¥ 1 ½ l Ï u ¼ k © u e Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · e ¢ u ð , Ü Ý r p ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ...

7
111 ၆˝Œѐޥຐጯఙ۞ޥ҂Ă၁ଂ˝Œѐགྷฟ Ą˟Ȉ˘͵ܐࡔᚶᜈޥ҂ĂநᑕՀБஎˢĂໄߏͳ රበ۞Įڡį۞ܐਾĄ ˝ŒѐϤՂ͵ᑾበ۞Įᙊϲಞį)ˬסώĂР ڒॡᘹۍ2000ѐ1ᘲ૯ыበ۞Į90ѐ ޥຐᏴį)ˬסώĂᇃҘˠϔۍ2000ѐ7ຉะ˞༊ ॡጯఙ۞ޥຐјڍĂͽۋኢ۞Ķયᗟķќะᕩᙷᙯ۞ ĂયᗟΒ߁Ķ፬ซᄃчۋķăĶϔཌྷķăĶҋϤ ཌྷາνۋķ۰Ķጯఙఢቑķ)າጯ*ăĶޢጯķăĶˠ ჟৠķăĶξϔķăĶҋϤཌྷķăĶϒķăĶགྷ ᑻநķĂඈඈĄะ၆Ᏼ۞՟ѣ೩Їңវ ۞ෞበᏴᄲځĂՀ՟ѣژྋᛖտߏᆃኳ۞ય ᗟĂ۰ңд˝Œѐ۞ԛјĄᏴะගˠ۞О෪ ߏĂયᗟಶߏયᗟĂયᗟߏҋயϠ۞Ą ͳර۞ĮڡįТĂс۞ϫ۞ߏफ़۞ຉะĂ ߏсдጱኢᄲ۞ĂೡᘱĶ༊۞ჟৠᄻĄķଂຍ ཌྷ˯ᄲĂĮڡįᏴ۞Щछ)ӈᏜĶ༊ы ᙊķ*ຐߏਕᙋăវனߍॡĶჟৠķ ޥ1Ĉޥຐ۞Ր৶ 112 ᄻ۞Ąҭտ˘ߏᆃᇹ۞ॡĉтڍԧԧ Ϡ߿д˘ᆃᇹ۞ॡĂԧ˫ңͽኢෞҤι۞ჟৠ ĉᄲᖎಏ˘ᕇĂԧͽ˘ᆃᇹ۞ЩჍĂჍײ?дᖙዦѩ३ॡĂԧ˘дವԱ˘ඍ९Ăҭ˘ϏਕԱזĄ ٺበ۰ү۰Ă˵ధ˘ߏܧኘΞ۞યᗟĂҭ ԧᛇιࢦޝĄдኢ۰˝ŒѐޥຐጯఙڶېĂ ૱֍۞ॡໄĂಶߏϡ˘Қ۞छᅳጱˠՀ߆ඉត ೡ˘ன၁۞ĂӈᏜ۞Ķ።ΫⴺតķĶᖼ ݭķĄдౙĂᇹઇҋѣ۞ЯĄҭߏĂ၆ٺд ౙͽγ۞ۍޥຐኢĂᇹ۞நಶमˠຍ˞Ą༊ॡ ۞ޥຐኢĂᅮА༊ॡЩĂЩะវன۞Ăߏι۞ώኳᄮᙊĄ Ղຕഅ೩Ă۞˘ߏޢໂᝋ۞ॡ 1 Ąޢໂᝋ дజჍઇĶཌྷķĂҭཌྷਕໄ߁ॡ۞ ޘטڼ߆পᇈĄᐮ)R. Baum*ᔁ)A. Shevchenko*അ ĂঔγտЯԼ۞ޢࢭԛ๕តᓜĶቑݭෘķ યᗟĄЯѩĂયᗟտ۰ᅮѣ၆ᒖဩ۞າჍ ײ2 ĄາჍײͽĶཌྷķĶώཌྷķ 1 Ղຕ: IJޢໂᝋཌྷॡ۞ˠϠጯĈĮݣჯႬะįԔijĂ www.novelscape.comĄԧдϡ۞ߏజତ۞צĶޢໂᝋķ هĂጐგԧᄮё۞Ķາໂᝋķ˵ధՀቁ˘Ą֍षĂ IJ۞Ķາໂᝋཌྷķϐ͵෪ijĂĮ༊տįĂ2005 ѐĂௐ4)ᓁௐ91*Ą 2 Richard Baum and Alexei Schevchenko, “The ‘State of the State’ ” in Merle Goldman and Roderick MacFarquhar, eds., The Paradox of Chinas Post-Mao Reforms )Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999*, p. 333.

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

�11

1�

2000

190

2000

7

1

�11

2�

?

1

R.B

aum

A.S

hevc

henk

o

2 1:

ww

w.n

ovel

scap

e.co

m

2005

491

2R

icha

rdB

aum

and

Ale

xeiS

chev

chen

ko,“

The

‘Sta

teof

the

Stat

e’”

inM

erle

Gol

dman

and

Rod

eric

kM

acFa

rquh

ar,

eds.,

The

Para

dox

ofC

hina

’sPo

st-M

aoRe

form

sC

ambr

idge

,MA

:Har

vard

Uni

vers

ityPr

ess,

1999

,p.3

33.

Page 2: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

�11

3�

3

4

20

3Fr

ank

N.

Piek

e,“B

urea

ucra

cy,

Frie

nds,

and

Mon

ey:

The

Gro

wth

ofC

apita

lSo

cial

ism

inC

hina

,”

Com

para

tive

Stud

ies

inSo

ciet

yan

dH

isto

ry37

:219

95:4

94-5

18.

Min

xin

Pei,

“Mic

rofo

unda

tions

ofSt

ate

Soci

alis

man

dPa

ttern

sof

Econ

omic

Tran

sfor

mat

ion,

”Co

mm

unis

tand

Post

-Com

mun

istSt

udie

s29

:2

1996

:13

1-14

5.N

anLi

n,“L

ocal

Mar

ketS

ocia

lism

:Loc

alC

orpo

ratio

nin

Act

ion

inR

ural

Chi

na,”

Theo

ryan

dSo

ciet

y24

1995

:301

-354

.Pe

terN

an-s

hong

Lee,

“The

Chi

nese

Indu

stria

lSt

ate

inH

isto

rical

Pers

pect

ive:

From

Tota

litar

iani

smto

Cor

pora

tism

,”in

Bra

ntly

Wom

ack,

ed.,

Con

tem

pora

ryC

hine

sePo

litic

sin

His

tori

cal

Pers

pect

ive

Cam

brid

ge:

Cam

brid

geU

nive

rsity

Pres

s,19

91,

p.16

8.M

arga

ret

Pear

son,

“The

Janu

sFa

ceof

Bus

ines

sA

ssoc

iatio

nsin

Chi

na:

Soci

alis

tC

orpo

ratis

min

Fore

ign

Ente

rpris

es,”

Aust

ralia

nJo

urna

lofC

hine

seAf

fair

s,no

.31

Janu

ary

1994

:25-

46.

Viv

ienn

eSh

ue,“

Stat

ePo

wer

and

Soci

alO

rgan

izat

ion

inC

hina

,”in

Joel

Mig

dal

etal

.,St

ate

Pow

eran

dSo

cial

Forc

es:

Dom

inat

ion

and

Tran

sfor

mat

ion

inth

eTh

ird

Wor

ldC

ambr

idge

:Cam

brid

geU

nive

rsity

Pres

s,19

94,p

p.76

ff.

4To

nySa

ich,

“The

Four

teen

thPa

rtyC

ongr

ess:

APr

ogra

mm

efo

rA

utho

ritar

ian

Rul

e,”

Chi

naQ

uart

erly

,no

.13

2D

ecem

ber

1992

,p.

1160

.M

auric

eM

eisn

er,“

Bur

eauc

ratic

Cap

italis

m:S

ome

Ref

lect

ions

onth

eSo

cial

Res

ults

ofth

eC

hine

seC

omm

unis

tR

evol

utio

n,”

pape

rpr

esen

ted

atth

eSy

mpo

sium

on“R

ethi

nkin

gth

eC

hine

seR

evol

utio

n,”

UC

LA,N

ovem

ber1

9,19

94.

Dor

othy

J.So

linge

r,“C

apita

listM

easu

res

with

Chi

nese

Cha

ract

eris

tics,”

inD

orot

hyJ.

Solin

ger,

Chin

a's

Tran

sitio

nfr

omSo

cial

ism

:St

ate

Lega

cies

and

Mar

ket

Refo

rms,

1980

-199

0A

rmon

k,N

Y:M

.E.S

harp

e,19

93,p

p.12

6-15

2.

1

�11

4�

5

1990

6

1990

5G

erem

ieR

.B

arm

e,In

the

Red:

On

Con

tem

pora

ryC

hine

seCu

lture

New

Yor

k:C

olum

bia

Uni

vers

ityPr

ess,

1999

,p.7

.6

2004

iv,x

ix,

8-10

Page 3: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

�11

5�

7

1989

1989

1990

8

7

2004

iv, x

ix,

8-10

8

1

� 1

16 �

Page 4: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

� 1

17 �

9

10

11

9

Vac

lav

Hav

el,

“The

Pow

er o

f th

e Po

wer

less

,” i

n Ja

n V

ladi

slav

, ed

., Va

clav

Hav

el o

r Li

ving

in T

ruth

Lo

ndon

: Fab

er a

nd F

aber

, 198

6, p

p.

42.

10

http

://w

ww

. ya

nnan

.cn,

200

5/8/

22.

11

http

://w

ww

.xys

.org

/xys

/ebo

oks/

liter

atur

e/

essa

y/ya

npin

.tet,

2000

/3/2

9.

1

� 1

18 �

——

——

)

1989

1989

1989

19

8919

68

1989

77

Page 5: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

� 1

19 �

77so

lidar

ity o

f the

shak

en12

13

1989

12

A

viez

er T

uche

r, Th

e Ph

iloso

phy

and

Polit

ics

of C

zech

Diss

iden

ce fr

om

Pato

cka

to H

avel

, Pitt

sbur

gh, P

A: U

nive

rsity

of P

ittsb

urgh

Pre

ss, 2

000,

p.

73.

13

V

acla

v H

avel

, “T

he P

ower

of

the

Pow

erle

ss,”

in

Jan

Vla

disl

av,

ed.,

Vacl

av H

avel

or

Livi

ng in

Tru

th

Lond

on: F

aber

and

Fab

er, 1

986

, pp.

44

-45,

79-

80.

1

� 1

20 �

1993

14

1991

1989

??

?

1989

15

1995

16

14

20

04iv

, xix

, 8-

10

15

16

19

953

Page 6: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

� 1

21 �

?

1

� 1

22 �

919

70

17

17

— w

ww

.asi

adem

o.or

g

Page 7: ¥ 1 ½ L Ï u ¼ K © U E Í : Î a 6 ß à ' 7 · E ¢ U ð , Ü Ý R P ¥ ö / Ð ¶ u ñ Þ a Ä ¶ Ï á Ø > Þ ... o u r t e e n t h P a r t y C o n g r e s s: A P r o g r

� 1

23 �

1

� 1

24 �

Pi

erre

Bou

rdie

u

Situ

atio

nal

Tens

ions

of C

ritic

-Int

elle

ctua

ls, D

isen

chan

ted

Dem

ocra

cy, —