1 erzincan military hospital department of ...thirty adult albino new zealand rabbits were included...

1
Glubran 2: A New Alternative for Nasal Packing Enver Cesmeci, MD 1 ; Onuralp Kurt, MD 2 ; Salim Dogru, MD 3 ; Murat Salihoglu, MD 3 ; Zafer Kucukodaci, MD 4 ; A>la Gungor, MD 3 1 Diyarbakir Military Hospital Department of Otorhinolaryngology, 2 Erzincan Military Hospital Department of Otorhinolaryngology, 3 GATA Haydarpasa Training Hospital Department of Otorhinolaryngology, , 4 GATA Haydarpasa Training Hospital Department of Pathology Enver Cesmeci, MD Diyarbakir Military Hospital Email: [email protected] Website:S Phone:905057950464 Contact 1.Alkan S, Dadas B, Celik D, Coskun BU, Yilmaz F, Basak T. The efficacy of NS2Sbutyl cyanoacrylate in the fixa>on of nasal septum to the anterior nasal spine in rabbits: experimental study. European archives of otoSrhinoSlaryngology : official journal of the European Federa>on of OtoSRhinoSLaryngological Socie>es. 2007;264(12): 1425S30. 2.Dinis PB, Haider H. Septoplasty: longSterm evalua>on of results. American journal of otolaryngology. 2002;23(2):85S90. 3.Huizing EH, Groot JAMd. Func>onal reconstruc>ve nasal surgery. 2nd edi>on. ed. Stusgart ; New York: Thieme; 2015. p. p. 4.Habesoglu TE, Kulekci S, Habesoglu M, Deveci I, Deveci S, Toros S, et al. Compara>ve outcomes of using fibrin glue in septoplasty and its effect on mucociliary ac>vity. OtolaryngologySShead and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of OtolaryngologySHead and Neck Surgery. 2010;142(3):394S9. 5.Genc E, Ergin NT, Bilezikci B. Comparison of suture and nasal packing in rabbit noses. The Laryngoscope. 2004;114(4):639S45. 6.Boenisch M, Nolst Trenite GJ. [Fibrin glue for opera>ve correc>on of septal devia>ons]. Hno. 2004;52(11):963S7. 7.Lemmens W, Lemkens P. Septal suturing following nasal septoplasty, a valid alterna>ve for nasal packing? Acta otoSrhinoSlaryngologica Belgica. 2001;55(3):215S21. 8.Nunez DA, Mar>n FW. An evalua>on of postSopera>ve packing in nasal septal surgery. Clinical otolaryngology and allied sciences. 1991;16(6):549S50. 9.Alar T, Ceylan KC, Duman E, Usluer O, Basok O. Is Acrylate CoSmonomer (GlubranS2) Useful in the Preven>on of Prolonged Air Leaks AAer Pulmonary Lobectomy? The Indian journal of surgery. 2013;75(5):373S6. 10. Buric N. Use of NSbutyl cyanoacrylate with metacryloxisulfolane (glubran 2) surgical glue for flapless closure of oroantral communica>on. Implant den>stry. 2013;22(3):238S43. 11. Erkan AN, Cakmak O, Kocer NE, Yilmaz I. Effects of fibrin glue on nasal septal >ssues. The Laryngoscope. 2007;117(3):491S6. 12. Korkut AY, Teker AM, Eren SB, Gedikli O, Askiner O. A randomised prospec>ve trial of transSseptal suturing using a novel device versus nasal packing for septoplasty. Rhinology. 2010;48(2):179S82. References Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate histopathological effects of Glubran 2 (n-butyl-2-cyanoacrylate and methacryloxysulpholan co-monomer) (GEM S.r.l Italy) on septal tissues of rabbit. Methods: Thirty adult albino New Zealand rabbits were included in the study. Rabbits were randomly divided into negative control (n=6), positive control (n=12) and study (n=12) groups. In positive control group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and then unilateral nasal packing was inserted into ipsilateral nasal cavity. In the study group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and glubran 2 was applied between the flap and the septal cartilage. Rabbits in the positive control and the study groups were killed 3 weeks and 8 weeks after the flap elevation. Samples from the excised nasal septum underwent routine tissue procedure for histopathological evaluation. Results: Mild mucosal inflammation was observed in both study and positive control groups. Mucosal ulceration was not observed in any of the groups. Mild mucosal thickening was detected in the study group at the end of eighth week. Significant decrease in the thickness of the septal cartilages was observed in both of the groups, but there was no inflammation or degeneration. Conclusion: We detected that Glubran 2 does not lead to a significant histopathological response in rabbit nasal septal tissues and can be used in septoplasty operations performed in humans. Key Words: Nasal septum, septoplasty, nasal packing, rabbit, glubran 2. Abstract Mild mucosal inflammation was observed in both study and positive control groups Mild mucosal thickening was detected in the study group at the end of eighth week (chart 1). Mucosal ulceration was not observed in any of the groups. There was no difference between the study and the positive control groups in terms of submucosal fibrosis, loss of goblet cell and loss of cilia. Foreign body reaction, granulation tissue formation, loss of cartilage was not observed in any of the groups. Significant decrease in the thickness of the septal cartilages was observed in both of the groups, but there was no inflammation or degeneration (chart 2). There was no difference between the three groups in terms of perichondrium thickness. IntroducEon Thirty adult albino New Zealand rabbits were included in the study. Rabbits were randomly divided into negative control (n=6), positive control (n=12) and study (n=12) groups. Rabbits in the negative control group were sacrificed after removal of their nasal septum at the beginning of the study. The positive control and the study groups were divided into two subgroups with six rabbits in each group to investigate short- and long-term effects of Glubran 2 on nasal septal tissues of rabbit. In positive control group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and then unilateral nasal packing was inserted into ipsilateral nasal cavity (figure 1). In the study group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and Glubran 2 was applied between the flap and the septal cartilage (figure 2). After that septal cartilage lightly compressed with a wide-tipped forceps for 60 seconds. Rabbits in the positive control and the study groups were killed 3 weeks and 8 weeks after the flap elevation. Samples from the excised nasal septum underwent routine tissue procedure for histopathological evaluation (figure 3). Methods and Materials Septoplasty is one of the most frequently performed procedures in otorhinolaryngology. Several complications including septal hematoma, infection, abscess formation, septal adhesion, and septal instability can be seen after this operation (11). Nasal packing, septal splints, septal suturing, or tissue adhesives may be used to avoid these complications. However, each has own advantages and disadvantages. Using fibrin Glubran 2 fix the flaps is a new technique that is effective and easy to apply in a shorter operative time, shorter hospital stay, and with better patient satisfaction. Suture technique is one the unpacking method to fix the flaps. However, its use is limited, it is a laborious application in terms of the surgeon, it causes additional traumatized area and prolongs the operation time (7, 12) Tissue adhesives are another unpacking method. Erkan et al (11). reported that fibrin glue cause to intense inflammation, prominent cilia and goblet cell loss, submucosal significant fibrosis, mucosal damage, increase in mucosal thickness and decrease in septal cartilage thickness. Discussion We detected that Glubran 2 does not lead to a significant histopathological response in rabbit nasal septal tissues and can be used in septoplasty operations performed in humans. Conclusions Septoplasty, performed to correct nasal septal deviation, is one the most frequently performed procedures in ear nose throat clinics. The main principles of septal surgery include correction of the anatomical deformities of the septum and restoration of the nasal functions, while protecting the mucosa, cartilage and bone as much as possible (1, 2). For this purpose, an incision is made from the caudal septum initially and then submucoperichondrial and submucoperiosteal flaps are elevated (3). Nasal septal anatomy must be restored after making the necessary corrections in cartilage and bony septum. Submucoperichondrial and submucoperiosteal should be placed back to restore the nasal septal anatomy. Nasal packing with a variety of materials is used to support septal flap apposition, close dead spaces between cartilage and mucoperichondrial flaps and prevent complications such as bleeding, septal hematoma formation, infection, abscess formation, septal adhesion, and displacement of the cartilage or bony grafts (4, 5). Nasal packs are commonly used for after septoplasty operations. However, they cause pain and patient discomfort (5-8). Recent studies have focused on alternative methods such as suture techniques and tissue adhesives. Glubran-2 is a new synthetic tissue adhesive and hemostatic agent in a ‘ready-to-use‘ applicator that is applied topically and can be used both in laparoscopic and open surgeries (9, 10). It has better properties than previously available cyanoacrylate adhesives regarding elasticity and polymerization temperature. On contact with live tissue in a moist environment, it polymerizes rapidly to create a thin but elastic film of high tensile resistance, which guarantees firm adherence of tissues. Polymerization occurs at a temperature of 45 °C so that there is no thermal damage to underlying tissues (9). Results Figure 1. Submucoperichondrial flap eleva>on. Figure 2. Glubran 2 applica>on between septal car>lage and submucoperichondrial flap Chart 1. Mucosal thickness . Figure 3. Nasal septum excision 0 50 100 150 200 250 Neg. Control Gr. Pos. Control Gr. (3rd week) Pos. Control Gr. (8th week) Study Gr. (3rd week) Study Gr. (3rd week) 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 Neg. Control Gr. Pos. Control Gr. (3rd week) Pos. Control Gr. (8th week) Study Gr. (3rd week) Study Gr. (3rd week) Chart 2. Nasal septal car>lage thickness.

Upload: others

Post on 21-Jan-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Erzincan Military Hospital Department of ...Thirty adult albino New Zealand rabbits were included in the study. Rabbits were randomly divided into negative control (n=6), positive

Poster'Print'Size:'This'poster'template'is'44”'high'by'30”'wide'but'can'be'used'to'print'any'size'poster'with'a'similar'aspect'ra>o.'

Placeholders:'The'various'elements'included'in'this'poster'are'ones'we'oAen'see'in'medical,'research,'and'scien>fic'posters.'Feel'free'to'edit,'move,''add,'and'delete'items,'or'change'the'layout'to'suit'your'needs.'Always'check'with'your'conference'organizer'for'specific'requirements.'

Image'Quality:'You'can'place'digital'photos'or'logo'art'in'your'poster'file'by'selec>ng'the'Insert,(Picture'command,'or'by'using'standard'copy'&'paste.'For'best'results,'all'graphic'elements'should'be'at'least'1500200(pixels(per(inch(in(their(final(printed(size.'For'instance,'a'1600'x'1200'pixel'photo'will'usually'look'fine'up'to'8“S10”'wide'on'your'printed'poster.'

To'preview'the'print'quality'of'images,'select'a'magnifica>on'of'100%'when'previewing'your'poster.'This'will'give'you'a'good'idea'of'what'it'will'look'like'in'print.'If'you'are'laying'out'a'large'poster'and'using'halfSscale'dimensions,'be'sure'to'preview'your'graphics'at'200%'to'see'them'at'their'final'printed'size.'

Please'note'that'graphics'from'websites'(such'as'the'logo'on'your'hospital's'or'university's'home'page)'will'only'be'72dpi'and'not'suitable'for'prin>ng.'

'[This'sidebar'area'does'not'print.]'

Change'Color'Theme:'This'template'is'designed'to'use'the'builtSin'color'themes'in'the'newer'versions'of'PowerPoint.'

To'change'the'color'theme,'select'the'Design'tab,'then'select'the'Colors'dropSdown'list.'

'

'

'

'

'

'

'

'

'

The'default'color'theme'for'this'template'is'“Office”,'so'you'can'always'return'to'that'aAer'trying'some'of'the'alterna>ves.'

Prin>ng'Your'Poster:'Once'your'poster'file'is'ready,'visit'www.genigraphics.com'to'order'a'highSquality,'affordable'poster'print.'Every'order'receives'a'free'design'review'and'we'can'deliver'as'fast'as'next'business'day'within'the'US'and'Canada.''

Genigraphics®'has'been'producing'output'from'PowerPoint®'longer'than'anyone'in'the'industry;'da>ng'back'to'when'we'helped'MicrosoA®'design'the'PowerPoint'soAware.''

'

US'and'Canada:''1S800S790S4001'Email:'[email protected]'

'[This'sidebar'area'does'not'print.]'

Glubran 2: A New Alternative for Nasal Packing Enver'Cesmeci,'MD1;'Onuralp'Kurt,'MD2;'Salim'Dogru,'MD3;'Murat'Salihoglu,'MD3;'Zafer'Kucukodaci,'MD4;'A>la'Gungor,'MD3'

'

1Diyarbakir'Military'Hospital'Department'of'Otorhinolaryngology,'2'Erzincan Military Hospital Department of Otorhinolaryngology, 3GATA Haydarpasa Training Hospital Department of Otorhinolaryngology, , 4GATA Haydarpasa Training Hospital Department of Pathology'

Enver'Cesmeci,'MD'Diyarbakir'Military'Hospital''Email:'[email protected]'Website:S'Phone:905057950464'

Contact(1.Alkan'S,'Dadas'B,'Celik'D,'Coskun'BU,'Yilmaz'F,'Basak'T.'The'efficacy'of'NS2Sbutyl'cyanoacrylate'in'the'fixa>on'of'nasal'septum'to'the'anterior'nasal'spine'in'rabbits:'experimental'study.'European'archives'of'otoSrhinoSlaryngology':'official'journal'of'the'European'Federa>on'of'OtoSRhinoSLaryngological'Socie>es.'2007;264(12):1425S30.'2.Dinis'PB,'Haider'H.'Septoplasty:'longSterm'evalua>on'of'results.'American'journal'of'otolaryngology.'2002;23(2):85S90.'3.Huizing'EH,'Groot'JAMd.'Func>onal'reconstruc>ve'nasal'surgery.'2nd'edi>on.'ed.'Stusgart';'New'York:'Thieme;'2015.'p.'p.'4.Habesoglu'TE,'Kulekci'S,'Habesoglu'M,'Deveci'I,'Deveci'S,'Toros'S,'et'al.'Compara>ve'outcomes'of'using'fibrin'glue'in'septoplasty'and'its'effect'on'mucociliary'ac>vity.'OtolaryngologySShead'and'neck'surgery':'official'journal'of'American'Academy'of'OtolaryngologySHead'and'Neck'Surgery.'2010;142(3):394S9.'5.Genc'E,'Ergin'NT,'Bilezikci'B.'Comparison'of'suture'and'nasal'packing'in'rabbit'noses.'The'Laryngoscope.'2004;114(4):639S45.'6.Boenisch'M,'Nolst'Trenite'GJ.'[Fibrin'glue'for'opera>ve'correc>on'of'septal'devia>ons].'Hno.'2004;52(11):963S7.'7.Lemmens'W,'Lemkens'P.'Septal'suturing'following'nasal'septoplasty,'a'valid'alterna>ve'for'nasal'packing?'Acta'otoSrhinoSlaryngologica'Belgica.'2001;55(3):215S21.'8.Nunez'DA,'Mar>n'FW.'An'evalua>on'of'postSopera>ve'packing'in'nasal'septal'surgery.'Clinical'otolaryngology'and'allied'sciences.'1991;16(6):549S50.'9.Alar'T,'Ceylan'KC,'Duman'E,'Usluer'O,'Basok'O.'Is'Acrylate'CoSmonomer'(GlubranS2)'Useful'in'the'Preven>on'of'Prolonged'Air'Leaks'AAer'Pulmonary'Lobectomy?'The'Indian'journal'of'surgery.'2013;75(5):373S6.'10.'Buric'N.'Use'of'NSbutyl'cyanoacrylate'with'metacryloxisulfolane'(glubran'2)'surgical'glue'for'flapless'closure'of'oroantral'communica>on.'Implant'den>stry.'2013;22(3):238S43.'11.'Erkan'AN,'Cakmak'O,'Kocer'NE,'Yilmaz'I.'Effects'of'fibrin'glue'on'nasal'septal'>ssues.'The'Laryngoscope.'2007;117(3):491S6.'12.'Korkut'AY,'Teker'AM,'Eren'SB,'Gedikli'O,'Askiner'O.'A'randomised'prospec>ve'trial'of'transSseptal'suturing'using'a'novel'device'versus'nasal'packing'for'septoplasty.'Rhinology.'2010;48(2):179S82.''''

References(

Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate histopathological effects of Glubran 2 (n-butyl-2-cyanoacrylate and methacryloxysulpholan co-monomer) (GEM S.r.l Italy) on septal tissues of rabbit. Methods: Thirty adult albino New Zealand rabbits were included in the study. Rabbits were randomly divided into negative control (n=6), positive control (n=12) and study (n=12) groups. In positive control group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and then unilateral nasal packing was inserted into ipsilateral nasal cavity. In the study group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and glubran 2 was applied between the flap and the septal cartilage. Rabbits in the positive control and the study groups were killed 3 weeks and 8 weeks after the flap elevation. Samples from the excised nasal septum underwent routine tissue procedure for histopathological evaluation. Results: Mild mucosal inflammation was observed in both study and positive control groups. Mucosal ulceration was not observed in any of the groups. Mild mucosal thickening was detected in the study group at the end of eighth week. Significant decrease in the thickness of the septal cartilages was observed in both of the groups, but there was no inflammation or degeneration. Conclusion: We detected that Glubran 2 does not lead to a significant histopathological response in rabbit nasal septal tissues and can be used in septoplasty operations performed in humans. Key Words: Nasal septum, septoplasty, nasal packing, rabbit, glubran 2.

Abstract(Mild mucosal inflammation was observed in both study and positive control groups Mild mucosal thickening was detected in the study group at the end of eighth week (chart 1). Mucosal ulceration was not observed in any of the groups. There was no difference between the study and the positive control groups in terms of submucosal fibrosis, loss of goblet cell and loss of cilia. Foreign body reaction, granulation tissue formation, loss of cartilage was not observed in any of the groups. Significant decrease in the thickness of the septal cartilages was observed in both of the groups, but there was no inflammation or degeneration (chart'2). There was no difference between the three groups in terms of perichondrium thickness.

IntroducEon(

Thirty adult albino New Zealand rabbits were included in the study. Rabbits were randomly divided into negative control (n=6), positive control (n=12) and study (n=12) groups. Rabbits in the negative control group were sacrificed after removal of their nasal septum at the beginning of the study. The positive control and the study groups were divided into two subgroups with six rabbits in each group to investigate short- and long-term effects of Glubran 2 on nasal septal tissues of rabbit. In positive control group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and then unilateral nasal packing was inserted into ipsilateral nasal cavity (figure 1). In the study group unilateral mucoperichondrial flap was elevated and Glubran 2 was applied between the flap and the septal cartilage (figure 2). After that septal cartilage lightly compressed with a wide-tipped forceps for 60 seconds. Rabbits in the positive control and the study groups were killed 3 weeks and 8 weeks after the flap elevation. Samples from the excised nasal septum underwent routine tissue procedure for histopathological evaluation (figure 3).

Methods(and(Materials(

Septoplasty is one of the most frequently performed procedures in otorhinolaryngology. Several complications including septal hematoma, infection, abscess formation, septal adhesion, and septal instability can be seen after this operation (11). Nasal packing, septal splints, septal suturing, or tissue adhesives may be used to avoid these complications. However, each has own advantages and disadvantages. Using fibrin Glubran 2 fix the flaps is a new technique that is effective and easy to apply in a shorter operative time, shorter hospital stay, and with better patient satisfaction. Suture technique is one the unpacking method to fix the flaps. However, its use is limited, it is a laborious application in terms of the surgeon, it causes additional traumatized area and prolongs the operation time (7, 12) Tissue adhesives are another unpacking method. Erkan et al (11). reported that fibrin glue cause to intense inflammation, prominent cilia and goblet cell loss, submucosal significant fibrosis, mucosal damage, increase in mucosal thickness and decrease in septal cartilage thickness.

Discussion(

We detected that Glubran 2 does not lead to a significant histopathological response in rabbit nasal septal tissues and can be used in septoplasty operations performed in humans.

Conclusions(

Septoplasty, performed to correct nasal septal deviation, is one the most frequently performed procedures in ear nose throat clinics. The main principles of septal surgery include correction of the anatomical deformities of the septum and restoration of the nasal functions, while protecting the mucosa, cartilage and bone as much as possible (1, 2). For this purpose, an incision is made from the caudal septum initially and then submucoperichondrial and submucoperiosteal flaps are elevated (3). Nasal septal anatomy must be restored after making the necessary corrections in cartilage and bony septum. Submucoperichondrial and submucoperiosteal should be placed back to restore the nasal septal anatomy. Nasal packing with a variety of materials is used to support septal flap apposition, close dead spaces between cartilage and mucoperichondrial flaps and prevent complications such as bleeding, septal hematoma formation, infection, abscess formation, septal adhesion, and displacement of the cartilage or bony grafts (4, 5). Nasal packs are commonly used for after septoplasty operations. However, they cause pain and patient discomfort (5-8). Recent studies have focused on alternative methods such as suture techniques and tissue adhesives. Glubran-2 is a new synthetic tissue adhesive and hemostatic agent in a ‘ready-to-use‘ applicator that is applied topically and can be used both in laparoscopic and open surgeries (9, 10). It has better properties than previously available cyanoacrylate adhesives regarding elasticity and polymerization temperature. On contact with live tissue in a moist environment, it polymerizes rapidly to create a thin but elastic film of high tensile resistance, which guarantees firm adherence of tissues. Polymerization occurs at a temperature of 45 °C so that there is no thermal damage to underlying tissues (9).

Results(

Figure(1.'Submucoperichondrial''flap'eleva>on.'

Figure(2.'Glubran'2'applica>on''between'septal'car>lage'and''submucoperichondrial'flap'

Chart(1.'Mucosal'thickness .'

Figure(3.'Nasal'septum'excision'

0

50

100

150

200

250

Neg. Control Gr. Pos. Control Gr. (3rd week)

Pos. Control Gr. (8th week)

Study Gr. (3rd week)

Study Gr. (3rd week)

0'

100'

200'

300'

400'

500'

600'

Neg.'Control'Gr.' Pos.'Control'Gr.''(3rd'week)'

Pos.'Control'Gr.''(8th'week)'

Study'Gr.'(3rd'week)'

Study'Gr.'(3rd'week)'

Chart(2.'Nasal'septal'car>lage'thickness.'