faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$...

27

Upload: others

Post on 30-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

� ������������� ��������� ������������������

� ����� � �!���#"$���&%(')�*���,+��-%*���,.

/10325476989:<;�=5>@?7ABDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\F]<^SP<Z _3CFI`\LZ Kba1RJTXcdGJe Z TfR3INP<Z[G9GgKDBhGi_jZ[\

BhGi_jZ[\F]kcdl�mQnJo<pqo<]r^ts uvs ltswrx P<CFy<INZ P<zr{D|HW x Gi_jZ[\Fs C x |

GJP x} 0Q:<~D:<?769�h4��<�<:

BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJT�UXWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\F]r^SP<Z _3CFI`\LZ Kba1RJT��dR3P<Pl x CFPHGJ|<CFI`GJe e CFCt�g�J���j�r]jB���nJ�<p3pq�9�dR3P<P�]H�hCFINM1GJPja

WYe CFMOCFPH\Fs E<|<E<EkCg{D��Z ��Z�s |<P<Z ���kR3P<P�s x C

ujCFErKNCFM��kCFI�pg�j]H�J�3�Q�

�L���i� �k�g�`�J�b�v� �k�g�`���b�S�¡ ��V¢ �¡��£��b�<¤5�¡��¥F�  i¦��g�`�J�b�v�b Y§�� §�¨ �b�9©�ª«�F�i�b¨ ¨ �  i¦­¬k®b�¡ i�¡£�� �b�k�`¢r¯F®b�¡�J�b°D±[²7�b�i���  i¦�` i�´³kµi�i�J�V±·¶L¸¡¸¡¸Y¹·¹�ºk»g�¡�<¼¡�`¨ µg�`�i¨ ��®b�¡£�£��b Y§��r¤5���`���5�  i�i�b�q§��b�´§���½j�¡µi� �kª��`¥¡�L¤7��¥F�[ºj¾k�b����� �¡ i�H�`¢g§��i� �H�g�`�J�b��g�b¼Y���J�b�b ´�i���b���b Y§��b���N§H§��i�7¿` i��¯F�¡µq§��i�b�� SÀ5�`¨ � ¢ �¡�� i� �7¬k®b�¡ i�¡£�� ®5���i�b�¡�·Á´Àv�¡ q¢ �b���b i®b�7¿¡Â¡Â¡ÂqÃq�N§H¬5¯F¬vªÄ¶L¸¡¸¡¸�  D¯q�` Y§�� �`¦¡�X�i��Àv�¡£��J�¡�·§��b¨ �qÃq�` i�S�  ����b£��  g�`���k�N§v§��i�VÅ7 i� ¼Y�b����� §�� �b�k�`¢jÆ�¨ � ®L�` Y§��¡ÃiÇv�b��¨ �  h±[È7µi£d�J�¡¨ �q§É¹�ÃiÇv�¡ i QÃÊ �b¼q� �LÃ<ª��`�  iË��` i�1¯Y§LºHÌV�`¨ ¨ �b QºSÍ��S�`���´¦¡���N§��É¢ µi¨k¢ �¡�­®b�¡£�£��b Y§����`¢5§��i�S�g�`�·§�� ®b� �g�` Y§��LºD»<�  g�` i®b� �`¨k��µi�i�J�¡�·§¢ ���¡£-¯F»HÇ�Ρ¡Î��N§�Çv�¡ i «Å7 i� ¼Y�b����� §@Áh�` i� Ê »<ÌϦ¡���` Y§7³kµ�¶L¡ÐYÑ`ÎNÒ�¶­� ���`¨ ���´¦¡���N§��É¢ µi¨ ¨ Áh�`®�¥F i�L¤7¨ �b�i¦¡�b�Qº

Page 2: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

�������������� ������������������ �������"!#��$%��������&!�')(#*+ � ,-��.0/��21"��*3�����3��'4����5!�+ �2�6�2�#'7*1��8')������$9*1��:�����1"��;��<���21)=������0�8�>'?/���!�1"�-.(#�2')����@� ��/��2'7�21"�"=A�2�����(B��=A�-�-.3��C>D�'9�:���"/��EF�G'?/�*'%��<���21)=��������*�IH��J*������(K�#'7��.5�2�1%�8�L'7�21��J�9� �M�"/�*1"��.M!�(#H2+ ���9�8�!�(K'��ON&1"�(�=3/B+ <�P6� �9*��.���#+ <6� �M��<���21)=������.����21"��*3���Q*3�R'?/��������"!#�Q� �4!�1"�-.(#�2')����S�8���21"��*3������T9'?/B�:�0��*3���Q� �GU���(#H���')�8')(K')�8V�BWO��<���21)=������R�:�*1)=�(#��.6'7�RH��%')<"!�����*+ C5XM�J*��*"!�!�+ ����*')�����$YEZ�����������.��21�*6�6�-.��2+�� ��U)+ ��*1��#�8�B=��8�L��'7�&![��$�W%�8�E\/B����/Q'?/��]!�(#H2+ ���J�8�!�(K'��41"�&!�1"�����2�#'�.� ^_�21"�2�#'a`���E]+ ��.�=A�J�8'7�2�J��CbdcMegfJh ���-�-i?j���K�-i�k[l\��m B«�g�H]#n��J�oQpAqsr k#�t\��m cXRQ\bK9Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\F]XCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJTh\NWYR3EkC3]d\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba3]­WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC0v RjCF�<Z |H\Z Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P�] w P<Rg��e C x z3C3s

Page 3: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

� ��������� ����������

UXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\ORJTt\NWYR3EkC GJINZ[\LC�TfINR3M,\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\OZ P KNy<C E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�RJT«y<CYKNCFINR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\Oz3RjR x \Fs�´y<C1WYe[G3\N\LZ[WFGJe�v GJI`\LyHGJe e Z[GJPÏP<RJKNZ R3PÏRJT ubR3Z PQK�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P���v GJI`\LyHGJe e��bp��3m3���jpqmQ�J�����´C��rE<e[GJZ PH\Z PH\bK`GJPHWYCq\dRJT�\L|HW`y�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\X�jaOKNy<CDT·G3W¡K´KNyHGgK�\LR3MOCDT·G3W¡KNR3I`\XRJT7E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�GJINChE<|<INChE<|<�<e Z[WZ P<E<|rK`\Fs��´yHGgKSZ[\F]<R3PHWYChKNy<CtZ P<E<|rK`\�yHGi_3C«�kCFCFP |H\LC x TfR3I�E<INR x |HWYZ P<zOR3P<C�z3RjR x ]jKNy<CFa �kCqWYR3MOCWYRQ\bKNe Cq\N\Le aÏGi_gGJZ e[GJ�<e C9TfR3It|H\LC1Z P*KNy<C E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJT´RJKNy<CFI`\Fs� *C1INCYTfCFI�KNR KNy<Z[\tG3\«KNy<C"! ��8�#'!�(#H2+ ���L�8�!�(K' Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P RJT«CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\9RJT«\NWYR3EkC3s$#ÉP KNy<Z[\1EHGJEkCFIq]X�dC x CFM1GJI`WFGgKNC�KNy<Cx R3M1GJZ P�RJT�GJE<E<e Z[WFGJ�<Z e Z Kba RJT7KNy<C�ubR3Z PQKSE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rKDC��rE<e[GJPHGgKNZ R3P KNROCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\´RJT�\NWYR3EkC«�ja\bKN| x ajZ P<zhKNy<C�CFPQK`GJZ e C x \bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC´RJTv\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\F]gZ�s C3sgKNy<C�EHGgKLKNCFINP9RJTvM1GJINz3Z PHGJerWYRQ\bK�INC x |HW¡KNZ R3PH\x |<C�KNR1KNy<CtE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJT�INCFe[GgKNC x z3RjR x \Fs&%D|<IDM1GJZ P WYR3PHWYe |H\LZ R3P Z[\´KNyHGgK«\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�WFGJP �kCG3WFWYR3|<PQKNC x TfR3I­Z POKNCFINM1\­RJTvE<|<INCSE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\XCq\N\LCFPQKNZ[GJe e atZ T7GJP x R3P<e a9Z T�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\ .����21"��*3���G3\VKNy<Ch\NWYR3EkC�RJT5E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P1Z PHWYINCqG3\LCq\��·W¡Tbs��´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �'�¡s( *ChGJe[\LRt\Ly<Rg� KNyHGgK­KNy<CSR3E<EkRQ\LZ KNCWFG3\LC«RJT�Z PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<zO\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\dZ[\�_3CFINa1INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3C)�·\LCFC"�´y<CFR3INCFM��rs ���¡sl�E<INZ MOC«C��<GJMOE<e C�MORJKNZ _gGgKNZ P<zOR3|<I��dR3I w Z[\ `���E]+ ��.�=A� G3\�G9T·G3W¡KNR3I�RJTVE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�s�%D|<I

GJPHGJe ar\LZ[\5Z[\7GJE<E<e Z[WFGJ�<e C�KNRhG�P<RJKNZ R3P�RJT �+*�!�+ ���2�8'jw P<Rg��e C x z3C­G3\5KNy<C­EkRQ\N\LCq\N\LZ R3P«RJTH\LEkCqWYZ ,kW�E<Z CqWYCq\RJTVZ PrTfR3INM1GgKNZ R3P R3I�|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<zH]HG3\´C��rCFMOE<e Z ,HC x �ja1KNy<CtZ x CqG9KNyHGgK w P<Rg��e C x z3C«Z KNCFM1\SWFGJP�kC�EHGgKNCFPQKNC x ]<R3I�e Z[\bKNC x Z P GOWY|<ININZ[WY|<e |<M s-�´y<Z[\SWYR3PQKNI`G3\bK`\d��Z KNy GOP<RJKNZ R3P�RJT �8�5!�+ ���2�8'7w P<Rg��e �C x z3CDG3\­\ w Z e ekG3W/.Q|<Z INC x KNy<INR3|<z3yOE<I`G3W¡KNZ[WYC3]j\L|HW`y1G3\�KNy<C x Z[GJz3P<RQ\bKNZ[W�WYR3MOEkCYKNCFPHWYCDRJT�G«MOC x Z[WFGJex RrW¡KNR3IOy<R3P<C x �ja e R3P<z*C��rEkCFINZ CFPHWYC3s�#ÉP KNy<C CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\9e Z KNCFI`GgKN|<INC3]X\L|HW`y Z MOE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e �C x z3C�Z[\hRJT@KNCFP G x<x INCq\N\LC x |<P x CFIhKNy<C9e[GJ�kCFeVRJT10Le CqGJINP<Z P<z �ja x R3Z P<z�2 GJP x TfINC�.Q|<CFPQKNe a _jZ CF�dC xG3\9GÏM1GubR3I9\LR3|<I`WYC RJTDZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z INCYKN|<INPH\�KNR*\NWFGJe C3�·lSININRg�4�bpqm3oQ�'���¡s3 �y<Z e C e CqGJINP<Z P<z �jax R3Z P<zH]QG3\­Z PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z�INCYKN|<INPH\VKNR�\NWFGJe CSMOR3INC�z3CFP<CFI`GJe e a3]3I`GJZ[\LCq\ x Z 5 WY|<e KdZ[\N\L|<Cq\XGJ�kR3|rK­KNy<CDPHGg�KN|<INCDRJT�WYR3MOEkCYKNZ KNZ R3P GJP x C�.Q|<Z e Z �<INZ |<M GJPHGJe ar\LZ[\F]JKNy<CDE<y<CFP<R3MOCFP<R3P Z K`\LCFe T7WFGJP1�kChG x C�.Q|HGgKNCFe aWFGJErKN|<INC x |H\LZ P<z WYR3Pj_3CFPQKNZ R3PHGJeXKNRjR3e[\/6dTfR3IOM1GJPja E<|<INEkRQ\LCq\F]­CF_3CFP-GÏR3P<CY��Z P<E<|rK��iR3P<CY��R3|rKNE<|rKWYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��Z KNy x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z9M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK`\´��Z e e x RHsan�Z w C«Z MOE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e C x z3C3]rC��rE<e Z[WYZ Kw P<Rg��e C x z3CXZ[\VGJP�Z MOEkR3ILK`GJPQK�\LR3|<I`WYCXRJTkZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<zDINCYKN|<INPH\ x |<CdKNRhZ K`\�P<R3P<INZ _gGJe INR3|H\7PHGgKN|<INC´G3\GJP1Z P<E<|rK�7�KNy<CD|H\LCSRJT�\LEkCqWYZ ,kW w P<Rg�´��y<Rg� TfR3IXE<INR x |HWYZ P<ztR3P<CSz3RjR x1x RjCq\­P<RJKXE<INCqWYe | x CSZ K`\d\LZ �M�|<e K`GJP<CFR3|H\�|H\LCdZ P�KNy<C´E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�RJTHRJKNy<CFIVz3RjR x \Fs(�´y<C´Z PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<zDINCYKN|<INPH\ x |<CXKNR«C��rE<e Z[WYZ Kw P<Rg��e C x z3CtPHGgKN|<I`GJe e a K`G w CtKNy<CtTfR3INM�RJT­CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\SRJT �����"!#� sh�da x C�,HP<Z KNZ R3P�]kCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\SRJT\NWYR3EkChZ Pj_3R3e _3CSM�|<e KNZ E<e C«R3|rKNE<|rK`\Fsav R3INCFRg_3CFIq]3C��rE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e C x z3ChG3\dGJP Z P<E<|rK�Z[\dZ P<y<CFINCFPQKNe ay<CYKNCFINR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\F]�\LZ PHWYCO�ja Z K`\�_3CFINa PHGgKN|<INC1\LR3MOCYKNy<Z P<z w P<Rg��P*WFGJP<P<RJK��kC1e CqGJINPQKtGJzQGJZ P�s�#ÉPRJKNy<CFI��dR3I x \F]<G9EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJI w P<Rg��e C x z3C«Z KNCFM�WFGJP��kC�|H\LC x G3\�GJP�Z P<E<|rKDR3P<e a Z P8.Q|HGJPQKNZ KNZ Cq\��R3IOp3s1�´yj|H\F]5KNy<COPHGgKN|<I`GJe�TfI`GJMOCF�dR3I w KNR MOR x CFe�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PÏ�HG3\LC x R3PÏC��rE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e C x z3CZ Pj_3R3e _3Cq\SM�|<e KNZ E<e C9Z P<E<|rK`\�G3\D�dCFe e�G3\DM�|<e KNZ E<e C9R3|rKNE<|rK`\Fs9�7R;:FCFINRJ��Z P R3P KNy<COWYR3M��<Z PHGgKNR3INZ[GJe.Q|<Cq\bKNZ R3PH\DEkRQ\LC x �ja�KNy<C9M�|<e KNZ � x Z MOCFPH\LZ R3PHGJe Z Kba RJT�KNy<C9z3RjR x \LEHG3WYC3]v�dC��dR3I w Z P*G x Z[\NWYINCYKNC\LCYKLKNZ P<z�Z PÏ��y<Z[W`yÏ�kRJKNyÏZ P<E<|rK`\«GJP x R3|rKNE<|rK`\«GJINCtTfR3INM1GJe Z :FC x G3\ ���2'�� RJT­z3RjR x \DI`GgKNy<CFIDKNyHGJP_3CqW¡KNR3I`\dRJT�WYR3PQKNZ Pj|<R3|H\<.Q|HGJPQKNZ KNZ Cq\Fs =l�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P Z[\S\NGJZ x KNR1�kC�W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\´RJT�\NWYR3EkC�Z T�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK`\

x CqWYINCqG3\LC�G3\9MOR3INC z3RjR x \OGJINC E<INR x |HWYC x s>�7CqW`y<P<Z[WFGJe e a3]­CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT«\NWYR3EkC���Z e edKNyj|H\O�kCZ x CFPQKNZ ,HC x ��Z KNy ��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1��8')< RJT7KNy<C�WYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s#ÉP KNy<C«e Z KNCFI`GgKN|<INC3]jKNy<Z[\�\bKNINR3P<z�P<RJKNZ R3PRJT«CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\ORJT«\NWYR3EkC Z[\1GJe[\LR w P<Rg��P |<P x CFI1KNy<C PHGJMOC RJT�0NWYRQ\bK1WYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQK`GJINZ Kba3] 2*Z PWYR3PQKNI`G3\bK­KNRtKNy<CD�dCqG w CFIXINC�.Q|<Z INCFMOCFPQKXRJT7\L|<�HG x<x Z KNZ _jZ Kba8�·\LCFC@?�GJPA:qGJIXGJP x �Z e e Z z;�bpqm'�<pB��GJP xCED  ´§��i� �v���b���J�b®É§LÃF�¡µi�5�`�i�i���Y�`®���¢ �¡¨ ¨ �L¤7�5¯F®L�`�·¢�F �7±·¶L¸HGq¶N¹k�` g�`¨ Áq��� �v�`¢Q�i���F�iµi®É§�� �¡ �¤7� §��´�  i�i� ¼q� ��� �i� ¨ � §�� �b��± ���b��`¨ ���9¯F®L�`�·¢d±·¶L¸¡¸JIF¹·¹�º�Æ-�i� ��®b���ɧ��h£��F�i�b¨5���b�b£��d�g�`�·§�� ®bµi¨ �`��¨ Á1�`�i�i���¡�i��� �N§��h�  O§��i�«®b�¡ Y§��LKF§S�`¢V�b®b�¡ i�¡£�� �´�`¢��®b�¡�J�¡ÃH���  i®b���iµi��§��«§��i�D�`�����F®b� �N§��b�1 i�¡ qÒ@®b�¡ Y¼Y�LKq� §�� �b�d�`¢�§��i��§��b®��i i�¡¨ �¡¦`ÁYÃv�i���F�iµi®É§�� �¡ O�i�b®b� ��� �¡ i�D± ¤7�i�ɧ��i�b��i���JMi§·Ò@£S�+Kq� £�� Ëb�  i¦´�¡�����F®b� �`¨ ¨ Áh�¡�q§�� £S�`¨ ¹��g�b¼Y�´�´��� ¦¡ i� Mg®L�` Y§��i� ��®b���ɧ��X®b�¡£d�i�  g�N§��¡��� �`¨<®b�¡£��J�¡ i�b Y§V�ɼY�b t�  t�®b�¡ Y§��  Fµi�¡µi�����ɧ·§��  i¦��  S§��i�­��µi�i�i���¡�i¨ �b£ �`¢r¤7�i� ®��h¦¡�F�F�i��§��´�i���F�iµi®b�­�  D�J�¡��� §�� ¼Y�NFµg�` Y§�� §�� �b�Lº

p

Page 4: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

?�GJPA:qGJI��bpqm'�3m����¡s *C�G x R3ErK�KNy<C \bKNINR3P<z3CFI�P<RJKNZ R3P Z P KNy<Z[\tEHGJEkCFItTfR3ItZ K`\tINZ[W`y<CFI�\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC3]��Z KNy<R3|rK x Z[\LE<|rKNZ P<zSKNyHGgK7KNy<CX�dCqG w CFI�R3P<C­M1Giah�kC­KNy<CXMOR3INC x Z INCqW¡KNe ahINCFe CF_gGJPQK�TfR3I7C�.Q|<Z e Z �<INZ |<MGJPHGJe ar\LZ[\Fs3�´y<C e RrWFGJedC��jKNCFPQKORJTSCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJTh\NWYR3EkC3]�Z�s C3s7KNy<C�INC x |HW¡KNZ R3P Z P KNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJeWYRQ\bK«RJTXE<INR x |HWYZ P<z�G EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIhz3RjR x � �<INR3|<z3yQK«GJ�kR3|rK«�ja�KNy<C1G x<x Z KNZ R3PHGJe�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PÏRJTGJP<RJKNy<CFI�z3RjR x�� ]���Z e e´�kC�INCYTfCFININC x KNR*G3\tKNy<C ��<���21)=�< �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x�� s��SRJKNC KNyHGgK9KNy<C\LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x�� KbajE<Z[WFGJe e a x CFEkCFP x \tR3P KNy<C \LCYK�RJT´z3RjR x \�RJKNy<CFIN��Z[\LC1E<INR x |HWYC x 6\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba WFGJP*�kCOEHGJI`GJE<y<I`G3\LC x G3\DKNy<COINC�.Q|<Z INCFMOCFPQKhKNyHGgK«KNy<C \LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFPÏKb�dRz3RjR x \´Z[\�GJe �´Giar\dP<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _3C3]jP<ROM1GgKLKNCFI���yHGgKSRJKNy<CFI�z3RjR x \�GJINCh�kCFZ P<z1E<INR x |HWYC x scXRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\ x CFINZ _3C x TfINR3M ubR3Z PQK�E<|<�<e Z[WhZ P<E<|rK`\�GJINC«GJe �´Giar\d\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI�6rWYR3Pj_3CFI`\LCFe a3]

�dC�\Ly<Rg� KNyHGgKXGJPja�WYRQ\bKVTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P1\NGgKNZ[\bTfajZ P<z�G�\bKNINR3P<z3CFI�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P9RJT<0 '7�'7*+ \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba 2WFGJP �kC�INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKNC x M1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe e a G3\SGJINZ[\LZ P<z�TfINR3M KNy<C�|H\LC�RJT[ubR3Z PQKSE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\Fs��´y<CCqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WSWYR3PQKNCFPQK­RJT5KNRJK`GJek\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba9Z[\�KNyHGgK­KNy<Ch\LajP<CFINz3a��kCYKb�dCFCFP GJPja9EHGJZ IXRJT5z3RjR x \Z[\ x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<zÏG3\�KNy<C \NWYR3EkC RJTSE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P Z PHWYINCqG3\LCq\/6­\L|HW`y x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z>�·\LCFe T@� x GJMOEkCFP<Z P<z��\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�GJINCOINCYTfCFININC x KNRÏG3\�0N\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�2 CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\«RJTS\NWYR3EkC3s #�K�KN|<INPH\tR3|rK�KNyHGgKtKNy<CWFG3\LCÏRJT�\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C*CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\ RJT9\NWYR3EkCÏZ[\ MOR3INC Tf|<P x GJMOCFPQK`GJeDKNyHGJP�GJP x E<INCq\L|<M1GJ�<e aT·GJI1MOR3INC E<INCF_gGJe CFPQKOKNyHGJP KNy<C TfR3INM1GJe e a \LajMOMOCYKNINZ[W WFG3\LC RJT«Z PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z$�·\LCFe T@��INCFZ PrTfR3I`WYZ P<z��\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\F]���y<Z[W`y Z[\t\Ly<Rg��PÏKNR �kC INCFM1GJI w GJ�<e a INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3C3s��´yj|H\F]��dC1GJININZ _3C1GgK�KNy<C1M1GJZ PWYR3PHWYe |H\LZ R3P RJT�KNy<C«EHGJEkCFI´KNyHGgK '?/��%��'7�&!6��1"�� '?/��M=A�2���21"*+d���')������ �9���������������J� �4�����"!#��*3����3��'F����5!�+ �2�6�2�#'7*1��8')�����5'7�%'?/��_�6�1"����')1�(#�2')(K1"��. ! ��8�#'#!�(#H2+ ���_�8�!�(K'\�8�#'7�21)!�1"�2'7*')����R�:�����6*+8+ $H��2�8�B=�+ *1)=A�2+ <�*6�6*')'7�21J� �9*3����(K���8�B=6��(��S�2���2�#'Y1"�&=�(K+ *1��8')< s

�´y<C�E<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rKXZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P9Z[\VTfIN|<Z KLTf|<eHCq\LEkCqWYZ[GJe e a��kCqWFGJ|H\LC�Z KXR3EkCFPH\VKNy<C�EkRQ\N\LZ �<Z e Z KbaKNR9MOR x CFevCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\XRJT�\NWYR3EkCDZ P�G�HC��rZ �<e Ch�´Gia�KNy<INR3|<z3y�GJE<E<INR3E<INZ[GgKNCDG3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3PH\XR3P KNy<CEHGgKLKNCFINP RJTVZ P<E<|rK`\Fs< *CtZ e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC«KNy<Z[\SEkR3Z PQKD��Z KNy G1_gGJINZ CYKba RJT��HG3\LZ[W«C��<GJMOE<e Cq\�Z PÏujCqW¡KNZ R3P� 67Z P ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �<]��dC x CF_3CFe R3E*Z P*z3INCqGgKNCFI x CYK`GJZ eXG MOR x CFe­RJTdCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\hRJT´\NWYR3EkCO�HG3\LC x R3PKNy<C�|H\LC«RJTVC��rE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e C x z3C3slD\�G \LZ MOE<e C C��<GJMOE<e C1Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNZ P<z KNy<C �HG3\LZ[W WYR3PHWYCFErK`\�RJTS\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�GJP x

E<|<�<e Z[W Z P<E<|rK`\F]´WYR3PH\LZ x CFIOKNy<C E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJThCqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\9INCq\LCqGJI`W`y EHGJEkCFI`\F]d\NGia G*P<RJKNC R3PC�.Q|<Z e Z �<INZ[GOZ P C��jKNCFPH\LZ _3C«TfR3INM�zQGJMOCq\ � ]vGOKNy<CFR3INCYKNZ[WFGJe7GJPHGJe ar\LZ[\�RJT�CFPQKNINa x CYKNCFININCFPHWYC � ]kGJP xGJP GJE<E<e Z C x #+%S��EHGJEkCFI�Hsdl�INCq\LCqGJI`W`y<CFIdCq\bKNZ M1GgKNCq\´KNy<C�WYRQ\bK1� ��C��vR3ILKH�dRJT���INZ KNZ P<zOKNy<C«KNy<INCFCEHGJEkCFI`\7G3\�yHGJe THG�a3CqGJI�RJTr�dR3I w 6g\Ly<CdGJe[\LR x CFe Z �kCFI`GgKNCq\�R3P�KNy<CdWYRQ\bK7RJTr��INZ KNZ P<zhGJPja«\L|<�H\LCYK7RJTrKNy<CE<INR�ubCqW¡KNC x EHGJEkCFI`\Fs��SCFIDCq\bKNZ M1GgKNC�RJT�KNy<C�WYRQ\bK`\F]<MOCqG3\L|<INC x Z P �dCFC w \�RJT�WYR3PHWYCFPQKNI`GgKNC x �dR3I w ]Z[\�G3\�TfR3e e Rg�S\/7�� ��� ��� ��� �<]�� ��� � � ���&pinr]�� ���� � ��&pq�<]�� ��� ��� � � ���$pg�j]�� ��� ��� � ����J�<]� ��� � � � ��� �g�H]hGJP x � ��� ��� � � � ��� �Jo<s lD\�Z[\�CqG3\LZ e a W`y<CqW w C x ]�KNy<C C��<GJMOE<e C*C��ry<Z �<Z K`\CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\SRJT­\NWYR3EkC3]kZ�s C3sHKNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bKDRJT­GJPja�z3Z _3CFP EHGJEkCFI x CqWYINCqG3\LCq\SG3\SMOR3INCtRJKNy<CFIEHGJEkCFI`\ GJINC GJe[\LR ��INZ KLKNCFP�s v R3INCFRg_3CFIq]­KNy<CÏCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\1Z P-KNy<C C��<GJMOE<e CÏGJINC \L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C3]Z�s C3s<KNy<Ct\LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP Kb�dROEHGJEkCFI`\ x CqWYINCqG3\LCq\´��y<CFP G9KNy<Z I x EHGJEkCFISZ[\SGJe[\LRO��INZ KLKNCFP�s��<R3IZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]gKNy<CS\LajP<CFINz3a«�kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x H]JZ�s C3sgKNy<C´INC x |HW¡KNZ R3P9RJTHKNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJerWYRQ\bKVRJTk��INZ KNZ P<z� �ja GJe[\LR���INZ KNZ P<z �Z[\dz3Z _3CFP �ja!� ��� ��� ��"$# � ��� ��� � �%"&� ���� � � '(��phZ T � Z[\dP<RJK´��INZ KLKNCFP�]<GJP x�ja)� ��� ��� � � ��"*� ��� � � ��"+# � ��� ��� � � � �,"*� ��� � � � � '�� � Z T � Z[\�GJe[\LR ��INZ KLKNCFP�s�#ÉP*T·G3W¡Kq]�KNy<C\LEkCqWYZ ,HC x WYRQ\bKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*Z[\hKNRJK`GJe e a \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIq]�y<CFPHWYCOG x MOZ K`\�G INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P Z PÏKNCFINM1\RJTsubR3Z PQKhE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\h��y<Z[W`y Z PQKN|<Z KNZ _3CFe a WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x KNR�WYR3MOMOR3P Z x CqG3\DGJP x KNRjR3e[\h\LyHGJINC x�ja KNy<C x Z �vCFINCFPQK�EHGJEkCFI`\Fs�<R3IhZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]vKNy<C9EHGJEkCFI`\ � GJP x&� M1Gia \LyHGJINCtKNy<CO|H\LC9RJTd\LR3MOCzQGJMOCSKNy<CFR3INCYKNZ[WSKNRjR3e[\XKNyHGgK´KNy<ChINCq\LCqGJI`W`y<CFIXyHG3\Xa3CYK´KNR9e CqGJINP�s�ujZ MOZ e[GJINe a3]QKNy<CFINC«��Z e ev�kC�\LR3MOCRg_3CFINe[GJE RJTVWYR3PHWYCFErK`\�GJP x Z x CqG3\´P<CFC x C x TfR3I´KNy<C«Kb�dR #+%S��EHGJEkCFI`\ � GJP x Hs

�´y<C�INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P Z P KNCFINM1\DRJT­E<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rK`\hCFMOCFINz3Cq\�TfINR3M�Z MOE<|rKNZ P<z \LEkCqWYZ ,kW",A�rC xWYRQ\bK`\�KNR1KNy<C�G3W/.Q|<Z[\LZ KNZ R3P RJTVKNy<C�E<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rK`\F]kZ�s C3sHKNy<C�\LyHGJINC x WYR3PHWYCFErK`\SGJP x Z x CqG3\�Z P R3|<IC��<GJMOE<e C3s­ujEkCqWYZ ,kWFGJe e a3]QTfR3IdCqG3W`y.-0/1� ��� � � � ] x CFP<RJKNCD�ja.243*KNy<C ,A�rC x WYRQ\bKdRJT x CF_3CFe R3E<Z P<zGJe e´WYR3PHWYCFErK`\ ��0LZ P<E<|rK`\+2���KNyHGgKOGJINC%ubR3Z PQKNe a CFMOE<e Rga3C x �ja C��<G3W¡KNe aÏKNy<C�EHGJEkCFI`\tZ P*- �·GJzQGJZ P

Page 5: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

MOCqG3\L|<INC x Z P �dCFC w \hRJT´WYR3PHWYCFPQKNI`GgKNC x �dR3I w �¡s �´y<CFINCOC��rZ[\bK`\�G (K�#���2(#� G3\N\LZ z3P<MOCFPQK«RJT�,A�rC xWYRQ\bK`\�243 TfR3IXGJe e - \L|HW`y9KNyHGgK­TfR3IXGJPja9\LCYK��ÏRJT5EHGJEkCFI`\F]gKNy<CSz3Z _3CFP1WYRQ\bK�� ���-�VC�.Q|HGJe[\VKNy<C�KNRJK`GJeWYRQ\bKXRJT�GJe eHZ P<E<|rK`\­KNyHGgKdGJINC�P<CFC x C x TfR3IX\LR3MOCSEHGJEkCFIXZ P��´]3TfR3INM1GJe e a�� ���-����� 3�� ��� 243ds�#ÉPKNy<C9C��<GJMOE<e C3]kKNy<C9|<P<Z .Q|<COG3\N\LZ z3P<MOCFPQKhZ[\Dz3Z _3CFP �ja 7 2������ ��� ��� � p3]�2������ ���� nr]�2������ ������<]2������ ��� ���<]�2������ �&�r]�2������ ��o<]�2������ ��m<s #ÉP z3CFP<CFI`GJe�]�KNy<C ,A�rC x WYRQ\bKOG3\N\LZ z3P<MOCFPQK�Z[\R3�rK`GJZ P<C x TfINR3M ���� ! (�=A*'7��� �-�-H2�8(B�J�8�#V�21������� ]5G3\�C��rE<e[GJZ P<C x Z P x CYK`GJZ e7Z PÏujCqW¡KNZ R3P*�9�kCFe Rg��scXIN|HWYZ[GJe3TfR3I7R3|<IVGJE<E<INRQG3W`y«Z[\�KNy<CdR3�H\LCFIN_gGgKNZ R3P«KNyHGgK�KNy<Cd\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INCXRJTH\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�Z[\7INC��HCqW¡KNC x �jaKNy<C�EHGgKLKNCFINP RJT�KNy<C�G3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x E<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\Fs��<R3ISZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3] 2������ ��� � �9MOCqGJPH\´KNyHGgK�KNy<CFINCGJINC1P<RÏWYR3PHWYCFErK`\tWYR3MOMOR3P KNR KNy<C P<RJKNC R3P C��jKNCFPH\LZ _3C1TfR3INM C�.Q|<Z e Z �<INZ[G � GJP x KNy<C GJE<E<e Z C x#+%S��EHGJEkCFI� KNyHGgKOGJINC1P<RJKOGJe[\LR \LyHGJINC x �jaÏKNy<C KNy<CFR3INCYKNZ[WFGJeXEHGJEkCFI�R3P CFPQKNINa x CYKNCFININCFPHWYC � s�´y<Z[\�WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \­KNROKNy<ChT·G3W¡K�KNyHGgK´KNy<CFINC«Z[\´P<ROINCFM1GJZ P<Z P<zO\LajP<CFINz3a1�kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x OR3PHWYC� Z[\��kCFZ P<z1��INZ KLKNCFP�s�hZ _3CFPtG´KNRJK`GJe e a�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�]JWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCZv RjCF�<Z |H\7Z Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P�WFGJPtRJT<WYR3|<I`\LC

R3P<e a1\LCqWY|<INC�KNy<CSTfR3INM1GJeHEkRQ\N\LZ �<Z e Z KbaORJT7G�ubR3Z PQKdE<|<�<e Z[WSZ P<E<|rK´Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�63KNy<CDM1GgKNy<CFM1GgKL�Z[WFGJe e aÏZ x CFPQKNZ ,HC x Z P<E<|rK`\tP<CFC x P<RJK9GJe �´Giar\«�kC CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e a MOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e�s�#ÉP x CFC x ]VCF_3CFP Z TKNy<C INCqGJe�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P E<INRrWYCq\N\«Z Pj_3R3e _3Cq\«Z MOE<|<INC �fZ�s C3s7INZ _gGJe INR3|H\J�DZ P<E<|rK`\F]�KNy<C INCq\L|<e KNZ P<z WYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*M1Gia _3CFINa �dCFe eV�kC9KNRJK`GJe e aÏ\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIqs9#ÉP KNyHGgKtWFG3\LC3]vKNy<COZ P<E<|rK`\ x CFINZ _3C x TfINR3MWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC v RjCF�<Z |H\ Z Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P�]�G3\N\L|<MOC x KNR �kCÏE<|<�<e Z[W �ja-WYR3PH\bKNIN|HW¡KNZ R3P�]�e[G3W w CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WMOCqGJP<Z P<zHs#ÉP ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �H]r�dCt\Ly<Rg� KNyHGgKSZ KSZ[\�P<R3P<CYKNy<CFe Cq\N\dTfINC�.Q|<CFPQKNe a EkRQ\N\LZ �<e C«KNR1_3CFINZ Tfa1KNy<CGJ�H\LCFPHWYCORJT´INZ _gGJe INR3|H\hZ P<E<|rK`\��HG3\LC x R3P Z PrTfR3INM1GgKNZ R3P*R3P*KNy<C WYRQ\bK«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P GJe R3P<C3]�KNy<CFINCF�jaCFPH\L|<INZ P<z9KNy<C�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WhMOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e P<Cq\N\´RJT7KNy<C]ubR3Z PQKSE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rKSZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�s

�´y<Ct|H\LCtRJT&�fP<R3Pr�ÉWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCB��v RjCF�<Z |H\SZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P Z[\D\bK`GJP x GJI x Z P KNy<C�INCFe[GgKNC x e Z KNCFI`GgKN|<INCR3POWYRQ\bKX\LyHGJINZ P<z«\LZ PHWYCDujyHGJE<e CFa�� \�\LCFMOZ PHGJeHWYR3PQKNINZ �<|rKNZ R3P��bpqmQnJ���H6JRrWFWFG3\LZ R3PHGJe e a3]gR3P<C�GJe[\LR@,HP x \INCYTfCFINCFPHWYCq\SKNR Z K`\«WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCtTfR3INM �·\LCFC�v R3|<e Z P��bpqm'�'���SGJP x! R3|<P<z3�bpqm3mJ�����¡s«lD\hR3|<IhM1GJZ PM1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe5WYR3PQKNINZ �<|rKNZ R3P�]r�dC«\LyHGJINEkCFP KNy<Z[\dKNRjR3ev�ja E<INRg_jZ x Z P<z9G�P<Rg_3CFe5W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :qGgKNZ R3PRJTSKNy<C WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCRv RjCF�<Z |H\9Z Pj_3CFI`\LC Z P KNCFINM1\�RJTSKNy<C�y<Z z3y<CFIL��R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\#" RJTDG*WYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P � �´y<CFR3INCFM��rs �'�¡s �´y<Z[\�Z[\�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e aDINCFe CF_gGJPQK7\LZ PHWYC�KNy<C,HI`\bK x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C x Cq\NWYINZ �kCq\M1GJINz3Z PHGJerWYRQ\bK`\�GJP x KNy<CS\LCqWYR3P x�x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3CdKNy<C�e RrWFGJe<\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\/6gMOR3INCFRg_3CFIq]iEkRQ\LZ KNZ _jZ KbatRJTkKNy<CKNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C�WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \­KNR x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z���0N\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�2��d\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fs�´y<C �kR x a RJT«KNy<C EHGJEkCFI Z[\1R3INzQGJP<Z :FC x G3\OTfR3e e Rg�S\Fs �´y<C TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �*Z[\ x Z _jZ x C xZ PQKNR ,H_3C�\L|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3PH\Fs´uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs p�Z PQKNINR x |HWYCq\´KNy<C�Tf|<P x GJMOCFPQK`GJe7WYR3PHWYCFErKDRJT�G x Z[\NWYINCYKNCWYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja WYRQ\bKSWYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQK`GJINZ KNZ Cq\"�fEkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\J�¡s­uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P�rs � x Z[\NWY|H\N\LCq\dKNy<C x Z[\bKNZ PHW¡KNZ R3P��kCYKb�dCFCFP$0NWYR3MOEkCFMOCFPQK`GJINa 2 �fZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z��dGJP x 0N\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�2� x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z��V\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fs #�KXZ[\­\Ly<Rg��P9KNyHGgKdGJPja9WYRQ\bK­Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P GJINZ[\LZ P<zhTfINR3M ubR3Z PQK­E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P��Z KNy E<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rK`\SC��ry<Z �<Z K`\D\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fsd^D\LZ P<z WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC9v RjCF�<Z |H\SZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3PG3\7KNy<C w CFahKNCqW`y<P<Z[WFGJeQKNRjR3e�]3GhWYR3Pj_3CFI`\LCX\bK`GgKNCFMOCFPQK�Z[\ x CFINZ _3C x Z P1uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3PO�rs �<sVujEkCqWYZ ,kWFGJe e a3]Z K«Z[\h\Ly<Rg��P KNyHGgK«|<P x CFI�G MOZ e x INCFz3|<e[GJINZ Kba�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P*GJPja WYRQ\bKDTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\tG x MOZ K`\�G6ubR3Z PQK�E<|<�<e Z[W Z P<E<|rKOINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P�s�#ÉP uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs �H]Z K9Z[\�\Ly<Rg��P KNyHGgKtKNy<C�WFG3\LC RJTS\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�Z[\�KNy<C T·GJI�MOR3INC1INCFe CF_gGJPQK9WFG3\LC3s �daWYR3PH\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYC3]5KNy<C4ubR3Z PQKtE<|<�<e Z[W1Z P<E<|rKtZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P*RJT´CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\hRJT�\NWYR3EkC \LCFCFM1\hKNR �kCGJE<E<e Z[WFGJ�<e C9|<P x CFI«_3CFINa z3CFP<CFI`GJeVWYZ I`WY|<M1\bK`GJPHWYCq\Fs�l \LCYK«RJTd�HG3\LZ[W�C��<GJMOE<e Cq\DZ[\«E<INCq\LCFPQKNC x Z Puj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs nrslD\ G MOR3INC x CYK`GJZ e C x GJE<E<e Z[WFGgKNZ R3P�]´�dCÏ\bKN| x a Z P�ujCqW¡KNZ R3P � G MOR x CFehRJT80Le CqGJINP<Z P<z �ja

Z PH\LZ z3yQKJ2OZ P ��y<Z[W`y CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\´RJT­\NWYR3EkC�GJINZ[\LChTfINR3M x Z �vCFINCFPQKDG3W¡KNZ _jZ KNZ Cq\SINC�.Q|<Z INZ P<z9KNy<C9\NGJMOCCFe CFMOCFPQK`GJINa \ w Z e e[\Fs �´y<C�E<INR3EkRQ\LC x 0N\bKNCFEj��Z[\LCte CqGJINP<Z P<z1MOR x CFe 2 Z[\SCq\LEkCqWYZ[GJe e a EHGJI`\LZ MOR3P<Z R3|H\Z P*KNyHGgKtCF_3CFINa E<|<�<e Z[WOZ P<E<|rK9WFGJP*�kC1|<P<Z .Q|<CFe a*G3\N\LZ z3P<C x KNR R3P<C1G3W¡KNZ _jZ Kba3]7INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKNZ P<z KNy<C$ �·§���� ®É§�¨ ÁD���J�L�`¥F�  i¦�%k�i� ¦¡�i�b�·Ò@�¡���i�b���i� &3�b���b i®b�b�Lº

Page 6: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ[\bKNZ[W 0Le CqGJINP<Z P<zD\bKNCFE 2DG3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x ��Z KNytKNyHGgK�G3W¡KNZ _jZ Kba3s��´G3\LC x R3P�GDW`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :qGgKNZ R3PZ P KNCFINM1\tRJT´KNy<C CFPQK`GJZ e C x \bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC RJTS\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\F]7�dC GJINz3|<C9KNyHGgK�KNy<C 0N\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC1e CqGJINP<Z P<zMOR x CFe 2DWFGJP�\LCFIN_3CXG3\�GSINCqG3\LR3PHGJ�<e CXGJP x |H\LCYTf|<ej�kCFPHW`y<M1GJI w MOR x CFeQZ PtKNy<C´WYR3PQKNC��jK�RJT<e CqGJINP<Z P<z�HG3\LC x R3P�C��rE<e Z[WYZ K w P<Rg��e C x z3C3s

#ÉP KNy<C�,HPHGJe­ujCqW¡KNZ R3PÏ�H]5�dC x Z[\NWY|H\N\DKNy<COE<INR3�<e CFM&RJT x CYKNCFINMOZ P<Z P<z���y<CYKNy<CFI«E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PZ[\hC��<WYe |H\LZ _3CFe a �HG3\LC x R3PÏE<|<INCOE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\F]�R3I«��y<CYKNy<CFI�\LR3MOC9Z P<E<|rK`\�GJINC�INZ _gGJe INR3|H\FstlSe eE<INRjRJT·\�GJINC«WYR3e e CqW¡KNC x Z P GJP GJE<EkCFP x Z �5s

� �;��������J�� ������ �������� � ��� ����� ������

n�CYK��,�kC G�,HP<Z KNC \LCYK�RJT�z3RjR x \«KNyHGgK9WFGJP �kC EkRJKNCFPQKNZ[GJe e a*E<INR x |HWYC x �ja G;,HINM s �<R3I�GJPja\L|<�H\LCYK � /�� x CFP<RJKNC �ja � ���-��KNy<C WYRQ\bK1RJThE<INR x |HWYZ P<z C��<G3W¡KNe a KNy<C z3RjR x \OZ P �<6´KNy<Cq\LCWYRQ\bK`\XGJINCS\L|<MOM1GJINZ :FC x Z P GtWYRQ\bK­Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P.�@7Q������� s�´y<CSCFe CFMOCFPQK`\XRJT��$GJINCS\LR3MOCYKNZ MOCq\Z PQKNCFINE<INCYKNC x G3\�y<CYKNCFINR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\ �8��.�8V-��.(#*+ R3�KubCqW¡K`\F]gC3s zHsiWFGJI`\F]iR3IVG3\ ')<"!#��� RJT<z3RjR x \���0LE<INR x |HW¡Ke Z P<Cq\+2�� x Z[\bKNZ P<z3|<Z[\Ly<C x �ja \LEkCqWYZ ,kW w P<Rg�´��y<Rg��]VC3s zHs x Z �vCFINCFPQK1WFGJIOMOR x CFe[\O\LyHGJINZ P<z*GÏ�HG3\LZ[WWYR3MOMOR3P x Cq\LZ z3P�sD^SP x CFIhKNy<C�e[GgKLKNCFIhZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�]vWYRQ\bK`\DGJINZ[\LC�TfINR3M�KNy<C�P<CFC x KNR�G3W/.Q|<Z INCKNy<C ��*"!#*�H2�8+ �8')< KNR E<INR x |HWYC�z3RjR x \O�kCFe R3P<z3Z P<zÏKNR KNy<C \NGJMOC E<INR x |HW¡K1e Z P<C3]´GJP x Z PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<zINCYKN|<INPH\�GJINC x |<C«KNR \LyHGJINC x WYR3MOEkR3P<CFPQK w P<Rg��e C x z3C«\L|HW`y G3\´Rg_3CFINe[GJE<E<Z P<z����B��kCFP<C�,<K`\Fs

�´y<INR3|<z3y<R3|rKq] ��Z[\´G3\N\L|<MOC x KNR9�kChMOR3P<RJKNR3P<CDZ P KNy<C«\LCFPH\LCDKNyHGgK � � � �"! � ���-�­��y<CFP<CF_3CFI� / � ��0LE<INR x |HWYZ P<zOMOR3INC�WFGJP�P<CF_3CFI´�kCtW`y<CqGJEkCFIJ2��¡]<GJP x P<R3INM1GJe Z :FC x \LR9KNyHGgK � � #'�,���<s $

%'&)( *�+-,/.�,/02143657,98�:;+-,9<=3�>?5@:"A�.�3CBED/14365UXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT­\NWYR3EkC x Cq\NWYINZ �kC«KNy<C�INC x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJT�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe7WYRQ\bK`\ x |<CtKNR1KNy<CtE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJTRJKNy<CFI�z3RjR x \Fs�uj|HW`y ��<���21)=������ �kCYKb�dCFCFP«z3RjR x \�WFGJP«�kC x Cq\NWYINZ �kC x �jah\LCqWYR3P x ��R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\RJT�KNy<CtWYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s *C x C�,HP<C«KNy<C�� ,HI`\bKH� x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3CGF«RJT��«GgK � ��Z KNy INCq\LEkCqW¡K´KNR � �ja

H � � ���-��7 �1� ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-��J�´yj|H\F]KH � � ���-��Z[\­KNy<CDM1GJINz3Z PHGJekWYRQ\bKXRJT�E<INR x |HWYZ P<z � z3Z _3CFPOKNyHGgK �*Z[\dGJe INCqG x a�E<INR x |HWYC x s�#ÉPR3I x CFISKNR CFMOE<yHG3\LZ :FCtKNy<Z[\hZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P RJT�KNy<C1,HI`\bK x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C3]k�dC9GJe[\LR ��INZ KNC�L � ���-��TfR3IH � � ���-�¡s­cXe CqGJINe a3]gTfR3I�CqG3W`y ��M � ]�L � �4N �VZ[\�GJzQGJZ P9G«INCqGJe ��_gGJe |<C x Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3POR3P1� � sVl�WYIN|HWYZ[GJeINR3e CtZ P KNy<C�TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z GJPHGJe ar\LZ[\���Z e eV�kC�E<e[Gia3C x �ja Z K`\ x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Ct��Z KNyÏINCq\LEkCqW¡K � ��y<Z[W`y �dCGJe[\LROINCYTfCFIdKNR G3\dKNy<C �21"�3����O !#*1�')��*+�.��21��8V*')�8V� RJT��h��Z KNy INCq\LEkCqW¡K´KNR � ��� � � 7

H ����� ��� � ���-� 7 �PH � �QL � ���-�����RH � � H � � ���-���� # � ����I&� ��� � � � "�� ����I&� � � � '4" # � ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-� '

l WYRQ\bK Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�Z[\ \NGJZ x KNR��kC W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �jaÄCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\ RJT1\NWYR3EkC3]«Z�s C3s x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<zM1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK`\F]dZ ThKNy<CÏWYINRQ\N\b��EHGJILKNZ[GJe[\�GJINC GJe �´Giar\9P<R3Pr��EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C3s�U�.Q|<Z _gGJe CFPQKNe a3]XKNy<C ��<�SO�21)=�< �kCYKb�dCFCFP GJPja � GJP x.� ]

\LajP ����� ��� ���-��7 �0"TH ����� ��� � ���-� � ���rs pB�Z�s C3s5KNy<C INC x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJTdKNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bKtRJT´E<INR x |HWYZ P<z � x |<COKNR KNy<C E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJT � ]7Z[\GJe �´Giar\dP<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _3C3s-#�KDZ[\�CqG3\LZ e a _3CFINZ ,HC x KNyHGgKDP<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ Kba RJT�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\´Z[\�C�.Q|<Z _gGJe CFPQK

U »g�¡��£S�`¨ ¨ ÁYÃQ§��i�b���D�`���d§��Fµi�d i�@MBKq�b�9®b�¡�·§��LºDÍ��i�b i�ɼY�b�d¤5�� i�ɼY�b�·§��i�b¨ �b���d���É¢ �b��§�� © MBKq�b�O®b�¡�·§���°��  t§��i�¢ �¡¨ ¨ �L¤7�  i¦iÃi�·§���� ®É§�¨ ÁS���J�L�`¥F�  i¦´¤5��£��L�` O© NFµg�`��� Ò MBKq�b�h®b�¡�·§��Lº °V �·§���� ®É§�¨ ÁD���J�L�`¥F�  i¦�% Mg���·§·Ò@�¡���i�b�5�i� &3�b���b i®b�¡º

Page 7: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

KNR ��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1��8')< RJT7KNy<CtWYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�]<Z�s C3srKNR9KNy<CtWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P KNyHGgKq]rTfR3ISGJe e � � � / � ]� ����I�� � � � ������� �"! � ���-� � � � � ��J

�´y<C�R3�KubCqW¡K�|<P x CFIS\bKN| x a Z[\´KNyj|H\dKNy<CtWYe[G3\N\´RJT�GJe e�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJISWYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\�R3P � � s �#ÉP ��INZ KNZ P<z x Rg��P C�.Q|HGgKNZ R3P>���rs pB�´R3P<C�P<RJKNCq\DGgKhR3PHWYC�KNyHGgKDKNy<CO\LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x

� x CFEkCFP x \OR3P KNy<C \LCYK���RJTDz3RjR x \9GJe INCqG x a E<INR x |HWYC x s>�´y<Z[\ x CFEkCFP x CFPHWYC Z[\O\LZ z3P<Z ,kWFGJPQKqs#ÉP x CFEkCFP x CFPHWYC�RJT � �dR3|<e x INC�.Q|<Z INChKNyHGgK

H ����� ����� ���-�,� H ����� ��� � ����� �TfR3IdGJe e�� � � � KNyHGgK x RtP<RJKdWYR3PQK`GJZ P � R3I � s­uj|HW`y1Z P x CFEkCFP x CFPHWYCDy<R3e x \­Z T7GJP x R3P<e a9Z T7GJe e<KNy<Z I xx CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\�GJINC):FCFINRH]7Z P ��y<Z[W`y WFG3\LCOKNy<C WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��Z e e­�kC INCYTfCFININC x KNR G3\ �2(#*�.1"*')��� sBDCq\LE<Z KNCDZ K`\XGgKLKNI`G3W¡KNZ _3CFP<Cq\N\VTfINR3M GtWYR3MOE<|rK`GgKNZ R3PHGJe<EkR3Z PQKdRJT5_jZ CF��]jG9.Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[W´MOR x CFe<KN|<INPH\R3|rK�KNR��kCSZ PHGJE<E<INR3E<INZ[GgKNC´Z POMORQ\bKXWFG3\LCq\Fs��XajE<Z[WFGJe e a3]3\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\ x CFEkCFP x R3P �*Z P1G�\LZ z3P<Z ,kWFGJPQKGJP x CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e a MOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e5�´Gia3s

�7R Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNCtKNy<C9INR3e C�RJT�KNy<C�KNy<Z I xÏx CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C3]vWYR3PH\LZ x CFI«G \LZ MOE<e C9C��<GJMOE<e C�RJTdG \LCFe e CFIx CFe Z _3CFINZ P<z KNR�G ,HP<Z KNC Pj|<M��kCFI RJT9\bKNR3INCq\ Z P�G e Z P<CqGJI WYZ Kba3s�uj|<E<EkRQ\LC*KNyHGgK�KNy<CFINC GJINC��C�.Q|<Z x Z[\bK`GJPQK«\bKNR3INCq\F]v\LR KNyHGgK � � �Qp � J J J � � � sDl \LCFe e CFIDe RrWFGgKNC x GgKDKNy<C�C x z3C�RJT­KNRg��P>�·GgK«����´GJPQK`\­KNR9\LCFIN_3CSKNy<Cq\LCh\bKNR3INCq\Fs��<R3I´\LZ MOE<e Z[WYZ Kba3]<G3\N\L|<MOCSKNyHGgKdKNy<C«WYRQ\bKdZ PHWY|<ININC x �ja1\L|<E<E<e ajZ P<z\bKNR3INC � M � WYR3PH\LZ[\bK`\´Z P KNy<C«KNI`GJPH\LEkR3ILK`GgKNZ R3P WYRQ\bK�RJT x INZ _jZ P<zOTfINR3M KNy<Ct\bK`GJILKNZ P<zOEkR3Z PQKh��KNR\bKNR3INC � E<e |H\t\LR3MOC WYR3PH\bK`GJPQKtWYRQ\bK�� ��EkCFI9\bKNR3INC9TfR3I�|<P<e RQG x Z P<zHs� �Z KNy KNI`GJPH\LEkR3ILK`GgKNZ R3PWYRQ\bK`\XE<INR3EkR3ILKNZ R3PHGJe<KNR�KNy<C x Z[\bK`GJPHWYC3]QKNy<C«WYRQ\bKdRJT�\LCFIN_jZ P<z�\bKNR3INC � Z[\´\LZ MOE<e a!� ��� ��� �,� � � s

����

��

��

NGN N ��������

NGNGN ��

NGNGN ��

N NGN ���� �

��

�! #"%$'&)( *�+-, �/.0 12 & , �/.0 3

4

5 � =�(K1"��6#798s�21�V-�8�B=6��'7�1"���%�8��*6+ �8����*1J�2�8')<ujZ PHWYCOZ P \LCFIN_jZ P<z�\bKNR3INC � KNy<C1\LCFe e CFI«yHG3\DKNR x INZ _3C9�kCFa3R3P x GJe e­\bKNR3INCq\ �;: � ]5KNy<C1M1GJINz3Z PHGJeWYRQ\bKDRJTX\LCFIN_jZ P<z R3P<CtRJT�KNy<Cq\LC�Z[\<�R3PHWYC�\bKNR3INC � Z[\D\LCFIN_3C x s �´y<C9WYRQ\bKDRJTX\L|<E<E<e ajZ P<z�GJPja \LCYK� / ��RJTX\bKNR3INCq\SZ[\hz3Z _3CFP �ja&� ���-���=N �!> �-� � M1G � �´]vZ�s C3sHKNy<COWYRQ\bK`\DRJT­|<P<e RQG x Z P<z E<e |H\KNy<C«KNI`GJPH\LEkR3ILK`GgKNZ R3P WYRQ\bKSRJT�\LCFIN_jZ P<z�KNy<C�T·GJILKNy<Cq\bKD\bKNR3INC«Z P �´s-#�T �@?M �´]<M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK`\�GJINCKNyj|H\"L � ���-�,� � # � " M1G � � 'BA´]j��y<CFINC # 'BA Z[\´\Ly<R3ILKXTfR3IdM1G �(�� � � � sVujajP<CFINz3Z Cq\dGJINCDz3Z _3CFP�ja

\LajP ����� ��� ���-�,� # MOZ P%� ��� � � "*M1G � � 'BA ��·\LCFC ��Z z3|<INC*pB�¡s #ÉP EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]�KNy<C \LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x$� Z[\1GJe �´Giar\�P<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _3C3]WYR3P ,HINMOZ P<z KNy<C1E<INCq\LCFPHWYC9RJTdCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\«RJT´\NWYR3EkC3s �7R Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC3]7\L|<E<EkRQ\LC9KNyHGgKt\bKNR3INC �M1G � � Z[\�GJe INCqG x a1�kCFZ P<z1\LCFIN_3C x s��´y<C«M1GJINz3Z PHGJe5WYRQ\bK9 � � � ")��XRJTV\L|<E<E<e ajZ P<zOGJPja1T·GJILKNy<CFI\bKNR3INC � � �Z[\hINC x |HWYC x �ja � " ���y<CFP<CF_3CFI�GJPÏZ PQKNCFINMOC x Z[GgKNC1\bKNR3INC � ��Z KNy� :0�C: � Z[\GJe[\LR \LCFIN_3C x s&�´y<C x CFEkCFP x CFPHWYC�RJTX\LajP ����� ��� ���-��R3P � Z[\SKNI`GJPH\LEHGJINCFPQK�7XKNy<C�INC x |HW¡KNZ R3P Z P KNy<CD+D  �� �i�b Y§�� ¢ Áq�  i¦X�b®b�¡ i�¡£�� �b�v�`¢Q��®b�¡�J�7¤7� §�����µi�i£��F�iµi¨ �`��� §@ÁYÃY¤5���`����µi£��7�FEHG IKJML�± ���i�¡�·§·Ò[§��b��£D¹r§��b®��i i�¡¨ �¡¦`ÁYº

D  ��g�`�·§�� ®b¨ µi¨ �`�LÃ3�¡µi���` g�`¨ Áq��� �V�i�F�b�V i�`§V§��`¥¡�d�  Y§��h�`®b®b�¡µi Y§�§��i�d� &3�b®É§��`¢k§��`¥F�  i¦D�b Y¼Y�b¨ �¡�J�b�LÃQ�[º �¡ºJ�`¢v®��i�F�¡���  i¦§��b®��i i�¡¨ �¡¦¡� �b�Lº

n

Page 8: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

M1GJINz3Z PHGJe­WYRQ\bK�L � ���-� x |<C1KNR \LCFIN_jZ P<z GJP Z PQKNCFINMOC x Z[GgKNC \bKNR3INC � ��Z KNy M1G � � : � : � Z[\\LM1GJe e CFIh��y<CFP<CF_3CFIDM1G � �-Z[\he[GJINz3CFIqs #ÉPÏRJKNy<CFIh�dR3I x \F]v\LajP ����� ��� ���-�SZ[\ x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z Z P �<7�TfR3IGJe e ��� � GJP x GJe e � � � � ]

� / ��� � \LajP ����� ��� ���-��� \LajP ����� ��� ����� ��J ���rs �'��´y<CtWFG3\LC�RJT x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z1\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\dZ P KNy<Ct\LCFPH\LC�RJT����rs �'�d��Z e e7�kC�INCYTfCFININC x KNR G3\dKNy<C�WFG3\LC«RJT��(#H���')�8')(K')�8V� \LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\/7D\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\D�kCqWYR3MOC9�dCqG w CFISKNy<COMOR3INCO\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\hGJINC9GJe INCqG x a �kCFZ P<zC��rE<e R3Z KNC x sXujZ PHWYC�\LajP ����� ��� ���-��� "TH ����� ��� � ���-�¡] ���rs �'�XZ[\´C�.Q|<Z _gGJe CFPQK�KNROMOR3P<RJKNR3P<Z[WYZ Kba1RJT�KNy<CWYINRQ\N\b��EHGJILKNZ[GJe[\?H ����� ��� � �4N �¡]jGJP x y<CFPHWYC�KNRtP<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ KbatRJTvKNy<C�KNy<Z I x1x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C�RJTkKNy<ChWYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�] �

H ����� ��� ��� � �4N �<7 �RH � # H ����� ��� � �4N � ' J�´y<Z[\�\LZ MOE<e CSC��<GJMOE<e C x CFMOR3PH\bKNI`GgKNCq\�KNyHGgK�KNy<CS\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC�RJT5\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�Z[\�Z POz3CFP<CFI`GJe<WYR3M9�

E<e C��5s�#ÉP1EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]JZ K´\Ly<Rg�S\VKNyHGgK­KNy<C .Q|HGJe Z K`GgKNZ _3CS�kCFyHGi_jZ R3I�RJT�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�Z[\XWYe RQ\LCFe a�INCFe[GgKNC xKNR9KNy<C".Q|HGJe Z K`GgKNZ _3Ch�kCFyHGi_jZ R3IdRJT7KNy<ChKNy<Z I x�x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3ChRJT�KNy<C�WYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s­lÄTf|<P x GJMOCFPQK`GJex Z[\bKNZ PHW¡KNZ R3P WYR3PHWYCFINPH\�KNy<C ��� =�� RJT5KNy<CSKNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C3sVlD\­R3|rKNe Z P<C x GJ�kRg_3C3]3P<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ KbaRJTXKNy<C9KNy<Z I xÏx CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C9CF_3CFINaj��y<CFINC9WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \SKNR \L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C8� x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z��D\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fs�´y<C9EkR3e[GJI«WFG3\LCtRJT ����5!�+ �2�6�2�#'7*1�< �fZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z��S\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\SZ[\«GJe[\LR WYR3PHWYCFZ _gGJ�<e C3s �SRg�dCF_3CFIq]�dCh\LyHGJe evGJINz3|<C´KNyHGgKdKNy<Cq\LChWFG3\LCq\XGJINCSP<RJK�\LajMOMOCYKNINZ[W9�·\LCFC�ujCqW¡KNZ R3P��rs �t�kCFe Rg� �H7�\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\d��Z e e ,Hz3|<INC«M�|HW`y�MOR3INC«E<INR3MOZ P<CFPQKNe a Z P R3|<ISGJPHGJe ar\LZ[\Fs�SRg��WFGJP��dC«|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x KNy<C�E<INCq\LCFPHWYC«RJT�\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3Ct\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\��

%'& % :�� 5��E1 �����E1 �/3�*�+-,/.�,/0214365 ,98=:;+-,9<=3�����3��K,��",/1).��������)1)+�� .�<����E5�´y<C�TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z«C��<GJMOE<e CSZ[\�MOCqGJPQK­KNR�Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC´KNy<CSP<RJKNZ R3P1RJTAubR3Z PQKXE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\XWYCFPQKNI`GJerKNRKNy<CSTf|<ILKNy<CFI x CF_3CFe R3E<MOCFPQKXRJT5KNy<CSKNy<CFR3INa3sXcXR3PH\LZ x CFI�KNy<CDTfR3e e Rg��Z P<z�_3CFINaO\bKbaje Z :FC x x Cq\NWYINZ ErKNZ R3PRJT�KNy<C�WYRQ\bK´\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INChRJT7E<INR x |HWYZ P<z9�]v8 \ �·G��dCFe e � w P<Rg��P��hCFINM1GJP�WFGJIdM1G w CB�¡s � ��Z I`\bKq]QKNR�kC�GJ�<e CSKNR9E<INR x |HWYC«GJPja �]v8 � GgK�GJe e5G�WYCFILK`GJZ P�GJMOR3|<PQK�� �¡� RJT�,HINM9����Z x ChRg_3CFINy<CqG x yHG3\KNR �kC9Z PHWY|<ININC x shBDCF_3CFe R3E<Z P<z G \LEkCqWYZ ,kWtE<INR x |HW¡K«e Z P<C3]5\NGia KNy<COni�É\LCFINZ Cq\SRJTX�]v8 �]kINC�.Q|<Z INCq\e[GJINz3C�C��rEkCFP x Z KN|<INCq\ � �i¨"! �$# s�ujZ MOZ e[GJINe a3] x Cq\LZ z3P<Z P<z�G EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIhMOR x CFe�]�\L|HW`y*G3\DKNy<C1n3�3niK x ]Z Pj_3R3e _3Cq\hG x<x Z KNZ R3PHGJe­WYRQ\bK`\ � £��%! �$#Ns ��Z PHGJe e a3]5KNy<C G3W¡KN|HGJeVE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P*RJTXKNy<C1Z P x Z _jZ x |HGJe­WFGJIyHG3\X|<P<Z K�WYRQ\bK`\'& £��$! �$#`s�´yj|H\F]jE<INR x |HWYZ P<z9G�\LZ P<z3e Ch�]v8 � �@KNy<Z P w RJT � M � G3\XR3P<ChWFGJIdRJTG9EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJI´MOR x CFe �´yHG3\dKNRJK`GJe�WYRQ\bK

� ��� ��� �,�(� �¡� � � �i¨"! �$# � � £��%! �$# � & £��$! �$# J�<R3I�Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]V\L|<E<EkRQ\LC1R3P<C n3�3niK x Z[\��kCFZ P<z E<INR x |HWYC x s �´y<CFP�]�KNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bKtRJT´E<INRJ�x |HWYZ P<z G \LCqWYR3P x n3�3niK x Z[\)& С¿¡ÐN§�� s �da WYR3PQKNI`G3\bKq]�KNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK1RJTb]´\NGia G n3� �JZ�]­Z[\� С¿HG`� � & С¿HG`� sav R3INChz3CFP<CFI`GJe e a3]QKNy<C«KNRJK`GJe5WYRQ\bK�RJT�E<INR x |HWYZ P<zOGO\LCYK � RJTVWFGJI`\�� ���-�XZ[\´z3Z _3CFP�ja�KNy<Ch\L|<M RJT5Rg_3CFINy<CqG x WYRQ\bK`\F]JKNy<C�� .Q|HG3\LZ �E� ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\�RJT�GJPja9E<INR x |HW¡KdWFGgKNCFz3R3INatZ P �$�fe Z P<CR3I�MOR x CFe �dE<e |H\dKNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bK`\dRJTVCqG3W`y�Z P x Z _jZ x |HGJe7WFGJIqs

#ÉP*KNy<Z[\�C��<GJMOE<e C3]�KNy<C E<INCq\LCFPHWYCORJT´CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\«RJT�\NWYR3EkC1Z[\ x |<COKNR)! ��8�#'a!�(#H2+ ���R�8�!�(K'�� ]Z�s C3skZ P<E<|rK`\DINC�.Q|<Z INC x �ja \LCF_3CFI`GJe�z3RjR x \9�·WFGJI`\J�dKNyHGgKh�kCqWYR3MOC�TfINCFCFe a Gi_gGJZ e[GJ�<e C�R3PHWYCt|H\LC x TfR3IR3P<CO\LZ P<z3e C9z3RjR x �·WFGJIH�¡s��<R3IhZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]vKNy<C1WYRQ\bK«RJTdE<INR x |HWYZ P<z�G n3�3niK x GJP x G n3� �JZ#ubR3Z PQKNe a*,+ �i���b�·¼Y�V§��g�N§7§��i�V¼¡�`¨ µi�­�`¢.- $'&)( *-( /K+10 ±32H¹v� ���  i�i�b�J�b i�i�b Y§V�`¢r§��i�­�¡���i�b���`¢r§��`¥F�  i¦��i�b��� ¼¡�N§�� ¼Y�b�Lº4 Í��i� ¨ �7���¡£��7���L�`�i�b���v£S�bÁd�J��¨ �b���H¢ �¡ i�S�`¢jÇ5ªhÍ��k§��g�` S¤5���`���¡ÃY§��i�ÉÁS£S�bÁd i�ɼY�b�·§��i�b¨ �b�����`�i�i���b®b� �N§���§��i��J�b�g�`¦¡�¡¦¡� ®L�`¨g¼¡�`¨ µi���`¢J§��i�7�LKi�`£��i¨ �¡ÃY�b���J�b®b� �`¨ ¨ ÁX�`¢3§��i��®b��� ���i i�b���<¤7� §��d¤7�i� ®���Ç5ªhÍ F �< i�¡£��b i®b¨ �N§�µi����®b�¡ Y¼Y�ÉÁq�§��i�-NFµg�`¨ � §��N§�� ¼Y���·§���µi®É§�µi���­�`¢<� §��7�i���F�iµi®É§7���g�`®b�¡º

o

Page 9: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

Z[\D\LM1GJe e CFI�KNyHGJP KNy<C�\L|<M�RJTVKNy<C�WYRQ\bKDRJT�E<INR x |HWYZ P<z1CqG3W`y RJTVKNy<C�Kb�dR WFGJI`\S\LCFEHGJI`GgKNCFe a \LZ PHWYC�kRJKNy WFGJI`\´\LyHGJINC�WYR3MOMOR3P�Z P<E<|rK`\F]<PHGJMOCFe a1KNy<RQ\LC�INC�.Q|<Z INC x TfR3I x CF_3CFe R3E<Z P<z9KNy<C�ni�É\LCFINZ Cq\Fs

#ÉPtz3CFP<CFI`GJe�]FKNy<C´WYRQ\bK�\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INCXRJT<E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3Pt��Z KNy�ubR3Z PQKVE<|<�<e Z[W­Z P<E<|rK`\VWFGJPt�kC x Cq\NWYINZ �kC xG3\XTfR3e e Rg�S\FsFn�CYK��-�kCtG9\LCYK�RJT7E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\´��Z KNy�z3Z _3CFP E<INZ[WYCq\�����]�� M �hs,�<R3I�GJPja�� M �e CYK ����� /�� x CFP<RJKNC9KNy<CO\LCYK«RJT­KNy<RQ\LC9z3RjR x \D��y<Z[W`yÏINC�.Q|<Z INC�Z P<E<|rK��Ss9�´y<C9KNRJK`GJeVWYRQ\bK«RJTE<INR x |HWYZ P<z9KNy<Ct\L|<�H\LCYK � RJT�z3RjR x \´Z[\´KNyj|H\´z3Z _3CFP��ja

� ���-�,� ��� � ! � # �� ������ J

�SRJKNC´KNyHGgK­CqG3W`y9E<|<�<e Z[W´Z P<E<|rKXRrWFWY|<I`\�R3P<e a�R3PHWYC´Z P9KNy<CS\L|<M R3P9KNy<C�INZ z3yQKL��yHGJP x \LZ x C3]Q\LZ PHWYC�Z K�kCqWYR3MOCq\XTfINCFCFe a1Gi_gGJZ e[GJ�<e CSTfR3I´GJe evR3|rKNE<|rK`\dR3PHWYChZ K´yHG3\d�kCFCFP |H\LC x �ja1R3P<C3s�#ÉP KNy<CDTfR3e e Rg��Z P<zH]Z K«��Z e eV�kC9WYR3Pj_3CFP<Z CFPQKDKNR Z x CFPQKNZ Tfa Z P<E<|rK`\�� ��Z KNy KNy<CFZ I;0LC��jKNCFPH\LZ R3PH\+2� ����� / � ]vZ�s C3sv��Z KNyKNy<COWYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<z \LCYK`\DRJT­z3RjR x \�KNyHGgKhINC�.Q|<Z INC�KNy<Cq\LC9Z P<E<|rK`\Fs@#ÉP EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]k�dCt��Z e eVINCYTfCFIKNRÏG \LCYK�- RJT�z3RjR x \tG3\tG 0LE<|<�<e Z[W1Z P<E<|rKJ2 ��y<CFP<CF_3CFI�KNy<CFINC Z[\tGJP�� M � \L|HW`y*KNyHGgK - � �����¡]7Z�s C3s5��y<CFP<CF_3CFI«KNy<CFINCOZ[\�\LR3MOC�����Z P<E<|rK«KNyHGgKtZ[\«INC�.Q|<Z INC x C��<G3W¡KNe a �jaÏGJe e­z3RjR x \hZ P�-ts�SCFPHWYCYTfR3ILKNy�]vG1E<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rKhZ[\SKNyj|H\D\LZ MOE<e a G WYCFILK`GJZ P \L|<�H\LCYKhRJT�z3RjR x \F]kGJP x KNy<C�\LCYKhRJT­GJe eE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\hZ[\hG WYR3e e CqW¡KNZ R3P RJTX\L|HW`yÏ\L|<�H\LCYK`\Fs �´y<C9E<INZ[WYC�RJT�KNy<C 0LZ P<E<|rKJ2.- /�� Z[\DKNy<CFPz3Z _3CFP��ja1KNy<CtGJz3z3INCFzQGgKNChWYRQ\bK�RJT�GJe e�����Z P<E<|rK`\´INC�.Q|<Z INC x C��<G3W¡KNe a �ja1KNy<C�z3RjR x \´Z P -97

243>7 � ��� � ! � # � 3

��� �

��Z KNy � � 7 ���9�ja WYR3Pj_3CFPQKNZ R3P�sVU�rE<INCq\N\LZ P<zOWYRQ\bK`\dZ P KNCFINM1\´RJT�KNy<C243 R3P<ChKNyj|H\´R3�rK`GJZ PH\dTfR3IGJe e �´]� ���-���

3�� � � 3�� ���243'J ���rs ���

*C´WFGJP�_jZ CF�*2OG3\�GDMOCqG3\L|<INCXR3P9� � GJP x ��INZ KNC 2 ���1�<7 � � 3���� 243�TfR3I�GJPjahT·GJMOZ e a� /-� � s�SRJKNC�KNyHGgKq]QZ P1z3CFP<CFI`GJe�]gKNy<CFINCS��Z e eH�kCSM1GJPja9\L|<�H\LCYK`\�--TfR3I­��y<Z[W`y.243�� �<]QGJP x R3�H\LCFIN_3CdKNyHGgKKNy<C«T·GJMOZ e a RJTVGJe e�E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\�Z[\´z3Z _3CFP��ja1KNy<C ��(-!�!#�1�'�� 7 � ��-+/ � 7 243 ?� � � RJT,2�s�da ���rs ���¡]rR3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\

L � ���-�,�1� ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-�,� 2 ����- 7 ��M - / ��� � � ���rs ���GJP x

\LajP ����� ��� ���-�,� 2 ����- 7 � ��� � � / - / � � � � � ���rs n'���y<CFINC � � x CFP<RJKNCq\�KNy<C WYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQKORJT ��Z P � s>�´y<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe´WYRQ\bKORJT � GgK ��Z[\�KNyj|H\z3Z _3CFP �ja�KNy<COGJz3z3INCFzQGgKNCtWYRQ\bKhRJTXGJe e�Z P<E<|rK`\DKNyHGgK�GJINC�INC�.Q|<Z INC x �ja � �<|rK�P<RJK«GJe INCqG x a�|H\LC x�ja \LR3MOC�z3RjR x Z P �´s ujZ MOZ e[GJINe a3]�KNy<C \LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x$� GgK ��C�.Q|HGJe[\OGJz3z3INCFzQGgKNCWYRQ\bK«RJT´GJe e�Z P<E<|rK`\�WYR3MOMOR3PÏKNR � GJP x�� KNyHGgKtGJINC9P<RJK�INC�.Q|<Z INC x �ja GJPja CFe CFMOCFPQK�RJT �´s�#ÉPEHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]XZ K Z[\1WYe CqGJIOTfINR3M ���rs ���9GJP x ���rs n'��KNyHGgK GJPja WYRQ\bKOTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�RJThKNy<C TfR3INM ���rs ���Z[\1MOR3P<RJKNR3P<C GJP x \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIq] x |<C KNR KNy<C P<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ Kba RJT�2�s@v R3INCFRg_3CFIq]­Z K Z[\ GJe[\LRCF_jZ x CFPQK«TfINR3M�KNy<COINZ z3yQKL��yHGJP x \LZ x C9RJT ���rs n'��KNyHGgKt\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\«GJINC x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z Z P �´]�Z�s C3svKNyHGgKKNy<C1CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\hRJT´\NWYR3EkC1GJINC1\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C3s6v R3INC9z3CFP<CFI`GJe e a3]5KNy<COy<Z z3y<CFIL��R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\RJT�GJPja�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P RJT�KNy<C�TfR3INM ���rs ���dyHGi_3CtGJe KNCFINPHGgKNZ P<z1\LZ z3P�]<�kCFz3Z P<P<Z P<z ��Z KNy GOEkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C\LZ z3P1TfR3IXKNy<C&,HI`\bK x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C��·\LCFC@�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs ���kCFe Rg� �¡s­uj|HW`y WYRQ\bKXTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\X��Z e ev�kChWFGJe e C xMOR3P<RJKNR3P<C1GJP x '7�'7*+8+ <0��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1 s1U�.Q|<Z _gGJe CFPQKNe a3]5KNy<C WYe[G3\N\«RJTXKNRJK`GJe e aÏ\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJItWYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\hWFGJP �kC�W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja KNy<C�E<INR3EkCFILKba KNyHGgKSKNy<C9GJ�H\LR3e |rKNCt_gGJe |<CtRJT­GJPja�y<Z z3y<CFIL�R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C Z[\ x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<zHs��<R3INM1GJe e a3]VTfR3IOGJPja � � � � = � J J J � ���� / � ] x C�,HP<C KNy<C

Page 10: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3ChRJT��S��Z KNy INCq\LEkCqW¡KdKNR � GgK � INCqWY|<I`\LZ _3CFe a9�ja H�� � ���-��7 � H � � � H ��� ��� � ��� ���-���¡sl MOR3P<RJKNR3P<COWYRQ\bKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*Z[\hKNRJK`GJe e a \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI«Z T´GJP x R3P<e a Z Tb]5TfR3I�GJe e�P<R3Pr��CFMOErKba � ]GJP x GJe e � � � � ]

� / ��� ��� H�� � ���-� � � � H�� � ����� � � J ���rs o��%D�H\LCFIN_3C9KNyHGgKO\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba*WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \hKNR KNy<C�WFG3\LC >� �&p3]�GJP x \L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _jZ Kba RJT\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�KNRÏKNy<C WFG3\LC >� �&�rs *C���Z e e´INCYTfCFI�KNR*MOR3P<RJKNR3P<C�GJP x KNRJK`GJe e a \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIWYRQ\bKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\tG3\«W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja 1"�&=�(K+ *1 \L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3COCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\hRJT´\NWYR3EkC3s��´y<C9KNCFINM0LINCFz3|<e[GJIJ2 \LCFCFM1\_ub|H\bKNZ ,HC x �ja KNy<C�T·G3W¡K9KNyHGgKOKNy<C�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[W�WYR3PQKNCFPQKORJThGÏEHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIOWYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P GJE<EkCqGJI`\dKNROINCq\LZ x C«Z P Z K`\<,HI`\bK´KNy<INCFC x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\Fs �

%'&�� � 0 <��)1)+�1 � �",/1).�� � .�<����E5��K>?1).�3 � 8 BE,/0���,/.� ��D9> �K3�� ,'3 11�T5� .��/3CBS5 14,/.

cXR3PH\LZ x CFIXP<Rg� G�MOR3P<RJKNR3P<ChGJP x KNRJK`GJe e aO\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI´WYRQ\bKXTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s�´y<ChGJ�kRg_3CSE<INRrWYC x |<INCTfR3I1GJz3z3INCFzQGgKNZ P<z E<INR x |HW¡KL��z3INR3|<E \LEkCqWYZ ,kW ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\OWFGJP �kC Z Pj_3CFILKNC x ]XG3\O\Ly<Rg��P �ja KNy<CTfR3e e Rg��Z P<zOINCq\L|<e Kqs��� p k#� p���� ���� f k[l���� �[�K� p"! k p ��i��\�$#2l&% p ��-i�k[l(' 5 �16*�#<����2'd��(K���2')���� � 7v� � � �'?/��21"�6�+*��:��'���*R(K�#���2(#�J�6��*3��(K1"� 2 �� � � $]'?/��J��� O ��*+8+ ��. WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC9v RjCF�<Z |H\DZ Pj_3CFI`\LC $a��(#��/'?/�*'MN*)BC,+�PO/��+ .3��$Z��C8�-C���(#��/�'?/�*'��2�1�*+8+ � $

� ���-�,� 2 ����- / � 7 -��!� ?�R# � �,� 3�� � � 3�� ���

243 �

E\/��21"� 243>7 � 2 ����- � � C�-�/��9�6��*3��(K1"� 2 /�*3�%'?/��Z�2�+8+ �EF�8�B=01"�&!�1"�����2�#'7*')�����C 5 �1J*+8+ - $

243�� �(3 � ��� � � N'� "�pB�/. ! 30� # A = J

� �1"���V�21�$ 2 �:�%����SO7���&=A*')�8V�9� �9*��.���#+ <6� � � �:�%'7�'7*+8+ <6��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1�C�´y<C�,HI`\bK1EHGJILK1Z[\ G \bK`GJP x GJI x INCq\L|<e K Z P-WYR3M��<Z PHGgKNR3INZ[WF\OGJP x KNy<C KNy<CFR3INa RJT«P<R3Pr�ÉG x<x Z KNZ _3CE<INR3�HGJ�<Z e Z KNZ Cq\&�·\LCFCT��RJK`G��bpqm3oJ���¡]jcXyHGgKNCqGJ|<P<CF|rT�GJP x�1 G �vI`Gia;�bpqm'�3m����¡s(�´y<CD\LCqWYR3P x EHGJILKq]QGJe[\LR�dCFe e � w P<Rg��P�]QTfR3e e Rg�S\dTfINR3M �´y<CFR3INCFM��rs ���kCFe Rg��s

�´y<ChP<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ Kba9RJT�KNy<C�WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCMv RjCF�<Z |H\dZ Pj_3CFI`\LC1�fy<CFPHWYCYTfR3ILKNy�7­WJs M s Z�s �9GJe e Rg�S\­|H\KNR�Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK«Z KtG3\«G ���3��'4.�������5!#�3���8')���� s�#ÉPÏKNy<C1�]v8 �C��<GJMOE<e COGJ�kRg_3CtKNy<C1WYRQ\bK x CqWYR3M9�EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P �´G3\DC��rR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\Le a�z3Z _3CFP�]vG3\SKNRJK`GJe�WYRQ\bK`\D�dCFINC�WYR3MOE<|rKNC x �HG3\LC x R3PÏE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LC x,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\«\LEkCqWYZ ,kW9KNR WYCFILK`GJZ P*z3INR3|<EH\DRJTdE<INR x |HW¡K`\Fs �SRg�dCF_3CFIq]5CF_3CFPÏZ TdKNy<COE<|<�<e Z[WOZ P<E<|rK`\GJINChP<RJK�EHGJILK´RJT7KNy<C«E<yjar\LZ[WFGJe x Cq\NWYINZ ErKNZ R3P�RJT�KNy<C«KNCqW`y<P<R3e R3z3a3]3KNy<C x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P ���rs ���XWFGJP\bKNZ e e7G x MOZ KDGJP�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WhZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�Z P�KNCFINM1\´RJT �8�5!�(K'7��. ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\F]r��Z KNy�KNy<C�_gGJe |<Cq\243 INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKNZ P<ztKNy<C@,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\dRJT7KNy<C«E<|<�<e Z[WhZ P<E<|rK`\ 0LZ MOE<|rKNC x 2tKNROC��<G3W¡KNe aOKNy<C«z3RjR x \dZ P-ts@�´y<CFR3INCFM&�rs p«KNyj|H\DCFPQK`GJZ e[\�KNyHGgKq]v|<E KNR�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3PH\SR3P x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\SRJT­R3I x CFI � � ��0LINCFzJ�|<e[GJINZ Kba 2��¡] *�#< WYRQ\bKtTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja \L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJTD\NWYR3EkC G x MOZ K`\\L|HW`y GOWYRQ\bK x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P�Z P KNCFINM1\�RJT�Z MOE<|rKNC x ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\Fs2 ²7�`§��«§��i�t�` g�`¨ �¡¦`Á §���§��i��§��i�b�¡�·Á �`¢­®��i�¡� ®b��µi i�i�b�D��� ��¥JÃ5�   §��g�N§S§��i�t�J�b�g�b¼q� �¡���`¨�®b�¡ Y§��b Y§«�`¢X�t¼Y�¡ ²7�bµi£S�` i qÒfª«�¡��¦¡�b i�·§��b�� hµq§�� ¨ � §@ÁS¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ «�`¨ £��¡�·§��LKq®b¨ µi��� ¼Y�b¨ ÁD���b��� �i�b�7�  D� §���Mg���·§5§��i���b�­�i�b��� ¼¡�N§�� ¼Y�b�X± ¢ �¡�5§��i��b®b�¡ i�¡£�� ®«®b�¡ Y§��b Y§«�`¢�§��i�«§��i� ��� �i�b��� ¼¡�N§�� ¼Y�¡Ã7���b�43V� £d�g�`¨ ¨�±·¶L¸¡¸¡ÂY¹·¹�º »gµi�·§��i�b��£��¡���¡Ã��`¨ ���9�   §��i� �S®b�¡ Y§��LKF§Lâ µi i®É§�� �¡ i�����N§�� �·¢ Áq�  i¦S§��i�´®b�¡ Y§��  Fµi�¡µi�X�` g�`¨ �¡¦¡µi���`¢�±[¿qº 5Y¹X±É©�£�� Kq�b�tµq§�� ¨ � §@Á«¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ i��°F¹��g�b¼Y�´�J�b�b t¢ �¡µi i��§���i¨ �bÁh�d�i� �·§��  i¦¡µi� ���i�b�h���¡¨ �¡Ãi���b�XÀ5�`�g�`¨ ¨76�­�` i�h³<�¡£S�` i��¥YÁ�±·¶L¸¡¸85Y¹�º

Page 11: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

�´y<C�|H\LC�RJT&�fP<R3Pr�ÉWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCB�Yv RjCF�<Z |H\SZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P�Z[\S\bK`GJP x GJI x Z P KNy<Cte Z KNCFI`GgKN|<INC«R3P WYRQ\bK\LyHGJINZ P<z \LZ PHWYC ujyHGJE<e CFa$�bpqmQnJ���¡s %hWFWFG3\LZ R3PHGJe e a3]7R3P<C GJe[\LR8,HP x \�INCYTfCFINCFPHWYCOKNRÏZ K`\9WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCTfR3INM�G3\ x C�,HP<C x y<CFINC3s �<R3I1Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3] R3|<P<z �bpqm3mJ����INCYTfCFI`\�KNR WYRQ\bKOTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\1��Z KNy KNy<CINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P ���rs ����G3\�0 x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\NGJ�<e C3s 21�dRJKNy R3|<P<z �bpqm3mJ�H]HE�svm3����GJP x v R3|<e Z P>�bpqm'�'�<]E�s3pF�Q���kP<RJKNC�KNyHGgK�Z P«KNy<C�KNRJK`GJe e a«\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI�WFG3\LC3]FKNy<CdujyHGJE<e CFah_gGJe |<CXG x MOZ K`\7G�EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJINe a\LZ MOE<e ChGJP x Z PQKN|<Z KNZ _3CSINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P�s(#�K´GJMOR3|<PQK`\�KNR�G3\N\LZ z3P<Z P<zH]JTfR3I´GJPja9Z MOE<e Z[WYZ KdZ P<E<|rKq]rGJPC�.Q|HGJe�WYRQ\bKS\LyHGJINChKNROCqG3W`y�z3RjR x KNyHGgKS|H\LCq\´Z K�7 �� � � ��� � 3�� �����. 3 slD\­GhTfR3INM1GJe<INCq\L|<e Kq]��´y<CFR3INCFM �rs pSWFGJPORJT5WYR3|<I`\LC�R3P<e a9\LCqWY|<INCdKNy<CSe R3z3Z[WFGJerEkRQ\N\LZ �<Z e Z Kba�RJT5GubR3Z PQKXE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rKXZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�s(�´y<CSM1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe e a�Z x CFPQKNZ ,HC x Z P<E<|rK`\­P<CFC x P<RJKXP<CqWYCq\b�\NGJINZ e a1�kC�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e a1MOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e 6<\LCFCtujCqW¡KNZ R3P �Hs ph�kCFe Rg� TfR3ISGJP�C��<GJMOE<e C3s��SR3P<CYKNy<CFe Cq\N\F]�´y<CFR3INCFM��rs pOCq\bK`GJ�<e Z[\Ly<Cq\hKNy<C1INCFM1GJI w GJ�<e C9z3CFP<CFI`GJe Z Kba RJTXKNy<C4ubR3Z PQKtE<|<�<e Z[W1Z P<E<|rK + *�B=�(#*�=A�TfR3I�K`GJe w Z P<z GJ�kR3|rKDCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT­\NWYR3EkC *3�9� � R3INZ z3Z PHGgKNZ P<zOTfINR3MgubR3Z PQKDE<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rK`\Fs�v R3INCY�Rg_3CFIq]QZ P ujCqW¡KNZ R3P��Hs �t�dC«E<INRg_jZ x C«G9\LZ MOE<e C�\L| 5 WYZ CFPQKSWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P�|<P x CFI���y<Z[W`y KNy<C«CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WMOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e P<Cq\N\´RJT�KNy<C�Z MOE<|rKNC x Z P<E<|rK`\�Z[\S\LCqWY|<INC x slD\­G ,HI`\bK­Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNZ R3P�]3WYR3PH\LZ x CFI­GJzQGJZ P�KNy<C�C��<GJMOE<e C´RJT5\LCFIN_jZ P<z�\bKNR3INCq\�Z POKNy<C�e Z P<CqGJI­WYZ Kba3s

ujCFIN_jZ P<z G�\bKNR3INC � INC�.Q|<Z INCq\DKNy<COZ P<E<|rK80 x INZ _jZ P<z TfINR3M � " p�KNR � s 2 �´y<Z[\«Z P<E<|rK�Z[\«Z PÏT·G3W¡K\LyHGJINC x �ja GJe e�\bKNR3INCq\­KNyHGgKSGJINCDT·GJILKNy<CFI´R3|rK´KNyHGJP � s��SCFPHWYC3]jTfR3I´CqG3W`y � ]jKNy<C�\LCYK � ��� J J J � � � Z[\GOE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rKh��Z KNy�2������ � � � � � �«G3\´KNy<C�KNI`GJPH\LEkR3ILK`GgKNZ R3P WYRQ\bKSRJT x INZ _jZ P<zOTfINR3M � " p�KNR � s<#ÉPG x<x Z KNZ R3P�]vCqG3W`y \bKNR3INC � INC�.Q|<Z INCq\DGJP Z x Z RQ\LajPHWYI`GgKNZ[W�Z P<E<|rK�� ��� ��Z KNy�2������ �= INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKNZ P<zKNy<C�WYRQ\bK�RJT�|<P<e RQG x Z P<zHs��´y<CtWJs M s Z�sHRJT�KNy<C�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P&� ���-��� �N��!> �-� � M1G � � Z[\´KNyj|H\R3�rK`GJZ P<C x �ja�\LCYKLKNZ P<z

243��� �

p Z T�-+�+� ��� J J J � � � TfR3I � : � � Z T�-+�+� ��� TfR3I � : � �p � Z T�-+�+�)� � �� RJKNy<CFIN��Z[\LC�J

#ÉP1RJKNy<CFI­�dR3I x \F]gKNy<CDWYRQ\bK x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNR3P9RJTvKNy<C�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P!� ���-�,� "NJ�!> �-� � M1G � �*Z P9KNCFINM1\RJT�ubR3Z PQK´E<|<�<e Z[WDZ P<E<|rK`\´Z[\dz3Z _3CFP �jaOZ MOE<|rKNZ P<zOR3P<ChWYRQ\bKL��|<P<Z KdKNR9CqG3W`y \LCYKdKNyHGgK�WYR3PH\LZ[\bK`\XRJT�GJe e\bKNR3INCq\�KNyHGgK�GJINCtT·GJILKNy<CFI«Gi�´Gia TfINR3M�KNy<CO\bK`GJILKNZ P<z EkR3Z PQKhKNyHGJP*\LR3MOC�z3Z _3CFPÏ\bKNR3INC � ]�GJP x GJP|<P<e RQG x Z P<z�WYRQ\bKhRJT �KNR�CqG3W`yÏ\LZ P<z3e C9\bKNR3INC;�·\LCFC���Z z3|<INC1�'�¡s �SRJKNC�KNyHGgKhKNy<C1,A�rC x WYRQ\bK 2���� �Z MOE<|rKNC x KNR KNy<C�T·GJILKNy<Cq\bKh\bKNR3INC9\L|<�H\L|<MOCq\D�kRJKNy KNy<C�KNI`GJPH\LEkR3ILK`GgKNZ R3P WYRQ\bKDTfINR3M � "-ptKNR �GJP x KNy<C�|<P<e RQG x Z P<z1WYRQ\bKSGgK9��s

������¶ ������

¿ ��������� ¿ ��������� ¶ �������sss�sNs �� ���� ���� ���� ��5 � =�(K1"��) 7��*�'7�2���������*+8+ <���.��2�#')� �Y��.4!�(#H2+ ���9�8�!�(K'��%�8�L'?/��9+ �8����*1��2�8')<

�´y<C­TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zDINCq\L|<e K�\Ly<Rg�S\�KNyHGgK�KNy<C´WJs M s Z�sJ\LZ M�|<e K`GJP<CFR3|H\Le a x Cq\NWYINZ �kCq\7KNy<C´WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PGJP x GJe evZ K`\ x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\Fs­ujZ PHWYC x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\XE<e[Gia \L|HW`y G9WYCFPQKNI`GJevINR3e ChZ P KNy<C�GJPHGJe ar\LZ[\dRJTVWYRQ\bKTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\F]<Z KD\Ly<Rg�S\´GgKDG9E<|<INCFe a M1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe�e CF_3CFevKNy<C�Z MOEkR3ILK`GJPHWYC«RJT7KNy<CtWJs M s Z�s��� p k#� p���� �! �2' �37´� � � � H��L*I���2'Y��(K���2')����>EF�8'?/G�-C �6C ��C 2 C 5 �1L*+8+ � *��. *+8+����SO �2�5!�')< � / � $

H�� � ���-�,� � "�pB�/. � A = N 2 ����- 7 � / - / � � � ��J

m

Page 12: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

��G w Z P<z � �1-�GJP x ���1- � Z P8�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs ��R3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\XKNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zO\LZ MOE<e C�INCFE<INCq\LCFPr�K`GgKNZ R3P�RJT�KNy<CtWJs M s Z�sf k#�k h�h �K� q � �� �2' �@7Q� � ��� H���*O���2'[��(K���2')���� EF�8'?/L�-C �6C ��C 2 C 5 �1J*+8+sXM$

243��RH�3�� � - � � N'� "�pB�/. 3 A = J%D�H\LCFIN_3C�KNyHGgK«�kRJKNy*INCq\L|<e K`\hGJE<E<e a KNR�GJIN�<Z KNI`GJINa \LCYKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\Fs"#ÉPÏEHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]HKNy<COC�.Q|<Z _gGg�e CFPHWYChRJT7P<R3Pr��P<CFzQGgKNZ _jZ KbaORJT�2�GJP x KNRJK`GJe5\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba1RJT �SZ[\´GJP Z MOMOC x Z[GgKNC«WYR3PH\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYCRJT�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �rs �

�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �tWFGJP �kCh|H\LC x KNR x CFMOR3PH\bKNI`GgKNCSKNy<C«INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3CFP<Cq\N\­RJT(.Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WSWYRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡�KNZ R3PH\F]jKNy<CFINCF�ja1|<P x CFINe Z P<Z P<z9KNy<C«INR3e ChRJT�KNy<Z I x GJP x y<Z z3y<CFIL��R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\Fs­uj|<E<EkRQ\LChKNyHGgKTfR3IhGJe e ��� � GJP x GJe e �-��Z KNy � ��� ��� � � � #r]HKNy<C9\LajP<CFINz3a�\LajP ����� ��� ���-���kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x � Z[\\bKNINZ[W¡KNe aOEkRQ\LZ KNZ _3CD�<|rK x RjCq\XP<RJK x CFEkCFP x R3P �´s��da)�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �r]3KNy<Z[\XZ MOE<e Z Cq\­KNyHGgKdKNy<Ch\L|<Er�EkR3ILK�RJT�KNy<CtWYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<z9WJs M s Z�s 2 WYR3PH\LZ[\bK`\´C��<G3W¡KNe a1RJT�GJe e5R3P<CY�XGJP x Kb�dRJ��CFe CFMOCFPQK�\L|<�H\LCYK`\RJT � ]rZ�s C3s � � � � ��� � � 7 ��� � M � � s�#ÉP�EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIq]rR3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\´�ja ���rs ���¡]rTfR3ISGJe e �´]

� ���-�'� p� � � � ��� ��� � � ���rs � �

GJP x MOR3INCXz3CFP<CFI`GJe e a3] � ���;I'� ��� =" � � � L � � � �¡s��SRJKNC­KNyHGgK����rs � ��Z[\7CqG3\LZ e a«_jZ R3e[GgKNC x ��y<CFPM1GJPja9z3RjR x \�Z P�� \LyHGJINCSGtWYR3MOMOR3P1Z P<E<|rKq]QC3s zHs3��y<CFPOKNy<CFINCDGJINCS\LZ z3P<Z ,kWFGJPQKXRg_3CFINy<CqG x WYRQ\bK`\Fs�SCFPHWYC3]vMOR x CFe e Z P<z G WYRQ\bKSTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*G3\ .Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[W«CFPQK`GJZ e[\hG \bKNINR3P<z .Q|HGJPQKNZ K`GgKNZ _3Cte Z MOZ K`GgKNZ R3PR3P KNy<C�C��jKNCFPQKSRJT�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\FslSPHGJe R3z3R3|H\Le a3]´G _gGJP<Z[\Ly<Z P<z ��� � pB����KNy x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C MOCqGJPH\F]��ja��´y<CFR3INCFM,�rs �r]dKNyHGgK�GJe e

E<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK`\DGJINCt\LyHGJINC x �ja GgKSMORQ\bK�� z3RjR x \F]<��y<Z[W`y Z MOE<e Z Cq\�� ���-��� =� � � � � ��� ��� �dTfR3IGJe e �´s

%'&�� ���3 � BS1 ��11�43CD93 ��:'�K> ���T5 ,98�:�� 5��E1 �����E1 �/3 :"A�.�3CBED/14365lD\ �dC yHGi_3C \LCFCFP�]´KNy<C*GJE<E<e Z[WFGJ�<Z e Z Kba RJT«KNy<C�ubR3Z PQK�E<|<�<e Z[W Z P<E<|rK Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�]´Z�s C3sXKNy<CZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P RJT´KNy<C�WJs M s Z�sVG3\tG WYRQ\bK x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P�]VZ[\te Z MOZ KNC x KNR KNy<C�WFG3\LC1RJTS\L|<�H\bKNZ �KN|rKNZ _3C1CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\«RJT�\NWYR3EkC8� x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z \LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\J�¡s)�´y<Z[\tWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P Z[\«P<RJK�G3\«INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3CG3\hZ K�M1Gia GJE<EkCqGJIq]�\LZ PHWYC1\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _jZ Kba RJT´\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\DZ[\«CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e a MOR3INC9PHGgKN|<I`GJe�KNyHGJPKNy<CFZ I WYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQK`GJINZ Kba3s>�´y<Z[\OZ PQKN|<Z KNZ R3P Z[\1WYR3P ,HINMOC x �ja KNy<C�T·G3W¡KOKNyHGgK WYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQK`GJINa�fZ�s C3srZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z��X\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\dZ MOEkRQ\LC�\bKNINR3P<z9INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3PH\XR3P KNy<C�Rg_3CFI`GJe eHC��jKNCFPQKSRJTV\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\F]G3\´C��rE<INCq\N\LC x �ja KNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z9Z P<C�.Q|HGJe Z Kba3s,�<R3ISGJe e � ]

� � � � �����

\LajP ����� ��� � #'�"! � ��� ��� ��J =�

#ÉP KNCFINM1\hRJT�KNRJK`GJe�WYRQ\bKq]5WYR3MOE<e CFMOCFPQK`GJINa \LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\SCFPQK`GJZ e�KNy<CO\NGJMOC9\bKNINR3P<z INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3PG3\dKNy<C9.Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WDMOR x CFe��·W¡Tbs ���rs � ���H7� Àv�i�/NFµi�ɧ�±·¶L¸¡Ð¡ÎqÃV¯F�b®É§LºV¶EIO�` i� ¿85Y¹´�  Y§����F�iµi®b�b� §��`§��`¨ ¨ Á ��µi�i£��F�iµi¨ �`�����ɧ�¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ i�D�  1§��b��£����`¢�§��i��`¨ §��b�� g�N§��  i¦d��� ¦¡ S�`¢Q§��i�V�i� ¦¡�i�b�·Ò@�¡���i�b�5�i�b��� ¼¡�N§�� ¼Y�b�V± §��Fµi��®L�`¨ ¨ �  i¦­§��i�b£�©��`¨ §��b�� g�N§��  i¦d�`¢r�  �Mg i� §����¡���i�b��°F¹�Ãi�` i���µi¦¡¦¡�b�·§��b�X§��g�N§<§��i�ÉÁX�F®b®bµi�<£��¡���<¢ ���ENFµi�b Y§�¨ ÁX�` i�X���b�b£Ï£��¡���Hµi���É¢ µi¨F§��g�` ­§��`§��`¨ ¨ Á­��µi�J�b��£��F�iµi¨ �`�r�¡ i�b�5± �J�b¨ � �É¢¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ i�ɹ�ºvÈ7���i� �D i�`§��·§��N§��­���i�b�¡���b£-¿qº ¿X i�¡�VÀv�¡���¡¨ ¨ �`�·ÁD¿qº ¶� i�J�`§��«���b�b£ §��´�J�� i�ɤ­ºC�� »g�¡�­¼Y�b��� Mg®L�N§�� �¡ QÃH¨ �ɧ������������ C ��� � � ����� �YÃH�` i�O�¡�i���b�·¼Y��§��g�N§ � �! " C �·Áq  $'&)( *�# + ± ��$%������� C ��� � � ��� ! �`¹&�' & ±)(Y¹ �*' & ± �+$,���-�`¹,. 0 ±����-�`¹�ºX���i�d�·§��N§��b���  i�ENFµg�`¨ � §@Á�§��Fµi�V¢ �¡¨ ¨ �L¤7��¢ ���¡£-§��i�´�`����µi£��q§�� �¡ t�`¢v�  i®b���L�`�·Ò�  i¦t�·Áq i�b��¦¡� �b�Lº1²7�`§��D§��g�N§LÃ5�YÁO®b�¡ Y§����`�·§LÃ5�  9§��i�h��µi�i�·§�� §�µq§�� ¼Y�h®L�`���h�¡ i�h®L�`  �¡ i¨ ÁO�i�b�iµi®b�D§��i�h�  i�ENFµg�`¨ � §@Á

� *0/21&3 $'&-+ �·Áq  $'&)( *�+ ±)(Y¹4. ± � � ¶N¹65 0 ±����-�`¹�ºpq�

Page 13: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

��� p k#� p���� �� �2' � 77� � � � H��6�6����'7�����*��.Q��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1�C 5 (K1�'?/��21��6�1"��$4*3����(K�6�'?/�*'�$Y�2�1L*+8+ ��� �[$%��<� ����� ��� �4N � �:�0�8���21"��*3���8�B=$J��C8�-CM'?/�*'9'?/��0'?/B�81". .��21��8V*')�8V�I� � � �:�0����SO!#�3���8')�8V�O�2V�21�<E\/��21"�-C -�/��2��$[�2�1�*+8+ � $

� ���-�'� p� � � � ��� ��� ��J

�da WYR3MOEHGJINZ[\LR3P�]­\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C \LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�CFPQK`GJZ e´P<R GJPHGJe R3z3R3|H\tINCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3P �kCFa3R3P x MOR3P<RJ�KNR3P<Z[WYZ Kba3�fZ�s C3s(� ���-��� M1G � � � �� ��� ��� �� =

. � � � � ��� ��� ���¡s �´y<C�GJPHGJe R3z3a KNR Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\SR3PKNy<C«INCqGJeke Z P<C«M1Gia1�kChZ PH\bKNIN|HW¡KNZ _3C3s�#�T�� 74# � ��� �9��� Z[\dZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z9GJP x WYR3PHWFGi_3C3]JKNy<CFP�Z K�Z[\P<RJKDEkRQ\N\LZ �<e C«KNyHGgKDZ K`\�KNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C�Z[\D\bKNINZ[W¡KNe a P<CFzQGgKNZ _3C�CF_3CFINaj��y<CFINC3s =+=��da WYR3PQKNI`G3\bKq]<Z KZ[\´EkCFILTfCqW¡KNe a EkRQ\N\LZ �<e C«KNyHGgK�Z K`\´KNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C«Z[\�\bKNINZ[W¡KNe a EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C«CF_3CFINaj��y<CFINC3slD\��dC­yHGi_3C­GJe INCqG x ahGJINz3|<C x Z P�KNy<CdWYR3PQKNC��jK7RJTA.Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[W�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\F]iKNy<C­INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3PH\

x Cq\NWYINZ �kC x GJ�kRg_3CS��Z e eH�kCD|<P x Cq\LZ I`GJ�<e CSZ P M1GJPjaOWFG3\LCq\F]JTfR3IXZ PH\bK`GJPHWYCSKNy<CFaOGJINCSCqG3\LZ e a9_jZ R3e[GgKNC x��y<CFP9Rg_3CFINy<CqG x WYRQ\bK`\�GJINC´\LZ z3P<Z ,kWFGJPQKqs �<INR3M�KNy<Z[\��dC´WYR3PHWYe | x CdKNyHGgK�KNy<C�WFG3\LCXRJTv\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\dZ[\dKNy<C��ja T·GJI�MOR3INC«INCFe CF_gGJPQK�WFG3\LC«Z P GJE<E<e Z[WFGgKNZ R3PH\Fs

%'&�� *�;>?0 <��4365�´y<C9WYRQ\bK x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P Z P KNCFINM1\DRJTXWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC�v RjCF�<Z |H\DZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P GJe e Rg�S\SR3P<CtKNR MOR x CFeWYRQ\bKtTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\tKNy<INR3|<z3y GJE<E<INR3E<INZ[GgKNC *O!�1����1�� INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3PH\tR3P KNy<C EHGgKLKNCFINP RJT´KNy<C E<|<�<e Z[WZ P<E<|rK`\Fs#ÉP KNy<Z[\�\L|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P�]r�dC«E<INCq\LCFPQKdKb�dRO\LZ MOE<e C�GJP x �HG3\LZ[WDC��<GJMOE<e Cq\/6rZ P ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �<]j�dCx CF_3CFe R3E G3\�G9MOR3INC«CFe[GJ�kR3I`GgKNChC��<GJMOE<e C�G9MOR x CFe�RJT�\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC«e CqGJINP<Z P<zHscXR3PH\LZ x CFIhGJzQGJZ P KNy<C�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PÏRJTX�]v8 \«G3\ x Cq\NWYINZ �kC x Z P uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs �1GJ�kRg_3C3s«l

x Z[\bKNZ PHW¡KNZ _3C­TfCqGgKN|<INCXRJTrKNyHGgKVC��<GJMOE<e C­Z[\�KNyHGgKVE<|<�<e Z[W­Z P<E<|rK`\VGJINC ������'7��. 75TfR3IVGJPjaDKb�dRSE<INR x |HW¡KL�z3INR3|<EH\�WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<z KNR�KNy<C E<|<�<e Z[WOZ P<E<|rK`\�- GJP x� ]7INCq\LEkCqW¡KNZ _3CFe a3]7R3P<C1yHG3\ - / R3I / -���y<CFP<CF_3CFI - � ?� #rs�#ÉP-RJKNy<CFIO�dR3I x \F]­E<|<�<e Z[W Z P<E<|rK`\ x R P<RJK �fP<R3Pr��KNINZ _jZ[GJe e aA�Rg_3CFINe[GJE�s��´y<ChTfR3e e Rg��Z P<z�,Hz3|<INC«Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNCq\dKNy<Z[\�E<INR3EkCFILKba3s

��

��

�� �� �� ������� �K� �� ���� ������� �K�

�� �� �)������� �� ���)��� �

� "!# s@s@s � $!# � $!# s@s@s � "!#s@s@s sNsNs �� ��� $!# s@s@s � $!#� �-� � s@s@s&%' 3(

5 � =�(K1"� + 7�Xg/B���21"*1"��/B<0� �Z!�(#H2+ ���J�8�!�(K'��

#ÉP z3CFP<CFI`GJe�]rG�T·GJMOZ e a�� /�� � ��Z e e��kCtWFGJe e C x G N&'7*/*B���������7P�/B���21"*1"��/B< Z T�TfR3ISGJe e�- � M �1]-;� ?�R#tZ MOE<e Z Cq\ � -0/ R3I /*-@�¡s­lDWFWYR3I x Z P<z3e a3]rG�WYRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P �@7Q� � � � ��Z e e5�kCWFGJe e C xR/B���21"*1"��/B����*+ Z T5KNy<Ch\L|<E<EkR3ILK � RJT�Z K`\dWJs M s Z�sQZ[\XG�y<Z CFI`GJI`W`yja3s�lD\XZ[\­CF_jZ x CFPQKXTfINR3M ��Z zHsj�Z P ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs ��GJ�kRg_3C3]3KNy<C«WYRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P � ���-�,� NB�!> �-� � M1G � � |H\LC x Z P KNy<C«C��<GJMOE<e CDRJT\LCFIN_jZ P<z�\bKNR3INCq\XZ P KNy<Che Z P<CqGJI´WYZ KbaOZ[\´GJe[\LRty<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJe�sVlD\dGJP<RJKNy<CFIdZ PH\bK`GJPHWYCDRJT7y<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJe\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC3]<WYR3PH\LZ x CFIdKNy<C�Z PQKNINR x |HW¡KNR3INa1C��<GJMOE<e C«RJT���INZ KNZ P<zOCqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\´INCq\LCqGJI`W`y EHGJEkCFI`\Fs�#ÉPCLC ���i� �V� �V�L�`��� ¨ Á«���b�b t�YÁ�®b�¡ i��� �i�b���  i¦S§��i��Mg���·§V�i�b��� ¼¡�N§�� ¼Y�*),+fºXÇkÁ��`����µi£��q§�� �¡ QÃ-),+v� �V i�¡ qÒ@ i�b¦Y�N§�� ¼Y���` i��i�b®b���L�`���  i¦��ɼY�b�·ÁF¤7�i�b���¡º5Àv¨ �L�`��¨ ÁYÃq�  D§��i� ��®L�`���.),+<£dµi�·§��g�b¼Y�­�d®b�¡ Y¼Y�LK«�g�`�·§Lº

p3p

Page 14: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

KNy<Z[\�WYR3PQKNC��jKq]JGDINCqG3\LR3PHGJ�<e CX\bK`GJILKNZ P<zhEkR3Z PQKVZ[\�KNR x C x |HWYCdKNy<CdE<|<�<e Z[WdZ P<E<|rK`\�TfINR3M�KNy<C�� �(K1���*+� �J������������� �8'7�21"*')(K1"� WYe[G3\N\LZ ,kWFGgKNZ R3P \Lar\bKNCFM&TfR3I�INCq\LCqGJI`W`y*GJILKNZ[WYe Cq\Fs)�´y<C G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P*Z[\KNyj|H\�KNyHGgK­CqG3W`y��·\L|<�r�E�bWFGgKNCFz3R3INa�RJTvGJILKNZ[WYe Cq\F]J\L|HW`y1G3\@0NBGv Z[WYINRjCqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WF\F] 2�0NB«�@?­INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PGJP x %DINzQGJP<Z :qGgKNZ R3PH\F] 2�R3I�0NB«�g�)?­INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�] 2OINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`\�GOE<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK«WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<z�KNRKNy<C*WYR3MOMOR3P WYR3PHWYCFErK`\ GJP x Z x CqG3\ G3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x ��Z KNy�KNyHGgK�WFGgKNCFz3R3INa3s ?­INRg_jZ x C x KNyHGgK GJPjaINCq\LCqGJI`W`ytEHGJEkCFI�WFGJP9�kC´|<PHGJM��<Z z3|<R3|H\Le atG3\N\LZ z3P<C x KNR«C��<G3W¡KNe a�R3P<C�\L|<�vWFGgKNCFz3R3INa�GgKVKNy<C´e Rg�dCq\bKe CF_3CFe-�·\L|HW`y G3\F]jC3s zHs-0NB«�g� ?­INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P 2��¡]jKNy<C�INCq\L|<e KNZ P<z9T·GJMOZ e a RJTVE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\�C��ry<Z �<Z K`\�Gy<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJe<\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC3s��´y<CDZ PQKNCFINCq\bKXZ P \LZ MOE<e CDEHGgKLKNCFINPH\­RJT5Z P<E<|rK`\d\L|HW`y1yHG3\­G�y<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJeR3INzQGJP<Z :qGgKNZ R3P�e Z Cq\SZ P KNy<C�T·G3W¡KDKNyHGgKh\L|HW`y EHGgKLKNCFINPH\�RJT@KNCFP WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x KNR \LEkCqWYZ ,kW«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PHGJeTfR3INM1\VRJTkKNy<CDWYRQ\bKVTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s��<R3I­Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]J�ja��´y<CFR3INCFM �<s p´Z P!�SCFy<INZ P<z�GJP x ?­|<E<EkC9���J�3�Q�'�¡]GÏWYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P Z[\�y<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJeXZ ThGJP x R3P<e a Z TSKNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJedWYRQ\bK9RJTDE<INR x |HWYZ P<z � z3Z _3CFPG \LCYK9RJT�z3RjR x \ ��C�.Q|HGJe[\«KNy<C MOZ P<Z M1GJedM1GJINz3Z PHGJeXWYRQ\bK9RJT � z3Z _3CFP GJPja ���8�B=�+ � z3RjR x Z P �´]Z�s C3sEL � ���-���-MOZ P � � 'L � ��� � � �¡slD\hG x Z �vCFINCFPQK«C��<GJMOE<e C�RJTdG x<x Z KNZ R3PHGJe�.Q|HGJe Z K`GgKNZ _3C�\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC3]5\L|<E<EkRQ\LC�KNyHGgKhz3RjR x \hGJINCx Cq\NWYINZ �kC x �ja Kb�dR .Q|HGJe Z Kba x Z MOCFPH\LZ R3PH\FsSUSs zHs ]kWFGJI`\�M1Gia��kC x Cq\NWYINZ �kC x �ja KNy<CFZ ID�kR x a � = M� = � �iWYR3|<EkC � \LC x GJP � \bK`GgKNZ R3Pr���´GJz3R3P � ]�GJP x KNy<C y<R3I`\LCFEkRg�dCFI�RJT´KNy<CFZ I9CFP<z3Z P<C � " M � " ��QpinJ� � �J�3� � �3nJ� � �·\LCFC!��Z z3|<INCO� �kCFe Rg� �¡s�l 0Lz3RjR x 2 � M � �2� =�� � " Z[\«KNyj|H\tG�KbajEkC1RJTE<INR x |HW¡KhI`GgKNy<CFI�KNyHGJPÏGJP Z P x Z _jZ x |HGJe�E<yjar\LZ[WFGJe7R3�KubCqW¡Kq]vGJP x � ���-� x Cq\NWYINZ �kCq\DG ,HINM!� \hWYRQ\bKDRJT�kCFZ P<zDGJ�<e C�KNRDE<INR x |HWYC�KNy<C­I`GJP<z3C�RJT<z3RjR x \ �´s *CXE<Z[W¡KN|<INC­E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�RJTrz3RjR x \7G3\�Z Pj_3R3e _jZ P<zCFe CFMOCFPQK`GJINa E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P E<INRrWYCq\N\LCq\Fs cXRQ\bK`\OGJINZ[\LC TfINR3M KNy<C WFGJEHGJ�<Z e Z Kba RJTDEkCFILTfR3INMOZ P<zÏKNy<CE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P E<INRrWYCq\N\LCq\dINC�.Q|<Z INC x �ja GJPja1z3RjR x Z P KNy<C«I`GJP<z3C3sVUXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\dRJT�\NWYR3EkC«R3INZ z3Z PHGgKNCZ P x Z �vCFINCFPQK1z3RjR x \9INC�.Q|<Z INZ P<zÏKNy<C \NGJMOC�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P E<INRrWYCq\N\LCq\F]­y<CFPHWYC \LyHGJINZ P<z KNy<C \NGJMOCCFe CFMOCFPQK`GJINa WYR3MOEkCYKNCFPHWYZ Cq\"� ��E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\J�¡s

� � �

� � �

� � �

���-�����

�-�)�����

���-�����

� � � � ��� � � " � � � � � )" �� ��� )"

5 � =�(K1"��� 7�X ')EZ� O .�8�6�2���������*+�=A�-�-.6�)!#*����

#ÉP KNy<Z[\1WYR3PQKNC��jKq]­Z K \LCFCFM1\9PHGgKN|<I`GJedKNR G3\N\L|<MOC KNyHGgKOKNy<C WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<zÏZ P<E<|rK`\OyHGi_3C KNy<CTfR3INM�RJT90LINCqW¡K`GJP<z3|<e[GJIJ2O\L|<�H\LCYK`\DRJT9� =�� � " 7�Z T � GJP x �\LyHGJINC�G WYR3MOMOR3P Z P<E<|rKq]kKNy<CFP*\LRx RjCq\«GJPja z3RjR x � KNyHGgK«Z[\�0LZ PQKNCFINMOC x Z[GgKNC�2 �kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x �Z P*�kRJKNy .Q|HGJe Z Kba x Z MOCFPH\LZ R3PH\Fs#ÉP KNy<C9E<INCq\LCFPQKhC��<GJMOE<e C3]kKNy<C9PHGgKN|<I`GJe�R3I x CFINZ P<zQ\ x Cq\NWYINZ �<Z P<z KNCqW`y<P<R3e R3z3Z[WFGJe 0L�kCYKb�dCFCFP<P<Cq\N\+2GJINC z3Z _3CFP �jaÄpinJ�g��y<E : �J�3�g��y<E : �3nJ�g��y<E R3P@� = ]´GJP x �ja WYR3|<EkC : \LC x GJP : \bK`GgKNZ R3Pr��´GJz3R3P*R3P7� " ]VG3\ x CFE<Z[W¡KNC x Z P$��Z z3|<INC1�Hs;�´y<C1INCqW¡K`GJP<z3|<e[GJIt\LyHGJEkC1RJT�E<|<�<e Z[W1Z P<E<|rK`\t��Z KNyINCq\LEkCqW¡KDKNR KNy<Cq\LC�R x CFINZ P<zQ\SZ MOE<e Z Cq\F]vTfR3IhZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]kKNyHGgK�G��J�3�g��y<E \LC x GJP � �dR3|<e x \LyHGJINC�GJe eCFe CFMOCFPQK`GJINaÏWYR3MOEkCYKNCFPHWYZ Cq\«KNyHGgK�GJINC1WYR3MOMOR3P<e a P<CFC x C x TfR3ItE<INR x |HWYZ P<z G �3nJ�g��y<E*\LC x GJP �GJP x G �J�3�g��y<EÏWYR3|<EkC Hs9lD\«Z[\«CqG3\LZ e a _3CFINZ ,HC x ]vKNy<Z[\«CFPQK`GJZ e[\hKNyHGgKt\LajP ����� ��� ���-� � � TfR3I�GJPja��� � ]kZ�s C3sHKNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bKDRJT �f�kCFZ P<z�GJ�<e CtKNR���E<INR x |HWYZ P<z � Z[\DP<RJKDTf|<ILKNy<CFIhINC x |HWYC x �jaE<INRg_jZ x Z P<z KNy<C1GJ�<Z e Z Kba KNR E<INR x |HWYC �z3Z _3CFP KNyHGgK«KNy<C1E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PÏE<INRrWYCq\N\LCq\hINC�.Q|<Z INC x �ja �GJINCDGJe INCqG x a9Gi_gGJZ e[GJ�<e C3s��´yj|H\F]3KNy<C *�!�1����1�� G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P RJT5KNy<CDINCqW¡K`GJP<z3|<e[GJIX\LyHGJEkCDRJT�E<|<�<e Z[W

pi�

Page 15: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

Z P<E<|rK`\SajZ CFe x \�KNy<C�KNCq\bK`GJ�<e C�Z MOE<e Z[WFGgKNZ R3P KNyHGgKSKNy<CFINC�Z[\SP<R1INCFM1GJZ P<Z P<z \LajP<CFINz3a �kCYKb�dCFCFP Kb�dRz3RjR x \ � GJP x �R3PHWYC9GJPÏZ PQKNCFINMOC x Z[GgKNC�z3RjR x&� Z[\«GJe INCqG x a �kCFZ P<z�E<INR x |HWYC x s"�´y<COC��<GJMOE<e CZ[\hGJP Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC�RJT­KNy<C 0LE<INR x |HW¡KhRJT­e Z P<Cq\+2 GJP x WFGJP �kCOGJPHGJe a�:FC x Z PÏMOR3INC x CYK`GJZ eV|H\LZ P<z KNy<CKNRjR3e[\´E<INRg_jZ x C x Z P �SCFy<INZ P<z8�bpqm3m3m��XGJP x �SCFy<INZ P<z GJP x ?­|<E<EkC����J�3�Q�'�¡s

� ��� ������ ����� ��"�-�8�/�� �/� �)� �T���

*C�P<Rg��WYR3PH\LZ x CFI�GJP GJE<E<e Z[WFGgKNZ R3P KNR1GOWYR3PQKNC��jK�Z P ��y<Z[W`y WYRQ\bK`\�GJINZ[\LCDTfINR3M KNy<C�P<CFC x KNR1G3W¡�.Q|<Z INCXWYCFILK`GJZ P�GJ�<Z e Z KNZ Cq\�R3I w P<Rg��e C x z3C�Z KNCFM1\Fs�UXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\5RJT<\NWYR3EkC ��0 w P<Rg��e C x z3CVCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\+2��GJINC x |<C�KNR x Z �vCFINCFPQK�GJ�<Z e Z KNZ Cq\hINC�.Q|<Z INZ P<z WYR3MOMOR3P*\ w Z e e[\h\L|HW`y*G3\h\LyHGJINC x ����B w P<Rg�´��y<Rg��slD\1G \LEkCqWYZ ,kW�C��<GJMOE<e C3]dWYR3PH\LZ x CFI1GÏy<Z z3yr�É\NW`y<RjR3e´M1GgKNy KNC��jKN�kRjR w WYR3PQK`GJZ P<Z P<z G \LCYK ��RJTE<INR3�<e CFM1\Fs *C Z M1GJz3Z P<C G \bKN| x CFPQK ��y<R KNINZ Cq\9KNR \LR3e _3C WYCFILK`GJZ P�\L|<�H\LCYK`\ � RJT«E<INR3�<e CFM1\Fs�<R3IhKNy<Z[\F]5KNy<C1\bKN| x CFPQK«yHG3\DKNR Z Pj_3Cq\bK�G�WYCFILK`GJZ P*GJMOR3|<PQK«RJTXC��vR3ILK � ���-�¡]�MOCqG3\L|<INC x Z PÏKNZ MOC|<P<Z K`\F]v\NGia3s´UXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT­\NWYR3EkCtGJINZ[\LC«TfINR3M x Z �vCFINCFPQKDE<INR3�<e CFM1\S\LyHGJINZ P<z WYCFILK`GJZ P 0NGgKNR3MOZ[W/2WYR3PHWYCFErK`\Fs �<R3I«Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]7\L|<E<EkRQ\LC�KNyHGgK�KNy<C1\LR3e |rKNZ R3PH\hRJTdE<INR3�<e CFM1\ � GJP x�� INC�.Q|<Z INCO\LR3e _Q�Z P<z G .Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WtC�.Q|HGgKNZ R3P�s"�´y<CFP�]5yHGi_jZ P<z�GJ�H\LR3IN�kC x KNy<C9e R3z3Z[W�RJT �DZ CYK`G � \DTfR3INM�|<e[G1TfR3IhKNy<C\LR3e |rKNZ R3PH\�RJT&.Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[W9C�.Q|HGgKNZ R3PH\F]7KNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe­WYRQ\bK�RJT��dR3I w Z P<z�KNy<INR3|<z3y E<INR3�<e CFM � Z[\INC x |HWYC x R3PHWYC«E<INR3�<e CFM � yHG3\´�kCFCFP \LR3e _3C x s

%D|<I�TfI`GJMOCF�dR3I w G3\N\L|<MOCq\VKNyHGgKdM1G3\bKNCFINa�RJT5E<INR3�<e CFM1\­Z[\X�g�`pY��_gGJe |<C x s�U­Z KNy<CFI­KNy<Ch\bKN| x CFPQKZ[\VGJ�<e CdKNR«\LR3e _3CdGDE<INR3�<e CFM ]gR3I�\Ly<CdZ[\VP<RJKqs-%DPHWYC´GDE<INR3�<e CFM�Z[\�M1G3\bKNCFINC x ]gZ K�Z[\7Tf|<e e a�Gi_gGJZ e[GJ�<e C�·G3\�GhE<|<INC´E<|<�<e Z[W´Z P<E<|rK­RJTv\LR3ILK`\J�5TfR3IVTf|rKN|<INC�e CqGJINP<Z P<zHs(�´y<CFINCYTfR3INC3]g�dC´INCYTfCFI�KNRhKNy<C´TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zMOR x CFeXG3\�G�MOR x CFe­RJTde CqGJINP<Z P<z �8� ��'7�&![� ]7R3I80Le CqGJINP<Z P<z��jaÏZ PH\LZ z3yQKqs 2 *C1��Z e eXGJe[\LR G3\N\L|<MOCKNyHGgKtKNy<C1KNRJK`GJedWYRQ\bKtRJTSGJ�H\LR3IN�<Z P<z G \LCYK ��RJT w P<Rg��e C x z3C1Z KNCFM1\ x RjCq\tP<RJK x CFEkCFP x R3P KNy<C\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYC«Z P ��y<Z[W`y KNy<C�Z KNCFM1\SGJINC�GJ�H\LR3IN�kC x s = "cXR3PH\LZ x CFItG \LCYK��,RJT w P<Rg��e C x z3COZ KNCFM1\�GJP x G WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P$�;7�� � � � ��Z KNy$� ���-�

.Q|HGJPQKNZ TfajZ P<z KNy<C9C��vR3ILKDP<CFC x C x KNR>0Le CqGJINP 2OKNy<C�Z KNCFM1\hZ P �´]vMOCqG3\L|<INC x Z P KNZ MOC9|<P<Z K`\Fs �´y<CTfR3e e Rg��Z P<z1INCFe[GgKNZ R3P E<e[Giar\DG1WYCFPQKNI`GJe7INR3e C�Z P R3|<IDGJPHGJe ar\LZ[\Fs�urGia KNyHGgKhGJP Z KNCFM ��!�1"����(-!�!#�3�����GJP-Z KNCFM � Z ThKNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe´C��vR3ILK RJThe CqGJINP<Z P<z � Z[\):FCFINR ��y<CFP<CF_3CFI � yHG3\1GJe INCqG x a �kCFCFPGJ�H\LR3IN�kC x 63TfR3INM1GJe e a3] x C�,HP<C«G !�1"����(-!�!#�3���8')����L1"�2+ *')���� � � R3P �&TfINR3M KNy<C«WYRQ\bKXTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P �ja

� � � � 7 � TfR3IDGJe e � � � � � ����I � ��� �,�1� ���-��J �·�<s pB��<R3I�Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]J|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<zhy<Rg� KNR�\LR3e _3C´G .Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WXC�.Q|HGgKNZ R3P�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\�KNy<C�WYR3PHWYCFErKRJTV\+.Q|HGJINChINRjRJKqs­�da �·�<s pB�¡]jKNy<Z[\�MOCqGJPH\dKNyHGgK´KNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe5WYRQ\bK�RJT�|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<z9KNy<C�e R3z3Z[WRJTS\+.Q|HGJINC1INRjRJKtZ[\9:FCFINR ��y<CFP<CF_3CFI�KNy<C MOCYKNy<R x RJTS\LR3e _jZ P<z .Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WOC�.Q|HGgKNZ R3PH\�yHG3\t�kCFCFPTf|<e e a GJ�H\LR3IN�kC x s�lD\´Z[\dCqG3\LZ e a1_3CFINZ ,HC x ]QTfR3I�GJPja \LCYK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P �g]jKNy<C�Z P x |HWYC x E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3PINCFe[GgKNZ R3P � � Z[\dINC��HC��rZ _3C«GJP x KNI`GJPH\LZ KNZ _3C3]jy<CFPHWYC�G�E<INCFR3I x CFIqs��7R�Tf|<ILKNy<CFI�Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC3]rWYR3PH\LZ x CFI��Z z3|<INC9nO�kCFe Rg����y<Z[W`y INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`\´KNy<C�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P GJMOR3P<zOKNy<C��HG3\LZ[W80 w P<Rg��e �C x z3C Z KNCFM1\+2 RJThKNy<Z[\ EHGJEkCFI�� \ ujCqW¡KNZ R3P �rs #ÉP ��Z z3|<INCÏnr]dP<R x Cq\ INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKOKNy<C w P<Rg��e C x z3CZ KNCFM1\F]<\L|HW`y�G3\XKNy<C x C�,HP<Z KNZ R3P�RJT�G x Z[\NWYINCYKNC«WYRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P3�fZ KNCFM$pB�¡]jKNy<C«e R3z3Z[WSRJTVWYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCv RjCF�<Z |H\VZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P;�fZ KNCFM ���¡]gKNy<CSGJINz3|<MOCFPQK�TfR3IVKNy<C�E<INZ _jZ e C x z3C x \bK`GgKN|H\VRJTv\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3CS\LajPr�CFINz3Z Cq\´RJT­ujCqW¡KNZ R3PÏ�rs �8�fZ KNCFM�o��¡]kGJP x \LROR3P�sdlSP GJININRg��TfINR3M Z KNCFM � KNR1Z KNCFM � MOCqGJPH\´KNyHGgK� E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\ � s �<R3IDZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]k|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<zOKNy<C�INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P RJT­G WYRQ\bKSTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P Z PKNCFINM1\�RJT�Z MOE<|rKNC x ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\9�fZ KNCFM$� �´E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\´KNy<C�WYR3PHWYCFErKDRJT�KNRJK`GJe�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba�fZ KNCFM n'�¡shlD\DC��rEkCqW¡KNC x ]vKNy<C�M1GJZ P MOCq\N\NGJz3CtRJTdujCqW¡KNZ R3P*� �fZ KNCFM �A7 0LINCFz3|<e[GJISCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\SRJT\NWYR3EkC�G x MOZ KDG9E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rKDZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P 2��­E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\´CF_3CFINa1RJKNy<CFI�Z KNCFM x Z[\LE<e[Gia3C x sC�$ Àv�b�·§��`�  i¨ ÁYÃ`§��i� �H� �H�����b�·§���� ®É§�� ¼Y�5�`����µi£��q§�� �¡ Qº D  ´�` dµi i�iµi�i¨ � ���i�b�d¢ �¡��£��b�Q¼Y�b����� �¡ d�`¢g§��i� �H�g�`�J�b��±[²7�b�i���  i¦�` i�h³kµi�i�J��±·¶L¸¡¸¡¸Y¹·¹�Ãg¤5�����i�L¤ �i�L¤ §��i�X�` g�`¨ Áq��� ��®L�` h�J��¦¡�b i�b���`¨ � Ëb�b���`¨ ¨ �L¤7�  i¦X¢ �¡���g�N§��qÒ@�i�b�J�b i�i�b Y§�®b�¡�·§��Lº

pq�

Page 16: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

5 � =�(K1"����/��21"�

BDCFP<RJKNC��ja ��� 7 � � � 7 � � � ��� GJP x ��� 7 � � � 7 � � � � � KNy<C 0L|<Er�É\LCYKJ2ORJTXGJe e�Z KNCFM1\SKNyHGgKE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LC � GJP x KNy<C;0 x Rg��Pr�É\LCYKJ2�RJT�GJe evZ KNCFM1\dE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LC x �ja � ]rINCq\LEkCqW¡KNZ _3CFe a3s�lSe[\LRH]je CYK� � 7 �+� � M � 7 � � � � TfR3IS\LR3MOC ��M � � GJP x � � 7 �+� � M � 7 � � � � TfR3IS\LR3MOC ��M � � s� ���� �d �� �2' �)7���� � � H��R*����2' ��(K���2')���� EF�8'?/ �-C �6C ��C 2 C -�/��2��$_'?/��O��(-!�!#�1�' � � � 2��������:��'��J� �M���2'��J� �4'?/��Z�2�1�� - � $a��C8�-C -+� - � �2�1�*+8+ - M �4C�´yj|H\F]HGOE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK - M � WYR3PQK`GJZ PH\´��Z KNy GJPja Z KNCFM � M - GJe e5Z KNCFM1\ � KNyHGgKSE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LC� s*^SP<e Cq\N\tKNy<C E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P Z[\t_3CFINa*INZ[W`y�]VZ K`\ w P<Rg��e C x z3C Z MOEkRQ\LCq\tR3P<e a e RjRQ\LCINCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3PH\dR3P KNy<C«T·GJMOZ e a RJT�E<|<�<e Z[WhZ P<E<|rK`\Fs,�<INR3M G�MOR x CFe e Z P<zOEkCFI`\LEkCqW¡KNZ _3C3]rz3INCqGgKNCFIdEHGJIL�\LZ MOR3PjatZ[\ x Cq\LZ I`GJ�<e C3s *C���Z e erP<Rg� \Ly<Rg� KNyHGgKVKNy<CFINC´Z[\­Gh�dCFe e � x C�,HP<C x 0LMORQ\bKVEHGJI`\LZ MOR3P<Z R3|H\+2MOR x CFe7WYR3PH\LZ[\bKNCFPQK���Z KNy KNy<C�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�� � 6rKNy<C�MOR x CFe7Z[\´_3CFINa1KNI`G3W¡K`GJ�<e C�GJP xx RjCq\´P<RJKD\LCFCFM KNR1�kC�C��<WYCq\N\LZ _3CFe a1INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3C3s��Z I`\bKq]VR3�H\LCFIN_3C9KNyHGgK9Z P KNy<C E<INCq\LCFPQK9WYR3PQKNC��jK�RJTSe CqGJINP<Z P<z G KbajE<Z[WFGJedWYRQ\bKtTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��Z e e

\NGgKNZ[\bTfa1KNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z1WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P�RJT�\bKNINZ[W¡K�MOR3P<RJKNR3P<Z[WYZ Kba3s�s���i��� ! k[l\k#�-k[l\i��i?� q)�<R3ISGJe e � GJP x �´]4� ����I&� ��� � �*� ���-�d��y<CFP<CF_3CFI ��� ��� � #rsuQKNINZ[W¡K MOR3P<RJKNR3P<Z[WYZ Kba \bK`GgKNCq\9KNyHGgK KNy<C M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�C��vR3ILK RJT«e CqGJINP<Z P<z � Z[\ \bKNINZ[W¡KNe a EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C��y<CFP<CF_3CFI P<R Z KNCFM KNyHGgK�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\ � yHG3\ GJe INCqG x a �kCFCFP GJ�H\LR3IN�kC x s�^D\LZ P<z �HG3W¡K �<s p3]\bKNINZ[W¡KOMOR3P<RJKNR3P<Z[WYZ Kba Z[\9CqG3\LZ e a \LCFCFP KNRÏZ MOE<e a ���SM � TfR3I1GJe e � M � ]­Z�s C3s � WYR3PQK`GJZ PH\9GJe e|<Er�É\LCYK`\ �� s =4$ �´y<C TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z ��'7�&!�EF�:��� + ��*1��#�8�B= �6�-.��2+ INC�.Q|<Z INCq\ WYR3Pj_3CFI`\LCFe a3]XKNyHGgK ��#+ <\LCYK`\9RJTSKNy<C�TfR3INM �� GJINC INCFe CF_gGJPQKOE<|<�<e Z[W Z P<E<|rK`\/6�Z P RJKNy<CFIO�dR3I x \F]�Z K G3\N\L|<MOCq\tKNyHGgKOR3P<CWFGJP*G3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNCtKNR GJPja w P<Rg��e C x z3C�Z KNCFM � G |<P<Z .Q|<C30NGgKNR3MOZ[W�WYR3PHWYCFErKJ2 ��� KNyHGgK�Z[\«\LEkCqWYZ ,kWKNR � GJP x GJPja-MOR3INC*G x _gGJPHWYC x Z KNCFM s lD\ G \LZ MOE<e CÏC��<GJMOE<e C3]DWYR3PH\LZ x CFI KNy<C w P<Rg��e C x z3CZ KNCFM � � n ��0LINCFz3|<e[GJI«CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\«RJT´\NWYR3EkC�2��DZ P���Z z3|<INC nrs lS�H\LR3IN�<Z P<z ��0Le CqGJINP<Z P<z�2���KNyHGgKEHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJISWYR3PHWYCFErK�INC�.Q|<Z INCq\dKNy<C�P<RJKNZ R3P RJT�KNRJK`GJe�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba ��y<Z[W`y GJe[\LRO|<P x CFINe Z Cq\´KNy<CMOR3INC´G x _gGJPHWYC x Z KNCFM1\X�DGJP x �<s(�´y<C)0NGgKNR3MOZ[WdWYR3PHWYCFErKJ2hG3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x ��Z KNyOZ KNCFM � � nDZ[\�KNyj|H\INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKNC x C��jKNCFPH\LZ R3PHGJe e a �ja1KNy<C�E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK ��� � �gn � � � � � ��0bKNRJK`GJe�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba 2��¡s

�´y<C1\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC1e CqGJINP<Z P<z�MOR x CFe­Z[\«KNy<C1MORQ\bK�EHGJI`\LZ MOR3P<Z R3|H\hMOR x CFeXWYR3PH\LZ[\bKNCFPQK���Z KNy(� � ]GJP x Z KDWFGJP��kC�W`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :FC x �ja�GJP�Z P x CFEkCFP x CFPHWYC�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P KNyHGgKSZ x CFPQKNZ ,HCq\´KNy<C�\LR3|<I`WYChRJT\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fs(�´y<CDWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P \NGiar\VKNyHGgKd\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\V�kCYKb�dCFCFPOKb�dR�Z KNCFM1\ � GJP x �WFGJPORrWFWY|<I­R3P<e aZ T�KNy<CFa�\LyHGJINC«G1WYR3MOMOR3P�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P KNyHGgK�yHG3\�P<RJK�a3CYK��kCFCFP e CqGJINPQKqs� q l p � � q � � �k � � � � � �K� p t �4� p �������Zk[�-i?�-i�k[l\� ������� ' #�Td\LajP ����� ��� ���-� ?� �<]HKNy<CFP KNy<CFINCC��rZ[\bK`\ � ?M � � \L|HW`y KNyHGgK � � � � GJP x � � � s�4�k��Zk[�-i?�-i�k[l$�d �� X ���2' ��(K���2')���� ��7v� � � � ��*')�:� �Y���8 8��g� �O*��.L��#+ <�� ��'?/�����(-!�!#�1�'� �%�8'��9�-C �6C ��C���*')�:� �Y��� � /1� ��� 7 � M � � CYD��L'?/B�:�J��*3��������4/�*3��$[�2�1�*+8+ � $

2 ��� � H � � ��� ��� � � �,� H � � � ����� � ��� �,� � ��� � 7 � ! � ��� ��"�� ��� � 7 � : � ��� ��J �·�<s �'�D��0!#*1�')���2(K+ *1�$%*�#<Q�6����'7����6���2'\��(K���2')���� ��*')�:�?��<�8�B= 8 8�� �:�R*(K'7��6*')����*+8+ <L'7�'7*+8+ <Q��(#H O�6�-.(K+ *1�C�´y<C«yHGJe e M1GJI w RJT7KNy<Ct\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC«e CqGJINP<Z P<z9MOR x CFe5Z[\dKNyj|H\dKNy<CtG3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNZ P<z�RJTVG9|<P<Z .Q|<C80LM1GJIL�z3Z PHGJe 29Z P<E<|rK ��� ��Z KNy CF_3CFINa z3RjR x � s�cXR3PHWYINCYKNCFe a3]<�ja �·�<s �'�¡]rKNy<Ct_gGJe |<C�2 ��� Z[\´KNy<CtM1GJINz3Z PHGJeC��vR3ILKORJTh|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<z � z3Z _3CFP KNyHGgK GJe e´Z KNCFM1\ � ?� � KNyHGgK � E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LCq\�yHGi_3C��kCFCFPC UJD  i�i�b�b�QÃ3�YÁh�·§���� ®É§7£��¡ i�`§��¡ i� ®b� §@Á«�` i�«���i�b�¡���b£�¿qº ¿qà - & 0 ±·± ���q¹��Y¹ ���j±���� %0�! !�#" ��� �`¹�$�ÂqÃJ�` i���YÁ»J�`®É§VÎqº ¶¡Ã%�j±���� %�� &��" �'� �`¹ �(� &*) º

pF�

Page 17: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

e CqGJINPQKqs #ÉPQKN|<Z KNZ _3CFe a3]dKNy<C Z P<E<|rK � � M1Gia �kC _jZ CF�dC x G3\OKNy<CÏW`yHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ[\bKNZ[W + ��*1��#�8�B= ��'7�&!G3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x ��Z KNy w P<Rg��e C x z3C«Z KNCFM � s

�7R9Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNCDKNy<C�WYR3PQKNCFPQK´RJT�?­INR3EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P �<s phz3I`GJE<y<Z[WFGJe e a3]jWYR3PH\LZ x CFI�G9WYRQ\bKdTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�R3PKNy<C�\LCYK�� � �$RJT�EHGJZ I`\dRJT�PHGgKN|<I`GJe5Pj|<M��kCFI`\ �fR3IS\LR3MOChe[GJINz3C ,HP<Z KNC�\L|<�H\LCYK�RJT�Z KH�´\L|HW`y KNyHGgK� � = � � " �'� � � � = � � " � � � = � � = � � " � � " s���Z z3|<INCSo«�kCFe Rg� x CFE<Z[W¡K`\�KNy<CD\LyHGJEkCSRJT5G«KbajE<Z[WFGJeZ P<E<|rKS��Z KNy GJP x ��Z KNy<R3|rKDWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P u<u ?V]<INCq\LEkCqW¡KNZ _3CFe a3s

1

� �

-+� ����������������������������

1

�-�

������� �������

� �������

5 � =�(K1"��� 7�-K<"!�����*+\�8�!�(K'��4EF�8'?/L*��.�EF�8'?/��(K'�8 8��

�´y<CD\bKNINCFP<zJKNy RJT�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P�u<u ? x CFEkCFP x \XR3P1KNy<Ch\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INCSRJT5KNy<CDZ P x |HWYC x E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ �KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�s�ujEkCqWYZ ,kWFGJe e a3]jWYR3PH\LZ x CFI­KNy<CSKb�dRtC��jKNINCFMOCDWFG3\LCq\­RJT7GtWYR3MOE<e CYKNCDE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3PINCFe[GgKNZ R3P��f�dCqG w R3I x CFIH��GJP x GJP9CFMOErKba�E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P9INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�]gINCq\LEkCqW¡KNZ _3CFe a3s #ÉP9KNy<C´TfR3INMOCFIWFG3\LC3]Ju<u ?ÏZ[\VGJ|rKNR3M1GgKNZ[WFGJe e a�\NGgKNZ[\E,HC x ]J\LZ PHWYCd�ja �HG3W¡K��<s pdGJPja«E<|<�<e Z[WdZ P<E<|rK�Z[\�KNy<CdTfR3INM ��� TfR3I\LR3MOC � M � 6rZ P KNy<C�e[GgKLKNCFIDWFG3\LC3]Hu<u ?-Z[\�C�.Q|<Z _gGJe CFPQK´KNROKNy<C�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P � / � � ��� 7 � M � � ]Z�s C3sHGJPja E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rKSM�|H\bKS�kCtGO\LZ P<z3e CYKNR3P�s

#ÉP�KNy<C�E<INCq\LCFPQKSWYR3PQKNC��jKSRJT�\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC«e CqGJINP<Z P<zH]rZ KhWFGJP��kC�GJINz3|<C x KNyHGgKhWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P u<u ?-Z[\��Z KNy<R3|rK�INCqGJeke RQ\N\dRJT7z3CFP<CFI`GJe Z KbaO�ja GJE<E<INR3E<INZ[GgKNCSCFP<e[GJINz3CFMOCFPQKdRJT�KNy<C x R3M1GJZ P�7VZ T�P<CqWYCq\N\NGJINa3]\LZ MOE<e atG x<x 0NGJ| �rZ e Z[GJINa w P<Rg��e C x z3C­Z KNCFM1\+2SKNyHGgK�GJINCX\LyHGJINC x G3\7Z P<E<|rK`\��jat\LCF_3CFI`GJeJZ KNCFM1\VG3\�GJPZ PQKNCFINMOC x Z[GgKNChR3|rKNE<|rK´Z P�Z K`\dRg��P INZ z3yQKqs�7R9Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNCDKNy<Z[\F]rWYR3PH\LZ x CFI´GJzQGJZ P.��Z z3|<INC�ntGJ�kRg_3C3sBDRjCq\«KNy<C WYRQ\bK«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P R3PÏKNy<C x R3M1GJZ P*RJT w P<Rg��e C x z3C9Z KNCFM1\�Z P*KNyHGgK9,Hz3|<INC1\NGgKNZ[\bTfa*u<u ?V]Z�s C3s x RjCq\ ��Z z3|<INCOn1INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKhG�\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC�e CqGJINP<Z P<z MOR x CFe3�$?­INCq\L|<M1GJ�<e a�P<RJKqs"�7R \LCFCtKNy<Z[\F]WYR3PH\LZ x CFI�C3s zHs<KNy<C�WYe[GJZ M RJT�KNy<CtE<INZ _jZ e C x z3C x \bK`GgKN|H\�RJT­\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C�\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\"�fZ KNCFM�o��´GJP xKNy<CtWYR3PHWYCFErK�RJT7KNRJK`GJe�\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba �fZ KNCFM�n'�¡sXuj|<E<EkRQ\LChKNyHGgKSCF_3CFINa1Z KNCFM E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LC x �jaKNy<Cq\LChKb�dR;�fZ�s C3srZ KNCFM1\«p3] ��GJP x ���XyHG3\´GJe INCqG x aO�kCFCFP GJ�H\LR3IN�kC x s-%D|<I´Z PQKN|<Z KNZ R3P�Z[\XKNyHGgK´KNy<CFINC\bKNZ e evZ[\´G�EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C«\LajP<CFINz3a9�kCYKb�dCFCFP Z KNCFM1\Sn�GJP x oA7�\LajP � � � � � ���Qp � � � � � ���-�<]jZ P _jZ R3e[GgKNZ R3P RJTu<u ?Vs�#ÉP x CFC x ]rR3P<C«WYR3MOMOR3P e CqGJINP<Z P<z9\bKNCFE KNyHGgK�Z[\dP<CFC x C x TfR3I´|<P x CFI`\bK`GJP x Z P<z9�kRJKNy�Z KNCFM1\�nGJP x o�Z[\­KNy<C«WYR3PHWYCFErKXRJT7\L|<�H\bKNZ KN|rKNZ _3C«\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\�Z K`\LCFe T7GJP x KNy<ChINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3PORJT7WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNCv RjCF�<Z |H\DZ Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P Z P KNCFINM1\SRJT x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\1� �´y<CFR3INCFM&�rs �'�¡sDl x<x Z P<z KNy<Cq\LC�Kb�dR Z KNCFM1\��·G3\Z KNCFM1\«pi�tGJP x pF��Z P ��Z z3|<INCt���kCFe Rg� �XG3WFWYR3|<PQK`\XTfR3IdKNy<C«EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C«\LajP<CFINz3aO�kCYKb�dCFCFP n�GJP x o<s�SRJKNCdKNyHGgK�KNy<C´Z PHWYe |H\LZ R3P9RJTHP<CF� Z KNCFM1\VM1Gia«P<CqWYCq\N\LZ K`GgKNCXKNy<C�G x<x Z KNZ R3P9RJT<Tf|<ILKNy<CFI�Z KNCFM1\VZ THKNy<CINCq\L|<e KNZ P<zOE<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�Z[\dKNR1\NGgKNZ[\bTfa WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P u<u ?Vs4�<R3I�Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]jKNy<C«EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C\LajP<CFINz3aÏ�kCYKb�dCFCFP*KNy<C�G x<x C x Z KNCFM1\ pi� GJP x pF� M�|H\bK��kC�G3WFWYR3|<PQKNC x TfR3It�jaÏKNy<C Z PHWYe |H\LZ R3PRJT�KNy<C�P<RJKNZ R3P RJT�KNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C �fZ KNCFM pq���¡]­GJP x \LRÏR3P�s cXR3MOE<e CYKNZ P<z)��Z z3|<INC�n Z P KNy<Z[\M1GJP<P<CFIq]<�dC",HPHGJe e a�GJININZ _3C x GgK�KNy<CtINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P�Z P&��Z z3|<INC9���kCFe Rg��]<��y<Z[W`y E<INCq\L|<M1GJ�<e aWYR3PrTfR3INM1\dKNR9KNy<Ct\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC«e CqGJINP<Z P<zOMOR x CFe�s#ÉP ��Z z3|<INC��j]<�dC�GJe[\LR9Z PHWYe | x C x KNy<CtGJINz3|<MOCFPQK`\\L|<ININR3|<P x Z P<ztKNy<C«INCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ _3CFP<Cq\N\XRJT7KNy<C".Q|HG x I`GgKNZ[WDMOR x CFe�]<G3\XKNy<Z[\´Z[\´E<INR3�HGJ�<e a GJe[\LR�y<CFe ErTf|<eKNR GJE<E<INCqWYZ[GgKNC KNy<C �HG3\LZ[W MOCq\N\NGJz3Cq\�RJT«ujCqW¡KNZ R3P-�r]X\L|HW`y G3\9Z KNCFM1\Oo*GJP x �<s �´y<C MOCYKNy<R xRJTXCFP<e[GJINz3Z P<z1KNy<C x R3M1GJZ P RJTdG WYRQ\bKDTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P KNR G3W`y<Z CF_3C�WYR3MOEHGgKNZ �<Z e Z Kba ��Z KNyÏKNy<CO\bKNCFEj��Z[\LCe CqGJINP<Z P<ztMOR x CFevC��rCFMOE<e Z ,HC x y<CFINCD��Z KNy KNy<Chy<CFe E RJT���Z z3|<INCq\´ntGJP x ��WFGJP �kC«GJE<E<e Z C x Z P1Tf|<e e

pin

Page 18: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

z3CFP<CFI`GJe Z Kba 7�TfR3I�GJPja WYRQ\bKDTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P���R3P � ]vKNy<CFINC9C��rZ[\bK`\«GJPÏC��jKNCFP x C x WYRQ\bKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P���tR3P\LR3MOC x R3M1GJZ P����R��\L|HW`y KNyHGgK����WYR3Z PHWYZ x Cq\S��Z KNy���R3P���GJP x \L|HW`y KNyHGgK���t\NGgKNZ[\E,HCq\Du<u ?�·\LCFC�SCFy<INZ P<z1GJP x ?­|<E<EkC��bpqm3m3m���TfR3I´KNy<C x CYK`GJZ e[\J�¡s

5 � =�(K1"��%/��21"�

�´y<C \bKNCFEj��Z[\LCOe CqGJINP<Z P<z MOR x CFe­yHG3\��kCFCFP E<INCq\LCFPQKNC x G3\�G |H\LCYTf|<e­�kCFPHW`y<M1GJI w MOR x CFe­Z PKNy<CÏWYR3PQKNC��jK RJT�e CqGJINP<Z P<zHs #�K yHG3\1�kCFCFP GJPHGJe a�:FC x Z P \LR3MOC x CYK`GJZ e�KNR Z e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC KNy<C z3CFPr�CFI`GJe�MOR x CFe e Z P<z \bKNI`GgKNCFz3a RJT�\LEkCqWYZ TfajZ P<z \bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC x T·GJMOZ e Z Cq\�RJT�Z P<E<|rK`\Fs´l�TfR3INM1GJevKNy<CFR3INa RJT\bKNCFEr���jaQ�É\bKNCFE e CqGJINP<Z P<z yHG3\t�kCFCFP x CF_3CFe R3EkC x Rg_3CFI�KNy<C e[G3\bK9,<T@KNCFCFP a3CqGJI`\��ja BDR3Z z3P<R3P GJP x�HGJe M1GJz3P<CSZ P1KNy<CFZ I­KNy<CFR3INa9RJT&0 w P<Rg��e C x z3C�\LEHG3WYCq\+2��·\LCFCDBDR3Z z3P<R3P GJP x �HGJe M1GJz3P<C9�bpqm'�Qn'��TfR3IG�,HI`\bK9\bK`GgKNCFMOCFPQKq]�GJP x BDR3Z z3P<R3P GJP x �HGJe M1GJz3P<C �bpqm3m3m��DTfR3I�G WYR3MOE<INCFy<CFPH\LZ _3COKNINCqGgKNMOCFPQKGJP x INCYTfCFINCFPHWYCq\hKNR INCFe[GgKNC x �dR3I w �ja RJKNy<CFItGJ|rKNy<R3I`\J�¡s)�´y<C WYCFPQKNI`GJeVR3�KubCqW¡KtRJTXKNy<CFZ I�KNy<CFR3INaZ[\OG w P<Rg��e C x z3C \LEHG3WYC ��y<Z[W`y WFGJP �kC�_jZ CF�dC x G3\9G x R3M1GJZ P RJT w P<Rg��e C x z3C Z KNCFM1\�R3I x CFINC x�ja G z3CFP<CFI`GJe Z :FC x E<INCq\L|<E<EkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�s = F �y<Z e C1KNy<CFINC GJINC \LR3MOC Z PQKNCFINCq\bKNZ P<z M1GgKNy<CY�M1GgKNZ[WFGJedWYR3P<P<CqW¡KNZ R3PH\�KNR R3|<It�dR3I w ]7KNy<C Z PQKNCFPQK9GJP x x CYK`GJZ e[\�GJINC�.Q|<Z KNC x Z �vCFINCFPQK�7�TfRrWY|H\LZ P<zR3P w P<Rg��e C x z3C�G3\N\LCq\N\LMOCFPQKq]5BDR3Z z3P<R3P GJP x �HGJe M1GJz3P<C x R�P<RJKhEkRQ\bKN|<e[GgKNCOG WYRQ\bKDTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PÏRJTe CqGJINP<Z P<zH]iGJP xtx RDP<RJK�INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK�KNy<CXR3I x CFI�\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC­RJT w P<Rg��e C x z3C­Z KNCFM1\7Z P�KNCFINM1\7RJTHGgKNR3MOZ[W0Le CqGJINP<Z P<zO\bKNCFEH\+2��fE<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\J��G3\´Z P R3|<I´E<INCq\LCFPQKSG3WFWYR3|<PQKqs

� � � ����� �&�9���?�<� �@������ ��� �C� � �/���&�J�4�����8� � ���� �� � ��&�?����� � �&�?����� �C� �8� � �&

�y<CFP x R KNy<C ,A�rC x WYRQ\bKtWYR3MOEkR3P<CFPQK`\�Z MOE<|rKNC x _jZ[G WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC6v RjCF�<Z |H\�Z Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P*G x MOZ KGJP CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[W Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P GJP x ��y<CFP GJINC KNy<CFa R3P<e a M1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe�WYR3PH\bKNIN|HW¡K`\�� �´y<Z[\Z[\DKNy<C .Q|<Cq\bKNZ R3P*G x<x INCq\N\LC x Z PÏKNy<Z[\«\LCqW¡KNZ R3P�s #ÉP uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3PÏ�Hs p3]v�dCO\bKN| x a KNy<C9E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3PRJTtM�|<e KNZ E<e C*|<P<Z K`\�RJT�G y<R3MOR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\ z3RjR x GJP x ,HP x KNyHGgK Z P�KNy<Z[\�WFG3\LC KNy<C ,A�rC x WYRQ\bKZ MOE<|rK`GgKNZ R3P�_jZ[G9WYR3Pub|<zQGgKNC4v RjCF�<Z |H\´Z Pj_3CFI`\LZ R3P e[G3W w \´GJP CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WDZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�s�#ÉP x CFC x ]��y<CFP CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJTD\NWYR3EkC INC x |HWYC KNRÏCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\tRJTD\NWFGJe C3] *�#< WYR3M��<Z PHGgKNZ R3P RJT x Z �vCFINCFPQK|<P<Z K`\´RJT�KNy<Chz3RjR x \LyHGJINCq\dG9\LEkCqWYZ ,kW��fM1GgKNy<CFM1GgKNZ[WFGJe e a1Z x CFPQKNZ ,HC x �XZ P<E<|rK´KNyHGgK´Z[\dP<RJK�\LyHGJINC x�ja�GJe ejRJKNy<CFI�|<P<Z K`\Fs��´y<CFINCYTfR3INC3]gZ P uj|<�H\LCqW¡KNZ R3P9�Hs �r]g�dC x CFINZ _3C´GhWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P�KNyHGgK­z3|HGJI`GJPQKNCFCq\7G\L|<�H\bK`GJPQKNZ _3C\ubR3Z PQK­E<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rKXZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P9�ja�INC�.Q|<Z INZ P<zhKNy<CSGJ�H\LCFPHWYC´RJT<0N\NWFGJe C´C��vCqW¡K`\Fs 2��&)( � ��� �E14<��43��R.T1 �E57,98�� ,/0 ,9D936.�3C,��T5�� ,',��T5� ��[ ����6l p�� kdkdtZm c �k[l\k � i p �Jk���d�� h�pcXR3PH\LZ x CFI�P<Rg� KNy<CS\LEkCqWYZ[GJe<WFG3\LC´RJT5G«WYR3MOE<e CYKNCFe a9\LajMOMOCYKNINZ[W´WYRQ\bKVTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�7Vl�WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�@7Q� � ������Z e e5�kC�WFGJe e C x�����5!�+ �2'7�2+ <6��<���6�2')1���� Z TVWYRQ\bK`\ x CFEkCFP x R3P<e a R3P KNy<C«Pj|<M��kCFI�RJTz3RjR x \hE<INR x |HWYC x ]5Z�s C3svTfR3I�GJe e �´]�� ���-� � ���!> �-�STfR3I�\LR3MOC�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��7��i� � p � J J J � � � � � ]��y<CFINC � � > � s uj|HW`yÄG WYRQ\bK Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P x Cq\NWYINZ �kCq\1KNy<CÏE<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P�RJT�G /���6�"=A�2�����(B�R3|rKNE<|rKqs#ÉP�KNy<Z[\SWFG3\LC3]rCqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\dRJT�\NWYR3EkC�\LEkCqWYZ[GJe Z :FChKNR ���������������J� �4����*+ � surGia KNyHGgK GÏTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P � 7��i� � p � J J J � � � � � Z[\OMOR3P<RJKNR3P<C GJP x '7�'7*+8+ < �������*V� Z T«Z K`\

y<Z z3y<CFIL��R3I x CFI x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\´yHGi_3C«GJe KNCFINPHGgKNZ P<z1\LZ z3P�]rZ�s C3s<Z T�TfR3ISGJe e! �Äp3]H ! " # ���$#E� N�� "�pB� " A = �-� �

C V ���i��£��ɧ��i�F�i�¡¨ �¡¦`Áh�g�`�7�J�b�b h� £��i¨ �b£��b Y§��b�D�  h�d®b�¡£��iµq§��b�7�b�iµi®L�N§�� �¡ g�`¨r�·Áq�·§��b£�©�Æ�¨ �b¥F��°h± ¢ �¡�´©�Æ������b���·Ò£��b Y§X�` i�9½j�L�`�� i�  i¦«�  $3V i�L¤7¨ �b�i¦¡�h¯F�g�`®b�b��°F¹�®b�L¼Y�b���  i¦h§��i�S�i� ¦¡�qÒ@��®��i�F�¡¨k®bµi����� ®bµi¨ µi£Ä�  ��g�`��� ®S�`��� §��i£��ɧ�� ®¡Ã�`¨ ¦¡�b�i���´�` i�h¦¡�b�¡£��ɧ��·Á g� §�� �7�b¼¡�`� ¨ �`�i¨ ���¡ D§��i�­�  Y§��b�� i�ɧ�µi i�i�b��¤�¤�¤­º �`¨ �b¥F�Lº ®b�¡£«º

pqo

Page 19: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

��y<CFINC H ���$#E��7 � ���$# � pB�4" ���$#E�¡]QGJP x H ! " # ���$#E��7 � H�� H ! "�� = # ���$#E���´TfR3I �Äp3s�´y<C�TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zINCq\L|<e K�Z[\SGJP�Z MOMOC x Z[GgKNCtWYR3PH\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYC«RJT��´y<CFR3INCFM��rs �9GJ�kRg_3C3s� ���� � �� �2' �97r� � ��� H��6*�����5!�+ �2'7�2+ <R��<���6�2')1����O���3��'s��(K���2')�����C -�/��2��$ � �:�J�6���� O'7�����*��.6'7�'7*+8+ <6��(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1%� �9*��.���#+ <6� � � �:�%�6����'7�����*��.6'7�'7*+8+ <��������*V�-C

#ÉPhKNy<CX\LEkCqWYZ[GJe3WFG3\LCVZ P���y<Z[W`yhKNRJK`GJeQWYRQ\bK`\5GJINC�z3Z _3CFPh�ja&,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\vE<e |H\7WYR3PH\bK`GJPQK�M1GJINz3Z PHGJeWYRQ\bK`\F]rZ�s C3s ���$#E�,��� � #�TfR3I #F�-�<]jKNy<CtWJs M s Z�s<Z[\�z3Z _3CFP �ja 2 � ���i] 2�������� OTfR3IDGJe e � ]HGJP x243$�Ä�9TfR3IDGJe e7RJKNy<CFI�-96ky<CFINC«KNy<C�\LCYKSRJT�Z MOE<|rKNC x Z P<E<|rK`\ � yHG3\SWYe CqGJISCqWYR3P<R3MOZ[W«MOCqGJP<Z P<zHs#ÉPOKNy<ChWFG3\LC�RJT x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z«M1GJINz3Z PHGJeHWYRQ\bK`\F]3R3POKNy<CSRJKNy<CFIXyHGJP x ]JKNy<ChWJs M s Z�s3yHG3\�KbajE<Z[WFGJe e atTf|<e e\L|<E<EkR3ILKq]QZ�s C3s � �Ä���ts = � �y<Z e CSKNy<Z[\X\L|<z3z3Cq\bK`\VKNyHGgKXKNy<CFINCSZ[\dGtWYR3MOE<e C��OZ PQKNCFILTfCFINCFPHWYC�RJT7\LajPr�CFINz3Z Cq\X��y<CFP KNy<C�E<INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P RJTVG�y<R3MOR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\Xz3RjR x C��ry<Z �<Z K`\´CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\dRJTV\NWFGJe C3]jZ KSGJe[\LR\Ly<Rg�S\�KNyHGgKhKNy<COWYR3MOE<e CYKNCFe a \LajMOMOCYKNINZ[W�WFG3\LC x RjCq\DP<RJKhe CFP x Z K`\LCFe TXCqG3\LZ e a�KNR�G \L|<�H\bK`GJPQKNZ _3CubR3Z PQKDE<|<�<e Z[WtZ P<E<|rKDZ PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�s�#ÉP x CFC x ]HTf|<e eV\L|<E<EkR3ILKDMOCqGJPH\´KNyHGgK *�#< WYR3M��<Z PHGgKNZ R3P RJTx Z �vCFINCFPQK1�f|<P<Z K`\�RJTJ�dz3RjR x \�WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \XKNR1G9EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJI�E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rKqs� ��[ � ! ��l q�� kdkdt\��m�i����-i�l � �\i�� � i�l � c �k[l\k � i p �Jk���d�k�� p ��l\t �d�� h�puj|<E<EkRQ\LC´KNyHGgK�KNy<CSz3RjR x \LEHG3WYC'��WFGJPO�kC�EHGJILKNZ KNZ R3P<C x Z PQKNR x Z �vCFINCFPQK�KbajEkCq\�RJTvz3RjR x \Fs(#ÉP9KNy<Z[\WFG3\LC9KNy<CFINC GJINC9Kb�dR x Z[\bKNZ PHW¡K9\LR3|<I`WYCq\hRJT�WYRQ\bK`\/780E,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\+2�RJT�G3W/.Q|<Z INZ P<z KNy<C WFGJEHGJ�<Z e Z KbaRJThE<INR x |HWYZ P<z*z3RjR x \9RJT«G WYCFILK`GJZ P KbajEkC3]dGJP x 0L_gGJINZ[GJ�<e C WYRQ\bK`\+2 RJThE<INR x |HWYZ P<z z3RjR x \9RJThGEHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJI�KbajEkCSZ P1_gGJINZ R3|H\-.Q|HGJPQKNZ KNZ Cq\Fs��<R3IXZ PH\bK`GJPHWYC3] ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\�M1GiaOWYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x KNR�����BWYRQ\bK`\´RJT x CF_3CFe R3E<Z P<z1G9I`GJP<z3ChRJTVE<INR x |HW¡K�e Z P<Cq\SG3\´Z P�KNy<Ct�]v8 C��<GJMOE<e C�GJ�kRg_3C3s�<R3INM1GJe e a3]je CYK�� � I � ���9� � ��Z KNy�KNy<C � � EHGJZ IN��Z[\LC x Z[\?ubR3Z PQKqs-�´y<C x Z[\bKNZ PHW¡KNZ R3P��kCYKb�dCFCFP

,A�rC x GJP x _gGJINZ[GJ�<e C�WYRQ\bK`\VZ[\VTfR3INM1GJe e a�WFGJErKN|<INC x �jatKNy<C´TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z�G x<x Z KNZ _3CFe a�\LCFEHGJI`GJ�<e CdTf|<PHW¡�KNZ R3PHGJevTfR3INM RJT�KNy<CtWYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P�s��<R3ISGJe e �´]

� ���-�,� �)��� � M � 7 ��� � � ?� # � � � � ���

� � �!> ��� � � � ��� � �f�Hs pB�

��y<CFINC�� 7V� � � � INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`\ ,A�rC x WYRQ\bK`\F]�GJP x KNy<C.� � 7��i� � J J J � > � � � � � INCFE<INCq\LCFPQKKNy<C _gGJINZ[GJ�<e C WYRQ\bKtTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\tTfR3I�z3RjR x \�RJT�KbajEkC �vsÏl WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P KNyHGgKOG x MOZ K`\�\L|HW`y G\LCFEHGJI`GJ�<e ChINCFE<INCq\LCFPQK`GgKNZ R3P ��Z e e��kC�INCYTfCFININC x KNR G3\ .�������5!#�3��*�H2+ � s�4�k��Zk[�-i?�-i�k[l � �� X ���3��'���(K���2')���� �@7j� � ��� �:�J.�������5!#�3��*�H2+ ���8� '?/��%���2������� �6N �[CB6�P�� �*��.R��#+ <�� �4�8'Z��*')�:� �Y���%'?/��Z�2�+8+ �EF�8�B=�')EZ�R�����.�8')�������CN&� P 5 �1J*+8+ � M � $ ��� � M � � $Y*��. ?M � � $ L � ���-�,� L � ����I&� ��� � E\/��2���2V�21 � � �[$Y*��.N&�8� P 5 �19*+8+ � � � $ # > ��� � � � ��� > � � � � � � �2�1J*+8+ � ' � � ���-�,�1� � � � C� �1"���V�21�$9'?/��M��(K���2')������ � � *��. � *1"�R(K�#���2(#�2+ <�.��2'7�21����8����.L(-!G'7�I*L���1��6*+ � ,-*')���� � �� � �bpB� �2�1J*+8+ � M � CcXR3P x Z KNZ R3P �fZ �´\bK`GgKNCq\dKNyHGgKSR3PHWYC�G1\LZ P<z3e C«|<P<Z KSRJT�\LR3MOChKbajEkC � Z[\�E<INR x |HWYC x ]rZ PHWYINCqG3\LZ P<z9KNy<CR3|rKNE<|rK­RJTkKNy<Z[\VKbajEkC�CFPQK`GJZ e[\VP<R«Tf|<ILKNy<CFI�INC x |HW¡KNZ R3PORJTHKNy<CSM1GJINz3Z PHGJerWYRQ\bK�RJTvE<INR x |HWYZ P<z«z3RjR x \RJTvGJPja�RJKNy<CFIVKbajEkC� Hs­cXR3P x Z KNZ R3P��fZ Z ��\bK`GgKNCq\�KNyHGgK­WYRQ\bK`\VR3P<e a x CFEkCFP x R3P�KNy<C´Pj|<M��kCFI�RJTk|<P<Z K`\E<INR x |HWYC x RJTVCqG3W`y KbajEkC3s

�´y<C Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P��$WFGJErKN|<INCq\9EkRJKNCFPQKNZ[GJe´CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT«\NWYR3EkC3]­��y<Z e C�KNy<C � � WFGJErKN|<INC EkRJ�KNCFPQKNZ[GJe�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\9RJT«\NWFGJe C3s$�´y<Z[\1WYe CqGJIL�ÉWY|rK x Z[W`y<RJKNR3M�a3]X��y<Z[W`y Z[\ x |<C�KNR WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P �fZ �¡]\LCFCFM1\´GJE<E<INR3E<INZ[GgKNCSZ P�WYCFILK`GJZ P WYR3PQKNC��jK`\´\L|HW`y G3\XKNyHGgK´RJT ����B�C��rEkCFP x Z KN|<INC'6rZ K´M1Gia1P<RJK´�kCC D + �i���b�·¼Y�V§��g�N§7§��i�­®¡º £«º �[ºF�`¢H�d®b�¡£��i¨ �ɧ��b¨ ÁD�·Áq£�£��ɧ���� ®�®b�¡�·§�¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ «� ��®b�¡£��i¨ �ɧ��b¨ ÁD�·Áq£�£��ɧ���� ®��`��¤5�b¨ ¨[Ã�[º �¡ºq¢ �¡�7�`¨ ¨ �­Ã%��� �¡ i¨ ÁD�i�b�J�b i�i���¡ D§��i�­®L�`���i�  g�`¨ � §@ÁD�`¢��­º

pg�

Page 20: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

G3WFWYCFErK`GJ�<e C1Z P RJKNy<CFI`\Fs.�<R3ItC��<GJMOE<e C3]�Z P G WYR3PQKNC��jKtRJT´e CqGJINP<Z P<z �ja x R3Z P<z Z P ��y<Z[W`y*KbajEkCq\INCFE<INCq\LCFPQK´WYe[G3\N\LCq\XRJT��·WYRQ\bKNe aA�dG3W¡KNZ _jZ KNZ Cq\´GJP x Z P x Z _jZ x |HGJe<0LR3�KubCqW¡K`\+2t��Z KNy<Z P GtKbajEkC«Z PH\bK`GJPHWYCq\RJTVKNy<C9\NGJMOCtG3W¡KNZ _jZ Kba3]<KNy<C�M1GJINz3Z PHGJe�WYRQ\bKDRJT­G1INCFEkCYKNZ KNZ R3P RJT­\LR3MOCtG3W¡KNZ _jZ Kba ��Z e e x CqWYINCqG3\LCR3P<e a z3I`G x |HGJe e a G3\�GO\LZ MOZ e[GJISG3W¡KNZ _jZ Kba � Z[\´EkCFILTfR3INMOC x MOR3INC«RJT@KNCFP�s

�´y<C´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P!�´Z[\VKNRJK`GJe e a9\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI­��y<CFP<CF_3CFI ��Z[\VKNRJK`GJe e a9\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIXGJP x CqG3W`y � �Z[\dKNRJK`GJe e a WYR3PHWFGi_3C3s�ujZ PHWYChKNy<C]ubR3Z PQK�E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK�Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�Z[\´e Cq\N\´WYR3MOEkCFe e Z P<zO��Z KNy<Z PG�y<R3MOR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\­KbajEkC3]rR3P<Ch�dR3|<e x RJT@KNCFP G3\N\L|<MOCDKNRJK`GJe5\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba1R3P<e a1RJT �O]<GJE<E<e ajZ P<zKNy<C�MOCYKNy<R x R3e R3z3a Z P�C��vCqW¡KSR3P<e a KNR9KNy<C�CqWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\´RJTV\NWYR3EkC�G3\LEkCqW¡KSRJT��gs

��& % *�+-,/.�,/02143657,98�:;+-,9<=3 � 1 �6��,����@:;+-> �43�*�� 36+ �E5 *C P<Rg� E<INRg_jZ x C�G \L| 5 WYZ CFPQK1WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P TfR3I1G*\L|<�H\bK`GJPQKNZ _3C�E<|<�<e Z[W�Z P<E<|rK1Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P�6INR3|<z3y<e a3]jZ KDINC�.Q|<Z INCq\XKNyHGgK�KNy<CFINC«�kC�P<R30N\NWFGJe C«C��vCqW¡K`\Fs 2�<R3I«KNy<C1INCFM1GJZ P x CFI�RJTXKNy<Z[\t\LCqW¡KNZ R3P�]7�dC1WYR3PH\LZ x CFI«KNy<C WYe[G3\N\«RJT�GJe eVKNRJK`GJe e a*\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI

WYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\��@7Q� � ��� KNyHGgKDWFGJP��kC���INZ KLKNCFP Z P�KNy<C«TfR3INM��� ����� � � � �f�Hs �'�

��y<CFINCÏCqG3W`y � M ��WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x \1KNR G 1"��*+ Z P<E<|rK KNyHGgK�M1Gia-�kC*INZ _gGJe INR3|H\ R3I P<RJKq]hGJP x� � 7�� � � � x Cq\NWYINZ �kCq\«KNy<C WYRQ\bK`\�RJT�G3W/.Q|<Z INZ P<z Z KtZ P \L| 5 WYZ CFPQK�.Q|HGJPQKNZ Kba3s�lD\�Z P ujCqW¡Kqs��GJ�kRg_3C3] x CFP<RJKNCO�ja ����� /���KNy<C1\LCYK�RJTXz3RjR x \DKNyHGgK�|H\LC9Z P<E<|rK �S]vTfR3INM1GJe e a3]� ����� � � � 7� ����� ��� � �-� � s��<R3I�CqG3W`y�� M �h]4� � Z[\SG3\N\L|<MOC x KNRO�kC�MOR3P<RJKNR3P<C3]<\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJISGJP x RJT�R3P<CRJT�KNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<z�Kb�dR9KbajEkCq\Fs-K<"!#�MD-7 TfR3ISGJe e ��� � M �����H7/H � � ����� � � ��� �<sU­_jZ x CFPQKNe a3]5KNy<COKbajEkC)#«WYRQ\bK«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\�WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x KNR KNy<C1E<|<INCOE<|<�<e Z[W8�fZ�s C3s�P<R3P<INZ _gGJe INR3|H\J�Z P<E<|rK`\Fs#�T�� � Z[\�P<RJK�RJT�KbajEkC"#¡]r�dC«INC�.Q|<Z INC>� ����� ���9GJP x KNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zOWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P�s = �-K<"!#�MD D-7 TfR3IDGJe e ��� � M �����´GJP x GJe e � ��Z KNy)� ��� � � �!��� # 7�\LajP � ����� ��� ���-� � �<]��y<CFINC­\LajP � ����� ��� x CFP<RJKNCq\vKNy<CX\LajP<CFINz3aS�kCYKb�dCFCFP � GJP x � ��Z KNy�INCq\LEkCqW¡K�KNR´KNy<CdWYRQ\bK5Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P� ��s�´y<ChWYRQ\bKXTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\XRJT5KbajEkC@#�#­GJINCDG3\N\LRrWYZ[GgKNC x ��Z KNy KNy<CDINZ _gGJe INR3|H\­Z P<E<|rK`\d\LZ PHWYCSKNy<C«\LajP<CFINz3a�kCYKb�dCFCFP GJPja9EHGJZ IXRJT�z3RjR x \�KNyHGgKd|H\LC � INCFM1GJZ PH\­EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3CSP<R�M1GgKLKNCFId��yHGgKdRJKNy<CFIXz3RjR x \XGJINC�kCFZ P<z E<INR x |HWYC x s@�´y<CtTfR3e e Rg��Z P<z WYR3PHWYINCYKNC�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PHGJe7TfR3INM�MORJKNZ _gGgKNCq\DR3|<ISTfR3INM�|<e[GgKNZ R3P RJTKbajEkC"#�#´WYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\Fs,�<R3ISGJe e �´]<e CYK

� �����-�,� � � � � � �� � J �f�Hs ���

�SCFINC3] � � x CFP<RJKNCq\9KNy<C .Q|HGJPQKNZ Kba RJT«Z P<E<|rK � |H\LC x �ja z3RjR x � ]�GJP x � ���4N �OZ[\OKNy<C WYRQ\bK RJTG3W/.Q|<Z INZ P<z�KNy<C�Z P<E<|rKSZ P x Z �vCFINCFPQK&.Q|HGJPQKNZ KNZ Cq\Fs­l�WYRQ\bK´Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P RJT7KNy<C«TfR3INM �f�Hs ���XZ[\´RJT�KbajEkC#�#���y<CFP<CF_3CFI � � Z[\�\bKNINZ[W¡KNe a WYR3PHWFGi_3C3s&�<R3I�Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3]Ve CYK � � �kC KNy<C MOCYKNINCq\�\+.Q|HGJINC RJT�KNy<C�kR x a RJTXG WFGJI � KNyHGgKhyHGi_3C�KNR �kC�EHGJZ PQKNC x ]5GJP x � �ÏKNy<C�y<R3|<I`\SP<CFC x C x KNR x R KNy<C9EHGJZ PQKNZ P<zubR3��s#ÉP�KNy<Z[\SWFG3\LC3]r\bKNINZ[W¡KDWYR3PHWFGi_jZ Kba1RJT�� � RrWFWY|<I`\F]rC3s zHs ] x |<C«KNR30Le CqGJINP<Z P<z9�ja x R3Z P<zHs 2U­_jZ x CFPQKNe a3]VTfR3IOGÏWYRQ\bK9Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P*� RJTSKNy<C TfR3INM �f�Hs �'�¡]�KNy<C T·GJMOZ e a � ������7 � M � � RJTINCqGJekZ P<E<|rK`\ x RjCq\F]jZ P z3CFP<CFI`GJe�]3P<RJK�WYR3Z PHWYZ x CD��Z KNy KNy<CDT·GJMOZ e a � RJT �8�5!�(K'7��. Z P<E<|rK`\´\LZ PHWYCDKNy<C

C * �r�t£��`§�� ¼¡�N§��D§��i�h���ENFµi� ���b£��b Y§��� j± �v¹ $-¿qÃv®b�¡ i��� �i�b���t®b�¡�·§´¢ µi i®É§�� �¡  0�� ¤7� §��� j± �v¹ � ������� �«�` i��·Áq  $'&)( *�+ ±)(Y¹ $ ÂqºSÍ��i� ¨ �´¢[�`� ¨ �  i¦D§��«���b�i���b���b Y§d�h i�¡ i��� ¼¡�`¨ ���¡µi�­�  i�iµq§Là 0�� ®L�` O�J���i�b®b�¡£��J�¡���b�9�  Y§��h§��i���b� i�¡ i��� ¼¡�`¨ ���¡µi�<®b�¡�·§<¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ i�r¤7� §��d�  i�iµq§�� ���-�YÃ2��� �YÃF�` i� ������� �Yá���b���J�b®É§�� ¼Y�b¨ ÁYº<���i�b���É¢ �¡���¡Ã`§��i�5®L�`������ j± �v¹ �¿d®L�` h�J���LKq®b¨ µi�i�b�«�  D§��i���i�LMg i� §�� �¡ «�`¢r§@Áq�J� D D ®b�¡�·§7¢ µi i®É§�� �¡ i�Lº

p��

Page 21: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

e[GgKLKNCFI«GJINC9GJe �´Giar\�E<|<INCFe a E<|<�<e Z[W��ja WYR3PH\bKNIN|HW¡KNZ R3P�s@#ÉP KNy<C9E<|<INC9WFG3\LC3]vR3P KNy<C9RJKNy<CFIhyHGJP x ]KNy<C«Kb�dR9T·GJMOZ e Z Cq\ x R WYR3Z PHWYZ x C3s� ���� � � �2' � H��9*�'7�'7*+8+ <���(#H2�6�-.(K+ *1%���3��'���(K���2')���� � �_'?/��F�2�1�� N �[C )2P�C]D?�4*+8+ � � *1"�9� �')<"!#�MD�$a'?/��2� � � � ������7 � M � � C�hZ _3CFP G�WYRQ\bK«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P���RJTXKNy<COTfR3INM �f�Hs �'�¡]7Z[\hKNy<CFINC1G �´Gia KNR Z PrTfCFI�TfINR3M w P<Rg��e C x z3C

RJT��ÏGJe R3P<C ��y<CYKNy<CFI GJe ehZ P<E<|rK`\ GJINC E<|<INCÏE<|<�<e Z[WÏZ P<E<|rK`\F]DR3I���y<CYKNy<CFI \LR3MOC*GJINC Z MOE<|<INC�fZ�s C3srINZ _gGJe INR3|H\J�1� *C«��Z e evP<Rg�Ä\Ly<Rg�-KNyHGgK�R3P<ChWFGJP TfR3INM�|<e[GgKNC«G9\LZ MOE<e C«\L| 5 WYZ CFPQK�WYR3P x Z KNZ R3PZ P1KNCFINM1\­RJT5KNy<CSE<INCq\LCFPHWYCSRJT7\bKNINZ[W¡KNe a9EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3CD\LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\Fs(�´y<CFP�]j�dCS��Z e evGJINz3|<C�y<CF|<INZ[\bKNZ[WFGJe e aKNyHGgK�KNy<CtWYR3P x Z KNZ R3P WYR3MOCq\�WYe RQ\LChKNRO�kCFZ P<z1P<CqWYCq\N\NGJINa3surGiahKNyHGgK�Kb�dRDz3RjR x \ � GJP x � GJINC + �8�K`���. Z Tk\LajP ����� ��� ���-� �-��TfR3I�GJe e�� ��Z KNy!� ��� � � � ���R#rs

�<|<ILKNy<CFINMOR3INC3]kG �2+ ���2(#� RJT�z3RjR x \SZ[\DG \L|<�H\LCYK � / ��\L|HW`y KNyHGgK«GJPja EHGJZ IDZ P�� Z[\Se Z P w C x s�´y<C�INCFe[GgKNZ R3P�0LZ[\�e Z P w C x KNR�2 x C�,HP<Cq\SGOz3I`GJE<y�]jKNy<C + �8�K`�*�=A�4=�1"*"!#/ R3P�� 6<G1WYe Z .Q|<C�Z[\SG1WYR3M9�E<e CYKNCDZ P x |HWYC x \L|<�<z3I`GJE<y�sVlSe[\LRH]QP<RJKNCSKNyHGgKd�ja)�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �r]3Kb�dRtz3RjR x \ � GJP x � GJINCSe Z P w C xZ T�GJP x R3P<e a Z T � ��� � �=M � s p j�l\i?�-i�k[l �´y<C + �8�K`�*�=A�%�8��.��+* �� �/�­RJT7G�WYRQ\bKXTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��Z[\ x C�,HP<C x G3\­KNy<ChM1G �rZ M1GJevWFGJI x Z �PHGJe Z Kba RJT�GOWYe Z .Q|<C�RJT7KNy<C�Z P x |HWYC x e Z P w GJz3C«z3I`GJE<y�s *C���Z e e�P<Rg��\Ly<Rg� KNyHGgK �� �/�,�Ä�9Z MOE<e Z Cq\´KNyHGgKDGJe e5Z P<E<|rK`\�M�|H\bKS�kC�E<|<INCFe a E<|<�<e Z[WJs��<R3I´KNy<CWYR3Pj_3CFI`\LC3]J�dCh\LyHGJe ekGJINz3|<C´KNyHGgK´G�e Rg�-Z P x C��1M1G w Cq\­Z Kde Z w CFe a�KNyHGgKdR3P<CSZ P1T·G3W¡KXT·G3WYCq\�KNy<CDE<|<INCWFG3\LC3suj|<E<EkRQ\LC�KNyHGgK��ÄZ[\«INZ _gGJe INR3|H\/6vKNy<CFP �����SZ[\�G�WYe Z .Q|<C9Z PÏKNy<COe Z P w GJz3C9z3I`GJE<y RJT�� ��s��<R3I

GJPja EHGJZ I ��� � M �����dR3P<C«yHG3\F]\LajP ����� ��� ��� ��� � � � �,� ����� \LajP � ����� ��� ��� ��� � � � ��J

ujZ PHWYC3]r�ja \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba1RJTVGJe e%� ��]<\LajP � ����� ��� �-�tTfR3ISGJe e��S]r�dChyHGi_3Ch\LajP ����� ��� ��� ��� � � � � � �Z TSGJP x R3P<e aÏZ TS\LajP � ����� ��� ��� ��� � � � ��� ��TfR3I�GgK�e CqG3\bKtR3P<C��Ss ujZ PHWYC \LajP<CFINz3Z Cq\)�f��Z KNy INCq\LEkCqW¡KKNR �/�DGJINC x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z �ja KNy<COG3\N\L|<MOC x KNRJK`GJeV\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba RJT �g]5�dC9yHGi_3C9\LajP ����� ��� ���-���\LajP ����� ��� ��� ��� � � � �XTfR3ISGJe e � / � ��� � � � s-�´yj|H\F]<GJPja EHGJZ I ��� � Z P �����dZ[\�e Z P w C x ]r��y<CFPHWYC

�� �/�'� >� ����� ���KJ

�da-WYR3PQKNI`GJEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P�]XKNy<Z[\�\Ly<Rg�S\OKNyHGgK� �� �/�&���*Z[\�\L| 5 WYZ CFPQK TfR3I KNy<C E<|<INCÏWFG3\LC3]´Z�s C3sXKNy<CGJ�H\LCFPHWYC«RJT�INZ _gGJe INR3|H\dZ P<E<|rK`\Fs

�7ROZ e e |H\bKNI`GgKNC3]HWYR3PH\LZ x CFI´KNy<C«TfR3e e Rg��Z P<zOC��<GJMOE<e Cq\Fs#ÉP�KNy<C�y<R3MOR3z3CFP<CFR3|H\´WFG3\LC«RJT­ujCqW¡KNZ R3P�Hs p3s p3]H��y<CFP���Z[\�KNRJK`GJe e a \LajMOMOCYKNINZ[W�GJP x \bKNINZ[W¡KNe a \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJIq]<KNy<C�CFPQKNZ INC9\LCYKT� RJT­z3RjR x \TfR3INM1\�G WYe Z .Q|<C3]Vy<CFPHWYC �� �/��� > � sLv R3INC z3CFP<CFI`GJe e a3]7Z T �1Z[\ x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\NGJ�<e C1Z P KNy<C�\LCFPH\LCRJT9�f�Hs pB�«��Z KNy GJe e � � \bKNINZ[W¡KNe a WYR3PHWFGi_3C3]5KNy<C�WYe Z .Q|<Cq\�Z PHWYe | x C�GJe ed\LCYK`\=� � ]�KNy<CFINCYTfR3INC �� �/� �M1G � � > � � s �da*WYR3PQKNI`G3\bKq]�TfR3I�GJPjaÏy<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJe­WYRQ\bK�Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P$�g]�CqG3W`y z3RjR x Z[\te Z P w C x KNRGgK«MORQ\bK�R3P<C9RJKNy<CFI«z3RjR x ]5y<CFPHWYC� �� �/�=! �rs��da WYR3PH\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYC3]�G y<Z CFI`GJI`W`y<Z[WFGJe7R3INzQGJP<Z :qGgKNZ R3PRJT­KNy<C9T·GJMOZ e a � RJTXZ MOE<|rKNC x Z P<E<|rK`\«z3|HGJI`GJPQKNCFCq\�KNy<COGJ�H\LCFPHWYC9RJT10N\NWFGJe C�C��vCqW¡K`\+2 �ja IN|<e Z P<zR3|rK«INZ _gGJe INR3|H\DZ P<E<|rK`\ �Ss1�´y<C1\NGJMOCOWYR3PHWYe |H\LZ R3PÏGJE<E<e Z Cq\hZ TXKNy<COz3RjR x \LEHG3WYC�yHG3\«G E<INR x |HW¡KE<INR x |HW¡K \bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC GJP x GJe e«Z P<E<|rK`\ GJINCÏINCqW¡K`GJP<z3|<e[GJI�\LCYK`\ G3\ Z PÄKNy<C \LCqWYR3P x C��<GJMOE<e C*Z PujCqW¡Kqsk�rs n�GJ�kRg_3C3s�#ÉP x CFC x ]<Z T�GJe e5E<|<�<e Z[W«Z P<E<|rK`\SGJINChINCqW¡K`GJP<z3|<e[GJIq]QKNy<C«e Z P w GJz3C«z3I`GJE<y�Z[\´z3Z _3CFP�ja*KNy<C z3I`GJE<y x CFE<Z[W¡KNC x Z P ��Z z3|<INC �H]�R3I9G \L|<�<z3I`GJE<y RJT�Z Kqs �y<Z e C�G z3RjR x M1GiaÏKNyj|H\��kCe Z P w C x KNR \LCF_3CFI`GJeVRJKNy<CFI�z3RjR x \F]�P<R3P<CORJTdKNy<Cq\LC1WFGJP �kC1e Z P w C x KNR CqG3W`y*RJKNy<CFIqs!�SCFPHWYC3]�KNy<C

pqm

Page 22: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

WYR3ININCq\LEkR3P x Z P<z e Z P w GJz3C�Z P x C��ÏWFGJP<P<RJKhC��<WYCFC x �rs ��Z PHGJe e a3]5Z P KNy<CO\bKNCFEj��Z[\LC�e CqGJINP<Z P<z MOR x CFeGJzQGJZ P� �� �/�"!�� x |<C«KNR9KNy<Ct\LEkCqWYZ ,kW�\bKNIN|HW¡KN|<INC«RJT�KNy<Ct\L|<E<EkR3ILK � s

%D|<I�y<CF|<INZ[\bKNZ[WSGJINz3|<MOCFPQKVTfR3I�KNy<C�0NGJe MORQ\bK�P<CqWYCq\N\LZ Kba 2«RJT5G«e Rg� _gGJe |<C�RJT! �� �/�7TfR3I�KNy<CSE<|<INCWFG3\LC Z[\��HG3\LC x R3P KNy<C Z PQKN|<Z KNZ R3P KNyHGgK9Z TDGJP Z P<E<|rK���Z[\�|H\LC x �ja MOR3INC1KNyHGJP R3P<C z3RjR x ]�Z KZ[\h|H\LC x �ja MOR3INCtKNyHGJP�ub|H\bK ���� RJKNy<CFIhz3RjR x s #ÉP T·G3W¡Kq]5Z K�\LCFCFM1\hyHGJI x KNR ,HP x C��<GJMOE<e Cq\DRJT�fINCqGJe �DZ P<E<|rK`\�KNyHGgK�GJINCO|H\LC x �ja C��<G3W¡KNe a Kb�dR x Z �vCFINCFPQKtz3RjR x \/6�z3RjR x \«RJTXKNyHGgK w Z P x �dR3|<e xyHGi_3C1KNRÏ�kC>0LM1G x C1TfR3I9CqG3W`y RJKNy<CFIq] 2 \L|HW`y G3\tINZ z3yQK9GJP x e CYT@K1\Ly<RjCq\F]�TfR3I9Z PH\bK`GJPHWYC3s �´yj|H\F]>� �����´��Z e e5KbajE<Z[WFGJe e a �kCte[GJINz3C3s-#ÉP�KNy<CtE<|<INCtWFG3\LC3]rKNy<Z[\SZ MOE<e Z Cq\��ja �HG3W¡KD�Hs �tKNyHGgKDR3P<e a TfCF�EHGJZ I`\�z3RjR x \SGJINC«e Z P w C x s��da�WYR3PH\LC�.Q|<CFPHWYC3]<R3P<C���Z e e�,HP x CF_3CFP$0LMOR x CFI`GgKNCFe a \LZ :FC x 21WYe Z .Q|<Cq\R3P<e a |<P x CFIt\LEkCqWYZ[GJe­WYZ I`WY|<M1\bK`GJPHWYCq\Fs = �+�SCFPHWYC3] �� �/�D��Z e e­�kC \LM1GJe e�Z T�GJe e�Z P<E<|rK`\tGJINC9E<|<INCFe aE<|<�<e Z[WJs %DP*KNy<C RJKNy<CFItyHGJP x ]�Z P KNy<C Z MOE<|<INC WFG3\LC �� �/�hZ[\��kR3|<P x C x �kCFe Rg� �jaÏKNy<C1e[GJINz3Cq\bKWFGJI x Z PHGJe Z Kba�>� �����5RJTHGSINZ _gGJe INR3|H\5Z P<E<|rKq]g��y<Z[W`yt��Z e e3KbajE<Z[WFGJe e a«�kCXRJT �·GgK�e CqG3\bKH�5MOR x CFI`GgKNCX\LZ :FCZ T�KNy<C«KNRJK`GJe�Pj|<M��kCFISRJT�z3RjR x \´Z[\S\L| 5 WYZ CFPQKNe a y<Z z3y�s-�´yj|H\F]HGO\LM1GJe e�e Z P w GJz3C«Z P x C���Z[\�GOz3RjR xZ P x Z[WFGgKNR3I«KNyHGgK9GJe e­Z P<E<|rK`\�GJINCOP<R3P<INZ _gGJe INR3|H\�GJP x KNyHGgK�KNy<C E<|<�<e Z[W1Z P<E<|rK�Z PQKNCFINE<INCYK`GgKNZ R3P*Z[\CqWYR3P<R3MOZ[WFGJe e ahMOCqGJP<Z P<zJTf|<e�]g��y<Z e C´GSMOR x CFI`GgKNCXR3I�e[GJINz3C­e Z P w GJz3CXZ P x C��tZ P x Z[WFGgKNCq\�KNy<CdE<INCq\LCFPHWYCRJT�\LR3MOC«INZ _gGJe INR3|H\XZ P<E<|rKqs

� <T<=36.��T1���� � BE,',98�5

�4�kdk��5k�� ��� p k#� p�� � �;�´y<C«E<INRjRJT�E<INRrWYCFC x \´�ja Z P x |HW¡KNZ R3P Rg_3CFI >� s,�<R3IT� � � ��� ]H � � ���-� � � ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-�

� 2 ����- 7 - � ��� - �!��� # � �� 2 ����- 7 ��M - / � � � ��J

�SC��jKq]7e CYK >� � �r]7GJP x \L|<E<EkRQ\LC9KNy<C1z3Z _3CFP TfR3INM�|<e[G GJE<E<e Z Cq\hKNR GJe e x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3Cq\hRJTdR3I x CFI: >� s-�´y<CFP�]rTfR3ISGJPja � M � ]

H�� � ���-� �PH ��� H ��� ������� ���-����PH ��� ����� # � ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-� '� � "�pB� . � # 29� ��- 7 � � � � ��� � / - / ����I&� ��� � � � �

" 29����- 7 � � � � ��� � / - / � � � � '� � "�pB� . � A = 29� ��- 7 � � � � ��� / - / ��� � � M - � �� � "�pB�/. � A = 29� ��- 7 � / - / � � � �-J

C 4 ²7�`§��¡Ã��i�L¤5�ɼY�b�LÃ�§��g�N§��ɼY�b  � ¢´�` YÁ ¦¡� ¼Y�b  ¦¡�F�F� � � �D¨ �  i¥¡�b� §�� �`§��i�b�«¦¡�F�F�i�h¤7� §�� ¨ �L¤Ä�i���¡�g�`�i� ¨ � §@ÁYç��i�S Fµi£d�J�b�X�`¢����BJML� G ��j®b¨ � NFµi�b�d�`¢��«¦¡� ¼Y�b O®L�`���i�  g�`¨ � §@Á9¦¡���L¤7�­¢[�`�·§´�`�­§��i�D Fµi£d�J�b�­�`¢�¦¡�F�F�i�d�  i®b���L�`���b�Lº²7�ɼY�b�·§��i�b¨ �b���LÃi§��i�­�  Y§�µi� §�� �¡ D§��g�N§�¢ �ɤ �b�i¦¡�b�7� £��i¨ Á´§��i�X�`�i���b i®b�­�`¢<��� Ëb�L�`�i¨ ��®b¨ � NFµi�b�7®L�` h�J��£S�`�i��¢ �¡��£S�`¨ ¨ Á�i���b®b� ���¡º

�J�

Page 23: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

�4�kdk��5k�� ��� p k#� p���� �� n�CYK �@7Q� � �����kC�MOR3P<RJKNR3P<C3]<\L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJI���Z KNy P<R3Pr��EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3CKNy<Z I x x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C3s&�´y<CtINCq\bKNINZ[W¡KNZ R3P RJT,�«KNR GJPja � /R� yHG3\�KNy<Cq\LC�\NGJMOCtE<INR3EkCFILKNZ Cq\/6ky<CFPHWYC3]TfR3I´KNy<C�E<INRjRJT�RJT�´y<CFR3INCFM �rs �9Z KD\L| 5 WYCq\dKNR \Ly<Rg� KNyHGgK

� �Q� ��� p� � � �� ��� ��� ��J �·lts pB�

BDC�,HP<C9KNy<C Gi_3CFI`GJz3C�WYRQ\bKhTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3P ��7��i� � J J J � > � � � � �ja ���$#E�"7 � =.�� ! � # � � � ! � # � ���-�¡]��y<CFINC��@�$#E�87 � ��� /�� 79> � � # � s1�SRJKNC�KNyHGgK���·���.���<]F� N-���bpB� � � � � � � ��� ��� �GJP x ��� � � � � �Q� �¡]���y<CFINC�� 7 � > � s1cXR3PH\LZ x CFIhKNy<C x CFINZ _gGgKNZ _3C H � x C�,HP<C x �ja H ���$#E�"7 �

���$# � pB��"$���$#E�¡s �da*G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P�] H � 7��i� � J J J � � "Äp � � � Z[\�EkRQ\LZ KNZ _3C3] x CqWYINCqG3\LZ P<z GJP xWYR3PHWFGi_3C3sV�da 1 CFPH\LCFP� \´Z P<C�.Q|HGJe Z Kba3]<R3P<C«yHG3\dTfR3ISGJe e #���p � J J J � � " p3]

���$# � pB� " ���$#E�,� H ���$#E�'� � " p " #� " p N H ���·����J

uj|<MOMOZ P<zOKNy<Cq\LC�Z P<C�.Q|HGJe Z KNZ Cq\F]rR3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\

��� � �,�� � = � � # ���$# � pB��" ���$#E� ' �

� � � = � �

� " p " #� " p N����bpB�,� �

� ���bpB� �

Z�s C3s �·lts pB�¡s�4�kdk��Jk�� � ���� �d �� *C \Ly<Rg� KNyHGgKq]�TfR3I�GJPja�- M � GJP x GJPja �@M -t] ��� / -ts ��Z � GJPja� M � ]�GJP x WYR3PH\LZ x CFI�KNy<COT·GJMOZ e a�� � 7 � ��- 7 � M - ��� � � � � ��Z KNy � ?M - � s�#�K���Z e eX�kC\Ly<Rg��P KNyHGgK�243����tTfR3I�GJe e%- M � � �ja1Z P x |HW¡KNZ R3P Rg_3CFI9>�-ts,��Z I`\bK´INCqWFGJe ekKNyHGgK´�ja ���rs ���¡]jTfR3IGJe e �´]

� ����I&� ��� � "�� ���-�,� 2 ����- 7 � M -0/ � � � ��J �·lts �'�n�CYK - M � � ��Z KNy >�- ��p3]­Z�s C3s�- � � ��� s �da G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P�]­R3P<C yHG3\�� ��� ��� � I$� ��� � "� ��� ��� � �,���A6<y<CFPHWYC3]jK`G w Z P<z ��� � ��� � Z P �·lts �'�dR3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\�2�������� �<s�SRg�-WYR3PH\LZ x CFIdGJPja�- M � � GJP x \L|<E<EkRQ\LC�KNyHGgK 2 � �«TfR3IdGJe e M � � ��Z KNy > : >�-ts

�da G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P�] � � - � I&� ��� � "�� � - � �,� �A6ry<CFPHWYC3]<|H\LZ P<z8�·lts �'�d��Z KNy ���1- � ]rR3P<C�R3�rK`GJZ PH\�� 2 ��� 7 � M /*- � �,� 2 ��� 7 � M �� - � � � 243 �

KNyj|H\F]<�ja1KNy<C�Z P x |HW¡KNZ R3P yjajEkRJKNy<Cq\LZ[\F]4243����<s�4�kdk��Lk��#�4�k��Zk[�-i?�-i�k[l �d �� *C*E<INRg_3C KNyHGgK u<u ? Z MOE<e Z Cq\ � / � �!� 7 � M � � �ja�GWYR3PQKNI`G x Z[W¡KNZ R3P GJINz3|<MOCFPQKqs��´yj|H\F]r\L|<E<EkRQ\LCSKNyHGgK - M � Z[\dP<RJKdRJT�KNy<ChTfR3INM - � ��� TfR3I�\LR3MOC�@M � ]7GJP x G3\N\L|<MOC9KNyHGgK�- Z[\�RJT´MOZ P<Z M1GJeXWFGJI x Z PHGJe Z Kba ��Z KNy KNyHGgKtE<INR3EkCFILKba3s�n�CYK �@M -�kC G�� � ��MOZ P<Z M1GJe´CFe CFMOCFPQKORJT -ts �da$�HG3W¡K1�<s p3],- � �� s �da G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P KNy<CFINC�C��rZ[\bK`\ M - � � ��� �¡sX�da ���rs n'�dGJP x MOZ P<Z M1GJe Z Kba RJT�-�R3P<C«R3�rK`GJZ PH\F]

\LajP ����� ��� � - �J���12 ��� 7 � ��� � / / - � �,� 243"J�da G3\N\L|<MOErKNZ R3P�]�243 ?� �<]vy<CFPHWYC9�jaÏu<u ? KNy<CFINC�M�|H\bK�C��rZ[\bK«\LR3MOC � ?M � - � � � ��Z KNy � � � �GJP x �� � � st�d|rK � ?M � - � � � Z P*EHGJILKNZ[WY|<e[GJIhZ MOE<e Z Cq\ � M -t]���y<Z[W`yÏZ[\hP<RJK�EkRQ\N\LZ �<e C9�ja KNy<CW`y<R3Z[WYC«RJT � GJP x HscXR3Pj_3CFI`\LCFe a3]j\L|<E<EkRQ\LChKNyHGgK � / � ��� 7 ��M � � s�´y<Z[\�Z MOE<e Z Cq\

\LajP ����� ��� ���-� � 2 ����- 7 � ��� � / - / ��� � �� 2 ��� � � 7 � � � � � � � � GJP x � ?M � � � � �

�rp

Page 24: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

GJP x y<CFPHWYC�u<u ?Vs4��Z PHGJe e a3]jTfR3INM�|<e[G��·�<s �'�­TfR3e e Rg�S\�GgK�R3PHWYChTfINR3M � / � ��� 7 � M � � s�4�kdk��Zk�� �4�k��Zk[�-i?�-i�k[l � �� �<R3IXCqG3W`y � M � ]',A�!� � �bpB��GJIN�<Z KNI`GJINZ e a9\L|HW`yOKNyHGgK´� ! � � �bpB�"!� ��� � � � �¡]j��y<CFINC � � M � � s��<R3IdGJPja �1W`y<RjRQ\LC � � M � � ]jGJP x x C�,HP<C � 7Q� � ��� G3\�TfR3e e Rg�S\Fs�<R3ISGJe e!� � /�� ]

�)� �� �<7 � � ��� � � 7-� M ��� � � " � �����

� � �bpB��J

�da WYR3P x Z KNZ R3P>�fZ Z �¡]kKNy<Z[\ x RjCq\DP<RJK x CFEkCFP x R3P KNy<COW`y<R3Z[WYCtRJT�KNy<C � � s@�´y<CtTf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\ � � GJINCZ P x |HW¡KNZ _3CFe a x C�,HP<C x G3\�TfR3e e Rg�S\FsDcXy<RjRQ\LCtGJPja \LCYK � KNyHGgK«WYR3PQK`GJZ PH\�C��<G3W¡KNe a�#��Ä�OCFe CFMOCFPQK`\RJT � � ]HGJP x e CYK � � M ��� � � s-�´y<CFP�]<\LCYK

� � �$#E�<7 � � � �$#�" pB� � # � ���-� "�� ��� � � � � � � ' J�da WYR3P x Z KNZ R3PH\��fZ �DGJP x �fZ Z �¡]vKNy<Z[\ x C�,HP<Z KNZ R3P x RjCq\DP<RJK x CFEkCFP x R3P KNy<COW`y<R3Z[WYCtRJT ��GJP x � � s#�KSZ[\´CqG3\LZ e a _3CFINZ ,HC x KNyHGgK�KNy<C«Tf|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\� GJP x � � ajZ CFe x KNy<C x Cq\LZ INC x�x CqWYR3MOEkRQ\LZ KNZ R3P�s�4�kdk��%k�� � ���� � � �da x C�,HP<Z KNZ R3PÏRJT �����¡]�R3P<C�yHG3\ � ����� ��� � � � TfR3I«GJe e � ?M �����¡]�GJP x�ja KNy<C \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba3]­Z P T·G3W¡K H � � �����-�!�&� TfR3I1GJe e � ?M �����¡s v R3INCFRg_3CFIq]VZ T � �-Z[\9RJTKbajEkC9#¡]<R3P<C�yHG3\�� ����� ��� � � ��"�� ����� � � �Ä�9TfR3IDGJe e ��� � M �����¡]<�ja x C�,HP<Z KNZ R3P�s��´y<Z[\SZ MOE<e Z Cq\� ����� ��� � � � ����� � � � �17���1TfR3IOGJe e ��� � M �����¡]dGJP x KNy<CFINCYTfR3INC3]XGJzQGJZ P �ja \L|<�<MOR x |<e[GJINZ Kba3]� �����-�,�����TfR3I�GJPja�� ��Z KNy � � ����� ?� #rs��<INR3M KNy<Z[\´Z K´Z[\´Z MOMOC x Z[GgKNCDKNyHGgK´KNy<C�WJs M s Z�srRJT � �Z[\´z3Z _3CFP��ja 2 � ! � #�����hGJP x 243�� ��TfR3ISGJe e�- ?� �����¡s

� �����&�?� ���;���

# p�'��9=5=�� ��/����bpqm3oQ�'�¡] �´y<CtUXWYR3P<R3MOZ[W@#ÉMOE<e Z[WFGgKNZ R3PH\�RJT�n�CqGJINP<Z P<zO�ja�BDR3Z P<zH]�� �2V-���2E � ���������������8[')(#.����� ����]5pin3ni�`pg�g�<s

# ��' } 2��H270Q0��:�������GJP x ���­���7~S27?76���� �bpqm3m3o��¡]dv Z �rC x ��Z[\ w lS_3CFI`\LZ R3P�] � �(K1���*+Z� �J����� O�������� -�/����1�<�� � ]r���Qni�bnrpq�<s

# � ' } ;52 �5:r254�?�:<4�!�����<GJP x ��� "$#����<2�!%!j=v2%�$�bpqm'�3m��¡]rujR3MOCtcXyHGJI`G3W¡KNCFINZ :qGgKNZ R3PH\­RJT\n�Rg�dCFI?­INR3�HGJ�<Z e Z KNZ Cq\dGJP x %SKNy<CFI5v R3P<RJKNR3P<Z[W�cdGJEHG3WYZ KNZ Cq\­KNy<INR3|<z3y KNy<Ct^D\LChRJT�v RjCF�<Z |H\<#ÉPj_3CFIL�\LZ R3P�] � *'?/��2�6*')����*+ 8s�-�2��*+ 8s�2���2������� �&� ]k�Jo3�g�b� �3�<s

# � ' } ;���'74�: �(�*)+� �bpqmQnJ���¡] �´y<CFR3INaORJT­cdGJEHG3WYZ KNZ Cq\F] X_�#��*+ ���9.��9+-, D�����')�8')(K' 5 �(K1����21�. ]5pq�<pY��JmQnrs

# n�'�/0�7>fA7?��7?1����� "L�2�hGJP x ��� " } �43k270Q~S2�A7?�: �bpqm'�Qn'�¡]�ujEHG3WYCq\�TfR3I KNy<C lD\N\LCq\N\LMOCFPQK RJT5«P<Rg��e C x z3C3] D��#'7�21���*')�����*+ � �(K1���*+ � � � *�SO � *���/B�8���8[')(#.����� � � ]�pg�Jni�`pqm3o<s

# o '�/0�7>fA7?��7?1����� "L�2�HGJP x ��� " } ��3k270Q~S2�A7?�: �bpqm3m3m��¡]�6 ���E]+ ��.�=A� 8�!#*������ ]kujE<INZ P<z3CFIq] �SCF� R3I w s

# � '�/1>@~7�H270Q0��089�;:*�"�bpqm3m3���¡] ?­INCqWFGJ|rKNZ R3PHGJINa-urGi_jZ P<z Z P KNy<C ujM1GJe e�GJP x Z P KNy<C�n7GJINz3C3]���������6�2')1�����*�.�< ]HnJ�g�L�g�<s

# � '28 27=�6F;5270Q0��=���;�bp��3m3���jpqmQ�J���¡] �Y1��8���2� !�+ ���@� � ��������������� ] ��Z I`\bK E<|<�<e Z[\Ly<C x p��3m3�<]��CFE<INZ PQK�RJT�KNy<C�CFZ z3yQKNy�C x Z KNZ R3P pqmQ�J�<]Kv G3WYMOZ e e[GJP�] �SCF� R3I w s

�3�

Page 25: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

# m '28 �74�0Q>@?1����� �bpqm'�'���¡] X&*�����J�9� ���a�-�"!#�21"*')�8V�������2�:������ � *-`�8�B= ]vcdGJM��<INZ x z3Ch^SP<Z _3CFIL�\LZ Kba ?­INCq\N\F]HcdGJM��<INZ x z3C3s

# pq� '�89:<;�=5>@?7A ��/��(�bpqm3m3m��¡]rBDZ _3CFI`\LZ Kba GJP x KNy<C��hCFR3MOCYKNINa RJT­ujZ MOZ e[GJINZ Kba3] ���8�6��� s# p3p�'�89:<;�=5>@?7A �5/��<GJP x } �5�h4��<�<:8�bpqm3m3m��¡]Bv R x CFe e Z P<z9UXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJT�urWYR3EkC3]<u �V�-BDZ[\NWY|H\b�

\LZ R3P�?�GJEkCFI�l��Éo3�j�j]r^SP<Z _3CFI`\LZ Kba RJTV�dR3P<P�s# pi��'�89:<;�=5>@?7A �h/��­GJP x } �S�h4��<�<: ���J�3�Q�'�¡]�l �´y<CFR3INa RJTDBDZ _3CFI`\LZ Kba3] ���������6�2')1�����*���� ]

p3pin3ni�`p3pqm'�<s# pq� 't��27?g27=(����� } �<�bpqm'�3m��¡]��7CqW`y<P<R3e R3z3Z[WFGJe­BDCYKNCFINMOZ PHGJPQK`\tRJT���Z INM GJP x #ÉP x |H\bKNINa uQKNIN|HW¡�

KN|<INC3]�cXy�s�p9Z P�7�� *��.�H��-�-`L� �9D���.(B��')1���*+� ]1)=A*�#� ,-*')���� ]7C x sv�ja ��s�urW`y<M1GJe CFPH\LCFCOGJP x��s B�sA �Z e e Z zH]HU­e[\LCF_jZ CFIqs

# pF� 't��27?g27=(� ��� } �JGJP x�� � /+��� >@0Q0Q>fA �bpqm'�<pB�¡]iUXWYR3P<R3MOZ Cq\�RJTkurWYR3EkC3] X_�6�21�����*���������������� �2V-���2E � � ]H�Jo'�g�b�Q�J�rs

# pin�' � ���Q2 �2)+� } �bpqm3oJ���¡]��´y<CFR3INa RJT%v RjCF�<Z |H\!�<|<PHW¡KNZ R3PH\F]�� �2�8'�����/B1�� ��'����(K1��Q*-/B1�����/��2�8�SO+ ����/�`��2�8'���'?/����1�����(K��.��[�21�EZ*��.'7���5�-H2���2'7� �5]<�J�Q�g�É�3o'�<s

# pqo '4:v;527�<0Q:%�����7�;:*� �bpqmQnJ���¡]dl �­GJe |<C TfR3I �v�L?VCFI`\LR3P �«GJMOCq\F]dZ P�7 �a��#')1���H2(K')������Q'7��'?/��-�/����1�<Q� ���5*�6���%D DRN�X_�#��*+ �O� � � *'?/��2�6*')������8[')(#.����� )� �P ]5C x sk�ja �ts �s 5«|<y<P*GJP xlts �s �7|HW w CFIq]A?­INZ PHWYCYKNR3P�^SP<Z _3CFI`\LZ Kba ?­INCq\N\F] ?­INZ PHWYCYKNR3P�s

# pg� '4:�!H27= !�"���(�bpqm'�<pB�¡]A?­INR x |HW¡KNZ R3P ujCYK`\���Z KNy�#ÉP x Z _jZ[\LZ �<Z e Z KNZ Cq\Fs ?�GJILK�#H7k�hCFP<CFI`GJe Z KNZ Cq\F]<GJP x?�GJILK<#�#H7 �´y<C�cdG3\LC«RJT�´�dR1lDW¡KNZ _jZ KNZ Cq\F] ���������6�2')1�����* � ��]5pY�É�Q�r]rGJP x �3mQni���j�J�<s

# p�� '4:�!H27= !�������bpqm3mJ���¡] �´y<C«lSe e RrWFGgKNZ R3P RJT ��Cq\LR3|<I`WYCq\XZ P KNy<C ?­INCq\LCFPHWYCDRJT #ÉP x Z _jZ[\LZ �<Z e Z KNZ Cq\F]� �(K1���*+ � �M�������������!���21��)!#���2')�8V��� < ]5p3p3pY�`pi� �<s

# pqm ' # �74�?7A ����� �2�A�bpqm3mJ���¡] � �2(K�8')<�CKD�� -�/����1�<�*��.�Y1"*��2')����� ]�?­INZ PHWYCYKNR3P9^SP<Z _3CFI`\LZ Kba9?­INCq\N\F]?­INZ PHWYCYKNR3P�s

�J�

Page 26: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

��������� ������ ���

���������������� ������ ��� ��������� ���

����������� ������� ������!"�! ���������#��$ ���� �&% #'

�������$ ��������������� �������������!"�(��#��� �)�*!����$ � �!�+�) �������!����������� ��

,

!����$ �- �!�+���! !�.�%+�� ����$ $ %/ #������ 0"��# #1

!����$ �- �!�+���! �+ ������!���������������� �� #2

��������� ��+�� ���-��%+������� ��������(!��� �+ $ ������#

3

�������$ ��������������� ������ ������!"� ! ��������$���������#��$ ���� �&% #

4

5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5

4

4

666 687

99999999999

4

4

4

66666666666 687

6666 687

: : : : : : : : :<;

========= >

99???????????????????????????????? @

5 � =�(K1"���#7�-�/���!�1"����(-!�!#�3���8')����I1"�2+ *')������ � 8s���2')���� )

Page 27: faculty.econ.ucdavis.edufaculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/nehring/papers/eos-9-02.pdf · ! #"$ &%(') *,+ -%* ,. /10325476989:@?7A BDCFEHGJILKNMOCFPQKSRJTVUXWYR3P

��������� ������ ���

���������������� ������ ��� ��������� ���

� .���������� "�� "��1

����������� ������� ������!"�! ���������#��$ ���� �&% #'

��������� ��+�� �����%+������� �����'

�������$ ��������������� �������������!"�(��#��� �)�*!����$ � �!�+�) �������!����������� ��

,

!����$ �- �!�+���! !�.�%+�� ����$ $ %/ #������ 0"��# #1

!����$ �- �!�+���! �+ ������!���������������� �� #2

��������� ��+�� ���-��%+������� ��������(!��� �+ $ ������#

3

�������$ ��������������� ������ ������!"� ! ��������$���������#��$ ���� �&% #

4

��%+�������%��%+������ � � ��� ����� �

���������� ���� �������� ��.��� ���#������� �-����#���$��4

� ���#������� �����#���$

���

� ����� ��� �����

���� �

5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5

4

4

666 687

999999999994

4

4

4

4

4

6666 687

: : : : : : : : :<;

========= >

66 687

6 687

66 687

4

4

��

��

��

��

��

�� �

: : : : : : : : : ::<;

��� �

��������������

��� ���

5 � =�(K1"�� 7�-�/���!�1"����(-!�!#�3���8')����I1"�2+ *')���� � �<8s���2')���� )R1"�2V-�:���8'7��.�C8 8��G��*')�:� �Y��.R���*���2�#+ *1)=A��.�.���6*�8�