11 healthcare challenges t shankar
TRANSCRIPT
The Institute of Management Consultants of India
Healthcare Challenges & Opportunities
March 2006
Tilak ShankarManagement Solutions
Healthcare IndustryHealthcare Industry
Largest in the world with revenues over $3 trillionLargest in the world with revenues over $3 trillion
Indian healthcare industry is worth about Rs.100,000 Indian healthcare industry is worth about Rs.100,000 crores, accounting 5% of GDPcrores, accounting 5% of GDP
Fastest growing industry in India with CAGR of about Fastest growing industry in India with CAGR of about 30%30%
Employs about 80 lakh people directly and indirectly – Employs about 80 lakh people directly and indirectly – (IT industry employs only about 5 lakh)(IT industry employs only about 5 lakh)
Total Turnover Rs. 100,000 Cr. p.a.Total Turnover Rs. 100,000 Cr. p.a.
Hospitals & NH
40%
Others7%
Labs &Diagnostics12%
Pharma & Supplies20%
Allopathic Doctors22%
Two thirds of beds in Govt. & local authorities (Total 630,000 beds)
HEALTHCARE – VARIOUS SEGMENTSHEALTHCARE – VARIOUS SEGMENTS
HOSPITALS, NURSING HOMES,
CLINICS, LABS
PHARMA
STATE/ GOI
MEDICAL SOFTWARE INDUSTRY
MEDICAL TOURISM MEDICAL/
HEALTH INSURANCE
NUTRITION INDUSTRY
TRANSPORT
POPULATIONGERAITRIC , PAEDIATRIC
MEDICAL, NURSING,
DENTAL, PHARMA COLLEGES
TPAMEDICAL
EQUIPMENT
Hospitals Hospitals Govt, Corporate, not-for-profit, othersGovt, Corporate, not-for-profit, others
Not-for-profit – Sec 80G, Sec. 35AC, Not-for-profit – Sec 80G, Sec. 35AC, Sec. 35(1)(2) of Income Tax Act, Sec. 35(1)(2) of Income Tax Act,
Section 25 CompanySection 25 Company
Hospital ManagementHospital Management• MarketingMarketing• Strategic PlanningStrategic Planning• Finance & AdministrationFinance & Administration• ITIT• HRHR• MaterialsMaterials• QualityQuality• New Project planning & execution (India & Overseas)New Project planning & execution (India & Overseas)
Emerging trends In HealthcareEmerging trends In Healthcare Secondary & Tertiary Care requires large investment, Secondary & Tertiary Care requires large investment,
viable bed size, technological obsolescenceviable bed size, technological obsolescence Increasing corporatizationIncreasing corporatization Venture capital fundingVenture capital funding Slow, but emerging private health insurance/TPASlow, but emerging private health insurance/TPA Global alliancesGlobal alliances Listing of companiesListing of companies Felt need for professional managementFelt need for professional management ““Sick” hospitalsSick” hospitals ““Marketing” of servicesMarketing” of services M&A, Brand buying, Brand extension, franchising M&A, Brand buying, Brand extension, franchising
Emerging Trends (Contd.)Emerging Trends (Contd.)
Rating of hospitals (CRISIL, ICRA)Rating of hospitals (CRISIL, ICRA) Accreditation by TPAsAccreditation by TPAs Recertification of Doctors (in future)Recertification of Doctors (in future) Spiraling hospitalization costsSpiraling hospitalization costs Epidemiology:Epidemiology:
• 500,000 cancer patients added p.a.500,000 cancer patients added p.a.• 40 million diabetics40 million diabetics• 60 million patients60 million patients• 70-80 million senior citizens70-80 million senior citizens• Obesity, psychiatric patients.Obesity, psychiatric patients.
IRDA, Private InsuranceIRDA, Private Insurance Tele-medicineTele-medicine
Emerging Trends (Contd.)Emerging Trends (Contd.)Quality standards:Quality standards:
Medical audit, accreditation & other standardsMedical audit, accreditation & other standards Waste disposal (State Government)Waste disposal (State Government) ISOISO JCAHO (USA Standard)JCAHO (USA Standard) NABLNABL Blood Banking (GOI standards)Blood Banking (GOI standards) Licensing & inspection (under consideration)Licensing & inspection (under consideration) Protocols for clinical trialsProtocols for clinical trials Consumer protection act (private hospitalsConsumer protection act (private hospitals))
India - an Epidemiological TransitionIndia - an Epidemiological Transition
Geriatric (7 – 8 % of Geriatric (7 – 8 % of population)population)
Cataract, prostate, depression, Cataract, prostate, depression, cardio-vascular, arthritis, adult cardio-vascular, arthritis, adult on-set diabeteson-set diabetes
Life styleLife style Obesity, hypertension, stress, Obesity, hypertension, stress, tooth decay, cardiovasculartooth decay, cardiovascular
EnvironmentalEnvironmental Allergic asthma, water-borne Allergic asthma, water-borne diseases (typhoid, jaundice, diseases (typhoid, jaundice,
Leptospirosis)Leptospirosis)
ElectiveElective Cosmetic surgery, tooth Cosmetic surgery, tooth correction, infertility treatmentcorrection, infertility treatment
Tertiary HospitalTertiary Hospital Capital IntensiveCapital Intensive Long gestation periodLong gestation period Doctor-orientedDoctor-oriented Frequent up-gradation of technologyFrequent up-gradation of technology Service organizationService organization
• Patient focusPatient focus• Employee focusEmployee focus
Location is keyLocation is key Also needs:Also needs:
• Teaching (Post-grad.)Teaching (Post-grad.)• Research & publicationResearch & publication• Community/epidemiology workCommunity/epidemiology work• Global alliancesGlobal alliances
Medical TourismMedical Tourism Emerging opportunityEmerging opportunity
• HospitalsHospitals• Travel agentsTravel agents• AirlinesAirlines• HotelsHotels
Rs. 1500 Cr. Revenue in 2004Rs. 1500 Cr. Revenue in 2004 McKinsey projection – Rs. 5000 to McKinsey projection – Rs. 5000 to 10,000 cr. In 5 years10,000 cr. In 5 years Major CorporatesMajor Corporates
TatasTatas FortisFortisMaxMax WockhardtWockhardtPiramolPiramol Apollo gearing upApollo gearing up
Coordinated program : Airline tie up, pick-up, Coordinated program : Airline tie up, pick-up, visa etc. subsequently general tourismppvisa etc. subsequently general tourismpp
Pharmaceutical IndustryPharmaceutical Industry Bulk drugs, drug intermediates, formulations, generic & Bulk drugs, drug intermediates, formulations, generic &
branded, OTCbranded, OTC Bio-technology, Bio-informatics, neutraceuticalsBio-technology, Bio-informatics, neutraceuticals Annual turnover – Rs. 23,000 cr. (5-6% growth p.a.)Annual turnover – Rs. 23,000 cr. (5-6% growth p.a.) Employment – DirectEmployment – Direct - 50 lakhs- 50 lakhs
Indirect Indirect - 25 lakhs - 25 lakhs 20,000 units (300 in the organized sector)20,000 units (300 in the organized sector) No. of hospitals – 16,000No. of hospitals – 16,000 Retail chemists – 6 lakhsRetail chemists – 6 lakhs 44thth in the world (volume) in the world (volume) 1212thth in the world (value) in the world (value) Significant exports from IndiaSignificant exports from India
Pharma - Key challengesPharma - Key challenges Many drugs off patent ($30-40 billion in the next 5 yrs) Many drugs off patent ($30-40 billion in the next 5 yrs)
strategic marketing alliancesstrategic marketing alliances Good manufacturing practices – qualityGood manufacturing practices – quality Industry – research collaborationIndustry – research collaboration Ayurvedic drugsAyurvedic drugs Bio-technologyBio-technology Only a small number of items under DPCO (40 or so)Only a small number of items under DPCO (40 or so) Spurious drugs in IndiaSpurious drugs in India Global R&D – 18 year patentGlobal R&D – 18 year patent Upto 15 years from molecule to marketingUpto 15 years from molecule to marketing
Medical equipment suppliersMedical equipment suppliers
Expensive capital expenditureExpensive capital expenditure• CT Scan, MRI, Cath lab, Laser, Theatre equipment, CT Scan, MRI, Cath lab, Laser, Theatre equipment,
X-rayX-ray Siemens, Philips, Hitachi etc.Siemens, Philips, Hitachi etc. New hospitals, modernization (technological New hospitals, modernization (technological
obsolescence)obsolescence) Each new bed – total capex Rs. 20-100 lakhsEach new bed – total capex Rs. 20-100 lakhs Equipment sales, AMC, Spare parts, trainingEquipment sales, AMC, Spare parts, training Rs. 8,000 to 9,000 crores p.a.Rs. 8,000 to 9,000 crores p.a.
Health Insurance & TPAHealth Insurance & TPA Public SectorPublic Sector
• General insurance of India &General insurance of India &4 subsidiaries4 subsidiaries
Private SectorPrivate Sector• Royal Sundaram, ICICI-Lombard, Bajaj Alliance etc. Royal Sundaram, ICICI-Lombard, Bajaj Alliance etc. • TPA - TTK, Heritage, Family Health PlanTPA - TTK, Heritage, Family Health Plan
Estimated premium incomeEstimated premium income• About Rs. 5000 croresAbout Rs. 5000 crores• Potential – 25,000 cr in 5-7 yearsPotential – 25,000 cr in 5-7 years
Present coverage – only about 3-4% of the Present coverage – only about 3-4% of the populationpopulation
Govt. likely to allow separate health insurance Govt. likely to allow separate health insurance co (Rs. 25 crores equity)co (Rs. 25 crores equity)
Insurance by NGOs/Community based Insurance by NGOs/Community based health insurancehealth insurance
Members pre-pay a set amount (flat rate)Members pre-pay a set amount (flat rate) Voluntary health insurance (VHS-Chennai)Voluntary health insurance (VHS-Chennai) Co-operative, SEWA, FoundationsCo-operative, SEWA, Foundations Narayana HrudayalaNarayana Hrudayala Universal Health plan of the four Universal Health plan of the four
insurance companiesinsurance companies About 50 million coveredAbout 50 million covered In addition:In addition:
• ESIESI• CGHS (Retired employees)CGHS (Retired employees)• MediclaimMediclaim
IT IndustryIT IndustryHealthcare VerticalHealthcare Vertical
TCS, Wipro, Infosys, Cognizant, iSoft, Covansys etc.
US, Europe, Australia clients, Govts. and private hospitals
Global healthcare spend $5 trillion, US 1.7 trillion (15% of GDP)
USA – IT spend $25-30 billion
Europe 800 billion
Healthcare spend 12% to 15% of GDP (India – about 5-6%)
iSoft – Healthcare 260 million, 4000 employees (950 application specialists)
Cognizant :• $600 million• Of the above, 22% from healthcare and life sciences• 3000 domain & technology experts
IT in Healthcare IT in Healthcare
Medical• Picture Archival & Communication System (PACS)• DICOM (Digital Imaging & Communications in Medicine)• Telemedicine• Electronic Medical Records• Clinical Decision Support Systems• HL7 protocol• Epidemic prevention software
Non-medical• Integrated hospital information system• Web-enabled Appointment Scheduling• Web-enabled applications for relatives to obtain conditions of the
critical patients• Multi-media applications for patient education• Medical equipment management software• Web-enabled CRM applications
IT (Healthcare) ProjectsIT (Healthcare) Projects
Mainframe, client-server based, web-basedMainframe, client-server based, web-based
End to end product linking with provider, payer, patient End to end product linking with provider, payer, patient HIPAA complianceHIPAA compliance
Data warehousing and decision support systemsData warehousing and decision support systems
Electronic Medical RecordsElectronic Medical Records
Healthcare CRMHealthcare CRM
Maintenance of systemsMaintenance of systems
BPOBPO Areas:Areas:
• Medical TranscriptionMedical Transcription• Claims processingClaims processing• Billing by Doctors (on insurance companies)Billing by Doctors (on insurance companies)• Clinical documentationClinical documentation• Clinical trialsClinical trials
Advantages of Indian Companies:Advantages of Indian Companies:• English languageEnglish language• Cost arbitrageCost arbitrage• Time differenceTime difference• High quality (e.g. >99.5%)High quality (e.g. >99.5%)• Multi-disciplinary teamsMulti-disciplinary teams
Clinical Research Organization Clinical Research Organization (CRO)(CRO)
Clinical TrialsClinical Trials Revenue Rs. 300-400 croresRevenue Rs. 300-400 crores CII Projection : CII Projection : Rs. Cr.Rs. Cr.
20072007 800 800
20102010 40004000 Large populationLarge population Medical, Lab manpowerMedical, Lab manpower
Healthcare ConsultingHealthcare Consulting
Major areas:Major areas: Hospital feasibility studiesHospital feasibility studies Funding of new projectsFunding of new projects Efficiency improvementEfficiency improvement Market survey & marketing of servicesMarket survey & marketing of services Organization reviewOrganization review Strategic planningStrategic planning Insurance productsInsurance products IT – ERP, EMR, system integrationIT – ERP, EMR, system integration
Healthcare ConsultingHealthcare Consulting
Clients:Clients: GOI, State Governments.GOI, State Governments. UNICEF, World Bank, ADB, DANIDAUNICEF, World Bank, ADB, DANIDA Corporate & not-for-profit hospitalsCorporate & not-for-profit hospitals Insurance CompanyInsurance Company Strategic investorsStrategic investors IT Companies IT Companies
Challenges Ahead…Challenges Ahead… Structure and financing of healthcare is changing rapidly
Future managers in healthcare sector to be prepared to deal with • evolving integrated healthcare delivery systems• technological innovations• an increasingly complex regulatory environment• restructuring of work• increased focus on preventive care• improving efficiency in healthcare facilities and the quality of the
healthcare provided• managing finances including modernization, expansion plans and brand
extensions• optimizing efficiency of a variety of interrelated services (e.g. those
ranging from inpatient care to outpatient follow-up care)• managing the growing aspirations of doctors (compensation, revenue
sharing, high-end equipment, specialized courses etc.)• High turnover of para medical staff including nurses• Social ‘Marketing’
To sum upTo sum up
Wide ranging career opportunities in India Wide ranging career opportunities in India and elsewhereand elsewhere
Domain expertise healthcare management Domain expertise healthcare management essentialessential
Growing sectorGrowing sector Job satisfactionJob satisfaction Socially relevant jobsSocially relevant jobs