=qf~ghbayobin"{id"

9" gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/ion`hm/~enu}enollubhyhe~/{id/

{}o~enuyo}hfìh~n}eyhoblelo"{id"

5" gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/ion`hm/~enu}enollubhyhe~/{id/iole~yhnthoèbne"{id"


21/35

6>

yge mf`fbnhba od ebdo}neleby no~y~ fbi }h~j~ ie`hnfye,Noba}e~~ }ef~obfm`x neby}f`hsei yge ebdo}neleby {oqe}hb yge deie}f` aote}blebyyge ob`x qfx ygfy hy nouìeb~u}e ygfy deie}f` {}ho}hyhe~ fbi bfyhobf` hbye}e~y~ hb}elotf` qouì me ~e}tei"

^yfye~ f}e boy {}enùiei d}ol noo{e}fyhba hb eddo}y~ yo}elote ubionulebyei hllha}fby~" Muy Noba}e~~ {}othieido} ~yfye noo{e}fyhob ubie} iedhbei nh}nul~yfbne~3

yo f}}e~y fbi ieyfhb ne}yfhb n`f~~e~ od ubionulebyeihllha}fby~, qgo Noba}e~~ hy~e`d ieye}lhbei ~gouì mefb ebdo}neleby {}ho}hyx: o} ubie} yge ~u{e}th~hob fbiih}enyhob od deie}f` oddhnhf`~, auf}fbyeehba noge}ebyebdo}neleby od deie}f` }elotf` {oqe} hb `hagy od deie}fòmcenyhte~ fbi {}ho}hyhe~"

HH" F]HSOBF^ ^"M" 6;1; H^ []EEL[YEI

MENFUÊ HY NOBD@HNY^ QHYG NOBA]E^^^

IE@EAFYHOB OD EBDO]NELEBY OTE]^HAGY

FBI EBDO]NELEBY []HO]HYHE^ YO

DEIE]F@ ODDHNHF@^"

F}hsobf~ hllha}fyhob ~yfyuye, ^"M" 6;1;, nobhny~qhyg yge deie}f` aote}bleby~ ewnù~hte noby}o` od }elotf`hb yqo dubiflebyf` qfx~" ^"M" 6;1; }evuh}e~ F}hsobfodstne}~ yo ebdo}ne deie}f` hllha}fyhob fq qhygouy deie}fòte}~hagy" Lo}eote}, mx e`hlhbfyhba deie}f` ote}~hagy,^"M" 6;1; hl{e}lh~~hm`x e~yfm`h~ge~ f ubh`fye}f` {o`hnxod fyy}hyhob yg}ouag ebdo}neleby, ^"M" 6;1;, 6ygeyx{e od ~eb~hyhte {o`hnx ngohne ygfy Noba}e~~ nollhyyeiyo deie}f` odstnhf`~ fòbe"


22/35

69

F" ^"M" 6;1;~ ubh`fye}f` hllha}fyhob {o`hnx

nobd`hny~ qhyg yge }evuh}eleby od deie}f`

ote}~hagy hb noo{e}fyhte deie}f`~yfye

hllha}fyhob ebdo}neleby"

F~ ew{`fhbei fmote, Noba}e~~ {}othiei lu`yh{èftebue~ do} ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo noo{e}fye qhyg ygedeie}f` aote}bleby hb ebdo}nhba deie}f` }elotf` {o`hnx"

êe ~u{}f fy 17" Muy noo{e}fyhba yg}ouag yge lefb~

Noba}e~~ ~{enhstei qouì ~umceny F}hsobf odstne}~ yo ygeote}~hagy od deie}f` odstnhf`~ qgebete} ygex ebafaei hbebdo}neleby hb fhi od }elotf`f }e~u`y ygfy Noba}e~~hbyebiei, muy ygfy F}hsobf ~eej~ yo ftohi"

Habo}hba yge oyge} {}oth~hob~ od 7 U"^"N" 6>51'a(,F}hsobf f}aue~ ygfy ^"M" 6;1;~ {}oth~hob~ do} ~yfye fbiònf` odstne}~ hbie{ebieby ebdo}neleby f}e fuygo}hseimx 6>51'a('6;('M("êe [ey" M}" >=" ênyhob 6>51'a('6;('M({e}lhy~ ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo noo{e}fye qhyg ygeZên}eyf}x\ hb yge hiebyhstnfyhob, f{{}egeb~hob, ieyebyhob,

o} }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, eteb qhygouy fdo}lf` q}hyyeb fa}eeleby" Muy, f~ yge yewy od yge ~yfyuyelfje~ nèf}, ygfy {}oth~hob ioe~ boy ewel{y ~ung odstne}~d}ol yge dubiflebyf` }evuh}eleby odnoo{e}fyhob, qghngebyfh`~ nol{`hfbne qhyg yge ên}eyf}x~ ~yfyei {}ho}hyhe~fbi }evuh}eleby~ qgeb ~yfye fbi onf` odstne}~ ebafae hbebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`"

Hd F}hsobf qe}e no}}eny ygfy 6>51'a('6;('M({e}lhy~ ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ yo {u}~ue hbie{ebieby}elotf` {o`hnhe~ fafhb~y ubionulebyei hllha}fby~,

qhygouy }eaf}i yo deie}f` {}ho}hyhe~ fbi }evuh}eleby~,yge }e~u`yhba ~ngele qouì ubie}lhbe Noba}e~~~nf}edu` }e~e}tfyhob od deie}f` odstnhf`~ ote}~hagy od ygeZ{\e}do}lfbne od hllha}fyhob odstne} dubnyhob~ mx yfye


23/35

65

odstne}~ fbi el{òxee~" 7 U"^"N" 6>51'a(" Yge}e qouìme `hyyè {ohby hb nf}edu``x ie`hbefyhba yge ote}~hagylengfbh~l~ do} q}hyyeb noo{e}fyhte fa}eeleby~ hd ^yfye~nouì ~hl{`x mx{f~~ ote}~hagy mx ftohihba fb fa}eelebyebyh}e`x" Lo}eote}, F}hsobf~ }efihba od 6>51'a('6;('M( qouì {f}fiowhnf``x ahte ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ lo}e{oqe}yo {u}~ue ~u~{enyei deie}f` hllha}fyhob tho`fyhob~ygfb deie}f` fq hy~e`d a}fby~ yo ob`x ~ole ~{enhf``x y}fhbeiodstne}~"êe 7 N"D"]" =71"5'n( 'hiebyhdxhba aote}bleby

oddhnhf`~ ygfy nfb f}}e~y fbi ieyfhb ubionulebyeihllha}fby~(: hi" =71"7'n('=('hh( '`hlhyhba fuygo}hyx do} qf}}fbyè~~ f}}e~y~(: hi " =>4"6'm( '{}othihba oyge}`hlhyfyhob~ ob f}}e~y("

Yge}e h~ bo hbihnfyhob hb yge ~yfyuyo}x yewy o}èah~`fyhte gh~yo}x ygfy Noba}e~~ hbyebiei ~ung {e}te}~e}e~u`y~" Mx }enoabhshba ygfy ~yfye fbi ònf` odstne}~ nfbnoo{e}fye qhyg yge ên}eyf}x eteb qhygouy f do}lf`q}hyyeb fa}eeleby, Noba}e~~ ihi boy e`hlhbfye 6>51'a(~}evuh}eleby od noo{e}fyhob o} yge deie}f` ote}~hagy ygfy

~ung noo{e}fyhob ebyfh`~"

Yge noo{e}fyhte ~ngele ebfnyei mx Noba}e~~ h~ flefbhbadu`, ftfh`fmè lengfbh~l do} ^yfye~ yo f~~h~y hbyge ebdo}neleby od deie}f` hllha}fyhob `fqeteb qhyg}e~{eny yo yge dubnyhob~ fy yge no}e od yge deie}f` }elotf`{}one~~ 'h"e", hiebyhdxhba fbi f{{}egebihba ubionulebyeihllha}fby~(" U"^" Hllha}fyhob fbi Nu~yol~ Ebdo}nelebynu}}eby`x gf~ do}lf` }e`fyhob~gh{~ qhyg ~hwyxehagy `fqebdo}neleby faebnhe~ hb yqebyxdou} ~yfye~ 'hbnùihbayqo ~yfye faebnhe~ fbi ~hw onf` fq ebdo}neleby odstne~ hb

F}hsobf( {u}~ufby yo ew{}e~~ 6>51'a( fa}eeleby~ ygfyfuygo}hse ~yfye fbi onf` odstne}~ yo f{{}egebi fbi ieyfhbubionulebyei hllha}fby~ do} {u}{o~e~ od }elotf`"êe


24/35

64

U"^" Hllha}fyhob fbi Nu~yol~ Ebdo}neleby,Dfny ^geey3 Ieèafyhob od Hllha}fyhob Fuygo}hyx ênyhob =71'a( Hllha}fyhob fbi Bfyhobf`hyx Fny"4 Yge~e noo{e}fyhteeddo}y~, ub`hje yge f`ye}bfye ~ngele ^"M" 6;1; ~ey~ u{,}eyfhb yge dubiflebyf` defyu}e od deie}f` ote}~hagy, ygu~{}e~e}thba yge fmh`hyx od deie}f` odstnhf`~ yo {}ho}hyhseebdo}neleby eddo}y~ fbi yo hl{èleby ~fdeauf}i~ do}yge f}}e~y fbi ieyebyhob od ~u~{enyei ubionulebyeihllha}fby~" êe ^yfyeleby od ]hngf}i L" ^yfbf, U"^"

Aoty Fnnoubyfmh`hyx Odstne, Hllha}fyhob Ebdo}neleby3Noby}o`~ ote} [}oa}fl Fuygo}hshba ^yfye fbi @onf`

Ebdo}neleby od Deie}f` Hllha}fyhob @fq~ ^gouì Me^y}ebaygebei =>, 17 '=;;8( 'ye~yhlobx medo}e Gou~eNoll" ob Gole`fbi ênu}hyx( '}enollebihba ngfbae~yo deie}f` ~u{e}th~hob yo {}ho}hyhse ifbae}ou~ n}hlhbf`~,}fyge} ygfb òqète` oddebie}~, fbi yo ftohi }fnhf`{}ost`hba("1 @hje f`` oyge} ^yfye~, F}hsobf nfb ngoo~eyo noo{e}fye o} boy noo{e}fye qhyg deie}f` ebdo}nelebyeddo}y~"7 Muy, goqete} lung F}hsobf lfx ih~fa}ee qhygdeie}f` }elotf` {}ho}hyhe~, hy nfbboy o{e}fye hy~ oqb

ubh`fye}f` }elotf` {o`hnx ouy~hie od fbx deie}f` ote}~hagy"

4" gyy{3//qqq"hne"aot/beq~/`hm}f}x/dfny~geey~/=71a"gyl '`f~yth~hyei Lf}" =>, =;6=("

1" gyy{3//qqq"afo"aot/beq"hyel~/i;8>76y"{id"

7" Yge deie}f` aote}bleby nfbboy, od nou}~e, nol{e` yge^yfye~ o} ygeh} odstne}~ yo fhi hb yge ebdo}neleby od deie}f` `fq"êe [}hbys t" Ubhyei ^yfye~, 5=6 U"^" 787,8>5 '6881(:Beq Xo}j

t" Ubhyei ^yfye~, 5;5 U"^" 699, 698 '688=("


25/35

61

M" ^"M" 6;1; ebfny~ f ~e{f}fye ~yfye }elotf`

~ngele ygfy nobd`hny~ qhyg Noba}e~~~ oqb

{}ho}hyhe~ fbi qhyg hy~ ieèafyhob od ebdo}neleby

ih~n}eyhob yo deie}f` fuygo}hyhe~"

F}hsobf ebfnyei ^"M" 6;1; yo ~u{{`fby, hb F}hsobf,Noba}e~~~ hllha}fyhob {o`hnhe~ fbi yge EwenuyhteM}fbng~ ewe}nh~e od hy~ ieèafyei ih~n}eyhob yo yf}aey ygelo~y ifbae}ou~ {o{u`fyhob~ od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~

do} hbte~yhafyhob, ieyebyhob, fbi }elotf`" Hb iohba ~o,F}hsobf gf~ ubie}lhbei yge te}x }elotf` {}ho}hyhe~ ygfyNoba}e~~ hbyebiei yge Ewenuyhte M}fbng yo e~yfm`h~g fbido`òq"

F}hsobf ebfnyei ^"M" 6;1; ~{enhstnf``x hb }e~{ob~eyo yge deie}f` aote}bleby~ f~~e}yei Z`\fnj od eddenyhteebdo}neleby od yge ewh~yhba hllha}fyhob }uè~, qghngF}hsobf m`fle~ do} hy~ ~gouìe}Zhba\ f ih~{}o{o}yhobfyemu}ieb od yge bfyhobf` {}omèl od h`èaf` hllha}fyhob"[ey" M}" 6=" F}hsobf~ ~oùyhob yo yge deie}f` ewenuyhte~

`fw ebdo}neleby {o`hnx, hi" fy =4, qf~ f {f}f`è`~yfyelfbifyei }elotf` {}one~~" ênyhob 6 od ^"M"6;1; ew{}e~~`x ien`f}e~ ygfy yge aof` od yge ~yfyuye h~fyy}hyhob yg}ouag ebdo}neleby" Ygfy {g}f~e h~ f dflh`hf}obe hb fbyhhllha}fyhob nh}nè~" F~ F}hsobf~ ~yfyuyeew{`fhb~, yge {o`hnx od fyy}hyhob yg}ouag ebdo}neleby~eej~ yo ih~nou}fae fbi ieye} yge ub`fqdu` eby}x fbi{}e~ebne od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~, f~ qe`` f~ygeh} enobolhn fnyhthyx" ^"M" 6;1;, 6" Menfu~e yge^yfye~ gfte bo hbge}eby {oqe} yo }elote ubionulebyeihllha}fby~, ^"M" 6;1; fnnol{`h~ge~ hy~ fhl~ mx lfjhba

`hde ~o ihdstnu`y do} ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ hb F}hsobf


26/35

67

ygfy ygex qh`` ngoo~e yo èfte yge ^yfye"8 F~hie d}oln}efyhba f go~yhè ebth}obleby do} ubionulebyeihllha}fby~, fyy}hyhob yg}ouag ebdo}neleby f`~o fhl~yo hbye}}u{yZ\ fbi fy}o{gZx\ beyqo}j~ od }e`fyhte~,d}hebi~, fbi nouby}xleb qgo lfx ~u{{o}y fbi ebnou}faeubionulebyei hllha}fby~"6;

Yge {}oth~hob~ od "M" 6;1;hbnùihba yge dou} fy h~~uehb ygh~ nf~eqo}j yoaeyge} 'hi" 6( yo fnnol{`h~g yge~e

aof`~ mx hl{o~hba ih~yhbny, ubu~uf` fbi ewy}fo}ihbf}xmu}ieb~ fbi om`hafyhob~ u{ob f`heb~ hb o}ie} yo {}e~~u}eygel yo èfte F}hsobf"Ghbe~, >6= U"^" fy 45" ^"M" 6;1;~f}}e~y fbi ieyebyhob {}oth~hob~ênyhob~ ='M( fbi 4~umceny ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ yo hbih~n}hlhbfye fbi}e{efyei hbye}ne{yhob fbi hbye}}oafyhob mx {um`hn odstnhf`~,hi" fy 44, hbnùihba {}oòbaei ieyebyhob do} hllha}fyhob~yfyu~ ngenj~ fbi ew{fbiei fuygo}hyx do} qf}}fbyè~~f}}e~y~, ~ee [ey" F{{" 6=f b"1, 64=f" @hjeqh~e, yge {ebf`yx{}oth~hob~ od "M" 6;1;ênyhob~ > fbi 5'N(ie`hme}fye`xew{o~e ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ hb F}hsobf yo a}efye}

}h~j od n}hlhbf` `hfmh`hyx ygfb ygex qouì dfne hb oyge}^yfye~ o} d}ol yge deie}f` aote}bleby, mx n}hlhbf`hshbale}e ub`fqdu` {}e~ebne fbi fyyel{y~ yo ~eej o} {e}do}lqo}j" êe U"^" M}" >6, >9>7" Dhbf``x, fb ewy}fo}ihbf}x

8" êe Bulme}~U^F,Fyy}hyhob Yg}ouag Ebdo}neleby H~ ygeY}ue Lhiièa}oubi ôùyhob 'Yge aof` h~ yo lfje hy ewy}ele`xihdstnu`y do} ubfuygo}hsei {e}~ob~ yo ` hte fbi qo}j hb yge Ubhyei^yfye~"(, gyy{3//qqq"bulme}~u~f"nol/nobyeby/èf}b/h~~ue~/fle}hnfbqo}je}~/fyy}hyhobyg}ouagebdo}nelebyy}uelhii`"gyl`'`f~y th~hyei Lf}" =>, =;6=("

6;" Lf}j J}hjo}hfb, Nebye} do} Hllha}fyhob ^yuihe~,Ioqb~hshba H`èaf` Hllha}fyhob3 F y}fyeax od Fyy}hyhob Yg}ouagEbdo}neleby 9 'Lfx =;;5(, gyy{3//qqq"nh~"o}a/f}yhnè~/=;;5/mfnj4;5"{id"


27/35

68

{}oth~hobênyhob ='G(nol{e`~ onf` fbi ~yfye odstne}~fbi faebnhe~ yo ebdo}ne "M" 6;1; yo yge lfwhlul ewyeby{o~~hmè mx fuygo}hshba {}htfye nhyhseb~ yo ~eej {ebf`yhe~od u{ yo )5,;;; do} efng ifx ygfy yge {o`hnx od fyy}hyhobyg}ouag ebdo}neleby h~ boy lfwhlf``x {u}~uei"66

Yge lfbhde~y {u}{o~e fbi hbethyfmè eddeny od ^"M"6;1;~ {}oth~hob~, Qh~" Ie{y od Hbiu~y}x, @fmo} $ Gulfb

]e`fyhob~ t" Aouì Hbn", 915 U"^" =7=, =86 '6874(, yfjeb

f~ f qgoè, h~ yo ih~nou}fae fbi ieye} moyg yge eby}xfbi yge le}e {}e~ebne od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~,^"M" 6;1;, 6, èfihba yo yge fyy}hyhob '~e`die{o}yfyhob(od yge lfco}hyx od ygo~e ge}e h`èaf``x"6= Muy fyy}hyhobyg}ouag ebdo}neleby gf~ bete} meeb yge hllha}fyhob~y}fyeax od yge Ubhyei ^yfye~, f~ obe od yge {}hbnh{fì}fdye}~ od F}hsobf~ `fq gf~ filhyyei" J}h~ Q" Jomfng,

Fyy}hyhob Yg}ouag Ebdo}neleby3 F ]fyhobf` F{{}ofngyo H`èaf` Hllha}fyhob, 65 Yu`~f C" Nol{" $ Hby` @" 655,654 '=;;7(" Deie}f` `fq gf~ bete} yoè}fyei ~umcenyhbaf`` ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ yo m}ofi hbvuh~hyo}hf`

{}fnyhne~ fbi {o`hne ~u}teh``fbne: yo yge noby}f}x,Zo\{{o~hyhob yo `fq~ " " " ~hba`hba ouy f`heb~ hb ygfy qfxh~ iee{~efyei hb ygh~ nouby}x" Ghbe~, >6= U"^" fy 1;,19" ^hlh`f}`x, behyge} le}e ub`fqdu` {}e~ebne bo} qo}j

66" F`ygouag ênyhob ='G( h~ boy ih}eny`x fy h~~ue medo}e ygh~Nou}y, hy~ m}ofi lfbifye od lfwhlul ebdo}neleby bene~~f}h`xfddeny~ yge hl{èlebyfyhob od yge dou} {}oth~hob~ ygfy ygh~ Nou}yh~ nob~hie}hba"

6=" Deib do} Fl" Hllha}fyhob ]edo}l,Ebnou}faei ]ete}~e

Lha}fyhob3 F êb~hmè êteb^ye{ ^y}fyeax do} [}oloyhba ygeOuymoubi Dòq od H`èaf` Hllha}fyhob 6 '=;;4(, gyy{3//qqq"dfh}u~"o}a/~hye/Ionê}te}/}e~ef}ng_%=;mfnja}oubie}_lfx6;=;;4"{id?ionHI


28/35

=;

mx ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ gf~ ete} meeb f deie}f`n}hle"êe~u{}f fy 6;: U"^" M}" >6, >9>7: N}o~mx t" Bfy`

Do}ehab Y}fie Noubnh`, 5>; U"^" >4>, >17 '=;;;( 'ZYge\~yfyuye nobhny~ qhyg deie}f` `fq fy f bulme} od {ohby~mx {ebf`hshba hbihthiuf`~ fbi nobiuny ygfy Noba}e~~ gf~ew{`hnhy`x ewel{yei o} ewnùiei d}ol ~fbnyhob~"(" Xeyqhyg ^"M" 6;1; F}hsobf h~ hl{e}lh~~hm`x fyyel{yhba yongf}y hy~ oqb nou}~e hb yge hiebyhstnfyhob, f{{}egeb~hob,fbi ieyebyhob od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ do} {u}{o~e~

od ew{e``hba ygel d}ol yge ^yfye"

Mx ieèafyhba ebdo}neleby fuygo}hyx yo deie}fòdstnhf`~, hbnùihba yge fmh`hyx yo {}ho}hyhse yge n`f~~e~od {e}~ob~ yf}aeyei do} }elotf`, Noba}e~~ {}eel{yeiF}hsobf~ fyyel{y yo n}efye f ~e{f}fye fbi fiihyhobfèbdo}neleby lengfbh~louy~hie od fbi hbie{ebiebyod deie}f` ote}~hagyyo ~e}te F}hsobf~ oqb }elotfòmcenyhte~ fbi boy yge deie}f` aote}bleby~ bfyhobfòmcenyhte~ hb ebdo}nhba deie}f` hllha}fyhob fq"Hi" fy >1>b"1, >18: nd" Th``f~ fy [f}j~hie [f}ybe}~ t" Nhyx od Df}le}~

M}fbng, D">i , =;6= Q@ 85==5=, fy #1 '5yg Nh}"Lf}" =6, =;6=( 'stbihba {}eel{yei f ònf` o}ihbfbne ygfymf}}ei ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ d}ol }ebyhba {}o{e}yxqgeb Zy\ge ubiebhfmè {}fnyhnf` eddeny od yge O}ihbfbneh~ ygu~ yo nol{e` yge ie{f}yu}e od f`heb~ d}ol yge Nhyx yooyge} nhyhe~, ~yfye~, o} do}ehab nouby}he~(" Ge}e, Noba}e~~hy~e`d gf~ }e{efyei`x ien`hbei yo hl{o~e yge {ebf`yhe~ ygfyF}hsobf hl{o~e~ f~ f lfyye} od ~yfye `fq, fbi behyge}Noba}e~~ bo} yge Ewenuyhte M}fbng faebnhe~ ngf}aeiqhyg ebdo}nhba hllha}fyhob `fq gfte ebio}~ei yge yx{eod lfwhlul, hbih~n}hlhbfye ebdo}neleby ygfy F}hsobf

lfbifye~"

^"M" 6;1; hl{}o{e}`x ih~{`fne~ fbi ~u{{`fby~ deie}f`fuygo}hyx ote} }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~,


29/35

=6

f ~umceny ygfy yge Nob~yhyuyhob èfte~ yo Noba}e~~, fbiygfy Noba}e~~ ieèafyei yo yge ih~n}eyhob fbi ewnù~hteote}~hagy od deie}f` ewenuyhte odstnhf`~" ^"M" 6;1; ygu~om~y}uny~ fbi hl{eie~ deie}f` eddo}y~ yo e~yfm`h~g bfyhobf`{}ho}hyhe~ do} yge }elotf` od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~"Fnno}ihba`x, yge Nou}y od F{{ef`~ no}}eny`x doubi yge dou}{}oth~hob~ od ^"M" 6;1; {}eel{yei mx deie}f` `fq, fbi hy~cuialeby ~gouì me fdst}lei"

HHH" F]HSOBF^ HBA@E^YFYE ]ELOTF@ [O@HNXGF^ BFYHOBF@ FBI HBYE]BFYHOBF@

EDDENY^"

Yge hbih~n}hlhbfye gf}~gbe~~ od ^"M" 6;1; h~ bofnnhieby3 F}hsobf ie`hme}fye`x ngo~e yo u~e fb h}ob st~yyo }eleix qgfy hy {e}nehtei yo me yge deie}f` aote}bleby~ubcu~yhstfmè u~e od jhi aòte~ fafhb~y ubionulebyeihllha}fby~" Fl" Hb~" F~~b t" Af}flebih, 5>8 U"^">84, 9=1 '=;;>(" Muy F}hsobf~ fyyel{y yo fii}e~~ ygeih~{}o{o}yhobfye mu}ieb hy mef}~ od f bfyhobf` {}omèl,

[ey" M}" 6, gf~ hbethyfmè nob~evuebne~ mexobi F}hsobf~mo}ie}~" Fbi ygo~e nob~evuebne~ ob`x }ehbdo}ne qgx ygeNob~yhyuyhob lfbifye~ f ubhdo}l }uè od bfyu}f`hsfyhob,fbi qgx Noba}e~~ fnno}ihba`x {}othiei do} ubhstei deie}fòte}~hagy ote} ebdo}neleby fnyhthyhe~ hb fhi od }elotf`"

Menfu~e F}hsobf nfbboy nol{e` yge deie}fàote}bleby yo }elote ubionulebyei }e~hieby~, ^"M"6;1;~ {}oth~hob~ gfte yge {}hlf}x eddeny od }eih}enyhbaubionulebyei hllha}fby~ yo oyge} ^yfye~" êe [`xè},951 U"^" fy ==8>; '}enoabhshba ygfy ubionulebyei

hllha}fby~ lfx lote meyqeeb ^yfye~(: ~eef`~o Hba}hi T" Efa`x, @onf` Hllha}fyhob [}o~enuyhob3 F ^yuix odF}hsobf Medo}e ^M 6;1;, 57 UN@F @" ]et" 6198, 6188 $bb">;>>;1 '=;66( 'nhyhba lu`yh{è ~yuihe~ ob lha}fyhob


30/35

==

dòq~("6> Hbieei, obe od F}hsobf~ nghed nol{`fhby~fafhb~y deie}f` hllha}fyhob {o`hnx h~ ygfy yge deie}fàote}bleby~ f`èaei`x ih~{}o{o}yhobfye ebdo}nelebyeddo}y~ hb Nf`hdo}bhf fbi Yewf~ gfte ei yo f dubbe`hba odfb hbn}ef~hba yhie od h`èaf` mo}ie} n}o~~hba~ hbyo F}hsobf"[ey" M}" =" ]eaf}iè~~ od qgeyge} oyge} ^yfye~ qe`noleo} omceny yo yge lha}fyhob od ubionulebyei hllha}fby~,^M 6;1;~ eddeny h~ yo ieye} hllha}fby~ d}ol }e~hihba hb

F}hsobf: F}hsobf nfbboy hl{èleby f {o`hnx ygfy }elote~

hllha}fby~d}ol yge Ubhyei ^yfye~" F~ f }e~u`y, F}hsobf~ubh`fye}f` eddo}y yo hl{o~e hy~ oqb }elotf` {o`hnx qh``hbethyfm`x gfte hbye}~yfye eddeny~"

Lo}eote}, yge eddeny~ od ^"M" 6;1; f}e boy `hlhyei youbionulebyei hllha}fby~ fòbe" Menfu~e ^"M" 6;1;~}eahle od lfwhlul ebdo}neleby o{e}fye~ fafhb~y f``{e}~ob~ ~u~{enyei od mehba ubionulebyei, fbi ~umceny~ygo~e {e}~ob~ yo yge yg}efy od {o`hne hbye}}oafyhob fbiieyebyhob, F}hsobf~ fq yg}efyeb~ yo fddeny eaf` }e~hieby~d}ol oyge} ^yfye~, qgo lfx me ieye}}ei d}ol th~hyhba

F}hsobf, o} qgo lfx ~udde} d}ol a}efye} hbvuh~hyo}hf`{}fnyhne~ fbi {o`hne ~u}teh``fbne qghè hb yge ^yfye"

Ghbe~, >6= U"^" fy 19" Hb fiihyhob, ^"M" 6;1; qh`` fddenydo}ehab th~hyo}~, lfbx od qgol f}e fuygo}hsei yo ebye} fbi}e~hie hb yge Ubhyei ^yfye~ 'hbnùihba F}hsobf( qhygouy}eah~ye}hba qhyg yge deie}f` aote}bleby o} omyfhbhbafitfbne fuygo}hsfyhob" êe C"F" >798" Do} ygh~ }ef~ob,F}hsobf~ ~yfyuye gf~ f`}efix {}otojei ~y}oba omcenyhob~

6>" ôle ~yuihe~ gfte e~yhlfyei ygfy yge le}e yg}efy od "M"6;1;~ ebdo}neleby gf~ f`}efix ei 6;;,;;; Gh~{fbhn~, lo~y`x od

Lewhnfb ie~neby, yo efte F}hsobf do} Lewhno o} do} oyge} ~yfye~"Fiho~ F}hsobf3 @oy~ od [eo{è F}e @efthba, Yge Enobolh~y , Bot"=5, =;6;, gyy{3//qqq"enobolh~y"nol/boie/6157678= '`f~y th~hyeiLf}" =>, =;6=("


31/35

=>

d}ol ~ete}f` do}ehab nouby}he~ fbi hbye}bfyhobf` a}ou{~"êe C"F" 65;654" ûng }e~{ob~e~ d}ol oyge} bfyhob~ yoF}hsobf~ {o`hnx qh`` boy me `hlhyei yo F}hsobf }e~hieby~o} mu~hbe~~e~: hb~yefi, oyge} ^yfye~fbi yge nouby}x f~f qgoèqh`` me yf}}ei qhyg yge ~fle m}u~g" êe Ngx

@uba t" D}eelfb, 8= U"^" =15, =187; '6715(" Hb `hagyod yge~e hbye}~yfye fbi hbye}bfyhobf` eddeny~, Noba}e~~~eb~hm`x ieèafyei yo deie}f` fuygo}hyhe~ yge ote}~hagy odebdo}neleby fbi }elotf` {o`hnhe~ qhyg {oyebyhf` bfyhobf`

fbi hbye}bfyhobf` hl{`hnfyhob~"

F}hsobf~ ubh`fye}f` {o`hnx od lfwhlul ebdo}nelebyf`~o yg}efyeb~ yo ihte}y deie}f` }e~ou}ne~ fbi {}ho}hyhsfyhobod hllha}fyhob ebdo}neleby eddo}y~ hb oyge} ^yfye~ mxlobo{o`hshba deie}f` fyyebyhob" Do} ewfl{è, ênyhob = od^"M" 6;1; {}e~~u}e~ yge deie}f` aote}bleby yo {}ho}hyhsene}yfhb hllha}fyhob ~yfyu~ ngenj~ mx {}enùihba yge}eèf~e od f}}e~yei hbihthiuf`~ qgo f}e ~u~{enyei yo meubionulebyei hllha}fby~ ubyh` yge deie}f` aote}blebynfb te}hdx hllha}fyhob ~yfyu~" F}hsobf qouì e~~ebyhf``x

}evuh}e deie}f` oddhnhf`~ yo }e~{obi hlleihfye`x yo F}hsobf oddhne}~ ielfbi~ do} hbdo}lfyhob o} ~yfyu~ngenj~, o} }h~j ygfy ieyfhbei ~u~{eny~ 'qgo lfx me èaf`}e~hieby~ o} U"^" nhyhseb~( qouì }elfhb ieyfhbei do}èbaygx {e}hoi~ od yhle"

@hjeqh~e, "M" 6;1; }evuh}e~ F}hsobf fq ebdo}nelebyodstne}~ yo }ede} fbx ubionulebyei hllha}fby yo deie}f`nu~yoix do} }elotf`, qhygouy }eaf}i yo yge deie}fàote}bleby~ }e~ou}ne~, {}ho}hyhe~, o} ie~h}e yo }elote{f}yhnu`f} n`f~~e~ o} yx{e~ od hllha}fby~"êe C"F" 6=;

6=>" Muy lfbx ubionulebyei hllha}fby~ lfx me ebyhyèiyo }elfhb hb ygh~ nouby}x f~ {o`hyhnf` }eduaee~, thnyhl~ odfmu~e, o} oyge} ewel{yei ~yfyu~e~~yfyuyo}x {}oyenyhob~


32/35

=9

ygfy deie}f` {}oneeihba~ fòbe nfb ieye}lhbe"69 Lo}eote},oyge} ubionulebyei hllha}fby~~ung f~ U"^" teye}fb~fbi xouba nghì}ebqh`` df`` qhyghb yge te}x nfyeao}he~od {e}~ob~ ygfy deie}f` odstnhf`~ gfte ieelei òq {}ho}hyxdo} }elotf` {u}{o~e~"êe~u{}f fy 6=" Xey F}hsobf~ `fq qouì habo}e yge~e deie}f` ngohne~ fbi hb~yefi dubbe`yo yge deie}f` aote}bleby yeb~ od ygou~fbi~ od {e}~ob~qgol deie}f` odstnhf`~ qouì boy hbie{ebieby`x yf}aey do}}elotf`"

Yge deie}f` aote}bleby lfx o} lfx boy gfte ebouag}e~ou}ne~ yo ~fyh~dx F}hsobf~ ielfbi~" Muy ygfy h~ boyyge }eètfby vue~yhob" ^hl{`x yo }e~{obi yo yge ooi od}evue~y~ fbi }ede}}f`~ lfbifyei mx ^"M" 6;1;, deie}fòdstnhf`~ qouì me do}nei yo ihte}y }e~ou}ne~ d}ol oyge}ebdo}neleby {}ho}hyhe~ hb moyg F}hsobf fbi oyge} yfye~hbnùihba yge }elotf` od ifbae}ou~ ye}}o}h~y~ fbinobthnyei n}hlhbf`~" Nol{e``hba yge deie}f` aote}blebyyo ~{ebi lo}e }e~ou}ne~ yo fitfbne F}hsobf~ ubh`fye}f`{o`hnx bene~~f}h`x iey}fny~ d}ol yge }e~ou}ne~ ftfh`fmè

yo oyge} yfye~ fbi hbye}de}e~ qhyg yge nob~yhyuyhobf` fbi~yfyuyo}x nollhyleby yo f bfyhobf` }elotf` {o`hnx"

Lo}eote}, f }u`hba u{goìhba F}hsobf~ `fq qouìubie}lhbe f noge}eby bfyhobf` {o`hnx hb fboyge} }e~{eny3

69" ee, e"a", 7 U"^"N" 6657'f('6( 'ubionulebyei hllha}fbyhb Ubhyei ^yfye~ lfx f{{`x do} f~xùl h}}e~{enyhte od ~ungf`heb~ ~yfyu~(, 'n('6('F('M( 'obne a}fbyei f~xùl, ubionulebyeihllha}fby lfx }e~hie fbi qo}j hb yge Ubhyei yfye~(: hi" 667='f('4('F('hh( 'ewel{yhba d}ol hbfilh~~hmh`hyx ne}yfhb ubionulebyei

hllha}fby~ qgo gfte meeb mfyye}ei o} fmu~ei mx dflh`x lelme}~(:hi" 6=>6'm('>('F( '}elotf` lu~y me qhyggeì qgeb ubionulebyeihllha}fby~ `hde o} d}eeiol qouì me yg}efyebei hb gh~ golenouby}x("


33/35

=5

~ung f }u`hba qouì fuygo}hse fbi ebnou}fae oyge}^yfye~, hb f`` {f}y~ od yge nouby}x, yo ebfny ygeh} oqb te}~hob~ od ^"M" 6;1;, }eenyhba ygeh} oqb nobhnyhba}elotf` {}ede}ebne~" ûng f {fyngqo}j od nol{eyhba,hbnob~h~yeby, fbi h}}enobnh`fmè }elotf` {o`hnhe~ qouìqgo``x ubie}lhbe Noba}e~~~ {}oth~hob do} bfyhobqhiedeie}f` ih}enyhob fbi ote}~hagy"

NOBN@U^HOB

Yge cuialeby od yge Nou}y od F{{ef`~ ~gouì mefdst}lei"

]e~{enydu``x ~umlhyyei,

JFLF@FI" GF]]H^Fyyo}bex Aebe}f` od yge^yfye od Nf`hdo}bhf

LFBUE@ L" LEIEH]O^ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

@OUH^ TE]IUAOêbho} F~~h~yfbyFyyo}bex Aebe}f`

FBYOBEYYE NO]IE]OCOÊ SE@HIOBSE[EIF

Ie{uyx Fyyo}bex~ Aebe}f`6>;; H ^y}eey^fn}flebyo, NF 89=99'864( >=>6884lfbue`"leieh}o~Kioc"nf"aot

E]HN Y" ^NGBEHIE]LFBFyyo}bex Aebe}f` od yge^yfye od Beq Xo}j

MF]MF]FI" UBIE]QOOI#ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

J]H^YEB N@F]JEMu}efu Nghed

NENE@HFN" NGFBAIe{uyx ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

^YETEB N" QUF~~h~yfby ô`hnhyo} Aebe}f`

6=; M}ofiqfxBeq Xo}j, BX 6;=16'=6=( 9647;=;mf}mf}f"ubie}qooiKfa"bx"aot

#Noub~e` od ]eno}i

Fyyo}bex~ do} Flhnh Nu}hfe


34/35

=4

AEO]AE CE[ÊBFyyo}bex Aebe}fòd Nobbenyhnuy55 E`l ^y"Gf}ydo}i, NY ;46;4

IFTHI L" @OUHEFyyo}bex Aebe}fòd Gfqfhh9=5 Vueeb ^y}eeyGoboùù, GH 8476>

@H^FLFIHAFBFyyo}bex Aebe}fòd H``hboh~6;; Q" ]fbio`{g ^y"6=yg Dòo}Nghnfao, H@ 4;4;6

YOL

LH@@E]

Fyyo}bex Aebe}fòd HoqfGoote} ^yfye Odstne Muhìhba6>;5 E" Qf`buy I}"Ie~ Lohbe~, HF 5;>68

IOUA@F^ D" AFB^@E]Fyyo}bex Aebe}fòd Lf}x`fbi=;; ^fhby [fu` [`fne

Mf`yhlo}e, LI =6=;=

LF]YGFNOFJ@EXFyyo}bex Aebe}fòd Lf~~fngu~eyy~Obe F~gmu}yob [`fneMo~yob, LF ;=6;7

COGB ]" J]OAE]Fyyo}bex Aebe}fòd O}eaob664= Nou}y ^y" B"E"^fèl, O] 81>;6

[EYE] D" JH@LF]YHBFyyo}bex Aebe}fòd ]goie H~`fbi65; ôuyg Lfhb ^y}eey[}othiebne, ]H ;=8;>

QH@@HFL G" Ô]]E@@

Fyyo}bex Aebe}fòd Te}loby6;8 ^yfye ^y}eeyLoby{e`he}, TY ;54;8

Fyyo}bex~ do} Flhnh Nu}hfe


35/35

11 states file anti-sb 1070 brief

Documents