100514 waiting for the water to come[1] - india, south asia · dr. fabian scholtes, zef dr....

48

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 2: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEFDr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF

EDITOR:CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG, CENTER FOR DEVELOPMENT RESEARCH (ZEF) 2009

Page 3: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Foreword

I. Introduction: climate change and poverty reduction are inseparable II. Climate change

III. What climate change impacts are anticipated in future?

IV. Climate change and poverty reduction

V. Poverty reduction and strategies to secure livelihoods: case studies and lessons learned

VI. Case study West Timor, Indonesia

VII. Recommendations: poverty reduction in times of climate change

Page 4: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

C

Page 5: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

C

Page 6: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ORGANISATIONS ON POVERTY REDUCTION

Page 7: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

THE POOR ARE PARTICULARLY AFFECTED BY CLIMATE CHANGE AND VULNERABLE TO ITS IMPACTS

I. Climate change and poverty reduction are inseparable

Page 8: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 9: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

II. Climate changeCONSEQUENCES AND PROJECTIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE

II.1.CLIMATIC EFFECTS OF GLOBAL WARMING

Page 10: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 11: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

II.2 PHYSICAL EFFECTS BEYOND CLIMATE CHANGE

Page 12: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

BOX 1: CASCADE EFFECTS: A DAM BURST SCENARIO

Page 13: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

II.3 CONSEQUENCES AND EXTREME EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE: FEEDBACK AND TIPPING ELEMENTS

Page 14: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

II.4 ECONOMIC AND HEALTH IMPACTS

Changes in agricultural production potential (2080s, in % of the potential of 2000)

Page 15: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

III. What climate change impacts are anticipated in future?

Page 16: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 17: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 18: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

III.1 GLOBAL PROJECTIONS: IMPACTS

IV.1 CLIMATE CHANGE, POVERTY AND POVERTY REDUCTION: HOW ARE THEY RELATED?

IV. Climate change and poverty reduction

Page 19: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Food

Water

Ecosystems

Extreme weather conditions

Risk of rapid climate change and large-scale irreversible effects

Final temperature levels (compared to preindustrial levels0° C 1° C 2° C 3° C 4° C 5° C

Disappearance of small glaciers worldwide – potentialthreat to water supply in many areas

Considerable changes in water availability

Over 30% increase on flowing away of surface water in the Mediterranean region and in southern Africa

Rising sea levels threaten large cities such as London, Shanghai,New York, Tokyo or Hong Kong

Coral reef ecosystems extensively damaged; damage finally irreversible

Possible start of breakdown of parts of or all the Amazon rain forest

Large proportion of ecosystems which cannot preserve their present form

Many species threatened with extinction

Increasing intensity of storms, forest fires, flooding and heatwaves

Slight increase in hurricane intensity causes twice as much damage in dollars in the USA

Danger of weakening of natural carbon dioxide sinks and the Atlantic thermohaline circulation; possible increase in release of natural methane

Start of irreversible melting of Greenland icecap

Increased risk of abrupt, large-scale climate shifts (e.g. collapse of Atlantic thermohaline circulation or western Antarctic icesheet)

Severe effects in the Sahel zone

Increasing harvests in many developed regions due to CO2 fertilizer effect

Decline of harvests in many developed regions despite CO2 fertilizer effect

Decreasing harvests in many developing regions

Rising number of people threatened by hunger. Biggest increase in Africa and West Asia

Severe decline of harvests in whole regions (e.g. up to one third of Africa)

Page 20: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

BOX 2: MI BOSQUE. CLIMATE PROTECTION = POVERTY REDUCTIONG

Page 21: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

IV.2 ADAPTING TO THE IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE

Page 22: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

IV.3 SUPPORTING RESILIENCE

Page 23: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

IV.4 CRITERIA FOR SUCCESSFUL ADAPTATION MEASURES

Page 24: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

1 2 3 4

Page 25: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

IV.5 MEASURES

CRITERION DESCRIPTION

EFFECTIVE-NESS

FLEXIBILITY

FAIRNESS

EFFICIENCY

SUSTAINA-BILITY

Page 26: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

PROTECTION AND MAINTENANCE OF LIVELIHOODS SUPPORTING LIVELIHOODS

Page 27: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

V. Poverty reduction and strate-gies to secure livelihoods: case studies and lessons learned

V.1 SMALLHOLDER FARMERS IN TANZANIA: SPECIAL-ISING AND REDUCING DEPENDENCE ON AGRICULTURE

Page 28: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 29: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

V.2 MICROINSURANCE IN INDIA: THE POOR PROTECT THEMSELVES AGAINST RISKS

BOX 3: MICROINSURANCES AND WEATHER-RELATED DISASTERS: CARE INDIA AND BAJAJ ALLIANCE

Page 30: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 31: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

VI. Case study West Timor, Indonesia

VI.1 IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN (EAST) INDONESIA

VI.2 TOINEKE, WEST TIMOR: ECONOMY AND SOCIETY

GENERAL DATA ON WEST TIMOR, INDONESIA

Page 32: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

VI.3 PERCEPTIBLE LOCAL IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE

Page 33: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

CASE STUDY: IBU YANSE TON

Page 34: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 35: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

VI.4 COPING AND ADAPTATION STRATEGIES

Preventive measures to avert the impacts of climate change

CASE STUDY: PAK AUGUSTINUS LEBISA UND IBU NAEMA BANOET

Page 36: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Short-term reactive coping strategies

Future oriented coping strategies

Page 37: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Long-term adaptation strategies

Page 38: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

CASE STUDY: IBU YANSE LAKABU

Page 39: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 40: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

CASE STUDY: PAK YANDRI A. NENO UND IBU ANTONIA MISA

Page 41: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

VI.5 TOINEKE: AN EXAMPLE OF LIFE IN POVERTY IN CONDITIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE

Page 42: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

VII. Recommendations: poverty reduction in times of climate change

Page 43: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 44: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

Bibliography

Page 45: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 46: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

IMPRINT

The German Spendensiegel (donations seal) guarantees that your donation will be used responsibly, that the organization is run on economic lines and that all expenses are examined carefully.

Page 47: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,
Page 48: 100514 Waiting for the water to come[1] - India, South Asia · Dr. Fabian Scholtes, ZEF Dr. Anna-Katharina Hornidge (Case study Indonesia), ZEF EDITOR: CARE DEUTSCHLAND-LUXEMBURG,

CONTACT

CARE Deutschland-Luxemburg e.V.

Main officeDreizehnmorgenweg 6, 53175 BonnPhone: (+49) 228 97563-0, Fax: -51E-mail: [email protected]: www.care.de

ZEF

Center for Development Research (ZEF)Walter-Flex-Straße 353113 BonnPhone: (+49) 228 – 73 -1846, Fax: -89E-mail: [email protected]: www.zef.de

CARE in Luxemburg a.s.b.l.43, Bd. Du Prince HenriL-1724 LuxembourgPhone: (+352) 26 2030-60, Fax: -91E-mail: [email protected]: www.care.lu

Büro BerlinLuisenstraße 41, 10117 BerlinPhone: (+43) 30 240 4774-10, Fax: -20E-mail: [email protected]