)1 !i 5 participants - ca state lands commission...

/,

~.

,, t .. - "'f i'. . .

'\i .· .... . ·~\) ~·

'~

"

..

' fl /

_ .... JlfWilltM-M-•M-lllll_Jl_!•-bUt••-----.. W""M~~~ ... -~Utl:i-liill:J_U_..,t .... -··--w_,_l! __ ._..,~,....~·P':f!'rt•il•• .. -:.~ 11 ~Ylt-fi11'0fll*)'l __ 1 'r?~ti•"1lhtl!ll!fMlilM uc . .-.c

l.

2

3

4

5

<•$ ,.,

7

a 9,\

10

ll

12 .. /,""""

14

15 l

10

17

18

19·

ao 21

22

23

24

2~

28

'•

SACRAMFJfTO, CALtFORNIA APRIL 12, 196.l I

)1 11 \J /}

!I ./

PARTICIPANTS: a:: ....... n • t':L !~"- i ~

-~ -,.1

T~:~ .• ~.P!!I;,§~}9Y,:

Alan Cranston., Controller, Cbairrna.n Glerm M. Ande:cson,.;;L1eutenarit Gove1--n:or John E. Carr~ Dir~,etor of Finance

\)

F. J°' Hortig,~eoutive Offieer Don .Rose, Executive Secretary to <Lieu·tenant

Governor AndEU?Son ··

OFFICE OF THE ATTGBNEY GENERA.! ... : •• n1·" -_ 11 , 1 •~, ,ft'

I

Jay L. Shavelsort, Deputy Attorney General

(In the ox10.er of their ~ppeat-ia.nce}

Joseph A. Ba1l, Esq. Representing Richfield O:LJ; Corporation

R~ W~ Ragland, Vice President Richfield Oil Col"''f?O:ra.tion

Miles w. Newby, Jr. Rep~esenting Texa.e-0, Ino.

J. Barton Hutchins Representi~1g Edwin Pauley Associates

Edmund D .. Buokley Eep:r•esenting T:tdewater Oil Company

Geoi;ge :':Cetchuro. Rep:t"esenting Mobil Oil Company

Eln1o:t'e Hutoh.tson, Consultitlg Enginee1~ for Auooc:l..atod Contractors

I,

1"1'~ul Home, Hep1,eoentlng Stan.clatld Oll Company oi.' CalJ •. ro1,n1.a, Weotern O_tH~1latlons

···~

',•i 11

G

II ;;,

'"

~-

~f

6

7

8

10

I 11

12 1.

13

14 .9

16

,, 16

(I 17

18 (1 191

20 • '(l 01

IQ '

22

23

24

23

,» 26 ., ." , "

f ··01 c:' .• '

H~'f,fil} \.lllM *"P ,J

" ( ......... 111...,._,.._•I" ·-•let-' _....,_tw.IP•-•J-'lllA41....,...__, -· ""'"_"'_"'_l ...... tlMl•~~l-H -Mfl ---·•-I -iitin-im ·-··~-'r'10-w~; -...~ h 1' ,J.~>i if* IQii;o;•t.Mj~ ... !•IO*l try·

2 PERMI.!S~ EASEMEN~S, L'EAS1:i3, AN1\ RIGHTS-@F-\&MY MW F'EE,

I

(a)) C. Edward Chrlstol~f'e~son,

( b) Howard P. E:i ts c:t1

{o) Del Monte Properties

( d) John tlrarr~

Lee· 11. Miller

Co.

i'hillips :Petrolewrl Co~

17 16

7

9

13

10

l

ll

13

14 ·. (e)

(r)

(g), Emerson A. Ray and Richard Castle · 18 16

(h,) Signal 011 & Gas Co.

(l) Signal 0.:1.l & Gas Co .. ,, ' " \

( jtc. '\,A/

Lindsey H .. Spight '" J '

(k) tJ.,. S ,JSo .rax: & Che~nica.l Corp.

(a) Pier E - Water mains under entrance charj,nel and noJ:-th

3 17

19 19

8 20

of pier E (2nd phase) 23

(b) Ap:p:t"oval ,(~irst axnen.dro.ent to Unit Agreetnent Fault~ Block III, Wilmington Oil F1ield 20 25

l.J. Authori:.::m.t:ton t1) apprctin~ o.nd recrrrd maps ... Stt.t.Yey Mes.a High Tid~ · Llne HoJ.:e Moon Bay iJ,f. 26

continu©d

\,

'r I' <I,

''"'' ,,,'·,..'*"iif ·' " . I

I

l

l

l

1

2

3

3

4

4.

6

'7

7

I

l

I I f

i]

Aitthorizatiox,i for m.1neral extraction l~ase ofter -Lentz Co:nstxiuf,rtion Oo1npany 10

1.J.

12 l 131.

8 ·.1;1;~.t~hori'.zativ11 to' iatfu.e oil ant:.l . gas lear~e tti Texaco Inc 4J

on l?aro.e:L 2, W$0.38lO,

14.

16 9

l6 .. 10

17

lfl'

lS ll

20!12

211 I ~~ 3

22 J J..

San.ta 13a1"'ba:rJa ,. Q~unty

MOTION ON ITEM 8

..,l\uthorisat ion ·~o of£e1? Para el ii, Santa Barba.1;a cou~nty

Conf''tr-ma.ti9n of e:maot:ttive

Report

Report on ata.ti.,1s of land as.lea prog1~ams

Report on 1'0.a.jor l:.i .. t:Lgation

6

21

15

4

1

23

5

23 llt, Rev.i:ew of aalen<'laring proced:ures 24

24

25 15

30

33

34'"'35 34 36

40

13

31

32

35

26

Issuance dredging. pemnit to Aaooc:l.ated Contrtlctars, i./S~.lt W(irks Canal, Richardson Bay, r1ar:i~n Co i1c 25 46 lt3 .,.

I

16 --·-"_e_t_~rm,._tn_a_t_1_o_n_o_r_n_e_.r_ .. t __ 1_ne. ___ e_t_1_n_e; ___ . _____ ·_" ___ 4_l~--~_}

1 -,;, .

3

10

1:1.1

.12.:·.1 l.~.

"'1'

141· 16 l

17

18

19

20

22

24

25

26

; ' I' t lllJif'l*•~~-.t.-~.ltllM, ... 1- ...... f!l ___ il~..-;)'<luu1~c...,.wWii¢ I

' / /{

I!tttEX IM ACOOIL.~A:ttll1i~ W!TH ITEM NiMBERS ~~)l.~i~\io~14-·.i111r1 \1tt~~-t,..Mlirl~1'ftt'r.' ~·~~,~·'9i~J nrlf##'1lfr<t'!lt'f!'OI ''

l

2 2~ -~'.') ...) .l'l

4 33

5 ~8 ..,.;,!....-.!'

6 2?

~1 J..l I

8 20

9 1rt• ,,t .J

10 15

l'l ..,. 21

12 ">1 ~...-.;.

13 14 l t~ 'f··. 26

15 .30

16 -:,') 17 l

18 16

19 19

20 25 2"' .l. 20 .;,

Ot'J f;.t;;;, 36

23 31

2)+ 1+0

~~'-' -· lt~ ~:;

1

4

2

5

14 2

13

l

3

4

12

32

33

.35

... ~~ lt 3--

I i l

I (

I

ii

a Z'b:!rrt ~ 4""fl!OJ .Pe:!Mltil,ts, :easementtt, le;a,$8S ~I~ 1~:tghts-o.e;..

7 w~ 1.s~¢. ll·.n'$u~.t t:, etat~llelil and ~st~bi:LJ'lhed i::vental and tet ,, S1· po£1'0ie~ of. t:Q.e Co~11lh:I.,.si~n., ._ . .. , . · 1

9 : . 11m.. HOm.'IG i . Ml''.· C'na.1.rman¥ as to Item 2( a) , we have l J.O.+. ;i:'.ll!it 7L'lllceivM. an :: :. .. . :".Y. ~d a serj.U of q.uest.t-nS X.CJ.ativei I

' '" ' ,',· 1/ .. , i '

ll t.o proeedure1 f'l"Oill t.rie ·Oftice Qf the. At~borntiy' Genera:l. a,ud_. , ,, 'I '-

12 . ·· tlleref ore, 1t :ts 11equea:t$d that:· actil'.:ln' on 1tam {a} be· d~ferx'

,. .. Ri.ts~h -" 'tli~l v@ tJta-yaa1~ prospecting pe~i ta tor m.1n~11ra,ls l7J

~!9·,f otber tlrmn oil snd·gas ....... .

19 r>m. HOfl.'.l1IGt Excuse me, ~. Chairman. r

ao I statemeQ.t should have beer~ made also with respect to item {b}J I

2ir. t· as to necer;s1ty for di$cussion with t~ Off:l.ee of the Attbr.ne ·

! I

go over. I1'em (c) - Del Monte Properties Oompan::,r -- l5-1a;.u; I tiithou.t otljection that i·tem wi.11

2.a cove, Carmel Bay, Pebble Bea.oh., Monterey Couutv,, tor a pier ________________________________ _,,.,_..._ __ __

,-)' \ '' I .; " ,, • I' '

, t""'"'--~_......,,__ ..... -·~·-· .. -~~-~q,lf~~)ilOl;lllO - .. -...~~-i\o!,~1f~-""""''l;'lt.~.~·~~-.. ,,

1 f to:t" 3~J.e u.Se .9t m&mben1 and gu.ccb& of li!Ullwae~.i;i Y;11.~hi• Cl~b t ·

2 [ ar.m~l re1ata1,. $~:rr.42. . A'tff: Co!lllll.~nt3 on t;ht\t itl~m'l'

at· · , .. ."·MR~ .s:!O.~~IG: ' :tt is· ata~t1Ji$,~~, and li1 at~¢:otid\~nc·e. w.1.tb,,

· 4· estttb11st~d 'pol1cy a..l1d ruleiJ; nnd l?i~gl.tlations of the b\t~~rte.

e-ll Lands o($nun~~a_s. 1u~: . ? .· s . .. .MR41: '11'\ti.NS~ON ~ Shal:t w~ 11,~oceed to th~1: othel" · it,~~'tl:a

0 ' , '

7 j a,,?ld "IOt;e 01i, ·them altegetll~x)? . '

~ ~·~a~;, a;,az:L_rtg and reoreational li,~aae,111 290 ao1-:.es ,,,~aeeasi(.~n

9 in Owens Dey Lake, ltcy--o County; t;otal rent;al, $292<$50"1

la MR. HORTIG~ I wJ..sh to di:t~~~ot the attent1.on of' tit.::;a

f 11 f Cowi?.i§iH.iliQ,n~ )it-i;.. G~~irrt1an,, to t;he f•~~t tha:t 'th~ l.~st 1.!lve-;f~e.x~: ..

12 I rental on thin same I!X'Ope;t>ty prio:r.- to rea,ppnliisal by the State

131 Lands :ttl.vis:i.on '!'las $50 i'or thie tn~a1 period. On reappraJ.<il:ll.. I 14·· ...• ,.. and :'IA a.ccort!rul.ce wl tla establi. shed ~~al policies of' the CCllll~,., ·

l ilt ~..,,,.lJ.';;.id,!!t"'l":i .t.·.h-:'rs_ "•'11l" 'b6 j1':1C""'7~q;ii(~•·\\.A "°'O ~~l"'lilt"J t!.Q ·· ._.. ••.t .... 11<'H~..l\....,~.i.,t 11.f.i; . .t...,.~ p. , ~~ , '"'• ···"' .i..·""""""~'•1~.4 V .· yJ:<-.;¥&;.4t',,,I • . l

... , is .. 1 MR. ORAN$m.N: Item ( e) ·..:.. :Lee R. Millar -· ;;~e1111iit to i1

· ,:. · l 7' exaa11at,g a,pprox:J,.mate1y 150 aab:l.10 yard.$ of matt;)rial, at · ro¥t\lty ·

:~,:·:~/ ii

19 Ox•eek, Ma.1 ... in Collb.ty;., . Any comment~~ on that ~ne? ,,

20

2l w:Lth rules and :regu.lations and polic.iee of' the Com.mission~

I /,

[email protected] survey perrnlt fr•t'Jm All:~·il 12, 196~

l?~trr,leUlll OompallY{ ... ;

to October· 12 •• "

l'vlR.. MOR~IG: E:i~cui..10 nw~, t61. - .. ~ 11'" you ha"'le that cor ....

25 rectioriJ rather t%.m.n 162; a t¥pog~aphical er:tlor- ..

26 - ..... -----.~~-~ .~~~on tlde-·a--n-d-~i-tl_b_n_1e_r_g_:i-e_·~d--l-t:t_n_d_u_1_ja . •')~ · •. -~ lil<W,Jlit l#il'O

S•

I ":'· . !I \ .:, . ,• '. : • l\ . ' ·. . f . ,;i. ' .1'i ''· . •• ·: ·, . "\• ? :·. . ' it •. I : ' !. . I. • :· ·! . ' . ;r . . ·~~<!'"""~,_..,,~~-"'· ~~··"'1*~ ... -,··-;r:-\· .... ···-,.~~~i._,~,:-~":'~··~ ... ,. 2·1•·· lWiJ~ r1~twe~n liri~ ~h,1~ wef.lt :f~om .:roin~e A_rcg1.1,ll~~ ~ih'.~11. B~be .. :t~

. . g 1 ooimt:Y, and ~hs ~~b~J.~n 11.e,.Wiu.•'d, .~· .,he· ~or~h~l:-~ ~~it" o;f

s ,{ tZ1e City· ot' .i~e'1JOl1~~ B~i;\qp, ~9~vig~ ··-0e1µi1r~ / '\~i~, ~Pll'L~h11~ 01i,_ th ~. ~1 . •ff,· ', . Mli,. Ht}B!tt~l: No ·st??' """~ a.i; ~andalid. ··a.t)pUcat1on,:1 b~' · ,,,·· }

1$ > . .Pl'lJ.ll;tps to enl!~e ;).tl 1teo:J.og.to~l e~~oi-~f;;\;P.):q. :tndl v~i.i~l . f ; a I welle 4i~11l.e_d -.~~nde.r i:;hi' .11f:l'l~it.. •:r:~,·-~tl;t~ B.12b~eb1f tw ir~a:tvi~u~ 7 i a~PP:ttQva1 as t5" looati.on ~nd depth tttt wbie1il they;.wou.ld :be f ··

,.

10 and. :ftlclmx"d Oaflt.;b~ -~ ll1'Pl?ovaJ. of· a0Si$lnlet1't; to B*1eebj,.e B,.

ll. f Walpo~ ()f. Min~t'la.l ~tlraeti·on · Lea.r;t• P.R. o" "1407 .1,2,:··.:;160 aerea f

1.2 s~oq:L· lanrl@· ~ San Earnaro;f<no .Cotm:t;~· .. ,, ' '

·IG't\ aon!!IG: ~hil subje~t ~eaae :Ls s. snaall nd.~e~~af '-\

) .. 4 · . lease {mdel? Wll1;t.on· 'VOloanlo mii'\e:rals !\lN~a ... extJ?acted f ~r u$~ a.s

ia ·· aggregate p1'1.tnUil7.

16,;.

11 .. l;) ... [email protected]~ (

Ml~~ CIANSTOM.;. :tt.Cr4 (b} - S:tgrml~ Oil Md Ga1l a~·;u~p ~-

let<H, 9.71 aeres tttkl alld. ai.tblllq,rged lands ;tn ()arqui .

Cont:tc.1£ Cos;\;a; County() fo~~ ult.:lm.ate use as a ah:t.pping ·

As outlined on the ~genda item, pages · J.

I 24'J join,.\ng u_pland for futut~a i1sa.ge, d~sire~: tlt!s expanded: typ~l o

25 operatlon a.nd in acvo:i.~lance With appra.lo3ls o.f: the li1.n~a value( ,

i.---~----_,,,...._ __ __. __ ..._._.,.,_ro._· --~•....--..n-·_..~---·-··--·~---,-,_1•-u¥..._....,.e;•-•-,;~-·--------••-·-n--•--h'-•-""

,, 'r

'c•'.>., ··.·. ' '

1- Ji

{'' .I

'\ /J

' ---· ' -" ,, . '

111·i;..~.a; ~-~u-r!O;J~~·1'1d' . .,r't ,.~-.. .. ,.,.,. ·•t;t•• .. 'jf tfil'lii lllhl1ii11Jl!li~~·r

4

l . y· - , , , r,

i1;e1n ( 1). .... S1e;nn.l OJ~l and Gaq · Com-

3 .. J:ff.le-t.supj.lOrtitd. d:t-11.lling g:ncl p1.,6duetior1·: plat.ftt-r1n a,pprox.:tm.e"te.ly .

7 ,ooo t~e1; :CX'Oln;J'shove' w.tth:l.ti arQa Qt. Oil and Gas Lease P:n.Q. j ' e 4~511.lJ tl\Ult-instotli· ~attn ~10-ld.,l( O~at)ge.\ Csunty,, .·. ' I a}'. MR. HOR~l<l: As t~ie C'munitH:Jion if» awai~e.t! Signal Oil I 1 L and Gas <'.om'.P(Uiy a~ the :Principal lessee of the state Lan<ls I e11. Conuni~\l3-:L'C.r1 in tine liuntit1gton Beach area !)'f Orange .Ceunt~ and ):

9 in oo~ct.1on with the e.ddit:Lot.tal d©V&lopment o~ existing

lb i leases 1·t ha2 been d$·te.rm1ned to be deai;-eable and necessaey

ll tl~at a plat1)'0rm be placed oftsno~e. 711 000 .feet -""' .tffshore

12 ~ r~oughlil a nd..le and half ........ :!.n olJder to pertn.i t the· moat. eff'ec"'"'

1'3 tive devel.-0pt:11etlt oft th,ase ie~s.ee., which have b~en .. in existenc

14 ,;··in the majority. dt'' cases ··(th~ leia~efJ havej ~inaa 1938. All ' ~ '

15 requiuit~ approval,s ox· nonooject:tons f:t'lOPl the Departmen,t of.

J,'1 ·

18 I ·. 3.trl

20

22., 23 j 24 f

25

26

GOV~ AlID.rutSON: How t•ar is that from the next near- l est; the otn~r 1 ... sland O\l.t th~~t:t? ·· · ·

MR. HOR~!G: Maza1~ilng a guess, about s.ix miliJta

;;-:, j\ )~-,, -t~ );:;"

"'>;; '~

1!1

)I ff ·;1 .

-··· ' '' ....

If

. ' " ' ' ' ,, '. ,' ' ' '' •·,, ' . ' ,. ' ' '., .. ,, . ' . . . .. ;.'· " . .5 . ~--··• .. k• '""'""""'-'·''1o0!""""' ·•.hl<'-~--.,...~ ............ _111·~-,~~·~.._ "''""l'.Wi~~··-~!lolol .. -~."ll••-'liil*l

1. 1 . · .. Mit· .c 1:on.':PIG: ··Tb• ~asEu1t:..t~1 ,. item ·~o Ql~11ni to,, t11e;~ s.t·t·~r,~

a ·-t:t~n o:C the Ccntim.i~sion :f,N oonnec\\~On/'w!.1$h,·tbis item., wh.i.Oh is \~o··· . . '"'N} . ,.· ,, . ~-,

3 ro:r.") ·itdc11t101ia:l ur,Jaf;e' of' an tixJ.atclnh\.St~te lea$~ on tcip ¢f Mt:.,. ·-''/: '. ' "\\_ .

4 Diabl'o, ·is the fact ··that ·the Ooroa'linic~~.ioi~s· Dif.'As:t~oit ·o~ tb.i .. ~ ~

e; .1, DeJ;tax~tw..ent ·.of Fin~nce have reported there _'.k~ .no obja¢t,:ton to .

' 1 a t~ia sublea~e in teirma cJf the, op•re.ti.on crei.~tit1g ~m~-+ dif.f'!-...cul·t;teG·

7' in .aonnec.tion -with Ste,te cc-imnunicat:toris alre~.dy e:xist111g on 1 ·

a Mt. D1a.b1o ~ I 9 M('I. CRANS'l'ON: Item {k) -' U. s. B'orax and Chemic;U l

10 Corporal:;ion -~ :E'.xtension of' tel:'l11 of Mi11eral Extl:'action Lease I 11 P.R .. O"' 736.2.t Inyo Cour.t:t;y, ~t royalty ra·f;ef$ as sp,aclf1edJ' fox•

1

\ 12 ten y~ai"js· conmtenatng May ll; 1962.t pursua...,,,.t. t111 Se.~tio.n' 18 cf

13 the lease,, to exp,l,ore and develop new areas of ·t:;he m:tne.. II.

14 Amr commenta on tfhat? I

15··1· MR,,. HQltTIG: Slnce I1t1ay the 11th$ 192:2 there ho.a been! .. . I i

16 ! a mineral extraction lease on the subject lands held by the l . · 17 ' pi;>edecess<irs in interest to U. S. J50~1ax and Chemical Corporil.tTJ11,,:

l8 ~o currently hol.d the last ex·tensiori of the part:icu.la:r.• lease.,

19 , The company; ha& 'beet} in the proees~ of developJ...ng new mark~~ ,. '

20

2l

23

25

26

utiliza'l;;icnis for the product which is mj,ned 1 whic.11 ls an in- ·

solub'le borate; and in order to be ce:t··taJ.n th.at the additiona.

capital improvements tio further develcp the h1a~ket would be

I f

they are entitled under· law, eo1iside:i:~.,ation. b~f the Lands Conm1iQ

sion for· a tcn-yoar ~xt~nolo:a ~li'* the lease otart~tne; May ll;1

1962, tho a:p~lcru:t de~rl~t. ~~- ~e co1'~:_t1~ thio e:.::101

..• ,.

,\ )f

.. ,· ., .. .. 6. \ ~-· «·1'~~¥ttt)f-'1:H :--,.,.:ldiil\;i totw-_>*i;•;rOf -~;:··-~'mf8 ·.~ (~~HI ill!i..i111.~~ltht -~1•.r"':·~~ l~,.:11•-Jw11••illf11l~O•.~·--w~•· ---lilof

1 ~· . w:t.iJ, be gra<lt'i~fjct it'i orcae1J that ·thm~· can procea~'L .t~rune"iiately ~ .'.• _;.: ' '.< ' " • \.t. '-"•.:_ , " I \ ~·

w.t th~ ;tbei::*. (;.apital !avest't1tent'( ~nd ext.er1$:lon . oi' tl':I.~: pperat:lcxt\. ;, )·J !• -~' •, y· --- ~-

Ali\d.:;. in ·1ConJ1ection witb -t:tu~ rpropo~ed .e~ts2ir)10~1 . ., in~· . • • - -- - '• - , ~ , . " ' -? I; ,

.fr.I'" "aJ3mue::fl afl. 'it :!:r,;, undel:' ·the st~u;u.te and .in· 1t:ne. l~~.$~ t,el1Rl&,,

i-· ~~a~r SU·eh teri1ns and· 09nditions wh.1c.h ·1;ne {lotrm1$.f{i6n nvt4y,: pr.f.i

a I ll~'ibe, ;l.t is propc:isSd that tile ~yaJ.tZI: adhe'duJ.e be rev:t~ed 7 f. upwa11tt to ~etl.ect the . improvement. in the value o.f tlie ,,tiror.:H.ic·t

··~.al a:qd th$ :t.~:P:rova:m.ent 1n t11~ mttr'ket&'bilit¥ ot the·· pX~oduct ·w!d;l'lh

. 9 f wi:ll bei; mJ.ned. ir1 the tuture as a resu.!t oi' the e~tensi@n oi' 1

...

lO J tP,ese ope3'a.t1ons ~ f . ·. 11 l · aov.r <!< AN.DEP..SOl{: I move tlloae items t1l1de:rr Class:t.fica-.

t:ton " . ,.

rm. CAM: Second ..

lS Beaoh:, . (~) Pro,Jeot is P1.er •t1.ir -- Water malns u...11der (intran.c.e . '

"'• "" }

19 cbannel and n9rtt1 of Pier nEt1 (2nd phaae); estimated ~'ubprojee .~

20 l

• i;rt- ¥•

e::1;penditure t}rom 4/12/61 to te~rm:L:t7.a:ti.on of $2ll0,000 with 78%

21 l ar $187 j.tt?OO . eat:tniated .. . I .

2~ that item?

2'3

24

25

26

MR. HOrezIG:

MR. CRANSTON:

" ' I?

~ .~):I~~~ I,,

.iJ·r)'

'--!.·\

r,,1,P , ~~\>

r :'! \'-'.i..· ):):"/" :4 H

•

. '

' ,,

·.;--

• ~ ~ h

£1.rlf'.t, a.riiertt'un~nt1 tc:> "Uni~ Agreement, FtAt1lt B16ck III;;. W1:t.• ', •\ .,

3 m~ngt'on Oil li~i~ldj to change the· :Lnt~rlm equi't.y a.rr101tJt-a·t~ .t~o·

4 . that thelt o~form mor~ nearly tf>R Vt1e: .:e:tn~l rey.ts·~3 equi~

PJ amounts :tor· th-e variouo prod~J.cere.,. .lny eommentrJ on th~t. 1t,em.?".

MR. RORT!G; Yes str. With ;tour approval, Mr. Chliirt 11. man.1 it is recommended tllat thG recorri •. rn.~ndatton 'be modif:teq. to I 8 read that~ '':tt is r~cQmrr1ended tb.a·t the Qcimm.iss;ton approve the

' ' ' . first amendment to Unit Agreement, Fh.)..~t Block III, Wilm:'i..ngton~

·co the c 011 ..... :i.o I ~iJ. Field, LQs Angeles County, Clal1fo:1m1a,. subjeet

111· dit:l~on that t:;he City submit: (l) Ey:ldenae t.hat a:.'ll other pa.r·ti a

12 to the ag:tt(-:ement have agr~~etl. to the am.endnient. a

l311· ~his modif:Ldation is .r:econnnended because ,the ox~igina

14, eondition proposed, rfiq1J:.tr'itlf.l'' approval subjeot to J:>esolut,1.ons , l ' .

15

l"l l lutions hftve, been received by the S.tat e Lattds Com1uis·sion*

Any eommente on th:is item?

I rnove :J.. f:; •

ia-l 19 J :respo1'lse·} If not, mot:to;n :ts in or'd.er.

2oj 21 ~m .. · It.

22 MR. CRANS'!'ON: is moved, seeo~1.dt~d and, m~de J

23 · .. uxian:Lmous ly. i i~i:,c~uti v~,I 2~i Item Classlfictttion 4 .... -. A.uthQriza.i';ion' fen."

2S I O:.:'l'leer to approve and have l'CCOX'df>d Shoet:J l tln•ough 9 or I

26 Lnpu ont.:1.::_"oui~~ ~-~~~l= M~un l:~f:lh '.i:td: L.L~:.~:c t._h_o __ ....

:· 1

l I 1 I

, I 'I

l :'1 I

\\ 1--1

.. : ····· ············· )1·r··., ·

. . ,,. e ...

1

/l ~~~1rt•~~11,.~ ... .._.,.,.., ..• .., • .,...,W1J11MM••u11~.i~..,.~~"' ·•i>11t w.-;<t"" ••~••W tiii»111r~..,.,,~~110-u•M1t ~·••·•u"181i'Wt·w:1n'!i#11Q/1k1 ilA'-i« " i

i 'I SncJ.'.•e of.' Hal.I.' M•)On Bay, !Jan Ha tc o County, Cal Li.' or·nJ,a, " dated ! I ,.,. .. , "',. '" .,,, I.

~· .. , ... u,.· nt1a1.·y J.:;::,.),9 (, .tl.n~t' ~1omme.nta on that .. 1.'ten1? .I/.

s .· . . 'JleUt. Ufi)R~IG: Pursuant· to a.tatutory grant <o:e a:t?ea or:t" I

4J~:r.hc-19te .fx•o.m Hal.t r1lo,on Bay,, I3an 1'Uiiteo County to the Z ;..n. r.Ia,.teo ·1 . c 0 .. \ I_/

51· Cc-u:lt¥ Harbor Di~·t:t~l<.rt 1 . wh:tch by a·ta.tute rcq,uired survey by

a .the state Landll Commission at the coat of. i::he gi>antee, ~~cil ,, I ~71 surt;ey was completed and P:t."lnta in reduced ai.ze of the ;&he:,3tn

~

.. al~jas co1r£pleted are atta.ahed to your calendar iteni. and 1,eqt1!1•e I!

9 authori1 .. zat:ton to a.ppx•ove and i")e'oord in accordance with th~

ll

12

,,,, ,_..,

GO'V.; ATu'DEFSON': I move it.

Second.

Approval

I

t

21 . i:n.te:r~~.'H~t of" th~~ St~ate. and the prev:ll\ously inte1 .. poaed protest is

22 f to

25 j t'M i(l"'PI

25 tlon proceedings

I '/ r

tti oxr;i;md J.'orrnct· c;;;llaml aroa ln tho ell:~·!' to appr<J1dmatGly 'J.loub 1,P

.. ~-· I 2S

llltJ!f"...;i iM/I!- lCIM lti'O

. ·~._. <;·.::·:~~:'" "

ll ~ I .I

\\

/). ' <·l 0

2

3.

"4

5

6

7

a

9

10

11

12

13

14 0 0

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

• 2a

I.I

) ....... ,..,,, . '!"llfll'"~ .. Wh•O•·>- ,' . :li11f\"'U'"'l•:J !I'" 1~'.:' II ; ••••f ''1'•-I ·11 . ~~ ·~h1 ... U!frt«·1 Ff'!~ and:.o to. lnolude a large a~ea or tidelands wiibh.in tn,/~ proposed

. J;I

new city. limit~., includlng those tideland,a previously granted

b~, the Legi;Jlature to t.he San Mate() County Harbor District.

The statutes :require that in proposals to annex un-

inhabited tide ar1d su'bmerged lands under the ~lurlsd.ic~ion of 9 - ··1 -~

\~

the State Lands Com.mission that.Ji f'or purposes or determining ,·

' · the valuation of those lands in eo:tmeotion w·:.tth any protest t

annexation proceedings, the State.I&ds Commission shall make

such valtta.tion and report to the annexing age~oy. This is th

first part ot a~ proposal -- to authoriz~ the report to the

City Council of the \Olty, of Half Moon Bay that. the value oi."

the lands pro.posed to be annexed under Resolution Nuniver 4•61

is .$3J.32l,OOO.

We have aJ.so received from the San I·1ateo (Jounty

Harbor District; a political subdivision of the State, objec

tions and protests, s.uggesting that the proposed anne:~ation

may not be in the best itrtereats of the State because or enc

branoes which the Harbor District might have imposed an their

act:I~vit1es under the State statutes as a result of

into a city and beJ.ng subject,, thererore, at least to some

approvals, :l..f* not direct control, of the City Council or the

Olty of Half Moon Bay.

Thia latter facet :ts strictly not a problem directl

within the concern of the dtate Iiandn Commisoion, but the

. 0

o~ ,.

' ,~ . " ·•

7-~· .!··ir' ' .;.

·,::,~?. . .

• cl; .

•)

r:J'

:to

1 in connect.ton with this IP~poa?t o:f:."t valuation to ·the Clty Counc:t i ··

·2 of Half Mu1?n Bay they were not . permitted to :repo:t"t their prob- , .. ·

5 lem to the Com.nl.1 .. ssion in cor.tnection with convincing the Cotnrnis ...

4 aion whetl,ler the Comm1a$ion should o:r sho4ld not protest the

5 annexation on the· basis of.State policy; because with this

a valuation., the State Land~ Oem.miss:L_on would be in a position,

7 if they proteatc4,- to blook the annex~tion. !

a Th~efore, th~ last half of this item is primarily

9 to ar-rord the San Mateo County Harbor District to present their

10 problems and, as they see it, the solut·ion that the Lands Com

ll mission could afford them. For this reason, they have been

12 notified that th:l.a i,tem was on the agenda and if the Chairman

13 would oall upon the proponents and opponents of this item who

<~, 14 are present here today we can get the matter before j,he Com-')

15 mission in that manner.

16

17

18

19

MR. CRANWON: Is there anyone who wishe~. to be

heard on this matter? Is there anyone in the room that wishes· «·

to be heard on thts mattei ... involving Half Moon Bay? {no

response)

20 r.m .. HOR~!G: Well, unde1 ... those circumstancEUJ, then,

21 Mr ... Chairman.) it is reoommend.ed that the resolution. on page 2€

22 be modified to read only:

as u:r:t is recommended tha.t the Commlssion o.uth.or.lze thE /,

24 li~ecut.1.ve Off leer to n.ot:tt·y tho Cit;~ Council 0£ the City of

J c:i 25 IIa.l.L .. I-loon Buy that ( 1) Pu1,,nt.1ant to t;h\~ pi•ov '. slons of Soctlcn f. /

Ii !;;; ll

1 . dotoi'*m1ned ·~.he pre~~~t valu.o (Jf the .. Sta.te:....~'W?lecl t 1de and aut>..., · ' '

t~ morg~cl lands :r.1:r~p9$ei. to be annexfbd u::~der ~.flenolut.~l<)n No. 11-61 ,, *' ' ' ' '

3" yi be ~3,321,0QOll_ -- end" of reso'lut!on; and then, pirent~etic r~

.··~ .the stare wiU notify the CitJr Counou. o.r t. he c.".tty .. · ot Ha:D.·1.f:····.J.fo.··· .. ~.11:;,.: .. ··. Bay that the £ltate Lands ¢!01mn1tra5 .. on did. ~?iiyt authori~e the st~.~ i5 *'to requGst the protG-11t to the arinexa~fon to.continue 1nettdl::tJ

7 ' .aov.,, ANDE!WON: '.He.t.i the Sa1.1 Mateo cr.om1.ty H .. at._rb~·r·. L.~1s~,1.

8 triat been 1-.:iuly notl.f ied of this? We:•e they infoi-ro.ed o;f' this

I meet:l.ng t<>day? s

10

l ... item • .L

·, 12.

M.ll~) RORTIG: Yes sir, they have a copy ot th.is ag<~rld~

MR. GRANSTOM ~ T0 be clear on that figure :l .. t is

13 t:hree million, thX:'ee b:undred twe~nty .... one thousand?

14.

15 thousand.

16 A motion ;La in order to a,ppr.ove the

MR. CAR'R: I move approval of the l~oeoromendat:l.on.

GOV ;s A'.NDERSON: Whan yot.1 not.i.l'y th~m.f you just send'~.

this individual item to the 11arb$'r :District ~roup, or how tlo 20 ., ..

21 you notify them?

22 MR. HORTIG: And to the City Council,; and :tn view of

23 the i'act that the - - Ii' you will excuse me a l'JO!ll~ntf, gentlemet,

24 I ha.VP. the .f.tle bet\?l"e me'): I ha~;e a note f-rom my· ~ee1"eta.r1J I

25 . aloo that a M1-rr" \61.hit tng, 1kt1! Moon Bay a.ttorne~, called uut~

28 · ch:!.of land ap1'>ra:loe1' .n.l?.d t•epoi'ltod ti·ia.t ho nrlt~ht ap11eui;~ J.n

L(>i:·l.Clni11Y Cltatod !n. O:rr<ir au ~:t'et.'l %0U:ThrTe!';~o num:h·eu-2 t wen '\;y""OUQ t;lU,;.tUfi1lifittl4'~ Ag'fMIHllJTltA1'tVJ: Pl'io~OUH. ll"1A'rl't Cl' e~tU'OIUU"'

I "" .. I'·. " (

,} ' ·~·I' ij

,_;

•

' ' (! . ' ·' ' ·. ~ ~ ' . 12

~ t . .( · r 'l••.1•1 IO~~~~-~~'l';t~d'!l;•W.b\~~.~~-""'1'1rdi'(' 1r•~li f 'il•ll:l::Mll •lill,_. !lo .• ~.,,... • .._.,~=l1al M~'!'!llllll ....... ~j,'Mt.Jt1-31• . ...,,

~ " ., ' 1\ . \, 11 ,'. t

i I. r. ,a,~ra.fuent. .. ·· ~' toJnor~ow. $~1.s :t:s a. e~ lephon'e 1tte$SRt5e. aa · Cl. i . . . J' ·.at yesterda~t; . ap.tj wet b.erve. ho.d 9zt~nsi:Y.e, CQrI-8api~l1dEn~e W.1.tb. ot;ne.

~ I'

····s·!'. attorneys\.· qr~ l)eha1.t ~t· both. pr:tv·ate landowner~ ~!'"f'J ~~10- Ha.lr . Moon Ba~r lia11bor Dist.r1at,; as bas the or~rl .. tle o§} th~ Att0.rney 4

Genet"s.71,. ·. _.,,:. all ot wh:toh have bean x~e. plied to .Sl~~elfios.J,ly ou ~i . ~· ~

J t letter to tbe· lndi.viduals (iireoti~g th.era,, plus the flnai cc1n-

: 1 i'ir&!ll.l:ionI Just reac). to you that there waa tel.ephoni,a vel'i-

8 1 i"ication as late a.a yesttu?day that the attoxjney 0£ the .Harb~r I . .

91 Dist-;rict knew that this item would be considered by t:1e Com-

~0 · mission todAv. '(." "<>"'l,I' ... ,':\! .

iii 12.

13

141 151 ief l'T I 181· l.9

20 f !

&'},'} t h~~ J

Second'!!.·

.seconded and made I Approval :ta mo1red,

Ite:m 6 -- Au·t;borJ .. zation for E..'(ecu.tive O:f'ficer to

notify Oit.y Council of City of Corofi'Rdo that _prest1nt -rla1ue of'

Stv;.·ta.-..own.ed tide '°'a.nd .surm1~rt;ed lar!ds ·in the Pac,if'ic ~taan, ,) ,' '\

San Diego County, p:t?oposed to b~. armexed under Resc;,1.ution Uo.

3191., ie $41,4-00,000.

good(!

Ther,.erore, it

23 Off:tCilr to adv1ue the cit~ purtn1ant to its reque3tJ and ao

atk · pi"?ov:!.ded b~r law, as to th.a valuation placed on the pi ... opw:;ed

20: 111.nncxatlon l:i.ndo by th(;) I..a'r.cta Conmiloo.lon,

26 J !;'ff\. CAHR: 1•11 .. $ Cha:trman., I'd lilto to vncio:r.--utand the L_ ._, __ _,, _________ . ____ ... ___________ " ______ __.

I,. fr,;\

' " i?·J.1 ~~J

. ,~--.~. :ff'V'

~t;~:::·

•

. .;i"\\

))

. •' \

13

(( itt·· MR. ~~R: . Ydir oonst~Jtion o'.( piera1 ;,·, \\

5.

! subj~ct to Corps of Engineers ••••

~e···. 1· ..

8·

9

l.O

ll

MR. CARR: It would be subject to app;r1:z>val of ilne _1 ?'

State Lands Contr~1ss1on?

MR~ HORTJ;G: Despite the ar.r.nexation, all eonst.iaucti I

would be subject to Cc::n.i."lrl.s~:ton approval. I

I

r.mr.· 'cru\NSTON: Moved 1·"and seconded~ unanimousl:y » •, 1:,

12 . approved,.

Ite;tn 1t -- Authorization for mineral extraction 1~as

I•t (1 of.fer, 6.6 acres :eubnierged lf.!tads in bed of SacrR.."nento Ri"ier,

!f) : •· Sacramento. and Yo1o Counti.es, for extraction ct sand at mil~il:l . ~,

lt).J.

17

ia

19

l')o ~

21

22

23

2, 2,5

26

royalty ot: five eents per cubic ytt.rd, P¥rsuant to application

of Lent~. ConstruatlO);i Compan)"".1 !ne. ~

MR, HORTIG: Thia authot"izati~n 1s recotri.rnended par-

reviewed, found to be legally suf'.ficient i~y the Off:i.ce of

report\td there is no possible interfereni.::e w.:..tb reareat:lonal

11.ie-e ot the land; and the Corpa o:r F..nglncers of the Department

of th~ .tinny i\as .Losuetl a permit autl.lor: .. :ting the pr;:.1pozed oper· -

'-'--------------__,..,_..._ ___________________ , ____ ...... ______ ------------------....-1

.; ...... fc,. ao ..... 'lll'D

f1

; :f !{ ))' ' '\ ,,

, "\

•

14

1 ·· the {Jroposal,.

I

'' ~}·;.' (No 41

MR. CRANS110Ng Any r~u:r:the:w c~o1nment~ on this :.ttem?1

refJponse) (l miotio~ is ! ... n. o~eri~

5

a.

'1

8',

9

10

ll

12'

13 f

ll ~.

15

16

·1:

18

19

MR. CRA.l,J!ON ~ Approv·al is m,o,;ed and seconded.~ . made

•1m.animoualy.

J:bET1JJ?; B -""" Authorization £or Executi v~ Ott loer tQ

issue Ol.l :a.nd Gas Lease to. ~exaco Inc.,' for the 4!;250-.lL~-aere ·

parcel of tide and su'Qmerged lands designated as Parcel 2_,

Wo!"'k Orde·r 3810, Santa Barbai•a C-O'ih"1.ty, in aonside1.,at1tln of • ·I

cash bonus payment of $9,550,0004

MR. HO.R!UIG: M~. 'iliairrrian, in t'iew of the invitatio ..

'Whi~h you., as Chai~a.n or the Lands Com.'lliSf,1iOn, ··. :LS$Ued ta

indust~J having U(y:&rest in the probl.ems of core dr:Llling

opez.a~ions, wh:L'ch have brought implicatiQnG; with respeqt to

tJ-1e issuanae pf State oil and gas lease~ an-4 have been the

subject .of a seri;es of letter prote3ts, I

gest your consi.deration at this t:tme, for ·~ '

21 · Iteris 8 and 9 on the O.;f~enda until the dis~u:Jsion which I pre ....

a:ai aum.e would fellow you:r• invittiltion h~a l1een completed,.,

lfl:s MR. CRANSTON: Yes. Let m~ :!.'ir!lt atate, then. that t 21 · I recel ved, and ·othera .reca:i.. "'led s im:tlar letl\1et"n oi,. March 29th ~

25 · letter dated March 28th s1~;;tu~d by Edwin w. l?aulcy ra:!.;J<tng

----..-------------------...... ,~,,.._ ____________ _... _______ ~--..... ~-------------·---------

•" ·\.{ "

(~-.

!!

1j ,._.""""" __ ..,...........__~v..-:li1111 -• _i'1'11l"••11;i~ ;· .,,_._ ~~IUJl\ftljil•tn e_tM::if~"""'"'Wf-· .,.1.,,..~t11<..:•..,......._~-~

. on.: Patio.el !; the ~!'eel hf.tr~" unelex~ .. 0,onside1~a;tionJ Up\ln :t:~oa~p . 1

of th~t let.ter, .:t ~ote a letter, to ali ·· com~an:tes to. wll:tc:rr geo ~ ·' --- . <>1 _ )i- ,. ' ·. t

'\" logitfatl · StlrVe:~ petiltitt:l have b•en. !Q.8¥.ed d!nce ~u.lv JO, 1959, \\ I ~ .. . 1J

~.,.·~\.·\·'··.~~eh . .t.'".eS.d a.·s.·· folL.ows··· : n.ne'ar {So and .so}: I encle&e a aOff' o .. , "·a lf1tter f:t'Qr.t Jidw;!Jl' W • Paµley, · dttte4 Ma.rob . 28~tf 1961, .. addX-t'.Hs$ed ft: ' ,. , I .. ' '

" ,,.1 to me ;U1 mY' ®P*o:t;ty a;s. Ot>4it~ti ei.f tr~ State Lands Oommiss1on ,i;j\,,\\ •.• ~· . ' .

71 The · C~1lllS$:1-0.t1. will mQet in Sac1'amento on A~pril l2t:h e~t 10 a -.m ;

a Lin ,Room. 2170, State . Cap1,tol. If' your company has ruw views to

9 discuss on·· fihe $Ubj~ct of the letter from Mr .. Pa:uley, the Oom~ "

~~ubsequent to that time, the .following com.mvnicatton .

ha"\fe been. rect-,:lved by the La..~da Gorruntasiou: 11'

12" •i

IS.

Variou.~ reasons are then set fort1 18

1 in tb.e c0tm1iiun1aation :ror ·this action,. 1-he letter was received» l!l·l ' ·1

i~ by the Lands Corr;.s11issiott too late for any meeting to be held to 20

25

•.··as

;,••-.:·-~ ,~;·s·~ ·;~.;,,

4) :

1 .. JF~·-;:;;;.;;·~·=~orna:r tOr '.rj,a:~:;·z~=~= other

.~r letter$ :t will m.entlon tto. i:iot amount to t~r~)..J. protea ta -"'4<

'"

$ t11~J a.:tsnply make ee.~t.a,j.n. aom.aaents} . ', ',

Another :t,t;te:t" . from. M91;)1l Ci3.. Oompaey, d~.rted APl"'il. r

5(: ti,;, a:igf!eq ir.1 R. ~ /,1 IR.;.venant.'f J'!f., 1~ho 10 appar~r;;tly on' thei~ f

f

9 Vesper:;

!Cl A latter phoned :tn this morning , dated April 11th, .

11 from Huntble 011 an~. R~fining o·om.pany ff Mont~rey Di v~aion,

12 signed by E., E~. Pyles, Viee President Monterey Division; ,., ·

15 And, f irui\,lly, a let t; ell' from. Texaco, Inc., dateQ. :

14 ,. 1

Apri.l Uth, s:l.g.YJ.ed by :Suford W. Max, Tliis letter• 'con11t;i:t;u.teJ

15 a/ reply by '~eXa.c~ t~ the 3.tatt11menta ma.de 111 the letter . by !~r. ] . I' ,

t ,. '

1

1

7

e I :aa~l iril the. ~et~er on.-~b(.;half __ of'1 Rich:tleld Oil Corporation ..

At t;li:t.a t.irn~ we would be· vecy happy t.1

0 hear from.

16 aeyone representing f!..nY firm who w!shes to make airy comments

19 to the Lands. 't1omnrl.ssior1 pur~uant t(" tlle l~tter inviting such

20· comments at this meeting.., \

21

22 · I repreaent. the Ri.chf·.t~ld Oil Corporation and I m.ig~t r1ay

23 th:t& -~· that the 0:<plrJration. on the coast, as you probably kn

24 was (to whi;~h we had reference 1n otcv lette11) by a t.~·oup lmo

25 as the UO!i.3H e.;ro·u.p.,, which now by x·e~a;:;)on o:r a ehange of na.'lU>l

i .. J

~ ... tollCIMPQ t;-~. '·

17 r~a ,lflrM~A~~-f-'11-.llJ'li't~A'f~Nlt~t!f. _;f:ikmtr l1 r•Po~~INU11tlllt~i¥\111l d ;tuiliWoW_,i;~J<M:'.~-~v;;;~tt~~".W ' · ~1l~Aiol.~ibtl (t-~1...,. ~. ~_..,.~

'·1 ·.1 Md>bil ~- bl.1.tl :tl'.1 thEI bifkling ,,~ ,i'a:rniel 2, Richfield 011 :i:orpora

·2- l tion. alons bid that; wa.s thb uu.su-0oesa.ful bidder a.ruff di.d not

~ 'b1¢ •. ;to~ .~hJl.·g~ou.p. So as ! a.P~,ttow on &hi~· agen4a item . ~ ~~ .

,, N'.u:tnb,er 8/ I s P,ak onlJ" to~ the R1-0ntiel:d .. Oil, Cbrp,ora.t1on .and & .·not. for the Sl1'URM group,. ·

el ~

7

"

J: will' net 1z,1iep~at the ~acts,, eon.sider· the .fa.eta,

s"eate.d in out- \J..etter1• of p:t11ot,est be·ca.use they. are well, mown to

j

s. you and you ean cc>ns1der them; 'but I do want to say th:l,s --

9 .. that 'is, it ~.eema to me that what oc~urred on l?.atJo.el 2 does ' l

bring 'back i:or the con.side;ra.t:ton of the Co1nmiss.1.on a matter or

.a~ to ho·w the$e Stat~ leases 1.ll;"e to be put out f:cr b:Ld.

12 Now~ lnrr.S.king.this statement rr11 assume certa:tn

,.. .a.. .i....1 ~· I t+ ..,., ""'·,....: d·.. ~ ,..,,,. t"" .,...,.. l.3 ...i.. aa "'s .- W-s.• c.1.1 can ~ rrove ..... _ 6W!·"' you Kn.OW \"Ina .,t:;1,er 1.1ileJ> are

assume that tha core hole which was· drilled by the Texas Com-. ' '

,·,

17 · Vaqueros sand •.ll4 found oi.l aa.nd;" so a·t' that time the Texa.s 1:

ia Company had more. in£e>rnuit:.ion on the character of the partil!ul

. 19 paro~I than othe.r bidders 1 which ! uay w:t.th no criticism exce ... t

20 I say ·au that time, if that is the case, Texas was in

21 poai'tion to bid than S.%13' .. one els~~; bu1~. the State Lands Conuniss

92- 'WB.Ll ; a.l~o irA a: p.oa:L ti.on to determine the va.lt4.e of that parcel

23

94.., available anc:1 other coi•a holes available, lcnew the value of

25 j that prop1¢rt~.

2a ~ It brings back what we have said before and we agal

L___ .... --·---·----·-·_,_.._ ________ \'------·-· ........ ........, ________ ..._. ________________ _.

~:"

'"' ·.· •. ;.· '

1~ .. .

~.· ·:":;

o "'I 1: '00~ 1 ~.

'.:} " ,, ·~.r- I\

,, I 13

r::~···•-.0••1111 .... ,._ jjr~h·-· 'tn;:- 4\JA"-- _q~ ... -,,l_Mil~ r b ....... ~~_j-11_, ..... ,. ___ ,._,_q __ ,, __ 't-'h••-•Mlit···1-W'!N~ttt'·••1-1 -------........... \ ·~J I

1 h to ui~re J t wh teh 1 ~ when ;i•ou do dat~1,,n1ne a p~~t>:l

e I .Lll valuab 1; s·· ~et::mlne , .!. t:; • 1:a.'l:uaD'le, Whetl1er ;vou would h:,t .. '

3 c;a.in motto fol' the Sta't}.ra" get: more out the l,.eservoJr :t."01: ttte

Statt) uy a mip:tmum bid with royatty; b~td~:U.ng5 than Wi tb f~he

pr$sent · metllc.~d. (;if b~,dding under w);\ich the diff'erant ootnpanie~ ·

6 ··seratnble to see how 1 mu~h they can pay J.n more bonus. :t'"hab 1z

7 a matter of :pol.toy, purely.

8 I must also agaln state that. my. t>f~mar~ are· predi- ·

9 cated upon .faets or which I have no k.Mwledge -- but you. 4.ir, ..

10 I have to assu,..wne when a bid com.es ln fox~ $9, 550 :s 000 there is

ll.. evidence be.rone the ~exas Company management that this is a

12 valuable oil land. I have to aSS'i,,'4"tle also thia State Iands Co.

13. mission has tiiat same information. If you have t!mt same

14 in.forro.atlon.i you are in a position to detexr;.'lline what is the

15 best policy or biddin~~ on t;hat parc;e1.

16 Now, with reference to the va1•ious i tem.s or the

17 ,, protest; that we urge .:l,n our letter on Parcel 2, \·:e say this:

8 We assurne that the State Lands Comrnission ·and the Executive l .

19- Officer and: his st:arr attempt to' give all oil companies who

20 ::Lre engaged in coi~e ·' .. ; ... ~~ling on the coast equal ~",;;Jpo:rtunlty

l and acce(,--a '~o tnforma:,_i"- We aloo assume that in the fut;t11"e 2 .. · . · ~ · '-' . · · v · 01.1 ,,,

{ 22 your 1~olicy will be the same --· that you W1ill attempt to give

l '

r 1• 23 tUJ ~11 the same acceoo / co we w.tll bo 1.n an equal. pos :ttion ~Yi"

b.tdding.

26

....... 1---------------------------------·--1·-·----·-·------··--·--------------------~)rr'

~~'~t!PO ;" " "

• "'',,

•

! 1 lQ "'·~~~ •i·ii~- • •n-•Tlfl:? 1 M?til'~~-p~1-li1*a)blll't'lioo:·-·g;-&:··~ ...... ~f ... r..-~~l't.; tt' ''pj~~;.«.~~~~1

~~ _i: ~~hl~J pr•c:lent m.ethcd, t~h.is z;rr.:1:¥~:)e.t r1(U;1m:Lt ·that t:,; L:HH.u.:H.i, rrll11ch ,.

2 1)01~nltG. tnc 001..,e hole to ~o to a ':e:r:~taln. de11tl1 ln accorclant~e·

3 . wlth th~ Judgment. oJ,, :1·oux- staf':f.", does,. &~lv.e ur.5 a.11 equal :tnfo:t'\11 ..... . .

4 ·cion. In the porm:tt it stat~~ ·that if y<;uc ehooutite:t* oil sar . .:rl

fS you aha.ll immediately w:tthd:t'aw and plug bacltt: 1 su11pose th~t

I a I i.J S") 110 one w:ll"l hav~ a complt::!te log betore the bidd~tr.1.g start·'!!·.

7 Aga'l.n, I :r~pea.t what we said in <"ux· protest. If' we

8 critic.ize the p1~ocedure, it 1$ upon £acts we don 1t know

9 ob'l'.11ously t:e a~u3uu1e the Texas Company dld penetra.ta the Vaque

lO sand and there was not oil, otherw1.se they would ha\re plugged

11 .· back and withdrawn. 'fie are assuming mautei'l<a not be:eore us,

12

13

1.4

15

lS

17

18.

19

:tr they di<l.j !t was in our pert1it and a,sGtune it was :tr1 theii~s.

not~ they obtained .:tn.f:ormation that we did not. i

. Oul' prot.e~t on Parcel 3 was not based upon t'acta • . I We as$U.'!led, because or lni"ormation recel"ii'ed by the ~exaa Comp:f'

an aol.1e hole two, tlley wcn .. tld gain infomatio:n on three. I w:t.11

1

1

say Mr. Itort~ig told me. that w£..:e not the case '"""'° we wel"e six

miles away, some d.istauce a:way, ~"ld thi~ was not so. ·1.

It i\O happens we were on an equal ·oasis on 3, beoau.s~ 20 RicllfleJ.d was the uucc:enaful bidde11 .,.,_, with which we are well

24 l

:I L

Ball, d.o we ~1.derst;.lmd you have l I

-

s: . on l:I~~ Gt the atcht'Ultl O;tl Corpo1'Sti1m, not on l.!ebalt' ot j 4·. t.11.e 9t!le~ g~oup o~ ·~he b:!~d o:rl ParcGl 30 J

6

10

ll

lS

14

Raglan<l a.t" if,1ehf1el.d is with us"' DtJ you l:uav~ all1' .tiurthe:1:" aom

m.ents to ma~'!

NG7,, Mr"" C.ran~tont ! d• not ..

CRANSTON; Is there ar~o:r1e \l>.tho wishes to malt~

MR.,. Ql1.A;N3TON :. Uolald ~9U repeat your naatt~r?

~:a~ NE~Y-~· Nawby~ ~'l.-t;. I ha.VY.a only a :few. 111<tmar.lm t

18 otber tka.n i,n °'onf'(;)rmity with t!a~ stat·u.tes. 'JJhe:re has beeri

19 au.ggestion that Ta:1tacots 'bid on Parcel 2 did not aonfol:m: to

20 ,. ·t;he term$ and co:n.ditio:ns contained 1n the bid px,oposal for

21 ·• ·. P.arael 2,, i

2~ }:.' !mie:re ls· 811.& ether· point .. I think :E 11.hor~ld. d:tecuse

~ j and that 1.s, whether il1 i°' to the beat inter~sts of the Sta'c.;i

24i for the Landa Coti:unission to award the bid to ~exaco. I th1.nk

SS - ! ahould aay only thl.s -- that Faraol $, w!:1ich adjoins Parcel

26

·------· ·-;p~-·-~-. -----1'-nlJ ____ """"""""'--' -· -l"Jb:.,..l:!f _,,.. _____ >"&""':1ok»'-••-I• --.,.,,.,, ·----,..-~J\~,---..._~ ......... ~ ""· ~--1!i>Mi.t!ll"O ·'!.i

:' \ I f

~\ ,...~

"'

.,

" ,,"'"''1 bid df somatbing 0ver five million dollars". Parcel 3 --- l ~ . ~

I'' .whichl'. of at>urs6, adjc;lntl Pare.el 2 on the east·.., is, the sub,ject

'gv no~[p.t a·'.l,eaa,e· whi)lb xrJly b~ ~wal;'ded to Richt::L~ld on a.,'bid w~~ic · ·- ~- . . /

'" ' . . ( / ') //

'.i. I ·~1~~~d .ts :,approxtmately a· million, three hundrect tiftt-/.· ~ I! '

. 0 · fii. tbcru1Wid dollars. Texaco has'}'ffe1-.ed to pay,. a bonus., has

6 . ·rnade a bid, of $9,5501 000 t.'01" rare~l 2, the parcel in between

r I tho&~ two prer1oualy men.t.1.oned properties. I think 1ti is ob

s v1ou$ that it is to the best. interests of the state that the

9 .Lands Comniiss1an award Pa:raal 2 to Texaco.

lo· Mli.1!' CR.11.MS~ON: · Thank you veey much. Is there ar1yone ·' f '.· .'

itJ else who wishes to ,~ake any comments?

12 ;

l:U<:e to ask a question here: What was the bid on nnn 1 Kr.

17

I

·. );9 , Psl.1cel 3.

20:

22'

'/ v "

AA. HOB.TIG: Ju.st, motnent, Mr" Carr. \

MR~· CARR: T.hat•s some time ago,.

MR. ROSE: 'What clo 'f'OU mean by unn?

MR. CARR: That 1s ah~eady on lease

M.R"' ROElE: $23,711,538.oo.

to

MR. O\RR• .. ' , Ille $23,000~000 on "Du and nine

Tex:aoo.

million and

13 a: halt 011 2, looks like the b:Ld (~n 3 would be very low to me.

MJ.l. ROSEt Inoiclentally, on "D", Mr. Carr,, besides

25 · the $23/"(0Q,,OOO bid .. the bid right bollind it waG $22,150,000.

i1 t'

11

ii d I I I

'

I'

I\ \\ \I

~;~ it° .. ~'

L -~i-i\

J :..~ \)

0.

. ··"1. l

'· " 1' 22 ,......._.., .. M4Hr-u~--n•-~r•~-ft-••-I1-•_.., __ , ...... ,,,1r,_....._..._..,.__........._ ........... ..._ __ ..._,._,, __ ._,._..._ __ _...~~----~--

1,I

!: MR111 <:HO/R'!IGt And a low of 1'*our million .. l,

* i ;:·co_ a AA. BA.ltr.J..: Mr. Chai~., th~t'e is a.nothar aub Ject I

,,,,, 3 . want to say som~thirli!;· about. and this also has to Co w1th Com-

:j ,, .. mi.sr:tlon pol,~oy ~tn J;he ~uture;. and that is, :tn o~ pl?otest we

·. 5 · poin.ted out thaJ~ what ~e eonsider,.a la;ek ,~ reg~jtations is

I "

,\ ' Ii

6 req~~r.Jd~! by thel! statute. There are n:umevoua resolutions passe ' :i

7 by the Oommisa1::on th(a,t we are aware of .1.n the past years that

a deal with this ;part10,ular problem, but I want to make our posi··

9 ti on clear a.nd then if you have .any quest.ions I• d be glad to

10 answer them.

11

12 . plied with the statute adequately .in adopting regulations on I

l3 this core· drilling,; that there were general statements of poli y

14 · 1n these resol'\lttions and then there t1las sort or an implied del "" ,.

lfS gation ot authority to the Ex:aout.ive ~')ffic.\~r· to determip.e thes '

16 particular depths to Which the aompatli.es· WOU:J.d be permitted to

17, d:r1iJ..l and then he would exercise his best discretion in the

18 matter in acoordance with that policy. We felt that more

1~. exact regulations could be drawn \11" by the Commission so tbat

20 everybody could go. to the regulation and aee exactly what they

21 oould do;t because i.f you will take the i'?eoord - .... 1£ you will

22 take the record there you w:Lll see that there are various dep' ~; ..

23 to which core drilling, to whi.oh wells are d1 ... illed.

24 No tr,, .Lt ts true beto:re you dr:J.11 different place2 inc

'~·· ... '.·.···. ,,,.·. (j ; •· •·

0

25 a st1'uctu1~c you cantt aay in a :regitlatlou nYou can drill (aay).

26 to },f., 300 feet 11 and have ·\t unlform tor eve1;yone,, boca~..loo tho.t

·tj,.

it ! .,

' ' ! ". . . ; ' " . ' '. J • . , ' • ., ~ • ' . ' ' ''. ' • '.. • ' ' ' ;. • ' "' Iv'"''°•~ ... ·~~·::.. ''' ~~ 1,._, (• ~\ • '• ' ,;'! .,. '!Ii ~ .... \ ~·~~r ',t, -.,H '•"' •' ·~_,· "f l <1!111' ' : \ ' 1 '' °¥1Ji: ~ • •* ' ~ • • ~ >'" ' # 7f.- • I' " • ' (, ' 'J • ' J ! '\ • • ; :/ t ' ' ., I' ' • ' ' '\. ,._ ,- ~

' ·~: t v ·-L ~~>:> • '~ ~ '-;..t • .,.-- ":· ). ,"".. =. ~'.\~ ... ·, '.,, ~ ~ .... JI' 'D I.,. .·· .. , '·. ~~~.. ' ~~~."" .. \"."''·, '~ :~ ,ti~I. A·" • • •' • '° •," ..... , ~~ ' • It • .~ ~ I"' ,• "" \ • • '-t. • • • ,. ,,... "' •

,,.

•

•

r ' .

·--........ ··--..l.I_.. ...... _.,,, ... , .~ 00 ~f .... _,_: ...... ~~"; .. ,.1* I (!f's--~ ·" ' " f. f ,, ! .

1: would not bo i:tnit'orm tor evecyoae 1 l:ecauae .. o~ the dit,teren()e

,l. atratographic. depth~" th• . riaa and diffevent: posl~lon ri'1ot tp...e

.. 'i ,

· s~<Jture;· but we t•lt -th&t · tbe re~lations 01.)uld··· bQ "tn:'1~ . · .3 '• . ,,, ·:. ,•.I

I, , ~, 1 1: j --;_ j 1 '

4 ,;~etly atated th•H ""- ~~· p:clJ:ttli:Pl~.a 1~ould 'be eu.ct1J' state ' l( . . ;' , . ' s there, and~·· adopted aa ragui~~~ons J and that wit~ one of· au.ft

\; \\

6 cx-iticiams. ' , .~· ''JI

7. GOV. ANDERSOM: How do you· feel that could be mo1"El L

8 exact!

lO·· yea1~s ago it provided - - there was some general statement th , e ...

ll that it could go to the' :first .....

12 MR. RORTIG: .. • • ,corapetent1 correlative atrailPgraphic

14 MI\,. ~~: E~1&cybody fi.gured that was -~ ev·e:twb:ody 1'.

15 , thought it was left up 1;(# them to. determine what that niier.ht b ... +

18 1.L'hen later on.# I th:tnk it was 1n August, l.959., ".tasn1t; i.ta Mr.

17. Itortig, it was chaQ.ie<i •• 9••

MR. HORTIG: Actually July, but ef.f'ecti·ve in August.

19 MR. BALL: • "' and then you went to a dept,h ,,.. -

20 actually, in other words, you would assign a depth :tn a lette.,:

21 £or the core drilling.

22

23

24

2!5

26

MR,, BALL: Instead o:f: us.ing generalized language

like ntbe nearest ~rtratograpbie marke:t?'t or inotead 01 .. asaign.m .t

to tho EXecuti ve Dlrector (or ~Lmpliedl7 a&;G1gnlt'l£ it to him,

becauoe I war;; somewhat in doubt aa to whothe:r. .. o:r not tho:t'e was _________________ _... ________________________________________ _

•1\\\ ' \1

JJ • '

ii' .-, \\

\ ,'. . •·, . . ~. . ' ' ' .. ' .. , . 24 . ' .r~·,-·· -----.---·.-. ., ~~i~M~:-~··•~!~"1 tfll,...,~~7~~~1~~1•.~t=t~-~ .\

l '~ an aueq\.iat!l 4eJ.e~at;1(Ul to tlc t~t.J.1 t9 l.et libri in ~aoh \·ir1ste,n{:t·ri

2 .. det•~ine •~ should:· ti~· J;he depttt~ '.: th-e r•sulatiort Gould be

3 j adoptet\ Which. woulQ .,pei'ami:t him, tq ata:ee ·a ,&ftuO.ralJ .. zed d\ipth<i<

4 Fox~ e;tW.tt1ifrl&9 !uppo~f.' he sa:t~d .~Gu C{)ltld1

•. ~.~o to the McntH'i!!:ttEr~~.r s~

5 1. Ol' '$o'U can gt\ to the Mi:i~i,ll de1un~ aha.A.a ox- to t~\ de~th ~f': th I . . . , . .·· . •1 ,

el 1· V•queroa sknd. 'l!hen e.v,eeyone wo~d know exaetl:v l•o~ rar thq I 7 . would go and if they went :r~MX' they" would vi¢lat;... th.e.ir

1

. g 1· pennit';\

9: Also, another statement on, wi:i.at I bad to say before -

101 I m11 s~.tPe I made rqsel:t.~ cleal~ on. Mumber 2 -- and that ls thltii ·

ll. · that if ;i in the judgment 0£ this Oam,misaion with the i~:a£01,mat1 n

detemir&e that i;he bid of 9,500.11000 ia a ~mall bid cvinpared i

nth tru; i>oai1U.ble reS@vo;tr triei·e, :ti:' you eot1l.d tietemille you I eo~.lld g~t mJ;ire foi~ t.he .Staf;e of Calif orn.:ta tha.i"l that with a J

r1 · lAavt:: it.; I dG11tt have i;t. I i.Mtn't malte any siggesti~D.r1s -- I

18 e.a.r1't argue i*ac·ts on wioh I ha1re no knowl~dge., 1 19'

21) I 211 22l ~.

24

25

26

MR. crullIS2!0~1: A~e ·tJleJle any £urtber ooi:ru~enta? Mr ..

Hortig.1 we have a full and complete l"'ecord of all people pres · t

r"m,,. HOR~IG: Ye@ air -~ it they ta:Lgned attendance

slj8p&~. You mlght aak that they be S'Ul?e t<.1 do so"

MR. Cl1At~S1l?ON: Well, evei7Y person here haa had an

opportunity t<) 31gn an. attendanee olip ar1fl we will pre~ume tl1

have done ao ~ Ii" there a~ no further ommnellts fr.om anyo~1e

--~------~-· ------------------------------"'--------"~--------¥~

,M11'1:t; 11'•-fO #"M 81"1: 'Id ,·:

1/

.t ,,

:1

t? \\ \ ,. i. ·. (\, 1

k }t~ :~;-~;~~~~ ;~~::~· ;~~=~~~:~:~' =r:;:~ ·;~;:i ;o

s ' ~e~tl~d:b~.2,"'11 ~ n. IMllnPillV. ar11i1>illd of fl:ltie me.ting w~es,0

to I 3 .prq~e•'t .. tho ~~ot <>11~ ... gas ~-... Jl .. l!e ·t. o '.l!~aeo on ia:r:'cd 2 l-·C· ·

4 othe~ yhar.t the .P.~tee·t w• have .. .fvorn _l11xaco~ . · · .,,

tr MR/J WJ?.?CHI?lp: Mt\~. Oha.i:mnart, DlY. name .110 ·Hutchins _,.,,. ., ,.,

'·' I om wi:th Ed.Win ?auley Assoc:tat'its.. I

9 UBANS':!ON: His :tetter did not appear to constit it:e

,, o a .td~"ll protest- Did your: wish u~t. to l\,:nterpret it thart way?

..... ~~I . . . :: :::N:tbe::::e Iw:0:ave a copy or a letter thal

th& Governor - - I have a copy here. · :tt . ·

h

!/ ' .I 14

15 1'tf1.th reference tq my ,letter to you ot Ma.rob 28th l 16 concernin~ the bidding on. ?arcel 2, I am attMthing a copy of

17 the letter aent to the State Lands Commissior1 by the attorne:ys

ia· for the Riehf'ield Oil Corporation.·, This l~eaffil"'lll.~ our positio "

19 :tn the matter.u

20

21

22

2.3

Do you have a ~op3 of that?

MR. CR.A.t~STON: I don't have a copy of that.

MR. OA.a.1...t=t: Is that what you a.re referx•ing to?

NR. IfOTOHIUS; :Chat one, as well aa the one sent to

24 the varioua indLviduals.

25

2S

MR. CARR: Thia is of recent date, aoottt April 10th.

MH.. HUTCIIINS: I tbink that'll about tllo same date tl

.:· ., ~

4

I' -.,.; . -;-: ' . ,¥,

~ ' r ·~

::i ' f ; ~-

1" .... ·~.~.·-'

~ > ~ ~·

.. :'

-..

. '

. (.;

~» ' 1.n?rp:reted N~ an obj~ctrio11,. ',

MR. '\Orul~S'?ON: Does ~pYone el.~e ••• "1 •..•

M.11,. 13UC..KI&Y: \· .. Mi'" Ohai~n -- :eu~kley ot !ri<lewater

7 :,011 •.. We woU:id not wQ.nt OtW let~er· suppo1,ting Mr. Pauley 12

8 letter interpre*,ed as ~ prcrfJe~t, ,fi.;1~'~1. prote3t, \'Jn !''~reel 'al!J

g·'

10

ll

mt. CRAP~"~t)N: ::tt is n~:lt a forn1i'.~l p.t1oteat?

MR. BUOKLEY: No.,

MR. eRANSTON: Any furthel"" comments to be. made?

MR. PCETCHUM: Mr .. ah.airman, George Ketchum, Mobil

13 Oil OumPc~ny. We, likewise". would not like to have our letter

14 interpreted ~s a protest to the awar-d on Parcel 2.

lF. "'

MRo CRANSfON: Any further comments? {No response}

16',:'. If there are none.J- the time for the Landa Commission to con-

17 s:t(ler its course has come, and I would l:tlce to state that in

18 view of the limited time that the State ha.z had to consider ti-

19 Ricl'l:f'ield protest and the currently received interpretatlcln of

20 the Pauley letter as a protest, I recommend that the Landa Com

· ,::;c ·"'/ 2l mission request the opinion 01" the Attorney General, who has

'I ,\'

22 l'lct had adequate t tmc to consider th:i.a matter"' Befo:t"e a(::tlng,

I would x1eiaommcnd that we a.al-: for all poosibltt speed in. l~t~cei v

lnt,1; the Attorney General ta advice on th1G matrce:.tl and I would

o.uo\11")0 o.11 l.ntc1"ilt.1'ated no.1~t; tan th.at as f'u:r aa the ChoJ.rman. ls ''" .

...__ ____________ __,,_, --------------.-------------..._----~-----------------

., ., (1

)I

• l

9

lo

11

11

Ii \'.

MR• C.RANS'J!ON : Tl!i.e Code does not spell out any tit'fi(i

the, Attorney General to advise \lS t~ou.ld n,ot po.us1t~l1.y ~e oon-~ ·,

sidered unreasonat)la. The Chairman would appreciate a, motton

to that intent,, unless others have other v:tews to exp:ress.

MR. CARR: I only have one questi1.~nJ Mr •. Chairman,

12 and that ia -- looking at ·this histo:i:1y of thaae otr1e1r leuses;. I

13 . when there was a $;;>1 000,000 bo!lus on E and nine a halt' millio1 14 dolla:;.• bonus o1;'1'e~ on lf!, and $23,000,000 on D -- not \ie;t:ng a. ·

1:.

15 geologiet, I 1 d likl! to get some ;tnt'orma.t:J.on as to wlr:/ 3 s..;iems

1.

16 to be worth as litt.le as the bid we received on it.· . r 17 MR. HORTIG: Mxr" Chairman, in response t>0· Mr. Oarr 1 ~

1 18 inquiry _,,,,. of course, the evaluation of 3 was not ~ubjeo·t of

19\ th~ J~l.genda t(.'lday. We do not have the material w:tth us, altlio~~

20 we ha~e auch material and at your convenience we can report ~1

21

22

23

24

25

26

J'·ou on that r;ubject.

mo.tion.

M:Ft. CARR: That ts the only cemme11t.. I aeoli.>tld the

GOV. .ANDJRSON: :C didn tvt mal<:e it, bt?,t I Will.

MR@ CARR: I thought you m&de ita

GOV. ANDERSON: AJ-1 l"1c;bt, I will. '!'hor~ is no way

l

,_ ____ ~,~~----"'-..... -----·----~-------/!'J-~.- •'X1''1•1W!,rlj,I * .....

'• .. ~~.=:

Ii ·, \( \ : ' ; ' ' ' ' ~· " : ·~, i

~~1f~~......,.,~-~'~lfl>)~~t,t~·4't;,· .. t __ U!fk\ll.t4'1ioJU:~~~·,_~~·-¥.•ll'*'*i4'~~·-· -----lil!J! i l . i:>f Texa~o w.tthdr,twirtg,, pu:tling ~nb j 1ifrt)·iseat. irlg thi{$? I am. Jur·. t

thinJd .. ng 1t.>f' the · time on thio il'' 2 .. . . . I .:~ . ' ''

· ·,, c MR~ Callt"G~~·: V$' !1',te a talrly lt.tbstant:tal d~pos'.it J

4 10n :tiand ·'and ther~ ti' no limit tlpq)ll'14 l:JUt ~ the Code as i;o t, ,$

e tU.flltt '·in ltlhiob we a~ requ;t:t;1Jd to ~t~ '1lh" only poasible gtio

af would la~ if we we~ unrll\asonafale.andit ia aeritainl.y not un~ I 7. , roason~ble bo seek the Att\lrney General ts ·opinion~

9 S:exa.o(i ttereJ! :ttd Just lilte to get into the reoord as to wheth

10 or· rtf)t he also understands it t:t1at way fJ Do we· w1derstar1d tb.i

11,. o.Qrrectly,: .now, tlia:t in dt~la,wing the acceptance or reJect;:to.u,

12 , ym~.. bid on l?ara·$l 2,, that is" u:nt.11 we •

i:s I. op:l.n1.oti .. th~ti your bid st:l.l.1 atands?

141 15

16

17

lJS

i9 I 20 i 01.·] ~

28

get an Attomey Gcnerl*a

tlW $.1<1 ~'Iii Sl'O \':

•

.. ,,., '·'

<) '. ~911~, I •

.... . . ' !!· ·.· . . 1 the whole t:ranoo.lt1~l'i\,.·. )I wo1ild h$:t)e' tpa.t we would. l;'!e e.ble tQ "'

• I

2 •. $~.art a~*lce t('J. you · bY the · en4 i01.. "th'.'1s· 00ntl1: ~ '

a I · MR. CRAN$®B': hnk yo~ Ver:r nrucn., . A\'e there ~. •I coll!ll\1ilnta bet'ol:.'~ :.0e lAM.h O.omnib:Bioh M\;,s <ill. tih., l!iOtion 'mltd.8'

5 • by LJ.e~tenm'lt Governor. A~~l'°Son? 'l.b~;rE! bei:ns rte# ·c~mm.e.n.t by

r ... J

a·I 9

'

10 . cet1:ned with. info:nnaticn tn:tl.t these ~ompanies get when the7

11 · dr1ll. lfow1 :t UJld~x~st'tand: t11a:t the State Lands D:t,,•,-1eion is not.

121 lS ... ·1· ..

14 J 161

161 3 .. 7

su.ppoaed t,o ~~tve this. intorm.atlon out. I unw~rata11d, howevex11, •

these compai1i~s send it bank and· 11\corth to eac1b. other a11d seJ .. 1

tt l)ack and tax-th to each ·~:r~her, but :l.t fltill, i@ som.eth:tu.g we .. ·

are not a·~ .. tP:P<-'H~ed to give out our~.r;J.v~.s, .•

When we g~t letters from .. l\"a::-,. Ptuile,- and others11 when'

ia; 1~ that, tbe~?· Are we at:tll supp.osed to be guarding tht)Se

19 letters as to ~~llat :tnfom.uation ·chey .nave:,, and lf one geto out

20 or our li.and3 ¥Eh:itt is tb~ position? I see they hava a lot of

21 informa.tion il'l theae things, where the:;r d.iscusil tb.e depths ano.'

:iaa the thi11gs they fQ1md _.,... page after pag1,~; ar1d these were ma..ilta ~

25 outJ each oi." ixs got O<ipler:.> oi1 1t, a11d I just wondered what

24 scH~Ulliity do we have :Ln th.ls pos1tion?

25

,I

.:\

.-".:_.,

I\

" .•... " ,_,_ \

, :i -, ' .' '.' ;. "'!~ ' ,_. •I . ;, . . , . . .. . . ~o I_ Jl > _', ~ - • : , ~

.~•«•-~'"'"""'1111~ui·1"i" 1 111~\!1~ .. ' !Ml,'Jl'~H r•-<tm•r~·••1'""'~ ._ "'""""' 01 1 ··r~1~1041~'tiio1<dllo;::to:'r''•••n.11a1s1:1•! '"'"-~•n•""1

· 1 J m.u~t; )1¢~ · be, "'.,d~Jelos~'l ~Y ·:~ne St"t.~ tan4a Comm1a~tton ·'or· by ari.y ·:

, ti~:: ()~ lt$ .)tpl~f~~-,, anQ; o~art .. CX~•Pt? ~Ain there .baa been a wrJ.:t~ ' :, i ~ (~ __ ' '" - ' ,', I; '.;, • ' ,, .: i) '

. !' .. tGta" CQlllSCnt :ff.).;, th~ :dJ.eaei)li.nati.:-)(& of. tb•~ lnfbl'ttliltiort by \1t 1h$.

1 : peracn ~hl.,, cfb~t.dn~¢l it., :i; d(.~•t thl.~"' fhtJre 1s any:.'. rttfitr:t-0- ·~

1 tion ·t,tp~r.) thtt ~ex-spn malting it. ·a'f1a:tlB;bl·c·, 1• ~rtd ~ii least·· i10

e e:>:.p.reis:a rest.11\ction i.3:1. t.ne Cod• Ss,t~t:!~on. as;a:Lnst otlJ,~x" par:.H>ns·

7 ." d11e.~.minat1ng a~ries er inf,orm~tion thwv ·· .tJ.c:l.ve, gotten in on

. ($. · vm;y or a11oth~r u to t:tt.tt4'V'GY qata. that t)th~-q people h~ve obvai d.

9

lo

In otlae:.~ word.a,, the seotion is a rest~ii0tion on the

Ther.:e ia nothing.tn it, I d~r:t•t

;l;..lte., ~ ....,.'!-... ll ~,O,,'\.,;i,t.r,\.~lo'

aJ is f this,. this 1!t .a a·enae ia a ~d et publie letter. It :ts

Now; when they. aena· us a let'ter l:tk

I directed to the $i;at~ Lands C~'!l:tssion~. Is this a :publ:tc lett!e.' r llf . 1 '.I.IS , then, that :Ls , so!l!eih1ng ;ui,yone e,an $$:; o:r is .. t. ,lfi~ ... a.·. e:e~ixig J 16, we· give to tha Cwnm:ts111011 aud do not 'g:i.'ve;, the infof'11!atien ollltl l l'!} MR •. SHA'VELsON: Well, I. infbrm.aily suggeat~d that w· • 7

18 j not read these letters verbat:tm into the record for the reaso.

19 r that it cou:t .. a be ,,eonatrtted a-:s 'the Lands ()(Jmmissi.on :a dissemin

20 ~ting som~ of ·.the dat~\ 1~ha·c ls in tl'1..ei~e, ;tn violation of the

ai . Coda. R:tght now JI I tliink we ought to stick to that dee.ls ion

22

23 we might decide that it· ts all right to inake that lnf<.u.'n1a~b:t.on ~

24 publio.

25

26

L_: ·-·-··----···..,,....·--·~«'-• __ ,-IN·-· ___ .. ...,.,, __________________ _

? I I' ,)

'•

~. ·~lt}.'

·t !/ r

·' ,f

"'!?" t·"···· ·~?r .. ,

:f'

. I

r~~OO<f!.li-••'illl•-·.,...Wft'. r· ··-;•r 1_-•iMM~Ul•'il-~ •hiY. :iil~.aJ4I \B(I ti 4Pll'~•Wllil• 1' etnW

1 · J.ett·e:r Gft1d I '1tou1d lik~'. to s~e a et1py of· the letter J

11 then we

~· ·\

3 .. 3·1ve the ~.ntormati~n ou.t at this tlmett? . In other -wo:rda,,, I '/

·1,. want to kfiow ·what we can w1thl10.ld and lithat.groun.dfl we have\ to. ~

:5

. ffithhold 1t;., ~/ r~---

x would suggest ~~at if the l~tter

fiden:tJ .. al by the Oode saction., that ~be letters not be :!'eleas d

9 at this time.; and Itll get a. more complete pictu:t•e of the att -

tude of ou1" ot.f ioa on· that after we nave bad time ta think 10'

Actually, Of couraeJc ina $ense we are. not giving o t

intorm.atiori tha .. t we ha.VIS a-Stained through th.e pe1'mit>' so you

,,could argue it eitshe~ way; but I think in the lllteres,tii o~ 1\ ·'J..4

15

;lG'

.,. 1'17

IS

21

" sz 1 l

caution lt{ would be better not to diasertdnate these letters -

for Oomm.j"aa~on membe1C4s or staff to d1asen1inate, these letters

s.t this time •

?i:m.. CRAN$9:0N: Next 1 tern on the ageada is number 9 -

pavoel of tide and submerged lands ln Santa Barbara County

'l.'.or t";il and, ga.a la&ae "'"I"" Faroel 4. The Chair recomma~da that

this matter go over to the nex\:: meeting.

MR. CARR: So .move*

GOV. ANDER;JON: !'ll aeeond lt. ,.)iii:'-. ( it

~I\," MU. CR..t\.NSroN: Moved and oeco11ded and unanimously

adopted. At this point :gince i;!Ome people may be leav.tng, the

)'c 2~

, 261 i---------------------~~--....._~~·--_... ____ . __________ __..., ______________ _,

(,'\ ~)'l1

~" •·

.(']

1·,

'~: -" c .,

t.~''

l>:S:

(.',, 1¢'ll'l'll;ll'1"1U BtfilMIMilt•Jfill•1d•'. u•· ... ..., ...... ~. '{ t• n . f illtlMT••• - T I? IOI ~ft _lg'illfJfi•U .... i'1U lllll!i'lr tt H ' !'"4iM 32

1 C:f1a.tr wo.uld l:tke to asl-t Ll~ therlli .la nomeons· lu~1~0 i'ron1 Long

a !leach who can gtve 11n a rGport on the extent of the damag<$ "oy,1, . "

3 · the earthquake. 11

(oft the racortl d1\acussi6n ll:l5-ll :20 a.m~} '

5 We will r.econv~ne formally now and

a . proceed to Item 10 -- con.fima:f;iol'l. of tit'ansaetiell$ (JOnsumma.ted ..

7 by the Executive Officer.,, pursuair:it to autno~ity confirmed by

·,a the Com.miss.ion at :tts me(lrting on Oct,~iber 5, 1959. Frank?

9 MR. HPR.TIG: The items tabulated on pages 34 and 35 f

10 :>tour agenda are routine ext ens ions and approvals of assignment

11 of: existing documentation previ0ual:y autho~ized 'by the :r,ands

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

:

Commission,, which actions were un~ertaken pursuant .to specific

delegation o:r authority f:r.om the Conunis1sion to the mc~\cutive ·

Officer, and :t.t is recommeraded tha'~ oonfrinna.tion o.f. these

actions be granted.

GOV. AlIDERSO*: I 1 ll move.

MR. CARR: Second ..

MR,, CRAMSTON: Moved, seconded.;; approved una.r;1.imously .•

Item 11 -- Report on status of legislation_, 1961

session ••••

21 r-m. HORTIG: •• which is noted as informative ou.ly If ·. l 22 · It oan. be amplified that the six bill~:; reported on that llere

23

24

25

26

intx•oduced by the :r:•equest or· the Opm.mio:J:L(;n not only passed ti

Sonate but are all 'l1:a. the Assemr:Jly and have bean bounoirle bac on,

-----------------------~· ·~• *'*'"'""'~-lxr•--·-----•-•·-.,~

1 ;

-·

';.,·~:·,

H

q· -, \

• 0

'6

7

and these are .being to:tlowed lloth in. oonuriitt~~~ and by dloo.ua- ·

sion 1~it.li autho:ra and affcitdlng teQlL~; ;~i~1l' a:?siatance t<J tho~1~ :: 1/'

gentlam.,n on behalf of the Commission. I MR ..• CRAMS!'fON ~ An~r queetions. ·or OOnhilents? (No

' I Nnw we pro~eed to Item 12. ,.~~ Fleport on s.tatus of

9 land se~l.es programs of the State Lands Oommiss:ton; inf~.n:im.a.tiv··.

10. Or).ly 1t.

on

.. 13 ... · a::?L ):)e:r1ding appl:t~ation.s fol? purchase of la.nda trom the State .

. "'

l.4

l:o · statn1$ of such a.pplication.a. anti sp$,nJ,,fic data a,~ to the ls.rids

l.6 . :i.avoJ:xt~.1';:d. ~he xi/report Jl in thre·e ;part~ and ~!t)luntinou~ ~ ha.a. be~r.·

17 del.1veJ.""ed to each ~.,;e th·e Com:miss:toners. Iti view o.t"' th.a v·oli-un·

19

25

r•eport

polioy

i."ot- study aa the bt:u.~ia of d.eteni11n.ati:on o:r GommissJ.on '

on proee$a:l.ng of applica-tiol'!a on auc.h proposals aa wil~ be .t'~comme:nded at tbe n4lxt regular meeting 1' I )

It.1 addition thr:.:reto, m$xy I read to i;he oc~mm:tss1on a 1

12'fbe l?~brua~!' 6th· letter from the F·u.bli~l Land~ Of:f..'J.ecrr· i11di.co.tes the Conun:ts.f1ion Fa de<:,i~ion, to withllo.l.d proco0.1)1.llg of' pu:t .. chase ap1)l:1,~ationG p•:n1d.1ng J.'le:~view and report to be made at tho March. m.t=ct1nf$. ( ~rh:tG io the item unde:r:• con, • .., ~lld~rat1on at the momc~nt.)

!: ;

{'"

' ( ~

I

;·'r_.

1·

If

S.

4

6'

6

7

8

10

l:t.·

12'

13 ,, ~.,,

lei

16

1:7

16

19

20

21 in the

11 .

n c~wret.t-por,dingly, we assu.m.e that· tt1e repc~rt · at:·'1th1t nieeting and oY1lr1ouf.r other rel.'8.ted ln,t'otmation reoei ved by the C"°rmn1sslon eot..tld have a·l)ea.ring on their recommendatfcn for action ..,nappl.Loat\U.ona pending •. oorreapond· ingly, we are to~wa~1ng the .t'ollow1ng 1nrormat1on toJ:J thai'r q.?n&ideration in connect.ion with deteminati<t .. '..UJ that <U•uld he made • . ( (

i/ 1

·\ .. .// - '

In that applications r..t.rw :pending were made . ·. go1ld faith more than one year ago and ln that variioua applications were accompan.ted by deposit~ whioh in certain oaseawere no doubt in aubstantial tt.s"'ilounta, 1t would follow that the applicants being citizens could be inconvenienced !ind suffe~ &" lo'13 Of income .from the amount~ pledged a.long with the appl!i.cations should further processina"J.tlclud1ng tb.e reasonable appraisal on tl1e basia consiat~u1t with that in etfeot .. at the t1Jne ot their applicationJ be denied by d~~ect1ves of the:· State Lands Comm.iesion or othetw pe-rson o;tt persons controlling thia program.

Co11sidering the foregoing i1'lformatio!:'"~ on bel'le.lf <1tf om?selves and gther applicants we petition that any (Jhangea or realigl.'h11ent ln the State IIA'lds Commission policy be applicable to future appli~oat1.on$, rather than existing a.ppl1ca.tions. U it be in o:rder, ltLll you pl,eaaa inake .. thii5 petttlon availabl.e to the Commission at this time as the problem is eoneioered.

Sincerely,

4tomic _Investm1enta, :J;n.c. . \signeu) Elmer E. Tesa;rer~ ·1

34

ThJ.o item wlll be ineluded and dealt with ~pecifical y

t~oommendat.tona to the Oom.mit.ision.

MR. CRANSTON: Any ru:rtha:t' eommenta? (No reswonse)

13' Now wo proceed to Item 13 ,,.._ Statuo oi" ma.Jo1i· litiq;atJ.on --

24 ,Lnfornl$'.:ti.ve onl;;.

i•lR. lIOHTIG: Which it :to atr lotly, a.u t;ha Conun.loa.ton

((

o_")

1

a 3

' 5

6

7

a

the ma;Jn1 .. act.Lon3 in wh.t.ch the gtate lo a party ln inte:t'~st,,1;

as ~~POl"ted on page3 38· and 39 o·t your agenda.

" sohedUjle ;proaedur.'e. F:t"'anlt? '')· ..

MR. HOR~~G: To ex,Pledite the diSCUSS'ion, ~~ .... • .1:. the

:,

Chairman wlll bear with me I will read the :tt·em.

On March 7, 1961, th~ Chairman J::>(HlU.eoted a review

10 calendar-soheduling proeed\ilr'es authorl!cl:ed 't'y the Com.inia.sion

ii· Oatober 29, 195Sl, ror the purpose ot detertn1n1ng 'Whether in4,,.

.. , 12 creased flexibility cf sohedul:Lng is desirable in the prepara · '

·~ 13" tion of the agenda of bus:J.ness £or the Ccmmisoic.ni~

< .>

0 0

_, -'·~~ ~'

()'

. . ~ .,

Investigation of the processing scnedule f:or aljL ,\ /\

15 applloatlona 1~ecei"~ad s.ince speci.flcation of calendar-

16 prii~~raration procedwres on ~tober 29~ 1959, hasonc·t nhown a

::, ::::::

1::~::q::r; f::1:~r::t:::e:::~;g r::::: :$1::::1::~ prior to a schedule-d Gonun:tss:ton m.eet,ing. In at.ktltlon, apec:ta·1! 19

20 meetings were held to proceatl t;hc1se applications :tn.~"ol.vi11g

j

I I ~

0

l 1 l l

21 broad public :lnt~re::.1tQ and public heal th or sa:t'ety wh.Lch Hqu:l r.•ed ./

22 · more e:(pedltious processing than c<.•uld be given. tht"otxgh month .. '

m.eetini..:;o ot: th& Corami;;:1ulon.

25

" A tew aca.ttered "'cqmpla.tat::> have beion ~t1ei:;e1.vod :r1~om

a.ppltua.nt:; de:J.lr•lng more rap l.d C()mt.11'.mlon con:Jl<lcrat ton. All I :,,

·~. 26 or thooe tnotnncao, wlth m1e oxccrtlon, rcuultcd r1~m late o~

"-"--------------------------------------·-----------------------------...-.

• ,,

•

., 1- I ''

'' ~ ' " J ·> ( ' ' ' ,, ," ),

· 5 ·. ,fo*~,j4f>~ rapt,d bt.1t, er.teeti \r~l~~ control1ed {~~l:end~r processi1ng ,·. ,, ! ' :' \ ~- ' . \' . -·· ,, ! •

' \' ",,"

& <fouid. result from ,fk d1.r.~ctiv~ to. the B..~ec~ti\te Officer t,o :!' pa:"1lcfllitS to eonel,.is,ton all app{i.ca&ion~ for operat~Ons wllich

QI ar~.· l.n 1

eilnt?rnumc~; w1.th all ~ta~utor'/ :;N:1quiren::ents and estab-:'

I>rOa·aSsing iS 1ncl.u .. ~led. ill the 1delegatiot:t.S Of authori·ty 1~rom' \\ 'i

th~:~q6lW?li.asion on October 5.• ·. 1959'4 Such a-ctw~a by the Ex~eu 'I' l

tiVQ 11\ocr.tc~r would be Gtibn11:tt6'<l to the cdmmisrriori t'or re1tiew 1

. I

r.t is r~oorrun~:r.~ded that the Commis.sJ..on · ( 1) re&,ff'i.rm

th,$ e~lenda:t1-achedttling p:roQedure~ adopted Oatobe:i:, 29, 1959; ' '\I ' ' ' ' • ·' ,

.t t'

and (2,) direc.'.f:;, the Exec.n~t.ive Oft.:tcer to process to conulusion·

I. ,•,

all applicat:tons for 011e1~at::tons in conformance with all stat,µ or'J7 ' ' \1

rt¥~~~~~~1ttant3 and $~tabl1shed pol.icles of the CommiPsior..l., u;; \, . :

speaitd:ed in th.e dalegationt;$ of authoritzr· adnpte.d October 5, .959

MR. CARR; I doii:tt unde:l...,stand exactly wh~t that

22. me.a:ns1r Mr. ChaJ.rman. Doe~ that mean that G'Llch applioat.tono

.e3 we have b.ad £1\)l~ ea.le; of land would be procon .. secl a.utomatioall

24 and th.en r,1ubmlttod l'or poot r-ev.iew i;o the eonamiaeion, M:~. Hor. ~t~?

23

___ ...._, __ , _,_,.------r~ ....... --• -•-• --•-••'Ill ____ ._,, --.-,--~--·~---·-'-~-· 09"9:-•--.,c,·..,......_.,,........_ __ """

1 . be, 0911veyed. Untie~ t,be atatu.te~, and to as~ul:'e p.~opex- .ccnvey ... ~.

I , ,~~e,, ,~t t:!.tle~ ,p~~i~s~,on rnqs{ cc;m1~ to the' o~~is31QtA· "in··the CJ •• :,

~! ... 1'i. x .. · 'St··.· :.n. st~no~. ,,'• ' .~e .· co····J,y ,th:L~ga .. tb&1.f would b·~ prcicg~a.ed ,wou!d '.

~l H Pt.lZ1l1ttii» e~:iarnen~;>'~ _ l.ioel~e~. toi~ sh~r$-te'rm e:pera:t;i-0n~,t

a.,,. g1.J..gnr4e11te 1 .. ~n.,bl1eaa~1 wbiil:'~, t!)e applicatJ .. ons. are $t~'Pmitted in

~ 't'°'l co:ifo~n,;ie With &.id.a/in{!; specified pol:tc~ ot the Comm:t.&:

1 I 7 t sion 'a rules, and i~gulat1ons and s tat.utes t?-

1 l 8 l\t..R. CARR.; Wheri wcu spe~l< ot permits.Y how bnad is I 9-: that inte;r-px~tation. of :parmlts?

.. 11 ' tt.."le ~'·1.-ds C0trm1i1:.1sion on. a negotittted ba~is,; :ta.<l:~hing; that re-

12.\,, 'qµ'.f~es competitiv~ pul)lic bi.dding.

15. ' 1"b"'ll( 1( ~·l!llt'h~l'\'11.r.,$ . _,_- -\XV~ - JO: ' ~4~l!N.£~,V'~, .•

',.

14 f' Olasaif ioa.tion 2 coulQ .. be ha.ndJ,.ed by you~l

15'

l6'

" 18

2l

SB.

a:s·

25

, :t.s n.ot

:,nitijeot

MR. .l{Of)~J:G: . Could: b~;,

;C-OV,. Al'llDE&S'ON: And then after it wae. done., it eoul 1

lVIR<ll lIORIJ!IG: or ~iisapproval ~ GOr/ «< JUIDER$0N: Supposing \\le disapproved,, then what?

iasued 1.n fact,.,

GOV. ANDERSOM1 In

to our approval?

Mlt. HOR~IG: That lo eusent.tally aor.r~ect.

a

'i '\

Jc ·~~ :.,r 1-I -JOiU-•t -'ltlP_W,~~-·WlllMlt!:f\-*4 'J\d )111'1ff 1 llll j

1 :1 !

~ ({f apprv'l~<t?

'i1

ii . l J- II _ T 'H #,..Ill-~.-..- I'. UIJU Ud~-~....._,

\\ MR. UOR'l'IG: Or c<r>Uld undertrake it on a oalcµlated I

I J

fr.. a.ppr~val and OOl'lf lmat1on by :Che Commission; but invariably '

" · et· the p~snure,~ are: tlUL.t, a piece of: machinery- is at a locatioit .)/ ""' .

· ·t' · ar1d the 1

' contractor wants to 111011e .aome pier and th,!re is no

~.<'"

rt .. ·· Lands Commission m.eeting for two weeks, and where it is routi

a operation and tne applieatiGn oompletely in con£01"1'rtanc~ w:lth

9 ! Commission poliey ai.~d "all the local planning and other agen{}.i,

have a.pprov'id. it and' th-ere are no objections, it W\rJuld appear

the ealculated risk in· th~::Je situations is minimal

O-OV.. AN.DERSOl~: hcept :tr he would move the pier an

then we wouidn 1t approve for aome reason •••••

MR. MOR'J:IG: Right ......

MR~ CARR: ~ake this speei.t'io ••••

'

MR. HOR!IG: • • then :lt would be better to hold

everything up9

MR* GARR: x#er11oval of sand at, the confluence of • I,,

the Amerio.an Fb .. ver ••••

MR. HOR!I&: Yea sir.

•l . MR,. CARI\; Actually, -what is that? Sand }>u:tlda up .

22 ·where it .Ls being carried by the Sacr.,mento ,and deposited ln

"5 the st.ream?

MR. HORTIG: ~hatts cor:rect. 'lftf .:" as• MR* CARR: Bo that lo a..n a.td to navication.

26 L ____ M_"'1

\_ .. _u_o_n_'l_I_G_: __ T_h_a_.t_l ...... a,_c_o_r_r .... e,_c_t_. __ r_f_) _n_o_t_r_.e_m_o_v_e_d_· _b_y _ ___,

1 this peni\it,, the Corps of EngJ.n-.er.s would have 't<) tak~ it ~~n, ~~

,i

That ia 'the type of thing you ha:ve in

MR. OARR: I Just wanted to tind ou,t wh~ther or not

Ni;;

MR. HORTI\1: Yes -- or tor a general type o.t opera.ti ·n < ..:,. -!l

9 . ats with r~spect to issuing prospecting permits or leasing tor i

10 ;boat docks, etcetera, and. so f ortti. There is a specifio polio

11 . in Wl?itin.g in. the record~ of the Lands Conunissicn as to the

12 , scope within which ·~hose :!"l~ems wil.1 be issued.

13' GOV. A~)DERSON: You would probably have awa:rdtjd (a}·. ·

'' ! /14 'and (b) subJ~~t t;o our azt,prova.l today¥ which we upon the requ. ' t -~,;>'

15 . of the Attorn~y Gene1~al de£eirYed..,

16';

17

18'

19

20

21

a2

MR: RORTIQ: I·tew.,s 2(a) and 2{b)?

GOV. ANDE.ll.SON :r· Yea.,,

MR. UORTIG~ I would have withb.eld them in view or

the ques'1ion ·,:raised ,roy the Attorney ,General .. \, 11 , '' ·~I

GOV. ANDERSON; But your dealings would have been

d:lrectly with 1

the olifl1iit?

MR. HORTIG: That 1s corre~~t, ail.'i but these items ..

23 ; particitlal"'l~ items (a) and (b) ..... prospecting pemn-,1te, are

, d (;/, t.tt :t"IGferred to the OJC.fice of the Attorney General :ror clca11at~fJ~

25 as :c."iequircd by statute; and, actually J we have the ·1;1'lt)blom ha;...

40 !~------~t;: fW*lliJ~W~l~·. , ·

1 Attorne~ General's ort1ce. ' a, been a ~.tart ':\~U.#'i~e ntatter ttJ do it e;,:ioa;et.ly the aame •1 i\f,it .

~ I 3 i;lie Att.:;:t'!ie;~ ~.~eral ...... we would'' have bee~·'1.ntormed; we wo·uld,

1

1.

t'. t.da,·~r.e wlth'he~a· action. .. n .

MR. CRAN~ON: Rei'erring to the ;resolutj.on that. ' I I

al app;;ar& on pva~se ·41, which spells out tr1e pi~2cedures tor ealera

7 • closing dates, the nox:mal px•ocedure l~ that: mater:tal r.1ust be ;: (j1,.._ ·•.

a· in ten dars ahe:rtd of' tim~ )!"or con2iderat:tpr;.; and. th.en the pro R .

9 i c.f~du:t;e f'or getting in. if somethir.i.g eomea in after that time

10 S,i.~elled out, co1nes U:'lder 0 2 n -· f·Or emergency rr.atters only,

11 emergency item.a. be1n/~ de.tined a.s those ~1<1b ar~ h:tgb.ly criti~ l i 'I

r \ 12. ~d w".aere delay in .action would re~ult in impeirment to .. the

13 .· public aa.fety 1 1'"1ealth, or walf~11re

li'

15

Ml'l. MORTIG·: That is eor.t"ect M

MR. GRANS'f,'JN: <\

16; that thi~ does give adequat;e opportur.d .. t:tr f9,;? those who m,ay

17 eome in late with som<?thing that is an emerr;ency to the'party

18: involved, put '£1$,:f /'not fit this de.fini:tion of' uimpai:t'men.t t:.? \ \

19 · the public safety, health, or welfare",; whethet< the:r:•e is ett~

20: flexibility to stve us a t;hance to fully connidel'll and yet

21. aeoommoda.te; give a citizer1 or group ot o1t~,.:zens e. chance..,

__ .., __________ . ___ .t'.t9•t•••·~•••·~~.J!t----H..-,_,----·-• ,.,.._e,..,...,, ..,. ... ·--~---------

')' •. :'"'··.· . ','

•'

' l<:

•

l

oovJ.(/Uf!l~, :tt it ia vr;:"!.t( compl.<~x ••• ~. . ,··

"' ··.)Iii'

:£ mor·i!fill

MR'."-· s:olttJ:G; ;m: J~3t doirirt set auy ~1mple cti(#,S atli/

I d•n*ii kt1ow whea:-e they w~~nt t.~, _.,.. tih~re 1~· no .. t.tueb I

T 'till& (~astl tfl:f a la.et~nd .. 11ute applieatittn,. i:f it !~ 1.,ea~\onabl~

'. 8 ·atar1dttrd 1' noneont~oversial and all, ''tiher£ that the Executive

· 9 0.ff1~Q1,. .a,pp:ri;)ve 1t w1der th~ delegat1\'.lll of authcrity ao that

10, the addi~i.1.n1al '~apel~ work that the sppl:1.ca2J1t orc.ttna:rily wants \/,

I

. 11 to u:n.dertflk($ w:tth other agen.e~~u' and so :t~0c1tth may .be undertaike · *

12 'r.h:Ls g~in in t.tr.10 pr1\":ll"" to the aex~ Com.Jn.la$ iotl nu~et:l:ng in m.o$t '

1$, completely v~li!i ur:.de1• tbe statutes, the conslder<l.t:J.on for

. 1.e ·eot1fl1~ation a.t tb.e riext La4~d;s Corr.anission me'~t1na.

17'

, .. l!J. fo1; a.tt applicant;.; an ind:t. vidu~.l i3 go:tng 'to .reel lt,, lf> super-

19 :l,mporban.t £or :tfr&ediate acti,,rH but it if] guin{i to inriJ:ude

~b cont1,,oveJfJaial or pol~tey determ;tnat:tvr; n1atters which, Ul1.d~r tho·

21 deltlgation of authPl\Jity, at least thin &1'ecutlvo Of:Clc~r would.

la' net undertake to i~~aolv.ra but ttfot..lld oi~ nece;lsity holcl and b:ri?1~;

'31' to the Commistllon for dete1,t·11:1 .. natlon :tn th~ ri?;"l;),t in.tJtant.HiiL~

~ f)et the elimination. 011 the nceo~uJ.ty 1\H• uub.r1ilttlng r~outlue ta] I J

•

j ' \l ' , ' ! , ' •, ,,, ·• lta .~~. ~.1,..~fl•"'".;.~,.., ..... ,._..~,_, 1 ~·1"""""""'!li!'"'"''""-~•·•u""*"'~"~1·1•1i!1ll!")'Jo!I. w•o•h <'~'111...-.-•i•~.· ·11ill1r,.1l•~1·.

, , .~·· . 01~er~tit.>n$ . by · t~k~~1g on tliat .. routli':\e ~ . . ~ · . .. · . •. ·O ._.,fl

1· ' ' <:>

I" is ao Bpecif 1o wh~:t~e it ~a1·s n\,:r:.ll 1h the ea.~~·. ~t Jh1blle healt ~ ...

0 ( 'Bat'e1,~ 'or walt~tr 1.s this· &et:i.en to be 'taken It- Iti> .isne:n~

~ii tbert:i m~t c<Om,t ingtancef.1. t"ather o:ften tha~ atte not ·t.oo ,,.

~~" pl.1eated, in trilieh the Exe~ufJi.v-h Off' Lee~ migl:rt r'~·liiii'tle dtunag~ ~; '~, { .

1., .· bG1ng dnn.e tc som.e priva*a~ aitimt~n o:t~ g1"'oup o:C .~1.tia~ns., whit.'h

8 · :. would be benet:icial to h,,,.m if he eoul(:I get som.e aeti.cn and S'Om

s·I exped.tent de('}1S:to11; and if lle is a:utomatiieally .'t?u.led out h'aea:

':LG . J.t doesn rt 00111e under th<ii publ:!.q healt:h, safety a!l.l.i weUare • j U ·. I lfOnder :!.:I.' it i.s the intertti o:t' the· Cornmias;J.on to have 1t that! &.l

1

··. : I str 1ng®nt1: .. :a •. ~~,,~: .. '..·Qwn....... "-"'>i!"'.... 1!"!.'f'.· ~'"". U""*e. °' .. ~ )l,'.1£4,.,. .nv,.n..x.·11- ~ t'1'a7 :r reply to, that?. _ .... ~J ... w .... ...,...., ~~ ..... ..,

."'At ... 4. II·.• ... ~ c.on:id. erEtd at the time these specifieq,;tior"'s we1:i-e originall ll'

. 15, drafted, aild abser1t a cJ,oaing of tb1s door_,, we WGuld be baol-t "

l. el' in the s1tua.t:l.on. -w.·he:re the <lolim).isfiiio11. .t'tiund l.tiJelf and. Whe~~ i .

17 , W1it8 Celt desiroua 'bo adopt this as a policy ........ booaiu~e, cibvicu, ly

1s1• .. · !:o eve1:"9' o:l.tiBen Who has .an !l.PPJ.icat1on .. • thl.s applioa,tion is I it ,

1

to hirn. of para.mount importanc.e. Wlthou.t ~hitS dooJJ closed., you

2r.» gentl,emen. on the OorrunltS::.d..on,!l if there is any openlng, a.::;;e irrune .

. ,)1'.

U~lon otu~ review; we :t.1.:1ve seen all matt~n."'s not p:rocH~s ~a

24 , lnufied:lately to the J.1ta:ta l~antla Oom.lnio~l:on were, ali I nay,, l.ate

~' 01,. in<}Omplete; oi~, a:;;l ln the uxtre:m example we 11ad, mo:n:l;hQ ;Jf

~ r.·efuoal on the pa1"lt t.>!' tl}~~ o.ppl.tuant 1;0 evcn1 r llo an appllcu.t:l. n

e: $ . th' lang~aage'. :t13 1'££·.publi-11 welta:t'@H

.. \ . ,,' '

7 I.\ ?~"' 0 ··11b;t~IG:' Ri.ght.

'

'" 10 MR@ liOR~!G; R:tgh.1:; "

.MR~ CRANSfON: An'Y further questions? {No :x:\esl;'onse)'

ta . We proceed to Item 15 _,,,,_ j.ssuance o.1 .. d~edgi1':lg pe:r:'mlt :i to Ii

ll-_ Associated Contracto:t?a, ~;o excavate 22,500 aub~t.c yar~is oi~ ·~ ,, 1,

14; mate:t--ial a:e royalty tJ'f.4 th:r~=:e eent15 pe1"'· tn11'ic yax~d.11 r~ont

';)

!i:SI l56,l53'-$~X.e-i'oot portion of salt Vorka Clane.l, Ri~.rdson

is_. · , •.. Bay, Marin CoWli.ly.

17 NR. fti;QR~.£.Qv !•lr. OhaiJ.~na.n,, I don't: believe the , :i' ;record ahowa that we had any act:t:.m on the pr.,oed.l.ng motion,

, -~ __ -_}1· __ :_1~~-''.}_~.·._:~' " MR. ORAN£Y.l'.'ON'li Was there a motion made?

>· ·_,.:, 20 MR .. HO.RTIG: Noai There was a reeo.rri.mendatio:n of the I),'

a1 2!'

'';!fU ,l.,ua ••

I .move.

CitAN.STON:

I I 1

f i I I

... J 1j '

·.'/

' 1

't'

'.'"\ \,)'>

-il'·~1,....;~u:U!i1•0~4l'~~-••""·10 1 ~_.~"' ''"'"II'·"'•''"''"·""' ~llii'>M'Al•ll'IHilil!l•*'"""uf~'----""""""4~ '

'\ (\

• $: amottnt ot .santi if~1ere.L."1 ~., ai.~d tl1• Nmov·aI 1• in an &NI. here• i • If . . . . '

gP.ant•d. tG .;n.e ·Oounwr ot F.iflrin., \!~~which the minerals · . ·

:1 I

17

" t:o.t•ore . ~ '

ii J'

MR4\ :OP,J~}!Si1CN: Motion is in order.

MR~ C!ANS~ON; App~ovtAl. mov:ad, $ec.ondep,,, unan:tmou.sl .. , . iY r

-- detenn1nat1on

11 · ~f date# tllr1e and place ot the next Commission m.eeti:r~~ ~ w

lta have ~ ten ta ti ve sche~!lu1e now? '

11 MR.' HOR:t!l:G: Ue had mentally,, l)U'C 1ica;r ',I i:n:agg~~1:, Ml ....

a I Cl:lainll~ ~ that that ttet:~mLnatiou be held :Ln al:r~l'ance wlth th '

: 9 • yosaihility in mind ol' l,'lelecting lateri •·~l:l. ~ can, a parllio •

20

1.l la:rl.y wact:!.cal da:ile to MJ;l.11ci'Cl.e with when the Comin1ss1on oan ·

., be int~ormed by the Attorn .. ey Qep.e~a.l with .respect to our oil. 2-& I

1$1& sas leasing poliay. {, ..

MR. Cl'AUSTON; :Ci.d we wish, howevex•1; to set a regular " h&"te? · ai. m•eting new, apart- .frt)m .any upeci~l meeting we migh'<;

251

' ..... ,~~·NJ .:;- "·.:;.,-;.

.(~.

II'' 'I ,

a 1:>the~1 ' hand 1 ' approx:lmatiell' thiey (l,ays rrom today would be a

s',daairable date, in -order to P•rmit stat:f'proqesaing or the !;

4 ·, .agenda. ~e , resula1" me•tlng ttate, · of<< course;; ~Jrld be ._,the ()'·-~,:

fJ last Thursday of' th~.a month,\\ lihich l~ a prepar.,t.i.on ~1me almos

a . .i.mposs1ble ·t;'O meet~ 1\

)"

7 i MR. <JRANSfON: ·· Is Vedn•&day or Thursday, May Srd o:r

a 4th, a.u1t&.ble to the other membe11Ja?

9

lO

GOV~ ANDER$01'!: I w,n not.t ,sttl:'>e -• May 3rd. or 4th * ••• -

MR. Cl-:ANS!J?ON:: J"ohn.t llow about y<tU? WeQ. •. nesday, May

12 MR. 1CARR: Well.)1 I have an appointment in San Franci co

~

14.

15'

1a,

MR. OaAl~S'rGUilt How about Thursday?

?.m. C"ARR.: Tt.tu~d\tty ii 0- K.

MR .• m!NS~N: :t'hurieday" the 4th,, ten~ativel~. Will

17 you ci1eck tl"lat, Glenn?

18

20 I , . 1·

21 · NR+· OMNS~ON; Did aomebody wi:.ih to be heard oli that ___

1

_. 22 prev:tous itemt

23 · MR. HU'.t'eHISON: Ml:', Cha:!.rman, memllel'll , :t .am • E.. l.:o~ l•

24 Hutchison, consul tine; etlgineer i"or the As~t.,ci~ted Contra .... to,rs •

. 25: I have about f'ou.:.. ... hat~... I am Preoident ot th.61 liun.ters Polnt

)' \) (\

ff

:J.-' H )i '. '''" ((

v;; ;: ""

:_,. I

l

'

l., Company in Saus&li~o.i arid. I wa.a very inu4h J.nterestt;d in Mt-~

s GOV;. lNDERSONt Whiob item ls this?

,,, 4 : MR.. CRANS'fON: · I:t4lm 15,,

'.)

6 '.i(lll.S the apeo:1.t1'o c.aae wheri the equ:tpm.ex1t wtu$· already at work

7 , ana W$ d:l.dnt t realize the State had anw more :!.n.ter£st in the ,

a area.because it was granted to the Count7 of Marin and we

g haantt ta,V~n 1teps to obt8in a pennit to ~move the niatet>ial.

10 The rua.aon l '·d like to speak about it is tb.1ti::

J r ... ,.

l·. l.' 1•. Numbe~ 12 and. it

one~, the removal of this ::t.s ror the benefit o:f na.v1gat1· ll

is q-q.i te di:ff i.ou!t to .f:tnd a pla.ee· t.o deposit th.is

13 • material 'beaauae ot, tit1e locatn.ton of it-. We al:3o ha11e in this '\\-::: "

14 ca.vial an a.dd:tti.orltl 1area oi" .nearJ;y a utile that. needf! to be

15 . dredged and wt don rt kl1ow whe;ne we e.~e 1;oing to put tht;) ma:t:0.1~:t

1e " and we d<)n:' t thinl.c. it :ts proper tl"i...at we allould be ol1a.:rged a

1 l~ royalt~i: !'or benefiting n~v:tgation -~ whiob ia a bene.tit to tti.~.

18. state as a \'ihole ar;;d not neoea~arily to the 11.1dividu.a.l peop.J.e •. j tt Ve didn't p1iotest this because we know it is a matte~ l!O I of routine. Ve don 111 want to be :1111all about it, but tbJ.s whol.L

.,.,l. Riohardsc;.m, Ea;v 111tua.tion needs to be l;'eviewed smd Itd l:tke eoJ. Iii ..

s ion to go into trlis matter 1:n. a way wl1ere an· equt table sol.uti ~n f'· •

24. calll be arrived at -- beC)a1iat: it is not oi1ly tho p;roperty owner'

25' but countiel}) and eitie~ a.1~e all 1nvclved in tnio.

26 l am quite sui~ Mr <J Mortie ia-1ows oomethinc; about

l hut I . don 1 t think doteJ:'llllnlrag mud ls mine.t~a1 ia the · .t~uli into

of the law that t'h• Legislat;ur$ stated when they were re••rvi a s the mineral rignta. .o.r cour-se i,., Sis di1rta.1n it ifi either

5 it 1a mineral -- but it haa no :real value.

6 I MR. tJRA.NS~N: Are you requesting that we rescind

7 j thG applioation at .three <.H~nts?

MR. Ht.P:CCHISON.: I think :Lt aho¥tld be granted w1thou !

9 Howeve111, we don• t want ta 'be a.mall about it. It ts a matter o

10 present regulations -- ~"' don tt want to go contra to tba.t. '>

11

I \' J ' ·11

' ii

12 about this 1n San Fr&toiaoo and this is a .t-ather peculiar sit .....

ul tio!j. If :!.t :!.sntt'!!Wleral, then we dontt have any jur1sdict:!. •

14 ian•t; that r1ght1 ,Mr. Ho:t1tig?

r.m. llOR~:t:G: That 1-s oor1~ect.

rm·. &f'Jtt In. thit.f parti~ul~ oaa(~ b~oauae th;ts ha..

MR .. HORT:IG: Y•s11 with the ?Jes~n:"vat1011 to the Stat,e .i\

May I point out in reply to yotttt qul~

20: tion and a.a a po$~1ble suggtation to Mr. Hutchiaon, the atatu

21 ha:ve. beGn 111e&lnlar9hed, the ap,t,lieability haa been determineds -~ tide

supported to ube point that othe~ ~ranteos· of State/arid aubme gad

lands (who t•eeosn:tze this diff:tcuJ.t.y and the fact that there

241 no e.1u$rnative e9urt$e of procedux-e it thAa State Lands 'Comm:J .. sa· on

23 is to' admilliiJ t~r tllo State m.ineral reservation) have not quea

:as toned tha appl:LcabilUy of the statute; but oven now have un Gl~

~· ,',

r;.:' ' ~'o'.:'

" h • " ' ,,· 48 .,,.__...._~ ...... (Oiill•~lfl)~~fillllMl""1M'tlW• !l'Wif!jl~lllllf81ti"4Milll•l.f••Mf!•lfjf"*""• ..... l~IM,i.'M~~flj\1 .. JJ1 W."1U.. ..... \iil1l1Pfilijf#olo,~-;~I(:~· ........ ~~

·- . .I ,, .~

.. i: considerati,an in ,'the Ltg.lsla~ura for all ili\rbor and navi~-~·19~·

. I , '1.evelop;a~~t at"e~a· & proposal thttt. thri , at&tlAte• , ~V:t1At~~.ttf£ th1'1' · \ ' ' 1 I . ' [\1-, '

. ; 4Naa be;~ a.M.nded tc· pro\rj/J.~ 011 thi:s, mJ;.*eral, r~eel~vatioi1 1tl.i;v.i . 1

',,

~~'.\,, 't~on, and1 th• neQtSsit~t to collect r~)ya.lty thert..e"\'oi~ ~hat t;

"~.

"'' ·· 11ah3ll not B,pply ~o 11uoh o;p;r;:t>a.tioiu .. as aro.,,o.ci:nduoted it!. aid t

a · n.a-v1gat :tonn ... ,.,I~ th&r•b¥" ~ :t:i' ad,;p~d aa l~·gielation.t then t~a:ta

7. Wi:Juld · elea:r the decke. foi1 trM! .b1~.ads Com.m1ss:lor.1. to make auch

a rlicognit:.t.011 , of i.t that you Ill:~' advoo~~t.tng and w:0.:1.cb, as 1J: $8.Y'.;,l ''

9 . illl being advocated by other h&.rbo.:t' districts ru1d without obJecL ui tion by the State Ll;m!:ls O,.,mm1ssion; but counsel ha.v1> :l.nf'omed l ll the State IAnda Oo.mm.Las~~on what they -a~e ~;no.lo2ed by unde:t*

12 p1 .. ~n:.ui1nt statutes •.

13 ~. \

15

17 'poor to good till. matGr:l.al and .llll bEl.l.!1.P.; Q.eposited,·· in !l1IUly in~ J'

18 atanoes on adJoilll.ng 'Stm..t~t land<'l pro"'.r:tdes l"*ecla3.m.ed land that_

19 aan. ~e used tor othe~- pu1'1$:ioaes ar1G. ears~ the:i:ietore,,, be used in> ''·

2.0 lieu or oth<Jr more expens:tve materials arid on this baaia has ~

22 GC)V~ ,l~-~!D!~tSOM: I~! thr,ae cents a :ta:tr ma:t?ket value? l ~' MR. HOR'l!W : 'l'h:l.a :l.tl 'Ii reas enable market . value '1ld · 1 24, haf1· 'Jee11 e$t~'bl:Lr;hed by the C·;;.lnwui~lSiQt:l. and has been pa.id by j 25 Jl~Lny., many pern~itteeo" ,Ji 2& ~Jl ~ CillU'i: Th:t~ : is $t>'75 "l

----*·~·,, l'J'f134carii:IJ~\~ .............. ....... t;_,..,..._, ._.., _________ _

,-'J

'l '

, .. . . " 4 l r-MR...--141i!!~!!!IO ........ ~ ...... ~-;:;;;-;:~···~~:- "", ·~~----..-.. ---·~~~; .. 3., · MR~ HU'iC:i:iISONt ~~t ma:ln thing,, cf 1~oui~$e, was th,e ..

3 • 1r.c1eonven:!.ou.ce. .• \f{i w:"~ tt a~ ~i:, it «nd we.! app1'41<:1A te the ... 1·.

4 actLan Mr. Hort~ ha~ tiilken :!.n getting this o,ri the agenda :tlor I 5 ua,. Ve w•11s ?'a:t.tn.r~-~~P~-1.~~•d t;hat we. WQl~ ncrtified to do it 'j .~·. · a · but I ~~ f;b.inking abeaqt;-~b~t 3'em~~t1.ln•~ n~eds co be done about

" 7 thia a1tuat1C>n bseauae in th.is instat1oe we oorl.ld. have had. ~ ·, ·~~,

r" i: ..

i<1 a . pl.acttd ot1 ou.r propGi"tY · ao~ict mattJrial at l'ilas cost than it is

1> :r

·~ .

•

9 , · co~t:bi,g us to d:t,.edge the canal aud plaoE$ thiB matex-iaJ .. on

f 10 f ar.,,id on top of that we a:1•e charged a royalty f'or something w~

ll I would rather r"ot have~ I am showin1$ you ~r1s.t in oona1dera.:tio 1

l2 of. tMSe matters even nou or in the f.'ut.'lu:'e it is quite dif'f'icu .t

131 tG det '·'.')nine wh,ai; is, the., equitable aitua:tion •...

1.4 GO"f .. AMDBRS01'h:, 1. Mr. Hartig, how do '.YOit a.1 .. rive at a

1:5 three-nent.. rate t·or this if the31· c~~ ~et 111 o:htapei' elsewhere

15 · and · b•ti'ler'l

17

ie the permita, SJ.'e so small t:Pat th~ royal.by apt1;,~.l.ly <J,oJ.lected

19 bar.sly pays the OOtn.I'11isa;to11 rs. ryosta of ;process:l.ng the ~enn.:tt o

20 In this inatartce tb.e:re are a ~t"e'i~r morr;: ¥ards, a.."ld I bhink l\;'.ir.

21 · .. Hutchia·vn will ag:t."ee ir1 corn.pa.x~iaon lfith the total proj•ct ·tlla't

S2 · the total estimated ooat or $6115.J even. ~'~ the minimum ~"lh.arge o

2s th11ee c~ents a cublo ya.rd, iJl. not e:ltoeaaive. I th:tnk Mr ...

24 .Hutchison ta PI'Obl~~m with the Com.rnisalor.1. ia tl".1.is -- that he ia

...._ ________ ..._, ___ .. --,~-·~-~----·-··---~----·--~------------------------------"""----'

•

. <'.

' ... • { '

,,.

·.. ~

"X··""' """'w-a· ..... t-1l ... d.""'" ..... P:-·,-t~x·,-11·1!lioi~"""'t: .... T"""7~=;o~:;,;;u;:-·",__--.. ""·J 8

$

7 l to the st:ate and this. may not be g:t.ven to pt'ivate uita:r.eata

6 r Withou;t ehar~e by the Landa Commission; it l-WUJ.d be giving

9 j away State p:roperty. ~ill iif an ext~ oo.ee, but thee e are I.

lo. j, the bo.rdera within wllioh we have to operate. I

MR. mJT'CKtSOl'~: In this oase halt the ma.tar!al will "\

12 b0 ;placed on s·treets ar1d roadi.l whi.eh will 'become!. county roads

l3. ~- st31eetthi '!hi•7i ls. a di't't:to~...ilt qi;Jest:ton and I den.it want t

14 appear small about~ :tt, but· .I d.o thib.k it; aliould have oonatder .. ~

ia . tion .in the future beaa:use ·that Ritaharaacn Bay ar(fdl i.:$ a ~~"~')lf'i m

lt aoo· Mai~rn Cc.runty has bee~ t:t?f1ng to g$t tAat dredr;ad~ ·

18. land t~t will have va.l:ue? ·

19 MR~ RlJ~CHISOM; In· 1t1rde:r.~ to d.ispt.u3e of :t.t,, -yeSJ; b11t

20 there :t,u so muQh. material the.tie ·that much ox.~ it oan~t be d.is-1 21 · p.c}sed of Uit1less some· pro1;i~ttt:1 ownex~ will let you pla<:~a i:l\ . ·

. ~\ !

af;l 1 t;here. 'rhei1l don't wa111t .it. ·:he oounty .ts t~·ingr to wo:rl= out

23. a thta~l, asking tihf~~ ownet1b to talt::e ·tho mat~:tt-:Lal a.stl~ iia:y tor it

24 a:nd d:redge the oana3. a:v 1t ma~r be tt!lett~ It l.$ quite 1.nv01l~-1t~d.

,__ __ ..._ _____ ,.... ___ ..,,.,,_., ... ·---· -·-· _,,.. ______ ... _¢;1-· -o-r·-~~.-.. ~• i~-· .. '•-•• -· _ .. ,.._.,.J

•,/

MR., ~pR.TJ'.:tJ: '!·~is., then., Gov:F):mor giveo i1s tm ad.di ,, ~'-

,~... ' \~ \

\i 7 advantage Qr dis.stdvantage, of the St.ate 2 t:J :r~eserved minerals

· 6 .f; ti,onal. d:tf.i~~oulty in that wtl cannot· permit the con11era:ton, to I .,.;y .. , '

'<? ; a ' at; no <!ost i' Ot" tile llene:t.'it er a pri va to contract. I / ~ ' 91 MR. liUTCHIBONi Well, I have an instance in Sausali '

; :'.' ,., ... 10 the J)ttople a:tye going .. to dredge one of' the streets and they ha-,/r,\ \: ,_ l[ -., . ! 'l 'I

I

11 the same g1 .. ant.. there as ~lse.lthere > ··. and they asked us if we~

12. : jlj'OUldri t t · lr;t them . depoa:t tr this material on our ·land. Well, w

we~ :i:~aluetEt.nt to d'.' it. In another yaSrP 'Or 1~0 we will be

,14 revamp·· in~. that entire ai~ea. and we don tt

1

w~t 1

~0 ~6ve mater:ta.l J ·~. C) I \' .'

15 . arqund fro~: one place to,. P..nothel't. It ts quite c•atly to do an

reclailJa thia land,, ~llti we don rt thlr.c.ki: we should ha"Ve to pay a

17~ royalty tor it•

I am wondering,. a~t .Pres ·. . I J

·'

19 den.t 9:e t,he Board of 'fruuteea o:e the Hunters Point Reolamatio

20 Distr1a1f. We have a.sl"ed the Legislature i.f they can make an

......

291 ~nab.li1ic act to h~ve a const:l.tut:ianal amendment allowing, the

',. .. ··.'··-·.,·.-. =.:.~ .. 1· .. ·· State Landa GommiHion to dispose of! these tidelandn to pri va., Ii 'c ~· ~. ~ioll \i\evelope~&. beaauae it is a stwnbling bloclt to the d.e\i'ttlopment

11

, Mn. 'CRANS!t'OM: We have to bring this ·to a tJloae at

1; 2~ thia poirit. May I ask: Would you like us to withhold a.ct ion

. . Be and re1;:iort back?

No 1 ,,

a. Thi~ is :?n• of tho•• Mr. Ho~;~I untionec.r.

MR'" ~CHISON: I would like to dia~uau this. matter .•,,

MR. 0 RAMS~~ON; Oer·tainly. It d like to ask Mr.

~ ,, · rf,,,' ltutch:Lna ~e thing in regard tO' the formality of Mr. Pauley ta l ~;, \, ffl protaat. The letter of Mr. Paul.ey to the Govern~:t re.t't1t'l'ed ilf j\ 9 ~I g(!tle!'al to the Rtoh.t'ield proteat. Richfield has now 'Wi.thdra j fl~ ' };'!·.;" J,,o t.~eir protest ()n J?ai•eel 3. Do you lEtaVe standing foxmial p:r.o ....

!.ell., ·t~sts on both Paroe.ia 2 and 3; or are you, like R1oht.telct, ,,,.,\\

~). '\ J,

. ". ~~~ 12. · can.tining Jrour protest ·to l'a:o~~1· 2? ~-.~ ,,

, "'·t·i···, .. ~ ... N.·. \ ~. 'r. ' t '' 14'

"~~. ' f''-''l.CY; like Ri.chfield., ·

11• • ~·J.-f- • ' ·1''

Mtt. OMNS1'0N; · I think to clear the· air we sliotild I

know whichever yot:;. want t·o. do.,

MR. ID1!C:HIN$: J! th;t,nk £or th~e record we Will, let i (;

~ts.nd aa is, Mr. Ci."anston ,..._ object to both of them.

rm. CRANSTON; Thank you very much. I believe we

t:: . ·· ,'SS My name is P.aul Home. I <!JI\ with the Standard Oil Compa.~y, .11 ~\ < 24 Western Operttti!:>nsl> In connect :.on with the lette:tls wh:Lt!h war

25 del:tver~d by, various \!\ompaniell, one of which was del:Lvered by

,\

'·"

\:.

~~~.

··~·

! -:-

" ·~ /~"})

··• ,,

•

Sta.nda.:i."id, theI'e waa .. c:mie d:t.scuasion this .. mornir1&\ aa '\

a the.i Comnd.:asion was !''f:qulred~ ·c;c.; treat those ,iin eonfident:la.l or

,S · 'was privileged· to disposa or :i t~eir contents.. I. wiah to state '

t"o:v·. the :record foi"t Standard of Oalifom:ta that our lette:v ia

:1 e 7

8

9

10

11

12''

13

"

not to be cons1de4'ed a.onf:.tdential oXt priv~tleged in any sensa.

The! Commissi(':)n is .tree to do anything they w1sh w1 th 1.t.

MR. GRA~fSTON: · Thank you very much.

I:t1 there :t.e no·tl,lin,g f'l,;tJ::thel'lr to eome bet'oJ:"e us j we

stand adjcurned.

14'

15

l&

17

18

19

20

21

2S

23

24

25

26 ,__ ______________________________________________ ........ ________________ _

) f(

.... l•llO llOlol !Jt'O

.--------......

" I 3

I\

v\

:r:., LOUISE H;'.1 L!I..LIQO., repo.~·ter for the Divi~J.ton or . I

, 5 · T:t:f'ty~three pages contain a full., true and aorrect t.ranaaript

a ·of ·;the 2'h.ort.hand not»ea ta.ken by me :tn the meeting of the

1 STA~E LANDS COMMISSl-OM in Sacramento, California, on April 12,

a .. 196111

. ! 91

10

191 20'

'25

Dated: Sacramento, California, April 17, 196le

----- ·--' _,.,,... .....,.,,, __ _

\I, ,, 1)

I

I

2$ L ___ ._. ____________ .. ______ ___..i

• .>

'I

I I

)1 !i 5 participants - ca state lands commission...

Documents