10+ top medical tests to follow on the lchf dieta lchf diet is very different from the standard...

12
10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIET DR. BRET SCHER

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jan-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIET

DR. BRET SCHER

Page 2: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

INTRODUCTION

Are you interested in trying a LCHF diet but afraid you might be harming yourself?

Or have you been told by your doctor/nutritionist/trainer/favorite celebrity that it is

a dangerous diet? Here’s the good news: it’s not dangerous! And the best news,

you don’t have to guess if it is helping you or not. There are simple tests you can

follow to see if your overall health is improving. Objective data without guessing!

Celebrity trends can’t promise that, can they?

Of course, following a LCHF diet has many benefits which are not measured in the

lab, such as:

• Increased Energy

• Weight Loss

• Mental Clarity

• Lack of hunger

• And more…

Despite these benefits, the medical community still fears avoiding carbohydrates

and eating more fat. They base this fear on decades of poor quality science and

unchallenged dogma. But here is the secret (hopefully not really a secret), their fear

is misguided and generally wrong.

Fortunately, you can measure your progress on the diet and prove to yourself (and

your doctor) that your health is objectively improving. You just have to know what

to follow, and most importantly, what to ask your doctor to follow.

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

1

Page 3: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

Why do I have to ask my doctor? Shouldn’t she/he already know what to follow?

Great question. (that’s why I asked it).

Many physicians practice within traditional norms and established guidelines.

Unfortunately, these norms and guidelines were developed from people eating

either the standard American diet (SAD) or a low-fat diet, and thus these norms are

ill-equipped to adequately monitor a LCHF diet.

Your doctor, therefore, may need a little nudge to check blood tests that are out of

the norm. You may hear, “I have never checked those before.” Or “Those tests

aren’t part of our usual workup.” That’s OK. Just smile, acknowledge their

statement, and say “I understand that. And here is what is so interesting. I read that

a LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from

different monitoring tests.” Then dive right into my list of the 10+ most important

markers to follow when you are on a LCHF diet.

Below is a list of the tests and the expected results on the LCHF diet. The second

section has a more detailed description. Please note that the basic tests are easily

ordered in almost all labs. The bonus tests, however, may require special labs or

special protocols to measure.

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

2

Page 4: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

BASIC TESTS

HgbA1c- should go down

Fasting glucose and fasting insulin (HOMA-IR)- should go down

hsCRP- should go down

LDL- usually unchanged, but could go up or down

HDL- should go up

TG- should go down

TC:HDL ratio- should go down

TG:HDL ratio- should go down

Apo B or LDL-P- usually unchanged, but could go up or down

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

3

Page 5: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

BONUS TESTS

OGTT or Kraft test- glucose and insulin should go down

Fibrinogen- should go down

sdLDL- should go down

oxLDL- should go down

LDL phenotype- should be pattern A

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

4

Page 6: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

MORE IN-DEPTH DESCRIPTION OF THE TESTS

1. Measures of glucose control AND insulin sensitivity- Most doctors

frequently follow just the glucose level and assume that is adequate. The

problem is that by the time the glucose is out of control, we have had years if

not decades of hyperinsulinemia trying to keep the glucose in check. We can

be much more proactive by detecting abnormal insulin levels, and thus fixing

the problem long before it effects our glucose level.

a. Fasting glucose AND fasting insulin- This allows you to calculate what is

called a HOMA-IR, which is essentially an equation using both glucose and

insulin levels. This is a great marker for insulin sensitivity. Here is an example.

A fasting glucose of 90 (normal) with a fasting insulin of 20 (high) suggests

that your body is working hard producing a very high level of insulin in

order to maintain a normal blood glucose (thus an elevated HOMA-IR). This

is an unhealthy state, with potential damage from years of elevated insulin

levels, and definitely on the road to metabolic disease and diabetes. On

the other hand, a glucose of 90 (normal) with an insulin of 2 (normal)

represents a very healthy state with a normal blood glucose at a low insulin

level (a low HOMA-IR). That tells us you are sensitive to insulin, and your

pancreas does not have to work overtime to maintain a healthy blood

glucose level.

b. HgbA1c- This is a marker of your 3-month average blood glucose. If this is

elevated, you know you have both a glucose and an insulin problem. This

may be inaccurate if you have disorders of your red blood cells (i.e. they

do not last 3-months like a normal red blood cell), but otherwise it is a

reliable test for a long-term glucose average.

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

5

Page 7: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

c. Bonus Tests: The above tests are very easy to do and you should get very

little push back from your doctor. The following are a little more logistically

challenging, and may be harder to get ordered.

i. Oral Glucose Tolerance Test OGTT- You start by drinking a 75-gram

carbohydrate sugary drink (not an easy or pleasant thing to do) and

then measure your glucose level at 1-hour and 2-hours. Since the

average person spends more time in the post-prandial state (i.e. having

eaten) rather than the fasting state, it can be very helpful to see how

your body handles a carbohydrate load. This measures your body’s

ability to respond to glucose, and your body’s sensitivity to insulin, and is

much more sensitive than just measuring a fasting glucose.

ii. Kraft test- This test is the same as the OGTT above, but you measure both

glucose and insulin. Adding insulin increases the sensitivity of the test

and will identify issues earlier than if you only measure glucose.

2. Measures of inflammation- Acute inflammation, such as with an

infection or injury, is necessary and beneficial. The problem comes when we

have chronically elevated levels of inflammation as this can affect our lipids,

our insulin sensitivity, our hormone levels, and even our weight loss.

a. High sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP)- This is a very sensitive marker of

inflammation, and is most useful to track trends as you change your diet

and lifestyle. Results can vary depending on what is going on at that

moment. It therefore has to be interpreted with caution. You should try to

measure it when you are at your true steady, more than 12 hours after

intense exercise, and preferably when you are at your healthy baseline

(i.e. not sick with a cold or worse).

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

6

Page 8: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

b. Bonus Test: Fibrinogen- This is a protein associated with forming blood clots.

You need elevated fibrinogen if you have a serious cut and need to stop

the bleeding. Chronic elevation, however, signifies chronic systemic

inflammation and thus can be an additive marker to CRP to follow

changes in your inflammatory levels.

3. Lipid Profile- Lipids are likely the most controversial topic regarding LCHF

nutrition. But it doesn’t have to be this way. The key is to evaluate the entire lipid

profile, as detailed below, as opposed to relying on just one marker such as the

total cholesterol or LDL concentration.

a. Apolipoprotein B (Apo B) or LDL particle number (LDL-P)- The traditional

lipid panel measures an LDL-C, or total concentration of your LDL

(described in more detail below). A better marker, however, is measuring

the total number of LDL lipoprotein particles, rather than the total

concentration. The classic analogy is this: what causes traffic? The number

of people in the cars (i.e. the concentration of people on the road or

concentration of LDL), or the number of cars on the road (the total number

of lipoproteins)? One lipoprotein particle with an LDL concentration of 100

(i.e. one car with 100 people in it) is thought to be less “dangerous” than

100 lipoproteins each with one LDL. Either way the LDL-C is 100, but they

represent two very different scenarios. Since each LDL lipoprotein has one

Apo B on it, the Apo B is an accurate proxy for measuring the number of

particles. These tests are not included in the standard lipid profile, so they

will need to be ordered additionally. They are very helpful in diabetes and

insulin resistance, as there is frequently a discordance between LDL-C and

LDL-p (i.e. LDL-C is normal but LDL-P is elevated).

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

7

Page 9: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

b. Low density lipoprotein (LDL)- Traditionally called the “bad” cholesterol,

LDL is actually not inherently evil. LDL has a role in our bodies for fighting

infections and inflammation, and also helps with energy delivery. In the

setting of low HDL, high TG and insulin resistance, however, a higher level

of LDL correlates with a higher risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD). In the

opposite situation, high HDL, low TG, insulin sensitivity, LDL does not

correlate as well with risk of CVD. Therefore, context is crucial when

interpreting LDL results. Also, contrary to popular belief, most people on a

LCHF diet see no meaningful change in the LDL. Less than 30% of

individuals (likely closer to 5-10%) may see a 50-100% increase in their LDL.

While we do not know that this is dangerous, it is something of note and

may require further investigation or alterations.

c. High Density Lipoprotein (HDL)- Traditionally called the “good” cholesterol,

it tends to track with insulin sensitivity, going up with improved sensitivity

and down with insulin resistance. In addition, HDL goes up with eating

more fat and greater levels of exercise. Having naturally high HDL levels

seems to negate the risk of LDL. Interestingly, drugs that increase HDL do

not lower cardiac risk. The benefit only seems to come from natural

elevations, i.e. through lifestyle!

d. Triglycerides- TGs are elevated in diabetes and states of insulin resistance,

and frequently come from increased carbohydrate ingestion. Triglycerides

are an important source of fuel for the fat adapted individual, and the

main source of fuel when in ketosis. Triglycerides tend to go down on a

LCHF diet as your body is efficiently using them for fuel.

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

8

Page 10: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

e. Total cholesterol to HDL (TC:HDL) ratio- This is not a separate test, but simply

using results you already have to get a ratio. It is a better predictor of CVD

than just LDL alone since it factors in LDL and remnant particles, and

accounts for the protective benefit of naturally elevated HDL. It is easily

calculated from a standard lipid profile, but frequently is overlooked.

f. TG:HDL ratio- Similar to TC:HDL ratio, it is a marker of insulin resistance and is

easily calculated from a standard lipid profile. It is also a better predictor of

cardiovascular risk than LDL alone.

g. Lipoprotein a (Lp(a))- This is a helpful one-time test, but not all that helpful

to follow over time. Higher levels are associated with more atherogenic

lipoproteins, an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, and frequently go

along with a family history of CVD. Studies show that lowering Lp(a) with

medications, however does not decrease clinical risk of CVD. Instead,

when Lp(a) is elevated, more attention should be paid to LDL and other

risk factors.

h. Bonus Tests: These are not measured by standard lipid tests and usually will

require sending the blood to special labs.

i. Small, dense LDL (sdLDL)- A higher proportion of small, dense LDL

particles is associated with greater cardiovascular risk. Again, however,

this is highly influenced by insulin resistance and inflammation.

ii. LDL phenotype (Pattern A or B)- This reflects the overall size of the LDL

particles. In a simplistic way, pattern A represents less dense particles

that are less harmful (easy memory device, A is Awesome). Pattern B

reflects the denser, more worrisome particles (B is Bad). A LCHF diet can

help change pattern B to pattern A.

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

9

Page 11: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

iii. Oxidized LDL (oxLDL)- Oxidized LDL particles are “damaged” and easily

taken up by macrophages. This turns the macrophage into foam cells

which leads to unstable plaques and heart attacks. Normal, non-

oxidized LDLs, however, are not taken up very well, and therefore pose

a substantially smaller risk. Anything that reduces inflammation and

oxidation can help reduce the risk of your LDL.

There you have it. 10+ Top Medical Tests to Follow on the LCHF diet. Remember, you

don’t have to guess if things are getting better or not. You can measure them! And

you don’t have to do this alone. Talk to your doctor and join one of them many

online support groups. If you have any questions or concerns, you can always

contact us for more information or to schedule an individual consultation at

www.LowCarbCardiologist.com

Bret Scher, MD FACC

Founder, Boundless Health

www.LowCarbCardiologist.com

10

+ T

OP

ME

DIC

AL

TE

ST

S T

O F

OL

LO

W O

N T

HE

LC

HF

DIE

T

10

Page 12: 10+ TOP MEDICAL TESTS TO FOLLOW ON THE LCHF DIETa LCHF diet is very different from the standard diets, and therefore may benefit from different monitoring tests.” Then dive right

Bret Scher, MD FACC

Founder, Boundless Health

www.LowCarbCardiologist.com