1. ademption 2. divorce 1. ademption 2. divorce 3. lapse

41
Will Revocation

Upload: aileen-smith

Post on 17-Dec-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Will Revocation

Page 2: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Revocation byOperation of Law

Page 3: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption

Page 4: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption2. Divorce

Page 5: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption2. Divorce3. Lapse

Page 6: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption2. Divorce3. Lapse4. Failure to survive by 120

hours

Page 7: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption2. Divorce3. Lapse4. Failure to survive by 120

hours5. Pretermitted child

Page 8: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types

1. Ademption2. Divorce3. Lapse4. Failure to survive by 120

hours5. Pretermitted child6. Murder

Page 9: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Revocation byPhysical Act

Page 10: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Requirements to Revoke by Physical Act

1. Mental Capacity

Page 11: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Requirements to Revoke by Physical Act

2. Revocation Intent

Page 12: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Requirements to Revoke by Physical Act

3. Physical Act [Ohio] Tearing Canceling Obliterating Destroying

Page 13: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Requirements to Revoke by Physical Act

3. Physical Act

By Proxy?▪ Proxy in testator’s presence?▪ Proxy upon testator’s written

instruction, even if not in testator’s presence?

Page 14: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Requirements to Revoke by Physical Act

4. Concurrence of first three requirements.

Page 15: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Remedy if intent and physical act do not mesh

1. If no evil conduct

No remedy – will is not revoked.

Page 16: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Remedy if intent and physical act do not mesh

2. If evil conduct

Constructive trust.

Page 17: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Partial revocation by physical act

Examples: I leave $10,000 to Walter Bishop I leave $10,000 to each of Walter

Bishop and Peter Bishop.

Approaches: Effective to revoke gift No effect on gift

Page 18: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Partial revocation by physical act

1. I leave my house to X.

2. I leave $10,000 to Y.

3. I leave the rest to Z.

What result?

Page 19: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Revocation bySubsequent Writing

Page 20: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types of revocation writings

1. Will

Page 21: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types of revocation writings

2. Codicil

Page 22: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Types of revocation writings

3. Declaration in writing with will formalities.

Page 23: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Methods of revocation by subsequent writing

1. Express Revocation

Page 24: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Methods of revocation by subsequent writing

2. Revocation by inc0nsistency

Page 25: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Practice question

Client wants to make minor changes to an existing will.

New will?

Codicil?

Page 26: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Presumptions

Page 27: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Proponent’s Burden

Applicant must prove testator did not revoke the will.

How prove a negative?

Page 28: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Presumption of Non-Revocation

Will found in “normal” location, and

No suspicious circumstances.

Page 29: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Presumption of Revocation

Testator possessed will when last seen and it cannot be found after death.

Page 30: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Revival

Page 31: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Fact Pattern

1. Testator executed valid Will 1.

2. Testator executed valid Will 2 which expressly revoked Will 1.

3. Testator validly revokes Will 2 but does not execute a new will.

4. What result?

Page 32: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Approaches

1. Revival Will 1 takes effect.

Page 33: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Approaches

2. No Revival Intestacy.

Page 34: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Approaches

3. Intent (UPC) Will 1 or intestacy, depending on

evidence of testator’s intent.

Page 35: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Conditional Revocation

Page 36: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

1. Express conditional revocation

“I revoke my will if [condition] occurs.”

Page 37: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

2. Implied conditional revocation(Dependent Relative Revocation)

Fact Pattern: 1. Testator executed valid Will 1. 2. Testator validly revoked Will 1. 3. Testator executed Will 2, but it is

invalid.

Was revocation of Will 1 impliedly conditioned (dependent) on Will 2 being valid?

Page 38: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Multiple Originals

Page 39: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Presumption

If cannot locate all originals, testator destroyed one original with intent to revoke.

Page 40: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Rebutting Presumption

Evidence may show testator destroyed “extra” originals realizing wisdom of having only one original.

Page 41: 1. Ademption  2. Divorce  1. Ademption  2. Divorce  3. Lapse

Apply “Cocaine Rule”