1

The INTOSAI Working Group on Key National Indicators

Pilot project on Key National Indicators

(within the framework of the Commonwealth of Independent States)

The 3rd meetingApril 7- 8, 2010, Astana

Scheme of projects interrelations

INTOSAI

INTOSAI Working group on KNI

Established according to the decision

of the INTOSAI XIX Congress

Expert groupon KNI in the framework

of the CIS

Established according to the decision of VIII

session of the Board of Heads ofSAIs of the CIS member-states

The Board of Heads ofSAIs of the CIS member-states

2

Project realization

The 1st Meeting of the INTOSAI Expert Group on KNI

Moscow, December 17, 2008

The 2nd Meeting of the INTOSAI Expert Group on KNI

Astana, May 20, 2009

The 3rd Meeting of the INTOSAI Expert Group on KNI

Moscow, November 26, 2009

3

Project realization

• Systematization and estimation of peculiar features of

national strategic planning systems;

• Particularities of a regulatory framework and Performance

auditing experience;

• Peculiarities of development of a system (set) of key national

indicators used in the SAIs activity.

4

Project realization

Outcomes:

• Analysis of international experience and perspectives of

the use of KNI in the CIS member-states SAIs activity;

• Draft Guidelines for the use of key national indicators in

Performance audit;

• Glossary.

5

Structure of Draft Guidelines for the use of KNI in Performance audit

• The term of performance audit;

• Performance audit purposes;

• Spheres of performance audit;

• Performance audit steps;

• Methods of collection and analysis of information;

• Preparation of an economic-methodological basis of the audit;

• Performance audit criteria determination;

• Methodology of indicators/key national indicators selection in performance audit;

• Development of key national indicators system;

• Definition of audit evidence and received data analysis;

• Preparation and distribution of the report on performance audit results;

• Monitoring of recommendations realization;

• Glossary. 6

www.ach.gov.ru www.prognoz.ru

Счетная палата

Российской Федерации

Term of Performance audit

Performance audit purposes

Spheres of Performance audit

Performance audit steps

Methods of collection and analysis of information

Preparation of an economic-methodological basis of the audit

Performance audit criteria determination

Methodology of indicators/key national indicators selection in Performance audit

Development of key national indicator system

Definition of audit evidence and received data analysis

Preparation and distribution of the report on Performance audit results

Monitoring of recommendations realization

Performance experience Glossary INTOSAI Working Group on KNI Knowledge base

ACCOUNTS CHAMBEROF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

7

www.ach.gov.ru www.prognoz.ru

Счетная палата

Российской Федерации

Reflection of the CIS strategy in national strategies of the CIS member-states

ACCOUNTS CHAMBEROF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

Growth of real GDP – 2,4-2,7 (to the level of 2007)

Moldova: Dynamics of GDP growth rate

Conception of long-term development of the Russian Federation: Dynamics of real GDP (% to the level of the previous year)

Conception of long-term development of the Russian Federation: GDP on PPP

per capita US dollars)

Conception of long-term development of the Russian Federation: Indexes of GDP

volume, constant prices

8

Working Plan of the Expert group on KNI for 2010

• Approval of the Draft Guidelines at the X Session of The

Board of Heads of supreme audit institutions of the CIS

member-states in September - October 2010;

• Submission of the Guidelines for consideration of the

Inter-Parliamentary Assembly of the CIS Members as an

international standard on audit activities.

9

Expected outcomes

• Development of a framework logical model of SAIs activity within

the KNI system for the purpose of development and realization of

national strategies for socio-economic development;

• Providing conditions for online (via the web-site) communication

of representatives of SAIs and external experts on the socio-

economic development assessment on the basis of KNI;

• Organizing a number of seminars and trainings for

representatives of SAIs within the framework of Performance

audit for the purpose of supporting the corresponding initiatives

within SAIs.10

11

Expert Group website

All the materials presented in the report are available on the

permanent site of the Expert Group

http://www.ach.gov.ru/ru/cis/

12

Thank you!