059-063 council - (nick roberts) _ planning _ attachment a - marked-up version - rebuttal

8/20/2019 059-063 Council - (Nick Roberts) _ Planning _ Attachment a - Marked-up Version - REBUTTAL

1/113

1

!""!#$%&'" !

)!*) +,-./,01.23 450,- 67565-,/ 8279 :6-

"# $%%&'&()* +,- .)%-,/&)-% +)% %-/-'-% '-0' &* &) *',&1-'2,(.32

4# 5/+61 '-0' 62+)3-* ,-6(,% +7-)%7-)'* 8,(8(*-% &) 8,&7+,9 -:&%-)6- ;-&'2-, 8,- (, 8(*'

7-%&+'&(),--) '-0' 62+)3-* ,-6(,% +7-)%7-)'* 8,(8(*-% +)% +3,--% &) 7-%&+'&() ;'2(*- +7-)%7-)'*

)(' +3,--% '( *'+9 ?/+61


2/113

2

?(+,%&)3 2(.*-* +)% :&*&'(, +66(77(%+'&()< '2+' 8,(:&%- 8-,7+)-)' +)% '-78(,+,9

+66(77(%+'&() (8'&()* C(, '2(*- B&'2 8+,'&6./+, 2(.*&)3 )--%* 7+9 +/*( -*'+?/&*2 B&'2&) ,-*&%-)'&+/

I()-*# H2- I()-* +/*( 8,(:&%- C(, + ,+)3- +)% 62(&6- (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-,# H2- 8/+))-% ?.&/'

62+,+6'-, (C + I()- &* %-C&)-% ?9 '2- 3-)-,+/ +)% I()- (?T-6'&:-* +)% 8(/&6&-* +)% &)6(,8(,+'-* '2-

?.&/' +)% /+)%*6+8- -/-7-)'* B&'2&) +) +,-+# U) *(7- I()-* 'H2- I()-* 8,(:&%- C(, 6():-,*&() (C +)

-0&*'&)3 *&)3/- %B-//&)3 &)'( 'B( %B-//&)3* &* +//(B-% '( 6+'-, C(, %&CC-,-)' C+7&/9 )--%* (, '(

3-)-,+'- +%%&'&()+/ C+7&/9 &)6(7-S B&'2(.' *.?%&:&%&)3 '2- 8,(8-,'9 +)% B2&/- ,-'+&)&)3 '2-

+88-+,+)6- (C + *&)3/- ?.&/%&)3#

$* '2- %-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)' &)6,-+*-*S '2- 3,-+'-, '2- ,-E.&,-7-)' C(, E.+/&'9 %-*&3)# H( +%%,-**

'2&*S C(., '2,-- (, 7(,- %B-//&)3* () + *&'- &) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+)S +)% R&0-% Q(.*&)3

J,?+) I()-*S +)% 7(,- '2+) ()- %B-//&)3 &) +)% '2- H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)% $8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3* I()-

+)% *8-6&+/&*' ,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* *.62 +* ,-'&,-7-)' :&//+3-* ,-E.&,-* + ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)'# H2-

,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' 8,(6-** B&// -)*.,- '2+' '2- 8,(8(*+/ 3&:-* -CC-6' '( '2- E.+/&'9 ?.&/' -):&,()7-)'

8,(:&*&()* (C '2- J)&'+,9 K/+) +)% '2+' &' 6()',&?.'-* '( '2- $.61/+)% K/+) 8,&(,&'9 (C + E.+/&'9 .,?+)

-):&,()7-)'#

V()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* B&'2&) ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+* 6+) 8,(:&%- (88(,'.)&'&-* C(, 6(77.)&'&-* '(

8,(:&%- C(, '2-&, 2-+/'2S *+C-'9S *(6&+/S -6()(7&6 +)% 6./'.,+/ B-//W?-&)3# U' &* +88,(8,&+'- C(, *(6&+/

C+6&/&'&-* ;-#3# 7-%&6+/ 6-)',-*S 8/+6-* (C B(,*2&8S 6+,- 6-)',-*S *62((/*S 6(77.)&'9 6+//* +)% 6./'.,+/

C+6&/&'&-*< '( ?- /(6+'-% *( '2-9 +,- +66-**&?/- '( /(6+/ 6(77.)&'&-*S 8,(:&%-% '2-9 ,-*8-6' '2-

+7-)&'9 (C '2- )-&32?(.,2((% +)% +,- 6(78+'&?/- B&'2 '2- *6+/- +)% &)'-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)'

+)'&6&8+'-% &) '2- I()-#

H2- $XR 8,(:&%-* *.88/-7-)'+,9S )()W*'+'.'(,9 3.&%+)6- () 8,-8+,&)3 8,(8(*+/* C(, )-B 2(.*&)3

%-:-/(87-)'* ?9 (.'/&)&)3 (8'&()* '( +62&-:- 2&32 *'+)%+,%* (C %-*&3) &) :+,&(.* 2(.*&)3 '98-*#

=?,@1.A,- 20/ 653.@.,- D57 1E, 7,-./,01.23 450,-

F>?,@1.A,-

"# $.61/+)%Y* ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+* +,- +'',+6'&:-S 2-+/'29 +)% *+C- -):&,()7-)'* B&'2 C.)6'&()+/ +)%

E.+/&'9 %-:-/(87-)' '2+' 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'-S )-&32?(.,2((% +)% '2- B&%-, 6()'-0' +)%

-)2+)6-* '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6- +)% )-&32?(.,2((% +)% 6()',&?.'-* '( *+C-'9 +)% + 8(*&'&:-

*-)*- (C 8/+6- B2&62 +,- &) 1--8&)3 B&'2 (, 6(78/-7-)' '2- 8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- 8/+6-#

4# $) &)6,-+*- &) 2(.*&)3 6+8+6&'9 +)% %&:-,*- ,+)3- (C 2(.*&)3 8,(:&%-* 62(&6- C(, 2(.*-2(/%* +)%

6(77.)&'&-* '( B2&62 7--'* '2-&, :+,&-% )--%* +)% /&C-*'9/-* (C $.61/+)%Y* %&:-,*- +)% 3,(B&)3

8(8./+'&()#

4+# Z)+?/- 2&32-, ,-*&%-)'&+/ %-)*&'&-* &) +,-+* 6/(*- '( 6-)',-* +)% '2- ,+8&% +)% C,-E.-)' *-,:&6-

)-'B(,1 +)% /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-*S B2&/-L

+# -)*.,&)3 %-:-/(87-)' &* +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 -0&*'&)3 (, 8/+))-% &)C,+*',.6'.,-[ +)%

?# 7+)+3&)3 8('-)'&+/ +%:-,*- +7-)&'9 -CC-6'* ,-*./'&)3 C,(7 .,?+) &)'-)*&C&6+'&() &) +,-+*

(C -0&*'&)3 &)6(78+'&?/- /+)% .*-* -#3# 7+)+3&)3 ,-:-,*- *-)*&'&:&'9 -CC-6'* () *&3)&C&6+)'

&)C,+*',.6'.,- +)% &)%.*',&+/ +6'&:&'&-*#

=# V()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* '2+' /(6+'- &) ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+* 6()',&?.'- '( +)% *.88(,' ,-*8-6' '2-

+7-)&'9 (C '2- )-&32?(.,2((%S +,- 6(78+'&?/- B&'2 '2- *6+/- +)% &)'-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)'

+)'&6&8+'-% ?9 '2- I()- B&'2 +)% 8,(:&%- (88(,'.)&'&-* C(, *(6&+/S -6()(7&6 +)% 6./'.,+/ B-//W?-&)3#

)53.@.,-

"# G-E.&,- R+)+3- '2- ?.&/' C(,7 +)% %-*&3) (C %-:-/(87-)'* '( -)*.,- &' 6()',&?.'- 8(*&'&:-/9 '(L

Catherine Reaburn 5/10/2015 8:21 AM

Comment [1]: Ryman, Aria Bay and Summerset primary evidence

Rachel Morgan 3/8/2015 11:44 AM

Comment [2]: Ryman (6106-20), RVA (6103-20), Aria Bay (4431-17) and Summerset (6650-40)

Rereata Hardman-Mi!

, 7/9/2015 9:14 AM

Comment [3]: Auckland KindergartenAssociation 6980-8


Comment [4]: 839-10032 Housing New Zealand

Rereata Hardman-Mi!

, 7/9/2015 9:30 AMComment [5]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-2

Catherine Reaburn 5/10/2015 1:20 PM

Comment [6]: Housing New ZealandCorporation, primary evidence of Amelia Lindsay

and Matt Lindenberg


Comment [7]: Christine Coste for AUOG, primary evidence

Rereata Hardman-Mi!, 7/9/2015 7:53 PM

Comment [8]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-18; New Zealand Health

Association Limited trading as Sanitarium Health

and Wellbeing Company 4359-9; Broadway Park

Residents Society Incorporated 3747-8


Comment [9]: 839-10034 Housing New ZealandCorporation


3/113

3

+# 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( &'* *&'- +)% 6()'-0'[

?# &* &) 1--8&)3 B&'2 (, 6(78/-7-)'* '2- 8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- I()-[ '2-

6# 6()',&?.'-* 8(*&'&:-/9 '( '2- :&*.+/ E.+/&'9 +)% *+C-'9 (C *&'-*S *',--'*S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-* +)%

)-&32?(.,2((%*#

"+# K,(:&%- 2&32 E.+/&'9 *&'-S /+)%*6+8&)3S ?.&/%&)3 +)% %B-//&)3 %-*&3) C(, 7./'&8/- .)&' ,-*&%-)'&+/

%-:-/(87-)' &) +,-+* (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ &)'-)*&C&6+'&()#

4# G-6(3)&*- '2+' '2- %-)*&'9 (C $.61/+)%Y* ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+* B&// &)6,-+*-S '( :+,9&)3 %-3,--*S (:-,'&7- +)% +88/9 6()',(/* '( 7+)+3- '2- -CC-6'* (C '2+' 62+)3- () ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9#

=# K,(:&%- + ,+)3- (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-* '2+' -)+?/- %&CC-,-)' 2(.*&)3 C(,7 * +)% %-)*&'&-*S + :+,&-'9 (C

2(.*&)3 (88(,'.)&'&-* +)% %&CC-,-)' 2(.*&)3 '98-* '2+' +,- +88,(8,&+'- C(, '2- -0&*'&)3 +)% 8/+))-%

&)C,+*',.6'.,-S )+'.,+/ -):&,()7-)' +)% '2- -0&*'&)3 +)% 8/+))-% ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2-

+,-+#

@# G-E.&,- + 8-,6-)'+3- (C 7-%&.7 '( /+,3- *6+/- ,-*&%-)'&+/ %-:-/(87-)' '( 8,(:&%- -E.+/ 829*&6+/

+66-** +)% .*- C(, 8-(8/- (C +// +3-* +)% +?&/&'&-*#

@# Z)6(.,+3- .)&:-,*+/ +66-** C(, 7./'&8/- .)&' ,-*&%-)'&+/ %-:-/(87-)'#

D# Z)+?/- +) -0&*'&)3 %B-//&)3 '( ?- 6():-,'-% &)'( 'B(S &) *8-6&C&6 I()-*S &) + 7+))-, '2+' 8,(:&%-*

2&32 E.+/&'9 &)'-,)+/ +)% ()W*&'- +7-)&'9#

\# Z)+?/- )()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* '2+' 8,(:&%- ?-)-C&'* '( /(6+/ 6(77.)&'&-* +)% B2&62 2+:-7&)&7+/ +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () +7-)&'&-* (C '2- ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+L

+# *.88(,' '2- *(6&+/ +)% -6()(7&6 B-//W?-&)3 (C '2- 6(77.)&'9

?# ,-*8-6' '2- 8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- )-&32?(.,2((% +,- &) 1--8&)3 B&'2 (, 6(78/-7-)' '2-

8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, +)% +,- 6(78+'&?/- B&'2 '2- *6+/- +)% &)'-)*&'9 C(,7 (C %-:-/(87-)'

+)'&6&8+'-% B&'2&) '2- I()-

6# +:(&%S ,-7-%9 (, 7&'&3+'- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9

%# B&// )(' %-',+6' C,(7 '2- :&'+/&'9 (C '2- O&'9 O-)',-S R-',(8(/&'+) +)% H(B) O-)',- I()-*#

]#G-E.&,-S B2-,- +88,(8,&+'-S ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)'* C(, *.?%&:&*&() +)% 2(.*&)3 %-:-/(87-)' C(,

+%%&'&()+/ ,-*&%-)'&+/ /+)% 6+8+6&'9S '( ?- 3&:-) -CC-6' '( B&'2&) *8-6&C&6 '&7-C,+7-*S &)6/.%&)3

'2,(.32 *'+3&)3 8,(:&*&()* +)% /+8*- 8-,&(%*#

^#G-E.&,- *&3)&C&6+)' 829*&6+/ B(,1* '( ?- .)%-,'+1-) ?-C(,- 3,+)'&)3 +)9 -0'-)*&() '( '2- /+8*-

%+'- C(, +)9 6()*-)' ,-/+'&)3 '( + /+,3-W*6+/- ,-*&%-)'&+/ *.?%&:&*&() (, /+,3-W*6+/- ,-*&%-)'&+/%-:-/(87-)'#

D# R+)+3- '2- 6.7./+'&:- -CC-6'* (C %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/ &)C,&)3-7-)'*S 8+,'&6./+,/9 &) ,-/+'&() '(

-CC-6'* () '2- )-&32?(.,2((%Y* 8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-,#

#

=


4/113

4

M'2-,- +,- 7+9 ?- 829*&6+/ /&7&'+'&()* *.62 +* '(8(3,+829S 3,(.)% 6()%&'&()*S &)*'+?&/&'9 (, )+'.,+/

2+I+,%*

MB2-,- 7(,- &)'-)*&:- %-:-/(87-)' 7+9 6+.*- (, -0+6-,?+'- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () '2- -):&,()7-)'#

H( 7+)+3- -0&*'&)3 (, 8('-)'&+/ +%:-,*- -CC-6'*S /+,3-, '2+) *'+)%+,% *&'- *&I-* +,- ,-E.&,-%

+)% ?.&/%&)3 6(:-,+3- +)% &78-,:&(.* *.,C+6- +,-+* +,- ,-*',&6'-%#

F>?,@1.A,-

"# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32' +)% ?./1 '2+' 7+&)'+&)* +)% 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'- +)%7+&)'+&)* +)% 6(78/-7-)'* '2- +,-+Y* *8+6&(.* /+)%*6+8- 62+,+6'-,S /+)%*6+8- E.+/&'&-* +)% )+'.,+/

C-+'.,-*#

4# X-:-/(87-)' 7+&)'+&)* '2- +7-)&'9 (C +%T(&)&)3 *&'-*#

=# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + %-)*&'9 '2+' &* +88,(8,&+'- C(, '2- 829*&6+/ +)% -):&,()7-)'+/ +'',&?.'-* (C

'2- *&'- +)% +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

)53.@.,-

"# N&7&' %-:-/(87-)' () + *&'- '( + *&)3/- %B-//&)3 +)% +66-**(,9 ?.&/%&)3* +)% G-E.&,- /+,3-

7&)&7.7 *&'- *&I-* +)% /&7&' '2- *6+/- +)% &)'-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)' '( -)*.,- '2+' '2- *&'- *&I- B&//L

+# *&'-* +,- ?- +?/- '( +66(77(%+'- ()W*&'- B+*'-B+'-, ',-+'7-)' +)% %&*8(*+/

'2- &)C,+*',.6'.,- )-6-**+,9 '( *.88(,' '2- %B-//&)3

?# %-:-/(87-)' B&// )(' %-',+6' C,(7 +)9 2&32 E.+/&'9 6(78/-7-)' +)9 /+)%*6+8-* E.+/&'&-* (,

)+'.,+/ C-+'.,-*6# %-:-/(87-)' B&// )(' -0+6-,?+'- +)9 829*&6+/ /&7&'+'&()* *.62 +* /+)% &)*'+?&/&'9#

4# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + 2-&32' +)% ?./1 +)% 2+:- *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61* +)% (8-) *8+6- '(

7+&)'+&) +)% 6(78/-7-)' '2- *8+6&(.* /+)%*6+8- 62+,+6'-, (C '2- +,-+#

=# G-E.&,- '2- 2-&32'S ?./1 +)% /(6+'&() (C %-:-/(87-)' '( 7+&)'+&) + ,-+*()+?/- /-:-/ (C *.)/&32'

+66-** +)% 8,&:+69 +)% '( 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

=?,@1.A,-

"# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32' +)% ?./1 '2+' 7+&)'+&)* +)% 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'- +)%

7+&)'+&)* +)% 6(78/-7-)'* '2- +,-+Y* ,.,+/ +)% 6(+*'+/ ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9

()-W'B( *'(,-9 ?.&/%&)3* B&'2&) + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.* *-''&)3S +)% /+)%*6+8- E.+/&'&-* +)% )+'.,+/

C-+'.,-*#

4# X-:-/(87-)' 8,(:&%-* 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9 /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'* C(, ,-*&%-)'* +)%

7+&)'+&)* '2- + ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 (C C(, +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +)% '2- *',--'#


Comment [22]: Sir/Madam Douglas FosterFamily Trust 3762-1






Comment [25]: Mahi Properties Limited (5476-12) and Rhondda F Richardson (6949-13)




Comment [27]: Auckland Council (5716-313)


Comment [28]: 5476-12 Mahi PropertiesLimited




5/113

5

=# X-:-/(87-)' &) .)*-,:&6-% ,.,+/ +)% 6(+*'+/ *-''/-7-)'* &* (C + %-)*&'9 '2+' &* +88,(8,&+'- C(, '2-

'2- 829*&6+/ +)% -):&,()7-)'+/ +'',&?.'-* (C '2- *&'- +)% +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

)53.@.,-

"# Z)+?/- *.?%&:&*&() +)% %-:-/(87-)' '2+' 8,(:&%-* C(, + *&)3/- %B-//&)3 +)% +66-**(,9 ?.&/%&)3*

+)% G-E.&,- /+,3- 7&)&7.7 *&'- *&I-* +)% /&7&' '2- *6+/- +)% &)'-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)' '( -)*.,- '2+'

'2- *&'- *&I- B&//L

+# *&'-* +,- ?- +?/- '( +66(77(%+'- ()W*&'- B+*'-B+'-, ',-+'7-)' +)% %&*8(*+/

'2- &)C,+*',.6'.,- )-6-**+,9 '( *.88(,' '2- %B-//&)3?# %-:-/(87-)' B&// 6(78/-7-)' )(' %-',+6' C,(7 +)9 2&32WE.+/&'9 /+)%*6+8-* E.+/&'&-* (, )+'.,+/

C-+'.,-*

6# %-:-/(87-)' B&// )(' -0+6-,?+'- +)9 829*&6+/ /&7&'+'&()* *.62 +* /+)% &)*'+?&/&'9#

4# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + '2- 2-&32' +)% ?./1 +)% /(6+'&() (C %-:-/(87-)' '( '2+'

7+&)'+&)* + ,-+*()+?/- /-:-/ (C *.)/&32' +66-** +)% 8,&:+69 +)% '( 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'*

'( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

=# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + 2-&32' +)% ?./1 +)% 2+:- *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61* +)% (8-) *8+6- *( +*

'( 7+&)'+&) +)% 6(78/-7-)' '2- ,.,+/ +)% 6(+*'+/ ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- +,-+#

@# G-E.&,- %B-//&)3* '( ?- %-*&3)-% '( 2+:- .*-+?/- +)% +66-**&?/- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- (C + *&I-

6()*&*'-)' B&'2 '2- *8+6&(.* E.+/&'&-* (C '2- I()-#

D# R+)+3- '2- C(,7 (C %-:-/(87-)' '( -)+?/- (88(,'.)&'&-* C(, 8+**&:- *.,:-&//+)6- (C '2- *',--'#

=?,@1.A,-

"# X-:-/(87-)' 7+&)'+&)* +)% 6(78/-7-)'* +,-+* B&'2 &%-)'&C&-% 2&*'(,&6 62+,+6'-, (,

-):&,()7-)'+/ :+/.-*#

4# >,(B'2 &* /&7&'-% &) +,-+* B&'2L

Rereata Hardman-!, 7/9/2015 10:07 AM

Comment [30]: The Waitakere RangesProtection Society Incorporated 2959-71

Rereata Hardman-!

, 7/9/2015 10:14 AM

Comment [31]: Mahi Properties Limited 5476-13 Rhondda F Richardson 6949-14


Comment [32]: Rhondda F Richardson 6949-6


Comment [33]: Graeme N and Lynette L Reed1614-49

Rachel Morgan 8/9/2015 12:41 PM

Comment [34]: No submissions request thisspecific change but there is general scope to make

this amendment based on the following submissions:

Habitat for Humanity Greater Auckland Limited

3600-10; Patrick Fontein 6282-16; Broadway Park



Comment [35]: Save Our City 8326-1


6/113

6

+# *&3)&C&6+)' -):&,()7-)'+/ (, &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*

?# 8((, +66-**&?&/&'9 '( '2- O&'9 O-)',-S R-',(8(/&'+)S H(B) +)% N(6+/ O-)',-*S '2- -0&*'&)3 (,

8/+))-% 8.?/&6 ',+)*8(,' )-'B(,1 (, /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-*#

" =# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32'S ?./1 +)% C(,7 '2+' 7+&)'+&)* +)% 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '(

'2- *&'-S +)% 6(78/-7-)'* '2- )-&32?(.,2((%Y* /(B %-)*&'9 8/+))-% *.?.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/'

62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 ()-W'B( *'(,-9* ?.&/%&)3* B&'2&) + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.* *-''&)3S (, '2-

&%-)'&C&-% 2&*'(,&6 62+,+6'-,#

4 @# X-:-/(87-)' 8,(:&%-* 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'* +7-)&'9 C(, ,-*&%-)'* +)%

7+&)'+&)* '2- + ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 (C C(, +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +)% '2- *',--'#

)53.@.,-

"# G-E.&,- 7&)&7.7 *&'- *&I-* '2+' /&7&' '2- &)'-)*&'9 (C %-:-/(87-)' &) +,-+* B&'2L

+# *&3)&C&6+)' -):&,()7-)'+/ 6()*',+&)'*S (,

?# &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'* '2+' +,- .)/&1-/9 '( ?- +%%,-**-% &) '2- C(,-*--+?/- C.'.,- (, B2&62

6+))(' ?- +%%,-**-% +' + *&'-W*8-6&C&6 /-:-/S (,

?# 6# 8((, +66-**&?&/&'9 '(L

'2- O&'9 O-)',-S R-',(8(/&'+)S H(B) (, N(6+/ O-)',-*S (,

& '2- -0&*'&)3 (, 8/+))-% 8.?/&6 ',+)*8(,' )-'B(,1S (,

&& /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-* &)6/.%&)3 -0&*'&)3 (, 8,(8(*-% 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*S 6(77.)&'9 C+6&/&'&-*S

-%.6+'&() C+6&/&'&-*S '-,'&+,9 -%.6+'&() C+6&/&'&-*S +)% 2-+/'26+,- C+6&/&'&-*#

"# R+)+3- '2- 2-&32' ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- (C %-:-/(87-)' +)% ,-E.&,- *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61*S

/+)%*6+8-% +,-+* +)% (8-) *8+6- '( 7+&)'+&) '2- /(B %-)*&'9 *.?.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-, (C ()-

'( 'B( *'(,-9S %-'+62-% %B-//&)3* B&'2&) + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.* *-''&)3#

4# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '(L

+# ?- (C + 2-&32'S ?./1 +)% C(,7 '2+' 7+&)'+&)* +)% 6(78/-7-)'* +,-+* B&'2 &%-)'&C&-% 2&*'(,&6

62+,+6'-, (, -):&,()7-)'+/ :+/.-*S (,

?# ?- (C + 2-&32' +)% ?./1 +)% 2+:- *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61*S /+)%*6+8-% +,-+* '( +62&-:- '2- 8/+))-%

*.?.,?+) ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 ()- '( 'B( *'(,-9 %B-//&)3* B&'2&) + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.*

*-''&)3#

4 =# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + G-E.&,- '2- 2-&32'S +)% ?./1 +)% /(6+'&() (C %-:-/(87-)' '(

'2+' 7+&)'+&)* + ,-+*()+?/- /-:-/ (C *.)/&32' +66-** +)% 8,&:+69 +)% '( 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6--CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

= @# G-E.&,- %B-//&)3* '( ?- %-*&3)-% '( 2+:- .*-+?/- +)% +66-**&?/- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- (C + *&I-

6()*&*'-)' B&'2 '2- *8+6&(.* E.+/&'&-* (C '2- I()-#

@ D# G-E.&,- C-)6-* '( ?- *.CC&6&-)'/9 /(B '( +//(B R+)+3- '2- C(,7 (C %-:-/(87-)' '( -)+?/-

(88(,'.)&'&-* C(, 8+**&:- *.,:-&//+)6- (C '2- *',--'#

=:7>20 450,

J50, /,[email protected]

H2&* I()- &* '2- 7(*' B&%-*8,-+% ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()- &) $.61/+)% 6(:-,&)3 *(7- 3,--)C&-/%* +)% 7+)9

-*'+?/&*2-% *.?.,?*# Z0&*'&)3 %-:-/(87-)' &) '2- I()- &* 62+,+6'-,&*-% ?9 ()- (, 'B( *'(,-9S 7+&)/9

*'+)%W+/()- ?.&/%&)3* *-' ?+61 C,(7 *&'- ?(.)%+,&-* B&'2 /+)%*6+8-% 3+,%-)*#


Comment [36]: Ian Craig for FletcherResidential, primary evidence



amendments based on the following submissions:Habitat for Humanity Greater Auckland Limited





amendments based on the following submissions:



Residents Society Incorporated 3747-8; Stephen

Davis 4823-19; Save Our City 8326-1




Comment [40]: David Hermans for the Ministryof Business, Employment and Innovation – primary

evidence

Catherine Reaburn 5/10/2015 2:05 PMComment [41]: David Hermans for the Ministryof Business, Employment and Innovation – primary

evidence



Rereata Hardman-!, 8/9/2015 12:58 PM


amendments based on the following submissions:






amendments based on the following submissions:Habitat for Humanity Greater Auckland Limited


Residents Society Incorporated 3747-8; Stephen

Davis 4823-19; Save Our City 8326-1




Comment [46]: Stephen Davis 4823-33


Comment [47]: Ruven Duinkerke 4713-1 and4713-2


7/113

7

U'* %-)*&'9 6()',(/* +//(B + 7(%-,+'- /-:-/ (C H2- I()- -)+?/-* &)'-)*&C&6+'&()S B2&/- ,-'+&)&)3 +

,-/+'&:-/9 *8+6&(.* E.+/&'9 6()*&*'-)' B&'2 + *.?.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-,S 6(78+,-% '( B&'2

'2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) +)% H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)% $8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3* I()-*# X-:-/(87-)' B&'2&)

'2- I()- B&// 3-)-,+//9 ?- 'B( *'(,-9 %-'+62-% +)% +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 &) + :+,&-'9 (C '98-* +)% *&I-*

'( 8,(:&%- 2(.*&)3 62(&6-#

H2- I()- -)6(.,+3-* )-B 2(.*&)3 '98-*S &)6/.%&)3 +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 () *7+//-, *&'-* C+6&)3 '2-

*',--'# H( C+6&/&'+'- '2- -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2-*- *&'-* +)% 8,(7('- E.+/&'9 %-*&3) (.'6(7-*S B2-)

+**-**-% '2,(.32 '2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' 8,(6-**S %B-//&)3* 7+9 2+:- ?.&/%&)3 ?./1 6/(*-,'( *&'- ?(.)%+,&-*S 8,(:&%-% '2+' *2+%&)3 +)% %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* () +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +,- 7&)&7&*-%#

H2,(.32 '2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' 8,(6-**S C(., (, 7(,- %B-//&)3* +' + 2&32-, %-)*&'9 7+9 ?- ?.&/' ()

/+,3- *&'-* B&'2 B&%- ,(+% C,()'+3-*# H2&* &* ?-6+.*- /+,3-, *&'-* +,- 6+8+?/- (C +66(77(%+'&)3 +

B&%-, ,+)3- (C 2(.*&)3 '98-*S &)'-3,+'&)3 %-:-/(87-)' &)'( '2- )-&32?(.,2((% +)% +62&-:&)3 2&32

E.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9#

H2- I()- +88/&-* %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/* '( +// ?.&/%&)3*S /&7&'* %-)*&'9 () *7+// *&'-* +)% ,-E.&,-*

,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' C(, '2,-- (, 7(,- %B-//&)3* +)% C(, ('2-, *8-6&C&-% ?.&/%&)3* &) (,%-, '(L

• +62&-:- '2- 8/+))-% *.?.,?+) ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- I()-[ +)%

• 7+)+3- '2- -CC-6'* (C %-:-/(87-)' () )-&32?(.,&)3 *&'-*S &)6/.%&)3 :&*.+/ +7-)&'9S 8,&:+69

+)% +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32'[ +)%

• +62&-:- +'',+6'&:- +)% *+C- *',--'* +)% 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*[ +)%

•

+62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 ()W*&'- /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'*#H2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' ,-E.&,-7-)'* -)+?/- '2- %-*&3) +)% /+9(.' (C '2- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- +**-**-%

+)% ,-6(3)&*- '2+' '2- )--% '( +62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 %-*&3) &* &)6,-+*&)3/9 &78(,'+)' +* '2- *6+/- (C

%-:-/(87-)' &)6,-+*-*#

F>?,@1.A,-

"# Q(.*&)3 6+8+6&'9 +)% 62(&6- B&'2&) )-&32?(.,2((%* &* &)6,-+*-%#

4# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- '2+' -)3+3-* B&'2 +)% +%%,-**-* '2-

*',--'S 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'- +)% &'* 6()'-0' +)% 6(78/-7-)'* '2- )-&32?(.,2((%_*

8/+))-% *.?.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 ()-W'B( *'(,-9 ?.&/%&)3*S &) + :+,&-'9

(C C(,7* +)% + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.* *-''&)3S -)3+3&)3 B&'2 +)% +%%,-**&)3 '2- *',--'#

=# X-:-/(87-)' 8,(:&%-* 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'* +7-)&'9 C(, ,-*&%-)'* +)% +62&-:-*

+ ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 C(, +%T(&)&)3 *&'-*#

@# X-:-/(87-)' &* +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 )-'B(,1 .'&/&'&-* &)C,+*',.6'.,- +)% &* (C + %-)*&'9 '2+' &*+88,(8,&+'- C(, '2- 829*&6+/ +'',&?.'-* (C '2- *&'- +)% +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

)53.@.,-

"# Z)+?/- + :+,&-'9 (C %-'+62-% +)% +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 '98-* +)% *8-6&+/&*' ,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* *.62

+* ,-'&,-7-)' :&//+3-*#

4# R+)+3- '2- 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- (C %-:-/(87-)' +)% ,-E.&,- *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61*

+)% /+)%*6+8-% +,-+* '( 7+&)'+&) + $62&-:- '2- 8/+))-% *.?.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C

8,-%(7&)+)'/9 3-)-,+//9 'B( *'(,-9* ?.&/%&)3*S &) + :+,&-'9 (C C(,7* +)% + 3-)-,+//9 *8+6&(.* *-''&)3

?9L

+


8/113

8

=# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + G-E.&,- '2- 2-&32'S +)% ?./1 +)% C(,7 /(6+'&() (C %-:-/(87-)' '(

'2+' 7+&)'+&) +//(B* &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,* '( 2+:- + ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C *.)/&32' +66-** +)%

8,&:+69 +)% '( 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ +:(&% -06-**&:- %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

@# Z)+?/- +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 () *7+//-, *&'-* B2-,- '2- %-:-/(87-)' C+6-* '2- *',--' +)% &)'-3,+'-*

B-// &)'( '2- )-&32?(.,2((%#

D @# G-E.&,- %B-//&)3* '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(L

+# 2+:- .*+?/- +)% +66-**&?/- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6-

?# 8,(:&%- 8,&:+69 +)% (.'/((16# ?- (C + *&I-S 2+:- +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32' +)% 8,(:&%- '2- +7-)&'&-* )-6-**+,9 '( 7--' '2-

%+9W'(W%+9 )--%* (C ,-*&%-)'*#

\ D# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(S B&'2 + 8+,'&6./+, -782+*&* () '2(*- 8+,'* :&*&?/- C,(7

'2- *',--' '(L

+# 6,-+'- +'',+6'&:- C,()'+3-* +)% 8,(:&%- :&*.+/ &)'-,-*' '( '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-* +)%

6(77() +,-+* B&'2&) '2- *&'-[ +)%

?# C+6- '2- *',--' +)% 7+0&7&*- 8,(:&%- 8+**&:- *.,:-&//+)6- (C &' (C '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*

+)% 6(77() +,-+* B&'2&) '2- *&'-#

6# 7&)&7&*- '2- %(7&)+)6- (C 3+,+3- %((,* :&*&?/- C,(7 '2- *',--'#

]# N&7&' '2- %-)*&'9 +)% *6+/- (C %-:-/(87-)' '( '+1- +66(.)' (C ()- (, 7(,- (C '2- C(//(B&)3

C+6'(,*L

+# +62&-:&)3 + ?+/+)6- ?-'B--) 7+1&)3 '2- 7(*' -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2- *&'- +)% 8,(:&%&)3 2&32WE.+/&'9()W*&'- +7-)&'9

?# '2- 8,(8(,'&()* (, '(8(3,+829 (C '2- *&'- (, '2- B&%'2 (C &'* ,(+% C,()'+3- 7-+) '2+' &' &* )('

8(**&?/- '( 7+0&7&*- %-:-/(87-)' B&'2(.' 3-)-,+'&)3 .),-+*()+?/- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () '2- +7-)&'9

(C +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +)% '2- *.,,(.)%&)3 +,-+

6# +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

^ \# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( 2+:- +:+&/+?/- 6())-6'&()* ?- +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 2+:&)3 +:+&/+?/-

6())-6'&()* '( B+'-, *.88/9 +)% B+*'-B+'-, )-'B(,1*#

]# Z)+?/- 7(,- -CC&6&-)' .*- (C &%-)'&C&-% ,-'&,-7-)' :&//+3- *&'-* '2+' -0&*'-% +* +' =` P-8'-7?-,

4`"=S '2,(.32 '2- 8,(:&*&() (C 3,-+'-, ?.&/%&)3 2-&32' +* *8-6&C&-% &) '2- $%%&'&()+/ Q-&32' O()',(/#

=

20 450,

J50, /,[email protected]

H2&* I()- &* 3-)-,+//9 /(6+'-% ?-'B--) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) +)% '2- H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)%

$8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3* I()-*# U' 8,(:&%-* + ',+)*&'&() &) %-)*&'9 ?-'B--) '2-*- 'B( I()-* +)% +//(B*

'2,-- *'(,-9 %B-//&)3* &) /(6+'&()* 6/(*- '( 6-)',-* (, '2- ,+8&% +)% C,-E.-)' *-,:&6- )-'B(,1 (,

B2-,- /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-* *.88(,' &)'-)*&C&6+'&()#

a:-, '&7-S '2- +88-+,+)6- (C )-&32?(.,2((%* B&'2&) '2&* I()- B&// 62+)3- '( +) .,?+) ?.&/'

62+,+6'-,S B&'2 %-:-/(87-)' '98&6+//9 .8 '( '2,-- *'(,-9* H2- I()- 8,(:&%-* C(, 2(.*&)3 &) + :+,&-'9

(C *&I-* +)% C(,7*S &)6/.%&)3 %-'+62-% %B-//&)3*S '-,,+6- 2(.*&)3 +)% /(BW,&*- +8+,'7-)'*#S H2&*

*.88(,'* '2+' B&// &)6,-+*-&)3 '2- *.88/9 6+8+6&'9 +)% 62(&6- (C 2(.*&)3S +)% 6,-+'-&)3 %&:-,*&'9-

B&'2&) )-&32?(.,2((%* +)% 8,(:&%- 2(.*&)3 62(&6-#

H2- I()- -)6(.,+3-* )-B 2(.*&)3 '98-*S &)6/.%&)3 +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 () *7+//-, *&'-* C+6&)3 '2-

*',--'# H( C+6&/&'+'- -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2-*- *&'-* +)% 8,(7('- E.+/&'9 %-*&3) (.'6(7-*S B2-) +**-**-%

'2,(.32 '2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' 8,(6-**S %B-//&)3* 7+9 2+:- ?.&/%&)3 ?./1 6/(*-, '( *&'- ?(.)%+,&-*S


Comment [59]: Addison Developments Limited5711-11


Comment [60]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-10053


Comment [61]: 5625-24 Alistair Ray


Comment [62]: Wesley College Trust Board andGrafton Downs Limited (4767-33) and Housing

New Zealand (839-10068)




Comment [64]: 6650-59 Summerset GroupHoldings Limited


Comment [65]: 6650-83 Summerset GroupHoldings Limited


Comment [66]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-18; Jonty Crane 4694-4


Comment [67]: Housing New ZealandCorporation, primary evidence of Amelia Lindsay

and Matt Lindenberg


Comment [68]: 4132-1 Sentinel Planning


9/113

9

8,(:&%-% '2+' *2+%&)3 +)% :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* () +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +,- 7&)&7&*-%#

H2,(.32 '2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' 8,(6-**S C(., (, 7(,- %B-//&)3* +' + 2&32-, %-)*&'9 7+9 ?- ?.&/' ()

/+,3- *&'-* B&'2 B&%- ,(+% C,()'+3-*# H2&* &* ?-6+.*- /+,3-, *&'-* +,- 6+8+?/- (C +66(77(%+'&)3 +

B&%-, ,+)3- (C 2(.*&)3 '98-*S &)'-3,+'&)3 %-:-/(87-)' &)'( '2- )-&32?(.,2((% +)% +62&-:&)3 2&32

E.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9#

a:-, '&7-S '2- +88-+,+)6- (C )-&32?(.,2((%* B&'2&) '2&* I()- B&// 62+)3- '( +) .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/

62+,+6'-,#

H2- I()- +88/&-* %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/* '( +// ?.&/%&)3* +)% ,-E.&,-* ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' C(, '2,-- (,

7(,- %B-//&)3* +)% C(, ('2-, *8-6&C&-% ?.&/%&)3* &) (,%-, '(L

• +62&-:- '2- 8/+))-% .,?+) ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- I()-[ +)%

• 7+)+3- '2- -CC-6'* (C %-:-/(87-)' () )-&32?(.,&)3 *&'-*S &)6/.%&)3 :&*.+/ +7-)&'9S 8,&:+69

+)% +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32'[ +)%

• +62&-:- +'',+6'&:- +)% *+C- *',--'* +)% 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*[ +)%

• +62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 ()W*&'- /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'*#

H2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' ,-E.&,-7-)'* -)+?/- '2- %-*&3) +)% /+9(.' (C '2- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- +**-**-%

+)% ,-6(3)&*- '2+' '2- )--% '( +62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 %-*&3) &* &)6,-+*&)3/9 &78(,'+)' +* '2- *6+/- (C

%-:-/(87-)' &)6,-+*-*#

F>?,@1.A,-

"# N+)% *.,,(.)%&)3 6-)',-*S 2&32 %-)*&'9 ,-*&%-)'&+/ +,-+* +)% 6/(*- '( '2- ,+8&% +)% C,-E.-)'*-,:&6- )-'B(,1 +)% /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-* &* -CC&6&-)'/9 .*-% '( 8,(:&%- .,?+) /&:&)3 '2+' &)6,-+*-*

$.61/+)%Y* 2(.*&)3 *.88/9 6+8+6&'9 +)% 62(&6- +)% +66-** '( 8.?/&6 ',+)*8(,'#

4# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- '2+' -)3+3-* B&'2 +)% +%%,-**-* '2-

*',--'S 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'- +)% &'* 6()'-0' +)% '2- 6(78/-7-)'* )-&32?(.,2((%_*

8/+))-% .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 '2,-- *'(,-9 ?.&/%&)3*S &) + :+,&-'9 (C

C(,7* +)% *.,,(.)%-% ?9 (8-) *8+6-S -)3+3&)3 B&'2 +)% +%%,-**&)3 '2- *',--'#

=# X-:-/(87-)' 8,(:&%-* 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9 /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'* C(, ,-*&%-)'* +)% +62&-:-*

+ ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 C(, +%T(&)&)3 *&'-*#

@# X-:-/(87-)' &* +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 )-'B(,1 .'&/&'&-* &)C,+*',.6'.,- +)% &* (C + %-)*&'9 '2+' &*

+88,(8,&+'- C(, '2- 829*&6+/ +'',&?.'-* (C '2- *&'- +)% +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

)53.@.,-

"# Z)+?/- + :+,&-'9 (C %-'+62-% +)% +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 '98-* +' &)6,-+*-% 2&32-, %-)*&'&-*S &)6/.%&)3/(BW,&*- +8+,'7-)'* +)% *8-6&+/&*' ,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* *.62 +* ,-'&,-7-)' :&//+3-*#

4# R+)+3- G-E.&,- '2- 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- (C %-:-/(87-)' +)% ,-E.&,- '2- 8,(:&*&()

(C *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61* +)% /+)%*6+8-% +,-+* 6()*&*'-)' B&'2 '( +62&-:- +) .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/'

62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 '2,-- *'(,-9*S &) + :+,&-'9 (C C(,7* +)% *.,,(.)%-% ?9 (8-) *8+6-#

=# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + '2- 2-&32'S +)% ?./1 +)% /(6+'&() (C %-:-/(87-)' '( '2+' +//(B*

&77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,* '( 2+:- 7+&)'+&) + ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C *.)/&32' +66-** +)% 8,&:+69S +)% '(

+:(&% 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ -06-**&:- %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

@# Z)+?/- +''+62-% 2(.*&)3 () *7+//-, *&'-* B2-,- '2- %-:-/(87-)' C+6-* '2- *',--' +)% &)'-3,+'-*

B-// &)'( '2- )-&32?(.,2((%#

D @# G-E.&,- %B-//&)3* '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(L

+# 2+:- .*-+?/- +)% +66-**&?/- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6-

?# 8,(:&%- 8,&:+69 +)% (.'/((1




Comment [70]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-18; Jonty Crane 4694-4




Comment [72]: Housing New Zealand 839-10060


Comment [73]: Christine Coste for AUOG,

primary evidenceRachel Morgan 3/8/2015 11:44 AM

Comment [74]: 839-10061 Housing NewZealand Corporation


Comment [75]: Ryman (6106-41) & RVA(6103- 41)




Comment [77]: Housing New ZealandCorporation 839-10064 and 839-10065




10/113

10

6# ?- (C + *&I-S 2+:- +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32'S +)% 8,(:&%- '2- +7-)&'&-* )-6-**+,9 '( 7--' '2-

%+9W'(W%+9 )--%* (C ,-*&%-)'*#

\ D# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(S B&'2 + 8+,'&6./+, -782+*&* () '2(*- 8+,'* :&*&?/- C,(7

'2- *',--' '( L

+# 6,-+'- +'',+6'&:- C,()'+3-* +)% 8,(:&%- :&*.+/ &)'-,-*' '( '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-* +)%

6(77() +,-+* B&'2&) '2- *&'-[ +)%

?# C+6- '2- *',--' +)% 7+0&7&*- 8,(:&%- 8+**&:- *.,:-&//+)6- (C &' (C '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*

+)% 6(77() +,-+* B&'2&) '2- *&'-#6# 7&)&7&*- '2- %(7&)+)6- (C 3+,+3- %((,* :&*&?/- C,(7 '2- *',--'#

]# N&7&' '2- %-)*&'9 +)% *6+/- (C %-:-/(87-)' '(

+# +62&-:&)3 + ?+/+)6- ?-'B--) 7+1&)3 '2- 7(*' -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2- *&'- +)% 8,(:&%&)3 2&32WE.+/&'9

()W*&'- +7-)&'9

?# '2- 8,(8(,'&()* (, '(8(3,+829 (C '2- *&'- (, '2- B&%'2 (C &'* ,(+% C,()'+3- 7-+) '2+' &' &* )('

8(**&?/- '( 7+0&7&*- %-:-/(87-)' B&'2(.' 3-)-,+'&)3 .),-+*()+?/- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () '2- +7-)&'9

(C +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +)% '2- *.,,(.)%&)3 +,-+

6# +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

^ \# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( 2+:- +:+&/+?/- 6())-6'&()* ?- +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 2+:&)3 +:+&/+?/-

6())-6'&()* '( B+'-, *.88/9 +)% B+*'-B+'-, )-'B(,1*#

=


11/113

11

H2- I()- +88/&-* %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/* '( +// ?.&/%&)3* +)% ,-E.&,-* ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' C(, '2,-- (,

7(,- %B-//&)3* +)% C(, ('2-, *8-6&C&-% ?.&/%&)3* &) (,%-, '(L

• +62&-:- '2- 8/+))-% .,?+) ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C '2- I()-[ +)%

• 7+)+3- '2- -CC-6'* (C %-:-/(87-)' () )-&32?(.,&)3 *&'-*S &)6/.%&)3 :&*.+/ +7-)&'9S 8,&:+69

+)% +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32'[ +)%

• +62&-:- +'',+6'&:- +)% *+C- *',--'* +)% 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*[ +)%

• +62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 ()W*&'- /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'*#

H2- ,-*(.,6- 6()*-)' ,-E.&,-7-)'* -)+?/- '2- %-*&3) +)% /+9(.' (C '2- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- +**-**-%

+)% ,-6(3)&*- '2+' '2- )--% '( +62&-:- 2&32 E.+/&'9 %-*&3) &* &)6,-+*&)3/9 &78(,'+)' +* '2- *6+/- (C%-:-/(87-)' &)6,-+*-*#

H2&* I()- +/*( 8,(:&%-* C(, + ,+)3- (C )()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* *( '2+' ,-*&%-)'* 2+:- 6():-)&-)'

+66-** '( '2-*- +6'&:&'&-* +)% *-,:&6-* B2&/- 7+&)'+&)&)3 '2- .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-, (C '2-*-

+,-+*#

F>?,@1.A,-

"# N+)% *.,,(.)%&)3 6-)',-*S +)% '2- ,+8&% +)% C,-E.-)' *-,:&6- )-'B(,1 +)% /+,3- .,?+) C+6&/&'&-* &*

-CC&6&-)'/9 .*-% '( 8,(:&%- .,?+) /&:&)3 '2+'8,(:&%- .,?+) /&:&)3 '2+' &)6,-+*-* $.61/+)%Y* 2(.*&)3

*.88/9 6+8+6&'9 +)% 62(&6- +)% +66-** '( 6-)',-* +)% 8.?/&6 ',+)*8(,'#

4# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- '2+' -)3+3-* B&'2 +)% +%%,-**-* '2-

*',--'S 8(*&'&:-/9 ,-*8()%* '( '2- *&'-S &'* 6()'-0' +)% 6(78/-7-)'* '2- )-&32?(.,2((%_* 8/+))-%

.,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 C&:- *'(,-9 ?.&/%&)3*S (, *&0 (, *-:-) *'(,-9

?.&/%&)3* &) &%-)'&C&-% +,-+*S &) + :+,&-'9 (C C(,7* +)% *.,,(.)%-% ?9 (8-) *8+6-S -)3+3&)3 B&'2 +)%+%%,-**&)3 '2- *',--'#

=# X-:-/(87-)' 8,(:&%-* 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9 /&:&)3 -):&,()7-)'* C(, ,-*&%-)'* +)% +62&-:-*

+ ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 C(, +%T(&)&)3 *&'-*#

@# X-:-/(87-)' &* (C + %-)*&'9 '2+' &* +88,(8,&+'- C(, '2- 829*&6+/ +'',&?.'-* (C '2- *&'-S +)9

&)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'* +)% '2- 8/+))-% .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-, (C '2- )-&32?(.,2((%#

@# X-:-/(87-)' &* +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 )-'B(,1 .'&/&'&-* &)C,+*',.6'.,-#

D# V()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* 8,(:&%- 6():-)&-)6- +)% 62(&6- C(, '2- )-&32?(.,2((% B2&/- -)*.,&)3

'2- .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-, +)% +7-)&'9 (C '2- +,-+ &* 7+&)'+&)-%#

)53.@.,-

"# Z)+?/- + :+,&-'9 (C 2(.*&)3 '98-* +88,(8,&+'- '( +' 2&32-, %-)*&'&-* /-:-/* (C ,-*&%-)'&+/ %-)*&'9S

*8-6&C&6+//9 &)6/.%&)3 '-,,+6- 2(.*&)3 +)% +8+,'7-)'* +)% *8-6&+/&*' ,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* *.62 +*,-'&,-7-)' :&//+3-*#

4# $:(&% /(B %-)*&'9 ,-*&%-)'&+/ %-:-/(87-)'S B2&/- +//(B&)3 '2- 6()'&).-% .*- (C + *&'- C(, ()-

%B-//&)3#

= 4# R+)+3- G-E.&,- '2- 2-&32'S ?./1S C(,7 +)% +88-+,+)6- (C %-:-/(87-)' +)% ,-E.&,- '2-

8,(:&*&() (C *.CC&6&-)' *-'?+61* +)% /+)%*6+8-% +,-+* 6()*&*'-)' B&'2 '( +62&-:- +) .,?+) ,-*&%-)'&+/

?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C ?-'B--) C(., +)% *&0 8,-%(7&)+)'/9 C&:- *'(,-9 ?.&/%&)3* (, *&0 (, *-:-) *'(,-9*

?.&/%&)3* &) &%-)'&C&-% +,-+*S /(6+'&()* &) + :+,&-'9 (C C(,7* +)% *.,,(.)%-% ?9 (8-) *8+6-#

@ =# K,(:&%- C(, ?.&/%&)3 2-&32'* '2+' ,-C/-6' '2- *6+/- (C %-:-/(87-)' &) '2- +%T(&)&)3 ?.*&)-** +,-+

+)% U) &%-)'&C&-% /(6+'&() +%T+6-)' '( 6-)',-*S -)+?/- 3,-+'-, ?.&/%&)3 2-&32' '2,(.32 '2- +88/&6+'&()

(C '2- $%%&'&()+/ b()- Q-&32' O()',(/ B2-,- '2- +%%&'&()+/ %-:-/(87-)' 8('-)'&+/ -)+?/-%L

+# 8,(:&%-* +) +88,(8,&+'- ',+)*&'&() &) ?.&/%&)3 *6+/- C,(7 '2- +%T(&)&)3 2&32-, %-)*&'9 ?.*&)-**

I()- '( )-&32?(.,&)3 /(B-, %-)*&'9 ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-* +,-+*S +)%[




Comment [87]: 839-10071 Housing NewZealand Limited




Comment [89]: Housing New Zealand 839-10073






Comment [92]: 1069-4 Stuart Howard


Comment [93]: 2007-4 Point ChevalierResidents Against THABs Incorporated


Comment [94]: Ryman (6106-43 & 44) & RVA(6103-43 & 44)


Comment [95]: 1350-9 Singyip Estate Limited


Comment [96]: 2606-20 Fletcher ConstructionDevelopments (a division of the Fletcher

Construction Company Limited, 6212-26 Property

Council New Zealand, 2742-205 Unitec Institute ofTechnology


12/113

12

?# *.88(,'* 8.?/&6 ',+)*8(,'S 6(77.)&'9 *(6&+/ &)C,+*',.6'.,- +)% '2- :&'+/&'9 (C '2- +%T(&)&)3 6-)',-#

D @# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- %-*&3)-% '( ,-*8()% '( '2- 6()'-0' (C &)'-3,+'- &)'( '2-

)-&32?(.,2((%S B2&/- ,-6(3)&*&)3 '2- &)6,-+*-% ?.&/%&)3 ?./1 +)% &) 2-&32' '2- I()- +//(B*#

\ D# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- (C + R+)+3- '2- 2-&32' +)% ?./1 (C %-:-/(87-)' '( '2+' +//(B*

&77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,* '( 2+:- 7+&)'+&) + ,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C *.)/&32' %+9/&32' +66-** +)% +

,-+*()+?/- *'+)%+,% (C 8,&:+69S +)% '( +:(&% -06-**&:- 7&)&7&*- :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '(

&77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

] \# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' +%T(&)&)3 '2- ('2-, ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-* '( ?- *-' ?+61 C,(7 '2- ?(.)%+,9 '(

,-6(3)&*- '2- 8/+))-% ?.&/' 62+,+6'-, (C ('2-, +%T(&)&)3 ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-* '2-&, +7-)&'9 :+/.-*#

^ ]# G-E.&,- %B-//&)3* '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(L

+# 2+:- .*-+?/- +)% +66-**&?/- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6-S 7+0&7&*&)3 *.)/&32' +66-** B2-,- 8,+6'&6+?/-

?# 8,(:&%- 8,&:+69 +)% (.'/((1

6# ?- (C + *&I-S 2+:- +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% *.)/&32'S +)% 8,(:&%- '2- +7-)&'&-* )-6-**+,9 '( 7--' '2-

%+9W'(W%+9 )--%* (C ,-*&%-)'*

%# 8,&(,&'&*- 8-%-*',&+) +66-**S *+C-'9 +)% 7(:-7-)'#

c ^# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- %-*&3)-% '(S B&'2 + 8+,'&6./+, -782+*&* () '2(*- 8+,'* :&*&?/- C,(7

'2- *',--' '( L

+# 6,-+'- +'',+6'&:- C,()'+3-* +)% 8,(:&%- :&*.+/ &)'-,-*' '( '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-* +)% (8-)

*8+6-* B&'2&) '2- *&'-

?# C+6- '2- *',--' +)% 7+0&7&*- 8,(:&%- 8+**&:- *.,:-&//+)6- (C &' (C '2- *',--'S 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6-*+)% (8-) *8+6-* B&'2&) '2- *&'-#

6# 7&)&7&*- '2- %(7&)+)6- (C 3+,+3- %((,* :&*&?/- C,(7 '2- *',--'#

"`# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( 7+1- '2- 7(*' -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2- *&'- +* 8,+6'&6+?/-S '+1&)3 &)'(

+66(.)'L

+# '2- +?&/&'9 '( 8,(:&%- 2&32WE.+/&'9 ()W*&'- +7-)&'9

?# '2- 8,(8(,'&()* (, '(8(3,+829 (C '2- *&'- (, '2- B&%'2 (C &'* ,(+% C,()'+3- 7-+) '2+' &' &* )('

8(**&?/- '( 7+0&7&*- %-:-/(87-)' B&'2(.' 3-)-,+'&)3 .),-+*()+?/- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () '2- +7-)&'9

(C +%T(&)&)3 *&'-* +)% '2- *.,,(.)%&)3 +,-+

6# +)9 &)C,+*',.6'.,- 6()*',+&)'*#

""# K,(:&%- C(, + ,+)3- (C )()W,-*&%-)'&+/ +6'&:&'&-* B2&/- -)*.,&)3 '2+' '2- &)'-)*&'9 (C .*- B&// )('

%-',+6' C,(7 '2- ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 (C '2- +,-+#

c# G-E.&,- %-:-/(87-)' '( ?- +%-E.+'-/9 *-,:&6-% ?9 2+:&)3 +:+&/+?/- 6())-6'&()* '( B+'-, *.88/9+)% B+*'-B+'-, )-'B(,1*#




Comment [98]: 2742-203 Unitec Institute ofTechnology


Comment [99]: Consequential to Topic 013

RPS Urban Growth rebuttal evidence of NickRoberts


Comment [100]: 4823-24 Stephen Davis










Comment [105]: 2588-40 Z Energy Limited andBP Oil New Zealand Limited and Mobil Oil New

Zealand Limited5723-107 Progressive Enterprises

Limited.


Comment [106]: Broadway Park ResidentsSociety Incorporated 3747-8


13/113

13

B3, =T [email protected] -121:- 5D 320/ :-, [email protected].,-

H2- C(//(B&)3 '+?/- *8-6&C&-* '2- +6'&:&'9 *'+'.* (C /+)% .*- +6'&:&'&-* &) '2- ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-*#

[email protected] H27I, H51

450,

+:723 20/

#52-123

L,113,8,0

1 450,

L.0I3,

$5:-,

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

L:>:7>20

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

*7>20 450,

",772@,

$5:-.0I

20/

!62718,01

R:.3/.0I-

450,

+,-./,01.23

$6'&:&'&-* )(' 8,(:&%-%C(,

VO VO VO VO VO VO

O+78&)3 3,(.)%* VO X X VO X VO X VO X VO

XB-//&)3* K K K K K K

.8 '( = 4%B-//&)3* 8-,*&'-

.8 '( = 4%B-//&)3* 8-,*&'-

a)- .8 '( 4%B-//&)3*() + 8-,*&'-

GX@ = (, 7(,-%B-//&)3* 8-,*&'-

GX@ = (, 7(,-%B-//&)3* 8-,*&'-

X4 '( @%B-//&)3*8-, *&'-

GXD = (, 7(,-%B-//&)3*8-, *&'-

Q(7- (66.8+'&()* K K K K K K

G-'&,-7-)' :&//+3-* VO X VO X X GX GX GX

P.88(,'-% ,-*&%-)'&+/6+,- +)% ?(+,%&)32(.*-*+66(77(%+'&)3 .8 '("` 8-(8/-4``7d >e$8-, *&'- &)6/.*&:- (C*'+CC +)% ,-*&%-)'*

VO GX K GX K K K K

P.88(,'-% ,-*&%-)'&+/6+,- +)% ?(+,%&)32(.*-* )(' 8,(:&%-%C(, +?(:-

VO X VO X X GX GX GX


Comment [107]: Consequential from Topic 004evidence of Michele Perwick


Comment [108]: Consequential from Topic 004evidence of Michele Perwick

Rachel Morgan 3/8/2015 11:44 AMComment [109]: Auckland Council 5716-299,Leigh A Auton 5400-7


Comment [110]: 3354-3 Nigel Cartmell andJoanne Pilgrem, 3526-3 Nigel Cartmell, 4923-3Marceline Borren, 5035-3 Patricia

Hannan,5696-27 Stuart J and Orchid L Bracey,5810-5 Wendy Cook, 6370-119 The CharacterCoalition, 6756-7 Jimmy Chan


Comment [111]: 5277-55 The Urban DesignForum New Zealand, 5280-53 The NewZealand Institute of Architects, 6370-120 The

Character Coalition


Comment [112]: 1350-9 Singyip EstateLimited, 3243-5 Dong Global InvestmentsLimited


Comment [113]: Oceania (4290-38), Metlifecare(6098-39) and BUPA (6259-8)


Comment [114]: Oceania (4290-38), Metlifecare(6098-39) and BUPA (6259-8)


Comment [115]: Navigate 5373-4 /5


Comment [116]: Waitemata District HealthBoard 4476-20


Comment [117]: Navigate 5373-5


Comment [118]: Waitemata District HealthBoard 4476-20


14/113

14


450,

+:723 20/

#52-123

L,113,8,0

1 450,

L.0I3,

$5:-,

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

L:>:7>20

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

*7>20 450,

",772@,

$5:-.0I

20/

!62718,01

R:.3/.0I-

450, 5(+,%&)3 2(.*-*+66(77(%+'&)3 .8 '("` 8-(8/- 8-, *&'-&)6/.*&:- (C *'+CC +)%,-*&%-)'*

GX GX K K K K

5(+,%&)3 2(.*-* )('('2-,B&*- 8,(:&%-% C(,+?(:-

X X X GX GX GX

f&*&'(,+66(77(%+'&() .8 '(4``7d >e$+66(77(%+'&)3 .8 '("` 8-(8/- 8-, *&'-&)6/.*&:- (C *'+CC +)%:&*&'(,*

VO GX GX GX K GX K GX K GX K

f&*&'(,+66(77(%+'&() )('8,(:&%-% C(, +?(:-


#588,7@,

X+&,&-* .8 '( "``74 >e$ 8-, *&'-

VO X GX GX GX GX GX

G-*'+.,+)'* +)% 6+C-*.8 '( "``7d >e$ 8-,*&'-

VO X GX VO X VO X X GX

P-,:&6- *'+'&()* ()+,'-,&+/ ,(+%*

VO X X X X X X

aCC&6-* B&'2&) '2- O&'9

O-)',- e,&)3- aCC&6-O()',(/ +* &%-)'&C&-%() '2- 8/+))&)3 7+8*

V$ V$ K V$ V$ V$

aCC&6-* B&'2&) '2-H+1+8.)+ e,&)3- aCC&6-O()',(/ +* &%-)'&C&-%() '2- 8/+))&)3 7+8*

V$ V$ V$ V$ V$ K

#588:0.1S

O+,- 6-)',-*+66(77(%+'&)3 .8 '(4``7d >e$ "` 8-(8/-8-, *&'- -06/.%&)3 *'+CC

K K K K K K

O+,- 6-)',-* ?-'B--) VO VO GX GX GX GX


Comment [119]: Navigate 5373-5; SalvationArmy 7398-21


Comment [120]: Leigh A Auton 5400-7Minister of Social Development: Child, Youth and

Family 5704-7-8


Comment [121]: Steven R Garner 4605-1


Comment [122]: David W Adams 1190-1,Jennifer D Edwards 4284-10, David W Adams

1190-1, Westgate Partnership 4373-174, Mr and Mrs

S Nuich Trust 5788-165, J D Rai and Sons Limited

4581-2, Lawrence and Wendy Blount 7327-1


Comment [123]: As above (RM91)


Comment [124]: Hugh Green Limited 5259-79


Comment [125]: Hugh Green Limited 5259-79


Comment [126]: Z Energy Limited and BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Mobil Oil New ZealandLimited 2588-46


Comment [127]: Apply this control to the siteswithin the Single House zone that directly adjoin

the southern side of College Hill.


Comment [128]: Chivalry Enterprises Limited7100-4


Comment [129]: Apply this control to the siteson the northern side of Bracken Avenue and

southern side of Byron Avenue, Takapuna, as per

map at Attachment 3 to rebuttal.


Comment [130]: Primary evidence of PhillipHarland


Comment [131]: Navigate 5373-8


Comment [132]: Navigate 5373 9 and 10


15/113

15


450,

+:723 20/

#52-123

L,113,8,0

1 450,

L.0I3,

$5:-,

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

L:>:7>20

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

*7>20 450,

",772@,

$5:-.0I

20/

!62718,01

R:.3/.0I-

450, 4``7d @``7d >e$ 8-,*&'-

O+,- 6-)',-* ()*62((/* *&'-*%-*&3)+'-% ?9 '2-R&)&*'-, (C Z%.6+'&()

K K K K K K

O+,- 6-)',-* )(' 8,(:&%-% C(, +?(:-


O(77.)&'9 C+6&/&'&-* X X X GX GX GX

O(77.)&'9 C+6&/&'&-*() *&'-* %-*&3)+'-% ?9'2- R&)&*'-, (CZ%.6+'&()

K K K K K K

Z%.6+'&() C+6&/&'&-* VO X X X X X X

H-,'&+,9 -%.6+'&()C+6&/&'&-*

VO X X X X X X

Z7-,3-)69 *-,:&6-* ()+%T(&)&)3 +) +,'-,&+/,(+%

VO X X X X X X

Q-+/'26+,- C+6&/&'&-* .8'( 4``7d >e$ 8-, *&'-

VO GX GX GX GX GX

Q-+/'26+,- C+6&/&'&-*+)% +**(6&+'-%?.&/%&)3* )(' 8,(:&%-%C(, +?(:-

VO VO VO X X X

+:723

>,+I&)3 (C /&:-*'(61 ()*&'-* 3,-+'-, '2+)4S```74 )-' *&'- +,-+

K K VO K VO K VO K VO K

%202 UE,0:2

R+,+- 6(78/-0 X X X X X X

;,A,3568,01

$/'-,+'&()*+)% +%%&'&()* '( +*&)3/- %B-//&)3 () +

*&'-

K K K K K K


Comment [133]: Consequential amendmentfrom Closing Statement of Auckland Council for

Topic 055 – Social Infrastructure.


Comment [134]: Navigate 5373 9 and 10


Comment [135]: Ruven Duinkerke 4713-3


Comment [136]: Consequential amendmentfrom Trevor Mackie’s evidence for Auckland

Council for Topic 055 – Social Infrastructure (refer

paragraph 10.40)

Catherine Reaburn 6/10/2015 4:47 PMComment [137]: Not requested in primaryevidence but amended for consistency of approach

with Tertiary Education Facilities below


Comment [138]: Prema Charitable Trust, primary evidence of Richard Blakey


Comment [139]: The University of Auckland5662-93


Comment [140]: Minister of Police 4274-21New Zealand Fire Service Commission 867-56


Comment [141]: Minister of Police 4274-21,Auckland Council 5716-299, Ronald H Lever 2821-

2


16/113

16


450,

+:723 20/

#52-123

L,113,8,0

1 450,

L.0I3,

$5:-,

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

L:>:7>20

450,

%.O,/

$5:-.0I

*7>20 450,

",772@,

$5:-.0I

20/

!62718,01

R:.3/.0I-

450,

$/'-,+'&()* +)%

+%%&'&()* '( 'B( (,7(,- %B-//&)3* () +*&'-

K K K K K GX

X-7(/&'&() (C?.&/%&)3*

K K K K K K

H2- 6():-,*&() (C +%B-//&)3 &)'( +7+0&7.7 (C 'B(%B-//&)3* 6(78/9&)3B&'2 '2- /+)% .*-6()',(/* &) 6/+.*- =#=?-/(B

GX GX K K K X

5.&/%&)3* +66-**(,9 '(

'2- 8-,7&''-% +)%,-*',&6'-%%&*6,-'&()+,9)()W,-*&%-)'&+/+6'&:&'&-* /&*'-% +?(:-

GX GX GX GX GX GX

5.&/%&)3* +66-**(,9 '( +// ('2-, +6'&:&'&-* /&*'-% &) '2&* '+?/- 2+:- '2- *+7- +6'&:&'9 *'+'.* +* '2-+6'&:&'9 &'*-/C#

"2>3, G V [email protected] -121:- 5D /,A,3568,01 [email protected].,-

H2- C(//(B&)3 '+?/- *8-6&C&-* '2- +6'&:&'9 *'+'.* (C %-:-/(87-)' +6'&:&'&-* &) '2- ,-*&%-)'&+/ I()-*#

[email protected] [email protected] -121:-

X-7(/&'&() (C ?.&/%&)3* K

U)'-,)+/ +)% -0'-,)+/ +/'-,+'&()* '( ?.&/%&)3* K

$66-**(,9 ?.&/%&)3* K

$%%&'&()* '( +) -0&*'&)3 %B-//&)3 K

V-B ?.&/%&)3* +)% +%%&'&()* '( ?.&/%&)3*

+66(77(%+'&)3 +6'&:&'&-* '2+' +,- )(' %-C&)-% +*

%B-//&)3*

H2- *+7- +6'&:&'9 *'+'.* +* '2- /+)% .*- +6'&:&'9

'2+' '2- )-B ?.&/%&)3 (, +%%&'&() &* %-*&3)-% '(

+66(77(%+'- +88/&-*

H2- 6():-,*&() (C + %B-//&)3 &)'( + 7+0&7.7 (C

'B( %B-//&)3*S -06-8' +* *8-6&C&-% ?-/(B

K


Comment [142]: Peter H Nolan and WarwickJ James 5750-5


17/113

17

H2- 6():-,*&() (C + %B-//&)3 &)'( + 7+0&7.7 (C

'B( %B-//&)3* &) '2- N+,3- N(' +)% G.,+/ +)%

O(+*'+/ P-''/-7-)' I()-

GX

R&)(, %B-//&)3* &) '2- N+,3- N(' I()- GX

R&)(, %B-//&)3* &) '2- P&)3/- Q(.*- I()- B2-,-

'2- 7&)(, %B-//&)3 &* /(6+'-% B&'2&) + Q&*'(,&6

O2+,+6'-, (:-,/+9 +)% (.'*&%- (C +) &%-)'&C&-%

C/((% 8/+&)

K

G< '[email protected].,8(*-L Z)*.,- '2+' %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/ &)C,&)3-7-)'* +)% +6'&:&'&-* '2+' +%:-,*-/9 +CC-6' '2-

8/+))-% ,-*&%-)'&+/ 62+,+6'-, (C '2- I()- (, '2- ,-*&%-)'&+/ +7-)&'9 (C )-&32?(.,&)3 *&'-* +,-

8.?/&6/9 )('&C&-% B2-,- '2- +%:-,*- -CC-6'* () '2- -):&,()7-)' +,- 7(,- '2+) 7&)(, (, /&7&'-%

)('&C&-% B2-,- )-&32?(.,* +,- %--7-% '( ?- +%:-,*-/9 +CC-6'-%#

"# $) +88/&6+'&() '( &)C,&)3- 5.&/%&)3* '2+' %( )(' 6(78/9 B&'2 '2- C(//(B&)3 %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/*

B&// ?- *.?T-6' '( '2- )(,7+/ '-*'* C(, )('&C&6+'&() .)%-, '2- ,-/-:+)' *-6'&()* (C '2- GR$L

+# ?.&/%&)3 2-&32' &) '2- N+,3- N('S G.,+/ +)% O(+*'+/ P-''/-7-)'S P&)3/- Q(.*-S R&0-% Q(.*&)3P.?.,?+) +)% R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) I()-*

?# ?.&/%&)3 2-&32' &)C,&)3-7-)'* 3,-+'-, '2+) 47 &) '2- H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)% $8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3

I()-

?# 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9

6# +/'-,)+'&:- 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 &) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) +)% R&0-% Q(.*&)3

J,?+) I()-*

%# *&%- +)% ,-+, 9+,%* &) '2- N+,3- N(' I()-

-# 7+0&7.7 ?.&/%&)3 /-)3'2

C# ?.&/%&)3 *-'?+61* +)% 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 B&'2&) '2- H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)%

$8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3* I()-

3# ?.&/%&)3 *-'?+61* 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 &) '2- H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)%

$8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3* I()- B2-,- &' +%T(&)* /(B-, %-)*&'9 I()-*

2# ?.&/%&)3 6(:-,+3- &) '2- N+,3- N('S G.,+/ +)% O(+*'+/ P-''/-7-)'S P&)3/- Q(.*- +)% H-,,+6-

Q(.*&)3 +)% $8+,'7-)' 5.&/%&)3 I()-*

?.&/%&)3 6(:-,+3- 3,-+'-, '2+) @`g &) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) +)% @Dg &) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3

J,?+) I()-*

U T# /+)%*6+8&)3 &) '2- P&)3/- Q(.*-S R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) +)% H-,,+6- Q(.*&)3 +)% $8+,'7-)'

5.&/%&)3 I()-*

1# /+)%*6+8&)3 /-** '2+) =Dg &) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) I()-

T /# (.'/((1 *8+6-#

4# $) +88/&6+'&() '( &)C,&)3- '2- C(//(B&)3 +6'&:&'&-* B&// ?- *.?T-6' '( '2- )(,7+/ '-*'* C(, )('&C&6+'&()

.)%-, '2- ,-/-:+)' *-6'&()* (C '2- GR$L

+# :&*&'(, +66(77(%+'&() )(' ('2-,B&*- 8,(:&%-% C(,

?# 6+,- 6-)',-* )(' ('2-,B&*- 8,(:&%-% C(,

6# 6(77.)&'9 C+6&/&'&-*#


Comment [143]: =c4\W" R&62-//- 5,+%/-9 +)%

>,I-3(,I h%(B&1(B*1&S =]\4W] P&,FR+%+7 X(.3/+*

e(*'-, e+7&/9 H,.*'

Rereata Hardman-Mi!

, 7/9/2015 2:59 PM

Comment [144]: ^=cW4^ +)% ^=cW"`"c`Q(.*&)3 V-B b-+/+)% O(,8(,+'&()S D]D`W4 K-'-, Q

V(/+) +)% h+,B&61 i i+7-*S D^4`W] $)9() +)%

K-'-,* e+7&/9 H,.*'*S "@"`W4 P.?%&:&*&() P(/.'&()*

N&7&'-%S "]c@W" G()+/% P.,-)%()1


Comment [145]: Vijay Lala, for PropertyCouncil NZ, Fletcher Construction Developments,

Unitec, Tamaki Redevelopment Company and

Crown Mutual Limited, primary evidence




Comment [147]: Fletcher Residential Limited1731-10


Comment [148]: Fletcher Residential Limited1731-10


Comment [149]: David W Adams 1190-1,Jennifer D Edwards 4284-10, David W Adams

1190-1, Westgate Partnership 4373-174, Mr and Mrs

S Nuich Trust 5788-165, J D Rai and Sons Limited

4581-2, Lawrence and Wendy Blount 7327-1


Comment [150]: 5373-10 Navigate


Comment [151]: Massey Community Church3588-4


18/113

18

K< H20/ :-, @501753-

K,--)S\c4]W@ >,-3 V&1(/(CCS\c@4W@ H-' f

N--S]`\cW= V&6(/- N--S]=D]W= Q( A&) $)'2()9

N-.)3S^]]cW= O(,)-/&.* 5/+)1Sc"@]W4= G(62-//- N

R(//(9#

Rereata Hardman-Mi!, 7/9/2015 2:41 PM



19/113

19

?# -+62 8,(8(*-% %B-//&)3 &* *-'?+61 +' /-+*' 4#D7 +)% )( 7(,- '2+) D7 C,(7 '2- C,()'+3- (C '2-

*&'-#

@# h2-,- '2,-- (, C(., %B-//&)3* +,- 8,(8(*-% () + C,()' *&'- B&'2&) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) (,

R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) I()- '2- *&'- 7.*' ?- +' /-+*' "D7 B&%-L

+# +' '2- C,()'+3-

?# C(, +' /-+*' ^` 8-, 6-)' (C '2- /-)3'2 (C &'* *&%- ?(.)%+,&-*#

D# h&'2&) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) I()- + %-)*&'9 (C ()- %B-//&)3 8-, 4``7 4 +88/&-* B2-,- C(.,

(, 7(,- %B-//&)3* +,- 8,(8(*-% +)% '2- *&'-L

+# 2+* + 7&)&7.7 )-' *&'- +,-+ (C "4``74

?# &* +' /-+*' 4`7 B&%-L

+' '2- C,()'+3- (C '2- *&'-

& C(, +' /-+*' ^` 8-, 6-)' (C '2- /-)3'2 (C &'* *&%- ?(.)%+,&-*#

\# h&'2&) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) I()- )( %-)*&'9 /&7&' +88/&-* B2-,- C(., (, 7(,- %B-//&)3* +,-

8,(8(*-% +)% '2- *&'-L

+# 2+* + 7&)&7.7 )-' *&'- +,-+ (C "4``7d

?# &* +' /-+*' 4`7 B&%-L

+' '2- C,()'+3- (C '2- *&'-

& C(, +' /-+*' ^` 8-, 6-)' (C '2- /-)3'2 (C &'* *&%- ?(.)%+,&-*#

]# H( +:(&% %(.?'S B&'2&) '2- R&0-% Q(.*&)3 P.?.,?+) +)% R&0-% Q(.*&)3 J,?+) I()-* '2- 7(*'

,-*',&6'&:- %-)*&'9 +88/&-* '( -0&*'&)3 +)% 8,(8(*-% ,-+, *&'-*#

^ 4# X-:-/(87-)' '2+' %(-* )(' 6(78/9 B&'2 6/+.*-* "W\ +?(:- &* + %&*6,-'&()+,9 +6'&:&'9#

c =# O/+.*- " +?(:- %(-* )(' +88/9 B2-,- + %B-//&)3 &* 6():-,'-% &)'( 'B( %B-//&)3* +* + 8-,7&''-%

+6'&:&'9#

K


20/113

20

]# V( 7(,- '2+) ()- 6(77-,6&+/ :-2&6/- +**(6&+'-% B&'2 '2- 2(7- (66.8+'&() 7+9 ?- () *&'- +' +)9

()- '&7-#

^# P'(,+3- C(, ,.??&*2 +)% ,-696/&)3 +**(6&+'-% B&'2 '2- 2(7- (66.8+'&() 7.*' ?- 8,(:&%-% () *&'-

+)% *6,--)-% C,(7 8.?/&6 :&-B#

c# R+'-,&+/* (, 3((%* 7+).C+6'.,-%S *-,:&6-% (, ,-8+&,-% &) '2- 2(7- (66.8+'&() 7.*' ?- *'(,-%

+)% B(,1-% () B&'2&) + ?.&/%&)3 () '2- *+7- *&'-#

"`# h&'2 '2- -06-8'&() (C 3((%* (,%-,-% +)% %&*',&?.'-% -/-6',()&6+//9 (, ?9 7+&/F6(.,&-,S >((%*

*(/% C,(7 '2- 2(7- (66.8+'&() 7.*' ?-L

+# >((%* 8,(%.6-% () *&'-S (,

?# >((%* '2+' +,- 8,&7+,&/9 (,%-,-% ?9 7+&/ (, -/-6',()&6 ',+)*+6'&() +)% ,-%&*',&?.'-% ?9 8(*'

(, 6(.,&-,S (,

6# >((%* +)6&//+,9 +)% ,-/+'-% '( + *-,:&6- 8,(:&%-% ?9 '2- 2(7- (66.8+'&()#

""# $ 2(7- (66.8+'&() '2+' %(-* )(' 6(78/9 B&'2 6/+.*-* "W"` +?(:- &* + %&*6,-'&()+,9 )()W

6(78/9&)3 +6'&:&'9#

K


21/113

21

KS 1E, %.0.-1,7 5D &/:@21.50

"# $6'&:&'&-* *2(./% 6(78/9 B&'2 '2- ,-/-:+)' %-*&3)+'&() 6()%&'&()*S &)6/.%&)3 3-)-,+/ Z%.6+'&()

%-*&3)+'&() 6()%&'&() 4 W V(&*-#

4# $6'&:&'&-* *2(./% ?- /(6+'-% B&'2&) -0&*'&)3 ?.&/%&)3*#

K


22/113

22

M


23/113

23

N< ;,A,3568,01 #501753- Y +:723 20/ #52-123 L,113,8,01 450,

N


24/113

24

X.I:7, KT $,.IE1 .0 7,321.50 15 >5:0/27S

4# H2&* 6()',(/ %(-* )(' +88/9 '( + ?(.)%+,9 +%T(&)&)3L

+# &)%.*',&+/ I()-*

?# 6-)',-* +)% 7&0-% .*- I()-*

6# '2- >-)-,+/ 5.*&)-** I()-

%# '2- 5.*&)-** K+,1 I()-

-# *&'-* B&'2&) '2- 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6- I()-* -06--%&)3 4```7 4#

=# h2-,- '2- ?(.)%+,9 C(,7* 8+,' (C + /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6- *',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9S

(, +66-** *&'-S '2- 6()',(/ +88/&-* C,(7 '2- C+,'2-*' ?(.)%+,9 (C '2+' /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6-

*',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9 (, +66-** *&'- /('#

@# $ 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 7+9 8,(T-6' ?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- B2-,- '2+' 8(,'&()

?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- &* &' &*L

+# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "#D74 &) +,-+ +)% )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) 2-&32' +)% B&%'2 7-+*.,-% 8+,+//-/ '(

'2- )-+,-*' +%T+6-)' ?(.)%+,9

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) 4#D7 6.7./+'&:-/9 &) /-)3'2 7-+*.,-% +/()3 '2- -%3- (C '2- ,((C

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) %-8'2 7-+*.,-% 2(,&I()'+//9 +' c` %-3,--* '( '2- )-+,-*' +%T+6-)'

?(.)%+,9#


Comment [177]: Diagram amended to show 1mside and rear yard


25/113

25

X.I:7, MT &O,861.50- D57 2 I2>3, ,0/ 57 /578,7

D# V( 7(,- '2+) 'B( 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 8,(T-6'&()* +,- +//(B-% C(, -:-,9 \7 /-)3'2

(C *&'- ?(.)%+,9#

N


26/113

26

N+1- =`7

O(+*'+/ 8,('-6'&() 9+,% 4`7S (, +* ('2-,B&*- *8-6&C&-% &) +88-)%&0 \#]

N


27/113

27

4# h2-,- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- +' 3,(.)% /-:-/S ,-E.&,-% ?9 +)9 %B-//&)3S &* /(6+'-% *(.'2 (C +)9

?.&/%&)3 /(6+'-% () '2- *+7- *&'-S '2- *(.'2-,) ?(.)%+,9 (C '2+' *8+6- 7.*' ?- *-8+,+'-% C,(7 +)9

B+// (, ?.&/%&)3 ?9 +' /-+*' ;47 k `#c;2


28/113

28

X.I:7, PT %,2-:7,8,01 5D D,0@, E,.IE1

N


29/113

29

P< ;,A,3568,01 #501753- Y L.0I3, $5:-, 450,

P


30/113

30

"# 5.&/%&)3* 7.*' )(' 8,(T-6' ?-9()% + @DW%-3,-- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- 7-+*.,-% C,(7 + 8(&)' 4#D7

-06--% + 2-&32' (C 4#D7 7-+*.,-% :-,'&6+//9 +?(:- 3,(.)% /-:-/ +' +/()3 *&%- +)% ,-+, ?(.)%+,&-*S

+* *2(B) &) e&3.,- \ ?-/(B# H2-,-+C'-,S ?.&/%&)3* 7.*' ?- *-'?+61 "7 C(, -:-,9 +%%&'&()+/ 7-',-

&) 2-&32' ;@D %-3,--*5:0/27S

4# H2&* 6()',(/ %(-* )(' +88/9 '( + ?(.)%+,9 +%T(&)&)3L

+# &)%.*',&+/ I()-*

?# 6-)',-* +)% 7&0-% .*- I()-*

6# >-)-,+/ 5.*&)-** I()-

%# 5.*&)-** K+,1 I()-

-# *&'-* B&'2&) '2- 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6- I()-* -06--%&)3 4```7d#

=# h2-,- '2- ?(.)%+,9 C(,7* 8+,' (C + /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6- *',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9S

(, +66-** *&'-S '2- 6()',(/ +88/&-* C,(7 '2- C+,'2-*' ?(.)%+,9 (C '2+' /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6-

*',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9 (, +66-** *&'- /('#

@# $ 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 7+9 8,(T-6' ?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- B2-,- '2+' 8(,'&()

?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- &* &' &*L

+# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "#D74 &) +,-+ +)% )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) 2-&32' +)% B&%'2 7-+*.,-% 8+,+//-/ '(

'2- )-+,-*' +%T+6-)' ?(.)%+,9

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) 4#D7 6.7./+'&:-/9 &) /-)3'2 7-+*.,-% +/()3 '2- -%3- (C '2- ,((C

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) %-8'2 7-+*.,-% 2(,&I()'+//9 +' c` %-3,--* '( '2- )-+,-*' +%T+6-)'

?(.)%+,9#




31/113

31

X.I:7, M =]T &O@,61.50- D57 I2>3, ,0/- 20/ /578,7-

D# V( 7(,- '2+) 'B( 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 8,(T-6'&()* +,- +//(B-% C(, -:-,9 \7 /-)3'2

(C *&'- ?(.)%+,9#

P


32/113

32

G&8+,&+) "`7 C,(7 '2- -%3- (C 8-,7+)-)' +)%

&)'-,7&''-)' *',-+7*

N+1- =`7

O(+*'+/ 8,('-6'&() 9+,% "`7S (, +* ('2-,B&*- *8-6&C&-% &) +88-)%&0 \#]

P


33/113

33

+# &* C,-- (C ?.&/%&)3*S 8+,1&)3 *8+6-*S *-,:&6&)3 +)% 7+)(-.:,&)3 +,-+*

?# -06/.%-* +)9 +,-+ B&'2 + %&7-)*&() /-** '2+) "7#

4 "#h2-,- + $ %B-//&)3 2+* '2- 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7 +' 3,(.)% /-:-/S 8+,' (C '2- ,-E.&,-% 7.*' 2+:-

+) (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- 7.*' ?- '2+' &* +?/- '( 6()'+&) + %-/&)-+'-% +,-+ 7-+*.,&)3 +' /-+*' 4`7d

'2+' 6(78,&*-* 3,(.)% C/((, +)%F(, ?+/6()9F,((C '-,,+6- *8+6- '2+'L

+# B2-,- /(6+'-% +' 3,(.)% /-:-/ 2+* )( %&7-)*&() /-** '2+) @7 +)% 2+* + 3,+%&-)' )(' -06--%&)3 "

&) 4`

?# &* +' /-+*' D74 +)% 2+* + 7&)&7.7 %&7-)*&() (C "#^7 B2-,- 8,(:&%-% &) '2- C(,7 (C ?+/6()9 (,

,((C '-,,+6-

? 6# &* %&,-6'/9 +66-**&?/- C,(7 '2- 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7S %&)&)3 ,((7 (, 1&'62-)

%# &* C,-- (C ?.&/%&)3*S 8+,1&)3 *8+6-*S *-,:&6&)3 +)% 7+)(-.:,&)3 +,-+*

6# 2+* + 3,+%&-)' )(' -06--%&)3 " &) 4`

4# h2-,- + %B-//&)3 2+* '2- 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7 +?(:- 3,(.)% /-:-/S 8+,' (C '2- ,-E.&,-% (.'%((,

/&:&)3 *8+6- 7.*' &)6/.%- + ?+/6()9 (, ,((C '-,,+6- '2+'L

+# &* %&,-6'/9 +66-**&?/- C,(7 '2- 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7

?# 2+* + 7&)&7.7 +,-+ (C ^7d

6# 2+* + 7&)&7.7 %-8'2 (C 4#@7#

4# h2-,- (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- +' 3,(.)% /-:-/S ,-E.&,-% ?9 +)9 %B-//&)3S &* /(6+'-% *(.'2 (C +)9

?.&/%&)3 /(6+'-% () '2- *+7- *&'-S '2- *(.'2-,) ?(.)%+,9 (C '2+' *8+6- 7.*' ?- *-8+,+'-% C,(7 +)9

B+// (, ?.&/%&)3 ?9 +' /-+*' ;47 k `#c;2


34/113

34

P


35/113

35

X.I:7, =GT %,2-:7,8,01 5D D,0@, E,.IE1

P


36/113

36

X.I:7, =KT %2O.8:8 W./1E 5D I272I, /557

P


37/113

37

Q< ;,A,3568,01 #501753- Y %.O,/ $5:-.0I L:>:7>20 450,

Q:7>20 450,


Comment [199]: 1731-6 Fletcher ResidentialLimited


Comment [200]: 5324-21, Alan E Bilkey 5280-63, The New Zealand Institute of Architects 5277-

65, The Urban Design Forum New Zealand


38/113

38

Q5:0/27S

K.,8(*-L 7+)+3- '2- 2-&32' +)% ?./1 (C ?.&/%&)3* +' ?(.)%+,&-* '( 7+&)'+&) + ,-+*()+?/- /-:-/ (C

*.)/&32' +66-** +)% 7&)&7&*- +%:-,*- :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,* /&7&' (:-,W

*2+%(B&)3 (C )-&32?(.,&)3 *&'-* +)% 8,(:&%- *8+6- ?-'B--) ?.&/%&)3*#

"# 5.&/%&)3* 7.*' )(' 8,(T-6' ?-9()% + @DW%-3,-- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- 7-+*.,-% C,(7 + 8(&)' 4#D7

-06--% + 2-&32' (C 4#D7 7-+*.,-% :-,'&6+//9 +?(:- 3,(.)% /-:-/ +' +/()3 *&%- +)% ,-+, ?(.)%+,&-*S

+* *2(B) &) e&3.,- "4 ?-/(B# H2-,-+C'-,S ?.&/%&)3* 7.*' ?- *-'?+61 "7 C(, -:-,9 +%%&'&()+/ 7-',-

&) 2-&32' ;@D %-3,--*5:0/27S

4# H2&* 6()',(/ %(-* )(' +88/9 '( + ?(.)%+,9 +%T(&)&)3L

+# &)%.*',&+/ I()-*

?# 6-)',-* +)% 7&0-% .*- I()-*

6# >-)-,+/ 5.*&)-** I()-

%# 5.*&)-** K+,1 I()-

-# *&'-* B&'2&) '2- 8.?/&6 (8-) *8+6- I()-* -06--%&)3 4```7d#

=# h2-,- '2- ?(.)%+,9 C(,7* 8+,' (C + /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6- *',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9S

(, +66-** *&'-S '2- 6()',(/ +88/&-* C,(7 '2- C+,'2-*' ?(.)%+,9 (C '2+' /-3+/ ,&32' (C B+9S -)',+)6-

*',&8 8-%-*',&+) +66-** B+9 (, +66-** *&'- /('#

@# $ 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 7+9 8,(T-6' ?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- B2-,- '2+' 8(,'&()

?-9()% '2- ,-6-**&() 8/+)- &* &' &*L

+# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "#D74 &) +,-+ +)% )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) 2-&32' +)% B&%'2 7-+*.,-% 8+,+//-/ '( '2-

)-+,-*' +%T+6-)' ?(.)%+,9

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) 4#D7 6.7./+'&:-/9 &) /-)3'2 7-+*.,-% +/()3 '2- -%3- (C '2- ,((C


Comment [201]: 5280-64, The New ZealandInstitute of Architects

5277-66, The Urban Design Forum New Zealand;

5711-42, Addison Developments Limited 5713-37,

Anselmi Ridge Limited (ARL)




39/113

39

?# )( 3,-+'-, '2+) "7 &) %-8'2 7-+*.,-% 2(,&I()'+//9 +' c` %-3,--* '( '2- )-+,-*' +%T+6-)'

?(.)%+,9#

X.I:7, Q =PT &O@,61.50- D57 I2>3, ,0/- 20/ /578,7-

D# V( 7(,- '2+) 'B( 3+?/- -)%S (, %(,7-, (, ,((C 8,(T-6'&()* +,- +//(B-% C(, -:-,9 \7 /-)3'2

(C *&'- ?(.)%+,9#

\# H2- 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 ,./- %(-* )(' +88/9 '( -0&*'&)3 (, 8,(8(*-% &)'-,)+/ *&'-

?(.)%+,&-* B&'2&) +) +88/&6+'&() +,-+#

Q5:0/27S

K.,8(*-L

W -)+?/- '2- -CC&6&-)' .*- (C '2- *&'- ?9 8,(:&%&)3 %-*&3) C/-0&?&/&'9 +' '2- C&,*' C/((, (C +

%B-//&)3 6/(*- '( '2- *',--' C,()'+3-S B2&/- 7+&)'+&)&)3 + ,-+*()+?/- /-:-/ (C *.)/&32' +66-**

+)% 7&)&7&*&)3 :&*.+/ %(7&)+)6- -CC-6'* '( &77-%&+'- )-&32?(.,*#

"# H2&* %-:-/(87-)' 6()',(/ &* +) +/'-,)+'&:- '( '2- 8-,7&''-% 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 6()',(/

&) 6/+.*- ]#= +?(:- B2&62 7+9 ?- .*-% C(, +)% +88/&-* '( %-:-/(87-)' &* B&'2&) 4`7 (C '2- *&'-

C,()'+3- '2+' &* + %-)*&'9 (C ()- %B-//&)3 8-, =``7d (, 3,-+'-, +)% 6(78/&-* B&'2 '2- /+)% .*-

6()',(/* &) 6/+.*- =#"#4 +?(:-#

4# U' B&// ?- 8,(6-**-% +* + )()W)('&C&-% ,-*',&6'-% %&*6,-'&()+,9 +6'&:&'9 &C &' 6(78/&-* B&'2 6/+.*- =

?-/(B#

=# 5.&/%&)3* B&'2&) 4`7 (C '2- *&'- C,()'+3- 7.*' )(' -06--% + 2-&32' (C =#\7 7-+*.,-% :-,'&6+//9

+?(:- 3,(.)% /-:-/ +' *&%- +)% ,-+, ?(.)%+,&-*# H2-,-+C'-,S ?.&/%&)3* 7.*' ?- *-' ?+61 ()- 7-',-


Comment [203]: Alternative height in relation to boundary rule reinstated in response to the primary

evidence of Brian Putt on behalf of Mahi Properties

Limited. Amendments to the rule made for

consistency with the same control that applies in theMixed Housing Urban zone.


40/113

40

+)% '2-) `#=7 C(, -:-,9 +%%&'&()+/ 7-',- &) 2-&32' ;]=#= %-3,--*< .8 '( \#c7 +)% '2-) ()- 7-',-

C(, -:-,9 +%%&'&()+/ 7-',- &) 2-&32';@D %-3,--*< +* *2(B) &) e&3.,- "\+ ?-/(B#

@# H2- -06-8'&()* '( '2- 8-,7&''-% 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 6()',(/ /&*'-% &) 6/+.*- ]#= +?(:-

+88/9#

D# $ ?.&/%&)3 '2+' %(-* )(' 6(78/9 B&'2 '2&* 6()',(/ &* + %&*6,-'&()+,9 +6'&:&'9#

X.I:7, [ =P2T !31,7021.A, E,.IE1 .0 7,321.50 15 >5:0/27S

D# H2- +/'-,)+'&:- 2-&32' &) ,-/+'&() '( ?(.)%+,9 ,./- %(-* )(' +88/9 '( -0&*'&)3 (, 8,(8(*-% &)'-,)+/

*&'- ?(.)%+,&-* B&'2&) +) +88/&6+'&() +,-+#

Q


41/113

41

N+1- =`7

O(+*'+/ 8,('-6'&() 9+,% "`7S (, +* ('2-,B&*- *8-6&C&-% &) +88-)%&0 \#]

Q


42/113

42

?#+ 4# $' /-+*' D` 8-, 6-)' (C '2- C,()' 9+,% 7.*' 6(78,&*- /+)%*6+8-% +,-+#

=# e(, '2- 8.,8(*- (C '2&* ,./-S '2- )-' *&'- +,-+ B&// ?- 6+/6./+'-% () '2- ?+*&* (C '2- +88/&6+'&() +,-+

B&// ?- ',-+'-% +* '2- *&'- +,-+#

Q


43/113

43

6# (, (:-,/+8 B&'2 )(' -0'-)% (:-, +) (.'/((1 *8+6-* (, (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- ,-E.&,-% ?9 +)('2-,

%B-//&)3#

c# $) (.'/((1 *8+6- +' 3,(.)% C/((, /-:-/ C,(7 + 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7 7+9 ?- ,-%.6-% '( @7 %--8 &C

8,&:+69 '( +%T+6-)' %B-//&)3* &* 8,(:&%-% ?9 C-)6&)3 +' /-+*' "#\7 &) 2-&32'#

X.I:7, \ =QT +,^:.7,/ 5:13559 -62@,

Q


44/113

44

@# H2&* ,./- %(-* )(' +88/9 '( %-:-/(87-)' (88(*&'- '2- C&,*' D7 (C + ?.&/%&)3 B2&62 C+6-* '2- *',--'S

7-+*.,-% C,(7 '2- C,()' 6(,)-, (C '2- ?.&/%&)3#

"2>3, PT %2O.8:8 E,.IE1 5D 1E21 6271 5D 2 >:.3/.0I W.1E.0 2 -.1, [email protected] 2 [email protected] 3.A.0I 7558 57

>,/7558 W.0/5W W.1E.0 1E, -28, 2 -.1,

;.-120@, 5D 1E, >:.3/.0I D758

1E, 327I,-1 [email protected] 3.A.0I

7558_ 3.A.0I`/.0.0I 7558 57

20S >,/7558 W.0/5W aOb

%2O.8:8 E,.IE1 5D 1E,

>:.3/.0I /,D.0,/ 6571.50 5D

W233 5665-.1, 20 ./,01.D.,/

W.0/5W

H,0I1E 5D W233 7,-17.@1,/ .D NN

/,I7,, 27@ .- 6,76,0/.@:327 15

W.0/5W aSb a75:0/,/b

"#`7 4#`7 "#`7

"#D7 =#`7 "#D7

4#`7 @#`7 4#`7

4#D7 D#`7 4#D7

4#]7 D#@7 4#]7

=#`7 \#`7 =#`7

=#D7 ]#`7 =#D7

@#`7 ^#`7 @#`7

@#D7 c#`7 @#D7

X.I:7,- =[ 20/ =\T +,^:.7,/ -,1>2@9- D57 /2S3.IE1






Comment [218]: Figures amended for clarity (inresponse to primary evidence from Cowie Street

Investments and others)


45/113

45

Q,1W,,0 >:.3/.0I- W.1E.0 2 -.1,

K.,8(*-L ,-E.&,- ,-+*()+?/- *-8+,+'&() ?-'B--) ?.&/%&)3* () '2- *+7- *&'- '( 7+)+3- %(7&)+)6-S

8,(:&%- +66-** '( %+9/&32' +)% )+'.,+/ :-)'&/+'&()#

"# 5.&/%&)3* 7.*' ?- *-8+,+'-% B2-,- '2- 2+?&'+?/- ,((7 (C + %B-//&)3 2+* B&)%(B* (, ?+/6()&-*

'2+' C+6- (.' '( '2- B+// (C +)('2-, ?.&/%&)3 () '2- *+7- *&'- ;'2- C+6&)3 B+//


46/113

46

"# $ %B-//&)3 +' 3,(.)% /-:-/ 7.*' 2+:- +) (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- 7-+*.,&)3 +' /-+*' @`7d '2+'L

+# &* C,-- (C ?.&/%&)3*S 8+,1&)3 *8+6-*S *-,:&6&)3 +)% 7+)(-.:,&)3 +,-+*

?# -06/.%-* +)9 +,-+ B&'2 + %&7-)*&() /-** '2+) "7#

4"#h2-,- +$ %B-//&)3 2+* '2- 8,&)6&8+/ /&:&)3 ,((7 +' 3,(.)% C/((, /-:-/S 8+,' (C '2- ,-E.&,-% 7.*'

2+:- +) (.'%((, /&:&)3 *8+6- 7.*' ?- '2+' &* +?/- '

059-063 council - (nick roberts) _ planning _ attachment a - marked-up version - rebuttal

Documents