01-12 e 1030 - grips final.pdf · new measurement index for advancing research capability ......
TRANSCRIPT
SciREX CenterNational Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
7-22-1, Roppongi, Minato-ku, Tokyo, JAPAN 106 -8677
E-mail : [email protected]
SciREX CenterNational Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
SciREX Program Portal Site
https: //scirex.grips.ac.jp/en/
B r i d g i n g
P o l i c y a nd S c i enc e
Collaboration/Co-evolution
Policy Needs
Evidence/Policy Options
DevelopmentDevelopmentEvolutionEvolution Policy Science
MISSION
BACKGROUND
ACTIVITIES
Collects and analyzes data and information to ultimately establish
policies.
DATA COLLECTION
Currently conducts 6 research projects for 2 years from 2019 based on the policymakers’ policy needs and makes the research to be reflected on actual evidence-based
policies.
RESEARCH
Supports such projects that develop new indexes, analytic methodologies, models,
data-systematization tools that contribute to making
evidence-based STI policies.
FUNDING
SciREX DOES
Collaborates with 5 SciREX member centers
(6 universities) each of which carries its own unique
curriculum to train future STI policymakers and researchers.
EDUCATION
Provides networking opportunities for
stakeholders through seminars, workshops, and
symposia.
NETWORKING
1 Bridges the “Policy Formation” and “Policy Research”
to have them co-evolve.
2 Develops the methodologies that contribute to STI policy formation
as well as integrates STI-related evidences.
3 Provides opportunities for all the stakeholders
to discuss policy issues.
1 Acts as the HUB of the 5 SciREX program member centers (6 universities).
2 Develops the methodologies for policy formation and integrates STI-related evidences.
3 Facilitates outreach and publication activities.
The development of the SciREX program called for an establishment of its
Center that coordinates all the SciREX activities among the member
centers and stakeholders, and reflects the activity results on the
government policies. The Center was thus set up in 2014 at the National
Graduate Institute for Policy Studies (GRIPS).
Science of Science PolicySciREX (Science for RE-designing Science, Technology and Innovation
Policy) program is a Japanese Government program that analyzes
various economic and social issues and explores the best practices of
evidence-based science policy. Established in 2011, the program is
funded by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and
Technology (MEXT).
S C I E N C E F O R R E - D E S I G N I N G S C I E N C E , T E C H N O L O G Y A N D I N N O V A T I O N P O L I C Y 32
@University of Tokyo
The SciREX program is carried out at 5 member
centers (University of Tokyo, Hitotsubashi University,
Osaka/Kyoto Universities, Kyushu University and
GRIPS) in collaboration with three science policy
research institutions (NISTEP, RESTEX, and CRDS),
STI ministries, politicians, industries, and citizens.
The SciREX Center at GRIPS acts as the HUB of all of
these entities to coordinate all of their activities.
SciREX Center DOES
Coordinate SciREX activities
6 research projects are carried out (2019-2020) based on
the policymakers’ policy needs:
To bridge the SciREX program results with the
policymakers, the SciREX Center provides many
opportunities for the stakeholders to discuss
various issues. The Center also issues policy
recommendations, working papers, SciREX
portal site, and web magazines.
1
2
3
4
5
6
Research
Public Relations and Outreach SciREX Program Member Centers:
Politics, Ministries and Agencies, Local Governments
SciREX Program Liaison
Internship
Hands-on Experience
Basic research & Human Resources Development
In collaboration with:
Industries
NPOs
NGOs
Citizens
Networking-Seminars-Summer Camps-Workshops-Symposia
Education -Core contents for “Science of Science Policy” -Training for administrators
Sharing Research Results by: -Policy proposals -Working papers -SciREX portal -Web magazines
Researchinstitutions
and Universities
“Foresight and Impact Analysis Method” in emerging and
interdisciplinary science fields and network making
Analysis of the mechanism for strengthening the base for creating innovation
by use of SciREX Policymaking Intelligent Assistance System (SPIAS)
Establishment of innovation ecosystem that meets the basic, applied,
and commercialization research in medical field
New measurement index for advancing research capability
Effective use and implementation of research results in seismic field
“Disruptive inclusive innovation” that contributes to attaining
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). (*for 2019)
SciREX Center
in the Context of
SciREX Program
@Hitotsubashi University
@Kyushu University
@Osaka and Kyoto Universities@Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
54
76
The importance of emerging and interdisciplinary fields
is increasingly recognized both in and outside of Japan.
However, its social and economic impacts are not
sufficiently understood. To multifacetedly grasp
foreseeable impacts, we are developing the “Foresight
and Impact Analysis Method” that is used in Foresight
activities into a method that can be applied for
individual cases and purposes. We are also going to test
prototypes to apply them to real policymaking
processes, and form networks between researchers
and policymakers.
This project analyzes the data for research funds and research results
to clarify the factors that affect the research capabilities and the
mechanisms. Based on the analyses, we examine the human
resources diversity and mobility, international cooperative research,
joint use of research facilities to see whether the policies on them
are designed to advance the research capabilities. The analyses use
the SciREX Policymaking Intelligent Assistance System (SPIAS) that
was developed in cooperation with related organizations, including
JST, CRDS, and NISTEP. This project also explores, through close
discussions with government administrators, an effective use of
SPIAS that contributes to making evidence-based policies
We examine afresh the definition and index of university ‘research
capabilities.’ In addition to examining the index for quantity,
quality and impact of research results suitable to each academic
field, we make system-level measurements as to how each
university functions in the whole picture of the academic sector.
To cover all of these, we develop a new measurement index and
actually conduct analyses.
This project examines a new system design to effectively and efficiently
promote basic, applied and commercialization research in life science
field. We encourage companies to make active commitment from the
early stage of R&D. We also aim to clarify the conditions and methods for
improving performance of the transformational (from basic to clinical)
research at universities and academic research organizations (ARO) that
lead clinical research, focusing on the financial aspect.
To make good use of the results of seismic and disaster prevention research,
we sort out what the administration can do and cannot, and the needs for
research based on interviews and surveys to the related people. We also
facilitate workshops and analyze the domestic and overseas cases,
through which we will propose such policies
that match the research and needs.
‘Disruptive Inclusive Innovation’ uses technologies and business models to solve social issues,
and impacts the society through innovation. We will focus the industries active not only in
Japan and other developed countries, but also in developing countries and the venture
company activities in emerging countries, and examine the role of innovation and the policy
support system to attain SDGs.
Project Leaders:
Analysis of the Mechanism for Strengthening the Base for Creating Innovations by use of SciREX Policymaking Intelligent Assistance System (SPIAS)
Study on the Establishment of Innovation Ecosystem that Meets the Basic, Applied, and Commercialization Research in Medical Field
Development of New Measurement Index for Advancing Research Capability
Examination of “Foresight and Impact Analysis Method” in Emerging and Interdisciplinary Science Fields and Formation of Networks
Study on the Effective Use and Implementation of Research Results in Seismic Field
‘Disruptive Inclusive Innovation’ that contributes to attaining Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (*2019)
11
2
3 4
5
6
6 Research Projects (2019-2020) The SciREX Center currently carries out 6 research projects based on
the policymakers’ policy needs. Tackling these projects is one of the
challenges of “co-evolution” of the researchers and the policymakers.
This co-evolution effort enhances SciREX program to develop and
makes the community further matured.
Tateo ARIMOTO, GRIPS Adjunct ProfessorHideyuki HIRAKAWA, Professor, Osaka University CO Design Center
Project Leader:
Kenta IKEUCHI, SciREX Center Affiliated Fellow RIETI Researcher
Project Leader:
Koichi SUMIKURA, GRIPS Professor
Project Leader:
Takayuki HAYASHI, GRIPS Professor
Project Leader:
So MORIKAWA, SciREX Center Affiliated Fellow Lecturer, Graduate School of
Engineering, University of Tokyo
Project Leader:
Michiko IIZUKA, GRIPS Professor
Research at SciREX Center
co-evolutionview
governance
population
mathematical
service
sta
rt
wri
te
administrative
financial
complex
professional
exercise
climate
me
asu
re
political
studyquantitative
acquire
eff
ec
t
ma
in
lead
soc
iety
real
public
po
sitio
n
cu
rre
nt
soc
iety
cu
rre
nt
soc
iety
medium
resource
strategy
role
fin
al ide
ntify
po
ssib
le
en
d
basic
relations
evolutionrelations
evolution
be
st
trend
increase
include
valu
e
ba
sis
state
na
ture
like
govern
follow
aff
ec
t
economic
aim
law
range
conflict
energy cre
ati
on
ch
an
ge
innovativemeasurement natural
pollution
government
exp
lain
wo
rk
pro
pe
rty
introduce
un
de
rlie
poverty
problem
inte
rna
tio
na
l
action
exist
appropriate
risk
area
capacity
technologyrange
technologyrangemeasurement
technologymeasurement
bio
eth
ics
standard
loo
k
lea
rn
conduct
model
theme grouppe
rfo
rma
nc
e
enable
function
soc
iety
function
soc
iety
analyze
trade
firm
practical
ed
uc
atio
n
smes loc
al
literature
global
broad
analytical
sub
jec
t
historytechnology
historytechnology
masterproblem
masterproblemp
oin
t
deal
know
inte
rac
tio
n
design
presentation
ca
seinn
ova
tio
n
discussion
req
uir
em
en
t
insurance
goal
available
address
company
outline
support
document
co
st
relevantmo
de
rn
ability long
create
cri
tic
al
management
aff
ec
t
management
aff
ec
t
engage
purpose
carepolicymathematical
policymathematical
function
policyfunction
sector
file
statistics
mechanism
policymechanism
policyintroduction
type
ip
network
actor
administration
contemporary
dig
ita
l
ethics
co
mm
un
ica
tio
n
income
readlife
regard
objective
prerequisite
focus
concerndomestic
dra
w
theory
gra
nt
school
deepen
form
insight
ess
en
tia
l
instrument
de
cis
ion
preparation
business
key
wa
ys
open
speaker
historical
relate
waypresentation
waypresentation
exp
ec
t
activity
challenge
implication
analyse
differentinfluence
sti
ye
ars
legal
impactinstitutional
resu
lt
creativity
fund
potential
discipline
finance
tool
question
transportation
accord
sustainability
need
dis
ea
se
require
larg
e
trademark
ce
rta
in context
critically
fie
ld
ne
ce
ssa
ry
gre
at
analysis
wo
rk
analysis
wo
rk preparationanalysis
preparation
overview
programanalyze
programanalyze
growthpatent
ma
rke
t
approachformal
seminar
pa
rtic
ipa
nt
da
ta
bring
developliterature
developliterature
non
do
ma
in
production
term
integration
condition
nu
mb
er
timemanagementtimemanagement
cre
dit
survey
situation
begin
involve
cooperation
rep
ly
environment
cover
microeconomics
reg
ion
major
labor
task
technologytask
technology
mean
regulatory
cla
ss manage
de
ba
te
analysis
de
ba
te
analysis
less
on
po
we
r
pla
ce
scientist
project
intellectual
contribution
evidence
search
ordertea
ch
quality
variety
lecture
benefit
foundation structure
provide
globalization
specifically
sethelp
conservation
asp
ec
t topic
pla
n
offer
application
source
co
re
issue
ma
ke
ab
le
rig
ht
component
prepare
be
ha
vio
r
skillgrowth
skillgrowth
advance
internet
urban
ict
co
ntr
ol
enterprisedevelop
enterprisedevelop
administrator
researchergovernment
collaborate
8 9
The camp is annually held with a theme for the year. It is a
training opportunity for the participants with various
backgrounds to try to make evidence-based policies.
SciREX Summer Camp
Internship
Undergrad and graduate students can participate in the
SciREX program as interns to enhance their understanding on
policy research by actually putting hands on the SciREX work.
SciREX Core Contents
Policy Liaison members (incumbent administrators) are
forming networks. By participating in the SciREX research
projects and representing the administrators’ needs, they try
to match the administrators’ needs and research seeds.
Policy Liaison (coordinators)
International Network
SciREX Seminars
Seminars are held once a month in the neighborhood of the
government organizations in Tokyo. It provides an opportunity
for the SciREX projects to make public the progress of their
research and for the researchers and administrators to
exchange views.
The SciREX Center organizes and holds international STI policy-related activities.
Examples are:
The SciREX Center co-organized the 3rd conference of the International
Network for Government Science Advice (INGSA) held at GRIPS in 2018.
Policy experts, practitioners and faculty members from more than 50
countries discussed scientific advice from various viewpoints.
INGSA-2018
The SciREX Center held the DII workshop and symposium at GRIPS.
The discussions focused on the innovations to solve the issues to attain
SDGs, comprehensive S&T for SDGs, scaling up the startups to solve
social issues, and ind-univ-gov. partnership for SDGs.
Disruptive Inclusive Innovation (DII)
Networking
2018 theme: STI policies and society in 2030
Discussion Groups:
Day1:Roundtable
Pioneer beyond country bordersDII and Ventures
Day2:Symposium
DII for accelerating global impact and attaining SDGs
The SciREX Center produced the core contents to be used
in the class of “Science of Science Policy.” The contents meet the needs
of students, young and mid-career administrators, and funding agency staff.
They can be obtained on the SciREX Center portal site.
To Accelerate Global Impact and Attaining SDGs
Training for Early-career Administrators
The SciREX Center provides training sessions to the early-career
government administrators to enhance their abilities to plan and
establish STI policies. The administrators come up with policy
proposals through 2-day class work followed by a 2-day workshop.
STI Dynamics
STI Governance & Policy Formation
ProcessSTI and Society
Evaluation of STI policies’ Social & Economic Impact History & Overseas
Information of STI policies
56 students and 92 faculty members and related organization members
participated in the Summer Camp-2018.
https://scirex-core.grips.ac. jp/ (in Japanese)
STI Dynamics
SciREX ActivitiesCo-evolution Brought by Researchers and Policymakers
The SciREX Center is the Core Center to enhance co-evolutionary
relationship between the SciREX researchers and the government
administrators. The Center holds various activities where the
researchers and the government administrators work together to
exercise evidence-based policymaking.
The 8th S&T Basic Plan
Universities
Energy
Space
Medical care
ELSI
Child abuse
SDGs
Data-driven policymaking
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2018 Topic:
Science Advice in a Changing World
Sub topics:
- Scientific advise in a changing era
- SDGs and scientific advise
- Future of scientific advice
- Issues for specific cases
Core Contents
2Chapter
1Chapter
3Chapter
4Chapter
5Chapter
East Asia and their politics; Formerly GRIPS President
SciREX Center DirectorProfessor Emeritus, GRIPSChancellor, Prefectural University of Kumamoto
Takashi SHIRAISHI
Science and Industrial Technology Policy, Public Policy, S&T & Diplomacy
SciREX Center Deputy DirectorExecutive Advisor to GRIPS President, Adjunct Professor, GRIPSPresident, Ocean Policy Research Inst., Sasakawa Peace Foundation
Atsushi SUNAMI
S&T Policy, R&D Funding System
SciREX Center Deputy DirectorAdjunct Professor, GRIPSSenior CRDS FellowVice Director, Nat. Inst. for Advanced Studies
Tateo ARIMOTO
Policies for intellectual Property, STI, Life Science; Current research includes innovation ecosystem establishment in medical fields.
Professor, GRIPS
Koichi SUMIKURA
S&T policy, Scientometrics, Higher-education policy, Evaluation; Current research includes research activities at universities and public institutions.
SciREX Center Deputy DirectorProfessor, GRIPS
Takayuki HAYASHIi
Analysis of R&D, innovation and productivity; Current research includes establishment of data platform to know R&D results qualitatively and quantitatively.
SciREX Affiliated FellowRIETI Researcher
Kenta IKEUCHI
Senior Executive Fellow, CRDS
Hiroyuki YOSHIKAWA Tatsuo OYAMA
STI policy; Involved in SciREX Center management; Current research is on Foresight and impact analysis method.
SciREX Progam Specialist
Asako OKAMURA
Management of R&D programs; Involved in SciREX Center management; Current research is on R&D promotion through cooperation with stakeholders, and evaluation of research.
SciREX Program Specialist
Nika ANDO
Professor Emeritus, GRIPS
Adjunct Professor, GRIPS Professor Emeritus, Keio Univ.
Masahiro KURODA Adjunct Professor, GRIPSProfessor, Tsuda Univ.
Akira MORITA
Current job includes accounting and general affairs of the SciREX Center.
SciREX Program Specialist
Saki HARUYAMA
10 11
Public administration, policy studies; Current research includes data and ICT technologies in public policies, role of academic research and use of them in forming policies.
SciREX Affiliated FellowLecturer, Graduate School of Engineering, Univ. of Tokyo
So MORIKAWA
Labor Law; Involved in SciREX Center management; Current research is on R&D-type venture support policies and inclusive innovation.
SciREX Program Specialist
Izumi SUZUKI
Science Communication: Involved in SciREX Center management; Current research is on improvement of policy formation process.
SciREX Program Specialist
Noel KIKUCHI
Advisors
Policy and ScienceTo BridgeSciREX Center Members
SciREX Center is staffed by members of expertise in various fields.
SciREX research activities are carried out by incorporating their knowledge.
Also, in cooperation with various stakeholders, the SciREX projects are
enhanced to exercise evidence-based policies that are critical in the future.
STI policy in developing and emerging countries; Current research includes inclusive innovation and STI policies to attain SDGs.
Professor, GRIPS
Michiko IIZUKA
Management of Technology; Current research is to establish data platform to know STI policy-driven R&D results quantitatively and qualitatively and case study on star scientists.
SciREX Program Specialist
Tatsuo SASAKI
As of April 2019