1. what's ideal about ideal theory - stemplowska

8/7/2019 1. What's Ideal About Ideal Theory - Stemplowska

1/22

!"!#$%&'()*+!,--.!/&!!"#$%&'()*"+,'%-.'/+%#0$#*0!1$23!450!6$3!4!7892&!,--.:!

!

319

!

!

!!

!

!

!!

!

Whats Ideal About Ideal Theory?

!

;!+*=!?@(

+=+*=$'(=AF+*@+! A*@'=! @! C$??$! H*@+! +*=&! A@&!$>>='A!=@+9'=!(A!>='0!?9C*!

$>!H*@+!+*=&!A@&!H(22!!%$2(C&! @

!+*=!D=/@+=!$J='!+*=!D(A+((D=@2! +*=$'&3! N

+($$'!*$H!+$!(?%'$J=!$9'!A$C(=+&!+*@+!@'=!@%%2(C@/2=!>$'!9A!*='=!@!D$?=A+(C!M9A+(C=0!$%='@+=!A(?92+@'$?!+*=!C'(+(C(A?!+*@+!)$$D!

A$C(=+&!+*@+!@'=!@%%2(C@/2=!>$'!9A!*='=!@


2/22

320 Zofia Stemplowska!

!

!

1. The Ideal/Nonideal Distinction!

"#$%! &'! &()$*! %#)+,-! &.! %#)! /+.%)0%! +1!.+,2$%&3)! 4+*&%&/$*! %#)+,-5!6.)!

'%,$&7#%1+,8$,(!9.(),'%$.(&.7!+1!%#)!%),2!'%$%)'!%#$%!$!%#)+,-!&'!&()$*!&1!&%!#)*4'!&%')*1!%+!%#)!$''924%&+.!+1!'+:/$**)(!19**!/+24*&$./);

$''92)'!%#$%!4)+4*)>!$%!*)$'%!7).),$**-!'4)$?&.7>!(+!8#$%!%#)!%#)+,-!():2$.('!+1!%#)2;!=9/#!$!%#)+,-!&'!&()$*!&.!%#)!').')!%#$%!&%!$''92)'!$.!&():

$*&@)(!A9.%,9)B!3),'&+.!+1!,)$*&%-C!&.!%#)!$/%9$*!A.+.&()$*B!8+,*(>!4)+4*)!

(+!.+%!$*8$-'!/+24*-!8&%#!8#$%!&'!,)D9&,)(!+1!%#)2;!E#)!4,+F*)2!8&%#!

'9/#!$!'%,$&7#%1+,8$,(!()1&.&%&+.!+1!&()$*!%#)+,-!&'!%#$%!)3).!&1!$''92&.7!

19**!/+24*&$./)!&'!$!'911&/&).%!/+.(&%&+.!1+,!$!%#)+,-!%+!D9$*&1-!$'!$.!&()$*!%#)+,->! &%! &'! 9./*)$,! &1! &%! /$.! '),3)!$'!$! .)/)''$,-! /+.(&%&+.;! G1%),! $**>!

%#),)!&'!.+!'#+,%$7)!+1!+%#),!1)$%9,)'!+1!%#)!$/%9$*!A.+.&()$*B!8+,*(!%#$%!

/+9*(!4+%).%&$**-!F)!F,$/?)%)(!+11;!"#$%! &1!8)!8),)! %+!F,$/?)%! +11! %#)!

1$/%!%#$%!&.! %#)!.+.&()$*!8+,*(!4)+4*)!.))(!$//)''!%+!1++(!$.(!8$%),!%+!

'9,3&3)5!"+9*(!%#)+,&)'!F$')(!+.!%#)!$''924%&+.!%#$%!4)+4*)!/$.!*&3)!+.!

$&,! #$3)!).+97#! &.!/+22+.!8&%#! %#)+,&)'!$''92&.7!19**!/+24*&$./)! %+!

$**+8!9'!%+!2$?)!/+22+.!'%$%)2).%'!$F+9%!%#)&,!9')19*.)''5!!

! G'! ,)/).%!8+,?! +.! &()$*!%#)+,-!()2+.'%,$%)'>! $!.92F),! +1! %#)+,&'%'!

#$3)! %,&)(! %+!2+3)! F)-+.(! %#)!9.(),'%$.(&.7! +1! &()$*! %#)+,-! $'! F$')(!

'+*)*->!+,!4,&2$,&*->!+.!%#)!$''924%&+.!+1!19**!/+24*&$./);!H$,,)**->!1+,!

)0$24*)>! &.! $! ,)/).%! /+.%,&F9%&+.! %+! %#)! ()F$%)>! '977)'%'! A+,! &24*&)'B!!!

%#$%! $**! +1! %#)! 1+**+8&.7!2&7#%! F)$,! +.! 8#)%#),! $! %#)+,-! +97#%! %+! F)!!!/*$''&1&)(!$'!&()$*C!A&.$44,+4,&$%)B!1$/%!&.').'&%&3&%-I!%$?&.7!&.%+!$//+9.%!

$F'%,$/%! #-4+%#)%&/$*'I! $! /+'%:F*&.(! $44,+$/#I! &7.+,$./)! +1! /+.'%,$&.%'I!

&()$*&@$%&+.I! $.(! &7.+,$./)! +1!8#$%! &'! 1)$'&F*);J! E#&'! &'! $! *+.7! *&'%! +1!!!

1)$%9,)'! $.(! H$,,)**-! (+)'! .+%! )04*+,)! &.! $.-! ()%$&*! #+8! %#)-! $,)! $**!!!!

,)*$%)(! %+! +.)! $.+%#),;! K*%&2$%)*->! #+8)3),>! #)! '977)'%'! %#$%! 8)! '))!!!

A&.$44,+4,&$%)B! &.').'&%&3&%-! %+! 1$/%'!$'! %#)!2$&.!()1&.&.7!/#$,$/%),&'%&/!!

+1! &()$*! %#)+,-;L =4)/&1&/$**->! %#)! %-4)! +1! 1$/%! &.').'&%&3&%-! %#$%! *&)'! $%!!!!

%#)! #)$,%! +1! &()$*! %#)+,->! $//+,(&.7! %+! H$,,)**->! &.3+*3)'! &()$*&@$%&+.;M!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !,)3&')(!)(;!AP$2F,&(7)>!Q$'';C!R$,3$,(!K.&3),'&%-!

S,)''>!TUUUB>!44;!V:W!$.(!!#)!$(('!%#$%!X`(a)%),2&.&.7!)0$/%*-!#+8!1$/%:').'&%&3)!$!%#)+,-!

+1!b9'%&/)!+97#%!%+!F)!7+)'!F)-+.(!%#)!$'4&,$%&+.'!+1!%#&'!4$,%&/9*$,!$,%&/*)[!A&F&(;>!4;!WL]B;!

!M

YF&(;>!4;!WLW;!=))!6.+,$!6cZ)&**>!XGF'%,$/%&+.>!Y()$*&@$%&+.!$.(!Y()+*+7-!&.!d%#&/'>[!&.! N;_;e;! d3$.'! A)(;B>!9&'53" 2$.3&,&4$(" 567" :&6-%;4&'5'(" 2'&83%;,! AP$2F,&(7)C!

P$2F,&(7)! K.&3),'&%-! S,)''>! TUWWB>! 44;! MM:]U>! $.(! #),! #&


3/22

Whats Ideal About Ideal Theory? 321!

!

!

"#$#!%&$$#''(!)$&*+!,-!&!).+/.-0/.,-!1#/*##-!.)#&'.2&/.,-!&-)!&1+/$&0/.,-!

.-/$,)30#)!1(!4-,$&!456#.''7!!"#$%!&$'()8!&00,$).-9!/,!456#.''8!0,-+.+/+!

.-!.9-,$.-9!+,:#!0,:;'##-!;$,1'#:!*./?,3/8!?,*#>#$8!&+@

+3:.-9!&-(!=&'+#?,,)+!&1,3/!/?#:A!'*+!,'-!$'()8!,-!/?#!,/?#$!?&-)8!0,-@+.+/+!.-!/?#,$.2.-9!/?&/!:&B#+!+,:#!=&'+#!&++3:;/.,-+C

D!E?3+8!=,$!#,'>#!.)#&'.2&/.,-!F+.-0#!*#!&$#!&++3:.-9!&!=&'+#?,,)!&1,3/!&!-3:1#$!,=!;#,@

;'#G8! *?.'#! $#0,::#-).-9! /?&/! ;#,;'#! 1#! ?#')! $#+;,-+.1'#! =,$! /?#.$!

0?,.0#+! 1#0&3+#! ./!,=/#-!?&+! ;,+./.>#!.-0#-/.>#! #==#0/+H*?#/?#$!,$!-,/!

/?#(!0&-!0?,,+#!*.+#'(H*,3')!.->,'>#!:#$#!&1+/$&0/.,-!=$,:!/?#!0,:@

;'#

0.+#'(!1#0&3+#!.)#&'!/?#,$(!.->,'>#+!.)#&'.2&/.,-8!&00,$).-9!/,!%&$$#''(8!/?&/! ./! #-)+!3;! 1#.-9! K.:;,/#-/L! &+! -,$:&/.>#! /?#,$(A!,-! ?.+! >.#*!*#!

:3+/!/3$-!/,!-,-.)#&'!/?#,$(!.=!*#!*&-/!/,!:&B#!;$,9$#++!*./?!-,$:&/.>#!

M3#+/.,-+CN!

! %&$$#''(5+!).+/.-0/.,-!1#/*##-!.)#&'!&-)!-,-.)#&'!/?#,$(!#0?,#+!/?&/!,=!

O.''+8!*?,!?&+!&'+,!&$93#)!/?&/!.)#&'!/?#,$(!.->,'>#+!.)#&'.2&/.,-C!O.''+8!

?,*#>#$8!##!,=!*?&/!/?#!Q!.+!'.B#8!13/!$&/?#$!:,)#'+8!,-!/?#!1&+.+!,=!&++3:;@

/.,-+!/?&/!&$#!#'.)'/'&!)$,0!=&'+#8!*?&/!&-!.)#&'!Q!+?,3')!1#!'.B#!F*?#$#!K+?,3')L!0&-!$#=#$!/,!&!?,+/!,=!>&'3#+7!:,$&'8!;$3)#-/.&'8!/,!),!*./?!#==.@0.#-0(8!&-)!+,!,-GCR!J)#&'!/?#,$(8!/?#-8!&00,$).-9!/,!O.''+8!+/.;3'&/#+! #'.1

)'/'&!)$,0! =&'+#!&//$.13/#+! /,!.-).>.)3&'+! &-)S,$!9$,3;+!&-)! /?#.$!.-/#$&0@

/.,-+CTU!E?#!0,-0'3+.,-!/?&/!O.''+!$#&0?#+!&1,3/!/?#!3+#!,=!.)#&'!/?#,$(!.+!

+.:.'&$!/,!/?&/!$#&0?#)!1(!%&$$#''(7!&00,$).-9!/,!O.''+8!.)#&'!/?#,$(!0&-@

-,/!.''3:.-&/#!-,$:&/.>#!;$,1'#:+!;$#0.+#'(!1#0&3+#!./!.->,'>#+!&++3:@

.-9!*?&/!.+!+.9-.=.0&-/'(!=&'+#CTT!!

! O(!,3/'.-#!,=! /?#!>.#*+!,=! 1,/?! /?#,$.+/+!?&+8! ,=! 0,3$+#8!1##-!,-'(!

$3).:#-/&$(!FJ!*.''!$#>.+./!/?#.$!>.#*+!.-!:,$#!)#/&.'!.-!+#0/.,-!V!1#',*G8!13/!/?#!).+03++.,-!+?,3')!&'$#&)(!?&>#!1$,39?/!/,!/?#!=,$#!,-#!=3-)&:#-@

/&'!M3#+/.,-7!?,*!*,3')!*#!B-,*!.=!*#!&$$.>#)!&/!&!9,,)!)#=.-./.,-!,=!

.)#&'! /?#,$(! &-)8! 1(! .:;'.0&/.,-8! &! 9,,)! &00,3-/! ,=! /?#! ).+/.-0/.,-!1#@/*##-!.)#&'!&-)!-,-.)#&'!/?#,$(W!4$8!/,!;3/!./!).==#$#-/'(7!*?&/!.+!/?#!).+@

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D456#.''8!2(3!%*#456#$'&+4!)*47'%$6+8!;;C!XU@XTC!

! IY##8! =,$! #


4/22


!

!

"#$%"#&$!'())&'*+!"&!%,)"(-*.!/*#"0*-!1,--*223!$&-!4#22'!#$!"0*#-!,%%&($"'!

&55*-'!*6)2#%#"!,$'7*-'!"&!"0*'*!8(*'"#&$'9!1,--*223!+&*'!$&"!%&$'#+*-!&:;

(2,;

"#&$'9! G+>#""*+23H! 0*! '(==*'"'! ,! 03)&"0*'#'! 5&-! 0&7! "0*&-#F#$=! #$! "0*!

2#=0"!&5!'#=$#5#%,$"23!5,2'*!,''(>)"#&$'!%&(2+!,""-,%"!*$&(=0!"0*&-#'"'!"&!

*>*-=*!,'!,!A"3)*9B!I(%0!"0*&-#F#$=H!0*!*6)2,#$'H!'*-@*'!"0*!#$"*-*'"'!&5!

"0&'*!70&!0,))*$!"&!,))-&6#>,"*!"0*!5,2'*!,''(>)"#&$'!>,+*!:3!"0*!"0*;&-39! J0('H! 5&-! *6,>)2*H! "0*! ,''(>)"#&$! "0,"! ,22! )*&)2*! -*2,"*! "&! *,%0!

&"0*-!#$!,$!,("&$&>&('!7,3H!,%%&-+#$=! "&!4#22'H!'*-@*'! "0*! #$"*-*'"'!&5!

A>#++2*;"&;())*-;%2,''!70#"*!>,2*'K70&!,-*!0(=*23!&@*-;-*)-*'*$"*+!#$!

"0*!)-&5*''#&$,2!)0#2&'&)0#%,2!)&)(2,"#&$9BCL!I&!"0*!#+*,2?$&$#+*,2!"0*&-3!

+#'"#$%"#&$!)-&)&'*+!:3!4#22'!'*-@*'!"0*!)(-)&'*!&5!+#'"#$=(#'0#$=!"0&'*!

70&'*!*$=,=*>*$"!#$!)&2#"#%,2!"0*&-3!#'!-*2,"#@*23!($%-#"#%,2!5-&>!"0&'*!

70&! '(%%**+! #$! %&$'"-(%"#$=! "0*&-#*'! "0,"! -*52*%"!>&-*! "0,$! "0*#-! &7$!

#$"*-*'"'9CM!!

! N#',=-**>*$"!&@*-!"0*!+#'"#$%"#&$! #$! 8(*'"#&$!7#22H! %2*,-23H! "&! '&>*!

*6"*$"!+*)*$+!&$!"0*!)(-)&'*'!"0,"!"0*!+#'"#$%"#&$!#'!'())&'*+!"&!'*-@*9!G$+H! &5! %&(-'*H! "0*! "0*&-#'"'! 70&! %&$'"-(%"! "0*! #+*,2?$&$#+*,2! 2,:*2'!>#=0"! '**O! "&! 5(-"0*-! +#@*-'*! *$+'! 7#"0! "0*#-! 2,:*2'9! 1&-! *6,>)2*H! "0*!

)-#>,-3!)(-)&'*! &5!,! "0*&-#'"! "-3#$=! "&!+#'"#$=(#'0! #+*,2! 5-&>!$&$#+*,2!

"0*&-3!>,3!7*22!:*!"&! -*'*-@*! "0*! 2,:*2!A#+*,2!"0*&-3B!5&-!A('*2*''!"0*;

&-3B!,$+!"0*$!"&!"-3!"&!#+*$"#53!,$+!)*-'(,+*!('!&5!70,"!>,O*'!,!"0*&-3!

('*2*''9!I&!#$!&-+*-!"&!,=-**!&$!,!+#'"#$%"#&$H!7*!7#22!0,@*!"&!,=-**!&$!"0*!

)(-)&'*P'Q!#"!#'!'())&'*+!"&!'*-@*9!J&!',3!>&-*!,:&("!"0*!)(-)&'*'!&5!"0*!

+#'"#$%"#&$H!0&7*@*-H!2*"!>*!5#-'"!*6,>#$*!70,"!"0#'!"0#$=!#'!70&'*!"3)&2;

&=3!#'!#$!8(*'"#&$R!$&->,"#@*!"0*&-39!!!

!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! CDS:#+9H!))9!CTT;UV9!

! CLS:#+9H!)9!CUD9!

! CMS$!,!-*%*$"!:&&OH!4#22'!0,'!-*"(-$*+!"&!"0*!)-&:2*>!&5!#+*,2!@*-'('!$&$#+*,2!"0*&-39!

W*=-*"",:23H!"0*!:&&O!,))*,-*+!"&&!2,"*!5&-!>*!"&!*6,>#$*!#"!#$!"0#'!,-"#%2*9!E("!S!'0&(2+!

)$"!&("!"0,"!4#22'!'(==*'"'!#$!"0*!:&&O!"0,"!),-"!&5!"0*!,""-,%"#&$!&5!#+*,2!"0*&-3!+*-#@*'H!,>&$=!&"0*-!"0#$='H!5-&>!#"'!'#>)2#%#"39!S!5#$+!"0#'!'(==*'"#&$!)2,('#:2*9!I**!X,-&2*!Y,"*;

>,$!,$+!X0,-2*'!4#22'H!!"#$%&'$()(*"+,#&$,"#!PX,>:-#+=*R!Y&2#"3!Y-*''H!DVVUQH!*')9!

))9!CVL;MH!CCD;CZH!DLD;LM9!


5/22


!

!

2. The Structure of Normative Theory!

"!#$%&'()*$%#$%'!+&',-#./%!&'!0&1.#./%)2-+!3%!4+5%'1#&&5!-1!-!1(16

#%,-#.2! -22&4+#! &7! &4'! 8+&*9%5:%! -3&4#! -! :./%+! 5.,%+1.&+! &7! '%-9.#(!;*$%'%!#$%!9-##%'!.1!3'&-59(!2&+1#'4%5

2&+1#.#4#%1! 8+&*9%5:%! -00'&0'.-#%! 7&'! #$-#! 5.,%+1.&+=! >&'! %?-,09%@! -!#$%&'(! #$-#! 1(1#%,.A%1! &4'! 8+&*9%5:%! -3&4#! 29.,-#%! 7942#4-#.&+1! ,-(!

+%%5! #&!,%%#! 2'.#%'.-! '%9-#.+:! #&!7-91.7.2-#.&+! #$-#!*&495!+! -009(!#&!-!

#$%&'(!5%-9.+:!*.#$!#$%!0'&39%,!&7!#$%&5.2(=!B,0&'#-+#9(@!-99!142$!#$%&6

'.%1!$-/%!1#'42#4'%1C!#$-#!.1@!#$%(!$-/%! !"#$%&@!142$!-1!-114,0#.&+1@!'$%(

#$%&@!142$!-1!7.+-9!0'.+2.09%1@!-+5! '49%1!'%:49-#.+:!#$%!)*+!,-%!'"!&7!#$%!&4#04#!7'&,!#$%!.+04#=!B+!$%'!*&'51@!*%!2-+!-91&!#$.+8!&7!#$%&'.%1!-1!

5%/.2%1!#$-#!-'%!1400&1%5!#&!-99&*!41!#&!0'&:'%11!7'&,!&+%!1%#!&7!1#-#%6

,%+#1!#&*-'51!-+$%'!1%#!&7!1#-#%,%+#1!.+!&'5%'!#&!.+2'%-1%!&4'!8+&*96

%5:%!-3&4#!1&,%!D=!!

! E$-#!.1!#$%!.+#%'+-9!1#'42#4'%!&7!-!"'+.-%!,*!#$%&'(FGH!"99!+&',-#./%!

#$%&'.%1! ,41#! 2&+#-.+! ;+&',-#./%

,%+#1!%?0'%11.+:!0&1.#.&+;1

+&',-#./%!#$%&'.%1!+&',-#./%=!B+!-55.#.&+!#&!0'.+2.09%1@!+&',-#./%!#$%&6

'.%1!*.99!+%%5!#&!2&+#-.+!%9%,%+#1!#$-#!3.+5!#$%1%!0'.+2.09%1!#&:%#$%'!-+5!

-22&4+#!7&'!#$%.'!'%9%/-+2%=!I$%(!*.99!#$41!-91&!2&+#-.+!,&5%91!;$&*%/%'!

1.,09%&99&*.+:! $%'1@! B! -,! *.99.+:! #&!

-009(!#$%!*&'5!K#$%&'(L!:%+%'&419(!#&!5%12'.3%!%/%+!-!,&5%1#!2&99%2#.&+!

&7!2&$%'%+#!0'.+2.09%1@!&7!*$.2$!1&,%! -'%!#$%! .+04#1! -+5! 1&,%! -'%! #$%!

&4#04#1!&7!-!:./%+!#$%&'(=!M&,%!+&',-#./%!#$%&'.%1@!$&*%/%'@!*.99!2&+6

#-.+!-+!-55.#.&+-9!#(0%!&7!&4#04#@!*$.2$!B!*.99!'%7%'!#&!-1!'%2&,,%+5-6

#.&+1=GN

! O%2&,,%+5-#.&+1! -'%! 10%2.7.2! 0'&0&1-91! 7&'! -2#.&+1@! 0&9.2.%1@!

-+5J&'! .+1#.#4#.&+-9! '%7&',1! #$-#! -'%! -39%! #&! -2$.%/%! .,0'&/%,%+#1! -1!

,%-14'%5!3(!#$%!10%2.7.%5!0'.+2.09%;1

B5%-9!I$%&'(@!-+5!#$%!I$%&'(!&7!B5%-91@L!4+0439.1$%5!*&'8.+:!0-0%'=!

! GN"99!+&',-#./%!#$%&'.%1@!3%.+:!+&',-#./%@!*.99!&7!2&4'1%!2&+#-.+!;+&',-#./%

0&9.2.%1@!&'!.+1#.#4#.&+-9!'%7&',1!#$-#!1$&495!1422%%5!.+!-5/-+2.+:!#$%!/-94%1!%?0'%11%5!

3(!#$%!0'.+2.09%1=!


6/22


!

!

"#$%! %&'(&'$)! %*! "! +,-./! '0.%12345! 6,7,#"1#28! '0.! '1"9,',%/"#! 9,$',/:',%/!!!!!!!

;.'"11.##2?$!"/9!@,##$?$!

$&++.$',%/$!"#$%!#."9!&$!'%!*%:&$!%/!'0.!,/(&'=!'0.!(1.$./:.!%*!*"#$.!%1!$,+/,*,:"/'#2!*"#$.!"$$&7(',%/$3!A'!$..7$! '%!7.!'0"'! B%&'$,9.!%*!9.;"'.$!

";%&'! 9,$:,(#,/"12! ;%&/9"1,.$8!

*&/:',%/!%*!'0.!'0.%123!D0,$!,$!"11.##2!"1.!'12,/+!

'%!9%E!'0.2!

',%/$!

! 4NA!"7!+1"'.*!'%!@,:0".#!M'$&F"!*%1!(1.$$,/+!7.!'%!:#"1,*2!'0.!'.7(%1"#!.#.7./'!,/!

72!9.*,/,',%/!%*!-,";#.!1.:%77./9"',%/3!

!4U

M*!:%&1$.!:#",7,/+!'0"'!


7/22


!

!

"#$%&!'#!(#)*"!$++,"$-.,*/!')&&,'.!(0/!%#%$",-*!.0,#1/!$'!',,%!-'!$+2

3#1.-%.!4(,!-**!(-%.!.#!0,-1!-5#).!6721,8#++,%"-.$#%'9!-%"!(0/!$",-*!

.0,#1/! +$&0.! 0-:,! 5,,%! ')5;,8.! .#! 81$.$8$'+! 4$.! "#,'! %#.! #

.$:,! .0,#1$,'!#!(0$*,!.0,!*-..,1!-1,!$%.,1,'.,"!$%!1-%A$%&!-*2

.,1%-.$:,!'#8$,.-*!-11-%&,+,%.'>!)*.$+-.,*/!($.0!.0,!3)13#',!#

$%&!0#(!.#!+-A,!-":-%8,+,%.'!.#(-1"'!;)'.$8,!EE! 0,! $'! $+3*$8$.*/! "$'.$%2

&)$'0$%&!%#.!'#!+)80!5,.(,,%!.1-%'8,%",%.-*!-%"!8#+3-1-.$:,!.0,#1$,'!

#

.$:,!.0,#1$,'>!.0#',!.0-.!1-%A!!"#$%&!'#8$,.-*!-11-%&,+,%.'=!C

1,8.>!.0,%!D,%J'!8-.,$H-.$#%!8-%!5,!')5')+,"!)%",1!.0,!#%,!C!-+!')&2

&,'.$%&B!'()'*&)&+'&,')'*#')-&)#.&)/.&/#.&0)'()#11&/')'*#')"0%)234'"1&)"4),(')#1*"&!#$%&)5(.)34)*&.&)#,0),(->! .1-%'8,%",%.-*! .0,#1$,'!(#)*"! !(0,1,! C!-*'#!"$'8)''!.0,#1$,'!.0-.!-$+!.#!#!OX-1+!-%"!X/3#81$'/B!X-:,!P,!Y#.!C.!P1#%&!Z%!

71)&'@S!83$%"1)8(%"1:);&4.1*!IN!4EFF[9B!IET2LU=!

! EED,%>!OP0-.!7#!P,!P-%.!Q1#+!-!G0,#1/!#

_-*,%.$%$>!OZ%!.0,!633-1,%.!]-1-"#M!#


8/22


!

!

"##$%&! '&! ($! )$&*!%+"(! ,! ("-*! ($! .*! "/!01)$2("/(!3'*&(0$/4!%+"(! 0&! (+*!

)'2)$&*!$5!.'0#60/7!(+*$20*&!(+"(!6$!/$(!$55*2!89:2*;$11*/6"(0$/&! (+*B!%0##! 0&&'*!&$1*!

89:2*;$11*/6"(0$/&!.'(!(+*B!%0##!"#&$!0&&'*!2*;$11*/6"(0$/&!(+"(!"2*!/$(!89:2*;$11*/6"(0$/&!"/6!%0##>!0/!"660(0$/>!60&;'&&!&$1*!)2$.#*1&!

%0(+$'(! "010/7! ($! 0&&'*! "/B! 2*;$11*/6"(0$/&! ".$'(! (+*1! "(! "##C! D+0&!

6$*&!/$(!1*"/! (+"(! (+*2*! 0&! /$! )$0/(! 0/! 62"%0/7! "! 60&(0/;(0$/! .*(%**/!

06*"#!"/6!/$/06*"#!(+*$2BE"5(*2!"##>!0(!6*)*/6&!$/!%+"(!%*!%"/(!(+*!60&:

(0/;(0$/!5$2E.'(!0(!6$*&!1*"/!(+"(!(+*!60&(0/;(0$/!%0##!.*!5"2!#*&&!01)$2:

("/(!(+"/!;20(0;&!$5!06*"#!(+*$2B!1"B!+"?*!#*6!'&!($!.*#0*?*C!,(!"#&$!1*"/&!(+"(!(+*!60&(0/;(0$/!0&!/$(!#0-*!(+"(!.*(%**/>!&"B>!(+*!(+*$2B!$5!*?$#'(0$/!

"/6!;2*"(0$/0&1>!%+0;+>!70?*/!(+"(!(+*B!"2*!1'('"##B!*@;#'&0?*>!;$'#6!/$(!

.*!;$1.0/*6! 0/!$26*2! ($!*@)#"0/!"!70?*/!)+*/$1*/$/C!F"(+*2>! (+*! 60&:

(0/;(0$/!.*(%**/!06*"#!"/6!/$/06*"#!(+*$2B!0&!1$2*!#0-*!(+"(!.*(%**/>!&"B>!

2"(0$/"#! ;+$0;*! (+*$2B! "/6! )&B;+$"/"#B(0;"#! (+*$2B4! (+*B! ;"/! 6*"#!%0(+!

6055*2*/(! "&)*;(&! $5! (+*! &"1*! )2$.#*1! "/6>! "&! &';+>! ;"/! .*! ;$1.0/*6!

&+$'#6!(+*!/**6!"20&*C!

! G"?0/7! &'77*&(*6!+$%!%*! ;"/! (+0/-!".$'(! 06*"#! (+*$2B>! ,!%0##! "#&$!

%"/(! ($! 6*5*/6! (+*! '&*! $5! &';+! (+*$2B! ($! (";-#*! /$21"(0?*! 3'*&(0$/&C!

G$%*?*2>!.*5$2*!,!7$!$/!($!$'(#0/*!%+"(!(+*!)$0/(!0&!$5!(+*$20*&!(+"(!$55*2!/$! 89:2*;$11*/6"(0$/&>! #*(!1*! 502&(! *@)#"0/!%+B! ,! 6$! /$(! (+0/-! (+"(!(+*2*!0&!1';+!10#*"7*!0/!;"(*7$20H0/7!(+*$20*&!.B!%+*(+*2!(+*B!6$!I$2!6$!

/$(J!1"-*!5"#&*!$2!&07/050;"/(#B!5"#&*!"&&'1)(0$/&C!!

3. Whats the Point of False Assumptions?!

,! +"?*! "27'*6! ".$?*! (+"(! (+*! 6*."(*! $?*2! 06*"#! "/6! /$/06*"#! (+*$2B!

&+$'#6! .*! '/6*2&($$6! "&! "! 6*."(*! $?*2! (+*! 5'/;(0$/I&J! $5! /$21"(0?*!!!!!

(+*$2BC!K/*! )$&&0.#*!0/(*2)2*("(0$/!$5!(+*!1$?*! ($!;"(*7$20H*! (+*$2B! 0/!

";;$26"/;*!%0(+!%+*(+*2! 0(! 1"-*&! 5"#&*! I"/6L$2! &07/050;"/(#B! 5"#&*J! "&:

&'1)(0$/&! 0&! (+"(! &';+! "!1$?*! 0&! 0/(*/6*6! ($! "##$%!'&!60&(0/7'0&+! .*:

(%**/!'&*5'#!"/6!'&*#*&&>!$2!0/5$21*6!"/6!0##:0/5$21*6!/$21"(0?*!(+*$:

20*&C!='(>! "&! ,!+$)*! ($! &+$%!.*#$%>! *?*/! 05! (+0&! 0&! (+*! 0/(*/(0$/!$5! (+*!

06*"#L/$/06*"#! (+*$2B! ;"(*7$20H"(0$/>! 0(! 5"0#&! ($! 6*#0?*2! $/! 0(&! )2$10&*4!

1"-0/7!5"#&*!$2!*?*/!&07/050;"/(#B!5"#&*!"&&'1)(0$/&!6$*&!/$(!;$/6*1/!

(+*$2B!($!.*!'&*#*&&!"/6!1"B!*?*/!.*!/*;*&&"2B!5$2!0(!($!"/&%*2!"!2"/7*!$5!3'*&(0$/&C!!

! D$!6*5*/6! (+0&! ;#"01>! #*(!1*!5$;'&! 502&(!$/!(+*!'&*&!$5!1"-0/7! 5"#&*!"&&'1)(0$/&>! #*"?0/7! '/(0#! #"(*2! (+*! )2$.#*1! $5! 1"-0/7! &07/050;"/(#B!!

5"#&*!"&&'1)(0$/&!I+$%*?*2!%*!1"B!%"/(! ($!6*50/*!M&07/050;"/(N!+*2*JC!


9/22


!

!

"#$%&'! $(')! $(*$! $*&+,%)-! ./#*0! 1/#.,'23! 43*56! *.#7$! 8(*$! 973$%&'! /':

;7%/'3!#)!*!3#&%'$*,!3&*,'*,3'!*33721:

$%#)3?! @#/! 'A*21,'6! $#!$('#/%B'!*$!*! &'/$*%)! ,'=',!#>!-')'/*,%$56!8'!8%,,!

(*='! $#!2*+'!3#2'!*11/#A%2*$%#)3!$(*$6!.'%)-!*11/#A%2*$%#)36!8%,,!.'!>*,3'6!.7$!$(*$!8%,,!*,3#!.'!)'&'33*/5!$#!2*+'!*)5!1/#-/'33!*$!*,,?

CD!E)!*0:

0%$%#)!$#!2*+%)-!*11/#A%2*$%#)36!$('#/%3$3!2*5!(*='!$#!1/'$')0!$(*$!&'/:

$*%)!0%>>%&7,$%'3!0#!)#$!*/%3'!#/!$('5!8%,,!)'='/!.'!*.,'!$#!3*5!8(*$!973$%&'6!#)!$('!8(#,'6!/';7%/'36!*3!$('!,'A%$5!#>!$('!1/#.,'2!8%,,!.'!3%21,5!

$##!-/'*$?!E>!$(%3!%3!$('!&*3'6!(#8'='/6!$(')!$#!0'>%)'!*)5!$('#/5!$(*$!'):

-*-'3!%)!%0'*,%B*$%#)!*3!%0'*,!8#7,0!.'!$#!)>%)'!$('!&*$'-#/5!#>!)#):

%0'*,!$('#/5!$#!#)'!)&'/)'0!#),5!8%$(!='/5!)*//#8!*)0!/',*$%=',5!3%2:

1,'!1/#.,'23?!!

! E$!,0!.'!#.9'&$'0!$(*$!)#!%0'*,%B*$%#)!47)0'/3$##0!*3!$('!2*+%)-!#>!>*,3'!*33721$%#)3!)#)%0'*,!$('#/5!

&*)!.'!73'0!$#!&*1$7/'!$(%3!$/7$(?!F/#.,'23!$(*$!&*))#$!.'!$*&+,'0!%)!$('%/!

>7,,!,'A%$56!$('!#.9'&$%#)!-#'36!3(#7,0!)#$!.'!$*&+,'0!*$!*,,G!-')'/*,:

%$5!*)0!%),'$')'33!*$!$('!'A1')3'!#>!$('!31'&%>%&!*)0!$('!)&/'$'!%3!

)#$!*!1/%&'!8#/$(!1*5%)-!>#/!-*%)%)-!*)!#='/*,,!4.7$!)'&'33*/%,5!3+'8'0

3')3'!#>!8('/'!8'!3$*)0!=%3:H:=%3!*!-%=')!1/#.,'2?!I('!1,*73%.%,%$5!#>!

$(%3!=%'8!&,'*/,5!0'1')03!#)!*!&'/$*%)!1%&$7/'!#>!2'$*:'$(%&*,!/'*,%$5!$(*$!

0')%'3!$('!=*,%0%$5!#>!)#/2*$%='!-')'/*,%B*$%#)3?!E!&*))#$!('/'!')$'/!$('!

,'A!0'.*$'! *.#7$!$('!2'/%$3! #>!37&(!*!2'$*:'$(%&*,!1#3%$%#)J! E! &*)!

#),5!1#%)$!#7$!$(*$!%>!*&&'1$%)-!$(*$!%0'*,%B*$%#)!%3!73','33!/';7%/'3!#)'!$#!*&&'1$!37&(!*!2'$*:'$(%&*,!1#3%$%#)6!$(')!$('!1/%&'!#>!17/-%)-!%0'*,%B*$%#)!>/#2!)#)%0'*,!$('#/5!%3!='/5!(%-(!%)0''0?!K7&(!*!$('#/5!8%,,!.'!7)*.,'!$#!

-')'/*,%B'!*.#7$!$('!1/#.,'23!%$!%3!3711#3'0!$#!3#,='?!@#/!$('!/'3$!#>!$('!

1*1'/!E!8%,,!3%21,5!*3372'!$(*$!$(%3!%3!)#$!*!1/%&'!8#/$(!1*5%)-!*)0!$(*$!

$('/'>#/'!8'!3(#7,0!)'%$('/!/'9'&$!%0'*,%B*$%#)!*3!*!1,*73%.,'!2#='!8%$(%)!

$('#/%'36!)#/!*&&'1$!%0'*,%B*$%#)!*3!*!3')3%.,'!8*5!#>!0%3$%)-7%3(%)-!.':

$8'')!%0'*,!*)0!)#)%0'*,!$('#/5?!!

! L7$!8(*$!*/'!8'! $#!2*+'!#>! $('#/%'3! $(*$! $#! /'*&(!$('%/! )&,73%#)3!

/',5!#)!!"#$"%"&'$()*!>*,3'!*33721$%#)3M!N>!/3'!$('!,*.',!O3%-)%>%&*)$P!%3!/*$('/!%21/'&%3'6!.7$!973$!*3!,#)-!*3!%$!%3!)#$!2'*)$!$#!3$*)0!>#/!O*3:

3721$%#)3!8(#3'!1/'3')&'!/')0'/3!*!$('#/5!73','33P!%$!&*)!.'!,'>$!7)0'/:

'A1,#/'0?!Q(*$6!$(')6!&*)!8'!,'*/)!$(*$!%3!#>!73'!.5!*3372%)-!$('!>*)&%>7,!%)! #7/! )#/2*$%='! $('#/%'3M! @%/3$6! .5! *3372%)-! $('! >*)&%>7,! 8'! &*)! 3''!

2#/'!&,'*/,5!973$!(#8!&/7&%*,!&'/$*%)!)3$/*%)$3!*/'!$#!3(*1%)-!8(*$!8'!

)3%0'/! 0'3%/*.,'! #/! 973$! 8(')! $('5! */'! 1/'3')$! 4*3! ,#)-! *3! 8'! */'!!!!!

&*/'>7,! )#$! $#! *3372'! *8*5! *,$#-'$('/! $('! 1/#.,'2! 8'! */'! $/5%)-! $#!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! CDI(%3! %)&%0')$*,,5! 'A1,*%)3! 8(5! 3#2'$%2'3! *3372%)-! >7,,! ,%*)&'R8(')! >7,,!,%*)&'!*11/#A%2*$'3!$('!$/7$(R3(#7,0!)#$!.'!=%'8'0!8%$(!3731%&%#)!'=')!.5!$(#3'!

8(#!.',%'='!$(*$!)#/2*$%='!$('#/5!273$!#>>'/!73'>7,!1/'3&/%1$%#)3!>#/!73!('/'!*)0!)#8?!


10/22


!

!

"#$%&'()!*+,-.!/01!'2#34&'.!#--,3567!"+#"!+,3#6!6#",1'!8#-!301'!3#&&'9

#:&'!"+#6!8'!"+56%!5"!5-!80,&;!#&&08!,-!"0!-''!+08!0,1!$06$'4"506!0/!#!

1'"5,-")!*+5-!

3#""'1-!60"!3'1'&=! /01! 56"'&&'$",#&! 1'#-06-!:,"!#&-0!:'$#,-'!0,1!%608&9';7'!0/!$06-"1#56"-?-,$+!#-!+,3#6!6#",1'?5-!-,:>'$"!"0!41071'--.!#6;!

1'#&5@567!"+'!6013#"5,15'-!#"!801%.!40&&,"506.!#6;! -0!06)HN!

*+'!$0348"!+'1'!5-!"+#"!5/!8'!/0$,-!06!>,-"!"+'!35-/01",6'-!$06-5;'1';!

:=!F801%56!B#6;!40--5:&=!0"+'1!35-/01",6'-.!-,$+!#-!56/'1"5&5"=.!$06-5;9'1';!:=!F801%565#6-(.

HO!8'!85&&!'6;!,4!0


11/22


!

!

"#$%&'(!")!$*(&+!,"-$+"./!0*1$!23"+4&-!#+5(%!#%!$"!+(,"5-&6(!&%!$*1$!3(!

%*"#.'!-"$!1&7!1$! (-%#+&-5! $*1$! -"!"-(! &%!3"+%(!"))! $*1-!"$*(+%!"-!1,8

,"#-$!")!&-(9#1.&$&(%!"#$%&'(!")!$*(&+!,"-$+".:!;#$!$*1$:!1%!)1+!1%!

3*&,*! $*(! ,"%$%!")!,"7(! $*("+=/!M%!R"*-!2#--!*1%!


12/22


!

!

"#! $%&"'(! $)! "*+,-*-'$! .///! $0-! 1)'1,23")'3!)#!4! $0-)%&! 56"$0)2$!47823$9

*-'$3:! 6)2,7! ')$! %-32,$! "'! 4'&! ')$"1-4;,-! "'1%-43-! "'! $0-! 823$'-33! )#!

)'-!

! ??N'!0"3!4%$"1,-!"'!$0"3!"332-=!A74*!_6"#$!-g4*"'-3!60&!(4"'"'(!4!1,-4%-%!2'7-%3$4'79


13/22


!

!

"#$"! %&! '(()*! +*,&--*.%$"'&.(/! 0)"! "#*1! ")+.! &)"! .&"! "&! 0*! 234

+*,&--*.%$"'&.(5!!

! 6#$"!$+*!7*!"&!-$8*!&9!"#*&+'*(! "#$"!%&! '(()*!+*,&--*.%$"'&.(!0)"!

"#&(*! "#$"! $+*! '.$::;',$0;*! 9&+!)(!#*+*! $.%!.&7

0)';%'.?!'.!&"#*+/!'.$,,)+$"*!,&.("+$'."(@!$.%!"#'(!$99*,"(!"#*!"1:*!&9!(&;)4

"'&.!"#$"!'"!%*;'A*+(5!B)""'.?!$('%*/!9&+!.&7/!,$(*(!'.!7#',#!7*!$+*!('-:;1!%*$;'.?!7'"#!0$%!"#*&+1/!7*!,$.!%'("'.?)'(#!0*"7**.!"7&!9)+"#*+!"1:*(!&9!

"#*&+'*(! ,&."$'.*%! 7'"#'.! "#*! (*"C! >$@! "#*&+'*(! "#$"! 9$';! "&! '(()*! 234

+*,&--*.%$"'&.(!0*,$)(*!"#*1!'?.&+*!"#*!9$,"!&9!.&.-$+?'.$;!.&.,&-4

:;'$.,*/!$.%!>0@!"#*&+'*(!"#$"!9$';!"&!'(()*!234+*,&--*.%$"'&.(!0*,$)(*/!

*A*.!7'"#!9);;!,&-:;'$.,*/!"#*+*!'(!.&!(&;)"'&.!"&!"#*!:+&0;*-!9&+!7#',#!

+*,&--*.%$"'&.(! $+*! (&)?#"5! D! 7';;/! '.! (*,"'&.! E5F! 0*;&7/! %*9*.%! "#*!:&'."!&9! "#*&+'*(!"#$"!$(()-*!).+*$;'("',!;*A*;(!&9!,&-:;'$.,*/!0*9&+*/!'.!

(*,"'&.!E5G/!"$8'.?!):!"#*!#$+%*+!"$(8!&9!%*9*.%'.?!"#*!:&'."!&9!"#*&+'*(!

"#$"!(*$+,#!9&+!(&;)"'&.(!"&!:+&0;*-(!"#$"!,)++*.";1!#$A*!.&!(&;)"'&.(!"#$"!

,$.!0*!("$"*%!$(!234+*,&--*.%$"'&.(5!D!7';;!"#*./!'.!(*,"'&.!E5H/!+*")+.!

"&!"#*&+'*(!"#$"!9$';!"&!'(()*!234+*,&--*.%$"'&.(!0*,$)(*!"#*1!-'(+*:4

+*(*."!"#*!,&.("+$'."(!&.!7#$"!'(!%*('+$0;*!$.%!$,#'*A$0;*!9&+!)(!#*+*!$.%!

.&75!!

!

4.1. Ignoring noncompliance!

D-$?'.*!$!"#*&+1!"#$"!%*('?.(!'"(!+*,&--*.%$"'&.(!7#';*!$(()-'.?!"#$"!

:*&:;*!7';;!,&-:;1!7'"#!$;;!"#$"!,$.!0*!I)("'9'$0;1!$(8*%!&9!"#*-/!7#*./!

'.! 9$,"/! "#*+*! '(! ('?.'9',$."! .&.,&-:;'$.,*! >7#*"#*+! &+! .&"! '"! '(! 7'%*4

(:+*$%!&+!'(&;$"*%@5!=#'.8!#*+*/!9&+!*J$-:;*/!&9!$!"#*&+1!,&.,*+.*%!7'"#!

+*,&--*.%'.?!#&7! "&!*99','*.";1! $.%!I)(";1! (&;A*! "#*! :+&0;*-!&9!:&A4

*+"15!D-$?'.*!"#$"!(),#!$!"#*&+1!+*,&--*.%(!"#$"!$;;!$99;)*."!:*&:;*!%&4

.$"*!$!(-$;;!$-&)."!&9!"#*'+!7*$;"#!"&!$!?;&0$;!9).%5!K'A*.!"#$"!-$.1!

:*&:;*!7&);%!9$';!"&!%&!(&/!(),#!$!"#*&+1!7&);%!.&"!(),,**%!'.!&99*+'.?!$!

(&;)"'&.!"&!"#*!:+&0;*-!&9!:&A*+"1!"#$"!'(!$,#'*A$0;*!9&+!)(!#*+*!$.%!.&75!=#*+*!'(!$!(*.(*/!&9!,&)+(*/!'.!7#',#!"#*!(&;)"'&./!*A*.!'9!.*A*+!$,#'*A*%/!'(!L$,#'*A$0;*/M!('.,*!'"!,&);%!0*!$,#'*A*%!'9!:*&:;*!,#&(*!"&!$,"!&.!'"5!

N)"!'"! '(! $!(*.(*! "#$"! #$(! :+&A*.! "&&! "#'.! 9&+!-$.1! $.%!9&+! "#'(! +*$(&.!

(),#! "#*&+'*(! ,$.! 0*! ,;$(('9'*%! $(! "#*&+'*(! "#$"! 9$';! "&! &99*+! 234

+*,&--*.%$"'&.(5!!

! O;*$+;1/! "#*./!"#*!9'+("!-$I&+!7&++1!+*?$+%'.?!"#*!$(()-:"'&.!&9!9);;!

,&-:;'$.,*!>&+!$.1!'.$%*P)$"*!;*A*;!&9!,&-:;'$.,*@!'(!"#$"!$!"#*&+1!"#$"!

-$8*(!"#*!$(()-:"'&.!7';;!0*!).$0;*! "&!&99*+!$.1!(:*,'9',!?)'%$.,*! +*4

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'.?! &9! &)+! A$;)*(! $.%! :+'.,':;*(! 7&);%! #*;:! )(! "&! ,&-*! ):! 7'"#! 0*""*+! 234+*,&--*.%$"'&.(5!2%$-!Q7'9"/!L=#*!R$;)*!&9!B#';&(&:#1!'.!S&.'%*$;!O'+,)-("$.,*(/M!

!"#$%&'()*"+,'%-.'/+%#0$#*/!"#'(!'(()*/!::5!HTH4UV5!


14/22


!

!

"#$%&'"!()#*!*+!%+!&'!,&$,-./*#',0/!+1!'+',+.23',04!51*0$!#336!#,*&+'/!

#'%!&'/*&*-*&+'/!()+/0!%0/&$#7&3&*8!&/!#//0//0%!&'!*)0!3&")*!+1!*)0!#//-.29

*&+'!+1!1-33!,+.23',0!(&33!+1*0'!70!-'%0/&$#730!"&:0'!*)0!#,*-#3!0;*0'*!

+1!'+',+.23',04!


15/22


!

!

"#$#%&!'(!%)*!+*,$#&-#"#%.!'/!%)*#,!01%#'(&2!3)0%!$'%#40%*&!%)*!0&&5$+6

%#'(!'/!/5""!1'$+"#0(1*7!%)*(7!#&!%)*!8',,.!%)0%!8#%)'5%!#%!%)*!(',$0%#4*!

,*95#,*$*(%&!8*!1'$*! %'!01:('8"*;

%)0%!%)*#,!"*

0&%*,&!0-,'0;!1'5";!-*!L$#&M,*0;!0&!0(! #(;#10%#'(!'/!%)*#,! "*

;*$0(;#(

BN!

! =)*&*!0,*!0""!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BC>04#;!P2!?&%"5(;7!@Q%'+'+)'-#0R!S'(1*&'(!0(;!F&+#,0%#'(!#(!>*$'1,0%#1!=)*6

',.7A!#(!!"#$%&'()%*+,(-$&)(./*+* 0-)1$2$3-)%'1*4&'#"5$&6!LT,#(1*%'(R!T,#(1*%'(!Q(#64*,%.!T,*&&7!UVVJM7!++2!UCN6JC7!0%!+2!UGC2!Q(/',%5(0%*".7!?&%"5(;H&!-'':!'(".!0++*0,*;!

0/%*,!%)#&!+0+*,!80&!011*+%*;!/',!+5-"#10%#'(!0(;!%)5&!W!10(('%!;,08!0&!$51)!0&!W!8'5";!"#:*!%'!'(!)#&!;*/*(&*!'/!8)0%!)*!10""&!)'+*"*&&!L#(!%)*!&*(&*!'/!5(,*0"#&%#1M!%)*',#*&2!

! BGS'$+0,*!)*,*!=)'$0&!D0

! BN>*$0(;&!10(!-*! ;*$0(;#(

%)#&!#&!%)*!10&*!%)*(!8*!0,*!-01:!%'!%)*!+,*1*;#(


16/22


!

!

"#$%&&'!()*+$%&!,#-.+.#(!/)!0%(!1%&&!2%03!#(4!5#!(#$"%+.6)!+7)#$'!0%(!

-.8)9-+),!+7)!8.11.0*&+'!+7%+!%$.-)-!2)0%*-)!/)!%$)!(#+!-*$)!7#/!+#!.(+)$9

,$)+! ,)#,&):-! *(/.&&.(;()--! +#! 0#",&'!2'! 8)0.8.(;! (#+! +#! %-3! +7)"! +#!

0#",&'!/.+7!"#$)!+7%(!+7)'!%$)!+7)"-)&6)-!/.&&.(;!+#4!)(%$=!L>7%+!>)!

H/)!+#!B.-+%(+!H+7)$-=N!-.+!(!)/0#-1!+./.21,#3#4).'.5!)/!O!POQQRSI!OTR9RQU=!,4!OVW4!


17/22


!

!

"#!$%"&'%(!)*%()%+!$*(!)*$&(",%+!-.&!%/0(%##%#!1!0(*0%(!'1(2*$3!)*$#"#4

&%$&!5"&'!&'%!"+%16!7**+89:;!%!&*!1)'"%,%!#*2%!*.&)*2%?!"$!&'"#!)1#%!1!0(*0%(!'1(2*$3!*=!'.21$!%$+#8!!

! %$!"$&*!1))*.$&8:G!H*(%*,%(?!&'%(%!"#!$*&'"$7!23#&%4

("*.#!1-*.&!.$1)'"%,1-6%!(%)*22%$+1&"*$#!"=!5%[email protected]"=3!1#!.$1)'"%,1-6%!

I1#!F!+"+!"$!&'%!0(%,"*.#!#%)&"*$J!0(*0*#16#!&'1&!=1"6!&*!2*&",1&%!0%*06%!&*!

)*2063!5"&'!&'%2!%,%$!&'*.7'!&'%3!+*!$*&!+%21$+!&'%!"20*##"-6%8!#!&'%!+"#&"$)&"*$!-%&5%%$!+%%0!"20*##"4

-"6"&3!*$!&'%!*$%!'1$+!1$+!&%)'$")16!"20*##"-"6"&3!*(!0*##"-"6"&3!*$!&'%!*&'%(8!F217"$%!1!0*6")3!0(*0*#16!#&1&"$7!&'1&!+*)&*(#!#'*.6+!1##"7$!)%(&1"$!2%+")16!&(%1&2%$!*$!&'%!-1#"#!

*=!"$=*(21&"*$!1-*.&!-(1"$!1)&","&3!+.("$7!*$%T#!$*(216!+13!I1#!2%1#.(1-6%?!"$!0("$)"06%?!

-3!-(1"$!#)1$$"$7! &%)'$*6*73!#.)'!1#!=HQFJ8!F! &'"$>!&'1&!5%!)*.6+!)61##"=3!#.)'!1!0(*4


18/22


!

!

! "#$%&%'(! %&%)! *+! ,!-.!$'#)/!-)0!1'#1#2-32! '%4#..%)0*)/! 56%!7)8

-46*%&-93%!26#730!)#5!9%!'%+%''%0!5#!-2! '%4#..%)0-5*#)2(! *5!$#730!25*33!

)#5! +#33#$! 56-5!2746!1'#1#2-32!6-&%!)#!)#'.-5*&%!+7)45*#):!;6*2!9'*)/2!

.%!5#!56%!2%4#)0!2!N%)!6-2!27//%25%0(!5#!*.-/*)%!56-5!$%!-3$-C2!)%%0!5#!G)#$!$6-5!*0%-3!M725*4%!'%


19/22


!

!

"#$%&!#'! ()'*)+&$#%!#%!"(#")(!#(! $,)-*! ./0&$+)! 12!-%-*#32!4$&5! ()*-&$#%6

05$"07! 89-3$%):! &5)%:! &5-&! 2#/! -()! 0)-(+5$%3! '#(! -! *$')! "-(&%)(7! 8%!0/+5!

+-0)0!$&!5)*"0!!()'*)+&!#%!45-&!-%!$,)-*!"-(&%)(!4#/*,!1)!*$;)!)-4*0I0!"(#.)+&!$0!!0))!$&!"()+$0)*2!-0!-%!-&&)9"&!!9#,)*!&5)!+#%,$&$#%0!/%,)(!45$+5! !"#$%&'B-0!#""#0),!!-!()*"#+,%,'-*%B$0!"#060$1*)7EJ!>-4*0:!#'!+#/(0):!9-2!1)!9#0&!$%&)()0&),!$%! &5$0!D/)0&$#%!$)+$.'+

'/$'-$! &5-&! &5)! +#%,$&$#%0! &/(%! #/&! ! 1)! ()-*$0&$+! /%,)(! ()-0#%-1*2! '-6

-4*0:!4"#$%&'+1#+51%2-'##!?N-91($,3):!A-007Y!Z-(-4*0!4)()! !9$0$%&)("()&!45-&! ./0&$+)! '/%,-9)%&-**2!

()D/$()07!_))!^7H7!N#5)%:!6'#&"%-7+4"#$%&'+1-*+83"19%$:! ?N-91($,3):!A-007Y!Z-(


20/22


!

!

"#$%&'!$()$!('!%*!"#$!"'&'**)+%,-!)"*.'+%"/!$('!01'*$%#"!#2!3(#.!.'!&)"!

/'$!$#!41*$%&'!2+#5!.('+'!.'!)+'!+%/($!"#.67!81$!+)$('+!$('!01'*$%#"!#2!

3(#.!2)+!$('!%9'),!#2!41*$%&'!&)"!8'!+'"9'+'9!:)$%8,'!.%$(!"*$+)%"$*!

$()$!,%5%$!$('!';$'"$!$#!.(%&(!%$!&)"!8'!+'),%.%$(!$('!(#:'!$()$!%$!.%,,!+'?'),!41*$%&'!$#!8'!:)$%=

8,'! .%$(! $('! "*$+)%"$*! &1++'"$,-! 2)&'9!8-! ,%8'+),! 9'5#&+)&%'*@ABC!D$!%*!

:+'&%*',-! 8'&)1*'! .'! &)"! 8'! +')*#")8,-! &'+$)%"! $()$! .'! )+'! %"01%+%"/!)8#1$! 41*$%&'E+)$('+! $()"! *%5:,-! )8#1$!.()$! #1+! :#,%$%&),! *-*$'5! &)"!

&1++'"$,-!9',%?'+E$()$6!%2!.'!)&&':$!F).,*G*!)+/15'"$6!.'!.%,,!*''!$()$!

41*$%&'!9#'*!"#$!+'01%+'6!2#+!%"*$)"&'6!$()$!.'!)%5!$#!',%5%")$'!9%*)/+''=

5'"$!#?'+!"&':$%#"*!#2!$('!/##9A!H%5%,)+,-6!$(#*'!.(#!9#!?),1'!=

51"%*$! %9'),*! 5)-! "'?'+! ,')+"! 2+#5! I)+;! (#.! $#! 8+%"/! "%*5!

)8#1$!81$!5)-6!"#"'$(','**6!8'!:'+*1)9'9!$()$6!*)-6!'5)"&%:)$%#"!%*!5#+'!?),1)8,'!$()"!,%8'+),!>"'/)$%?'@!2+''9#5A!J?'"!%2!$('-!"'?'+!$+%'9!$#!8+%"/!

"%*5!)8#1$6!$('-!,9!9'&%9'!$()$!+'91&%"/!),%'")$%#"!%*!)"!%5=

:#+$)"$!$)*K!2#+!1*!('+'!)"9!"#.A!!

! F'2,'&$%#"!#"!%9'),!#+!:+#:'+!41*$%&'!#"!%$*!#."!&)""#$!$',,!1*!.(%&(!

)&$%#"*6!:#,%&%'*6!)"9! %"*$%$1$%#"*! $#!)9#:$6!81$! %$! &)"6!)*!D!()?'!)+/1'96!

),'+$!1*!$#!$('!:+'*'"&'!#2!:+'?%#1*,-!1"9%)/"#*'9!?%&'*!)"9!?%+$1'*!#+!

';:#*'!*#5'!)::)+'"$!?%&'*!)*!?%+$1'*A!L(%*!%*!%5:#+$)"$!*%"&'!$('+'!%*!"#!

/##9!+')*#"!$#!';:'&$!$()$!),,!#2!$('!+'01%+'5'"$*!#2!41*$%&'!*(#1,9!:+'=

*'"$!$('5*',?'*!$#!1*!)*!#8?%#1*!41*$!)*!*##"!)*!.'!++'&$,-!%9'"$%2-!),,!

#2!#1+! "*$+)%"$*A!M,,! %"!),,6! $('+'2#+'6!"*$+1&$%"/!$('#+%'*!.%$(!"#"=MN=+'7'"9)$%#"*!"''9!"#$!8'!5'+',-!)"!';'+&%*'!%"!&,'?'+"'**O!%**1=%"/! +'7'"9)$%#"*! $()$! )+'! "#$! MN=+'7'"9)$%#"*! %*! )! $)*K! 2#+!

"#+5)$%?'!$('#+-!.('"!%$!),,#.*!1*!$#!1"9'+*$)"9!.()$!#1+!?),1'*!+'01%+'!

#2!1*!%"!$('!*%$1)$%#"!%"!.(%&(!.'!2%"9!#1+*',?'*A!

4.3. Misrepresentation of what is desirable and achievable!

P()$! $('"! #2! $('#+%'*! $()$! #22'+!"#"=MN=+'7'"9)$%#"*! 2#+! +')*#"*!

#$('+!$()"!$()$!$('*'!$('#+%'*!(',:!1*!$#!%9'"$%2-!.(%&(!/#),*!.'!*(#1,9!*'$!#1+*',?'*!)"9!(#.!.'!*(#1,9!'?),1)$'!.('+'!.'!2%"9!#1+*',?'*Q!H1&(!$('#+%'*6!D!.)"$!$#!&,)%56!)+'!"#$!$('#+%'*!$()$!.'!51*$!9'2'"9!%"!#+9'+!$#!

9'2'"9!%9'),!$('#+-A!F)$('+6!.'!*(#1,9!+'/"%


21/22


!

!

"#$%&'!(&%)*!+,%-./!01*)($"!+,)+!"+).+(23!4.-$!+,%!(&%)*!("!)+!*%)"+!+,%!5%"+!

6)/!-4!.%)*(7(23!(+89:;!#.>-"%"!%=%2!

(4!(+!1)22-+!-44%.!?@A.%1-$$%2&)+(-2"'!)2&!(+!+,%.%4-.%!&-%"!2-+!,)=%!+-!

1*)($!+,)+!(+!-44%."!)!"+).+(23!>-(2+!4-.!1,)23%8!B4!1-#."%'!$)2/!+,%-.(%"!1)2!5-+,!")/!($>-.+)2+!+,(23"!)5-#+!-#.!=)*#%"!)"!6%**!)"!6,)+!6%!1)2!

C#"+(4()5*/! %D>%1+! -4! >%->*%'! )2&! )+! +,%! ")$%! +($%! 6.-23*/! 1*)($! +,)+!

+,%(.!.%1-$$%2&)+(-2"!).%!?@A.%1-$$%2&)+(-2"!6,%2!+,%/!).%!2-+8!E+!("!>.%1("%*/!5%1)#"%!"#1,!)!1-$5(2)+(-2!("!>-""(5*%'!)2&!5%1)#"%!(&%)*!+,%A

-./!("!2%1%"")./!+-!2-.$)+(=%!(2F#(./'!+,)+!>-*(+(1)*!+,%-.("+"!6(**!(2%=(+)A

5*/!G%%>!1-2"+.#1+(23!+,%-.(%"!+,)+!&-!"-$%!+,(23"!6%**!)2&!"-$%!5)&*/8!

H,%!>-(2+!+,%2!("!+-!G2-6!,-6!+-!(2+%.>.%+!+,%$!6%**8!

5. Conclusion!

E!,)=%!).3#%&!(2!+,("!>)>%.!+,)+!-2%!,%*>4#*!6)/!-4!#2&%."+)2&(23!+,%!1#+!

5%+6%%2!(&%)*!)2&!2-2(&%)*!+,%-./!("!.-#3,*/!+-!1*)""(4/!)"!2-2(&%)*!)2/!

+,%-./!+,)+!(""#%"!.%1-$$%2&)+(-2"!+,)+!).%!&%"(.)5*%!)2&!)1,(%=)5*%!4-.!#"!3(=%2!6,%.%!6%!4(2&!-#."%*=%"!)2&'!)"!(&%)*!+,%-./'!)2/!-+,%.!+/>%!-4!

2-.$)+(=%!+,%-./8!E&%)*!+,%-./'!(4!>.->%.*/!%D%1#+%&'!2-+!-2*/!,)"!)!>-(2+I!

(+!("!(2&(">%2")5*%!+-!,%*>!#"!$)G%!>.-3.%""!6(+,!)!2#$5%.!-4!G%/!F#%"A

+(-2"8!J).!4.-$!5%(23!(..%*%=)2+!-.!$("*%)&(23'!(+!,%*>"!#"!+-!"%%!-#.!>.(2A

1(>*%"!)2&!>.-5*%$"!$-.%!1*%).*/'! (+!%2"#.%"! +,)+!%=%2!6,%2!6%!).%!2-+!$-+(=)+%&!+-!&-!6,)+!1)2!5%!.%F#(.%&!-4!#"!6%!).%!2-+!+,%.%5/!*%+!-44!+,%!

,--G'! )2&! (+! )**-6"! #"! +-! #21-=%.! $-.%! -4! 6,)+! 6%! =)*#%! )2&! ",-#*&!

+,%.%4-.%! >#."#%8! E&%)*! +,%-./! +,%.%4-.%! #21-=%."'! 1*).(4(%"'! )2&! ")4%A

3#).&"!-#.!2-.$)+(=%!1-$$(+$%2+"8!!

! B21%!6%! #2&%."+)2&! +,%! 1#+!5%+6%%2! (&%)*! )2&!2-2(&%)*! +,%-./! +,%!

6)/!E!,)=%!"#33%"+%&!(2!+,("!>)>%.'!6%!6(**!2-+(1%!+,)+!1-$>*%D!2-.$)A+(=%! +,%-.(%"'! "#1,! )"! K)6*"L"! +,%-./! -4! C#"+(1%'! ).%! *(G%*/! +-! 1-2+)(2!

6(+,(2! +,%$"%*=%"! 5-+,! (&%)*! )2&! 2-2(&%)*! +,%-./8! H,("! "#33%"+"! +,)+!

+,%.%!("!2-!.%)*!1-24*(1+!5%+6%%2!(&%)*!)2&!2-2(&%)*!+,%-./8!E2&%%&'!6%!

",-#*&!"%%!)**!2-.$)+(=%!+,%-.(7(23!)"!>).+!-4!)!1-$$-2!>.-C%1+I!+,%!#"%!

-4!(&%)*!+,%-./!+%1,2(F#%"!1-2+.(5#+%"!+-!+,%!#"%!-4!2-2(&%)*!+,%-./!+%1,A

2(F#%"!M)2&!=(1%!=%.")N8!B4!1-#."%'!(+!1-#*&!5%!).3#%&!+,)+!>-*(+(1)*!+,%-A

.("+"!,)=%! )*.%)&/!$)&%! %D+%2"(=%! #"%! -4! (&%)*! +,%-./!6,(*%!2%3*%1+(23!

2-2(&%)*! +,%-./8!H,("!$)/!6%**! 5%! +,%! 1)"%8!O-6%=%.'!F#%"+(-2(23! +,%!

>#.>-"%! -4! (&%)*! +,%-./! )"! "#1,! 6(**! "($>*/! +)G%! #"! )! "+%>! 5)1G6).&"!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :;P(**"'!0QE&%)*!H,%-./L!)"!E&%-*-3/'9!>8!RST8!U-+%!+,)+!K)6*"'!4-.!(2"+)21%'!("!%DA

>*(1(+!)5-#+!+,%!*($(+"!-4!+,%!&(.%1+!)>>*(1)5(*(+/!-4!,("!+,%-./I!0E2!+,%!$-.%!%D+.%$%!)2&!+)23*%&!(2"+)21%"!-4!2-2(&%)*!+,%-./!+,("!>.(-.(+/!-4!.#*%"!V+,%!*%D(1)*!>.(-.(+/!-4!+,%!*(5A

%.+/!>.(21(>*%!-=%.!+,%!-+,%.!>.(21(>*%"!-4!K)6*"()2!C#"+(1%W!6(**!2-!&-#5+!4)(*X!)2&!(2&%%&'!

6%!$)/!5%!)5*%!+-!4(2&!2-!")+("4)1+-./!)2"6%.!)+!)**89!K)6*"'!!"#$%&'("&)"*+,-./%'!>8!;SY8!


22/22


!

"#$%&"!$%#'!%&()!*+!,-$%!,%#$!,&!+%.*(/!0&!+$"-1-'2!$.!#3%-&1&4!'#5&(64!

0"-'2-'2!).(-$-3#(!+3-&'3&!#'/!'."5#$-1&!$%&."6!3(.+&"!$.2&$%&"!-7!,&!#"&!

$.!+.(1&!$%&!*"2&'$!)"#3$-3#(!8*&+$-.'+!$%#$!3.'7".'$!.*"!+.3-&$-&+9:;!

!Zofia Stemplowska

.(-$-3#(!?%&."6!>.(-$-3+4!@3%..([email protected]#(!@3-&'3&+!

A'-1&"+-$6!.7!#$$-!?#5#"#!J&'#"/4!K#'-&(!#+$&"'#C4!I.'#$%#'!M*.'24!#'/!J#*"#!N#(&'$-'-4!#+!,&((!

#+!$%&!&/-$."+!.7!$%-+!+)&3-#(!-++*&4!E'2"-/!O.0&6'+!#'/!F/#5!@,-7$4!#'/!#'!#'.'65.*+!

"&7&"&&!7."!3.55&'$+!.'!#'!"(-&"!1&"+-.'!.7!$%-+!)#)&"4!#'/!$.!@."-'!H#-#+*4!P#$%&"-'&!

Q//64!"-."-$6! -'! >"#3$-3&!=.'7&"&'3&!#'/!$%&!R*77-&(/!>.(-$-3#(!?%&."6!\."C+%.)9!

1. what's ideal about ideal theory - stemplowska

Documents