n r , A r l x , r ' r . l , , , t i ' t : : r ' r i i t . : . [ 4 0 n 9 ] ' l t 1i:,:['j,, r,.: .:,i__r,r: lt" :';g:. :,

Prn riilleif ,,''r,i r4f \rrrt!-:"P-l:

PeqeH3hc Ha Ha OHC ,,Aorcrop" npoQ. g-p apx. Aner<caugbp A. CnaeB

PEUEH3rrfl

npo$. r-p apx. Arexcangr,p !. Cnaen

AI{CEPTAUI4q 3A TPUAOBI{BAHE HA OBPA3OBATEJIHA

I{ HAyTIHA CTEIIEH *AOKTOP', HayrrHo HarpaBreHue:

5,7, "Apxurenrypa crpoHTeJrcrBo rr reoAe3Hftt, Hay'rua

clequaJrHocr "Opranusaqufl rr ylpaBJreHrre Ha crpourercrBoro"

Tena: ..PEHTAEI{JIHOCT HA CTPOIITEJIHI4TE PA3XONI,I B

3ABI{CI4MOCT OT fIAPAMETPI{TE HA

3ACTPOqBAHETO''

Ocnonanne 3a u3rorBqHe Ha peqeH3uqra: 3anoneA 586 or 11.07.2017

Ha Pexropa ua YACI

.{orcropanr: Xopcr Jluurrca, AoKTopaHT Ha caMocroqreJrHa [oAroroBKa

flpegcraneHara or Xopcr Jluurr<a ,qr.rcepraqrrr cbn:bpxa 277 crpauugu ocHoBeH TeKcr.

Cnopeg ,qaHHvre or aBTopa reKcrr.T BKJrloqBa o6qo I 89 uso6paxeHra.ara, KaKTo lr

c6lT,p)r(aHrre, 6rbnuorpatpru rz crrr4cr,K c r{3r]oJr3BaHure cxeMr4. H.flrou or pa:pa6orxure e

npeAcraBeHur rpyA ce ocHoBaBar Ha ny6ruraquu n AoKJraAr,r Ha aBTopa rro reMr4, cBT,p3aHr4 c

HacTorIqaTa TeMa Ha AI4cepTallr.rrrTa.

,{ucepraquonumr rpyA pa3BHT B ner qacrrr. Tpy,qrr 3arroqBa c yBo,qHa qacr, Ko-sro

o6ocHoBaBa aKTy,ulHocrra Iz neo6xoAuuocrra or npoyqBaHero r.I HefoBoro 3HarleHr4e u

Qoplryrupa ueJrure 14 3aAarrr.rre Ha u3cJre.uBaHe, o6erra n npelMera Ha aHaJrr43, aBTopcKara

Te3a, a cbrrlo u lrs6panara MeroArrKa. Creasa o6ua.racr, Korro u3Jrafa o6uara HacoKa u

nJIaHa Ha rrpoyqBaHe. Tperara uacr ugeHruQuqupa peneBaHTHure 3a nnaHr.rpauero flaxroplt

Ha lrKoHoMl4qecrara etfexrunHocr. 9ere'sprara qacr e npoeKTHa lr onr4cBa eMnupttqHoro

Ir3cJIeABaHe, Koero aHaiur3upa uarqa6Hu-r yp6aunclrven npoexr "3e:reH rleHrr,p ,rllrHq".

Har<parxo e npelcraBeH xo,ua Ha pa3pa6orBaHero Ha ro3r,r npoeKT or geQuHr.rpaHero Ha

Or:

Ornocno:

PeqeH3he Ha Ahcepraqhq 3a nphAo6hBaHe Ha OHC ,,AoKrop" npoh. B-p apx. AreKCaHAbp A. CnaeB

HeroBI{Te uenu u ca onucaHlt cfpa,qr.rTe npeAMeT Ha aHaJII,I3a, KaKTO }r yCTaHOBeHIITe

xapaKTepr{cltKr{ r,{ rroKa3areJrr,r. Tpygr,r 3aBbprxBa c r{acr, Korro o6o6rqasa pe3yJrrarxre or

I43CJIeIBaHeTO V ITpaBV CrbOTBeTHr4 lt3BOIr4 I4 npefiOpbKr.r 3a IIpaKTUKaTa Ha I]JIaHIIpaHe I{

npoeKTr4paHe. B ragu qacr ca rocoqeHr4 rr nprrHocrrre Ha A ceprarlu.flTa.

Xopcr Jluura e r43nor3BaJr 57 uayunu r{3ToqHuKa (xypna,ur, KHr.rrrr, lrHTepHer

u3ToqHurlr.r u IoKJraAr,r or r,r3crenBaHr4r) :a reopernvHara qacr Ha cBorra Auceprarlur.

Orgeruo. 3a eMnupuqHoro r.r3cJreABaHe e u3rroJr3BaJr 8 4pyrn r43TorrHr4ra - rry6luuHo

Htull4rrHrr npoyqBaHr4r Ha Apyru rr3cJre.qoBareJrr4. Karo cson ny6luraqun, cBbp3aHr{ c reMara

Ha Anceprauxrra, Jlurura e nocoqlrJr ABe cBorr pa:pa6orrur: npr4Hoc Kr,M u34aHue Ha

Ir3AarencrBo Tpayuep or 2013 u ysacrue n ron$epeuquq Informatics, Geoinformatics and

Remote Sensing, Corfux, 2013. lloco.rlar e cr,I{o }r II4nJroMHara cu pa6ora or Ynlraepcurer

lleororA (Dpauqeuc, I4uc6pyr, u Marlrcr:spcra pa6ora or Vencxus frosetf Illyunerep

l{ncruryr. Teslt gne pa6oru ue orroBaprr Ha r43ucKBaHr4rra :a rry6.nuraqllu 3a rrprrcl)KAaHe

na OHC ,,loxrop", Ho KaHAtrAartT e npeAnorrorJr Ha BHrrMaHrrero Ha )r(ypnro clrqo rr

AoKna,qrrre crr npeiq Axa,qeuuqra 3a crporrreJrcrno u Llucwrryra no npo$ecrroHanHo

HaclpqaBaHe ua fopua Ancrpll.r u Penugr4oHHoro lpy)KecrBo ua Ancrpul y nepuoga 2012 -

2017, c noero r,r3r4cxBaHr{rra Ha ro3r,l xpurepufi ca yAoBJre'r'BopeHrz.

AHaru:rr ua ,{ucepraqraoHHr4rr rpyA no3BonqBa Ia ce HanpaB-sr crenHrrre lr3Bo.qr.r Bt,B

Bpb3Ka cbc cT,,qT,pxaHtteTo rr KaqecTBaTa Ha r{3cneABaHeTo:

I . Arrya,rnocr r,r 3HaqeHr4e na pa:pa6orrara

Axryamrocrra Ha pa:pa6ornara e cBbp3aHa c:bc cbBpeMeHHure npo6-rrevu Ha

pa3Bltrr.rero ua o6urasaHero, xr.rJrtru1Hlrre $opuu u AHeIrrHl[e peaJrHocrlt noJru r.uqccKr{,

LtKoHoMr.rqecKu n coqururHrr peaJrHocrn. 3saqenlrero ua pa:pa6orxara ce lbJrxtl Ha

Heo6xoguvocrra ,ubplr(aBHr.rre vHc'ru"rytfr4u Aa ocuryprr aneKBarHrr ycnoBtrr :a o6r{rasaHe

3a BCI4rrKlr tpa)KAaHri npr.r cbBpeMeHHlrTe ycJroBur Ha HapacHaJrr{ Bb3Mo)t(HocTr4 Ha

PeqeH3he Ha A cepraqhr 3a nphAo6hBaHe Ha OHC,,AoKrop" npob. A-p ap^. Ane^caH4bp A. Coaea

cTpouTeJIHuTe TexHoJIofuIt oT eAHa cTpaHa) a! oT lpyfa, Bce no-Bl4coKlrre u3ucKBaHut Ha

Bcr.rrrKLI coql{alrlHlt cJroeBe. Ba,ragcrr Me)KIy He[peKbcBatuo HapacrBa rl{Te Hy)K,qIr u

BIICOKIITe TeXHOJIO|I4Ii I43IICKBa OnTI,IMI43r.rpaHe Ha ITOCJIeAHI4Te I{ CI,OTBeTCTBaLUO

noBurrraBaHe Ha rrxHara erpexrunnocr.

2. IJer, 3aAaqn, o6err lr re3a Ha AllcepraulloHHoro t43cJIeABaHe

I{er Ha u:cre.qBaHero e Aa npoyqu Bpb3Kara MexAy, or eAHa crpaHa, nnaHupaHero Ha

xlrJrurrlHr4Te crpyKTypn Ha yp6auucruuHo Hr4Bo r.r nplr rrHBecrrrur4oHHoro npoeKTrrpaHe r{, or

Apyra cTpaHa, pa3xoAHTe I]pn It3[T,JrHeHrre Ha cTporrTeJIcTBoTo r4 npu eKcnloaTal\LrflTa v, Ha

Ta3I4 OCHOBa, Aa Ce npeAnOXaT IrHAr4KaTOpI{ 3a OIIeHKa Ha npOeICI4Te.

O6ercr sa poyqBaHero ca )KIrJrI{IrIHrrre crpaAl.{ or pa3nltrrHu Nulltqnu Qopltu

(xoplrgopnu u cexquouHu) r.{ c pa3JruqeH 6poii Nr.r;utrqa Ha erarK or pa3nr4qHl{ Tunonofuu

(4nycrafiHrz, rpucraituu u verupracrafinu). Kourperno eMnI4pLIrIHoro LI3creABaHe o6xeaqa

crpa,qr4Te or ,,3e.nen qeurr,p ,rluHq".

Tesara Ha r{3cne,qBaHero e, qe flJlaHlzpaHero Ha )KIrnDulHIrre crpyKTypl4 Ha

yp6aHucru.rHo HlrBo rr, orqe floBeqe, r{HBecrI4III4oHHoro npoeKTnpaHe I4Mar KJrIoqoBo

3HaqeHrre sa e$exrueuocrra Ha xr{nuulHoro crpol4TeJrcrBo BbB BcurrKI4Te fi rfopuu. 3a

u3MepBaHe Ha ra3r4 erferrunHocr Mofar Aa 6rAar cbsAa.qeHl4 lIHcrpyMeHTn r4 I4Hrr{Karopn rI

ToBa Iqe AoBeAe Io 3HaqI4TeJrHo roBI4IxaBaHe Ha BcuqKu pa3rJIexAaHIr QopMI4 Ha

etperrunnocr. OcnosHl4.gr I43cJreAoBareJrcKrI Bbnpoc e: Moxe JII{ r.Ir(oHoMl4rlecKara

penra6urHocr Ha AaAeHa apxrrreKTypHa xonqen{uq/ npoeKTaHTcKrr no.4xo,4 Aa ce

aprr4KyJrnpa qpe3 r.{.qeanHr.r ranr.r pe$epenrHrr crofiHocr}r, uru qpe3 ctnocraBKa na crofinocrlt

or Apyrr{ npoerru?

3. Mero4onou4q 14 fiocre,uoBarellHocr Ha lt3creABaHero

lncepraquonuara pa:pa6orra aHu 43vpa e$exrunnocrra Ha xlrJrl4tqHara :acrpofira n

ner pa3rrrrrHu @opuu: E$exrunuocr Ha 3acrpoqBaHero, E$errunHocr Ha xlrJrlrtqero (lo

PeqeH3r,re Ha Ahcepraqrlg 3a nphAo6L4BaHe Ha OHC ,,AoKrop" npob. A-p ap\. Are^caH,qbp n. CtaeB

npaBr{reH npeBoA cnopeA MeH 6r.1 6un ESerrr.rnuocr Ha rr.rrroBere xulurqa./xunuulHara

runolorux) E$exrunHocr Ha nroulra, EQexrnnuocr Ha BT,HrrrHara o6lrusxa ra Eser11reHocr

Ha feoMeTpuqTa.

MeroAo:rorrEqra e pa3yMHo nocrpoeHa. I4z6pauvne MeronolrornqHu noIXoAr4 ca crpol.o

NOIIIqHII KATO U'JIO CT,OTBETCTBAT Ha rlenTa Ha ,4rrcepTarltroHHoTo

npoyvnaHe.MeronoJlorl4qHara rlocJre.qoBarerHocr BKJrrorrBa aHaJrI3 Ha yp6auucruuulrre

cTpyKrypl4 I{ I43CJIeABaHe Ha TIrnOJrOf HrrHaTa CTpyKTypa Ha )ro{nuqaTa. aHarru3 Ha BJrr4rHueTo

Ha 6a,ranca Ha nnouure (no 6r.rrrapcxara repMtrHoJrorur: xr4nr4luHr4, lloJle3Hrl,

KoMyHnKarrr.roHHrr rz r<oucrpyxrunnu) BT,pxy o6rqara e@errunuocr, a*ufir3 Ha

etperrunnocrra Ha BbHIrIHara o6eusra u feoMerprrJlTa Ha piBJrI,IrrHrz tf opull. Tegu analugu ca

HanpaBeHI'I nT'pBo Ha TeopeTl4qHo Ir HayqHo-rIpI,IIoxHo HI{BO' a cJIeA ToBa I{HIIrKaToplITe ca

TecrBaHu Ha eMnl4plrqHo HI4BO - nptr ll3cne.qBaHgro Ha rroKa3arenr{Te Ha sacrpofixara r.t

crpa.Ul4Te Ha ,,3e:ren qeurup Jluuq".

4. fiucepraguoHHo [poyqBaHe - EunuplruHa vacr

O6exr Ha eMnrrpr.rrrHoro npoyqBaHe e yp6aHlrcrlr.runr npoerr/xulu lHu_s KoMrtreKc

,,3elen qeHmp Jlznq", xofiro ce peurrlr,upa Ha Mrcroro na 6unlrara Tonapua

xeJle3onbrHa r-apa Ha rpa4 Jlllnq, fopHa Ancrplra. O6rqara nJrolq, noAJrexaqa Ha

peKoHcrpyKUr4l (nonropno pa:wrrae/:acrpoxnaHe) o6xnarqa or<olo 87 xrzr. rs.A4. Tog[

xr4nr4rqHocrpor{TeJreH npoeKT ce cqr{Ta 3a e,4r.tH or saii-ro,reuzre raKuBa, pe4nr43r4paH}r B

rp. Jlunq, O6ercmr Ha eMnupurrHoro npoyrrBaHe e noAxoArrrl 3a rlenra, rri xaro clpaAur.e,

BKnIoqeHH n,,3eren qeump JIrzHq" ca npegcraenreJrHr{ 3a H.sKor4 or uafi-nolyLrlpun'r'e

)KI4JurrrIHr,r Qopuu (ropu4opHr{ u ,'ceKrluoHuu"l c [yHKToB era)IteH 4ocEn) n Ancrpul lr

Enpona, KaKTo 14 Ha cBeroBHo uzso. B roBa orHoIrIeHr.Ie, KaKTo I'r Karo IrocnenoBareJlHocr

HA AHaIII'i3A MeroAonofr4tra e npunoxeHa aAeKBarHo. B rpafiHa cMerKa pe3ynrarr{Te or

eMnI4pr4qHI4Te U3CrerBaHu.[ AoKiBBar reoperurrHl4Te B3atIMOBpS3Kr4 u re3ara Ha aBTopa

4

PeqeH3[q Ha Ahcepraqhg 3a np[Ao6 BaHe Ha OHC,,AoKrop" npoh. A-p apx. AreKcaHdbp A. CnaeB

orHocHo BruqHr4ero Ha rpaloycrpoiicrseHoro u r.rHBecrr.{Ut4oHHoro npoeKTlrpaHe Br,pxy

rlpoyqBaHI4Te rler Br.rAa e$errnnHocr Ha xI.IJrIrrqHr{Te cfpaAlr Ir KoMnneKcr4.

5. KpuruuHlr 6e,rexror

fk pnara Kpurr4rrHa 6elexra, MaKap lr Aa He e nafi-saNHa or Bc[qKn npnrnru, rpr6na

Aa 6t,1e HacoqeHa rrn ue4o6para e3rrroBa peAaKrllrr vru rfifircara Ha raKaBa. He crana 4yva

npocTo 3a HeToqHocTr4 B npeBoAa oT BTopocTeneHHo 3HaIIeHIIe, a 3a TaKI,IBa, KOI,ITO Ce

orpa3rBar Ha HayqHIlJI cMI4cBJr. Moxe 6rz Hafi-.f,eHo raKoBa Hec6orBercrBI4e e cMecBaHero Ha

noKa3areJII{Te 3a lr.[l,THocr rr r4HTeH3uBHocr Ha 3acrporBaHero. -f,euo, pasrpaul4qeHuero

MexAy ABara repMr4Ha, KaKBoro nua n 6r,lrapcKara npaKTr,rKa, He e npuclrrlo 3a

ancrpr.rficnara (rarro, nnpoveM, JrrrrcBa r.r B TepMrrHononlflTa B Apyrrr 3anaAHoenponeficxu

4rpNanu), Ho B Ancepraqrlrra HefoBara Jrunca Bo.U4 Ao cbrrlecrBeHr4 HercHorrl. llo,qo6Hrz

c;ra6ocrz B npeBoAa rrMa Ha peAr4ua Mecra B Ar{cepraur4rra.

Karo uaeHa MeroAoJIofLIqHa c;ra6ocr 6ux noco.rllr Helr3tcHrBaHero Ha orHorleHrrgro

Ha aHaJrrr 3r4paHure rrer nrl4a eQerrr.rnuocr K6M o6rqara e$exrunnocr na xpafruua [poAyKT -

xl4nr4rrlara rr )ro4Jrr4ruHara cpe4a. Hecruueuo eQexrunHocrra Ha npoeKTupaHero Ha

xl4nutqara I4 xIaJIHtuHara cpena rrMa pa3Hoo6pa:nu flpoqBneHut, Karo roJItMa qacr or rtx ca

cBT,p3aHI4 c apxurer(rypHo-$yurquoHarHrrre KaqecrBa na o6errare. Teglr Kaqecrsa ca s

nmou clyuaft ca [o-JrecHr4 3a oueHrBaHe (uanpuuep orHor eHuero Ha rroJre3Ha rlv o6rqa

nloq, pa:pa6oreHo B .qrrcepraguna), Ho B lpyrr4 ca rr3KJrroqr4TenHo rpyAHrr 3a onpeAenrHe

Ir cr{JIHo ce BJrrrrrr or nH.qr{Br4AyiurHr4Te npe.qnoqraranru (Hanpnnrep, QyurquoHilJrHoro

yno6crBo, Koero Moxe na e crporo uHAr{BHAyanHo, I4nIr B3ar4MoBpb3Kara Me)KAy rfyHr<r1ul u

ecrerzra). Pa:6upa ce,, nono6Hu oueHKu ca r43KJrroqurenHo rpyAHrr r,r B H.aKou cJrytrau -

HeBb3MoxHrr, Ho aBTopr,T 6u rpa6earo, nbpBo, Aa or.qa,qe Ha ro:lr npo6lertr Heo6xo,4nvoro

BHTTMaHIIe lt, BTOpO, KaTO Ii3'CHU TOBa npr{HTIUnHO OTHOrXeHr4e Ha TeOpeTLIqHO Hr.rBO, Aa Aa.qe

o6rqa npe4crana 3a Mrcroro r.r o6xsara Ha rr3cJreABaHr.rre rrer Br4,4a e$ercrueHocr :a o6ulara

(cyvapnara) eQerurnHocr. flo4o6Hn rr3cneABaHr.rr He ca u3KJrroqeHr4r B npaKTnrara, rtfi

PeqeH3h.q Ha Arlcepraqhe 3a npqAo6hBaHe Ha OHC ,,AoKrop" npoq. A p apx. AreKCaHAbp A. CtaeB

KaTO [a3apHI{tT ycnex Ha .qaAeH xr.rnuuleH npoeKT ce LIHAITKLIpa oT IIa3apHaTa r]eHa Ha

xrrJII4lIlHI4Te I{MOTI4 t4, CJIeAOBaTeIHO, na3apHaTa UeHa qeCTO Ce [pLIeMa KaTO ttHAUKaTOp 3a

o6rqara eOeKTLrBHocr, a qpe3 xeAoHI{qHI{ Mero.qr4 Ha aHaJIr43 Mo)Ke,qa ce orqere rp[Hoca Ha

pa3ruqHl4Te Saxropu (nanpuvep rbcrorara na o6urasaHe rrJrr4 orHorxeHr{ero nojre3Hrr KbM

KoMyHaKarlrrouHra n:rou1u) KtNr o6rqu.r na:apeu elpexr.

6. flocruNenr4r Ha v3cJrelBaHero

Bncora orIeHKa 3acJry)r(aBar peArrrla cblrlecrBeHr4 acrreKTu Ha u3cneABaHero. Hafi-

uanpeg 6nx nocorrr4Jr uz6pauara reMa Ha Ar4cepraqmra, Korro e uHTepecHa, aKTyaJrHa r4

naxHa. AxryarHocrra u BaxHocrra Ha reMara neqe 6sxa aKIIeHTr4paHI4 no-Hanpe.4 B Ta3I{

perIeH3ns.

[pyr acnerr Ha Ar4ceprarlr4oHHl4r rpyA, roiiro clegna Aa 6r1e oueHeH BrrcoKo, e

peanrl3r4paHara rscHa BpB3Ka MexAy reopr4rra u npaKTuKara. Ir1:c.ne4naHero rr3urno e

HacoqeHo rrv npo6reuu, Kor,rro r4Mar KJrroqoBo 3HaqeHlre 3a ynpaBJreHcKara rr collr4anHara

npaKTlrKa Ha MecrHr{Te opraHr4 Ha ynpaBJreHr4e, a cbrqo z xrrra npolpecuoHarHara npaKTuKa

Ha yp6auucrnre n npoeKraHTr4Te Ha BcuqKrr HrrBa or npoqecr.rre ua yp6anzcruuno u

rrHBecTItqtroHHo npoeKTI4paHe.

Ha rpero Mrcro, Ho He u no BD(Hocr, rpr6na 1a ce nolqeprae u:6opa Ha rcna

MeroAoJrorur Ha aHaJruga, Korro AaBa enHo3HaqHr4 14 HaAex.qHr4 pe3ynrarrz. Vz6pauvne

noKa3areJru Ha flerre rr3cJreABaHr,r nu4a elperrunHocr ca yAo6Ho cpeAcrBo 3a orIeHKa Ha

)K.IJIUITIHIIe npoeKTr4 rarro ua yp6aHr,rcrrzqHo HrrBo, TaKa rr Ha Hr4Boro Ha npoeKT]rpaHero Ha

oTAeJrHrrTe cfpaAr{.

OceeH rocoqeHrrre npeAlrMcrBa Ha MeroAoJrorurra, uz6pauute noKa3areJrrr 3a

eQerrlreHocr ce 6a:upar Ha .4aHHu, Kolrro ca necHo gocrtrrHlr 3a BclIqKI4 xunuIIIHt4

npoeKTI4, He3aBr4cr.rMo or fioplrara na co6creeHocr LIJIIT r43rIT,JtHI4TeJrr Ha npoeKTa.

Peqenann Ha Ahcepraqhr :a npr4o6neaxe Ha OHC.,AoKrop" npoh. A-p apx. AteKCaHAbp A. Cnaeq

7. llpenoprxr.r.

flpegnug HanpaBeHnre 6elexru, cBbp3aHr4 c Heo6xoAurr.rocrra Aa ce rgrronu Mtcroro

Ha BceKr,r or r,BcneABaHl.rre Br,rAoBe eQeKfuBuocr n o6qara./cyvapnara eQerruBHocr Ha

xLrJrr4rrlHure o6er:ru, rrpenopbqBaM Ha AoKTopaHTa B flo-Hararr,rr]Hara cv pa6ora Aa ce

KoHqeHTpr4pa rrMeHHo Brpxy ro3rr npo6JreM.

3AKJIIOqEHI4E

Ha ocnosaH[e Ha r,r3TbKHarr4Te B perleH3r4rra cro6paxeuur Morra oueuKa e, qe

paepa6orrara na Xopcr Jhalrra nprarexasa Heo6xoAr,rMr4Te KaqecrBa Ha ycflelreH

AucepraIII4oHeH Tpyn. Teuara e BaKHa 3a npaKTvrara Ha nraHr4paHe r,r [poeKTr.IpaHe r{ e

aAeKBarHo pa3Br4Ta B npeAcraBeHara AoKTopcKa 4ucepra:,1las, Ero sarqo B 3aKrloqeH[e

cqvraM, ue na Xopcr Jlurura caegna Aa ce npr4cbAr.r o6pasonarelnara u HayrrHa creneg

,{or<rop".

25.09.2017 npoQ. a-p apx. Alercang:sp,{. Cnaen: