000001

000002

000003

000004

000005

000006

000007

000008

000009

000010

000011

000012

000013

000014

000015

000016

( G( 6. Ma Properties harasses us with notices demanding that we pay a 10% late fee for the times that

our rerithas been late. We have provided Ma Properties with information about the late fee

clause and California Law and he refuses to listen to it. His late fee clause is illegal because it

both contains a pre-determined fee and is so high that it is punitive in nature. For example, for

being two days late he is attempting to charge us $169.00, which far exceeds the 10% annual

rate permitted by California law. While we do regret ever being late paying rent, Alicia and Ihave gone through extraordinary hardship at times. In spite of the hardship that we have gone

through, out tent has never been mote than 5 days late, and most times when paid late wasonly one or two days late. Ma Properties has contributed to that hardship by lying aboutpromised facilities, using a "bait and switch" technique to get us to give them a deposit two

times larger than the one month his ad stated was required, and by committing breaches of thelease contract including the implied warranty of habitability and maintaining a reasonabiy

rodent proof building, as there have been many pest infiltrations into the building's basement

that Ma Properties has done nothing to abate. We simply ask that you help clarify who is correctin this matter.

To summarize, we are asking for immediate return of $1200.00 of our original $2700.00 security deposit

plus a permanent reduction in rent totaling $41.00. We are also asking for a temporary one-year reduction of rent of $36.00 per month to compensate us for the fact that this apartment, which was

advertised as laundry-ready, was not laundry ready until over three months after we moved in, and only

aftet we paid a plum bet $350.00 to do wotk which Ma Properties should have paid for. Also whatever value you would assign to the deplorable way that Ma Properties has treated us.

000017

000018

000019

000020

000021

000022

000023

000024

000025

000026

000027

000028

000029

000030

000031

000032

000033

000034

000035

000036

000037

000038

000039

000040

000041

000042

000043

000044

000045

000046

000047

000048

000049

000050

000051

000052

000053

000054

000055

000056

000057

000058

000059

000060

000061

000062

000063

000064

000065

000066

000067

000068

000069

000070

000071

000072

000073

000074

000075

000076

000077

000078

000079

000080

000081

000082

000083

000084

000085

000086

000087

000088

000089

000090

000091

000092

000093

000094

000095

000096

000097

000098

000099

000100

000101

000102

000103

000104

000105

000106

000107

000108

000109

000110

000111

000112

000113

000114

000115

000116

000117

000118

000119

000120

000121

000122

000123

000124

000125

000126

000127

000128

000129

000130

000131

000132

000133

000134

000135

000136

000137

000138

000139

000140

000141

000142

000143

000144

000145

000146

000147

000148

PROOF OF SERVICE Case Number L16-0094

I am a resident of the State of California at least eighteen years of age. I am not a party to the Residential Rent Adjustment Program ,case listed above. I am employed in Alameda County, California. My business address is 250 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, Suite 5313, 5th Floor, Oakland, California 94612.

Today, I served the attached documents listed below by placing a true copy of it in a sealed envelope in a City of Oakland mail collection receptacle for mailing on the below date at 250 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, Suite 5313, 5th Floor, Oakland, California, addressed to:

Documents Included Order

Owner William Wiebe 278 Connecticut St San Francisco, CA 94107

Tenants Alisa Highfill 3515 Brighton Ave #1 Oakland, CA 94602

Bernadette Quattrone 3515 Brighton Ave #1 Oakland, CA 94602

Collin Quillian 3515 Brighton Ave #1 Oakland, CA 94602

Marvin Gleaton 3515 Brighton Ave #2 Oakland, CA 94602

Steve Arnwine 3515 Brighton Ave #3 Oakland, CA 94602

Taylor Campion 3515 Brighton Ave #3 Oakland, CA 94602

I am readily familiar with the City of Oakland's practice of collection and processing correspondence for mailing. Under that practice an envelope placed in the mail collection receptacle described above would be deposited in the United States mail with the U.S. Postal Service on that same day with first class postage thereon fully prepaid in the ordinary course of business.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the above is true and correct. Executed on July 1 7, 2018 in Oakland, CA.

000149